Andrei and Natasha's Waltz Scene - War & Peace (2016)
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 02. 2016
- A breathtakingly tender and romantic scene of Andrei Bolkonsky (James Norton) and Natasha Rostova (Lily James) falling in love while waltzing in Episode 3 of BBC's War & Peace 2016. No copyright infringement intended.
- Zábava
And this is the moment when Pierre finally realizes that he loves Natasha as more than just a friend but she is unattainable to him. Paul Dano's acting was superb in this series. The entire series was phenomenal despite the over abundance of commercial breaks.
we have the BBC here in Britain, so no commercial breaks!
Respectfully I have to disagree
The impression I got was that he had always loved her - probably since they were children. He never said anything because she was always 'unattainable'
He grew up as an illegitimate child with no means of his own or prospect of inheritance. He would have known that there would have been no chance that her parents would have consented to marriage.
Even if they had, he is so unselfish that he would not want her to live the very modest lifestyle that he could have provided
As soon as he became the count he was caught up in a whirlwind and tricked into marriage before he could process what was happening - again making her unattainable.
Here was the first time he saw her fall in love with another man. And any dream he had of being with her probably left him at that point
I also think Lily James' (is that her name?) acting was easily the best
Darren Crabb Thanks to Lev Tolstoy and Russia wich inspired him and only then to BBCs 5th version of the novel.
Darren Crabb are u seriously comparing BBC to Tolstoy??
He wasn't in love with his wife. Rather than love, it was lust, tbh
Every woman should dance like this at least once in her life.....to remember.... before she leaves this world....
Jodha Akbar I agree strongly.
Thats so Abba...
Triscele Criative ABBA ? That’s another generation. No. This is historical vintage romance. Balls. Beautiful dresses. A whole different culture. Some like it. Some don’t, but that whole period in history had some amazing beauty!😉
@@jodhaakbar4865 Every generation has it's own: Only seventeenvski!
I agree as well 😊
Даже если не нравится эта экранизация зачем оскорблять актёров?
По мне, британцы очень постарались, костюмы, музыка, операторская работа. Даже для этой сцены заморочились и снимали на натуре, а не в декорациях.
Этот сериал вызвал очередной всплеск интереса к роману, это же здорово
Марина, да нам вынь да положь русский дух... Они забывают, что это не столько русский роман, сколько нетленный общемировой шедевр.
Ну такой жалкий Болконский - это перебор. Даже насквозь прожжённая Лили Джеймс и то лучше отыгрывает чувственную невинность, чем этот жиголо, подрагивающий на каждом шагу (он в курсе вообще, как военные ходят?). Только Пьер и хорош
@@sailorv8067 а мне понравился каст англичан. А как Вам Боярская в роли Карениной, угодила?)))
Они беспомощны все. Это не аристократия 19 века, ни русская, ни даже английская. Смешно и жалко с первых кадров и до конца.
Люди сравнивают с фильмом Бондарчука 1967 года. "Эталоном" фильма, попробуй переплюнь Наташу Ростову на балу, это не реально, она кроме того что очень хороша там была, так еще и стала именно эталоном "Война и мир", как и остальные актеры. Кроме того люди забывают о том что режиссер, актеры и сценаристы зная о существовании шедевра старались дотянутся , не сколько до фильма, сколько до впечатления, до эмоций полученных от просмотра Войны и мира, а эта планка очень высока, куда выше чем просто фильм.
He looked at her the way all women want to be looked at by a man. My God, James Norton brings Prince Bolkonsky to another level.
I agree, those glances....both of them. Sometimes I wonder why reality has to be so mediocre sometimes (in terms of relationships, seems people lost romance...not everyone of course. I'm still waiting my Andrej LOL😊)
I think he has looks and beauty of ancient times..he is not super beautiful but yet he is very charming and so good looking. I liked his portrayal of Andrej here (and this scene with Lily James is so pure, romantic and beautiful..touches the heart) and also loved his works in other TV serie as Grantchester and more. Wish we could see him around more.
@@nahla__ I hope you find him !
@@AT-cy7im ahah thank you ☺️ you're very kind. I hope everyone finds a person with a kind heart, manners/charm and intelligence. Someone who does care about the reciprocal other; I think it's important in a relationship, the respect and care.. besides the love. Wish you a good end of this year🍀 happy holidays
@@nahla__ Yes I do stand as well for these very valuble of sentiments that come from a kind heart, Happy Holidays to you as well.
@@nahla__ Just dont get older than 19 thats all
the eye contact in this scene is incredible. never for a second did they lose focus of each other and the chemistry is so thick. i'm so heavily invested in their relationship even though they have significantly lesser screentime. what a beautiful couple and the actors did it so well. i also love this era and this age, where people dress up to go to a ball and mutual affection is expressed in such a beautiful way- a dance, a look in the eyes, a touch of the hands. i love this so much.
I like those books and novells. I want those love stories. Big fan of romantic Austen and the drama of Tolstoi, but never, ever would I want to live in those times for real. Just the wealthy ton went to actual balls. Country dances weren't that lavish and like balls, apart from the merriment, realy a kind of marriage market.
Politeness was just required between equals.
Women were absolut dependent in those times. Wealthy women didn't had to work, but even they had a very limited education, no money or power and had to stay chaste and chaparoned (to stay free of roomers). The cause of this polite courtship was to be perfect, untouched bargening chips, to be married off to the advantages of their fathers and hopefully not to be a burden by attracting the wrong or no suitors. They were practically unmarriagable after the age of 25, also because married women were often reduced to breed children. Their tasks were producing offsprings (preferably males - an heir and a spare), to supervise part of their childrens upbringing, to keep their husbands happy and to make the home hospitable, keeping up appearance,...
I wont get started on hygiene or deadly makeup.
Reminds me of Young Victoria.
this is such a beautiful comment!
А ведь Андрей не любил Наташу.. А она была так юна и восторжена, впечатлительна, наивна, чиста..
@@alexpond648 iuuu, what a horrible life you describe!
Я читала книгу в оригинале и смотрела советскую экранизацию, так как русский язык - мой родной. Там Болконский и Безухов старше, чем здесь, а Наташа очень юна, как и должно быть по книге. Но эта экранизация мне тоже очень понравилась. Бережное отношение к первоисточнику. Видно, что фильм сделан с большой любовью. Герои такие живые! Большое спасибо авторам этого замечательного фильма и привет из России.
на начало романа ----
•Андрей Болконский (~27 лет);
•Пьер Безухов (20 лет);
•Марья Болконская (20 лет);
•Николай Ростов (19-20 лет);
•Наташа Ростова (~13 лет).
действие романа начинается в 1805 году; заканчивается оно через 15 лет - хотя и не все герои доживают до эпилога.
Мывсе читали роман "" в оригинале"-- так как изучали еще в школе. Лучше нашего( советского ) фильма . конечно, нет. Да. можно отметить красивых актеров и т.д. Но передать менталитет. поведение. чувствования героев романа Льва Толстого может только русские актеры и рус. режиссер . Сергей Бондарчук непревзойден!
Мне порекомендовали посмотреть версию ВВС. Я нехотя, с большим предубеждением, начал смотреть сериал. Но увидев своего Пьера, уже не смог остановиться. Сериал ВВС лежит совершенно в другой плоскости. Приятно неожиданной.
@@Maja789----да вы задрали со своим нытьём по Бондарчуку, с его престарелой ЭЛЕН.
...никто не сможет передать русский менталитет.
какой у вас менталитет то такой особенный, что его передать нельзя ?
шерлока Холмса Ливанов смог воплотить, а англичане Толстого снять не смогут ?
они сделали лучше, чем снял Бондарчук. блеск и роскошь имперской России, бальные залы, невероятные платья , трогательный Безухов.
конечно, никто не переиграет Тихонова , но это, извините, и есть русский аристократ, таких больше не делают.
и ваше высокомерное"спаибо за интерес" неуместно.
это не интерес - это огромное бабло и очень талантливо, скрупулёзно, качественно сделанная работа.
Очень классно сняли 🥇🥇🥇
Самая лучшая экранизация как по мне
@@user-ef2ju1kr8i Вы жалкая ничтожная личноть. Иноагент
That ballroom is real. It's in Catherine Palace just outside St Petersburg. Truly spectacular.
Indeed, I also dream of such balls♡♡♡¡
No. This is not Peterburg. This palace not far from Riga, Latvia. Former Biron residence.
@@user-mj3uc7de4b No, it`s in Saint-Petersburg
Ooh, that explains the Anastasia vibes this gives off.
Utterly captivating. Indescribable. Thanks for posting😇😵
She perfectly captured the youth, innocence and exuberance of Natasha Rostova!
It's amazing how heavily invested we grow into their relationship with how little actual screen time they have. They have such great chemistry! Definitely one of my favorite fictional couples.
smalltowngirlagb but Natasha and Andre are not meant to be in the least. He's toxic just like his father.
Gabrielle Is always singing I don't think it's that simple. Andrei is better described as "having issues"/ "troubled"
Are you talking about andrei and natashas relationship?
@@Peachypeachykeenjellybean -- Kind of, in the book he mellows a lot and changes, much like everyone does in the book.
Князь может вести себя таким образом, как в этом фильме, только в отношении кухарки ,но никак не в отношение невинной девушки благородного происхождения, еще и представленной ко двору! И пальцем нельзя было тронуть до свадьбы. И на эполеты руку, во время танца ,нельзя было положить. Уже не говоря о том, что актриса, играющая Наташу - с рублем глазу ,как, какая - нибудь, купчиха, а не графиня. А князя актер играет ,как какого - то дешевого соблазнителя, а не героя войны и романа.
Love Pierre and Natasha but goddamn my heart is always captured by Andrei and Natasha
Yes, I loved them more too
Blessed be God. Blessed be His Holy Name.
To be young and falling in love with someone who feels the same is exquisite. To not have your feelings reciprocated is devastating. Both are depicted here.
@once a musician Sorry to hear that, but she can't pretend to feel something that she doesn't. I've been in your shoes twice. it really hurts.
Reminds me the first time I met my love when I was young he was wearing completely White and carried beautiful red carnations to me. And then we danced. Today is a good day for me to have good memories for I am old now and he has gone to a better place in the heaven. But I always have beautiful memories of him
@once a musician
please what tittle of this moovie?
thanks!
You are lucky to be in love !
I have the same âge than you..and i so would to be in love another and a last time!!
@@amyaskamery7320 War and Peace.
It's pretty exquisite when you are older. Happened to me at 56. Sadly widowed 8 years later.
This waltz is a masterpiece by composer Tchaikovsky. The delicate and romantic melody perfectly captures the beauty and elegance of the era portrayed in the scene. The actors' chemistry and eye contact make the scene even more captivating.
It's a lovely piece, but the wrong period. Between the Napoleonic era and Tschaikowsky's music lies half a century. The music of Beethoven, Chopin, Strauß senior or Glinka would be the fashion in the early 19th century.
Это НЕ ЧАЙКОВСКИЙ
@@Seleuceбраво
@@user-jg8ci6oo5e
@@Seleuce A Beethoven waltz? A piece by the fetus Chopin?
If only there were balls like this today:) So stylish and romantic!
Woud be great if they were open for all 'classes', though, without ruining ones budget on a dress or suit, or uniform. And I'd probably be heartbroken because my bf would never accompany me to one of these, let alone learn how to dance the Waltz...
@The Earl of Warwick I shall not discuss the 'low class' issue with you, for we would not come to an agreement. However, the original comment said these balls should be held 'today' still, implying that modern life would still be the same, except for events and things like this one. Meaning, my bf would still be his not-dancing self with no sense for poetry or classical music.
At least in Germany and Austria, there are many formal-dress balls for New Year, the 1st of May, carnival etc. Even small villages tend to have their seasonal balls in the local town hall or the largest inn. Some of the venues are beautiful historic buildings. And as long as you do not wish to attend the Opera Ball in Vienna, the entrance fee is quite affordable. Even as a student, I did a lot of ballroom dancing and never felt it ruined my budget. Formal dress can be bought second-hand or hired. The problem rather is that mostly elderly people of a middle- to upper-class background attend because younger people are not interested. At the age of 16, boys and girls usually take their first dancing lessons to prepare for their graduation balls. But afterwards, only few continue. Dancing is no longer considered a necessary aspect of our "education", even more so as Tinder has replaced the dance floor as the space where singles make first contact. As a woman, in particular, it is hard to find a long-term dance partner for advanced lessons and balls these days. I am now living in Ireland and glad to have found a few reliable dance partners -- but all of them are my father's age.
@@MonaRenee have these balls been regressed by the migrants yet?
Well the "russian nobility" wasn't really russian to begin with, russia has been ruled by foreigners forever - a big part of their nobilitiy wasn't even capable of speaking russian, they either spoke german or french.
And let's be honest, the russians only went from one oppressive government to another, the communists weren't better (they were arguably worse imo), they killed millions of their own people who weren't going along with their political agenda, opressed minorites (including jews) and what's worse they tried to spread their misery to other countries. But going from Tsarist russia to soviet russia is like replacing the plague with cholera.
You can really read the emotions Natasha is going through while waiting for someone to ask her to dance and then when she's invited by Andrej. I loved Lily in this role, she was amazing.
Посмотрите пожалуйста экранизацию Сергея Бондарчука!
That's exactly how dances feel. Everyone else getting a partner, the anxiety rising lmao nailed it.
why did nobody ask her to dance before?
@@user-ii9oj7fi3v Стоит посмотреть. Эти две экранизации лежат совершенно в разных плоскостях. Их трудно сравнивать. Я из тех, кто сначала прочитал "Войну и мир", а уж потом смотрел разные киноверсии. И именно поэтому выбор актеров у Бондарчука мне тогда показался не совсем точным. Даже князь Андрей не ассоциировался у меня с Тихоновым, да и сам Вячеслав Васильевич, безусловно величайший актер, сомневался, что из него выйдет настоящий князь Андрей. Элен у Бондарчука вообще неубедительна. Конечно, у Бондарчука присутствует глубокая толстовская философия, впрочем в то время она в фильме показалась мне излишне нарочитой. Хотя с возрастом это ощущение пропало.
В версии 2016 попадание в образы по-моему более точное. Пожалуй, только к Наташе Ростовой есть вопросы, может быть, из-за того, что не никак не ожидал увидеть ее блондинкой. Пьер/Пол Дано, по мне, вообще лучший из всех Пьеров. Отлично сыграли старики. Очень хороша княгиня Мария.
Впрочем, Толстой потому и гениален, что дал широкое толкование восприятия образов своих героев. Поэтому это лишь мое восприятие увиденного да и прочитанного. И очень хорошо, что оно у всех разное. Универсальную версию, которая бы удовлетворила почти всех, не создать.
Russian War and Peace is very good also and actress plays all these emotions very beautifully
Мне очень понравилась эта версия "Войны и мира" Толстого. Очень трогательно) Спасибо создателям за такую чудесную картину❤
Now that many years have passed, I have to say this is the most accurate and beautiful portrayal of Prince Andrei and Natalia falling in love!!! And I actually read at least 500-pages of "War and Peace". I couldnt wait any longer and watched the miniseries. This movie actually made me a huge fan of Lily James and it's amazing to see how her career has blossomed. No matter how old she gets, whenever I see her in the movies my generation will see her as young, beautiful Natalia from War and Peace. And the music is absolutely breathtaking and it always brings a tear to my eyes to always watch these two fall in love over and over again!!! ❤
Ха-ха, 500 страниц! Толстой потел, писал, потел опять а ты не смогла читать. Я тебя успокою- редко кто из русских прочитал 20 страниц этого романа!
read the bok again cause this cast is awful
@@user-ht6dg7nz3zThis is your personal opinion. I'm Russian, but back in school I read the entire novel (three volumes) because we studied Tolstoy in our literature classes and then wrote an essay.
@@user-ht6dg7nz3z Слишком много на себя берете. Говорите от своего лица. Говорить за всех русских вам никто права не давал.
@@user-qn3hc7vb3o I have friends in Russia and now i meet a lot of them in Belgrade and i have read more Russians novels than anyone of them. I read all Dostoyevsky's book (Crime And Punishment x 3, Brothers Karamazov x 3, Idiot x 2 and everything else that he wrote), by Tolstoy (Anna Karenina, War and Peace, Resurrection, Kreuzer's Sonata, Father Sergius), Chekhov's several works, Gogol's "Dead Souls", "Oblomov"... Most of them have read a maximum of 3 of the books mentioned. It is a great pity, because the Russian classics from the 19th century are by far the best literary works in history.
I have wondered how Lily James fits so well in historical drama. The answer is she is a classic beauty. She has been in Downton Abby, Cinderella, Pride and Prejudice and Zombies and The Exception
she has been in MAMMA MIA czcams.com/video/byM1ygEdBc8/video.html
And the Dig
meh. not a perfect casting for War and Peace.
for Cinderella, she doesn't look that innocent. not as innocent looking as the Maleficent movie's Aurora.
yes
She was in Pride and Prejudice? Which version?
По-моему, самый удачный актер в этой экранизации-Пьер Безухов. Бондарчук играл эту роль в 45 лет :)
Точно! А красавице Элен у Бондарчука было не менее сорока.
Пол Дано - лучший Пьер. Даже в этом эпизоде его глаза самые выразительные.
The way she says "it's him". To know that feeling. That certainty. That bliss.
James Norton is, without doubt, one of our finest actors today…..whatever the role, he always gives 110%to the part. Always watchable,always “dishy”! Pat R.
Ah! I've always loved Tolstoy's novels. Something which has always stood out to me is how he specifically writes his"ideal" relationships so purely and so sweetly; they're nothing like the basic, solely-carnal-driven stuff we have out today.
@Noelle M Isn't Andrei and Natasha's love not quite fervent when Andrei is concerned? At the time the age gap is great and he doesn't think highly of her IQ and her immaturity annoys him. Though, ha ALWAYS TREATS HER wonderfully!!! His POV internal monologues-not so romantic. Did I miss something? Btw, I prefer these realistic portrayals of relationships.
@@mapletree3434 I'm sure he pictured all of that stuff too but it wasn't in vogue to write about carnal desires and stuff then :)
@@hunkhk Oh, it was vogue alright. Western people just don’t really understand the traditional Russian, and generally Eastern European, psyche.
@@mapletree3434 -- I think he's about 30 and she's 16 at this ball in the book.
Мерзавец он был и негодяй, ваш любимый Толстой
Love my boy Andrei's jacket
simple russian army uniform))
This is not Russian uniform It reminds lackey lieu Real Russian unifirm see in Bondarchuk film
@@acknodbikes5051 Not an army uniform. It's a specially designed ball suit.
It's farby and too overdecorated for a dress uniform of the time period.
@@flagflow1232 Dress uniforms.
I will never forget the Russian version, i was a child, it was a magic. Forever.
It actually got an Oscar as best film on foreign language
This is a quality adaptation of War and Peace. However, it has nothing to do with the great Russian novel. The director of the film took only the plot, without understanding the essence...Therefore, the film istaken as an ordinary adventure novel in an exotic setting. And the characters look like overdressed cowboys and marquee girls. If you want to understand why War and Peace is the greatest novel of the great northern empire, see the film adaptation directed by Fyodor Bondarchuk. Of course, the quality of the film is far inferior to the new digital versions, but the spirit of the series has been preserved and it will impress you from the first shots.
That and this version lie in different planes. These versions are difficult to compare. I had read War and Peace before the release of Bondarchuk's masterpiece on the screens.
In that film, Tolstoy's deep philosophy is perfectly conveyed, whilst in this film, subtle human relationships are well conveyed.
@@lavin6915 Essense of Tolstoi's philosophy? - I agree. Yet in the BBC version, difficult human relationships are well shown. This version does not look such a western-wise at all. This should be noted. If those marvellous palaces were had been restored to 1965 after the Second World War great Bondarchuk would surely show them in his film.
@@lavin6915 100%
I adore this scene the dance alone makes my heart stop every time I watch it. I do love Andrei and Natasha (Lily James is a very lucky woman :D) but at the same time when the camera panes to Pierre and you can just see his heartbreaking when he realises that the girl he has loved forever has fallen in love with his best friend - poor Pierre :'D
Yes, Paul Dano even in this scene plays so wonderful.
Leo Tolstoy is a genius!
Luda Kapkina I
I felt a streak of genius when reading Anna K. and War and Pea.
You are so right, my dear!
Was a genius, was.
read him and you will know 4 sure. No secret.
Ce fragilă e lumea noastră!Intr-o clipă, seninătatea și liniștea pot fi spulberate și atâtea vieți vor fi distruse.Gândindu-mă la războaiele care au loc in lume, imi vine in minte un pasaj din"Război și pace".Ploua peste câmpul de lluptă și parçă si natura spunea:"Opriți-vă, oameni buni!".
Какая красота! Снимали фильм в Санкт-Петербурге и в его пригороде- в Гатчине, в Царском селе в Екатерининском дворце. Когда снимали прогулку по снегу, видны декоративные перила Большого китайского моста.
Лучшая экранизация "Войны и мира" . Браво👍
One of the most beautiful scenes I've ever seen in my life ♥
I completely agree!
Sam Kay agree
The BEST ballroom scene ever imo is the 1997 Anna Karenina with Sophie Marceau and Sean Bean. Highly recommend it for Tolstoy fans!
Should watch her dance in Cinderella.
It is not the times you breathe, but the times you are left breathless.... What a profound scene.... It is hauntingly beautiful. Compliments to the producer!..
"Война и мир" Бондарчука - классика. Но эта версия заставила меня совершенно по-другому посмотреть на это произведение. Такое влюбленное, бережное отношение всей команды сериала. Какой потрясающий Пьер! И эта сцена меня заворожила... Каждый раз я плачу и восхищаюсь этим моментом жизни! Надо любить, надо просто любить и все...
Как бы потрясающие не был снят фильм Бондарчуком, но все же актеры должны быть максимально близки к своему герою по годам. Я ещё в детстве смотрела "Войну и мир" Бондарчука и то что 45-и летний Бондарчук сыграл 20 летнего Пьера меня сбило с толку. Я никак не могла понять как взрослый мужик может вести себя как ребенок. Но вот Пол Дано всё поставил на свои места. Именно юный Пьер мог вести себя так....... Именно этот фильм запал в моё сердце, неприменно молодой актер должен играть юного Пьера, а не как в нашем фильме. Пол Дано здесь на своём месте, для меня он "сделал" этот фильм. Потрясающий подбор актеров!!!
Мне этот сериал тоже очень понравился. Так красиво все передать. Они действительно прониклись нашим произведением. Операторская работа тоже на высоте. И свет и музыка.
@@user-dz4cq8qp1v «вашим». Вы его лично что ли писали?
@@kiskamashi2003 who are you?
@@user-dz4cq8qp1v i'm rasta
Every once in awhile, BBC visualizes an iconic scene from a period piece that absolutely delivers. A scenic masterpiece in choreography, editing, and acting.
i keep coming back to this video every time i'm in the mood for a little magic
Same here 😀
I'll never forget this! how can you not fall in love with all three of these people?
When I see Lilly James, I still see Rose of Downton Abbey.
She was beautiful, graceful, and exquisite in it also.
James Norton, the Prince of my dreams...
This was so magical, it took my breath away with its intense emotion, the surreal beauty, the elegance of a time long since faded into the mists of time...
Thank you for uploading this masterpiece 💖
this scene was pure magic😭😍
I love this scene, it's so romantic...sweet and dreamy. I really loved this TV serie by BBC, it was so very well done. Everything from costumes, actors and locations were simply perfect. A beautiful but sad story, I read Tolstoj's book years ago and loved it very much; he was a great writer. Russian literature is very interesting (I read quite some books), they have a great cultural heritage.
I am a Russian, and I like the BBC version. To me, Paul Dano is the best Pierre at all.
@@v24231 hi Victor, you're right...Paul Dano portrayed Pierre perfectly. He is a talented actor indeed. Loved this BBC TV serie.
PS: I'm italian.
@@nahla__ Ciao Nahla. Sono russo. È stato più di una volta in Italia. Adoro L'Italia. Amo Napoli, amo la piccola Sperlonga, non dimenticherò Ischia. L'Italia è un paese straordinariamente bella popolato da belle persone.
@@v24231 ti ringrazio :) si, l'Italia è un paese bellissimo, da nord a sud. Tante cose dovrebbero cambiare e potrebbero migliorare, ma questo ovunque...il mondo sta impazzendo. Anche la Russia è bella, vorrei visitare Mosca e San Pietroburgo un giorno.
Mi spiace per la situazione che state vivendo attualmente, la Nato non sta gestendo bene la cosa e c'è una campagna diffamatoria nei confronti del vostro popolo e presidente...gli USA vogliono governare a casa degli altri. Povera Europa....mi sembra di rileggere le pagine di Tolstoj. Un caro saluto, ciao :)
@@nahla__ Molto Grazie a Lei. Attraverso l'abisso, costruiremo sicuramente un ponte!
Benvenuti a Mosca, San Pietroburgo e Tver tra le due capitali. Ciao.
So romantic, the music....... love how he puts his hand on her back........... swoon 👍
How calm and confident is Andrei! 👏👏👏👏👏
I read thr book first as a teenager- and fell in love with Andrei!
настоящий англосакс... А Андрей Болконский русский князь
That waltz scene was so romantic! Two lovely young people in the prime of their lives enjoying a dance and each other’s company, simply
stunning🌹
Lily is such a beauty.
yes
But she isn't Nataliya Rostova
check at 0:11 and 0:18: what is wrong with those two idiots??? Natasha (Lily) is by far is the most beautiful girl in that Ballroom!!!!
Joe Bones
@Mal Vader, She may be, but not the richest.
И , все таки, рекомендую посмотреть русскую версию фильма Сергея Бондарчука» Война и Мир» , первый бал Наташи Ростовой .
Согласна с Вами. Один из моих любимых моментов в романе здесь просто испорчен.
Нет, только Савельева, Тихонов, Лановой, И только наша постановка! Только Бондарчук! Мощнейшее проникновение в первоисточник!!! Никакие американцы, британцы!
@@user-nu5yz4lb4z Get a grip
I’m completely in love of the music and the amazing jacket with silver details !!!
From the time I first read "War and Peace", I always wanted Andrey and Natasha to have a happy ending.
But reality is cruel
Alas... Yet your happy ending would not make Leo Tolstoy a genius.
Lily James is so beautiful in this, she looks just like a Princess.
Только не похожа на Наташу Ростову совсем.
OMG its too romantic
From the beat of the waltz into beats of two hearts. Lovely
Наташа и Андрей Болконский --чудо как здесь они хороши!!Сердечное спасибо актёрам, операторам, режиссёру,художникам за красивую сцену Наташи на первом бале и знакомство с Андреем!
И Пьер не менее... И еще, великолепная работа оператора.
Вы серьёзно? После Тихонова и Савельевой?!!!
@@TatyanaLACKY Я говорю больше о Пьере. Что касается Тихонова и Савельевой...
Понимаете, в далеком 1966 году в школе проходили "Войну и Мир". А у нас был великолепный энтузиаст-словесник Николай Васильевич, заслуженный учитель. Поэтому роман в классе вовсе не "проходили" с заучиванием "дуба", как это обычно бывает в школе. Тут же подоспели первые две части экранизации Бондарчука. Был организован поход в кино. В общем, Николай Васильевич, посвятил тогда два урока фильму. Вышло так, что я сначала прочел роман, а потом посмотрел фильм. Мягко говоря, фильм классом, а особенно преподавателем был встречен неоднозначно. Больше всего, конечно, досталось Пьеру: "И разве это Пьер!?" Досталось и другим персонажам. Наш словесник сразу сказал, что в роли князя Андрея куда убедительнее бы был тот же Лановой, который действительно великолепно сыграл Анатоля. (Да и сам блистательный Вячеслав Васильевич был далеко не в восторге от роли князя Андрея.) Не понравилась Николаю Васильевичу и сцена на балу: " Помилуйте, ну, почему у Наташи слезы, когда бал едва только начался? И зачем закадровый текст из романа? Без него, что, получилось бы менее убедительно? И отчего Пьер на балу, словно аршин проглотил? В книге не так, не так." Этот урок у меня до сих пор стоит перед глазами...
С тех пор прошло много лет. С годами тогдашняя критика стала мне самому казаться излишне придирчивой. И, действительно, киноэпопея оставило глубокий след и у меня. Но говорить, что лучше уже и не поставить, и не сыграть - это оставаться в плену стереотипов. Во всяком случае, в версии 2016 получился именно тот Пьер, который у меня отложился после первого знакомства с романом. Да и княжна Марья, в советской киноверсии отодвинутая далеко на задний план, здесь хороша. Даже князь Василий здесь не выглядит конченым злодеем. А ведь и Толстой увел этот образ от ходульности. Надо просто посмотреть все четыре серии киноверсии ВВС и лишь потом делать выводы.
Конечно, это лишь мое субъективное мнение. Уж не обессудьте.
Lily James is so pure and beautiful
check at 0:11 and 0:18: what is wrong with those two idiots??? Natasha (Lily) is by far is the most beautiful girl in that Ballroom!!!!
@@vader8867 yeah, but Natasha isn't beautiful actually. Lily James is, but not Natasha. Tolstoy specifically says she isn't.
Lily James is one of the prettiest and most talented actresses working today.
I saw Lily James as Juliet on the cinema screen. Boy could Lily James sing well.
Lily James as Rose in DA so gracious. I love her acting!!!
And we mustn’t forget her in Cinderella!
Mamma Mia and baby driver
She loved two men, she loved two men who were great friends, nobody criticizes this? 😭
Inmortal Leo Tolstoy! I enjoy these scenes from the waltz, it is so sweet and from James magic strength while dancing with Lily is the best and ovely couple!
Deeply regret the end of this great history!
There’s something really great about Lily James especially in ballroom scenes. In both this and Cinderella she’s so great
my god she's pretty
You may have seen her in Cinderella
Amo ❤bellooo❤
She’s Lily James! What else would she be!!
She’s pretty and versatile as well. She was in the movie Rebecca, which is a completely different type of role, but she nailed that too.
Every time I watch this, it makes me cry 😭
Costumes, music, love, one of the best waltz ever
Watching it is pain, when u know how it finished
Ленар Аюпов so true!
Definitely!
Trueeeee
I almost cried of rage when she fell for that Anatole shit after seeing this incredible scene
She was a teenager. This happens. She was foolish
"fell for that Anatole shit" isn't completely fair. Lost her head, lied to herself, tried to cover up the pain inflicted by the Bolkonsky's, these do Natasha little more justice. True, it would have been better if she were wiser. But wisdom is innocence fully developed. She gained it. Because she was innocent. Andrei should have known she was innocent. I should have known.
In the book Andrei knew Anatole as a totally vain and stupid person. Anatole was incredibly handsome and that was the only good thing about him. Bolkonsky just couldn’t stand his beloved Natasha left him for someone who deserved only despise. I guess that’s why Andrei could not forgive Natasha.
The costumes, the settings, the music, the acting all splendid
Despite the size of the book. The novel is fantastic. It is really worth reading it
I've had so much trouble to start reading it. But your message woke up my interest
@@ginamelendez6603 hope you enjoy reading it. Gripping plot
كنت ساشتري الكتاب واقلعت عن الفكرة كلامك شجعني
Reading a novel? No thank you! I prefer the novel in a dvd.😁
@@ginamelendez6603 , because it’s lost in translation. Something you cannot translate.
Oh God, this is so perfect.
Her face has so much emotion!
you should watch soviet film...All emotions you will find there!!!
I owned this movie, and I was watching all a way to the end... I was crying!
the book was published in 1869 and coming to video about it would spoil things. So why come to the video. You take that risk. It's not like the book came out a month ago.
Anna Smith he probably meant series....which is impressive
Luda Kapkina ki
Luda Kapkina I sat down at 10pm to watch the first and maybe second episode. Then I got totally sucked in and ended up watching the whole series
The name of the movie or série please
I made my resolution to read the book before I gift myself by watching this movie. Lily James is my ultra favorite actor and after seeing this I better hurry and read the book. I wholeheartedly wish her to win an Oscar some day. She also has a beautiful voice.
Ahh I remember sitting watching that, completely transfixed. Fabulous series. Another box set in my collection.
My favorite scene of the entire movie!! Beautiful! 🎉🌟🎉🌟
Laura Bolton Ehlis What movie Is this?
Maria Elkins War and Peace
Laura Bolton Ehlis same!! So heartfelt.
It's not a movie, it's from TV show
It s a book first of all.. you have to read the book it s amazing!
We need more scenes like this perfect one in our world!!!!
The book is so much better. Read it in a few weeks and i can say it is the best book i have ever read. A woumderful masterpiece!
Linda cena!
Guerra e Paz uma obra prima de Tolstoi.
Ele levou 7 anos para escrever e o romance tem 570 personagens.
Nosso fantástico Leon era não era um gênio?
what a soundtrack God!!!!
the best scene ever for the whole series. this is so memorable..
This is one of the most beautiful scenes ever filmed. ❤️
One of the most romantic moments in the cinema❤
They are so perfect together! It's a love that would have lasted throughout all time... if only Pierre hadn't come along, and Andrei didn't die!
My favorite scene! What a wonderfully shot series..
I love it when England makes these types of multi-part films. They get so deep into the characters. Love it love or love it! Keep making or remaking these films England.
Britain. This is British. Please don't call Britain, England - there is a big difference!
@@martinen.5025 we tell you Brits to not call us Yanks and y’all still do it. So don’t tell us how to speaks English when we got it down RIGHT. 😁
@@martinen.5025 England, Britain, it’s all the same thing to us Americans
My dad named me after the movie "War and Peace", thank you !!!
Es una escena magistral.
El libro es uno de mis preferidos: ¡¡ es un obra literaria de excelencia !!.
Guerra y Paz .
Orgullo y Prejuicio.
Cumbres Borrascosas
La edad de la Inocencia.
El Pájaro Canta hasta Morir.
Por Quien Doblan Las Campanas.
Lo que el viento se llevó.
Son mis favoritos, de mi amplia colección de libros.
Son tan magistrales, que mi corazón deja de latir, por sus impecables narrativas.
Desde Argentina 🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷
Hola, sabes como se llama esta pelicula?? Esta en español??
@@vanessahidalgo3338
La guerra y la Paz es una miniserie Inglesa, estaba traducida al español.
@@elenairmadinatale5234 Gracias Elena, no sabes adónde la puedo ver completa ? He estado buscando aquí en CZcams pero está versión sólo me salen capítulos cortos !!!
@@vanessahidalgo3338
Vanesa yo la vi por el canal de televisión Europa Europa.
Desde Argentina te saluda y espero puedas verla es ¡¡ muy hermosa miniserie !!
Te aconsejo ver la versión cinematografía Americana o leer el libro ( es maravilloso ). Todo lo que escribe Tolstoi es muy profundo y muestra realidades, que transforman, personas y Naciones.
Muchos cariños.
@@elenairmadinatale5234 muchas gracias Elena por toda la información brindada, por tomarte el tiempo, muy agradecida, supongo que tendré q buscar el libro, pasatiempo que me gusta bastante, y tambien voy a tratar de buscar la sería que mencionas, la Americana.. Saludos cordiales desde Costa Rica ❤ un gusto poder encontrar personas valiosas por acá ❤❤
I wish things like this could happen nowadays, so graceful and innocent
I keep going over this scene.The chemistry between Lily and James is as alluring as that between Colin Firth and Jennifer Elle in ‘Pride and Prejudice’. Super! Pat R.
Была поражена насколько глубоко и душевно был понят наш великий роман "Война и мир" режиссёром, актерами, костюмерами...Смотрела как завороженна этот сериал от начала и до конца! До слёз в конце каждой серии! Спасибо создателям этого фильма🙏
1:17-1:28 is just exquisite director work, the way it’s shot is breathtakingly beautiful...
2:05 the magic is happening ❤️. Does anyone else see the Disney stars floating around them?😄❤️❤️
Look at the pain in Pierre face😭😭😭😭😭
amazing actor...!
I have not seen a kind of pain. It's more of a tangle of different feelings. Amazing acting of Paul Dano!
Ослепительно красиво снято, игра актеров замечательная
а Вы заметили, как отличается взгляд, с которым "Штирлиц" танцевал с Наташей и в этом кадре.......
@@tamara6798 эти актёры молодые, и между ними чувствуются эмоции, в отличие от старого фильма.
@@ninamm879 да что вы говорите! Вы глаза Наташи видели в старом фильме?????? В них вся нежность и романтичность первой любви, а тут ничего не наблюдается)
@@1806tommy да просто это РАЗНЫЕ НАТАШИ ! Но ОБЕ ХОРОШИ! (в отличие от 3й французской с лицом типичной русской КРЕСТЬЯНКИ...интересно, кто предки актрисы?)))))
@@user-bs4wc6st9t для меня эта актриса осталась в роли Золушки, но не Наташи Ростовой
This is the most modern adaptation of Tolstoi’s masterpiece. It’s a BBC production at its best. Cast, Cinematography, Direction are great. I loved Norton and James especially, I have watched it again and again. I wish it were longer, many important incidents are omitted, but if I watch Natasha dancing in the wintry hut or with Count Bolkonski in the palatial mansion, I forgive the script writer. I will always cherish Audrey Hepburn’s Natasha , the BBC older production was very good for its time and more detailed, but the Russian adaptation is the best in my opinion. Still, this is an excellent series, the protagonists are fresh, dashing, they prove their talent again here. Not to be missed!
The best Natasha is undoubtedly Audrey Hapburn, the best Pierre is Paul Dano.
absolutely beautiful! I loved this series sooooo much! I don't know how much I cried at the end lol
да, Андрей Болконский как индюк,а НАТАША ТЕТКА ведь это девочка которой 16лет тростиночка да русскую душу не понять и нем более сыграть
@@user-gp4pm5wo1x А он до этого бала отчасти и был отрешенно надменным. Это у меня после первого прочтения романа осталось, когда еще фильм Бондарчука не вышел на экраны. А когда вышли первые две части, то наш замечательный словесник посвятил целый урок, у кого какие впечатления. А потом высказал свои. И, знаете, и я, и он, и еще несколько учеников не нашли игру замечательного Тихонова, соответствовавшую моим и их ожиданиям. Да и сам Вячеслав Васильевич был очень удивлен, когда ему Бондарчук предложил роль князя Андрея: "Сергей, ну посмотри на мои руки. Ну, какой из меня Андрей Болконский?"
Наташа Ростова-блондинка - для меня, мягко говоря, непривычна. Даже при той же комплекции, будь она брюнеткой, смотрелась бы тростинестей. Эх, ту Наташу Ростову/Людмилу Савельеву бы сюда... А вот Пьер Безухов/Пол Дано приятно удивил. По моему, он все время пытался расширить сценарные рамки и ему было тесно в них. Удивительный актер, принципиально уклоняющийся от голливудских соблазнов.
I love this actress. The best Natasha ever
Мне понравилась экранизация. И Пьер, и Андрей, и Наташа попали в образы. Пол Дано идеальный Пьер. Наша экранизация с Тихоновым в роли Андрея тоже очень нравится. А вот Пьер- Бондарчук не понравился. И наша Наташа-Савельева чудо как хороша. Но и английская экранизация снята с большим уважением и любовью к роману, приятно удивили.
Я думала, что это Элен и Анатолий Курагин. Очень раскованная девушка, на грани вульгарности, и довольно вульгарный парень без военной выправки.
Да, самым большим разочарованием той советской киноэпопеи стали Пьер Безухов и Элен. И образ княжны Марии получился слишком второстепенным. По мне, лучший Пьер - Пол Дано. Даже в этом эпизоде он великолепен.Эх, прокатить бы его в машине времени в 60-е... и обратно.
My favorite scene.... Andrei & Natasha are so cute and perfect dancers !
what a scene! what a play ! what a music! thank you!
El Principe Andres ....me enamore de ese personaje. Tiene los grandes valores de la epoca este Principe. Los valores que tanta falta hacen en el mundo actual. Una belleza Guerra y Paz.
Lily James and Paul Dano are phenomenal pitch-perfect choices for this. War & Peace is a novel made to be re-interpreted and re-appreciated for modern environs, and adapted and re-adapted, and I hope we’ll see some ambitious director take a crack at it the way Bondarchuk did some years in the future because man this deserves to enchant future generations that perhaps might never read the book
This is so beautiful! It looks and feels so magical!
It's so beatiful that it makes me cry! ❤ amazing interpretation of Tolstoy! 😍
Today is March 2022 and there is war going on in Ukraine so watching this brought me good memories back if someone I loved in the past who was wearing white and treated me like a gentle dove and he died in war. But it' good to have beautiful memories in the past. For maybe tonight I'll be able to sleep thinking of dancing with my past love dressed and white. My family comes from Ukraine and Germany and we know what war is about. But the beauty of love stays with you forever until you are gone in life.
The music is everything.
Most romantic scene on film ever!
Place, sounds ,actor ,actress
So Perfect!!!
My tears are watering when the waltz fades down.
Мне кажется, этим видео может восхищаться только тот, кто не видел этот же эпизод в фильме Бондарчука. Тут мы видим просто красивую картинку, а от эпизода из фильма Бондарчука любой почувствует головокружение и дрожь от сочетания музыки, танца и игры актёров.
100%. Нарциссичный Болконский и профурсетка Наташа
Вы абсолютно правы! Савельева и Тихонов - вот истинные Наташа и Андрей! Вообще, мне кажется, русскую классику способен воплотить на экране, лишь только русский кинематограф!
А ещё: разве Наташа не должна быть брюнеткой? Почему в иностранных версиях экранизаций ее постоянно делают блондинкой...
Абсолютно согласна, данная Наташа переигрывает сильно, невозможно смотреть, играет плохо, и какой этот юнец болконский?..
Is there a version of Bondarchuk’s that has subtitles in English?
Прекрасно снят фильм 👍