1946 Election Was NOT A Referendum For Pakistan |

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 08. 2021
  • Why the 1946 election was NOT a referendum for Pakistan. Why the 1946 election was an illegitimate election. The difference between an election and a referendum.
    WATCH FULL EPISODE ► • #AskAbhijit 20: Indian...
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
    ►PayPal: paypal.me/AbhijitChavda
    ►Become A Member on CZcams: / @abhijitchavda
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    JOIN #AbhijitChavda
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ★Twitter: / abhijitchavda
    ★Instagram: / theabhijitchavda
    ★Facebook: / theabhijitchavda
    ★Website:
    ★Email Inquiries: inquiries.chavda@gmail.com
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    #AbhijitChavdaPodcast
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ★Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/1WmKYRI...
    ★Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
    ★Google Podcasts: podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0...
    ★Stitcher: www.stitcher.com/show/the-abh...
    ★Amazon Music: music.amazon.in/podcasts/c879...
    ★Soundcloud: / abhijitchavda
    ★Audible: www.audible.com/pd/item_name-...
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    #AskAbhijitChavda #Abhijit #Chavda #AskAbhijitShow
    Thank you for watching!
    Please share the video and spread the message. 🙏

Komentáře • 221

  • @Anonymous-qn2gr
    @Anonymous-qn2gr Před 2 lety +72

    I am thankful to telangana state govt. Because it's clearly mentioned in our Class 10 SSC textbook about how 1946 elections are void. The same data that Sir just presented is clearly printed in the book

    • @sormazi
      @sormazi Před 2 lety +4

      This is great to know! Also, I'm curious as to if there still a aryan-dravidian sentiment in the south? Periyar had created a lot of chaos from what I've read.

    • @Anonymous-qn2gr
      @Anonymous-qn2gr Před 2 lety +8

      @@sormazi In Telangana there's nothing like that. I believe it's a feeling limited only to Tamilnadu. But , there is a anti north indian sentiment because consecutive governments have been baised. For example recently central government approved 157 Medical Colleges around the country, of them Telangana did not even one.

    • @theKarthikkingable
      @theKarthikkingable Před 2 lety +2

      @@Anonymous-qn2gr I could see how anti north bias exist given how the news of 157 college reaches. There r multiple phases of this mission and it is also true there r much less medical college for the population in north right now. Anyways centre is not taking entire cost, it is 60:40 by centre-state. In states like UP, yogi personally intervened in these matter and opened more medical colleges than 3 previous regimes in UP couldnt. Btw, I would also like to know about how come only anti north sentiment but full appeasement of old city hyderabadis who still believe they r persians, even making their urdu as state official language but always running propaganda against hindi?

    • @Anonymous-qn2gr
      @Anonymous-qn2gr Před 2 lety +8

      @@theKarthikkingable First of all i was never in support of the ruling TRS party when I made my statements. Second of all the mission had 2 phases and the result i mentioned was cumulative of both phases. Third of all the state government here has also opened 7 new Medical Colleges just in May. And finally considering that I'm native to Hyderabad i am totally aware what goes on in the old city. The situation is so worse that I wouldn't be surprised to see 10 or 15 illegal immigrants in a locality there. It pains my heart when I see Urdu on all Govt. websites, buildings etc. The motive of freeing Telangana from Nizam in 1948 by the Brave Local Countrymen was to end this Urdu and Muslim domination. I am a proud Telugu and Indian and the fact that Urdu is an official language of my state pains my heart a lot. I mention again I'm in support of no political establishment (party) . I only mentioned state government. And I am totally against that party which insults Hindus in Hyderabad.

  • @amitchakraborty2246
    @amitchakraborty2246 Před 2 lety +69

    A referendum is basicly like a yes or no question. An election happens based on multiple agenda but referendum has a single concern. In 1946 it was not asked to Hindus whether they accept the partition of their motherland or not.Hindus voted for the sake of independence while other community had their own agenda.So,1946 election has no match with a referendum.

    • @DungarSinghChauhan
      @DungarSinghChauhan Před 2 lety +2

      But it is good that partition happened otherwise there would have been communal violence between Hindus and muslims . Don't you think partition , being illegitimate, have helped us get rid of this voilence?

    • @RKB192000
      @RKB192000 Před 2 lety

      As he said in the video, referendum or an election, does not matter. It was held under foreign occupation and hence - *NULL* & *VOID*
      How hard is it to get that fact! Maybe a result of the proponents who glorify the British rule in India!

    • @pb8857
      @pb8857 Před 2 lety +1

      @@DungarSinghChauhan You are vomitting the Gandhi excuse, which he deliberately put to save himself from the wrath of Hindus because he knew very well that some Hindus like you will take his bait and dilute the wrath of other Hindus.
      The truth is if partition was strictly opposed and prevented, the communal feelings leading to violence that you are speculating would have vanished. This is very much like showing the stick to an unruly boy to bring him to discipline & order, without which he feels granted to carry on his tantrums. Just examine Gujarat before & after Godhra riots and you will know what I am saying.

    • @amitchakraborty2246
      @amitchakraborty2246 Před 2 lety +4

      @@DungarSinghChauhan Do you think communal violences did not happen? Were the Great Calcutta killing, Noakhali riots and many more secular violences?All riots after 1947 are the aftermath of partition.

    • @DungarSinghChauhan
      @DungarSinghChauhan Před 2 lety +2

      @@pb8857 I don't give a f"*k to Gandhi and his so called non violence and other philosophies... I am capable of forming my own opinions. Huhh idiot 😏

  • @ritchiechathanat2208
    @ritchiechathanat2208 Před 2 lety +136

    #AskAbhijit Whenever we think of Christmas, the image that often comes to mind is snow with Evergreen trees, Reindeers and the North Pole, everything mostly winter-themed. But Christ was born in Bethlehem in the Middle East, where there are no such geo-climatic occurrences. However, these themes of Winter, that are commonly associated with Christmastime, are found in the cultures of Germanic, Scandinavian and other North European peoples. The Germanic peoples used to celebrate "Yule" which was a pagan festivity, closely connected to pagan festivals like "Saturnalia" and "Brumalia" celebrated by ancient Romans, which marked the beginning of astronomical winter. Is it possible that the modern, so called Western, theme and representation of Christmas that we see today, is actually because Europeans (particularly the Germanic peoples and Romans) chose to stick to their indigenous polytheistic traditions even after the Christian takeover of the continent?

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer Před 2 lety +18

      One more fact He (the man you named) was a black.
      [Just putting things in above sequence]
      Mate, it was Lithuania, a Baltic nation. It was the last country fought against crusaders till the last breath
      Like Arya people in Aryavart, Lithuanian polytheistic suffered from countless atrocities
      Several unimaginable things were done to Lithuanian women
      I can't mention, otherwise my comment will be deleted.
      When Lithuanians felt that no longer they can sustain the war, it was the end of polytheism and adopting of Mediterranean cult.
      The credit should be gone to Lithuanians
      & not to forget, Lithuanians is a separate race close to Vedic Hindus.
      In countryside of Lithuania, you would listen similar sound of sanskritim in Lithuanian (language)

    • @aryanparasar4138
      @aryanparasar4138 Před 2 lety +7

      christ was born in summer.. the romans associated christmas to december 25 th because they wanted to mock people celebrating saturnalia.. it was politically motivated to co incide chirstmas with saturnalia

    • @ritchiechathanat2208
      @ritchiechathanat2208 Před 2 lety +4

      @@aryanparasar4138 Fascinating! But do you think Christmas, as we see it today, is just a modern manifestation of cultural assimilation that might've occured after the Christianisation of Europe? Because they were polytheists with Reindeers and Evergreen trees in their backyard so to speak:)

    • @ritchiechathanat2208
      @ritchiechathanat2208 Před 2 lety +3

      @@MrSoothsayer Fair enough friend, I'm inclined to feel sorry for those Lithuanians, but how does this relate to my question? :)

    • @tushar8524
      @tushar8524 Před 2 lety +4

      Very new and fascinating information.

  • @factsmotivationstory6039
    @factsmotivationstory6039 Před 2 lety +67

    #AskAbhijit Why Islam failed to enter in China and Japan and why did Buddhism decline in China and it became an Atheist Nation

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer Před 2 lety +20

      Obviously, communism puts end to all obstacles
      Buddha dharma was no more than an obstacle since it too stresses on non violence principle.

    • @barbarik3797
      @barbarik3797 Před 2 lety +4

      India was facing that invasion ghey were not powerful enought to send there army to an other if they wond ghey wold3have lost india is my best expalination

    • @raghavjajoo1047
      @raghavjajoo1047 Před 2 lety +3

      Because of ccp's cultural revolution, they don't want there people to follow any religion

    • @chittodnaresh9568
      @chittodnaresh9568 Před 2 lety +10

      Islam spread by conquering territories and then instigating forceful violence for conversion. The islamic empires never thought of invading japan or china.

    • @smitparmar2136
      @smitparmar2136 Před 2 lety

      Hum ne usko roke rakha he 1400 salo se is liye our geography bhi factor ho sakta he

  • @rathore3991
    @rathore3991 Před 2 lety +7

    Bapu tune Kya kiya ek ko Muslim state or dusre ko dharmshala banadiya😓😥💥💥💥

  • @bastabbiswas3885
    @bastabbiswas3885 Před 2 lety +14

    Thank you Sir. That voting rights information is an eye opener. 🙏🙏

  • @anishray7401
    @anishray7401 Před 2 lety +4

    Thank you so much for sharing this sir. Can this be shared on other social media platforms like FB?

  • @arn2695
    @arn2695 Před 2 lety +25

    #AskAbhijit pls tell the story of Khalistan movement

    • @arushreddi5419
      @arushreddi5419 Před 2 lety +7

      Basically, Indira supported Separatists (If I remember, to get votes in Punjab), but things got out of control in Punjab, so Indira initiated 1984 Operation Blue Star.

    • @barbarik3797
      @barbarik3797 Před 2 lety +4

      They had govts involvement in a riots on sikh community and they were fed hate aginst hindus and so the ideaology emerged u can watch defensive offenece

    • @barbarik3797
      @barbarik3797 Před 2 lety

      @@arushreddi5419 Is ur real name reddy or reddi?U can ignore if u dont want

    • @technoyamraj
      @technoyamraj Před 2 lety

      @@barbarik3797 yeah I watched that eye opening video .....
      Every should watch it ......

    • @arushreddi5419
      @arushreddi5419 Před 2 lety

      @@barbarik3797 both reddi/reddy will suffice/work. Because in Telugu its రెడ్డి.

  • @me15296
    @me15296 Před 2 lety +2

    I did not know these three points. Thank you 🙏🏼

  • @shiv-ud1bu
    @shiv-ud1bu Před 2 lety +5

    This video presents us to know more about democracy and other important aspects of our world.

  • @Krishna-yr8ty
    @Krishna-yr8ty Před 2 lety +1

    You nailed it !

  • @creativeideaswitharya2883

    You are very right sir

  • @Learning_simplified4u
    @Learning_simplified4u Před 2 lety

    Well explained 🙏

  • @animefan6853
    @animefan6853 Před 2 lety +2

    Great explanation

  • @aadityachourasia2124
    @aadityachourasia2124 Před 2 lety +1

    Nailed it !

  • @stoic_sapien1
    @stoic_sapien1 Před 2 lety +6

    Thank you sir
    For this video✊🇮🇳

    • @ChandranPrema123
      @ChandranPrema123 Před rokem

      yeah did Balochi and Pashtun and Malayali Muslims vote for Referandum?

  • @kamalsingh-fg6pm
    @kamalsingh-fg6pm Před 2 lety

    Well explained sir😀🙏

  • @piyushpathak576
    @piyushpathak576 Před 2 lety +4

    sir if you were our teacher in school the learning of subjects would have been so easy and i think we would not have hated any subject and we could polymath like you .

  • @gravit1906
    @gravit1906 Před 2 lety +18

    Sir plz make a vedio that how India can made its own silicon valley .

    • @barbarik3797
      @barbarik3797 Před 2 lety +2

      We probably are making in progress Bangalore

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer Před 2 lety

      No need to be silicon valley.

    • @barbarik3797
      @barbarik3797 Před 2 lety

      @@MrSoothsayer i dint get u

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer Před 2 lety

      @@barbarik3797 Why always wants to be like others?

    • @barbarik3797
      @barbarik3797 Před 2 lety

      @@MrSoothsayer So u dont want to have start upsnl and have businees in ur country we can have good things right?

  • @bababistril
    @bababistril Před 2 lety +1

    can you please make longer and very detailed videos on all topics 🙏🙏

  • @sharadoo7luck
    @sharadoo7luck Před 2 lety +6

    #AskAbhijit can you tell us about the person 'osho' of which the netflix series wild wild west based.

  • @adityanair3673
    @adityanair3673 Před 2 lety +3

    Good sir

  • @koteswar009
    @koteswar009 Před 2 lety +1

    In Australia we had referendum on just one question if same sex marriage should be legal or not. Same in UK on Brexit. Partition of India was not on referendum. But what's surprising is that UN asked for Kashmir referendum. Why didn't UN say British supervised Indian elections are null and referendum should be held on Partition.

  • @tekytoemagic5685
    @tekytoemagic5685 Před 2 lety +2

    Love you from heart sir😍😘😘💞

  • @chandanlahiri7648
    @chandanlahiri7648 Před 2 lety +5

    Sir, you are absolutely correct. There are many more points which can be sighted against the formation of Pakistan in 1947 under British rule which is illegal. Can India go to ICJ for nullifying the order of partition of India in 1947 and declaring it as absolutely illegal and fully against the principle of natural justice. India was partitioned by a foreign occupant illegally as per the sweet will of the minority community (muslim) and the decision of the majority Hindu community alongwith other Indian communities was not taken into account at all in this regard. Can it be brought to the notice of International Court of Justice after a lapse of 72 years? If the answer is yes, what should India do now?

  • @farooq.rasheed
    @farooq.rasheed Před 2 lety +2

    See the problem is that modern Indians hate Britons and British occupation but the Indian leadership back in 1947 were so comfortable with the Brits that they even made Mountbatten their first governor-general. Abhijit's videos on partition are so revisionist in nature.
    (And yes, I'm from Pakistan)

  • @ppchowdhury9332
    @ppchowdhury9332 Před 2 lety +4

    Basically, during 1946 election, the so called elite Muslims within India voted. To be more precise they are Ashraf class. A large part of them had the two nation theory in their heart. Most of the lower class common Muslims (also sometimes called Pasmanda) had no function in the voting. These Ashraf class is strongly anti Hindu. Sadly ,after Partition many of these Ashraf class people remained in India but with same mentality. This Ashraf class always played vital role in political representation where as most of the common backward Muslims (almost 90 % of Muslims) remained under the control of this Ashraf class.

  • @Abhinav_Bharat_of_VeerSavarkar

    In this way our constitution was also written by the chosen members by elected members under foreign occupation.

  • @neerajlivesinindia
    @neerajlivesinindia Před 2 lety +1

    V good

  • @user-od2ko7zz6z
    @user-od2ko7zz6z Před 2 lety +1

    Thank You Sir 💕, I didn't have any idea regarding the false Referendum Agenda!

  • @harshb747
    @harshb747 Před 2 lety +24

    Who would have lived in a nation with 50% muslims and 50% Hindus. I think it's best for both sides to live in their individual nations. If partition would have been completed entirely it would have been even better

    • @vanshdhoka7236
      @vanshdhoka7236 Před 2 lety +13

      I think that it would have been better if all lived in one nation , at first it could have led to a civil war but then there would be peace in the country as Hindus and Muslims lived together for years before. Now after partitioning there are tensions between India and Pakistan still which has led to deaths of more people.

    • @raghavjajoo1047
      @raghavjajoo1047 Před 2 lety +10

      Still we are living together Hindu and Muslims

    • @vineetthakur182
      @vineetthakur182 Před 2 lety +4

      @p goswami a civil war would have put end to this demonic cult and we would still had undivided land with even 50 percent hindu population

    • @MunaLife
      @MunaLife Před 2 lety +10

      @@raghavjajoo1047 Living together is not the problem. Converted Muslims denying their Indian cultural roots under outside influence and refusing to take pride in their Indian heritage is the problem.
      The formation of Bangladesh over language and culture issues have proved that cultural heritage is far stronger than religious issues when it comes to living our lives.

    • @raghavjajoo1047
      @raghavjajoo1047 Před 2 lety

      @@MunaLife Madame, Bangladesh was not seprated because of language, if this would happen all bengal should be gone, the formation of Bangladesh takes place due to muslim majority and second thing you said is correct about Muslims, but i can it will take time to influence all of them culturally and I am sure that they will come back, but it requires time.

  • @aniruddhnaik5277
    @aniruddhnaik5277 Před 2 lety +1

    My question is was the election in Crimea held under Russian occupation in 2014?

  • @Parthainvincibledey_95
    @Parthainvincibledey_95 Před 2 lety +3

    Sir your english is top notch... Next time please turn on CC... It helps a lot🙏❤️

  • @Harshdeep_._._Singh
    @Harshdeep_._._Singh Před 2 lety +5

    🙌

  • @notaditya1249
    @notaditya1249 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijeet
    Namaste Sir, I would like to ask if do you any insights on how to Kickstart Indic Renaissance. And your opinions about it, like how it will transform our society? Thanks a lot for imparting knowledge on us. Dhanyawad.🙏🏼

  • @krishsharma7147
    @krishsharma7147 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit what do you think of present day indian 5th gen fighter jet, and Tejas mak 2 in development?

  • @onesided444
    @onesided444 Před 2 lety +1

    Sir कस्साइट अभिलेख ke me irani aryans ki baat khi h ,aapke vichar ??

  • @vopsycreation5048
    @vopsycreation5048 Před 2 lety

    Sir tell about mount batten plan

  • @jitsss
    @jitsss Před 2 lety

    What was the slogan by both Congress & ML in this election on what points did they fought

  • @ROHITSINGH-fc4se
    @ROHITSINGH-fc4se Před 2 lety +3

    #AskAbhijit sir i understand countless things had been done to us indians in recent history/older history....by knowing these information i feel unstable as an indian and i cant stop thinking about it .After watching some of your videos i cant even sleep at night .....guide me please! #AskAbhijit

    • @USER-xm9ne
      @USER-xm9ne Před 2 lety

      Same bro, I get so disappointed and feel so demotivated whenever I try to do something for country

  • @abhinitharwal8439
    @abhinitharwal8439 Před 2 lety +3

    #AskAbijit Sir tell us more about Scythians are are they linked with Germans and vikings and how big there Kingdom is ??

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer Před 2 lety

      Weird to ruminate how you can think of linking scythians with Germans and Vinings?
      Scythians were mixture of many races, the culture they adhered was late Vedic dharma.
      In the contrary of scythians, Germans & Vikings were rural people playing around the countryside of Norway.
      Singing folklores, living nude, and plundering nearby locations.
      What similarity you find between them?
      Vikings didn't even know how a horse looks like

  • @sanjayladge757
    @sanjayladge757 Před 11 měsíci

    Why Congress did not insisted for referendum.?

  • @saptarshi7587
    @saptarshi7587 Před 2 lety

    Very good explanation. You explained very well about technicalities and acceptances of the election. But, we sud not forget that was the arrangements of the day, so the election was appropriate as per law of the time, may not be valid as per today's standard. Another issue, the political parties accepted the results.
    You can not deny situation of the day, mentally of the people. You have to take consideration of the statements of the political party at the time. Like famous statement of Sardar Ballav Bhai Patel, about granting reservation for muslims just after partition, that group of people capable of dividing country should not be considered as weak. Definitely Sardarji mentioned mentality of majority of muslim population.

  • @tiger_lion_king
    @tiger_lion_king Před 2 lety +3

    #AskAbhijit Where you see India in 50 years from now?

  • @codingclips
    @codingclips Před 2 lety

    If I want to grow up to be someone in life, I want to be Abhijit Chavda!

  • @teemothibhattacharjee9388

    Sir even Syleth is illegally Occupied by Bangladesh

  • @muditbhatia5553
    @muditbhatia5553 Před 2 lety

    Dhaaga khol dia

  • @Ayush90134
    @Ayush90134 Před 2 lety +8

    #Askabhijit sir I want to know that China and Taiwan are enemy of each other and biggest semiconductor and chip maker is from Taiwan like TSMC is there any option to attract these Taiwanese company to India.

    • @arushreddi5419
      @arushreddi5419 Před 2 lety +3

      Liberalisation. Reforms.

    • @theKarthikkingable
      @theKarthikkingable Před 2 lety +1

      Foxconn, Wistron already has presence in India. But a fabrication lab is a different game, heavy investment needed.

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety

      We can only ask for manufacturing. Inventing chips will need a lot of R and D. We have the brains, but not the money

  • @Amit-tr3np
    @Amit-tr3np Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit Sir kindly make a detail video on Bappa Rawal (Raval) and on Ahom dynasty.

  • @TRIDRIK_
    @TRIDRIK_ Před 2 lety +1

    #AskAbhijit Sir you are awesome. We Indians are so stupid that an election hold by the British occupiers in India during the British Occupation we accept it as legitimate. Till today, when you broke this myth, I was such stupid that I also accepted it as legitimate. This is what we were taught for all these years and also taught to our previous generations.

  • @cosmorebreak121
    @cosmorebreak121 Před 2 lety +1

    #AskAbhijit many people claim that ranbidarnath tygore had written national anthem for British king at that time and he was agent of British government working in India , is it true ?

  • @Tejas_
    @Tejas_ Před 2 lety +3

    There is only one reason why I am satisfied that india was partitioned: See the islamic extremism in Bangladesh and Pakistan today. 99% of Hindus in those countries were either forcefully converted or ran to India because they were sacred to die.

    • @sarakumari3179
      @sarakumari3179 Před 2 lety +1

      Same is going to here in india, already started in many parts

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety +1

      Exactly why partition shouldn't have happened. Let the civil war happen, let things be cleared out and the stronger one win(which we were ....we had major institutions, if any, on our side, populous on our side)
      So why are hindus so so afraid of such things?
      .
      If we lost, it would be simply natural selection. And I am not afraid of it as it would spare so many lives of our soldiers over the years.
      .
      Personally, I have no affinity or allegiance to this Indian state, a pathetic pseudo secular populist state. But I do have my regards and a soft spot for those nationalists and soldiers who would die for this nation, for it's people.

    • @sarakumari3179
      @sarakumari3179 Před 2 lety

      @@harshjain3122 i agree with you 100% this time AAR ya Paar

    • @Tejas_
      @Tejas_ Před 2 lety +1

      @@harshjain3122 sorry but your are also part of the problem because you don't have any "affinity or allegiance to this indian state". Even if you hate what we have become you should be willing to improve the country in whatever way possible. And if nothing is left in you for this country you're just a liability.

  • @NavdeepSingh-ch8xi
    @NavdeepSingh-ch8xi Před 2 lety +1

    #askabhijit how can India become a global hegemonic power? Can a free market approach could help us to defeat China's economy instead of current nehruvian socialism?

  • @shriyamjha7556
    @shriyamjha7556 Před 2 lety +1

    #AskAbhijit
    Is democracy the best form of gov.?

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety

      Nope. Most second world and third world countries which are wealthy today were a form of auth govt in their initial growth and stabilization period. Because as Aristotle himself said 'despots rule despots, educated and informed, homogeneous elect'....in a book of his.
      Examples include south korea, Vietnam, Singapore, Rwanda(ease of business at 29 in Africa), Uzbekistan, turkey under Ataturk when he reformed everything in Turkey, etc.

  • @paggisalsa
    @paggisalsa Před 2 lety

    Question - No records are present about Jesus from age of ~13 to ~30 in Christian scriptures. It's said that he went to Asia -- India, Tibet (India then) and China . Did he learn Hinduism and Buddhism and inculcated his learnings in Christianity ? What's your take on it ?

  • @HornetCucumber
    @HornetCucumber Před 2 lety

    But then Sardar Patel also had referendum in junagarh then merged into India.

  • @shaibalchowdhury1246
    @shaibalchowdhury1246 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit Sir do you think India should built a military base in Fiji to counter China and also to bring Micronesia and Polynesia under Indian hegemonical sphere.

  • @gauravpanwar1216
    @gauravpanwar1216 Před 2 lety +1

    Sir, Would india be more advance if we have used our languages hindi or sanskrit rather than english as the great mind of our country remain in country and contribute like china, japan ,korea and others
    SIR PLEASE ANSWER #AskAbhijit

    • @ABHIJEET_CHN
      @ABHIJEET_CHN Před 2 lety

      bhai tum khud English mein puch rhe ho...........

  • @chittodnaresh9568
    @chittodnaresh9568 Před 2 lety +3

    #AskAbhijit How could the hindu leaders had faced and countered the direct action day killings by the Muslim league led Bengal government in 1946 by not getting afraid and not surrendering to the muslim league's partition plan?

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety

      By not being cucks and going head first. Seriously it's not that hard.

  • @vandanadeshmukh7295
    @vandanadeshmukh7295 Před 2 lety +1

    #AskAbhijit sir can you explain how Shahaji Raje, the father of Chatrapati shivaji maharaj,died?

  • @RishiSharraf
    @RishiSharraf Před 2 lety +1

    Sir create a weekly Scripted Video with good editing on Important topics.

  • @dhyeypandya6984
    @dhyeypandya6984 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit Tell me the history about Pandya dynasty ? Is it was Brahmin? As we came across in the history textbooks about pandya dynasty from south

  • @kuldeepjawale3335
    @kuldeepjawale3335 Před 2 lety

    But we r happy sir,,,,, of it is not happend then we r also in thta same condition sorry but it is

  • @DungarSinghChauhan
    @DungarSinghChauhan Před 2 lety

    But people were asked to either remain in India or move to Pakistan!! At least this is what taught to us... Then how is it unfair 🤔🤔🤔

  • @garuda3935
    @garuda3935 Před 2 lety +2

    Sir, the more I learn, the more infuriated I become. Congress were true lackies of the Brits. And it's still shows, that their as$-licking, caused our stunted growth.

    • @marcomd4093
      @marcomd4093 Před 2 lety +1

      Being infuriated will not inprove your intelligence. Learn from the mistakes done in the past and help the modern India to improve the indian life quality. Division brought India to impoverishment and weakness. Strengths is gained through a solid union. Never forget this lesson.

  • @VanaeCavae
    @VanaeCavae Před 2 lety

    A another good example is Scotland. The pro independence Scottish National Party (SNP) won the majority of seats in the Scottish Parliament but lost the vote on the Referendum for Scottish independence.

  • @gunasekharj3883
    @gunasekharj3883 Před 2 lety +1

    #AskAbhijit Were Variankunnath Kunhammad Haji and Ali Musliyar who lead the khilafat movement in malabar during moplah riots(massacre) freedom fighters?

  • @praveenraamamrutur2017
    @praveenraamamrutur2017 Před 2 lety +2

    #askabhijit how did lal bahadur shastri died?? if it is murder then why was he murdered??

  • @yashgulave8366
    @yashgulave8366 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit Sir, you asked us to raise questions and I had one. So, here you go: In one of your videos you said that India had the Dharmic economics system that was even better and the capitalist system. You said that under the Dharmic system, education and medicine was completely free. But I have heard that it wasn't completely free, instead you were supposed to pay whatever you could according to your financial condition. Can you please confirm this?

  • @vijaykumara7927
    @vijaykumara7927 Před rokem

    Absolutely correct and it's fact that the British with their servent Gandhi and his team
    Lead by Nehru did all to fool the Indians.

  • @ravindraprasad5486
    @ravindraprasad5486 Před 25 dny

    Sample of 30 million choose pakistan out of 1.2 crore

  • @shauryapratapsingh6052

    #askabhijit how did hinduism and indegineous faiths survived in india even after thousand years of invasion and colonialism 🙏?

  • @OverLord3693
    @OverLord3693 Před 2 lety +1

    #AskAbhijit
    You say that Ramayana and Mahabharata are part of our history and not just Myths. But there are many instances and depictions where unscientific things like godly powers are used.
    If these do not invalidate Ramayana or Mahabharata as a source of history, then how can we find out what part of these is true and what part is superstition so that we can understand our own history better.

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety

      Metaphors. Have you seen how normal animals are described in mediaeval scriptures? A great great deal of exaggeration and misinformation because eye witnesses were sparse and no recording cameras and all you know.
      It's nothing exclusive to india tbh.

  • @yashtibrewal3468
    @yashtibrewal3468 Před 2 lety +1

    #AskAbhijit
    What is your take on Nathuram Godse and why he shot Mahatma Gandhi.

  • @kushagrsolanki4736
    @kushagrsolanki4736 Před 2 lety +1

    Plz make a video on ottoman empire from there rise to fall,did they come to india,are there any descendent of ottoman empire in india,were they as good and as mighty as they are shown, just a little bit curious about that empire

  • @MrSoothsayer
    @MrSoothsayer Před 2 lety +2

    #AskAbhijit
    Will taliban's victory motivate Pakistani youth to take over artificial country and declare it officially a radical Islamic nation?

    • @aashaypantoji1897
      @aashaypantoji1897 Před 2 lety +1

      What does official Islamic.nation mean. Pakistan was declared a Islamic country right from it founding. This is well shown in fact that how fellow Hindus in Pakistan are treated , how temples are burnt down and forceful conversions occur .
      And regarding a coup , well the Pakistanis army would simply massacre all protesters and majority.of their youth are already training in terrorist camps.or in the army
      So the comment doesn't make sense at least. To me . I will be happy if you explain it to me

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer Před 2 lety

      @@aashaypantoji1897 Being official Islamic nation & being a radical Islamic nation like taliban Afghanistan have a giant difference.
      1)Protocols today Pakistan obeys (not very much) doesn't have to do under taliban - like leadership.
      2)Sharia law will be above constitution and international treaties under Taliban - like leadership
      3)An official terrorist State.

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety

      @@MrSoothsayer probably not unless they are on the brink of economic collapse and civil unrest. Oh. We just need to give them a bit of a push and the fireworks may go off haha

  • @DungarSinghChauhan
    @DungarSinghChauhan Před 2 lety +2

    But it is good that partition happened otherwise there would have been communal violence between Hindus and muslims . Don't you think partition , being illegitimate, have helped us get rid of this voilence?

    • @redxrajvir4068
      @redxrajvir4068 Před 2 lety

      But still we can see Communal violence
      Between both religions.

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety +1

      It was a tradeoff. A bad one. We didn't get a hindu state. All we did is delay the shit...had it been done back then, the dust would have settle for once and for all...and we would be much stable, possibly a richer society with a bit lower population but mostly all Indic religions and an extreme deterence against abrahamic religions

    • @redxrajvir4068
      @redxrajvir4068 Před 2 lety +2

      @@harshjain3122 I thoroughly agree with U...
      Had we opted for civil war,it would have still resulted in a better outcome. The muslims of Punjab and Bengal were should have been given the priority coz these states were Muslim populated and these were the roots for Pakistan.
      Atleast we could have got Our whole land back including Pak,POK and Bangladesh.
      But yeah we were peace lovin' .....

  • @hrishisathe6281
    @hrishisathe6281 Před 2 lety +7

    #AskAbhijit sir i want to know full history of our greatest pm shri nehruji

    • @abhishekdarjee7069
      @abhishekdarjee7069 Před 2 lety +1

      Nehru no, not the greatest .

    • @shadowoffire4307
      @shadowoffire4307 Před 2 lety +1

      He is greatest and bigest blunder of india not greatest pm. Modi is greatest pm. And dictetor indhira gandhi like his father was anti hindu she was huge mistake.

  • @swapnilramekar6156
    @swapnilramekar6156 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit i came across a theory that jesus was actually desciple of budhha. Because his teaching was similar.

  • @subhojeetkarmakar2682
    @subhojeetkarmakar2682 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit sir , why did islam fail to enter tibet and china even though it was able to convert the people of central asia?

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer Před 2 lety +2

      Ans. Desert cult believers weren't smart to cross Himalayas

  • @sunnyghosh9147
    @sunnyghosh9147 Před 2 lety

    What's ur opinion on muslims living in india?? #AskAbhijit

  • @RKB192000
    @RKB192000 Před 2 lety

    😂 He is just being polite while referring to the ones who were claiming there was a referendum; and vehemently so.
    It is amusing that most of us tend to view those times from today's perspective and completely disregard that we were under occupation in 1946. Also, there are proponents of British rule being an age of peace, tranquility and "progress".
    P.S It maybe a possibility that they have learnt *critical thinking* from certain someone!

  • @anantharao279
    @anantharao279 Před 2 lety

    By same logic the current constitution is foreign occupation constitution. All same old articles of IPC, Sedition, telegraph, & othr countless laws exist as it was. Going further "unelected & outsider" Governor general became governor now with same unelected & outsider. What shame so called founding fathers just pasted first page Preamble & every other article violates it!!

  • @ibrahimshayk2309
    @ibrahimshayk2309 Před 2 lety

    So by this logic in 1946 INC also was not legitimate to run the govt and what about Calcutta killing there was a demand of Pakistan and you forgot to discuss about the one point agenda of AIML of Pakistan

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety +1

      The 'elections'(not referendum) in india worked something like: 'ok so you are the most organised party and atleast have a committee and speak English? Come here fellow elitist, become the 'elected' rulers of this nation.'
      There you go.
      Sources for the second part tho I am pretty sure it was retaliatory in nature.

  • @sanjayladge757
    @sanjayladge757 Před 11 měsíci

    Because Nehru wanted partition

  • @level8695
    @level8695 Před 2 lety

    H

  • @hvsr2597
    @hvsr2597 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit Is it possible to make india akhand hindu rashtra.

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety

      Lemme say this...it has as much chance as us getting a strong hinduistic party at the centre rather than whatever tf bjp is.

  • @philipdawes2661
    @philipdawes2661 Před 2 lety

    @abhijit chavda A few of points:-
    1) Even though the voting franchise was very limited (we brits only 'received' universal suffrage ourselves in 1928), how many Indians could participate in an election prior to elections being introduced by the British?
    2) Partitioning happening prior to the first 'universal indian government elections' - If Jinnah had waited until after independence, then a 'dictatorship of the majority' parliament would, most likely, have prevented an Islamic Pakistan (which with hindsight, might have been better for the population of what is now Pakistan).
    3) You have stated that the reason the British wanted partition as 'so that they could have a naval base and strategic presence in the region, which they would not get from India post independence' and also that, essentially, Ghandi and Nehru were tools for the British control/influence in India. Which of those 2 views are actually your views as they contradict themselves?

  • @ryzryz2402
    @ryzryz2402 Před 2 lety

    India should re claim Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Nepal, Maldives and Bhutan. And for terrorism and other problems there are many solutions like India should make a 200 million men vouluntary army to take over and crush terrorism.

  • @kunalbadade7815
    @kunalbadade7815 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit There was referendum in North West Frontier Province what happend? 49% people didn't vote because Abdul Gafar Khan boycott it because there is no option for Separate Pakhtu nation ! And all other people (51%) voted for Pakistan ! There is option for India why didn't they voted for it ! If muslims didn't want Pakistan why there is Direct Action Day ? Chain of riots ! Clearly Muslim leauge has Support of all muslim.Furthermore Look at demands of Other So called Nationalist Muslim leader they want 50% Reservation in Centre and Separate Muslim Constituency this is worse than pakistan

  • @ravindraprasad5486
    @ravindraprasad5486 Před 25 dny

    So paksitan is illegal

  • @aum6032
    @aum6032 Před 2 lety

    #AskAbhijit did Jesus ever exist?

  • @shivoham9719
    @shivoham9719 Před 2 lety +1

    #askabhijit Sir, if mahatma gandhi was acting as stooge for british as in one of your videos I have listened , then why Subhash chandra bose gave him the title "father of nation" And Rabindranath tagore gave him title "Mahatma"? Even Sardaar Vallabh bhai patel was fan of him.
    Thank you.

  • @gauravpanwar1216
    @gauravpanwar1216 Před 2 lety

    Sir, Would india be more advance if we have used our languages hindi or sanskrit rather than english as the great mind of our country remain in country and contribute like china, japan ,korea and others
    SIR PLEASE ANSWER #AskAbhijit

    • @harshjain3122
      @harshjain3122 Před 2 lety

      No but we would probably have tech giants of our own, a more advanced coding language if we also chose an auth govt with it.