“Over My Dead Body" | Julia Hartley-Brewer v Pro-Palestinian Activist
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 05. 2024
- “Over my dead body while they still hold hostages.”
Julia Hartley-Brewer furiously reacts to SNP leader John Swinney’s demand that the UK must “immediately” recognise the state of Palestine.
Austin Sheridan, SNP and pro-Palestine activist, advocates for two-state solution to Israeli-Palestinian conflict despite lack of clear borders.
Julia criticizes Austin Sheridan for comparing Israel Defence Force to Hamas terrorists, saying it's not the same thing.
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
He knows sweet FA about 'Palestine' he's trying to win brownie points from his left-wing base.
Do you know more
@@rosshitchen-ij6en It would seem most sane people know more
And you do - please enlighten us
@@rosshitchen-ij6en Clearly yes. Perhaps it is you that should learn.
@@ImtiazKhan-wh7xl Oh dear. You choose to be blind.
He just likes attention as a Scot he is embarrassing.
another clueless character
Yep, just like you.
@@Thanatos6 projecting your own faults fools no one here
@@Thanatos6And you’re opinion matters 🤡🤡🤡
She really is clueless... 100% bimbo air-head on this issue
Ahh… you Nazi Zionists certainly know how to control the narrative. 75 years of oppression, occupation, abuse, land theft and all the right wing can do is blame Hamas. Remember hate breeds hate.
As a humanitarian, as a Roman Catholic, I stand with Palestine.
🇮🇹🇦🇺🇮🇹🇦🇺
Politicians like him scare me.
This guy lives in cloud cuckoo land. The two state solution has been offered to the Palestinians on five occasions and been tantalisingly close to happening then they pull out of the talks at the last minute. So bleating on about it as if it likely is just daft. With hamas in charge who have promised to repeat October 7th attacks, how is this solution possible. If only it was.
Thats a lie and you know it.
Hamas have said they will lay down their arms if offered a 2 state solution based on pre '67 borders. Since all settlements post '67 are illegal what's the problem?
@@user-yv9ep4iu3b Where's your detailed, checkable evidence for your assertion? Prove it.
Google: "Hamas official says group would lay down its arms if an independent Palestinian state is established". You'll see the AP News article.
Look it up it's true ! But it does not fit in with your hatred of the Jews does it Adolf.@@user-yv9ep4iu3b
I think he should go and live in Gaza.
I really don't think it's the connection cutting out I actually think it's him ! . He just talked complete crap
Yes the phone got clogged up with his BS
He’s definitely talking out of his arse !
That’s the mentality of modern day politicians.
He can't even say that Hamas are terrorists!!
mandela was called a terrorist for his fierce defence against apartheid wasn't he
@@englishazzouzia8105You aren't seriously comparing the two ?
@@SuellaForPresident yes we are serious. Israel is worst Apartheide the South Africa. 🇿🇦🇵🇸🖤❤️🤍💚💙
SNP embarrassing themselves yet again!
Special Needs Party.
@@robertelliott2216 Hamza Useless`s Puppet .. must be on a back hander ;)
Ficken brass neck - these 🤡🤡 don’t speak for me 🤦♀️
Two state solution not going to happen
If it does happen it won't bring peace.
Yes; one nation for Israel and Palestines
yes it is just wait and see😜
@@PopBeerCan-rm6go
Arab rejected the Resolution 1947.
He's a woke snowflake 😢😢😢
He`s Mamza`s Puppet.. must be on a back-hander or just thick as sh..
He's a Wazzock.
Virtue signaller.
People like this do more harm than good.
Hamza Useless`s Puppet !
I am Scottish and I am sick to death of the SNP and their virtual signaling. The quicker they are no longer in power the quicker we can get back to dealing with issues closer to home.
I agree, but Labour will be no better. It's just a nightmare. I genuinely fear for the future of this country.
@@craighart9278….spot on mate…👍
I am Scottish and I can tell you traitors like you live on virtual only
I agree with you but you have Labour coming in soon, they are no better than the SNP.
How about this idiot housing 10 Palestinians for a year in his own home and then we will listen to opinion. These people hate England above loving their own kids!
This man is talking complete rubbish!
What ! someone from the SNP talking rubbish !
@@styuggs. I know unbelievable.
Nah. Julia talking pure shite.
"man"????? A puffed up little, snivelling male with mashed potatoes in his brain cavity.
Do explain @@Thanatos6
This man does not speak for Scotland.
He must do. They voted for him
No, he is not elected to any political position in Scotland or Westminster. He's an ex SNP counsellor. Not held a position for years.@@JB-fx8bp
@@JB-fx8bp No one voted for him. He in not even an elected local councilor. He is a spokesman for Alex wee shitty party.
Sheridan is so ignorant. Does he not know what hamas want. How come we have such ignorant people in our parliament
Yeah he was ridiculously weak , she’s disgusting
You say what Hamas want. It is clear that Israel wants to wipe out all Palestinians. Israel has stolen Palestine. Israel is committing genocide.
Recognise what? Then what when you do..with who.?
La la land politics.
If you haven't heard of the Balfour declaration and how the British Empire gifted Palestine to the zionists, then I would suggest that you are ignorant.
He was dropped on his head when he was shat out!
LOL good one
The Midwife threw the best bit away.
What gives swinney the right to demand anything?! He wriggled his way to first minister as SNP who got in power on the back of a policy that people don’t want, he persists with Independence and is supposed to SERVE THE PEOPLE. Why does he feel the entitlement to make demands?
Humza yousef is obviously a good friend of this guy too 🚀🕌🚀🕌🐑🐑🐑🐐💨
Because that's how the constitutional rules of the Scottish Parliament work, try researching before making a c@nt of yourself.
Austin Sheridan, one more reason that this country is on it's way out. Silly little man
spain dares to talk about israel, but what about Catalonia and Basque Country???
Exactly!
so you are against illegally taking land and settling people in it?
What about their city enclaves in Morocco such as Ceuta?
That's right with the aid of the Nazis practice on the Catalonia people with franco Guernica flattern to rubble Norway and Sweden war separated Sweden would like it back it goes on the Norman's in Britain taking all the land from the Britons it goes on and on how far back you can find the same thing
This is called Jihad, the Islamic art of war; it includes the womb, children, banking, politics, migration, war and anything which can disrupt the cohesiveness of a group of people. From the 14th century until the early nineteenth century. Islam has waged war. One thousand nine hundred and fifty-four battles and continuing, conquering vast tracks of Eastern Europe, Spain and Portugal, Andalusia and Ukraine, for example, which they still make claim to today. If a Muslim steps one foot into a foreign land, he will immediately claim the land as conquered by Islam. To add insult to injury, they were taught they were superior to us. In the earlier days of the invasion, when they placed young (men) into classrooms, they would soon become impossibly disruptive and violent as they were so out of their depth. They can befriend you, but only to advance the Islamic cause. They also can lie without malice to us to forward the Islamic cause; this is down to a story from the Life of Mohammad (Hadith). Do not be taken in; these people have but one plan. A British politician, a Green Party member, when it came up that we should take people from Gazza, claimed, "what's the problem, they are just children," to which somebody plays a post wherein a young lad, maybe nine or ten, claims that when we get into Europe, they must slaughter Westerners for Islam.
Austin Sheridan, mad as a bloody hatter.
Left wing idiot
Working class hero name 😂
@@spm36 plastic paddy
How many civilians died in the second world war, that's war I'm afraid
Yes, and that was an authoritarian regime annexing land outside their borders. You fool.
Its not the same if you are occupying them. its like the UK killing people back in the day in India and then saying that's war I'm afraid.....they shouldn't be there in the first place
Yes, a great achievement of Western civilization that should work as the gold standard of morality.
The second world war was between very well equipped national armies ... not one very well equipped army versus woman and children.
@@alimohsin1514helping to reduce the drain on the Earth 🤨!
What an arse
This guy is such a MELT!!!
Says some random moron on CZcams comments. Get a life.
I stand with Jewish people and Israel 🇮🇱🇬🇧
I 100% agree. I stand with Israel.
🇬🇧❤️🇮🇱
PEACE FROM TEL AVIV ISRAEL
TAKE CARE OF UK THEY ARE LIARS AND VIOLENT IN THE NAME OF THEIR VIOLENT RELIGION
Same here 👍
Free Free palestine
The Zionists want to do exactly this by making calls to resettle Gush khatif.
The PLO were offered that for 30 years and went against it, blocked it all the time, from the river to the sea means 1 state and that state is only Palestinian
I suspect people know what from the river to the sea means but are deliberately being obtuse to hide their deep-seated hatred.
They rejected the opportunity for "self determination" on 5 separate occasions 1936, 1947, 1967, 2000 and 2008
Yea totally... is like England is all England don't get no white rich people carving up our land and try saying they own from the coast to the Thames. Who ever still believes in that crap, are narrow minded individuals. Must be easy for these idiots, to just believe what the government and propaganda tells them. Pathetic.
Hmm its not rocket science- Israel are occupying illegally - why cant people understand this- Its like the Romans coming to England and saying we lived here before you so its our right - would you accept-errr errrr no you wont.
Nobody who has a sound mind and knows history and will always say that Israel is in the wrong here- And by the way I dont support Hamas i hate them they are scum- But let me ask you a question in the Holocaust if any extreme group wanted offer help I guarantee you every Jew would have accepted regardless who they are.
That is nor what the plo meant at all they recognized the israeli state but that Palestinians would live alongside the israelis in peace with EQUAL RIGHTS. And that was what was so controversial, for israelis
I would have thought he would be putting more effort into looking at the future of the Scottish people and concentrating more on making lives better for them. Why are we being brainwashed with Israel and Gaza when we have enough problems of our own.
Well done Julia!
Well done for what? For acting like an uneducated, rude and uncivilised piece of garbage?
U r displaying your ignorance
@PopBeerCan-rm6go
On the contrary
In case you can't confront yourself with the reality, go to chat with like-minded
She is your mother because you're s mf
Agree 👍
Never has been a Palestine state, Never will be.
Before 1948 wasn't an Zionist state so it is apples and oranges.
Yeah 143 countries out of 194 UN members recognise Palestine as a state . They are bloody mad
@@free_spirit111corrupt.
Unless you follow the yellow brick road.
actually, after april 13, it is very likely.
Really tired of hearing about Gaza and Palestine. The SNP should be concentrating on the people of Scotland, not some religious, cultural dispute thousand's of miles away. As with Just Stop Oil, the more this goes on, the more people will just switch off.
are you ignoring the fact that the UK started it and now provide weapons along with the US to kill innocent people? or should we all join you under that rock you're living under
No no ceasefire no no ceasefire
Shut up.
there was a ceasefire in place and then hamas attacked and broke it
@@user-mg2ip8cr8z brush ur teeth
@@user-mg2ip8cr8z This narrative is only true if you ignore the facts....so according to you no one died in the west bank on October 6th? or October 5th? or is it only a 'ceasefire' if Israel are the only ones doing the shooting?
Definition of a Palistinian: an Arab post-1960 who previously identified as being Arab but who now says he is Palistinian: They are NOT Palistinian, but they identify as being "Palistinian."
So, committing a terrorist attack and taking hostages is going to be rewarded by SNP and Labour? OMG!! 🤦♂️
Are you taking about Israel here or Hammas? as both are holding hostages and are committing terrorism
@@jacky5768one has hostages and one has prisoners of war! One is a designated terrors organisation! Or is that too difficult to grasp 🤨!
@@jacky5768 At last! someone with a more than 2 brain cells on here.
yes yes yes
@@lal2300 wtf are you talking about more then 3000 palestinian ar held in detention center without even a charge. Yes thats a hostage!!!
When Palestinians, not Hamas of course, are allowed to come here, be given a house, GP, NHS dentist, a phone, a laptop, a bike, school places im sure this traitor to our great nation will be much happier. C u next Tuesday.
We give all that to uneducated bigots too, I know who I'd rather have.
What a prat Austin Sheridan is
An incomprehensible prat.
If brains were gun powder, he wouldn’t have enough to blow his hat off. He’s an MP. How has the UK got to this stage of affairs. It’s becoming very worrying.
,
He's not an MP, MSP or local councillor. Just some SNP talking head.
I do hope all voters will either vote Reform or vote Tory.
Anything to keep out the disaster that would be a Labour government .
yes because we're not currently in a disaster.....
@@jacky5768there is bad in ‘some’ areas or bad in all areas! Everything I see from labour is disastrous!
I want to vote reform but doing so will allow Starmergeddin!
Let’s talk about immigration..... with immigrants 🥴... how did you think he was going to act?
Can you imagine voting for someone who doesn't read and whose arguments are not based on fact.
When I hear of Tory voters saying they will vote Labour, I think what insanity.
When I hear anyone saying they vote Tory I think what insanity
I can understand people not voting Conservative but to vote Labour is beyond me.@@jacky5768
What more do you expect from the SNP
We all know what hamas wants to do
yes and a lot of people support this goal
what a load of crap we ought to more worried about what's going on in this country
Cuckoo!!! Cuckoo!!! 😂
shes mental! totally agree
Ill have 2 of whatever he's on
A man completely out of his political depth. His leaders should have a word with him and his poor knowledgebase around the middle east.
Julia is one of about 3 people I would cross the street to shake her hand. Brave, factual and logical.
Ahaha u do that 🍩🍩 free 🍉🍉
U r sick
@@PopBeerCan-rm6go look Zioo r 😷
@@PopBeerCan-rm6go sick of ziooo
Who on earth in the middle east gives a hoot about what the snp thinks or says
There is no place called Palastine!
There is a palestine country before thé birth of your grandparent!
@@zahiraaitlachgar34 Haha You still trying that cut'n'paste !
There is no place called Israel.
There's only a place called Israel because a British Antisemite campaigned to keep Jews out of Britain. Read Hansard.
@@zahiraaitlachgar34Wrong and you know that.
Palestine has always been a territory of other Empires, Kingdoms, and Caliphates.
It has been that way since The Roman Empire conquered the area and it was the Kingdom of Judea.
It was Rome that changed the name of the to Sryia-Palistina after the Second Jewish Revolt against their rule. This was done to try and obliterate the connection the Jewish people had to their homeland.
"The Yids always win, The Yids always win, just like in Palestine, THE YIDS ALWAYS WIN" !!! Viva La Israel, no retreat and NO SURRENDER until the job is done!!!!!
100% 👍👍👍
So long as their problem doesn't become our problem we have enough problems as it is .
@@markmorrid8144 Their problem already IS our problem because of unvetted illegal immigration.
Bit of a European name there, did you 'settle' in 48?
@@Titus9508 Hello tit head still trolling I see.
Their logic doesn’t stand up to a single straight forward question - really makes you wonder about their motivation
Unpeaceful hamas
Julia. Absolutely accurate. Thank you
The Arabs have been offered a two state solution on 7 occasions and have never agreed to two states. How do you discuss with people who won't listen to you?
starting in 1937 with the peel partition plan then in 1947 the UN partition plan then all the others from the 1970s 80s and 90s , why anyone thinks it will work now is beyond me
so if I invaded your house and told you that this is all mine and gave you and your family a shed in the garden to live in then you would be okay with it?
@@jacky5768It was never theirs to begin with. They were merely on land that the Ottomans grabbed.
@@jacky5768 that is not what happened at all but when lies fill your head what else do u expect
@@jacky5768 they never even had a house to invade , squatters have zero rights to anything
There has never been a Palestinian state. There has never been Palestinian land.
Even if we were to go back to the 1967 cease fire lines that would be giving land to Jordan and Egypt, land which both Egypt and Jordan took by force.
Absolute lies disproven by every map, Atlas, history book, film archive on the planet. Keep your Colonial Racism to yourself.
so you're only a state and own land if a foreign power tells you that?
@@jacky5768 Well, the fact that there was no group that called themselves Palestinians before the 1960s is also a factor.
The Arabs during the British mansate simply called themselves Arabs.
Not to mention, Palestine is a European name for that land. It has no origin in the area. The first to use a similar-sounding name was a Greek man in the 5th century BCE.
There has never been a state, kingdom, nation, empire, group by the name of Palestine or Palestinian before the 1960s; even Araft, the "Father" of the Palestinian movement was born in Egypt and was an Egyptian.
@@Benjamin-vm8di Again your entire argument is based on Britain telling them who they are.....England was called something else years ago, does this mean anyone who's English shouldn't call themselves English and they don't have the right to exist?
@@jacky5768 Nope, my argument is that they never existed and never had a land.
They have the right to self determination, sure, but that right doesn't give you the right to land. If 11 million people now deterimened that they are X and London should be their own state, would England just give it to them? No. X never existed before and never had land before, they have no claim.
The Palestinians can decide today that they are a people, sure, it doesn't mean they are entitled to land.
He concentrate on his area of responsibility, not a different place miles away
He doesn't have any position of authority, not elected.
Wow, the SNP really are dumb as,
Just blinded by their hatred of the English
Now the facts of the fire are emerging and the haters case is imploding
One side is pure evil and the other side are not.
I know and its scary that the US and UK are funding pure evil
Let him see a video of that dreadful day in full.
Absolutely don't talk about the Right wing racist ZIONIST Apartheid Government when discussing possible peace in Palestine but rather keep being up Hamas who have only been in power for 16 years, also ignore the past 75 years of a Brutal Military Occupation and start the conversation on the 7 October. !!
WOW this is the pinnacle of IK journalism I'm blown away. !!
Can't understand a word he's saying. 😂
Neither can he!
Always amazes me people have time in their lives to devote to places in the world they’ve never been, have no connection to, and have no indulgence over.
Imagine if he spent his activism time demanding the end of grooming gangs and the removal of foreign criminals and gangs.
This guy is a self certified victim.
Why does he go there?
SNP are a joke
🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 ❤
translated----- (you love Genocide )
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💩💩💩💩
🇮🇱🏴❤️
i ate pork chops with your mother and Sister
@@user-gk1lo6ni1b grow up.
Lucky he didnt ask for 200,000 hamas supporters to be brought here, good reason why all Palestinian neighbours have said no thanks
They Will be flooding into Ireland now !!
Please supply subtitles for future then we’ll be able to hear both sides!
Yup, Julia's drunk again.
Well done JHB that was great check mate with the lRA comparison. ❤
So anyone the UK has invaded are ladled as terrorists when they fight back?
The SNP 😂😂😂😂😂
Me to!! If the SNP recognise Palestine, I in Scotland will feckin not!!
The SNP are nut lost my vote forever now 😪
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼Ms. Hartley!
Can’t understand him
he needs to read some History books instead of listening to his mate in the pub, what a joke!
Democratic state of Palestine? There isn’t a single Muslim democratic state. Why would Palestine be different?
Additionally, other groups that participated in the October 7 massacre are Palestinian Islamic Jihad -- and Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, the armed wing of the Fatah faction headed by none other than the multibillionaire president of the Palestinian Authority (PA), Mahmoud Abbas.
So **Pallystinian** who? Which regional, jihadist Arab tribe are we talking about?
The original terror group started this conflict is the Israel in 1948
@@run2cat4runaaahh you’re REALLY well read…………… not😡🔫 CRETIN
@@run2cat4run Also supported by the UN?
@@MrDrbld no they let this conflict happen
@@run2cat4run The UN supported the creation of the Sate of Israel in 1948. They are by many peoples definition both Zionists and terror group supporters
Free hostages
Some Scots need to realise that their accent is unintelligable. The French, Germans, or anyone else who appears on the telly try to be understood. We should have a plain English translation underneath this guy.
The Palestinians only want a single state solution
Thanks SNP isn't getting my vote this guy is a muppet.
Words of wisdom from special needs party 😂
Let him come face to face and negotiate with Hamas if he thinks they are rational normal people.....
This isn't the first time politicians have wanted to recognise a terrorist regime, there were exactly the same conversations about Pol Pot and the KR, and the UN wanting to recognise the KR as a legitimate Gov and political organisation. They didn't go well, politicians never learn, they seem desperate to reward some terrorists and their regimes by appeasing them and claiming they're legitimate, when we all know the truth that these regimes are just terrorists and who are abusing their power by indoctrinating the next generations into their hate filled belief system. Those who think otherwise especially politicians are naive useful idiots to these regimes.
One word, DELUDED!
Yeah she is, but what do you expect from talktv
@@jacky5768 So you believe that Hamas want peace! So one word for you, deluded!
Hi five ✋️ 🙏 Julia
looks like scotland will be inviting their palestinian bros in
“THE QUEEN’S SHILLING” is an essay written by a veteran presented to the Queen as an outstanding
instructor at Sandhurst Officers Training College. To gain poetic licence and avoid being pedantic, it echoes
ancient verse but its topics and tactics are all designed to address todays problems. It refutes those
rewriting British history, rediscovering the values that founded all democracies and the perils they face now.
Clear survival methods are crucially forwarded for embellishment & discussion. Click on the name above
these lines and then on the BLUE LINK. I’m largely bed-ridden now so no more London rallies= The Pen..
Julia you have the patience of a saint trying to educate bacon
It's not our problem 😅stay out of there problem
It is your problem. You lot started this whole thing.
We have already imported the problem.
@Thanatos6 explain your self clown 🤡
We started the issue and now help fund it.....but yes lets look the other way and pretend its nothing to do with us
I love Julia! She reminds me of a time when life in England made sense and when common sense was more common.
This guy should be behind a bar running a pub.Just agree with the regulars to appease them.
Thank you so much for supporting good journalism ❤
If they vote hamas then you should respect a democratic vote!
Yes but in most democracies the people who win don't turn around and murder the opposition and then never have another vote.
That was in 2006, no elections since.
Show him the unedited video from 7th Oct!
Vote for somebody else other than snp
God get him off. He has no idea what he’s talking about. He lives in disneyland
He's a lefty scot. What did you expect.
Scotland is such a utopia the MSP 's have time to focus on problems thousands of miles away.
Lucky old Scots.
wonder how long he would last working with his hamas mates.