Has Iesa (Jesus) really died? Ep. 3 | Arabic101
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 03. 2024
- ↪ ↪ If you can, please support the Channel: / 101arabic
↪ ↪ My Books: store.arabic101.org/product-c... --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is the third episode of the series (Doubt-proof). In this episode, we explain one of the oldest shubuhat on Prophet Iesa, that he died, and that Allah has taken his soul, and why this doubt is baseless.
PLEASE share the video as much as you can to spread the word and share the ajer in shaa Allah ...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
↳ Facebook: /101Arabic
↳ Twitter: @101Arabic
↳ Website: Arabic101.org
↳ Store: store.arabic101.org
#arabic101 #athan #learn_athan #Islam
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
Masha Allah
I just stumbled upon this question online a few days ago, I prayed to Allah to help me have the right understanding of this verse and I saw your video today.
May Allah grant you Jannah for your efforts and increase your imaan and status with him
Ameen
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that the word means Death in the verse 3:55
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
He specifically mentions this after quoting the verse 3:55. The video has many errors.
Moreover, let's go with the explanation of this video. When Allah or an Angel of death "takes" someone, it means death as well.
This man is always telling lies. In 25 verses of Quran, word Wafat is used for death, and same word WAFAT is used for the death of Jesus in 3:55, 5:117. He is dead and dead never come back. Hadiths are Fabricated tales
@@zaryabfarooq4432
where is the sahih isnad to ibn abbas , ali ibn talaha the one narrating from ibn abbas didn't hear from him so the narration is weak , bukhari saying ali ibn talah said means that he indeed said but the fact that he didn't hear from ibn abbas we don't know who is between them so weak
secondly the aya of the quran is clear that isa is yet to die and that the people of the book will believe in him , the jews are yet to believe so he is yet to die because they will believe in him before his death
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.
@@tofeeqmajeed3344
abu hurayra the companion of the prophet is of opinion of this video
سبحان الله مررت على هذه الآية و جائني تساؤل و لكن الحمد لله انكم وضحتم الموضوع جزاكم الله خيرا
يا أخي بارك الله فيك اقرأ ما كتبت هنا زادكم الله في العلم والإيمان.
@@munassaralam5442 ماذا تقصد اخي؟
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
The clear verses explain the unclear verses. May Allah Bless you. The mufasiroon have explained in detail and your video is a gem!
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that the word means Death:
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
He specifically mentions this after quoting the verse 3:55. The video has many errors.
Moreover, let's go with the explanation of this video. When Allah or an Angel of death "takes" someone, it means death as well.
@@zaryabfarooq4432 I heard from a sheikh that the question of whether Prophet Eisa عليه السلام died or not is not confirmed. as the other group (i,e those who see that Eisa was died) that متوفيك means death. and that Prophet Eisa dies twice. once before being raised as in [3:55] and one after His descent in the future as in [4:157]. so there's no need to dispute on this topic. it's not really clear. but personally I lean more to the opinion that he didn't die yet. and Allah knows best.
Edit: I forgot, a third group sees that متوفيك in this Ayah means to cause to fall asleep
@@zaryabfarooq4432 this is the internet and before any responses are given you have to do better then give a random Sahih Bukhari page with no link.
But just for the sake of understanding the rules of Tafsir any Tafsir of the Quran has to be in light of first the Quran explains the Quran, the Prophet explains the Quran and then the Sahaba and there students. If any of the latter contradicts the speech of Allah and the guidance of Muhammad then it is rejected and that’s with all Tafsir. Every human makes mistakes and having said that context is also necessary. Did the evidence reach a Sahaba or there students. Many variables and that’s why the scholars are needed because we as laymen can’t open up the volume of books of knowledge that contains all these gems. Alhumdulilah the brother explained it beautiful in brevity and that’s why it is such a gem Alhumdulilah.
@@save_sudan_and_palestineHe has died. It is confirmed through:
- 30 verses of the Quran
- Numerous Ahadith
- Ijmah of Sahaba
- Imam Malik RH, Ibn Hazm etc
@@zaryabfarooq4432Why don't you provide one of them then, well, here's the reference for he wasn't crucified Surah an Nisa [4:157]
Very informative❤
Awesome, may Allah reward you
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
جزاكم الله خيراً ونفع بكم
@@tofeeqmajeed3344
ابقى فى الكذب والتدليس لكنهم لن يضروا الإسلام فى شيء! فلن يضر السحاب نبح الكلاب ..
الحمد لله الذي عافانا مما ابتلى به غيرنا و فضلنا على كثيرٍ ممن خلق تفضيلاً كبيراً 🤍
Jazaka-Llahu khairan, dear brother! I thought about that problem every time when reading these verses, because the Quran translator in my native language for some reason chose the meaning of 'cause to fall asleep' instead of 'take'.
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.
@@tofeeqmajeed3344 Are you on discord?
First comment. Jesus never died. Allah took unto Him and he will return as a follower of Prophet Muhammad PBUH.
❤
While Muhammad was poisoned like a rat only to be eaten by cockroaches in a grave. Watch Christian Prince, Adam Seeker, Ahmad Exmuslim, abdool's should not call other who expose Islam as liars as they provide evidence from the Qur'an tafsirs and hadiths. Why abdool's just go round and round jumping from topic to topic because they're ashamed of their belief
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that the word means Death:
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
He specifically mentions this after quoting the verse 3:55. The video has many errors.
Moreover, let's go with the explanation of this video. When Allah or an Angel of death "takes" someone, it means death as well.
@@zaryabfarooq4432hadith number brother ?
@@zaryabfarooq4432 So Iesa (A.S) will die again, will taste death twice?? Or?? 😂
Maa Shaa Allaaho 'aleik - Beautiful explanation of the Aayah. May Allaah Subhanahoo reward you!
جزاكم الله عنا خيرا❤
من؟ يقول إنسان أحد، لا كثيرون
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that the word means Death:
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
He specifically mentions this after quoting the verse 3:55. The video has many errors.
Moreover, let's go with the explanation of this video. When Allah or an Angel of death "takes" someone, it means death as well.
@@zaryabfarooq4432there are ayaat in the quran that say isa alayhisalam is not dead.
"وما قتلوه وما صلبوه " is one of them
@@suhailnoor6898It says he wasn't killed or crucified. Doesn't say he didn't die.
@@suhailnoor6898 You are saying Ibn Abbas RA is wrong?
And yes, Isa AS wasnt killed nor crucified. I agree.
My grandfather wasnt killed nor crucified. BUT HE STILL DIED.
Always informative.
Always disinformation
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
@@tofeeqmajeed3344Wasn’t Razi absolutely obliterated?
@@VeKlutz It's not about personalities it's about objective truths.
Doesn't matter is what flashy way you say "1+1=3" it doesn't change the fact that "1+1=2".
Watch the video, it's gives a concise refutation to the logical fallacies of "Arabic 101".
You are indeed correct brother, and the qadyani you replied to isnt more than him, they are desperate that they cant do anything but try to bait non arabs into believing their bs
جزاكم الله خيرا. الفيديو مفيد جداً
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
Beautiful explanation.
جزاك الله خيرا
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
Great Video 💯
I know a lot of Christians making that claim , And This is really good answer for them
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
thank you for explanation brother.. jazakallahukhairan
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
@tofeeqmajeed3344 Are you from the
Christain or Jewish faith? They both
believe Isa * died. As the Ustad mentioned
the other 2 sets of ayah's where Allah S%
Disagrees with Christains and Jews Saying
that Isa *didn't die nor crucified, and all of
the people of the book will believe in lsa
before his death. This is the ijma of the
sahaba, as well as the pious predecessors
Are you telling all of them were wrong/lied
which includes the Scribes of the Quran?
Jews still deny Isa*. Therefore, he simply
can't be dead
Jazakallah Khair
It would be rlly nice if u start a series on in-depth tafseer of some shirt surahs
You mean short?
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that the word means Death:
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
He specifically mentions this after quoting the verse 3:55. The video has many errors.
Moreover, let's go with the explanation of this video. When Allah or an Angel of death "takes" someone, it means death as well.
@@zaryabfarooq4432can you give exact hadith number
@@zaryabfarooq4432 So do you mean Iesa (A.S) died? How about other verses that say Iesa didn't die? Are those verses wrong?
@@zaryabfarooq4432he's just explained it has multiple meanings, can you show the tafsir of in Abbas that says this for this ayat as I can't find it.
بارك الله فيك اخي
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
@@tofeeqmajeed3344 idk man
@@samadel.a765report this tofeeq guy for spam, he keep spamming his deceptive video under every comment in this video
nice Video !
JazakAllah 😊
جزاك الله خيرا كثيرا و عافيه ميزان حسناته اللهم آمين يارب العالمين
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
@@tofeeqmajeed3344 Qadiyanis are KAFIRS. That is qadiyani channel.
What an explanation ❤
مَا شَاءَ الله great video
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
@tofeeqmajeed3344 Are you from the Christain or Jewish faith? They both believe Isa ؑ died. As the Ustad mentioned the other 2 sets of ayah's where Allah ﷻ Disagrees with Christains and Jews Saying that Isa ؑ didn't die nor crucified and all of the people of the book will believe in Isa ؑ before his death. This is the ijma of the sahaba, as well as the pious predecessors. Are you telling all of them were wrong/lied which including the Scribes of the Quran?
Jews still deny Isa ؑ , therefore, he simply can't be dead
Informative video as always ❤
Misleading video. Told lies
@@abdar-rahman6965 such as?
Hi are you ahmadi?
@@abdar-rahman6965
@@abdar-rahman6965says the guy who belive in MGA 😂
Subhan Allah
Everyone should respectfully appreciate the information provided and keep studying.
This platform is not for debates, it’s for education.
Thanks
"Every soul will taste death" and one of the reasons is that Isa as will come again in this world to die and to fulfill what Allah said in this ayah
Kindly also address the claim of people saying Quran says that heavens and earth were created in 8days misinterpreting verses in surah Fussilat. JazakumLlahu kheir.
The mistake people make is when they add the numbers. Where does it say to add them when the actions within them are not the same? The simplest way to explain this: Two actions can be concurrent, meaning at the same time.
For example: If I said it took me 2 hours to cook the meat and 2 hours for the vegetables. Is that necessarily 4 hours? No. They could be at the same time. Apply this to the verses.
و الله أعلى و أعلم.
Nice explanation jazak allah khir
@@mostafa33064
Wa iyyakum.
czcams.com/video/9XNat02jfJs/video.html
السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته
جزاك الله خيرا
Great work. The Haq is clear.
Ramadan Mubarak 🌙
P S do we have a reference for Abu Huraira's may Allah be pleased with him,explanation
Ma shaa Allah Tabaraqallah beathiful knowledge of Allah me Allah bless you for sharing knowledge of Allah with Jenha firdouws allahoema ameen 🌴
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
SubhanAllah, so clear. I would like to know what are the others principle of Tafsir, i know that an ayah can be interpreted by using another ayah or by using a Hadith, but I don't know the rest. It would be useful in order to directly spot the people who are making wrong interpretations for example.
This channel is very underrated
Overrated. He spreads most of time, lies and he twists Quran under pretext of Arabic Grammar
Our response: czcams.com/video/V27xaf8obDU/video.htmlsi=8MStUU1dVKxJM-X6
He ended up comparing 2 completely different words.🤦
Qadianis and hadith rejectors are triggered
@@humaidahnnooman
Qadiani are gone Astray and Murshid of Hadith-Followers is Iblis Rajeem because Rasool, and all Sahaaba left behind only written Quran. No Hadiths. According to Quran 5:44, 6:114, a Person who is NOT HADITH REJECTER is a Mushrik Kaafir.
*Rasool and 4 Caliphs were also Hadith-Rejecters because during their era, there was ban on hadiths, and this is written in over 30 ancient books of Sunni Sect*
*Isa is naturally dead in Quran 3:55, 5:116-117, 3:144, and dead never come back*
@@humaidahnnooman
*If you are not Hadith-Rejecter; then you are a Mushrik Kaafir >> Quran 6:114, 5:44, 45:6*
Prophet and his companions left behind not a single page of hadiths. All hadiths are FABRICATIONS. They left behind ONLY WRITTEN QURAN. Quran=Islam; FULL STOP
Thanks a lot
Surah Maryam Ayah 33
وَالسَّلامُ عَلَيَّ يَومَ وُلِدتُ وَيَومَ أَموتُ وَيَومَ أُبعَثُ حَيًّا
“Peace be upon me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I will be raised back to life!”
Allah سبحانه وتعالى speaks through Isa AS and says “on the day I will die” not days (plural). Hence Isa AS will die only once, a natural death, not one due to betrayal.
like die 2024 years ago? then brought back to be judged by allah ?
jesus has died. this video has many error an arab scholar gave response to this video@@phantomdragon6062
@@phantomdragon6062 at the end of time when he defeated Dajjal.
"تُوَفَّىٰ" مبني للمجهول من "وَفَّى"، وليس من "تَوَفَّى"
Can you please tell me which tool did you use to animate in the video?!
Zajhakumullah khair
Alhamdulillah...well understood
Can you make a video about how people come up with the words in the brackets? jazakallah khayran.
May Alloh bless you guys.Aamim
Can you please tell us which scholars you take from jazakAllahu khair brother.
Allahumma barik
The wisdom behind this because when Allah took the soul from someone thet means he will not be alive again until the day of resurrection so means jesus is a full human creature if he didn't die that means there's possibly to return to this world before the end of time.
Where are the other first two episodes?!
Where are other first two episodes?
czcams.com/video/eFHGajTt9o4/video.htmlsi=8Skvzz5KpoJG5WGq
czcams.com/video/WnpYUZLdGyk/video.htmlsi=vcaRj-5jn7rXHtah
Can we download your book 📚 with spending money
A/a
Mashallah good explaining, and I’d like to add a small note if you may.
If we argue that it referring to death rather than sleep just for the sake of the argument, it doesn’t affirm the Christian belief because in the Christian belief you don’t just believe that he died but also the way of death was on the cross not natural death or by stabbing or anything like that, and the Quran clearly states that he was not crucified and that’s the main point.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته.
I would like to know your response to what people say about the verse in Surat An Nisa you displayed (4:159) . The claim is that the pronoun ه returns on the person from Ahlul Kitaab:
الضمير ه يرجع إلى "من أهل الكتاب" و ليس عيسى عليه الصلاة والسلام.
Jazakum Allahu khayran.
Imam Nawawi says that the majority of scholars believe it is referring to the people of the book, not Isa AS.
This was the view of Ibn Abbas RA as well, and so his students.
@@zaryabfarooq4432 People of which book??
@@pharmkiksi7463people of book means the Christians and jews as they both follow their holy book
@@muhammadhaider6071
the same way they believe he was killed yet the quran clearly states he wasn't
the narration that ibn abbas said isa died is weak ali ibn talha didn't hear from ibn abbas so weak when bukhari mentionned it we know that from bukhari to ali ibn talha it is correct but from ali to ibn abbas it is weak
in arabic the prounouns return to last mentionned unless proving otherwise, meaning isa
Doubt !!!
Is transliteration allowed ? Can we write dua and surat using english alphabets in a diary ?
Yes you can
like :
Alhamdu lillahi Rabbil aa'lameen *
Most scholars don't allow transliteration of the Qur'an
ما شاء الله❣️
DONT SAY THAT, BRUH
@@MugmanProductions ok.
Best translation is kanzul iman where linguistics as well as shifat of prophet also used.
Let the comment section remain open.
I pray to my lord and saviour and messiah Jesus to pray to this man
Mashallah
Simple and clear explanation.
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that the word means Death:
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
He specifically mentions this after quoting the verse 3:55. The video has many errors.
Moreover, let's go with the explanation of this video. When Allah or an Angel of death "takes" someone, it means death as well.
@@zaryabfarooq4432 He mentioned in the video that it can mean death. Did you even watch the video?
@@mrdr8695 Ibn Abbas RA literally defines the word in the context of 3:55. Open Sahih Bukhari. He quotes it first
@@zaryabfarooq4432watch the video , stop embarrassing yourself
There is a mistake، that in the verse "ثم توفى كل نفس ما كسبت" it is a different verb
you are a great light for muslims.
وَمَا مُحَمَّدٌ إِلَّا رَسُولٌۭ قَدْ خَلَتْ مِن قَبْلِهِ ٱلرُّسُلُ ۚ أَفَإِي۟ن مَّاتَ أَوْ قُتِلَ ٱنقَلَبْتُمْ عَلَىٰٓ أَعْقَـٰبِكُمْ ۚ وَمَن يَنقَلِبْ عَلَىٰ عَقِبَيْهِ فَلَن يَضُرَّ ٱللَّهَ شَيْـًۭٔا ۗ وَسَيَجْزِى ٱللَّهُ ٱلشَّـٰكِرِينَ
Ali Imron: 144🤭🙏
MashAllah ... Jazak Allahu Khiran.. beautiful explanation..
But even if that happened it would still be totally fine, right ?... the verses say they didnt *KILL* him nor they *CRUCIFIED* him, but God *RAISED* him to heaven... since these are known for certain, isnt it possible that the other details can differ? for example, God *caused his death* (but not killed/crucified by them so still coherent with the verse) and raised him to heaven then revived him again? or he caused him to die and he will still that way until his second time where he will be revived and sent back to earth and then he will die again? so the details changed, but the verses still coherent with each other: wasnt killed, nor crucified, but raised...
if you answer my question it would be great .. thank you
Using the internal evidence of The Qur'an we discover that Allah definitely does not say, he was not killed or crucified. Why do they distort The Qur'an! If Allah had meant to say, he was not killed or crucified, He would have said that but He said something very different which parallels The Torah of Moses if they bothered to read it, which they do not, therefore they are not guided. As for Surah Amram, he was taken as though in sleep, and he was returned to his body after 3 days & nights which is attested in Surahs Amram and Miriam. Moreover there is the eid from Surah The Table, do you need more evidence?
@@nickmansfield1 There is no need to go to Old Testament.
For a Muslim the Holy Quran is the Absolute Truth.
czcams.com/video/CxkUUP0RhKA/video.htmlsi=290opkJgyD8USY0E
@@nickmansfield1 Did you know that Torah was changed to suit the narrative of the NT? For example, the virgin mother? The Gospels are not an explanation of the Torah. The Talmud is the explanation of the Torah. The Torah preaches one god, not three in one.
You are completely correct. This was the position of all Sahaba, Imam MalikRH, Ibn Hazm and so on.
They all believed that Isa AS has died naturally. He wasnt killed nor crucified.
Raised has NEVER been used interchangeably to mean death by any culture any language. Mufti tariq masood has shut the qadiyanis up and called them the worst species to ever exist 😂🤣
Share this with all the Qadianis you know. Perfect video to refute that religion. Jazakullah khairan brother.
"And there is none from the people of the scripture but that HE WILL SURELY BELIEVE in Jesus BEFORE HIS DEATH"
The verse above is not talking about Jesus death but anyone from the people of the Scripture. The "HIS" is for "HE", not for Jesus (as). Subject and the object of the sentence is not Jesus(as).
How does that make sense? So all Jews believe in Jesus before they die?
@@Mehmet_Fatehhow does it make sense otherwise? You say that no one will die except that they will believe in Jesus meaning that everyone of the book will believe in him? What about the people that died yesterday and 1900 year ago and ww1 and ww2? They didn't believe in him? The verse is talking about the people of the book. Not jesus peace be upon him
Alhamdulillah
Just a question to increase my knowledge, why did Allah use متوفيك and not some other word
Just want to understand His wisdom
Because it is a common word referring to taking of the soul. It is used 25 times in the Quran and everytime, it is used to mean taking of soul.
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that it means taking of the soul as well
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
@@zaryabfarooq4432 Why in other verses that word not means death?
Surah Amram ayat 3 and 7.
@@pharmkiksi7463 Because this is the most common word when it comes to taking of someone's soul. To prove that Isa AS died a natural death.
Maut can mean he is killed, or crucified etc
@@zaryabfarooq4432 How about other verses more than one that said IESA (A.S) didn't die
❤
Reference for 4:50???
ما أجمل القرآن الكريم 💚
وَسَلَٰمٌ عَلَيْهِ يَوْمَ وُلِدَ وَيَوْمَ يَمُوتُ وَيَوْمَ يُبْعَثُ حَيًّا
وَٱلسَّلَٰمُ عَلَىَّ يَوْمَ وُلِدتُّ وَيَوْمَ أَمُوتُ وَيَوْمَ أُبْعَثُ حَيًّا
Maryam 15 and 33 🤭🙏
Not sure what you're pointing to in these two ayats. Here it refers to when he will die after returning to earth towards the end of days to set the record straight that he is not God or son of God and is a Muslim.
@@marufruma Prophet Isa or Jesus already death, رفع in Ali Imron 55 means death, that just polite way to said Death, its already proven in Ali Imron 144 that All Rosul(Messenger) already Death 🤭🙏👍👍👍👍
@@irfanmauludin398 no its NOT proven 😂🤣. Mufti tariq masood has proved what the Quran says,
@@razamughal9095 I dont care with Mufti 🙏🙏🤣🤣🤣, just give strong reasoning to us bro 🙏🤭
@@irfanmauludin398 watch his video where he roasted you 😂🤣. Easy.
💚
Do a katam
many issues. seems you've already assumed 2nd coming, and reinterpreting based on that. When الفاعل is God and مفعول is man then و ف ی means death. The root means to complete. It is used over 2 dozen times in that meaning (may be 28 or so). 4-159, contrary to the popular opinion, is not referring to JCؑ. إِلَّا لَيُؤْمِنَنَّ بِهِۦ قَبْلَ مَوْتِهِ is first a reference to Quran (بِهِۦ ), which was mentioned previously (4-153) and the second (مَوْتِهِ) a reference to the Prophetؐ as per the completion of proof (اتمام حجت) law. If there was supposed to be a 2nd coming, JCؑ would have mentioned it in his reply in 5-116.
*In Quran very clearly, Jesus is naturally dead but as you have already said: These sectarians tamper translation of Quran in order to reconcile Quranic translation with their already built-in some unsound Beliefs. If someone guides this kind of people, they will start to quote fabricated hadiths or will declare you a follower of False Prophet Mirza G A Qadiani*
What you have said is TRUTH
@@abdar-rahman6965 jesus is NOT dead. A few shitheads on this page will NOT alter the truth.
@@razamughal9095
In Quran, Isa is naturally dead 5:117, 3:144, 3:55 and dead never come back; and under this video, I have posted already tons of comments in order to explain this point but if you deny Quran; then no one can place you on the right track
That Man of Video is misusing his Grammar skills in order to support a Fiction which was indeed invented by Church, and then it was infused in forged hadiths and then in the heads of Mullahs.
Quran is Mubeen (clear) book. It is not a Book of Puzzles. It is as clear as is 2+2=4 in Quran that though Jesus did not die on the Cross but he lived over 100 years >> Kahlan 5:110, and died naturally.
Even it exists in over 25 well known Ancient Books of Sunni sects that Rasool told to his daughter Fatimah that Isa died at age 120. And Non-Religious Research also shows that he died at age 120
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that the word means Death:
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
He specifically mentions this after quoting the verse 3:55. The video has many errors.
Moreover, let's go with the explanation of this video. When Allah or an Angel of death "takes" someone, it means death as well.
He literally said that it can mean death but looking at context it doesn't 🤦♂️
He mentioned that the word can mean death. Why are you commenting this?
@@mrdr8695 because it means death in the instance of 3:55, thats what ibn abbas said, his commentary is specific to 3:55
@@MANHUW-vz6od because it means death in the instance of 3:55, thats what ibn abbas said, his commentary is specific to 3:55
You copied this comment from someone
At least Surah baqarah
Jazakallah for your informative Islamic contents. But I just wanted to correct you on a mistake here. The word tawaffa in Al Imran means death(but that doesn't justify the Christians view at all) Every time tawaffa is the فاعلand Allah is the مفعول به it always means death. But as I said it doesn't justify the Christians point at all as the Quran already debunked the notion that he was killed or crucified by the people. Allah himself took Jesus' soul at the time of his natural death.
If tawaffa means sleep it will clearly be differentiated just as in the verse ....يتوفٰكم بٱليل. Night was clearly mentioned. And lastly توفى "compensate" is from a different verb altogether تتوفي and not the verb being discussed.
May Allah accept from all of us 🙏🏾🙏🏾
Dont you see why the word mutaffiika was mention with word warafiiuka.
if the Quran mean to said ALLAH take his soul by death, its doesnt need to mention at all ALLAH take and raise prophet Iisa a.s. by Himself.
because we already know every death soul is always taken and keep in heaven untill we revive again by ALLAH.
So Quran just need to said 'Mutafiika' if ALLAH really mean He just take prophet Iisa a.s. soul by death naturally.
So here this verse is not literall meaning or metaphore, like what christian claimed thats Jesus was cruxified than raise after 3day of his death.
Because there already verse explaining clearly, "they did not cruxified nor they killed Iisa".
So thats why in Quran said "they all was in doubt who exactly they killed or cruxified".
So they just assumpted they already killed Iisa because thats what ALLAH make them saw by blinded they eyes..
While prophet Iisa was raise by ALLAH to heaven before they can captured and cruxified him.
If ALLAH mean he already death before he was raise to heaven then, there need for our Prophet Muhammad to mention ALLAH will sent down back Iisa a.s. in his second coming and then he will marry and died naturally as a sign of Qiyamah.
If prophet Iisa already death and then raise again, Prophet Muhammad will said ALLAH will rise him again from death.
If prophet Iisa a.s is already death then thats his prophethood time already end so there no need for ALLAH to rise him from death.
so what the mean rising Iisa a.s back from death, if his prophethood already end. why ALLAH choose prophet Iisa why nor other prophet? because we believe there no other prophet anymore will be sent after prophet muhammad. Prophet Iisa a.s. not death yet thats why his prophethood time still not end. so thats why he will be sent down on earth to continues his dakwah and preach his christian and jewish followers to follow and accept islam and also muhammad as prophet. then he will naturally die after marry to show that he just a normal human not a son of god or god.
He is not come back to teach new religion but to fixed the christianity and then continues teaching islam to christians according to prophet muhammad teaching.
I would recommend the book titled “Good Teacher: The Quranic and Prophetic Story of Jesus” for a more in-depth look on Jesus (as) within the Islamic tradition.
Best of the Mufassir, Ibn Abbas (RA) said that the word means Death:
وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: {مُتَوَفِّيكَ} مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas (R.A) said, “Mutawaffika (مُتَوَفِّيكَ) means death.”
[Sahih al-Bukhari p.634]
He specifically mentions this after quoting the verse 3:55. The video has many errors.
Moreover, let's go with the explanation of this video. When Allah or an Angel of death "takes" someone, it means death as well.
👍
Does Isah (pbuh) still alive could be the question.
Same body as upon his resurrections; after 3 day & nights according to Surahs Amram & Miriam.
@@nickmansfield1 According to your tafsir, g. No Islamic scholars saying this. Please just go back to reading your unknown authored book.
@@Nothing-rd9zh Not my tafsir sir. The Qur'an denigrates anything else after it in terms of ahadith btw.
*Jesus was naturally died 2000 years ago at age 120, and Quran confirms it in 3:144, 5:110, **3:55**, 5:116-117 but the Fanatics who love fiction of Ascension and Return of Jesus, deliberately tamper translation of Quran*
@@abdar-rahman6965
so how about the hadist mention by prophet muhammad refferring to sign of Qiyyamah (The end of day).
There are so many seperate hadist in sahih bukhari mention the second coming of prophet Iisa a.s. as the major sign of Qiyyamah.
some of them have detail explanation the event of when, where and how prophet Iisa a.s. will be sent down.
its was not base on bible or any christian sources. nothing similar story was mention in the bible about second coming of jesus as detail as in the hadists of second coming of Porphet Iisa a.s.
The hadists all said Prophet Iisa a.s. will be sent down back before the end of day. then he will live among mankind marry and die naturally.
REPEAT: The Hadists mention thats Allah sent down back prophet Iisa a.s. from heaven, not rising him back from death on the earth. which mean he should still alive right now in heaven among with angles and other prophets soul. like he is still living imon earth.
cause there is also hadist mention thats prophet Iisa a.s. living in heaven near ALLAH, about 2 day according the time in heaven. and remember 1day in heaven similar to 1000 years in this world.
so you mean if he already die naturally then ALLAH will rise him again and then let him die again? why thou?
ALLAH will not rise any death soul again after been taken to Himself. he only revive death soul again on the Judgement Day.
there not need for prophet muhammad to mention about prophet Iisa a.s. second coming if he already death. because the prophethood time for prophet Iisa a.s. already end if he already death long before prophet muhammad coming.
infact christian also believe in second coming of their Jesus. isnt this controversial for a prophet who teached christianity is false to admit and said thats he believe Prophet Iisa a.s. will be sent down back like christian said?
this second coming of prophet Iisa a.s. not only to show thats what prophet muhammad said is truth, because he dont said anything accept knowledge given by ALLAH.
but also to show to christian that prophet Iisa is also normal human not a son of god or god himself. thats why he will live among humankind, marry and die naturally.
he will deny his christians followers who claimed he is son of god. and he will guide those who believe him as prophet and follows his teaching to accept islam and syahadah.
thats will end christianity obsoluteley because he will also follows prophet muhammad and only continues islam teaching even he is a prophet himself.
this is also to proves thats every prophets even they are still alive till nowaday including prophets Iisa a.s. should follows islam and follows muhammad, according ALLAH ordered.
✅
Can you make one single learn arabic words in quran
It means' re call not die
same chapter maryam is told Isa [Jesus] was going to be honoured in the life this world and the next, however crucified people were dishonoured on the way to the cross and on the cross, the romans often hung them n4ked, let them die, hungry thirsty and in pain. it could never be Jesus on the cross,
yeah no way ALLAH will let his messenger be humiliates by the enemies like thats.
So no doubt ALLAH can saves prophet Iisa a.s. from be captured and cruxified by raising him to the heaven near ALLAH.
Christianity just want to find reason to cover the cruel cruxifation as unreasonanle explaination. and make it so romantised by saying their jesus die because of their sin.
Javed Ahmed Ghamdi is misleasing people...first of all, he ahould know the arabic language so well and then explain the context of the word متوفيك...
Self publicity of his scholarship is deplorable.
Does God take up anyone physically during sleep or death or spiritually? Even if we say Jesus was taken up physically does it prove he didn't die later on?
czcams.com/video/CxkUUP0RhKA/video.htmlsi=290opkJgyD8USY0E
@@Ismail-fk7bs There's verse 4:159 where it says all those who believe in revelations will believe in Jesus before his death. So does this mean his second death after his second birth?
@@Ismail-fk7bs Dear friend my question was does 4:159 mean Isha will die a second time before judgement day?
@@Ismail-fk7bs Actually I never said I believed that a person would be taken to heaven physically nor return to earth physically. Could it be that Isha would be reborn? Second coming of anyone doesn't have to be from heaven, right?
@@Ismail-fk7bs There are examples of humans returning to life in this dunya or two lives in one lifetime. Consider verses 2:259 and 2:243.
And there is none from the people of the scriptures : this i can understand that the text is referring to the people from the scriptures
Where i don't understand is Who is the HE??? refering to : but that He will surely believe in Jesus before his death??
True, he gave a strange translation too for that ayah because his says “believe in Jesus” when nowhere does it say Isa (عِيسَى). Rather it says bihi (بِهِ) which means “in it” such as the event of the crucifixion and raising
Can you turn off the comments. The keyboard warriors are enjoying themselves and creating fitnah. Let them choke on their hatred.
Certain groups. i.e the qadianis
Yessir please read my comment dear brother 🙏
@@munassaralam5442 if you are a qadiani, you are not my brother. I'm free from that cult, even if it was the lahori sect. I'm saved, alhamdulillah
We know Mirza Qadiani was a False Nabi but Quran is not false, and in Quran Isa is dead 3:55, 5:117, 3:144
@@abdar-rahman6965 the Quran DOES NOT say that. See a psychiatrist
INH creates fitnah regarding this verse
This video is the second person inline with INH.
So. Now, when will he come back. We have not too much time fo wait please. Because actually time is over. Head of 1400 years. Because we are now on the 1500 head already.
wait for the signs of Al-Mahdi arrival.
Prophet Iisa only coming when Al-mahdi was appointed as the Imam and khalifah.
Prophet Iisa a.s. will help Al-mahdi killed the dajjal.
There is how we connects the major sign of Qiyyamah (The end of day).
Love your channel. But with all due respect, you are wrong in this matter. Why do you leave our the fact that Ibn Abass (the person whom the Prophet ﷺ prayed for to understand the Quran), said mutawafeeka means mumetooka (ie I will cause you to die), in Sahih bukhari?
It is extremely clear that Isa AS died a natural death not on the cross. And that he will never come back. Someone in his likeness will come.
The Prophet, sal Allahu alayhi wa sallam, also prayed for Abu Huraira, radhi Allahu 'anh. You are also ignoring, willfully apparently, the other ayaat that say that Isa, alayhi sallam, was not killed or crucified. The numerous hadeeth that mention him returning and fighting the dajjal etc.
Read my comment again, akh. Muhammad ﷺ also didn’t die on the cross and was not killed. Does that mean he’s alive for 2,000 years?
Isa AS died a natural death just like any other human being.
Those Ahadith that mention Isa coming in the latter days refer to someone coming in the likeness of him, ie just how he came to revive the true teaching of Musa AS, the messiah for the Muslims will revive the true teachings of Muhammad ﷺ.
@@amaanahmed7376 absolutely waffling how do you come to the conclusion that someone in his likeness will come when the prophet clearly said Isa the Son of marry will come not someone in his likeness😂😂😂😂 I mean I heard many ahmadis waffling but that was the top I mean If you don’t believe he died then let it be but he will not come back and someone else in his likeness ?
Allow me to explain the conclusion:
According to quran: Isa AS has died a natural death
According to hadith: a prophet will come in the latter days who was given the name Isa
So, we interpret hadith in light of Quran. Since according to quran he’s dead, the Isa mentioned in the hadith cannot refer to the same isa of bani Isra’il of 2,000 years ago. Rather, it would refer to someone who would come from amongst the Muslim Ummah who would have the Messianic characteristics of Isa AS. Not that hard to understand, isn’t it?
@@amaanahmed7376 im certain you understand it incorrectly, its very easy for you. But neither the sunnah, other verses of the Qur'an, nor the arabic language are on your side. Come back to Islam, the correct understanding, lest the punishment find you in your grave or the Day of Judgment.
btw, where in Sahih al-Bukhari are you getting this tafseer from ibn Abbas, radhi Allahu anhuma? Ive searched the entire book of tafseer and can't find it.
This account usually does their homework before making videos but im disappointed with this one. Ibn Abass(ra) has clearlyed started that متوفيك مميتك
And so many other evidences of the Quran prove that Isa(as) has passed away.
The sooner Muslims realize this the better
He mostly spreads lies
@@abdar-rahman6965you're both lying to others and yourself, even Mirza Ghulam believed Isa ؑ was raised up alive
@@Peacecraft117
Seems to me that you are a person without any Shame and Conscience because despite I have already responded to you in DETAIL, but w/o reading my comments, you are repeatedly posting your nonsense. *And I have already mentioned under this video several times that Your Grandpa Mirza G A Qadiani was a false Prophet*
@@Peacecraft117
You are that Cattle which is mentioned in Quran 7:179
Christians believe jesus is alive in the sky with Allah. They don't believe he died and will never return, that's early Muslim belief, that all prophets have died. In surah nisa it says, they didn't notice kill him nor crusify him but it appeared as if they did. Meaning that "THEY" didn't do but he has died a natural death. As shown in the last verse of surah maidah. Also the word rafah here is used to remove jesus from all aligations that the Jews said about him. Such as he was cursed (god forbid) and they tried to kill him to prove that he isn't. A messenger of Allah, they also said mockingly that we killed the Messiah, jesus, the messenger of Allah. And Allah says that they didn't , but Allah has raised him. Allah also uses the same language about idrees (pbuh) in surah Maryam. If you believe isa (pbuh) is with his body next to Allah then that's shirk. Major shirk. There is 73 sects in Islam. Only one of them does believe that he has died a natural death and will never come back the other 72 believe he is still alive physically with Allah. This is a Christian doctrine not the belief of the prophet saw or the sahaba
please research hadists about major signs of Qiyyamah (The end of day) in sahih bukhari.
there are many hadists narration thats mention prophet Iisa a.s. will be sent down back again as a major signs of qiyyamah.
Christian believe they already killed him under cruxification. but arise from death after 3 day.
but Quran mention they didnot killed or cruxified him. quran also said at that time the peoples were also doubt wether they really killed the right persons.
but just assumpted thats they already killied him because thats what ALLAH make them to see blindly.
This event also mention in hadists sahih very details.
thats prophet muhammad said: prophet Iisa was not captured by the jews and the romans. but ALLAH make someone look similar like prophet Iisa appearance. so thats they thought they already catch him but nit really him.
prophet iisa will coming to prove thats his not die yet but also to deny the false claimed of christians followers saying he is son of god or god.
so thats he will live among human, get marry and die naturally like other normal human.
he will also follows islam and prophet muhammad.
to prove thats every prophets including prophet iisa, if they still alive must follows prophet muhammad and accept Quran as last book as their revealation according to ALLAH order.
this will end christianity absoutely.
The Quran will make you a good man or woman. It is the starting point and the engine that drives the rectification of your affairs.
You are total wrong.
Mutafiqa means to take soul /cause to die
If you says jesus is not dead then it means he will come and then die .
If he will come how can Quran states the event of the last judgement day where jesus is to be said did you say to people take me and my mother as lords he will say i never said you were near them and you know i dont know when you take out my soul
In this verse of the Quran jesus says that when you take out my soul "same word used" as jesus himself uses says when you cause me to die you were near them you know better i dont know. Why jesus doesn't because he was died and did not come the world again thats why he did not know what they did after him it clear jesus has been terminated by God according to Quran.
Jesus says in Quran mercy be upon me on the day i born and the day i will die and the day i will ressurect .
If according to you jesus is not died then he must come and die then he would get ressurected but if he comes now in this world he will know everything and tell them to worship God and everyone willk accept him then how God says him that you said to them that take me and my mother as Gods and how then jesus replies no i never and i dont know what they didn't after you take out my soul /cause me to die and you were near them it upto you wheather you leave them or not .
As Allah Almighty is everywhere, does it mean that Isa AS is also everywhere?
Allah is not everywhere, he is above, outside of creation. Isa is probably in the second heaven.
@@mrdr8695 So, what does he raised Isa AS " Ilayya" or "to himself" mean, in that case?
This is a very good point and proves Isa AS was not physically raised to Allah, rather, his raising happened just like the raising of all believers i.e in spiritual status.
All is Al-Rafi i.e one who raises believers and debases the kuffar.
It is like Ibrahim saying:
"I am going to my Lord"
Quran 37:99
@@abdussalamsookia it MEANS that Allah raised Isa out of this world to where he pleases. It CERTAINLY proves that Isa is NOT DEAD.
@@razamughal9095 My friend, read the passage again. It says "Ilayya" to himself. Isa AS is with Allah Almighty. And Allah Almighty is everywhere! Think my friend. Think.
Qadiyanis incoming👀
Read my comment 🤛
.........
+
Mostly uses christians their bibleverses from their linguistic languages and messages, which they claim the word of god. In reality it isn't.
Surah Amram, ayat 3 and 7 say otherwise. If you used the internal evidence of The Qur'an you would discover that Allah definitely does not say, he was not killed or crucified. Do not distort The Qur'an! If Allah had meant to say, he was not killed or crucified, He would have said that but He said something very different which parallels The Torah of Moses if you bothered to read it, which you do not, therefore you are not guided. As for Surah Amram, he was taken as though in sleep, and he was returned to his body after 3 days & nights which is attested in Surahs Amram and Miriam. Moreover there is the eid from Surah The Table, do you need more evidence?
@@nickmansfield1 I speak about the past bible, which is was word from god but today not anymore.
@@enes752_Science_of_Kingdom The Bible exists today according to S2:40-42, etc. You cannot deny a book of verifiable prophecy.
@@nickmansfield1 Daniel is a fake prophet.
@@nickmansfield1 Where is the original Injeel and Tanakh? Or, give me a manuscript at the time of Jesus being alive or Moses being alive. I'll wait for you to give me it.
Ahmadis seething rn.
Please read my comment dear brother 😇
Jesus pbuh csnnot die twice.He will die as explained when He will come back
What if he ascended and his soul is kept. It is the same as dying.
Nope!
@@snowstreams7503 If you used the internal evidence of The Qur'an you would discover that Allah definitely does not say, he was not killed or crucified. Do not distort The Qur'an! If Allah had meant to say, he was not killed or crucified, He would have said that but He said something very different which parallels The Torah of Moses if you bothered to read it, which you do not, therefore you are not guided. As for Surah Amram, he was taken as though in sleep, and he was returned to his body after 3 days & nights which is attested in Surahs Amram and Miriam. Moreover there is the eid from Surah The Table, do you need more evidence?
@@nickmansfield1 what Allah didn’t say he was not crucified 😂😂😂😂😂? So surah 4 verse 157 don’t deny a crucifiction ? Ok you can say that it doesn’t deny a overall dead as a natural dead because the saying they did not kill him refers to all the tries the Jews had to kill him before his crucifiction but you cannot say that God didn’t say he wasn’t crucified
@@Dontcallmeapusok If you studied Moses you would understand that Allah is saying that it was not by their power that he was made to appear to be accursed for he who is hung upon a cross is accursed of God. Moses speaks later of those who may say, it was by our own power we defeated them, no it was done through Allah, in Deut.32. This is not the only time that Allah uses this literary technique referring to less well known proofs. Indeed Yeshua ordered Judas to make a deal with the heretical leaders just as Joseph's fate was sealed for the price of a slave, and this is contrasted by prophet Zechariah with Dajjal. Do you understand?
@@nickmansfield1 so to make it short because you didn’t explain that good to be honest you believe that according to the Quran the messaiah son of Mary hung on the cross ?