Is Pep Guardiola right about Newcastle United and Eddie Howe's STRUGGLES?
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 03. 2024
- Liam, Dom and Jordan react to Newcastle United's FA Cup quarter-final defeat to Manchester City
#nufc #newcastleunited #football #facup #premierleague - Sport
Baffled to hear ppl rate Longstaffs performance I thought he was awful besides a few tackles. He even caught strays from the commentator who said he was invisible all game 🤣
I feel sorry for Bruno playing with this dross he worked his socks off yday for nowt, I wouldn't be surprised if he wanted out in the summer. Another pathetic performance we have to beat West Ham at home or it could turn on Eddie.
what tackles he did only 1
First half, Longstaff was back to his usual standard, in our opinion. Faded after that. Say as you see, always. L
Longstaff has been terrible for weeks now time to replace him in the summer ☀️
@@williamneailey6756 I wouldn't get my hopes up mate Howe seems to rate him highly. He will likely stay on as back up for Tonali, even though he's clearly not Premier League standard.
Only time commentator mentioned him was to remark that they hadn't actually mentioned him.
The problem playing a 532 like we did is the pocket between LWB and LCM and RWB RCM can get exposed as you have nothing Infront of the wing backs as we played 2 strikers.
Should have played a 523 (541) with gordan left almiron right and the can tuck in and cover.
Small tactical tweeks needed. 532 has it's issues and we seen it today
I thought It'd be more 5-4-1 but it wasn't much of the time. Still think onus is on 2x of the three midfielders to cover spaces. Did on right with Longstaff, not on the left. L
Who in their right mind plays Burn LWB i tell you who a manager who is feeling the heat and way out of his depth.
Who would you have played week in week out with our thin squad
The most obvious problem we have is that we do not have a decent large squad. How many players do we still have who would be more suited in the Championship . We started the season with a decent 15 man squad but with only 1 main striker.
Before kick off the majority of fans were expecting the triple cup winners, Whose squad of 25 strong could get into any other team in Europe never mind their national sides-to put at least 5 past a weak injury riddled squad but we ended up by losing by a deflection and an og and yet those same fans shout shite , Eddie out blah blah blah . Despite the problems on and off the pitch we still have 40 points on the board. Come the summer there will be changes.
@@stephennutkin2477 Squad size and recruitment is down to Eddie Howe. Either way you slice it he has a lot of criticism to answer for its been poor and there's no excuses.
@@stephennutkin2477 Not Burn as a flying wing back
@@stephennutkin2477 Livramento, Hall, Dummett, all have been fit, available and shown themselves capable.
First time I have watched the channel, I am a committed. (or should that be committed) 76 year old Geordie whose memories of our last cup success in the Fairs Cup still keep me believing we can win something again. I am now living in the East Midlands and having watched the game on TV, I found your analysis fair and truthful. I shall continue to follow your content. Well done boys.
Thanks for your support! Keep the comments coming. L
That disgraceful penalty decision at PSG was the turning point this season... its been abyssal since then
@@BrianPinas9 and 4-0 to Milan
@@BrianPinas9 🤣
@@Dave-ug9bh he’s over exaggerating but definitely 5 or 6 at least. Go watch the game again.
we should have beaten man utd ,9.1 and Sheffield united 8.0 .oh we did !! ....oh we should have beaten wolves 6.0 ...the turning point for me is Chelsea away in the league cup we should have made another final !! Simples
@@alanthompson3780your right but people choose bad games to suit their narrative. We should have sold more players to the Saudi league but didn’t because it would have looked bad but that didn’t stop the like of Liverpool . We started the season with a decent squad of 15 but with only one striker . A good showing in the CL but injuries soon weakened that decent squad and reduced us to having players either playing through injury or sitting on the bench with injuries so weak is the squad. Even those clubs above us in the league would have suffered this season if they had had the injuries we endured. The top three could have coped but they can because they’ve got strong full squads where most of their players would get into the present top six sides if not their national teams.
First time watching 👍👍. Great comments guys, a more insightful view, many thanks 🙏
Welcome aboard! L
BDB getting stick from the usual melts when goals weren't his fault. Missing physicality of J7 in midfield protecting the defence. Created few chances and to push city you need to take all your chances
Burn is a joke as a left full back and an even bigger one at left wing back. Who backs off and allows the best players in the world time to shoot around our box? A disgrace of a player thats who. He maybe a geordie but he is a shit footballer, I watch better at u17 level.
The season promised so much but the fact the majority want tge season to end now speaks volumes. I agree cant see us finishing higher than 10th
Agree, bar an improvement in performance and form. L
The thing that springs to my mind is the team spirit seems to have disappeared. I remember Trippier turning up at Burnley away on crutches to support the lads, that seems to have disappeared? 🤷♂️ To be playing Burn at lwb and Longstaff when he's injured when we have Miley and Anderson on the bench is a joke, he's not doing himself any favours.
Confidence and momentum goes both ways! L
Good chat as usual lads. Great podcast
Thanks! L
It was Eddie's choice to play Joe willock and bdb on the left where goals came from.he didn't have to.
Fair point. Didn't think Burn was an issue in the end, mind. L
Not upset about that other than the cosmic level injustice of city getting jammy goals.
I think the question we should ask is how would Eddie do if he had a squad like that?
Or how would Pep do with our lot?
@@georgemorley1029Pep is a very good manager as is Klopp but neither of them took over their respective clubs with squads as weak and demoralised as ours . They then consolidated their squads because they were allowed to spend without restrictions.
Another tough jgiht as a Toon supporter, two reflective goals but in reality City never got out of second gear. This season almost defined as sense we will bobble along inconsistently. Would love to see a Geordie Journo piece during the break on what should be our aspirations for next season and how we would achieve that? Thanks again guys.
Good shout. Will discuss with the lads. L
Enjoy your training on the long sands boys 🤣! You got to laugh or you cry! Disappointed but expected defeat. W Ham and Everton a must 6 points for me! HWTL
We need it! L
Think you nailed the overall situation on Newcastle this season as did Pep.
Too many games, too many issues, too small a squad, just 13:00 t too much for the team. You also added the intensity the team plays at under Eddie and his lack of experience managing or playing in Europe added to an already impossible task. I would also add unfair FFP rules will continue to weigh heavily upon us.
The owners did say it would be a 5/10 year project to get Newcastle into an elite club.
Enjoy your channel lads!!!
Thanks! L
Is Eddie Howe learning though Liam? Seems to me he’s making the same mistakes time and time again. Look, I might be completely wrong though mate but it just seems nothing is learned. I’m not sure playing Burn up against Kyle Walker is particularly clever. He’s one of the quickest players in the PL. How many times has Howe played DB against quick wingers this season? Been quite a few occasions now. Like I say, nothing learned.
The main problem defensively has been mid-field injuries on the left hand side, missing Willock and Joelinton has caused too many gaps and it's been exploited for months. Willock had a bad game but he's also not long back from injury, same with Isak. They are not fully match-fit yet. Playing against Man City in the middle of the park while not 100% yet is a tough ask. Burn gets a lot of stick this season but he's had a lot less support, more gaps and instead of holding back allowing Bruno to go forward, he's been pushing down the left leaving exposure at the back with Bruno also going forward. I don't think swapping to 5 at the back was the right idea, swapping to a less comfortable tactic that's been tried a few times mainly in pre-season with little success created even more gaps and some didn't look comfortable with it. Willock included who's been injured all pre-season and most of the season and not trained with that tactic much... but I feel like that was a forced choice without Tino and Tripps.
Bad luck, poor coach decisions, lacklustre performances, no intensity, big drop off, bans, mammoth injuries….oh well 1969 is now even further away seeing I was born in 1970😢 the wait for joy 🎉continues….blind faith, TOON/HWTL😂😂
It'll end one day... I think. L
Didn't expect anything from the game, think wkth injuries and the team with no permanency to it that its made the season so disjointed as the performances have been, with the games to go and a few players returned we have to hope for some cohesion and put some good results together
Hope springs eternal for some! I'm more of a realist, I've not seen any foundation to suggest the last 10 games gets any better. But we all hope! L
@@GeordieJournos thought there was a slight improvement when the substitutions were made yesterday ,even if we don't make Europe I think Eddie should stay,he needs to be able to prove what he can do if we do get some new recruits and a less injury prone season and give him until Christmas at least
Both goals were the fault of Willock massively and the lack of urgency to close down people and get stuck in. We were pathetic, 2 shots, 28% possession. Miggy put Isak in and he fluffed it. The robot striker had a great shot that sailed desperately wide( would have preferred that to deflected goals). Sean Longstaff was awful. 19 touches, 13 passes overall 3 of which he misplaced. Lost the ball 6 times and only put 1 cross in which went for the corner. Miley had 14 touches, completed 13 passes with 100% accuracy and did not lose the ball all in 30 minutes. Miley should start ahead of Longstaff. Hall should start at LB and BDB either play CB or take a holiday on the bench. Eddie just plays the same personnel and expects a miracle.
He was not forced to play the lads at Wolves away and Bournemouth away during the UCL group stage. He could have played the youngsters, Ritchie, Dummet and Krafth to give the regulars a break. He run this team into the ground. Maybe hindsight is 20/20 but he should have played the youngsters who were promising during pre-season and utilized the squad much better.
🎵 we've got Dom in the middle!🎵
🤣 L
More players we need not more managers,this tie was decided when we drew city, no one was calling for Eddie to go after PSG, can’t compare us to European champions
Not even close. L
Absolutely love the Geordie journos. Absolutely HATE EDDIE HOWE.
I’d replace him tonight with Hansi Flick or Nagelsmann - playing Dan burn as a wingback should be a sackable offence.
The treatment of lewis hall is abysmal.
The medical team is the worst in the league but no questions are being asked about it, every player relapses who they treat.
Botman needs sold in the summer, he can bring money in, he’s not good enough.
Howe loves to hang onto players cause he doesn’t wanna upset people. He’s not ruthless enough. He doesn’t wanna sell anyone it’s absolutely shocking. Get rid of Howe!!!!
Be careful what you ask for. I remembered many many years ago, many fans said the same when they ask for Sir Bobby Robson to be replaced, and Newcastle never recovered until the current owner took over
@@maxchan4024how dare you compare Bobby to howe. Howe is a mediocre manager and has proven it this season. Bobby was one of the greatest to ever be involved in the game. You can replace howe with 15 of the other 19 managers and there would be a marked improvement in the system
Longstaff just stands in front of people hardly ever puts a foot in. Thought he was a ghost to be honest.
All about opinions. Keep them coming! L
A chat about if we dont qualify for Europe will Isak and Bruno and Joelinton stay?
Thanks. L
@@GeordieJournos worth a You tube video,Liam over the next couple of weeks
@@grahamtowler1761 will discuss with the lads. L
@@GeordieJournos thanks
Think Jordan wants to go to Dubai to check out the training
Good vid lads. Keep them coming. 👍 3 daft Geordies rabbiting a load of Shi** 😂 👍
Geordie Waffle 😂
- J
Go away and look at Liverpool 9 years ago under Klopp's first season
This is eddies 2nd season well 2. 1/2
@@kennyw218 Yes of course it is but the first time he/we have had a season playing two games a week for a sustained period. Nine of the players that featured in the match were 'coached' (laugh) by Steve Bruce - so would have had their feet up or played golf a couple of years ago. Also we now have a so-called expert in sports conditioning in the staff - so time for him to step up.
I think you's should show Eddie a bit more respect. You have a responsibility as 'influencers' to make sure your reporting is accurate. I watched the press conference. Eddie was clear with what he said, he didn't know 'yet' 'exactly' what they would work on in Dubai until he analyses the Man city game and looks at West Ham. Then he'll know exactly what they'll work on. Makes sense to me, but you guys are trying to make him look incompetent at a time when some idiots out there with pathetically short memories are questioning him. I've often thought Craig Hope was one of the harshest journalists amongst you, but just watched his post-match video and he was full of support for Eddie. You guys have now got that title as far as I'm concerned and if the anti-Eddie angle continues, I'll be unsubscribing.
We respect the manager, all of us. L
@@GeordieJournos There’s a difference between respecting the manager and showing him respect. You have a duty as ‘supporter’s with influence’ which is the way people see you, rightly or wrongly, to choose your words carefully if you’re going to give your opinion on the manager or players. I watched your video this morning from the Sunderland academy, again a ‘we doubt Eddie Howe’ narrative. If you want to do a video where you ‘nail your colours to anyone’s mast’, why don’t you try doing one where you nail your colours to this manager’s mast, or not, as it would seem. If you do, please let me know. I won’t be watching any more of your videos for now. I’m sure when Eddie turns things around, as most ‘supporters’ believe he will, your narrative will change back, or at least go underground for a while.
FFP illegals 2-0 FFP legals
Newcastle was shit sorry
#standards L
Eddie needs to be judged on the rest of the seasons games get us into Europe
Despite all that money, you're still a mid table club and always will be.
Deluded Geordie's thought they were going to win The Champions League 😂
Bookmarked! 😉 L
Deluded Geordie's thought they were going to win The Champions League 😂
The road up and the road down are one and the same. L
Surely the fact Eddie and his staff have never been here means they should be given time to learn and the fact Klopp commented about the same 11 getting results against Chelsea, PSG, Man U in a week - what alternative did Eddie have? Literally the only 11 fit players we had pretty much! This is a journey, Man City didn’t get where they are in 2 seasons and they didn’t have FFP breathing down their necks!! Fans need to stop being so entitled and let the process happen. HWTL 🖤🤍
How much time? Is this a project to propel Newcastle on an upward trajectory or for Eddie Howe to get experience?
This isn’t a match in isolation, we’ve been atrocious this year forest, Blackburn, luton and Brentford to name a few.
Terrible transfer window.
Players being run into the ground and not picked on form.
Eddie is responsible for recruitment, training, work load, team selection and rotation. Accountability, some people just have no clue it exists.
Isn't about the players, more the way of playing. Lessons need to be learned! L