Bollywood's Role in India's Heated Political Environment | The Quint's Films & Politics Roundtable
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 12. 2019
- #SwaraBhasker, #VarunGrover, Anubhav Sinha, Renuka Shahane, and Neeraj Ghaywan join us for a discussion on Bollywood's role in contemporary Indian politics - in the times of Modi, CAA and NRC.
Do film industry professionals have a responsibility to speak up when the country is in political turmoil, or is that an unfair expectation to burden them with?
Is there pressure on #Bollywood celebrities to not criticise the ruling establishment, and do they fear the consequences of a possible backlash?
And are some of India's biggest superstars failing the people through their silence?
Join the discussion in the comments below.
Support The Quint's independent journalism. Become a member now: bit.ly/2mE6B8P
__
Check out The Quint for more news: www.thequint.com
The Quint in Hindi: hindi.thequint.com
For more videos, subscribe to our CZcams channel: bit.ly/2aIcith
You can also follow The Quint here:
Facebook: bit.ly/1RXYIg5
Twitter: bit.ly/1tjFuxI
Instagram: bit.ly/1Piyc18
We tell stories that no one is willing to tell. Support The Quint now. bit.ly/2mE6B8P
The Quint is very amazing channel and people working for it are very intelligent and talk to the point. You deserve whatever awards are out there. Respect a lot of it.
Anand patwardhan sir ko bulaa liya hota toh aur mazaa aata.....
You should bring people from both ideology.. Then this discussion will become democratic
I just subscribed your channel. I love the conversation you all had but suggest you to have round table conversation in hindi with English subtitle so that you thoughts and views can reach the masses. Jai hind🇮🇳
Kudos to the editing at 15:04, If you know what I mean. !!! Keep up the good work.
My problem is not that Bollywood doesn't speak. The issues lies in the fact that they use patriotism and nationalism to sell their movies but when the country is in trouble, they stay mum.
as much as I agree with you the problem is that these huge stars can take a hit from a film but someone else from the same production crew might not be able to do that. If SRK makes a statement it's not like that only he loses money, all of the employees from makeup artist to spot boy, etc will take a hit from it and those people might suffer because of it
The problem is that we Indians don't keep actor/actresses in a movie separate from the person itself, if we don't like even a single statement made by a star people will boycott his/her movie, it's sad but I can understand why big movie stars might get afraid a bit before taking any stand.
@@nishantdesai3705 I get that and I have made a comment in this regard too. I get the Khans trying to stay away from controversies based on past experience but the fact that Aamir and SRK posed with Modi is despicable. I think the larger problem is there is solidarity in Bollywood only when they have to kiss up to the establishment and not when coming together to question the establishment.
Very powerful statement, totally agree with you!!
@@prairiehorse6168 yes you're right
@@prairiehorse6168 truly correct! They didn't really have to go and pose with him it wasn't really an obligation to do so but they chose to do it. I understand Kangana and Akshay Kumar but baki....
Akshay Kumar's character in Kesari is a polar opposite of his real life personality. He can't and won't stand for his nation his people. But desh ki mitti ka add hr din ata h TV pe..lol.
Ya but he's talking about Canada na..
100's of bollywood actors are silent but you choose to attack on only one.. Second why he has to against the act.. He may be supporting.. Why you are killing democracy by assuming that everyone should oppose the act
Boss forget about Akshay Kumar. I saw him here in Canada when he came to Toronto and said in public that he will love to move to Canada for good after he retire from film industry.
Akshay Kumar knows things ..he knows what CAB etc is ..so don't impose your views on other people
Akshay Kumar is an extremely smart guy. Do you think he was stupid to ask a terrorist about how he eats a mango? His goal was to become famous through any means. Fame= money. He is getting older and he wants to milk as much money as he can while he can. He knows that as long as he lives in India, his kids will have to take sides and he doesn't want that so he was smart and he left to a country when people are respected irrespective of religion. Where an Indian is an Indian irrespective of which caste or creed he belongs to.
Why is nobody appreciating the moderator!
He's so good right!?
Didn't skip a second, that's how much I liked this conversation. Kash news debates bhi aisa hota!
Yes news debates should actually need to happen like this. That's so educational. U really can understand the point. Agreements and disagreements together. Otherwise media pr toh Jo behas Hoti h usse toh Allaah hi bachaye. Uff.
@@nikhilnewse3318 I believe that media plays a role of opposition, look at the independence struggle- media and printing press brought into light the flaws of the Govt... Coming to your statement, today I don't see any main stream media is doing that - If the govt is really making progress of the country and so the media is praising then that's well and good but I don't see that too - so I look forward for the true spirit of Journalism and Quint is doing an amazing job in that.
Can you just define "enjoy" in your comment. Like seeing what in the govt. should I enjoy? That would be really helpful.
@@deepikak8023 all people sitting there are talking same thing,that means not a discussion it is propaganda against someone
@@deepikak8023 discussion needs a difference of opinions..or ideologies
I love Quint news. I dont watch godi media news.
The more we stay silent the more the silence becomes acceptable and with that also the atrocities become acceptable.
Gurmeen Kaur inshaallah hinduvta khatm hoga ghazwa e Hind ho k rahega.
13 mera rishta kya
La illah illallah
Atrocities??? Where? N one more thing how our constitution is in danger ??
Please listen to both sides before making an opinion
@@007majumder whatt??????
@@007majumder na to humko hindu rashtra chahiye aur na hi gajwa e hind..
@@yuvraj8808 exactly
Better roundtable than the vain ones. Should’ve invited Anurag Kashyap.
Yeah major missing anurag sir
Change is when people who different openions join and have same kind of peaceful debates . otherwise both are same for me.
Should have invited Arnab Goswami too.
@Guddada Bhoota yes Mukesh Ambani Adani and all Modi's of Gujarat too
@Guddada Bhoota I don't think she is from Gujarat. Nirav, Narendra, Lalit Modi's are from Gujarat as far as I know.
Celebrities have their careers at stake but the student who is on the street has both his career and life at stake.
Speak up bollywood.
Ya and jihadis have full career opportunities like jamia girls
Those students were carrying weapons in library...Don't blame police they were just doing their duty....
Students from Aligarh and Jamia Milia? They should go to Pakistan.
Gand maraoo abb 🤣🤣
@@arundhokate804 Provide the proof please. I'm not against you or something. But I really want to know the reality.
That anchor is more mature than Rajeev Masand could ever be....
Oh come on, why you bringing Rajeev Masand into this?
Because his round tables are bad
Their round tables are on completely different subjects. How can you even compare?
Lol anchor is a tyre puncture wala
Being silent on these issues has nullified the effects of satyamev jayate or any other patriotic movies.
do u watch them
@@irrfan3300
No, she eats them.
Abey saaale.......
@@pencil_unleashed I asked her,coz she is my girlfriend i i always tell her to watch them..harami saale tu tu hai
Nothing nullified the good work done by them. Neither you or me or anyone have right to tell them what they need to do. Its the same as to force someone to shout "jai shree ram".
The same constitution which gives people rights to protest or speak the very same constitution give them right to be silent.
Its their choice what they want to do
You know what is more worried that how the people i used to respect calling people like bacchan sir the 'spineless' they just came to SO call bhakat, rastravadi level. Now there is no difference between them.
They all are conservative.
@@irrfan3300
Haven't you watched shows on "loose talks".
Poor guy.
"Abey saale..." is the most famous line. 😂🤣
Tu to chidh gya. Mtlb meaning hi nii smjha.
Renuka's smile still reminds me of Lo Chali mein, apne dewar ki baraat le ke
Bhai bhai bhai
Aww!
Agreed 😁 felt the same 😁
almost forgot that
She was in Tu Tu main main too
"If you don't choose your politics then your politics will choose you." 33:52 👌👌👌
Watch Right to Recall channel Tum logo ko chutiya bana raha hai ye log
The interviewer really knows to ask the right questions. His inputs show that he is really smart. Who is he?
Moron.
@@laxmanudekar5058 haa re, sensible questions kaun poochta he?? Aam ke baare me pooch na!! Chutiya reporter
haha he is someone who is ashamed on his own culture and religion, which is i guess hindu, or even if he is not hindu because i dont know this guy personally, but i am sure that he is someone who blindly supports what communists do, he supports islamic ideas over Hinduism even the wrong one, and one who is so called ^secular^ but only when a muslim is beaten or targeted, butget blind when hindus are treated badly,..........oh bhagwan,
@@nainakumari3666 kya communism, leftist, rightist, iske baare mein kuch pata bhi hai ya sirf godi media and other resources se hi suna hai...And kerla mein communist party hi jyadatar power mein rahi hai....Why kerla is so much developed and educated state in india? And also FYI
..Bhagat singh, subhash chandra Bose etc...had communist ideology..... Actually koi bhi ideology buri nahi hoti agar limit mein ho....but access always bura hota hai....Best example is present time....Jisme hanuman ji ki caste tak bata di politicians ne...
Kitni Chutiya hai tu 😆👏👏
Arrey yaar kya enlightening tha yeh conversation, maza aa gaya.
Anubhav Sir is great and I love how straight forward he is in his words and thoughts. Those who criticize his films MULK & ARTICLE 15 have no clue about the society and how it works.
Varun Sir is great and hilarious as ever, how perfectly he articulated his thoughts.
Really appreciate Neeraj Sir, Swara Bhaskar and Renuka Ma'am.
Also the interviewer guy had selected good bunch of questions.
ek number tha, bahut maza aaya. Thanks a ton the quint.
Article 15 was good films ,but mulk was the worst film
U cannot expect this kind of sane discussion on the current news channels 🙄 sab ke sab bik gaye hai sale😑
They have the same view. It’s just a bunch of friends with same ideology sitting together. Do a right wing table. The same thing will happen even more friendly.
Yes I'm sure the right wing table will end the discussion with abolish reservations, declare the distressed castes as untouchables and put them in detention centers.
@@psico6962sarcasm 😂
prithviraj wanjari this is the mentality when you consider every other ideology than yours as having a lack of conscience. They reversed the supreme courts decision on reservation. Are you looking down on the right wingers or they on the social economic backward classes? Hypocrite kon?
@@Vishal- I agree I went extreme, apologies for that. No I don't hate any ideology or group of people. The pain of seeing a friend getting his leg injured badly for protesting peacefully has made me angry. I see the govt is insecure and resorts to extreme suppression the moment they see opposition, and that's what I'm against.
Neeraj Gheywan... I am ashamed that I didn't know you 2 years back and today when I revisit this video, I recognize that you are the one who made "geeli puchchi".
Thank you for all your beautiful works which I am now aware of.
Props to the anchor for stirring such an engaging discussion 💯👏🏾👏🏾
And not putting a contrary opinion ? Major props
There is noone with even a little bit of different view.this doesnt feel like "discussion".
What's the contrary opinion to having representation in movies from a community oppressed for thousands of years? Oppress them for a thousand more?
Or bring in the baseless argument of "bUt ReSeRvAtIoN bRo"?
@@Vishal- From the title it is pretty clear that this is about Bollywood personalities who have been actively involved/vocal in this movement.
Suggest one intellectually sound right wing Bollywood personality co-herent enough to sit here and present his /her side of the debate ?
Forget Bollywood barring a few there aren't many in Indian politics itself.
But I agree representation is important.
So if you have any points worth stating/highlighting against anti-CAA/NRC protests (except for the usual rhetorics) I am willing to hear.
shrutika vargant Is the moderator any different from the one’s in the tv debate? I didn’t see any contrary opinion even from him. This ideology started by BUSH “either you’re with us or against us” is an American phenomena not an Indian one. When you surround yourself with people with same views it’ll only make you more rigid. This interview was just catering to a certain viewpoint to make it more rigid. Why’re you against CAA and nrc ?
Actors won't utter a word but after some years will play the role of a patriotic rebellious Peron in a movie for money. People should not watch movies and think the actors are stars they are just concerned about taking your money...even 90% actors can't act in bollywood.
People are going for entertainment and doing any favour on them.. If you don't want to watch a movie that's fine.. But don't behave like as if you are doing a favor..
exactly I dont want to see shah rukh or salma playing a characters related to whats going on ow to make money
@ruchi vishwakarma jb wo movie bna rhe hai tb mat Dekho.. Hum log movie apne entertainment ke liye dekhte hai.. Baki movie dekh ke unpe koi ehsaan krte hai..
Unki marzi unko opinion dena hai ya nhi dena.. Support krna ya oppose krna..
You don't have to be patriotic to play a patriotic character..it's ACTING...
Those who are here for nobody but Varun,
18:25, 19:20, 30:58, 33:10, 40:49, 47:33
You're welcome
Omgggg thanks man!
Thanks
Thanks all others are just ramblings
Thanks bro
thanks man
Neeraj Ghaywan is an inspiration to many of us.
Getting detained is a scary thing just think about champak who's mother got detained for 14 days and he is just 2 year old kid
Dissent is being accepted in society. It will soon be accepted by the governance too. These protests are carving the path for it...
What a line being caste blind is not equal to anti caste.salute
The only round table I watched full this year.
It was such a delight to watch this conversation, with all those intricacies and putting so much of sense in today's diaspora of mainstream media. Discussion must be like this only.
These are ISI funded . They don't even have to work.
There was no debate...the entire religion of Sikhism gain traction during their war against the Mughals...nort a fucking word about that...forced conversions religious tax and so many other things
I am so happy Quint brought them to discuss issues like this apart from "bollywood".
I know
Why are you feeling good after watching this video because you have muslim boyfriend.
And you have to make him feel good on this.
But when sria law will be implement then women will get most affect through this type of law.
So best wishes for you.
@Alvida Hamesha don't bother, he is just a troll.. going to every girl's comment and replying shit
@Alvida Hamesha
You know, I find it absolutely hilarious when muslims' own book teaches for death to apostles, women to cover up and even after that they won't reach jannah, hellfire to apostates and homosexuals, and they label other people to be Nazis. I mean, you see the double speak, no? There are prescribed killing of Jews, Christians and polytheists in the book and several auxiliary hadiths, beheading of people different than them and then somehow this is not equateable to Nazism at all. In fact, you guys are the actual Nazis, before the Nazis even existed! 🤣
Entire civilizations wiped away - Christians from Syria, Egypt, Lebanon. Zoroastrians from Iran. Hindus from Indonesia and Malaysia. Buddhists and Sikh from Afghanistan. And others are Nazis? Hmm.
@@shrutikavargant3673 wow, religion and politics aside, now the gender card.
@Alvida Hamesha
We looked in the mirror, and we saw the reflection of the mistakes our ancestors did of extending their hands to muslims. Even Maulana Abul Azad expressed his regret. And so did Ambedkar.
facebook.com/justicekatju/posts/-tumhe-yaad-hai-maine-tumhe-pukaara-tumne-meri-zabaan-kaat-dali-maine-qalam-utha/873517446022136/
Renuka Shahane ...ONE OF THE MOST DIGNIFIED CELEBS ever!!!
I must complement the interviewer...he has a good knowledge of the matter and conducted this discussion beautifully 👍
They r attacks on Hinduism and glorify Islam
Aapka chutiya kat chuka h.. 😅 Bhadae ho
oh asshole this interviewer meghnad bose is accused in sexual harrassment and molestation
Anubhav Sir, please make a movie on the contemporary situation in our country with Swara as the lead. I know she is gonna rock it. We should be able to see such a talented actor more on the screen. Love you both.
Make more roundtable like this in hindi so, reach to more people...
Yes hindi me jyda dhyn dena chahiye
I believe " elite indians" dont give a damn to social evil or on going CAA NRC protest or think about national interests ( remember : exceptions are there)
Gand me daalo in sabki jubaan ko. Lauda
And other languages too please! Let's not leave out Marathi, Bengali, Telugu etc
@@FishFireFood change your samskaar also, atleast in public.
Best roundtable of the year!
Bhai saal iss saal ke do hi din huye hai abhi 😂
@@ouroboros9225 Bhavnao ko samjho yaar... I meant it for 2019 only.
@Apurva Kumar Less than PMs interviews to Modia😅
@Foo-Keng Hooman ネコワオ righttt
He should have asked instead"Aam kaise khaate ho" 😂😂
@Foo-Keng Hooman ネコワオ bhai joke to samjho pehle hi serious ho jaate hai 😂
So, all those (rajput, sikh, Marathas) who faught against Mughals were wrong? And Mughals were really peace loving?
Is this bottom line?
Whatever they are smoking, is pretty strong.
But it was also not saving Bharat mata either . Everyone was fighting for their empire
The intellect of Varun Grover doesn’t fit with others here .. he deserves a separate dedicated interview .. the rant of others eclipsed Varun’s outlook .. disappointed !
intelligent Varun asks for photo IDs for his shows but for identifying illegal citizen kehta kagaz nahi dikhayenge
whole jackie shroff interview and not even a single "BHIDU"!!
Hah you must be on the wrong window.. where is Jackie?
😂😂😂 few will get the joke
@@ShivamSingh-qz3kh please enlighten us mere mortals..
@@SinghalLouis Anubhav Sinha looks like Jackie Shroff.
@@cliffbooth6543 ohh my god.. haha
Listening to Neeraj Ghaywan from 44:48 onwards teared me up. The point he was making is soooo subtle yet cuts so deep, it's amazing he was even able to recognize it about himself and articulate it.
This video needs to go viral. Quint needs all the admiration in the world.
Yes. The part I liked the most was Neeraj's. Because, it is very important to talk about not just caste, but the caste blind approach of Bollywood, which furthers the privileged attitude of already privileged UC.
Bunch of loosers conference
Mulk honestly did change my mindset, so yes, Bollywood does make an impact on its viewers.
I dont think
There are many movies on social evil like periods , many watch padman movie just as an mere entertainment only
Safiyyah Rahman it was impactful but showed only one side of the story
@@NiravJoshi did it?
Safiyyah Rahman yes for sure it did and may be that was precisely the purpose of the movie that is show the other side completely without any ifs and buts
@Shakti Prasad Mishra He won't say anything because that won't suit his agenda. How many bomb blasts and terrorists attacks did we had during last 6 years ?? None. Unki fatt k hanth me aa gyi h Modi se.
It was nice to watch the complete conversation. Understood every intellect adds values and meaning in life
We need one more round table like this Quint plz... And plz give sub title in hindi and english too..
A BLOODY GOOD INTERVIEW!!!.... Make more of these please... something worth being cherished... CHEERS QUINT!!!
Aapka chutiya kat chuka h.. 😅 Bhadae ho
@@pramodmehra2689 He will listen to only what supports his agenda. Thats what happens when two siblings marry each other. Child gets mentality unstable.
Sab deshdrohi ek sath ekkttha ho gaye he
Kaash yeh building 🏢 gir jati
Tukde tukde gang members
Sohi keh rahe haain
People like Swara Bhaskar are rare. Being a woman she has nerves of steel. We need more like her , Anubhav Sinha & Renuka
Good to see atleast some from Bollywood is speaking.
🤘🏻👏🏼👍🏼
Agar dusro ko apni dukaan band karne ka dar nahibhota to wo bhi bolte, bad thing is k un logo ki hi awaaz ko log zyada sunte aur wo hi chup hai
Why there are speaking only about selective why they did not speak about sonu nigam ka fatwa nikalata tha .aur kamlesh tiwari wala...
@@virendersingh-ew8qb अरे भाई चुतियों को लेकर इतना सीरियस नहीं होते इनको तो गंदगी की तरह बहा देते हैं हम ये कीड़े हैं 😂😂😂
@@Live-lyfe in kuto ko funding aati hai islamic organisation sa hinduwo ko badnam karane k liye 🤣🤣jhaat bas bol skate hai ye sab gandu sale
@@virendersingh-ew8qb exactly 😂
Lovely to see renuka..that warmth and clarity is reassuring
Where is Anurag Kashyap?? Quint should have included him perhaps?
Ganja marke bhaitha hai vo
You people are doing excellent job we are very proud of you. specifically you people are very brave and giving strength to public. Thank you for standing by our side.
Very good effort .hope to see it every year
WOW! varoon grover mentioned "annihilation of CAST"
wow!! wow bro! Huge respect!
Loved it! I like this anchor man.. I liked how he explained the questions.. Thank you Quint!
Of course you will.. Hinduphobic sick ba...
@@maheshsthavarad268 ja be lodu.. tere validation ki zarurat nahi hai life me mujhe..
Jake puncture laga..
This must feel magical for Meghnad to be at Aisi Taisi Democracy on 18th May and then sit down and chat with Varun! 👍👍
Secular Bollywood of a Secular Country "India".
Tho civil code ke against kyu ho be
Bn do india ko secular or modern country.
abid han9 you want secular country or secular developed country ???? If you want India to be developed country accept uniform civil code let’s be equals after stepping out of our house no more religion personal laws to divide and rule us .
@@sivasriram4357 bro civil court is against Democracy and Secularism of our Country,and the beauty of our Country is "Unity in Diversity".
abid han9 yeah unity in diversity is not our beauty it’s our strength and it won’t break out . We need to build on it and make it a developed country . See every Indian thrives to go aboard because of talent they can show case and get real good jobs . Those things has to be hilighted for a decade so brain drain should not happen . These things get hilighted only if these difference in religion kept in home and come out as same . 70 years of independence brother we need to keep this diversity aside and be unite then only we can progress other wise India will be developing country for ever with kind of population it’s so hard to get developed with current policy’s. Uniform civil code is not against democracy are you light head brother Australia has uniform civil code do you think it’s not democracy???
@@abidhan9693 how against secularism and constitution?Just be straight to the point.
Thanku Quint for bringing up these people for one of the amazing roundtable of 2020...it's truly a new year gift 🔥
The interviewer did a great job leading the interview, all the while giving them enough space to fully speak their minds without rushing. Good job yo!
Love you all they are great humans as a human from Afghanistan I proud on them keep fighting for your secular democracy country
Shutup and fight to make your country secular and tolerant instead of commenting on other secular countries.
Arthur Fleck I did a lot for democracy good future and I lost a lot of thing still I am trying
king tiger don’t insult anyone be a good human
I just love these vociferous stars
Yes, I wrote my personal view. They are stars in terms of resistance i.e. the risk they have taken.
Swara bhaskar is most courageous than other actress like kareena, deepika Aliya etc
Biggest joke ever 😂
🤣
Kongana
What a wonderful n relevant and needed roundtable discussion...
I really wanted to watch some discussion like this one from bollywood. Was eagerly waiting for this kind of video.
Thanks a ton QUINT
There is noone with even a little bit of different view.this doesnt feel like "discussion".
When someone is with you beyond background religion caste it makes you strengthen
Bhai ,actually we are afraid from you because islamic made every country more hell for other religion.
Prosecuted hindu where they will go.most of genocide has been done by islamic people.
@@vivekambedkar2507 Bhai, this is India, which is run by Constitution, not relegious holy books of any religion. Indian muslims don't owe you any explanation for the atrocities done by Islamic countries. Because we are Indian Muslims.
Chutia they are not with u they are using you for there propaganda and u this round table is a joke no cross questions every one is from same communist ideology yhey don't love muslims its just that they hate modi more............
@Alvida Hamesha how dare us us maybe u font know the jistory whst kind of atrocities were done by mughal emperors on hindus and u can still what are neighbouring countries are doing to there minorities and just yesterday gurudwara was attacked in pakistaan maybe u should lesrn some history first.........
@@adamseden1330 Only when you guys are in minority you support constitution and fake secularism. When in majority you guys want Islamic republic and sharia. Tell me one Muslim majority country with democracy.
वरुण ग्रोवर की सबसे अच्छी बात है कि वो सिनेमा, साहित्य पर कभी भी विस्तार से बात कर सकते हैं।
दूसरा - क्योंकि उनकी पढ़ाई साइंस से थी तो उनका टेम्परामेंट भी साइंटिफिक है और वो साइंस पर बोल भी पाते हैं।
The interesting part of discussion is there is no one for counter question. No one is there to put up other side of story.
what a wonderful gift by quint on new year's eve 😍😍😍😍😍
I luv u quint for this... Please people watch this roundtable whichever ideology you believe in rather than discussing what ananya pandey and siddharth chaturvedi think about nepotism on the other round table..
Truly enlightening!....
I love and deeply respect each and every soul that took part in this debate....
Good hosting, great conversation and well behaved guests. Even rich media houses dont make such quality work.
Absolutely!Lovely! lovely!lovely panel 💗💗💗love you all.....Dil sey😊
Showing Baniya as greedy, showing Brahmin or Mahant as villain, showing Thakur as villain, showing Sardar as comic character, is secular, let’s check some movies, Amitabh bachhan singling haj ka mahina but show aggression towards idol in temple, miracle in Dargah a blind can see again, but tantrik doing bad things, this type of shit is showing from 60s to 90s, n till now, in PK every character has bad side, only Pakistani Muslim character has good heart, u can make fun of lord shiva, but can’t utter a name of any messenger, f u all, btw I don’t believe in any religion but I m with truth only
I feel it's necessary to introduce anyone. I really don't know at least 3 of these people. I am from the south. I hope you consider our opinion as well.
Starting from left side...
Anubhav sinha,( director of article 15, mulk)
Swara bhaskar( actress)
Varun grover( writer/ activist)
Renuka Sahane( actress)
Neeraj ghyavan( director)
Expecting much more discussion like this. Just loveeeee it
When you see that Bollywood actually have some people with brains Loved it 😍😍
Yep, only Modi haters and Hindu haters have brain, others are jokers right ?
@@ansh-lo6xr ye hindu haters hain 😂😂😂😂 Abe ye khud hindu hain mtlb ye khudke haters hain. Mtlb asli hindi modi lovers hain 😂😂😂😂, aya ek or modi bhakt
@@backtonature1040 ok Tarek Fateh k bare me kya khayal hai? Is hisab se to tarek fateh bhi sach Bol raha hai, Muslim hoke,
@@ansh-lo6xr Abe kon Tarek fateh, Abe bhai career pr dhiyan do log cancer or corona se mar rahe hain, ab age 60 years ni hai, bas yahi politics or hindu muslim krke mar jaoge. India or duniya bahot khoobsurat h, explore karo, ye sab in the end khatam ho jana h
@@backtonature1040 dekh bhai, me hindu muslim nahi karta, ye panel k chomu kar rahe hai, movies ko hindu muslim angle se dekh rahe hai
Best discussion.....
The only thing was good that looking at that photo of the jeep 😂
Thanks for uploading complete interview
This was quite fantastic! Big kudos to all the guests and the Quint for putting this together. More of the same please.
Thank you Neeraj for talking about representation and making an effort.
This is the best discussion ever. I so much relate to Neeraj sir and as a ST girl I know how oppressed lower caste and how less opportunities are available. Then the struggle being brown colour, then female, then sometime highly qualified is a problem., being in abroad is a problem. List just goes on. The struggle is real but is so normalised that it does even feel that you are discriminated.
A very ‘need of the hour’ discussion by thoroughly enlightened individuals which, i am sure, shall go long way in shaping our motherland as a great nation.
Thank you, Quint.
As a Pakistani and an outsider in this argument. I feel if the Muslims in India wanted to come to Pakistan they would’ve done so a long time ago but it was their love for their homeland that made them stay. They believed in the brotherhood in India that people could live in that nation without racial or religious prejudice so they stayed and stood by their country. And I feel really heartbroken to see their own countrymen turn against them just because of some baseless propaganda.
No one has turned against them, the policy really doesn't affect them at all. The current so called student protests have only been conducted by universities who are affiliated with the opposition government. They don't even constitute 0.1% of the Indian student population. The media coverage and ofcourse the celebrities on this table who are also supporters of the opposition have exaggerated it to such epic proportions, it sounds like there is a civil war happening in India. There are no extraordinary circumstances the way it is being projected.
what a refreshingly sane and intelligent conversation - i wish more people would watch this video. just wanted to mention how films DO have the power to create huge impact: the gujarati film bavhi bhavai which informed and made me aware me of the horrors of caste - and my own huge privilege - when i was a small child. it was a moment that triggered empathy early in life; stayed will me. another film that was life-altering was Jodie Foster's Accused - it took that film to clarify ideas of consent, victim shaming and much more. thanks for masaan, for article 15, mulk , thanks Varun, Renuka, Swara for speaking, clearly, fearlessly, kudos to you all
Fantastic host asking important questions and steering the discussion expertly. One of the best round-tables I've seen!
"I don't think I am caste blind. But I am caste agnostic."
NOW "THAT" IS A TRAP!!!
Why do you say so?
The collective psyche of this entire panel is reflected in a single shot when all of them agree that tying a stone pelter to a jeep by the army as an act of self defence was wrong. It has left me aghast at the fact that they continue to support such elements of society. Rest all has already been said and done about this left brigade and their sad state of affairs that I don't wish to elaborate on and waste my time further.
Secondly, for a those who'll come at me saying that I'm a blind bhakt. To them I say, IF me defending the government is andh-bhakti, then so is your opposing andha-virodh. Which makes you no different from me then therefore you'll be showing duality and hypocrisy in your very own line of thoughts. You have a valid point, fine, we'll discuss, but no stupidity.
Lastly, I'm not surprised this is coming from Quint, I expect them to be biased, they're no different from the 'godi media' they often try to dismantle. Both of them are biased, both are stupid, both are dangerous to this society for propelling masses towards an uncertain future. Period.
It's ok bro. They are doing their jobs. And this is what they do.
Love each one of these guys. Respect!!
This is how you discuss. I understand that most of them are like minded and have similar point of view when it comes to CAA, NRC and similar political point of view, but the beauty in this whole conversation is by the fact that they are letting each other complete what they have to say and also bring respectful to each other.
Varun grover from @19:10 to @22:25 is enough for you to understand how well he speaks!!! Kudos to the guy!!!
Loved the conversation....but hearing Swara Bhaskar out I feel...."Itna bhi sach mat bolo ki akele reh jaao...bas chaar aadmi rakhlo kandha dene k liye"...huge respect to all the people in this round-table!
Which intern is responsible for this editing? So many unnecessary cuts.
So true.
This was very much needed!
Very imp and eye opening conversation!
Thank you guyz!
Thankyou all to just exist
What a treat to listen to enlightened & educated people in real sense who fight for a generous cause of humanity in general. Varun is right when he said one should read Dr Ambedkar's Annihilation Of Castes & then come up with point of existence or nonexistence of discrimination on the basis of castes in film industry or anywhere else.
Loved every bit of it . A group of true intellectuals throwing insight on the much needed burning issues.totally agree with all of their opinions.
Gulzar ko shayri nahi aati lol
Joke of century
really meaningful conversation👏👏👏
Wow, what an Interesting conversation it was!
Absolutely heartening to watch this!
Can you please add Hindi subtitles or even better also do a Hindi version of this! The Hindi belt needs to hear this. My parents need to hear this.
Yes please!
53:17- Swara and Bose' s retort to each other was so entertaining and if I may say, cute?
I wish there were more debates like these on the television so a larger mass could be reached . The television has really deteriorated.
amazing work specially how varun gave example to expain, thanks quint