when people say "it was too slow", I ask "Do you mean it dragged?" If they aanser "no" then it wasn't slow. There's a difference between MM tempo and pulse. It takes a great musician, like Celibidache , to play at slow MMs as he does but to keep the music going forward. What he gains, is in the textures, the inner parts have time to phrase, you hear so much more of what is happening in the orchestra. The inner parts have space to breathe.
There is a 1982 Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart performance also on YT. The tempos are very similar. This is the way Celibidache conceived the piece.
Magnifique ! Incomparable avec Karajan !!! Il n'y a pas de superlatifs assez forts pour Célibidache ! Quelle chance incroyable pour iwan...2003 d'avoir pu assister aux concerts de cette époque !
MINUNAT CELIBIDACHE ȘI ORCHESTRA,CE PĂCAT CĂ L-AM PIERDUT,OOFF, TOTUL IESE MINUNAT DIN MAINILE LUI,CE PERSOANĂ MINUNATĂ A AVUT ROMANIA ROMANUL CELIBIDACHE!!
Magnificent. Pardon the travesty of the beer advert, but Celi get to parts other conductors can't reach. Without comparison. Love his music. Thank you for the post.
superbe !! aussi bien que Karajan...un vrai Maître en musique Française en tout cas je l'ai vu en vrai avec l'Orchestre National de France avec du Beethoven la 6ème, Ravel ma mère l'oie, le Boléro .. j'avais 12 ans ..51 maintenant j'étais aux anges !!!!
Un tout petit peu plus âgé que vous..., j'ai assisté à presque tous ses concerts à la Maison de la Radio, quand j'étais étudiant en 74/75. 40 ans après, quel souvenir ! Je n'ai pas entendu en concert un seul autre chef qui m'ait autant "marqué"...
In 984 he shocked the New York audience including those movers and shakers of the American classical music industry with a student orchestra - The Curtis.
Interesting performance. I swear I hear a dog bark at 1:07 ??? The orchestra itself is not top quality, but there is something very heartfelt about this performance that others lack. I love the slow tempo. Thank you for posting this video.
The 'dog bark' makes me laugh! It was a very new orchestra when this was recorded and in a country where Franco was still supreme. Educational opportunities were few and far between. I worked with many of the musicians seen here and there was quite rightly a sense of great pride that something special had been created. The last founding member of the orchestra retired only relatively recently.
Platon Buddha and Celibidache are something for me.
Величайший дирижёр.Музыкант.Историк музыки.Сын Румынии.Уледший от политики ради музыки.Преклоняю колени.Беларусь скорбит.Земля пухом.Аминь...😢
Parcă auzi vocea compozitorului in interpretarea maestrului Celibidache.
Magnific!
when people say "it was too slow", I ask "Do you mean it dragged?" If they aanser "no" then it wasn't slow. There's a difference between MM tempo and pulse. It takes a great musician, like Celibidache , to play at slow MMs as he does but to keep the music going forward. What he gains, is in the textures, the inner parts have time to phrase, you hear so much more of what is happening in the orchestra. The inner parts have space to breathe.
So beautiful you said! The music flows... Love Celibidache and I am so proud he is romanian ❤
There is a 1982 Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart performance also on YT. The tempos are very similar. This is the way Celibidache conceived the piece.
@@samirafterone ❤ me too!
@@FrankB1001 ❤ beautiful music!
Celibidache =GENIU
Simply magic . When you think that he was an invited conductor, it is amazing what he got from these musicians.
Magnifique ! Incomparable avec Karajan !!! Il n'y a pas de superlatifs assez forts pour Célibidache ! Quelle chance incroyable pour iwan...2003 d'avoir pu assister aux concerts de cette époque !
Celibidache gets you to listen to parts which you simply do not hear in other interpretations! Just magic.
Grande el Maestro...
Rip în love ! 🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷
MINUNAT CELIBIDACHE ȘI ORCHESTRA,CE PĂCAT CĂ L-AM PIERDUT,OOFF, TOTUL IESE MINUNAT DIN MAINILE LUI,CE PERSOANĂ MINUNATĂ A AVUT ROMANIA ROMANUL CELIBIDACHE!!
Grande!!!!..Muchas gracias, y qué recuerdos del Teatro Real como sala de conciertos..
Assolutamente incomparabile,grandissimo direttore che innalza questo capolavoro del genio di Beethoven ai livelli esecutivi più alti.Sublime.
Celibidache is truly amazing.
-- Prodigieux Celibidache. --
Magnificent. Pardon the travesty of the beer advert, but Celi get to parts other conductors can't reach. Without comparison. Love his music. Thank you for the post.
This is one of my favorite symphony . 這一個版本很有層次感，很有節奏感，起伏有致。緩急輕重下，充滿生命力。
good. But, quale non è favorita ?
MAGNÍFICO!!!! BRAVO!!!
SIEMPRE CON SENSIBILIDAD Y CLASE DON SERGIU.
superbe !! aussi bien que Karajan...un vrai Maître en musique Française en tout cas je l'ai vu en vrai avec l'Orchestre National de France avec du Beethoven la 6ème, Ravel ma mère l'oie, le Boléro .. j'avais 12 ans ..51 maintenant j'étais aux anges !!!!
Un tout petit peu plus âgé que vous..., j'ai assisté à presque tous ses concerts à la Maison de la Radio, quand j'étais étudiant en 74/75. 40 ans après, quel souvenir ! Je n'ai pas entendu en concert un seul autre chef qui m'ait autant "marqué"...
Karajan? Dem fehlt doch jeder Funken Geist. Wie sollte der Beethoven verstehen können?
pure harmony !
perfection...
Grande Máximo Muñoz!!! ¡Qué bien fraseado!
Pues no tengo mucho de Celi hablando en español. No obstante volveré a revisar el VHS y si hay algo intentaré subirlo.
Saludos !!!!
It's quite interesting to watch Celi's rehearsals on the net.
Second rate orchestra? Not a problem Celibidache to the rescue!
In 984 he shocked the New York audience including those movers and shakers of the American classical music industry with a student orchestra - The Curtis.
Great Conductor undoubtedly, this was always his style,conducting practically all works very slow, for this symphony in particular i think it is OK.
marcelouz1 Always these complaints about his tempos. His interpretations are inspiring to me.
@@genevoce8548These complaints are right. Listen to the great Costantin Silvestri
Slow,deep,charming performance.
Interesting performance. I swear I hear a dog bark at 1:07 ??? The orchestra itself is not top quality, but there is something very heartfelt about this performance that others lack. I love the slow tempo. Thank you for posting this video.
The 'dog bark' makes me laugh! It was a very new orchestra when this was recorded and in a country where Franco was still supreme. Educational opportunities were few and far between. I worked with many of the musicians seen here and there was quite rightly a sense of great pride that something special had been created. The last founding member of the orchestra retired only relatively recently.
It is correct. It seems that a dog is barking at 1.07: Carsten Schjørring
Так как рабоьпл Величайший Мастер Чибилиаде с Оркестром не работал никто.ЕГО место было в Ла Скало.Господи Храни Душу Его.Аминь.😢😢
I like the hornist with sunglasses !
eindeloos mooi maar... er komt toch een eind aan.. en de Dirigent is totaal en extreem geweldig in alle opzichten !
❤
🙏🙏🙏
29:04 oboe is one bar too early... But that rather funny lapse doesn't ruin that great rendition at all!
1:07
very nervous oboe player, wrong entry at bar n. 344 in the 3rd mv. and horn very insecure before that
チェリビダッケのどこが良いのか、さっぱり分からない。音はだらしなく進行し、表現力に乏しい。