'If you want to promote Kannadigas for jobs, spend more money on higher education'
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 08. 2024
- Businessman and philanthropist TV Mohandas Pai said in Bengaluru, 'if you want to promote Kannadigas for jobs, spend more money on higher education. Give training to them. Spend more money on skill development. Spend more money on internships, spend more money on apprenticeship programs. So they all become skilled. Not like this. What are you trying to achieve by this?'
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our CZcams Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
A teenager born in New Delhi, built his political career in UP (from family Baston) after horrible defeat in family Baston can come & contest in Wayanad but others who majorly thrive in Private sector based on merit & without reservation has to go thru all this circus, sounds legit 😅😅😅
He can not win election in wynad without people supporting him .
Merit goes with nepotism rather than real merit !
It will be quashed by the high court as happened in Haryana private local reservations of 75% quota last year
Yes, you got the point, it will be crushed for sure, NASSCOM or other private body will question this and that is it. However, what message they are sending . . . ?!
@@tinguzz they need to introspect, as a Kannadiga it is clearly visible that MNC are acting against the local people and Kannadigas are not ready to do low wage job , people of UP,Bihar, Assam are taking the low wage job in Karnataka. Problem lies with both the stakeholders
Congress government knows this and thats why they made this to score some points
@@Kannadiga321-r4n Whose problem is it, if kannadigas do not do Grade C &D jobs? If outsiders do that job then what is the problem?
Now if states like Maharastra, Telangana, TamilNadu, Delhi-NCR start doing the same as their is large Kannadigas population working in these places it shouldn't be a concern for anyone in Karnataka Govt!! These people want india to go back to older days of language, caste, religious divides with actions like these, God Bless these politicians and the illiterate people who elect them
Agreed this is bad policy, but there are no mass migration from Karnataka to these state now. And Karnataka people who went there have integrated well, learnt local languages and give utmost respect to both their janmabhoomi and karmabhoomi (example Mangloreans in Mumbai). Again there are communities in Karnataka like Marwaris who are doing business from generations and have integrated well. I have not seen any hatred towards them. But come to Bangalore and see the migrants working in both high paying IT, Bank jobs or laborers/watchmen/factory workers. The amount of arrogance and disrespect they hold towards local language and local people is shocking. Leave learning Kannada, but they mock at it at every chance they get. The pride they have about their "fair skin", "national language" "traffic free villages", makes the local think - why the heck are you coming here then. So do not compare the Kannada community outside with the arrogant migrants in Blr.
You’re not even a Kannadiga, you’re not living in Karnataka. If in your state your deprive-deprived of employment opportunities in your own state by company in your state What use of those companies if they don’t provide employment for you, so please don’t comment on such sensitive issues. You don’t see the problems what we see here.
@@manojnnayak1387 Lol 🤐 just because my name doesn't match the expectations of your idea of Karnataka you decided everything on my behalf!! No one is undermining the genuine concern but just forcing corporations to follow by law shows the government incompetence and inability to train, educate or provide more opportunities by govt schemes, subsidised grants for startups etc by themselves. Rest if you are living in a union no all states are equal, so if other start doing the same it will open another pandora box of state vs state!! So open your pity mind and see the it as a competition and grow your skillset instead of relying on free govt quotas for job securities!!
@@sunilkb I support you, not everyone is ideal person but it goes both ways. These very same IT immigrants pay taxes, house rents, grocery and other activities in the areas increasing both the economic activity as well as land prices and rental income for locals. Cheap labor from Bihar, Chattisgarh etc keep the low cost jobs in the state competitive, so now just making reservations on jobs will open a pandora box of discrimination and similar policies against non locals in other states as well which will undermine the very basic concept of Republic of INDIA
@@kamaljeetsingh1467 we know how intelligent u people are at giving every possible reason to get jobs at many instances,now hiding behind the garb of talent you people depriving locals here of their right to employment, locals should be given first priority in jobs.
Kannadigas are one of the best talented people across the country.
Better stay in your state 😁
If these shameful instances of getting the jobs by decieving local people by assuming local for fools.
All companies are welcome to Telangana and Andhra Pradesh.
Not just Telangana but also to BIMARU states. Let all states develop. If people from other states are coming to work here thn why such companies shud open offices here instead let them open in other states. We dont need any companies or educational institutes who does not offer locals jobs as first priority.
My friend why Telangana . . .why are you forgetting CBN . . .
@@tinguzz to grow together bro, I’m from andhra, but telangana has been a home to me for the past 7 years for education and now job.
To all the comapnies who are leaving Karanataka after this you are most welcome to Andhra Pradesh
Thank you Karnataka govt. Companies now have a reason to move to other states.
We are happy to send them, but is your state capable of taking companies,,,never
If resources are coming from other states thn is it not better to open companies/offices in other states? You want free land from public funds of Karnataka people but dont want give jobs to locals???? This is pure fraud. People who dont know English from BIMARU states given jobs but not well qualified Kannadiagas all bcz of nepotism, corruption.
@manjun8358 more than capable. Northern states never got their share of industries because of the kind of useless leaders who were in power. All subsidies and incentives went for shifting of textile and manufacturing industries from north. Calcutta was way bigger than any southern city. All energy resources and timber were taken from North while the south kept its forests protected. All central funds were used to develop ports in south and logistics to connect them. And now when the funds are shifting towards north to compensate for the past, suddenly you guys are talking about justice. Of course.
@tsrini68 in your dreams. I used to work in Bangalore and employed three locals for house help and cooking. Paid taxes and excise on products which went to YOUR state government. Worked for a company which generated revenue from OFFSHORE services.
So NO. I never took 'funds' from your state. I earned it from a company which earned it from foreigners. I gave much more to your state than what it gave back to me.
And for goodness sake, I'm happy for your reservation. Your economy runs from IT. And more than half the IT talent comes from north, check it on your own from the surveys done by FICCI.
The way you guys made language issues so big was the reason I had to leave.
People of BIMARU states don't kill others for language.
@@Seriouslyfunny1 we don't care about your never ending history/stories...we just want to preserve our cluture🙂
I work in Bengaluru, I'm not from Karnataka nor Kannadiga.
I'm happy with this Decision as Companies will have to finally move out of this city and Gujarat stands a chance to fetch few companies. Can work peacefully there 😌
Get lost gujju u r decision is correct
Self service get out. 😂
At best this guy will go to back to Mahavir Nagar in Mumbai !!
@@ShivaKumarShivaKumar-np6xz racist ?
@@darshanthacker773 we don't want you people to work here, vocals for locals better stay in your state find employment there don't come to our state depraving employment to local people.
What about people from Coastal region like Dakshin Karnataka, who are not Kannada speakers or Kannadigas. But Tulu & Konkani's speaking people , who go outside the state like Mumbai & overseas, bring their wealth & earning in developing this region. Why don't they get reservation in their home region.
Similar law has been struck down in Haryana..violates Art 14..
Chandra Babu Naidu AP CM, Reddy Tel CM, Stalin TN CM must be beaming with these kind of moves by Karnataka Govt.
Our parents funded the free land given to companies, tax concessions, etc all for whom?? to locals or migrants from other states? why open companies here? let them go other states since resources exist thr. It is fundamental right after having invested our public funds. It is totally constitutional.
@@tsrini68free land are you joking no one gives land for stop lying.
@@dheerajpimoli9539 You show innocence like kids. Your lack of knowledge & facts is not lies. It is such a shame. After taking free lands, tax concessions, loans, etc these people dont want yo give jobs to locals. Why cant they shift to other states thn?
How clear & logical is Mr. Pai? More Respect to you sir🙏🏻🫡
Kudos to Pai
So Bengaluru will once again become the "Garden city" free of traffic? 😁
Yes, free from people, political graveyard
This is clearly unconstitutional. The constitution gives power to Parliament the put “place of birth” as criteria for employment. State legislature has no such power to make “place of birth” a criteria for employment.
This communist congress will destroy Karnataka. They know it will be declared unconstitutional and then they want to blame BJP, saying they undid the act. And foolish public with zero practical knowledge will fall for congress deception once again. Congress is pushing for regionalism in every aspect which is an internal security challenge.
Being locals we are not getting jobs in the private companies, even with necessary eligibility criteria. Peoples from others state dominate the scene in private companies with Kannadigas number very meagre. What good is a company in a state where it does not provide employment for the locals. Coming to the constitutional question of legislative jurisdiction, agreed state lacks the power to make laws regarding fixing the place of birth for job criteria. But remember Kannada state agreed to stay with the union. If Kannadiga interest are threatened with existential threat in their own state, that result in depriving of their livelihood, then it’s high time for Kannadigas to ask for separate nation, where they can legislate on the place of birth to fix as a criteria for employment. so please know the pain of Kannada guys who are finding it difficult to get a job in their own state. The cost of other peoples. Can you imagine these things happen in the states like UP Bihar, West Bengal Tamil Nadu no, you cannot because because Kannadigas have authoritative attitude towards other fellow Indians. The secular attitude of Kannadigas should not be taken as granted.
@@manojnnayak1387 1. No state can cede from the union.
2 the better thing would be to generate more employment and to attract more qualified people rather than reservation
@@manojnnayak1387 why cannot u find job ? is there any discrimination ? it means u r incompetent
@@amithabv1060 if people of a state decides to overthrow Suzerainty to central authority, history stands as in testimony for reeling of provincial states against central authority for independence, it can be done. may not be according to constitution if people of certain state decides to renounce Indian constitution then it can be done. Coming to the second argument, you’re talking about merit here, are you questioning the eligibility and merit of the local people? I beg to defer from your statement Bengaluru, according to many efforts stands among the top destination of large talent pool, especially the local talent pool because of the government efforts to skill the populations, especially local population here and you second statement about qualified people stands wide. Reservation is a better tool to ensure local people get into employment opportunities which they are being deployed because of the cheap labour migration from north, which is making the competitiveness of the South people to get job difficult, though they have highly qualified background.
@@sumit5639 it’s not about competency. It is about getting cheap labours that these companies wants to increase their productivity and profits, so they are employing peoples from the north who are cheaply employed depriving the employability of the local people.
Other states should also limit maximum 1% kannad people in each company.
Oh so scary, please don't do this. We "Kannad" people are standing in long queue for job, outside the Hi-Tech ISRO/NASA/SpaceX joint RnD centre in Patna !!
Meanwhile these beggar bimaris states are worse than African countries
This rule will boost WFH ,so all salary will be spent in respective states,b'lore rent wil come down drastically, industry will focus on better places like Hyderabad.
Overall Karnataka will suffer....
This should be contested in court
Deep respect
Dividing India
Companies will move out from Karnataka. Real estate and business will be impacted
The bill did not see the light they have withdrawn it but this fool even now goes on ranting
Companies are welcome to Noida!
Why this fellow is coming on all channels?
That too after taking all benefits from Karnataka.
Does he know the pain of unemployed educated local youths.
He must be part of solution not just opposing and provide some light by which locals are also benefitted in IT sector.
These are group C and D employees only. So, there is no talent required. But cost to company will increase for these jobs, and cost is already high due to all the taxes for freebies. It is double whammy. Either they should have freebies or reservation. Not both.
Not only group C and D employees, read it completely, it's 100% for C and D category and 75% and 50%
M.pai have no knowledge of ground realities. Good decision taken by KK government. To save culture, migration of poor such reservation is must.
Mohandas Pai remember what you said about Karnataka politicians earlier. How many jobs your company gave jobs to kannadigas.
Why he should give to kannadigas . . .? Is there any provision in constitution or labor law for that? come on please understand. Thy are running business not charity, they will hire based on talent and merit not like government shitholes to have N number reservations, they have business to run. A company in Bangalore fully owned and run by non Kannadigas is 100% legal and valid. Understand capitalism and free market.
@@AM-gb7rp they can give you an opportunity. To compete for it depends on your skill
@@tinguzz why don't you tell your theory &stand to MODI.. Is he allowing free market?? is India a part of supply chain? Why don't he explain declaine in FDA..State Government is not implementing reservations but assurance to local talent.
@@AM-gb7rp Yes, you are 100% correct central government has not industrialized this country yet. We are way behind China. If China misses some opportunity then it is going to Vietnam, Thailand and Malaysia not coming to India. India is still a infrastructure deficit country with per person capital available is less than sub-Saharan African countries.
India should seriously intergrade with global supply chain and our per capital should touch USD 10000$.
Every state should learn from Karnataka ❤❤
Yeah and leave the private sector alone
Court can't quash constitution also protects locals, ethnics .
Define domicile as educated kannad language at elementary, secondary and graduation level is eligible for jobs in kk
Why states created on language basis if they can't reserve employment for their domiciles.?
You can also appoint best trainers to improve the skill of local people. It can be done through CSR. Why you are not suggesting this to corporate. Instead fuming on kannada and kannadigas
Sir you have promised to come to cv raman after the startup conclave you didn't come? Why???
Good karnataka government.
As marwari we support this decision🙄
Kannadigas/Tuluvas/Konkani peoples should get atleast 50% reservations in private jobs in Karnataka
Why Konkani? Goa will give them reservations :) If anything Kodavas should be added in your list!! But this is a bad precedence. Remaining 50% will next be demanded for OBC/SC/ST and its sure way of killing private investment in states. In long run, our kids will have to go to Bihar/UP/TN for jobs then, which would be much worst.
Karnataka have 90% engineer.
I think now karntaka should be a different nation where anyone except kannadigas are not allowed so congratulations for creation of a new nation for your kind information this bill is going to struck down by Highcourt on the ground on article 14 and freedom to work so good luck play politics
I think for such times Constitution have article 356
Mr mohan you are kannada hater?
Dude he is not hating anyone but do you even understand the deeper conflict of this law? It is against to constitutional spirit, as a kannadiga I feel ashamed of such third rate laws. Entrepreneurs should be free to hire and fire anyone at any time, If I am investing then I should have the right to hire anyone or fire anyone as I have to observe profit or loss. Please do not think like a third rate uneducated villager without any education. Business is driven by merit and merit alone. This is not real estate Dhanda run by few third rate politicians.
@@tinguzz sir, not everyone in Karnataka is blessed and rich kid like you..there are many poor educated people in Karnataka state studied in kannada medium government schools... everyone is not privileged like you sir.. pray for betterment of poor aspirants who are seeking jobs .. childrens of farmers and daily wage workers..any government just asked reservation for group C and D positions only.... everyone has different opinion I know.. but in Karnataka kannada is supreme..and kannada people should get opportunities in some cases
@@Baalbabita On what basis, did you ever live in rural area? ever interacted with them? I own form land and I work there. Even in Rural area it is not easy to get labors. Simply our people do not wanna work, just talk to any read side restaurant owner he/she will tell you the problem of running business. Why almost no kannadiga work in hospitality industry in bangalore? jobs are there but they do not wanna work.
All construction work in bangalore is done by outsiders, why? Kannadigas do not wanna work in Construction. What business people will do? They hire whoever is ready and get the work done.
We live in free market economy, develop skill and talent and get whatever job you want.
You said what will poor farmer will do . . is that the problem of private sector? isn't it duty of the state government to develop them? Please understand.
@@tinguzz you please go to Village and work in your farm land.. you are soo rich na, y u are worried about government implementations...and reservations...? U are indirectly saying poor should work in village itself and rich kids like you cherish your life in cities...can you eat software? No ryt? For food u need agriculture only..so you better come to your village and Start farming..let poor people rule the state ..or u contest election,get elected and give lecture...😂
Sunil modi Bihar no dharam sarve jihad majhi CM Kumar CM Yadav CM,courrnt time qustion BR 01/=BR 28,110kms Van tools palaza traffic rool
BJP tried to bring same bill in Haryana
IT weas struck down by HC gandhu
I think this person not kannadiga 😂
1:42 , BIMARU peoples taught...and yet they want to flock to Karnataka,
and BIMARU state income matches with Uganda, Burundi, Papua....yet they want to complain on Southern States
Tell me who is bimaru even after having so much job opportunities still you need 50 percent quota in managerial post. I think real bimaru are those who cannot clear a job interview even after getting so much opportunities.
Why can’t you compete then? Are you so incompetent that you can’t even beat people from BIMARU states. What losers. Hahahaha. 😂😂😂😂
@@dheerajpimoli9539 bimaru because for all the great managerial work and clearing interviews with flying colors, you do outside your state, why are you not able to create jobs in your state and become managers there? Such condescending attitude and utter disrespect you guys show to the place which gives you job, is the main reason local people have bitterness towards outsiders and so these politicians will try to push such policies to cash in votes.
@@sunilkb first of all in karnataka also many jobs are created by outsider only. Case in point is Bhavesh agarwal he is from punjab but he has setup his ola electric company in Bengaluru. You know why because Bengaluru is very dynamic the reason for it's success multiple intelligent people from different state can meet here and create new innovation but it's sad people know about rights not duties. I was not trying de mean anyone just need to state some fact.
Great decision
I'm from Kerala but studied in Kannada medium school in Kerala till 10th. Am I a Kannadiga or oursider?
Depends on weather your community votes congress or not
If you are from Kasargod I guess you can claim Karnataka domicile. See the cet eligilibity section code d.
In my view it should not matter, if you have required skill then you should be free to work anywhere and live your life happily. That is it. As a Kannadiga I never expect anyone to learn Kannada or pass kannada exam . . . what kind of fascism is this?
Teach kannada
You want free land funded by Karnataka people but dont want to give jobs & educational seats to kids of parents? How is jobs for locals is illegal when most resources are supplied by Karnataka? This Pai or Muzmdar shaw are nothing to do with Karnataka or Kannadigas. In fact after being beneficiary of Karnataka, they commit fraud on locals. Shame. If they cant stand for Karnataka people how can they stand with Bharatha?
I guess he explained clearly, he said that any govt. must aim for better education and skill of their state and create an upper hand through merit instead by providing safety nets through reservations.
Reservations like these only promote complacency and people may feel good in the short term because they got jobs, but in the long run the business will stop getting contracts as the quality of work would have dropped.
It's a well known fact if you get job security as guaranteed then a large chuck of people become complacent. As we usually see in the case of govt officers most of the time, even though there are a few who work as hard as possible too.
@@pratplan Companies go other states for campus recruitment but not local colgs here. Thn why open companies here? How is that people who cant speak English well gets IT jobs but not well qualified Karnataka person? All bcz of nepotism, groupisim & corruption.
I guess you aren't ready to understand the topic therefore you started with another one
Again English is not the requirement for lots and lots of work it's the skill and attitude to work. Both skill and attitude are not guaranteed by your place of birth.
They eat food and water from Karnataka but want to work for American vompanies. They can't write 60% of code in Kannada. 😡
Be Indian first, remember lot of kannadigas went to other cities before IT boom. Don't be shortcited. I have small company of my own, only 15% of staff is local kannadigas, I sell 99% of my products outside karnataka. Shouldn't i move out of Bangalore to other states where i am selling more(by your logic)???
Hire best Indians on your business, build best products in India and for the world, grow and make Indian proud with Indians...
First stop the entry of outsiders into Karnataka. Outsider works for less so Kannadiga will lose out on that job. Mark my words.
Yes I really like this idea, Karnataka must be declared as a nation if they feel they need state specific policies and only entry through visa must be allowed.
Also, any central govt. Grants, budgets or nation wide schemes must be stopped immediately, any highways that were created by NHAI must charge emi to Karnataka from the point it becomes a nation. Existing outsiders shall leave the state before the nation deceleration date and apply for a work permit if they still want to continue working.
These are some of the high level steps that are required to stop entry of outsiders legally.
So before adding some comments somewhere atleast think once.
Just for your reference and a little more basic conceptual building.
Raj Thackeray had once tried this outsider non sense business for UP and Bihar Business, and Maharashtra lost 17000 cr of business on a daily basis for 10 days.
And we all know how big Mr. Raj Thackeray is today.
So some food for thought for you.
@@pratplan I wish your native town/village to 90% fill up with Rohingyas, and think about your culture/language...
same with us , we have 2500 years of Kannada history,...and our state is occupied with other people..and most of "other" peoples doesn't even have a respect to our language and traditions in slightest way
@@pratplan every person must live and work in his own state that way all locals will get jobs in their respective areas and zones. If outsider comes and takes job of local and local remains unemployed it leads to jealousy and bitterness and ultimately clash arises. You stay in your house and we stay in our house that way we respect each other and no law and order problem arises its simple to understand if common sense is present. Nothing complex about this theory. Your state govt should solve your unemployment issues and not offset it to the head and neck of some other state down south. If you don't agree with this basic then you are definitely a trouble monger looking for disputes day in and day out. This is with respect to employment tourism is okay but jobs of every area should go to its own locals. Local grassroot unemployment can be solved only locally.
@@pratplan we don't need central govt highways they are all cracked anyhow for us state govt highways are suffice. Let the respective state money remain within the state. Only when give and take comes does dispute arise between which state got more and which state got less. Feeding others kids is not going to workout in long run every man must feed his own kids. I cannot pay to fill your kids stomach. Your hand under your head this rule is universal and holds good all over the globe.
@@pratplan we don't need central govt schemes anyhow it doesn't reach the hindu upper caste like myself it all goes to sc st women and minority for votes who will remain poor forever to grab govt benefits. I paid taxes and dint get a single paisa in return from central govt. All the money from govt is going towards welfare of the low caste people in my state Karnataka.
Karnataka mein toh farziwada chal hin raha hai. Infact aaj ke date pe india ke savi state mein farziwada chal eaha hai