2024 Complete (Unbiased) All Star Rosters
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 06. 2024
- The All-Star game is a few weeks away, voting is open right now, but fans love to vote for their own guys. This is my unbiased look at who should make the 2024 all-star rosters.
#mlb #baseball #allstar #allstargame - Sport
No duran or devers is a crime
Devers would have for sure made it if i didnt need to make room for Paredes as the Rays rep
Devers isn’t better than Westburg
@@averypayne3279NAHHH THATS CAP by every stat other than defense maybe which has improved a lot this year by devers Raffy has been way better at the plate in almost every offensive category even as a Sox fan unbias this is true
@@averypayne3279but I will say your pitching is pretty solid man you could have a future at some college level
@@averypayne3279 💀
By stats Jarren Duran has been a top 10 guy in baseball this year he should be the third outfielder
The third outfielder over Tucker?
@@homerunproductions162 Not over Tucker, but Duran is a very good option as a pinch runner, pinch hitter or as a defensive sub. But I understand that more deserving players get crowded out by at least 1 per team.
@@homerunproductions162Tucker should not be there anyway
Yeah fr, based on war he’s like the 5th best position player
@@homerunproductions162yes Duran has over 1 war more than Tucker
Garret Crochet is def having a better season then Erick Fedde.
Crochet is having a good run, after his last start he's pretty much right in line with Fedde's season overall. If you want the hot hand then Crochet for sure
He's the AL leader in fWAR, so yes Crochet should be on the team.
Steven Kwan has to start with over a 1.000 ops
Hasnt played as much as the other guys though, but definitely think as the best hitter in baseball right now he needs a spot
Jarren Duran should honestly be in mvp talks right now he should def be in the all star game
Duran is right in line with Santander Greene and Kwan, you could easily swap him with any of them.
@@homerunproductions162Duran is way more valuable than those guys. He is a better fielder and base runner
Yeah nah, Francisco Lindor should’ve at least been mentioned
.747 ops, decent HR and SB totals, he's pretty borderline
The guards deserve some praise one hell of a surprise this year
Not only did you get the number of Guardians right, you even got the right guys and only missed on if they'd be starters or reserves. Best prediction for them this year.
I thought Kwan was borderline to even make it given his games played, surprised he grabbed a starting spot. I thought Naylor got robbed but after I made this video, Vlad really did come on strong to deserve that starting spot
No maldy is criminal #votemaldy
How low can Maldy go
As a rays fan Zack Little should be our one rep Paredes has not helped out the team this year he has good personal stats but he does not really help the team the same way Randy did last year
Westburg and Mountcastle deserve to be at least reserves. Mountcastle is beating Guerro Jr. in votes right now, and Westburg is second place for third base voting, only behind Jose Ramirez.
Mountcastle i agree should be the reserve but had to give a spot to vlad as the blue jay rep. As for Westburg, i still dont think he tops Devers for the 2 spot and of course i had to put parades so the rays had a guy
So happy you showed respect too wong and houck my Sox have needed them also a possible option for the AL bullpen would be Craig Kimbrel
Kimbrel has been good but if your era is above 2 as a reliever theres usually a bunch of guys better
@homerunproductions162 100% Agree
Kimbrel has blown a lot of save opportunities.
Why are you so underrated 😭
I dont know 😭
@homerunproductions162 As an orioles, fan, it's because you neglected to start Mounty, at alone have him, and you neglected to include Westy as the reserve for 3rd base
Mountcastle over Naylor though? I don't know about that. Westburg is in the mix but I still would have picked Devers over him even if I didn't need to add Paredes
@@Billyball35 As a Guardians fan, I totally support his unbiased choice :o
For real, they're both having great years though!
Homerunprductions162 Vladdy is leading the AL in OPS and batting average for first baseman. Don’t get me wrong Naylor and Westberg are having great seasons but the stats speak for itself.
Ps. He’s first In all star voting
Dude my guy, you scared me at first without ranger up there 😭
Now disagree with Yamamoto, Assad, and Sale over Cris Sanchez at the very least and also Skenes. Those top 3 are all great, but Sanchez has been so elite at limiting homers and has better eras than all of them. Would say especially Yamamoto and Assad out for Skenes and Sanchez but that's me personally as a Phillies fan
I was wondering when someone was going to mention Sanchez. That's my one regret on this video, I should have put him in there ahead of Yamamoto.
Royce Lewis?
Hes been awesome but has barely played this year
@@homerunproductions162 twins fan btw
Giancarlo Stanton has been sneaky good as a dh this year but I don’t know how long he’ll be injured for (Yankees fan btw)
Cashman knows all about Stanton and his injuries
As a Padres fan, thank you so much. Unfortunately, Fernando Tatis won't be able to make it as he is down for a number of months (perhaps the season) with a femur injury.
Yeah i saw that. This padres team gets more frustrating
uhhh you didn’t add brennan bernardino to the bullpen
He's been good but so many non-closers with low ERAs and only a few spots
Jarren Duran is literally a top 5 American League outfielder this hear
Duran is right in line with Santander Greene and Kwan, you could easily swap him with any of them.
@@homerunproductions162 You can't just ignore defense lol. Duran provides double the value of Santander
True, that's a good point
Exactly great point hope the guy makes it
I’m a big Duran fan
Josh Smith deserves more love for the year he's having stepping in for Jung. Dude is a bright spot in a dark time for the Rangers. Tough to make the roster though, I get that.
Josh Smith hasnt really been talked about but the guy has been amazing. Definitely should get the call if a there are some injuries
Logan Gilbert should make the team for 100% sure
I know I wish I could have added him but because a couple teams still needed a rep he was the odd man out. He's the top choice for an injury replacement in my books
Was about to click off the video when I didn’t see Ranger Suarez 😅
Haha i knew that presentation would probably trigger some people
Yes, the same with me. He has only blown one save out of 20 (I think) tries! He is better than Hader and doesn't complain like Hader did.
@@homerunproductions162 Triggered me, that is for sure.
@hopespringseternal2624 he’s talking about ranger not Robert btw
@@canaanlocke4375 Whatever. Robert is doing an incredible job for the Padres
Lindor should be over Alonso for the Mets, or Reed Garrett
Reed Garrett has been pretty good aside from a few outings that pushed his ERA over 3
I don’t want any Mets there except Alonso I guess cause I don’t what someone to get hurt
I would think Hunter Greene should get in over Logan Webb. he beats Webb in WAR, K's (stats in which He's in the top 3 and top 10 respectively) and has given up WAY less hits. And also why on earth would you choose Erick Fedde over Garrett Crochet for the white Sox
Everyone's given up way less hits than Webb 😂 but those runners dont score. He also got knocked around a bit since i put this video together
Logan Webb has a lower ERA and more innings pitcher than Hunter Greene. Strikeouts and hits don’t matter, runs matter
No matter what, I’d make Jose Siri our Rays representative. He’s by far the best player on the Rays.
IMO there should be at least one lefty bullpen guy per league, so I'd replace either Miller or Blanco (if we were to go 4 relievers) with Herrin in the AL. Otherwise, solid list.
Two time gold glover and best lead off/contact/non pure power hitter in the MLB. Steven Kwan, should get the start and bat leadoff.
Well you got your wish, he got the start
You gotta feel bad for Reynolds tho he’s playing unreal right now 22 game hit streak and has been hitting bombs consistently lately he should definitely be a starter if jurickson profar wasn’t having such a great year. I do think Colin holderman might make it he’s been having a sub 1 era for the entire year until last game.
I put Bryan Reynolds on my All Star Roster. He is my Pirates rep
Elly over Tovar 💀
Depends what you value. I wouldn't blame anyone for putting Tovar or Abrams or Adames over Elly
Final Score prediction?
Happy Heliot Ramos got a spot. He's been better than some of those guys you posted.
Yeah I thought he might, just wasnt sure if he would have enough work to get in. The numbers justified it
Where the heck is Logan Gilbert bro 😭 Gilbert over joe random and Erick fed-up every day
Yeah I absolutely agree he's the #1 replacement but he's victim of the "every team needs a rep" rule
Where the fuck is Royce Lewis? Only Joe Ryan for the Twins? WTF
Buddy Royce Lewis has been injured 3/4 of the season
Royce Lewis has played something like 18 games this year, he's been awesome though, but an all-star bid for 18 games? I don't know if that's ever happened for a position player
I think Carolos Correa from the Twins should make it
He's my first pick as a SS replacement or possible utility guy for the team
Subscribed 5 mins in! Unsubscribed with the Jarren Duran snub. Gotta retire your takes now
Assuming you dont have him over Soto Judge and Tucker, who do you boot? Santander, Kwan, or Greene?
Cope Man Soto Judge Tucker Kwan Greene and Santander are better than Duran
@@grantabeyta9054Greene is not better Duran is currently the 8th most valuable player in all of baseball and Tucker has died down
@@homerunproductions162 Duran has almost 3x the bWAR of Santander, why is this even a question?
@@Diabolical420 tucker has gotten hurt and besides War Greene is playing better
Alec Burleson having a great season. Could go at 1st or a corner outfield spot as well as DH.
He has been very good. Borderline all star worthy
Tyler anderson should yield the angels a couple prospects
Don’t they do legacy all star players? If they do Who would go in your opinion?
I think sometimes when its appropriate. The only one i can think of off the top of my head is McCutchen
Garret Crochet⁉️
I made this before he had that good outing against the Dodgers, and even though he's been hot lately, before this weekend Fedde was having a better overall year
Bro didn't pit anybody on the brewers 😢
My very first pick was a brewer
Cole ragans sould be on the team and Michael Massey should have been considered
Ragans was very close for me. When I made the video his numbers werent quite there
@@homerunproductions162 ok
I don’t see how William Contreras is the starter over Will smith
I started with Smith as the starter, but with Contreras putting in 9 more games, hitting for a higher average, HR and RBI very close, also he's stolen 5 bases, I think that made up for Smith's OPS advantage so I swapped them
Disrespectful to the Orioles, no Westberg, Ohearn, Rodriguez, Kimbrel or Suarez . MountCastle as an alternate is a joke.
Well I can't put the whole team on there. I had Santander and he wasn't even selected as a reserve. I thought Mountcastle deserved the #2 spot behind Naylor but Vlad came on strong the last couple weeks and squeezed him out. Only 3 Orioles ended up being selected (rosters released today)
My 32 Man National League Roster is very similar to yours. I do not think Elly de la Cruz should be an All Star. Instead put Spencer Steer who has a lot of RBI's in the outfield. I like Bryan Reynolds as being the only Pirate and Tanner Scott being the only Marlin. I wish I could add Kyle Schwarber, Masyn Winn, Aaron Nola, and Sonny Gray but there simply no more spots. My National League picks are below.
First Base
Bryce Harper
Freddie Freeman
Christian Walker
Pete Alonso
Second Base
Ketel Marte
Luiz Arraez
Short Stop
Mookie Betts
Willy Addames
Third Base
Alec Bohm
Ryan McMahon
Catcher
William Contreras
Will Smith
Designated Hitter
Shoi Ohtani
Marcell Ozuna
Outfield
Teoscar Hernandez
Jurickson Profrar
Fernando Tatis
Christian Yellich
Spencer Steer
Bryan Reynolds
Starting Pitchers
Reynaldo Lopez
Ranger Suarez
Shoto Imanaga
Zach Wheeler
Chris Sale
Javier Ashaad
Logan Webb
Tyler Glasnow
Relief Pitchers
Ryan Helsley
Kyle Finnegan
Robert Suarez
Tanner Scott
Our picks are extremely similar. I get why Elly would be left off, kinda has extreme negatives to go along with his positives
@@homerunproductions162 I also disagree with putting Patrick Bailey on the roster. I feel that Christian Walker of the Diamondbacks is having a better season. I know it is four first basemen but Alonso needs to represent the Mets.
I think Walker is definitely having a better year but I think each team needs a 3rd catcher
Fedde over crochet is crazy work
When I made this video Fedde's ERA was about a quarter run lower than Crochet. They've flipped since then
I thought you were giving unbiased picks? Will Smith has a 3.3 fWAR to Contreras's 2.2, mostly due to Contreras's lack of defense and -1.2 pitch framing. Also Arraez has only stated 39 or 90 games at 2nd base, because he's not a great defender, thus the Padres have mostly started him at DH since acquiring him. Reserve at 2nd should go to Brice Turang or Jonathan India, both who tower over Arraez in WAR 2.4 and 2.3 to Arraez's 0.5 fWAR. Short should be De La Cruz, with Francisco Lindor as a reserve. Both Winker and Reynolds shouldn't see reserve spots, both have had terrible defense this year. Cal Raleigh, Ryan Jeffers, Ben Rortvedt, and Logan 0'Hoppe are the top 4 catchers in WAR in the AL. Carlos Santana should be considered at 1st, as his defense has been at the top of the league. Steven Kwan should probably be a starter in the outfield, and Jarren Duran should be in over Santander. Garrett Crochet leads the AL in WAR, and he's not even on the team?
You rely heavily on WAR which is good for factoring in defense, I rely more on OPS since these positions are mainly decided on who has the best offense. When I made this video Crochet had an ERA about a quarter run worse than Fedde, he got hot as of late and now he's the obvious pick
@@homerunproductions162 Baseball is a 2 way game, not just an offensive game. It's probably more prevalent with catchers more than anybody, as they not only have offensive and defensive duties, they have pitch framing and game calling duties. JT Realmuto hasn't been the best hitting catcher, he's a good hitting catcher who's been the best overall catcher in the majors. Same could be said about other players like Francisco Lindor at short, or Marcus Semien at 2nd. ect.
My MLB All-Star roster looks like this
AL
1B: Ryan Mountcastle
2B: Marcus Semien
3B: José Ramirez
SS: Gunnar Henderson
OF: Juan Soto
OF: Aaron Judge
OF: Anthony Santander
C: Adley Rutschman
DH: Brent Rooker
NL
1B: Bryce Harper
2B: Brice Turang
3B: Alec Bohm
SS: Elly de la Cruz
OF: Teoscar Hernandez
OF: Nick Castellanos
OF: Ian Happ
C: Will Smith
DH: Shohei Ohtani
You specifically chose no Astros didn’t you? Altuve at 2nd Tucker in the OF and Alvarez as DH
@@scottwaldohe did, some people are still butt hurt for no reason
@@Markmen-cw8dj I still hate Altuve for what he did
Marcus Semien, the best looking man in baseball.
@@DaveysWonderfulWorld what did he do?
No trea Turner is crazy
Numbers are good but he's not gonna get a lot of play being hurt for a big chunk of the year
Is there an actually utility spot
I think once it comes down to the reserves and replacements there's nothing officially set
Buddy, ever heard of KENLEY JANSEN he is literally like 6 or 7 all time for career saves. At the VERY least least put him as a replacement. He is better than Taylor Scott se at least give Kenley his spot. Oh yeah where is Jarren Duran on this list?
Kenley is having a good year, you could def make a case. I put Duran as a replacement, his stats were right in line with Riley Greene, you could probably have put him on here over Santander but it's close
Bryan Hudson is where?😂
It's damn near impossible to crack the team as a non-closer relief pitcher. He's been insane though
So 32 players make it and 2 at each position
Pretty much, some positions have 3
Luis Arraez over Brice Turang is criminal. Arraez has .9 war and Turang has 4. Turang is literally 4.5x the war of Arraez. Also where tf is Yeli
Turang has a legit case over Arraez, hard to argue with that aside from batting average. I also put Yelich on the team as a reserve, I held back from making him a starter since he put in a whole month's worth of games less than Tatis/Profar/Teoscar, but I got no problem with him getting that starting nod.
@@homerunproductions162 Turang has just as good obp as Arraez
Garret crochet??
When I made this video Fedde's ERA was about a quarter run lower than Crochet. They've flipped since then
Dh is easy. Ozuna is better though
You could make the argument. But hard to go against Ohtani
Witt should have been the starter a AL SS starter. Lugo should start the game on the mound
let me guess which team is your favorite
At this point Lugo might get that start
They should just have the whole Guardians bullpen show up for the all star game
Seriously. Its insane
Honestly idk give the NL DH to ozuna over ohtani as of now
Thats not the craziest take. I get that
dodgers having 7 and phillies only having 4 is a war crime. no bias my ass dude.
If i could redo the list i would replace yamamoto with cristopher Sanchez. So that would be 6 to 5. The rest of the picks i stand by. If anything you can mock the dodgers for having 7 all stars but still being behind philly
@@homerunproductions162 fair enough, I think my rage blinded me 😂