Silent Hill 3 Analysis | Heather Mason

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 92

  • @stregahex
    @stregahex Před 5 lety +255

    Maybe this sounds ridiculous, but there's another detail that it has been unseen. Each of the first 4 game numbers is represented throughout their stories. SH1- I is the loneliest number...like Alessa was. The isolation of that girl on her own & also the power & will of One ( Alessa's Power Over SH ).
    SH-2 James looking for his partner, Mary & Maria (Ying & Yang ), the "second chance" in Maria & Rebirth Endings. The difference between 1 & 2 is that Cheryl was adopted/ not blood-related, while James & Mary were a "perfect couple" who loved each other just before Mary got terminally sick. SH3 - Alessa, Cheryl & Heather/ Alessa, Claudia & Dhalia. As you said, Triple Goddess (Maiden, Mother & Crone) & Holy Trinity. SH4 - The Home. #4 is symbolically known for being the square, the element Earth & even in the Tarot's minor arcana the four of each suit is related to Stability & The Home. My goodness! Team Silent was the Bomb. 💖

    • @Torthrodhel
      @Torthrodhel Před 5 lety +14

      Makes me wonder what their fifth game might've represented in this way.

    • @mex321
      @mex321 Před 5 lety +7

      Do you think they purposelly did this? I wouldn't be surprised if they did, Team Silent was amazing at those little details.

    • @stregahex
      @stregahex Před 5 lety +2

      @Chris Martin I heard that they're not fond of even numbers, but I wonder why.

    • @stregahex
      @stregahex Před 5 lety

      @RARproductions Wow! No Wonder The Room when possesed looks so putrid. 🤢

    • @SzaraWilk
      @SzaraWilk Před 4 lety

      @Yousef Ghaneemah Yeah, but in Europe five is more like pentagram. Circle and pentagram...

  • @RobloxiaTrollBR
    @RobloxiaTrollBR Před 5 lety +95

    I was waiting so long for this: my favourite character

    • @moizeslopes3991
      @moizeslopes3991 Před 5 lety +1

      Eu também hahaha ♥️♥️

    • @RobloxiaTrollBR
      @RobloxiaTrollBR Před 5 lety +2

      @@moizeslopes3991 :0 Brasileiros aqui???? ❤️❤️❤️

    • @moizeslopes3991
      @moizeslopes3991 Před 5 lety +1

      Eu msm hahaha sou fanzaco de SH e desse canal TB cara ♥️♥️

    • @RobloxiaTrollBR
      @RobloxiaTrollBR Před 5 lety +1

      @@moizeslopes3991 Eu tbm... Encontrei o canal dela pq era mt difícil achar um canal q falava do real simbolismo do jogo ao invés de só falar do terror em si. Aliás, a realidade chocante dos personagens e o simbolismo também adicionam pro terror e as pessoas nem percebem

    • @moizeslopes3991
      @moizeslopes3991 Před 5 lety +1

      @@RobloxiaTrollBR Justamente. Deve haver uns 10 que conheço a série e cada vez mais descubro mais detalhes que enriquecem ainda mais a trama, e me fazem pensar ainda mais sobre a vida..tamo junto querido

  • @FLASHZENTAURI
    @FLASHZENTAURI Před 5 lety +99

    Thank you so much for that video!
    Heather will always be one of my favorite video game characters, especially when I started with the series, I was 14 and could identify myself with her a lot, although she is a female.
    It never really bothered me that she's a girl, I just saw her as a young person who had to deal with the struggles of becoming an adult.

    • @Vibrantly_Monochromatic
      @Vibrantly_Monochromatic Před 5 lety +19

      That's wonderful knowing you can relate to a female character
      Because we all share similar experiences regardless of of our sex

    • @aithanleeom5152
      @aithanleeom5152 Před 3 lety +2

      She was born from a soul her story is by far interesting to me and she is called a reincarnation more games with Heather need to come she's an amazing character who's an abomination since she's literally born from a soul technically she's not even supposed to exist just like various other video game characters and her story of being a witch is most interesting to me she is a brilliant character.

    • @FocusedFighter777
      @FocusedFighter777 Před rokem +1

      There is nothing wrong with this.
      As a woman, there were so very little awesome women roles out there. (I'm 37 now.)
      So I always identified with males, still do a lot: however now we are finally starting to have much better roles for women in games/TVs etc.
      (A lot of people are still against it though.)
      Just the same way I think Harry is perfect, he is a human being.

  • @Trid3nt861
    @Trid3nt861 Před 5 lety +54

    Silent Hill 3 is very memorable. I got the pc version physical but have to get it to work.
    Even though Heather was not related to Harry, the diary that Heather/Cheryl Mason reads in the game shows that even when Harry had his doubts and other things, he decided to love her and care for her unconditionally. The red liquid in her necklace was Harry just being protective of her as a father. Even her badassery and bravery is from Harry.
    Harry went so far as to kill a order cult member who wanted to kidnap his child.

  • @mistermisfortune13
    @mistermisfortune13 Před 5 lety +48

    SH3 is my favorite Silent Hill game. Heather's a smart girl and I respect that

    • @bigboi-gx1xf
      @bigboi-gx1xf Před rokem +3

      Sassy has well

    • @codyelmore3809
      @codyelmore3809 Před rokem +2

      She's a warrior alright she is one of the bravest teenage girl in the horror game section!

  • @Freekchild
    @Freekchild Před rokem +11

    Something I noticed about Heather‘s clothing is that yes, she dresses comfortably, but does not exactly shy away from feminine expression either. She wears a skirt above the knees and shows her arms, yet seems insecure as well. She wears chunky boots that hide her calves and ankles, a turtleneck that hides her neck, wrist bands that hide her wrists (and oddly, a watch over one of the wristbands which seems strange and impractical). Perhaps I’m just projecting, but those clothing choices in particular remind me a lot of myself at her age: Very insecure about certain parts of my body, yet how is yearning to express myself and show as much skin as I was comfortable with.

    • @codyelmore3809
      @codyelmore3809 Před rokem +1

      I feel the same way I'm a guy but I want to say this I feel like me and her have some thing in common ! When I was a teenager myself I was heavily into dark clothes and I still wear nothing but black still till this day ! I remember I will wear a black t shirt a black hoodie or a black leather jacket In the winter only when it's ready cold ! I will wear black jeans or Blue jeans and will wear black milltary style combat boots! I will always tuck my jeans in my boots! I felt comfortable dressing like that ! I will be sure that my outfit was always was in the best way it was and will always try looking my best! I do shy away from trends! Plus I'm heavily a fan of metal music! So you can I'm a metalhead! Heather s ways of fashion are pretty cool though! But difference between my fashion and heathers fashion is her way of clothing is pretty much something that she came up with her self! Like something that matches with her style or attitude! Mine on the other hand was something I came up with myself as well a lot of kids didn't dress like like I did! I didn't have many friends either but hey it's cool! One other thing that I used to do at one point used to dye my hair black! Heather dyed her hair blonde! Heather is a reincarnated Version of Cheryl and Alyssa their natural hair color is black ! And Heathers hair is naturally black too! But Heather dyes her hair so the cult called the order want notice her! My hair is naturally dark brown though! Any way that's just my point of view! I just feel like in real life me and her might have something in common! She is probably one of the most interesting characters!

    • @FocusedFighter777
      @FocusedFighter777 Před rokem

      All of us learn to hide our bodies from a young age: I learnt fast that I needed to dress as a guy, and gain weight to be unatractive, also have short hair etc.
      This ensures less creeps will give you attention.

  • @briwuvsbeauty
    @briwuvsbeauty Před 5 lety +44

    Please never stop making these videos! You deserve so much more recognition

    • @Delaecress
      @Delaecress Před 5 lety +2

      Spread the word for this content!

  • @benyoung4623
    @benyoung4623 Před 5 lety +20

    you always make me want to go back and replay the core games of the series. I love the thought of going through it again with new knowledge of the symbolism and my life experiences. my bf has never played any of them either and I want to watch him experience them all!

  • @melisacaceres8740
    @melisacaceres8740 Před 4 lety +14

    I really enjoyed playing SH3 for how well we get to know Heather as a character. Her commentary while exploring it's so spot on for a teenage girl. And her personality really matches how smart, curious and daring she is. For example she isn't interested in the books of the store in the mall but the books on the church's library seem fascinating to her. Because they're unique like her.

  • @NyikoDoris
    @NyikoDoris Před 5 lety +36

    I've never played the games but when watching our play throughs and going through the Silent Hill wiki over ten times, I've always related most to Heather.
    Lost a parent suddenly and during childhood.
    While I didn't have to go to a mysterious town and fight a physical version of myself, the inner turmoil she feels after she has to truly recognise her fathers death after ignoring it, is something that hit home.
    And just the fact that she's the only female Silent Hill protagonist (and in my opinion, the strongest and smartest) having to go through a rollercoaster of not just growing up, but growing up during the most painful time of ones life just makes her my ultimate favourite.
    Heather is just...so real to me?
    Anyway, thank you for an amazing video as usual!

    • @Isow23
      @Isow23 Před 2 lety +3

      Same here, even though I haven’t played these games. I wished I did earlier but it’s too late for that. Heather/Cheryl, theirs something about her that feels like I don’t wanna sound dramatic but something draws me to her. Wherever her character design, early 2000s vibe around her. Personality idk but something about her I like. It’s weird but I haven’t felt drawn to a character until now.

  • @corarose5295
    @corarose5295 Před 5 lety +18

    That intro was dope... like the thing

  • @siriustoast
    @siriustoast Před 5 lety +15

    I have always really liked heather. Though Silent Hill 2 is my favorite, I always had a thing for Heather's heart beam and magical girl outfit.

  • @yevonite7401
    @yevonite7401 Před 5 lety +11

    I love your channel. I've never really seen someone do this much research on Silent Hill lore before. Especially on 3 and The Room, considering people tend to dismiss any game in the series that isn't 2.

  • @firzanwolfred6112
    @firzanwolfred6112 Před 5 lety +10

    the part after Heather killed the Evil God boss and turn back to look behind her, and with the fact that you stated that there was supposed to be an audio or sound of an infant crying, which if i may add, could be an interesting thing to consider that there may be a chance that Heather also had began her adulthood as a mother early on after she had an 'abortion' . This concept would be considered a nice touch to me if the dev team didn't remove the sound of the crying infant . This could also solidify your statement of Heather having the same upcoming as how her father had before and this had inspired me to make a fan comic that depicts the events in Heather's life after the game event and maybe i can potray how she also adopt the child/infant that was born after the battle of the Evil God .

  • @tuckernutter
    @tuckernutter Před 2 lety +2

    Heather was probably my first experience playing a horror/narrative driven protagonist in my youth. She'll always have a special place in my heart.

  • @Rough_Estimates
    @Rough_Estimates Před 5 lety +11

    I literally beat the game last night! Phew. I like the old intro a little more in the sense it gets me hyped.

    • @Torthrodhel
      @Torthrodhel Před 5 lety +4

      Don't literally beat the game, that'll damage it and it won't play properly afterwards. :P

    • @FocusedFighter777
      @FocusedFighter777 Před rokem +1

      ​@@Torthrodhel
      :D
      Yes, give sweet love to these games.

  • @AgentWolnyTyl3k
    @AgentWolnyTyl3k Před 5 lety +9

    People say that i need to sleep and eat to live. The truth is I need your videos and I won't go to bed until I watch it. Thank you, you are great ;)

  • @Bloody-cj2qv
    @Bloody-cj2qv Před 2 lety +5

    Whenever I'm playing dead by daylight it pains me to see someone playing as Cheryl when I'm the killer. She's a 17 year old who reminds me of me in some ways, if I were a girl. I really don't like hurting her.

  • @FedorovAvtomat
    @FedorovAvtomat Před 5 lety +8

    I get my computer working again. I see this, best first thing to do with the rejuvenated machine.

  • @ErikMyLove
    @ErikMyLove Před 4 lety +4

    Heather means in German "Erika" and it became an women's name too. I never thought about the meaning of this name and I never wondered why they named the protagonist this way. But now, it really makes sense.

  • @lizziealiteralweebx3448
    @lizziealiteralweebx3448 Před 5 lety +5

    God, I love you so much, you are the few people that talk about silent hill, and I love you for that.

  • @meltedvelveetacheesesauce4540

    Heather = Simba
    Henry = Mufasa
    Claudia = Scar

  • @stardust1815
    @stardust1815 Před rokem +1

    I gotta say it's kinda interesting having a character who is a reincarnation of a previously established character be nothing like her past life. Heather and Alessa are opposites in pretty much every way, the only similar thing that I can think of is that Heather's hair is naturally black which she dyed blonde. But in terms of personality and life story both lives could not be more different.

  • @theangellaces
    @theangellaces Před 5 lety +2

    Just discovered your videos and I’m addicted. Thank you so much!

  • @generaldiego
    @generaldiego Před 5 lety +5

    God your videos are so good!

  • @CuntyMisanthrope
    @CuntyMisanthrope Před 5 lety +6

    Love Heather

  • @powruser0
    @powruser0 Před 5 lety +3

    Great video as always!

  • @moizeslopes3991
    @moizeslopes3991 Před 5 lety +1

    Heather is my favorite SH character. Thx for the video, i was waiting for It !♥️

  • @JoseLuisRodriguez-kw8kw
    @JoseLuisRodriguez-kw8kw Před 4 lety +3

    I hope that the fact she is a playable character in DBD means a new Silent Hill is in development. The world needs more games like Silent Hill.

  • @JabamiLain
    @JabamiLain Před 5 lety +6

    So that's why Valtiel wants Heather to be God's mother ! Because God has promised that one day she would return and give "The Paradise" to the people, however, like every person that is born, she'll be a baby, then a child, then a teenager, and finally, an adult.
    "The Cult" believes they are the ones who must bring Her back, however due to their corruption, arrogance and hipocrisy, all they would be able to do was to create a demonic and disgusting encarnation that would do nothing but to bring ruin, death and destruction, because they would be terrible guardians to the child that She would be reborn in. That's why the angel wants to make sure that Heather/Alessa will be the mother of this child, because She first needs to learn that there's both good and evil in the world, and that it's up to her to, thought her "Paradise", make a world that will be in perfect balance and, consequentially, in peace.
    What do you think of this comment "Muse" ?

  • @LilPoopsie
    @LilPoopsie Před 5 lety +5

    I beat the game and started a new one with unlocked costumes and saved over my first save file D< pissed myself off lol

  • @MidnightMosaic
    @MidnightMosaic Před 5 lety +7

    i never clicked on a video so fast

  • @kenmojica
    @kenmojica Před rokem

    I love this character analysis

  • @yyyyy7789
    @yyyyy7789 Před 4 lety +4

    Heather is the best girl 💫 great analysis as always muse 💜

  • @reijiorochi
    @reijiorochi Před 2 lety +2

    Silent Hill 3 is a great way to close off Silent Hill 1. Was it a short game yes.
    And I think now its common knowledge that shes the baby Harry took with him by the end of the good ending but at the time I was 12 and it was a eureka moment when I found out shes the baby grown up again

  • @nothanks7263
    @nothanks7263 Před 5 lety +1

    oooh, i was ready for some music. your stuff takes precedence every time though!

  • @SeanOfTheDead5326
    @SeanOfTheDead5326 Před 5 lety +1

    I've been waiting for this

  • @matneptune
    @matneptune Před rokem

    Have you ever heard of Taliesin? He was a Celtic bard who was born three times. Although her hair is dyed, she shares his blond hair.

  • @user-te5uz9xi8f
    @user-te5uz9xi8f Před 5 lety +2

    Muse, I think it's time you made a course on how to be as eagle-eyed as yourself for seeing the symbols and connecting the dots. I would be happy to be your intern ))
    Also, could we nominate you to give talks somewhere? Ted? Conferences? We have to put you into the light ))

  • @samsteur1609
    @samsteur1609 Před 5 lety +3

    Nice one

  • @kovasky6553
    @kovasky6553 Před 3 lety +1

    The best Silent Hill character ❤️

  • @kamrynrist6049
    @kamrynrist6049 Před 5 lety +4

    I should probably beat the game first before I watch this, i'm at Brookhaven hospital rn

  • @JuicyFruits89
    @JuicyFruits89 Před 3 lety +1

    Love your videos.

  • @Wintersponge
    @Wintersponge Před 4 lety +1

    Can't wait to see her join dead by daylight along with Lisa!

  • @pristinepastel
    @pristinepastel Před 5 lety +2

    not gonna lie, i thought that first sound was my stomach lollo

  • @terrinater
    @terrinater Před 5 lety +1

    Came because of the complaints of cringey comments, stayed for an excellent and well crafted video

  • @ajromero3692
    @ajromero3692 Před 2 lety +1

    I sort of see Heather's story similar to Electra, the daughter of King Agamemnon. In the story, Electra's mother, Clytemnestra, murders Agamemnon. So Electra conspires with her brother to get revenge on their mother and they end up killing her. So basically, Heather is Electra, getting revenge on Claudia (Clytemnestra) for killing Harry (Agamemnon).
    In Jungian psychology, there's also the "Electra complex" which is the female analogous to the Oedipus complex (a girl's competition with her mother for possession of her father). Heather is clearly very close with her father, not in an unhealthy way or anything, but I would say more than the average teenage girl. Her father's death was the final push from Heather being a girl to being a woman.

  • @NicNico
    @NicNico Před 5 lety

    11:53 The better parallel between Norse Norns to Greek mythology would be the Fates or Moirai.

  • @Monarch_943
    @Monarch_943 Před 5 lety

    I didn't know Heather is the sh1 protag's daughter :o I played the games when I was little and I didn't understand a thing

  • @Geschrotteten
    @Geschrotteten Před 3 lety

    nice video

  • @fuziontonygaming
    @fuziontonygaming Před 4 lety

    She’s in DBD now

  • @wardabdulsalam3089
    @wardabdulsalam3089 Před 2 lety

    name of the soundtrack used in the video ?

  • @officialmouse8470
    @officialmouse8470 Před 3 lety

    12:15 I’m surprised you didn’t mention the three with Christianity: God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit. God using the Holy Spirit to make Jesus through Mary, but also that some Christians interpret all three being one in the same, but in different forms. It definitely reminds me of Cheryl, alessa and heather. But that’s just me

  • @jlprod420
    @jlprod420 Před 3 lety

    My favorite in-game female of all time

  • @fernandoblengio
    @fernandoblengio Před 5 lety +1

    There has to be a way to get you more subs, Facebook groups maybe? Let us know what we can do :)

    • @thegamingmuse
      @thegamingmuse  Před 5 lety +2

      That always helps! Sharing the videos around the internet on fb, twitter, discord, wherever you can, is a big help to me! :D

    • @fernandoblengio
      @fernandoblengio Před 5 lety +1

      @@thegamingmuse You definitely need more audience, your videos are marvelous, I'll do what I can to help. Have a great day!

  • @DiablitoKawaii
    @DiablitoKawaii Před 2 lety

    Harry is turning the Valves right?

  • @aertishipper6765
    @aertishipper6765 Před 5 lety +4

    I think Heather's trans. It actually makes sense. For one she gives birth to god by vomiting it out, also the dick monster/boss in the mall can symbolise her overcoming her dysphoria. Also she hates looking into mirrors i.e that whole mirror room that can kill u in the hospital, which also alludes to dysphoria. Its a cool theory! We certainly need mor trans rep in video games. Btw sidenote: Having dysphoria is in no way needed to be trans, its just a societal insecurity that makes us think we're not "woman enough" cause of peach fuzz or similar bs.

    • @drunkenmo
      @drunkenmo Před 3 lety

      i've had a similar feeling! She vomits the unwanted 'god' by taking an oestrogen pill for sure.

  • @Cibernetize
    @Cibernetize Před 3 lety

    Heather’s character design is literally Ashley Graham from RE4 but with an added white vest. Prove me wrong.

    • @ChakLok
      @ChakLok Před rokem +1

      And different facial features and different hair

  • @PunkFiddler
    @PunkFiddler Před 4 lety +5

    Heather/Cheryl is one of the characters SJWs and toxic feminists continue to deny that exists.

  • @gear4thluffy636
    @gear4thluffy636 Před 4 lety +1

    A lot of this is really reaching and seems like this is the first horror game you’ve ever played.
    Puzzles and blood alone don’t say anything about the character, those are literally staples of the genre.
    The game isn’t about “what it’s like to be a teenager growing up” or motherhood. She’s just a teenager and a cult is trying to birth a god through her.