INDIA PAKISTAN : MULTI DOMAIN SCENARIO
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 04. 2024
- #GUNNERSSHOT #InternationalRelations #UPSC #CSE #StrategicAffairs #defence
INDIA PAKISTAN : MULTI DOMAIN SCENARIO
Members of the panel are Lt Gen Ata Hasnain (R), Lt Gen K J Singh (R), Ambassador A Triguynayat, Ms Tara Kartha and Lt Gen P R Shankar (R).
GUNNERS SHOT IS A CHANNEL FOR DEFENCE & STRATEGIC AFFAIRS, TECHNOLOGY AND WELFARE OF ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
GUNNERS SHOT is a channel in which the best of Indian Military and Strategic experts express their views and opinions.
GUNNERS SHOT is a non partisan channel devoted to high quality.
Support Gunners Shot with your contribution through GPay to +91 9384855773
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT CZcams CHANNEL@ / @gunnersshot9829
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT TECH CHANNEL @ / @gunnersshottech-jl6gp
Join the channel as a member @ / @gunnersshot9829
THIS VIDEO IS AVAILABLE IN PODCAST FORM @ / @gunnersshot9829
Gunners Shot CZcams Channel has multiple .playlists to enhance your viewing experience.
All articles are available @ www.gunnersshot.com
Follow Gunners Shot WhatsApp Channel @ whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaEZ...
Twitter : @palepurshankar or @gunners_shot1
Join Telegram group @ t.me/gunnersshot
Disclaimer : Views expressed on this channel by this who appear on it are their personal opinions and can not be attributed to GUNNERS SHOT
This Episode needs to be listened again and again
The ideas and things put across in this Episode are different
Only then one can comment on the Contents of this Episode
what a debate great absolutely great analysis
Gen Ata Hasnain as usual went into more depth I loved it as it clears my understanding
Channels like gunners shot are
educating and creating awareness amongst the citizens of India. unfortunately no such content was available in the past.
Regards !
In depth analysis ..talks like this should be taken as an assignment for the students pursuing B.A./M.A.Defence studies
Always enjoy the contents of discussions. All respected participants.
If not best, certainly one of the best podcast of Gunners shot.
Very fine discussion. I still wonder why this channel didn't touched a million mark. Jai hind.
Help me spread it. People on CZcams want masala.
@@gunnersshot9829 you are right people want masala just see the Thumbnail of many youtubers on middle east crisis
Thanks dada 👍🏾
Congratulations !
Gunnershot
&
General Shankar sir
on reaching
30,000 subscribers
Next.. 50k...100k...
प्रणाम
Very fine discussion. No disrespect for our men in uniform ❤❤
💯💯💯💯💯
Fine discussion as usual with a very good selection of speakers .
I think your channel will do well in the medium and long run .
Such serious and strategic thinking channels always will have less traction , maybe in not more than 0.5 % of the Social Media viewers.
After all , that is the percentage interested in such informed discussion.
But you keep it up .
It is a great legacy for you to leave for posterity .
And of course credit goes to the very good Ex Armed forces officers and other strategic experts and thinkers .
Views will definitely increase , into several thousands and a few lakhs in due course , but never into millions .
As happens in the more popular Vlogs , which we are aware of .
Most people want to see issues / events in black and white.
They lack the comprehension to see shades of grey .
I am in no hurry. Long race to be won
Gen sir Tara Kartha and Gen KJ Singh please call them regularly.
34:50
General Ata sir..
On
Hybrid Warfare ...
1) There are/may be NO Outcomes
Do not look for Outcomes
2) Do not think in terms of
Victory & Defeat
as in
Conventional Military Thinking
3) The process is Long Term
4) Sometimes there will be ADVANTAGE, Other times there will be DISADVANTAGE
But...
Multi Domain or Greyzone effort should continue..
40:10
Another
New Thought..
General Ata sir ...
On Pakistan's Stature..
"DILUTE
Pakistan's
Islamic Importance"
.. by forming Relationships with
Islamic Nations
which are at the
COST
of their
Relationship with Pakistan
...........
Very Unique Idea put forward
details of its formulation and execution ..
Only
General Ata sir
should tell us in a Future Episode
38:20
Very New Terms..
In this Episode
General Ata sir..
On..
1) "Irrational Enemity"
2) "Muscular Nationalism"
3) International Effect of
Irrational Enemity
(Attitude of Western Media towards Bharat)
In today's day and age I think economy and hard power matters more than media/PR management
Until you reach there the rest matters
Jai Bharat
8:25
Another
New Point rarely Spoken..
General KJ Singh...
On
Climate on
Our Borders :
1) रक्षा मंत्री Rajnath Singh ji talked about
DISTURBING
Weather Patterns
on Our Borders
Is it
ENGINEERED ?
2) But don't China Credit for this
3) It is in the
COGNITIVE Domain
...............
Why it is NOT China ,
But in
COGNITIVE Domain
What does
Cognitive Domain
mean here ?
General sir should Explain in a Future Episode
27:30
Tara Kartha ji...
On Pakistan's Nuclear Weapons :
"If South Africa's Nuclear Program was taken away,
If Former Soviet Union's Breakaway Part's Nuclear Weapons could be taken away,
Then...
"Why Pakistan's
Nuclear Weapons
Cannot be taken away ?"
.....
This is a Point/Thought/Narrative /Policy
That
Nobody in Bharat has ever thought .
"How to pursue a Policy of taking away
Pakistan's
Nuclear Weapons"
One of the most things possible for Bharat if it can happen..
25:30
Tara Kartha ji ...
On Pakistan Breakup:
"There is a Constituency in this Country (Bharat) which says Pakistan is going to Breakup..
It is NOT going to happen"
⚔️⚔️🫡🫡⚔️⚔️
Happy VIJAYA DASHAMI TO EVERYONE ❤
43:50
General Ata sir..
On
Pakistan's
Nuclear OVERHAND...
1) Pakistan's behavior with Bharat has been like
Pakistan is the ONLY
Nuclear Power in Subcontinent
2) Bharat should let Pakistan know clearly what Our Nuclear Capabilities are and not tolerate its Reckless behavior
............
This is a Point which is at the ROOT
of
Pakistan's Reckless Bullying Behaviour in the Past
We really need to have a
Public Posture such that this Recklessness of Pakistan is checked
We really have been just silent on this issue
For Example:
Even at the Height of
Cold War Days
Both..
USA & USSR
Used to give each other Open Nuclear Threats
(With the result being that
NO Leadership ever Miscalculated the Intentions and Capability of the Other)
Sir, Why so detailed discussion on sensitive matter within open platform ?
dont worry...not so sensitive
How do we fang pak military? Reduce its size? Use regional groups to defame Pak military?
BLUE DOMAINS WILL GET BOOST
Here are some salient points:
1. All the six major powers will NEVER allow the Pakistan to exercise the nuclear threat.
2. Pakistan is a dysfunctional state of no real significance or relevance. Bharat should continue the exclusion strategy.
3. Offer Pakistani student scholarships to educate their yputh.
It was funny to listen to the Ambassador when he made the comment that, "We need Modi, he's a strong leader"! 😅
Sure if narcissism is the definition of a strong leader, who like Xi Jinping doesn't listen to others or believe in participatory and consultative processes that build up the plural democracy of India!
Hmm
He said "We need strong leader like Modi". So emphasis is on 'strong' not 'Modi'.
Also you criticize Modi on domestic policy, while Ambassdor is talking about external policy.
Sir on the point of differentiating between Pak Army and people, two points:
1. For any other nation there can be difference of opinion between the two, but on India they are on the same page. Don't you think so?
2. Even if there is some difference, Do Pak people matter? Isn't everything controlled by the military in Pak as we have seen in recent elections?
On one level you are correct. at another that is the last hope.
@@gunnersshot9829 Philosophically and in the longterm it may be the right approach. But in short to medium term it will not work according to me and can even be couterproductive.
Why don't you ask Ata Hasnain the critical questions. To define the enemy in the terms the enemy uses, and explain what these terms mean from the enemy’s perspective. This will give the warfighter a clear understanding of the enemy’s intentions, perspective, and the doctrinal support for the violence. Why he is fighting “Jihad” in the “Cause of Allah” why does he want to establish an Islamic State (Caliphate) under Islamic Law - known as Shari’ah. In order to accurately understand what this means, our professional duty is to know how jihad is understood by the enemy when mapped against “Jihad” as defined in Islamic Doctrine, and to understand what Islamic Law is and what its role is in its role is in war against India, Who is a combatant who is not.
Without this knowledge, we cannot accurately identify, target and defeat this enemy.
Hmm