WHATS BETTER!? Animal Crossing New Horizons VS New Leaf…
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 01. 2023
- #shorts #nintendoswitch
LinkTree: linktr.ee/NintenTalk
10% Off your entire Gamersupps order!! USE CODE: NINTENTALK
gamersupps.gg/discount/NINTEN...
_______________________________________
Become A Member: / @nintentalk
NintenTalk Discord: / discord
Edited by: kelseyykathleen (Instagram) - Hry
HAD consistent updates.
*cries in past tense*
New Leaf was updated 4 years after.
We may get one if we are still using the current Switches in another 2 years.
@@No-One-Important-Here no, Nintendo litteraly told us that 2.0 was the last major update. Any posible update from now on will just be patches
@@thornsandrosess Nintendo has been known to change their word… who saw DLC for Mario Kart Deluxe?
I wish they would just have a smaller team for basic item additions or just more tiny things to do. New leaf seems to have way more than new horizons.
@@No-One-Important-Here the difference there is that they never said there would be no dlc
As someone who isn't really into decorating I prefer new leaf. I love the island mini games and the villagers seemed more real. Even pocket camp villagers seem to have more personality than new horizons. I still like new horizons but it just feels like a fun vacation while new leaf feels more homey.
But there's also Lloyd who you can buy some items to put outside by talking to isabelle
Ya and I miss Harv's island
@David Swope In New leaf it was a campground. Tortimer had the island.
@@tinahoefs1455 ya I miss that now you can't visit him
Yes ikr !!
When ever i go to people island in new leaf it always look so good and mine looks like i just started
I’m sorry but the only thing New Leaf comes short on is the customisation.
same i agreeee
Literally, the video listed everything great about new leaf compared to new horizons then he chose new horizons 😂
right that’s the ONLY thing lacking that the team could’ve done better. it feels like, for NH, they lost the influence and goal and mindset that eguchi had when making the first few AC games…
Yeah makes me sleepy that I can't customize
Yeah I've been looking into new leaf recently as I liked new horizons and realised that yeah there's more to it but you can barely customise anything. if you're not white then tough luck, go tanning on the beach for four real life hours if you want to look like yourself.
I think the way to compare them is that New Leaf has more gameplay options, while New Horizons has more customization. So it comes down to what parts of Animal Crossing a person enjoys more.
Customization doesn't amount to shit when you get bored of it
I’m a decorator myself so…
new leaf was just so fun, i remember begging my parents to let me stay up so i could watch kk’s shows
and i remember working at the roost and intentionally screwing up orders of people i didn’t like
and the letter i sent welcoming poncho to my town he showed me 5 years later
and crying because of resetti
Lowkey this comment got me hella emotional .. I miss the simpler times 😭
ACNL just has so much more personality & heart to it! It’s a true AC game. NH is a great game for sure & is a massive improvement for graphics & design but was poorer in all the areas NL shined in! Same franchise, 2 very different games! ❤
its not, a true ac is all about arriving in a broken down town with a strange tom nook that builds houses and a town hall. well acnh has the arriving and tom nook, but wheres tom nooks house? Why dont i have a shop from the getgo? wheres the town hall?
True I think new horizons should allow more additions of buildings on our main island...name of few from New leaf]?
NH is like the breath of the wild (and tears of the kingdom) to Zelda.
I miss the Pelican characters. I liked having an actual post office. And I miss running around doing errands for villagers.
I miss the island with all the minigames from new leaf! I feel like the multiplayer in new horizons is lacking 😖
I wish they'd implemented the island visiting from pocket camp. I don't want to coordinate with another person to visit their island. Just match make me with a random person so I can get my darn apples!
True
The dude gave 100 reasons on why ACNL is great, and only 3 on ACNH, but he still chose New Horizons as the superior game 💀
New Leaf was the first mainline Animal Crossing game I bought within the year it released. The music was calming, the player villager redesign was inspired, the animal villagers felt like they could exist in the real world and didn’t say the same dialogue line back to back. In my opinion, it was a more living, breathing world than what New Horizons gave us.
That being said, I love New Horizons, I just happen to be very nostalgic. 😅
Tortimers island was THE BEST Animal Crossing feature to THIS DAY and I will DIE on this hill.
Yes!! And catching those big ass expensive beetles on the island at night.
💯
Who picked New Leaf? 🧡
This guy, no questions asked!
I do! I like being able to put things outside… but the fishing tournaments and bug hunts are so much better in NL… and Capn’s island! I loved being able to take a vacation on a tropical island! I do like the crops and cooking in NH, but overall prefer NL!
Me I still have 3DS with new leaf!
Me✋
New horizons is better in my opinion. I have played both for a long time but acnh just appeals to me more. maybe because of how much control you have over the outside of you're island' I love decorating. New leaf will always hold a special place in my heart though.
I like New Leaf more because it had more charm to it and felt like living in a town while New Horizons feels more like a diorama simulator, more decorating than actually being a member of the community.
I love ACNL. Defenetely my favorite game of all time. Unfortunately people aren't so active anymore....
The music is what really made the games for me, so new leaf takes the cake. I do like new horizon’s clothes though, it’s way less tedious to make an outfit all at once.
New Leaf! I loved how Main Street was setup!
New leaf has more personality New horizons has more of your OWN personality
None of the villagers have any “personality” in new horizons but in new leaf the dialogue and conversations were a lot more interesting :,)
I can go on about it but it really depends on what you enjoy the most
I’d have to disagree on the dialogue part. Both games were not that good when it came to villager personalities.
New Leaf for sure. Sure, it is my first Animal Crossing game, but it is just so much better than New Horizons. It felt more rewarding to pay off Public Work Projects and finally have something outside, where as NH, you can easily buy something and call it a day. And the Gold Tools... don't even get me started on what NH did...
Honestly, I feel like new leaf has a lot more events and gameplay, it focuses more on those kind of things rather than the designing side. But with new horizons, it’s mostly the other way round. With more decorative features and less events. I think I liked new leaf because there was a lot more of experience rather than just grinding loads for certain items. I also enjoyed the feature that you could get your hair done at Harriet’s but in new horizons you did it yourself. I would take the time each day to go to her shop and I also loved the fortune cookies in Timmy and Tommy’s shop. The post office was also really nice and I loved shrinks place too, he was one of my favourite Mocs aside from pascal and scallops are also my favourite animal. In new horizons, I feel like some things were changed to be easier and more accsessable but in new leaf I liked having to go to lots of different places and explore. We also have the mini games on tortimers island in new leaf, but in new horizons, it was only happy home paradise island we had. I also for some reason like the kind of cubic ds style games, just a little preference for me sometimes.
I think new leaf is better in almost every way. The only thing new horizons has over it is better graphics. I still like new horizons but when i bpught it i wanted an animal crossing game not a village design simulator. Where is the personality of the villagers, you know the heart of the series?
New leaf hands down ! Cool itmens and the gems 💎
New leaf had far stronger writing, music and gameplay (especially when it comes to online multiplayer). It is in my opinion that it is the best animal crossing game, as it takes everything from the previous entries and fleshes them out beautifully. It released complete only receiving minor bug patches before one big update that added quite a few NEW features. As opposed to adding features all of the previous games had very slowly over the course of two years. I personally play way more new horizons but that is because I love decorating, if you don’t absolutely love decorating it is a far worse game in every way except visuals.
was the consistent updates part sarcasm ? 💀
New leaf gang
👇
I agree the music in AC new leaf, is so good, I use music from NL in my videos all the time 😁😄
I remember when everyone in NL days would complain the dialogue wasn't as harsh or interesting as past games.. wild Nintendo never listened after 7 years
For me I find the NL graphics better…? Obviously NH is objectively better with it being HD. But NL colours are more true to the past titles. The grass is a darker green, everything is saturated, where as NH had less color?? If it makes sense
thats exactly what i think and its just more cartoonish or something idk i always just liked it better too
Who picked New Horizons? ❤️
Here sir
Here! I’ve never played new leaf
@@KaylaACNH_ i recommend you at least checking out videos telling why maybe getting it. 3ds’s Eshop is about to close, so u may find it a good idea!
Here :)
Here! Never actually played new leaf
In New Horizons Nintendo sucked out everything great about Animal Crossing, NL is the best.
"we have consistant updates "
moments before disaster:
I genuinely don't care about terraforming and decorating the city. New Leaf had so much to do and was actually fun to play. It felt alive.
We need a game that combines both
We need a game with parts of new leaf & new horizons
If the next AC game mixes the town evolution and upgrades from NL with the “start from scratch” and customization from NH, it will blow both games out.
I love New Horizons, but it’s NL by a landslide
I miss working at the coffee shop...
The villagers in new leaf were definitely a love/hate relationship for me.
I used to play new leaf on my brother's 3ds and since he was the mayor he set up a house for me cuz at the time of playing I was pretty young. So I just went out and befriended several villagers, but my bff was Blueberry by far. Then came Halloween, when she ruined my special clothes by throwing mud at it and I got so sad I cried and my brother bullied her for me until she left but didnt tell me till years later, just saying she left by herself. I still hate her till today tbh.
Also Blanche once came up to me FUMING bc my brother asked in a letter if she was a duck or goose and she angrily told me to tell him she was a SWAN, not a goose or duck, and it was hilarious.
What the fuck
I think a neat idea for the next Animal Crossing is the option to pick any song according to the hour from any animal crossing game for every hour.
For example, say I don’t like the 5pm music in the next animal crossing. I go to my nook phone and I choose “change music” and go down to 5pm and select “new leaf” for 5pm.
I really enjoy ACNH and I don't think New Leaf will get this high in my love... but I really enjoy it from time to time
Never know your next move
-pocket camp
I hope the next animal crossing isn't on an island, it was fun for this one to be different but I miss the Og style tbh and I hope we can go back to something like thst (especially with the train station at the back)
I hope they make new leaf remake with new horizon's graphics
My biggest complaint about NH is how everything feels so barren just to you to mess up with the whole "city planning" idea. They could just expanded the NL mayor capacities in the late game.
But in NH you're essentially GOD and you choose what to do and not.
I love both games, new horizions for the decoration and all of that, new leaf for the tiny nostalgia that I have from like 2019 or 2020
I feel like even after the update, new horizons just doesn’t have a lot of content. It’s almost only about decorating, but to me animal crossing has always been so much more than that. So in terms of gameplay, new horizons is seriously a downgrade from new leaf 💔
i like new leaf, you can actually be mayor, and in new horizons, your more of a community service worker than a mayor, and the term "island" makes you feel more isolated, and town just feels more better, i don't like being totally isolated, even know there is a low pixel count, the game just ROCKS! and the villagers have more personality, and you can make your island like north korea in new horizons, and i don't like that, villagers can't leave the island without your permission, and in new leaf they can leave and move in when they want, (well, that kind of stinks when you have rare villagers, so i'm gonna split that point between new leaf and new horizons) so final score: 3.5/0.5, new leaf wins!
And new leaf Isabelle didn't sound like a dying rat when she was singing
New leaf is one of the most important games to me period. The amount of personality is each of the villagers and npcs had me grow so fond of each of the villagers merits. The only part of new leaf that I never liked was the fact that villagers can leave without asking you. I guess it’s more realistic but as a child the most traumatic thing to ever happen to me (not rlly lol but still) was when my most adored villager O’hare left my town 😭😭😭 I have him now on new horizons but he just isn’t the same. New leaf had so much personality in each character I loved them so much. New horizons mostly puts an emphasis on physical appearance really. People only care about villager looks, and it’s easy to see why when all these villagers talk the same!!!! New horizons just feels too modern and simple. Idk those are just my thoughts😭 my favorite part of animal crossing was the relationships I built with my characters although I did love the decoration aspect
New Leaf had a better story line and depth of play. ACNH has more decoration aspects. Both good games but I would prefer ACNH mechanics with the depth of ACNL.
The only reason why New Horizons will always be better is the fact that we can place items outside
I feel like if animal crossing and new leafs good stuff combined it would be the best ac game.
From someone who discovered AC with New Horizons and went back to try New Leaf, I agree with many others saying that New Leaf just has so much heart 💓 New Horizons wins in so many areas but it is disgusting how good New Leaf still is. I really hope that the next one is a perfect blend of NL and NH, then our souls will be happy 🥰
Also, you can only be white in new leaf. Did NOT help with my self image back in the day 😂
How I think the next animal crossing should be is keeping everything in new horizons with better graphics and more furniture and other cool stuff but add more things to make villagers and NPC’s more interesting because when I’m bored in the game I like talking to villagers but if they did more interesting stuff then it would be so cool just imagine watching your villagers interact with stuff on your island and overall just having a life there instead of walking around and occasionally sitting down on a chair or singing
I really think this opinion may vary between those players who don’t care that much about personalization and are rather more immersive with villagers/npc’s and those who love flexing their creativity the most. I find myself being a bit more identified with the last group :)
I'll say it this way:
New Horizons is a better game, but New Leaf is A BETTER ANIMAL CROSSING.
I love the fact that you can get more than 10 custom design slots in ACNH, and how you can place furniture outside, New Horizons has better-looking (graphic-wise not design-wise) villagers, and I like jow you can choose whether your island is in the Southern hemisphere or Northern hemisphere.
However, New Leaf has better dialogue (Purrl was spreadsheet gossip about Gayle and Ribbot being a couple), and the town tree in ACNL was adorable, but one thing I miss most about ACNL is the island tours on Tortimer's island.
New horizons is better, because its 7 pm song is more relaxing, but New Leaf's 7 pm song is so creepy
ACNL! Horizons was great over lockdown, but I realised that having restrictions made being creative more fun!
I never played NL but I played WW and PG, and NH.
Honestly all the games are magic because you can use them as tools for divination, and your layout makes a difference.
Honestly I’m just happy that Animal Crossing now gives you a whole island. The next one should be an MMORPG.
The Dialogue and music in New Horizons is the only things that pulls it down for me 😪
As someone who even loved designing, I still like new leaf better! It was far more difficult to obtain money for furniture in new horizons. Not to mention the number of wallpapers and furniture items that got taken out of new horizons. New horizons has no soul, no heart. It’s just appearances and even then it lacks to me.
New Horizons was the first AC game I've ever played, and I love it so much. But I got New Leaf on X-Mas and I have been obsessed with it. I really can't choose.
If you have a gamecube I highly recommend trying the og animal crossing
I don't mind the customization limits in new leaf actually; I feel it allows more room for creativity in what you can do to make your town look nice and it gave it more personality
New leaf
New horizons. But I do wish we had all the gimmicks new leaf had in new horizons, it would be everything!!!
New Leaf was my first Animal Crossing game. No joke, it literally taught me how to spell when I was a kid (almost every word, phrase, or social skill I have is all because I learned it from New Leaf). That’s why I’m thankful I didn’t grow up with Wild World lol, if I did I’d probably be walking around calling people Coconutters or something
I miss errands! I miss the npc's! I miss the island and the minigames! I miss the shopping districts, the different shops, the good music (I'm sorry but the New Horizons' hourly music SUCKS. Lacks personality everywhere, not a single memorable fun track.)... There are just WAY less variety of things to do. New Leaf felt like developing a very lively town, while New Horizons just feels like an empty blank canvas you can customize to your liking to make it look cute. That's all, it really is lacking in every other field... Still a very nice game tho.
I think New Horizon's only qualifies that make it better than new leaf are the graphics and outdoor customization, but pretty much everything about new leaf was better. Better music, more special npcs, could work at the cafe, more store upgrades, the island mini games, better dialogue, more house customization options. The constant updates new horizons got were stupid as well because they were just adding all the stuff that should've been there from the very beginning. New horizons was just a shell of a game when they first released it. This has not stopped it from being one of my most played games ever though :/
Honestly: if I could have New Horizons graphics and gameplay but New Leaf NPCs and setting, I’d have the perfect Animal Crossing game.
If new horizons and new leaf combined a lot of what made their stuff really standout I’d be so hyped. The character customization in NH and the town feel and all the shops in NL is what I really loved about both. I play both now that I finally got my hands on NL lol
Awesome video!!
"Consistent updates" LMAO. NH is a decorating simulator.
Omg in new leaf I remember having a tent for like the longest time
I like New Leaf more since it was a really fun game and a big part of my childhood
New Leaf holds a special place in my heart because my Mom and I one hundred percent completed it together, she passed away 27 March 2020 :/ she never got to play new horizons
I feel like new horizons could’ve had a lot more updates, since it just gets….old after a while
Did you know you can beep the horn in the rv and anyone outside can hear it in New Leaf..also to me, they are tied. They are both really amazing games!
The only plus to New Horizons is graphics and island decorating. It has practically no content. New Leaf wins, hands down. It’s not even close.
I feel like new leaf just has more to do and I don't like the designing your island focus of new horizons. Liked it more simple in new leaf
New Leaf
>New Horizons
>consistent updates
LMAO
Animal Crossing went from a friend simulator to a dollhouse simulator.
Don’t matter which is better. Since the internet is going away after April we’ll be forced to play the switch version if we want to invite people over
Whilst I love NH more than NL, I do however miss the music which was way more better, I miss working in the cafe, I miss the third upgrade of Nooks as well as Gracie.
If all the above were included in NH it would be phenomenal!
We were very restricted in NL when it came to decorating our town. The fact that we have terraforming, growing crops, cooking and being able to decorate inside our villagers home and Paradise Island is what tips the scales more to NH for me. ❤❤
They should port this to the switch
My biggest gripe with NH is them introducing updates that came in the base game of NL. Like swimming. That was just embarrassing to watch them pretend it was so brand new.
My second biggest gripe is decorating the outside of the island is actually an overwhelming task and I quickly got annoyed by terraforming.
My third biggest gripe is they removed furniture sets!!! I loved collecting sets and when they took it away I felt like I lost a huge reason to play! The Nooklings' store sucks in comparison too, I feel like I see the same few items over and over.
My final big gripe is I hate crafting in any game and it didn't belong in Animal Crossing. Tools breaking is the dumbest thing ever. They made this big deal about more pocket space only to force me to fill it with crap for crafting when I needed it.
I like NL better. Ironically I'm more relaxed as a mayor than the Island Resort Rep.
the only bad thing about new leaf is not being able to choose where villager's houses go
idc about decorating outside tbh, so for me new leaf is better
New leaf has my heart. And soul
Also, if you have New leaf NPC's amiibo cards, you can invite ALL of them into Happy Home Paradise to create a home for them ( Shrunk, Katie etc. )
Uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, you kinda forgot Kappin's Island tour minigames and the ability to meet random people who were also currently playing.
New leaf juat because of shrunk
I miss the villagers u could get that were crossovers like wolf link or the squid sisters
If you could place items outside in new leaf it wouldn’t even be a question at all. I do like both games though.
I would honestly argue against the consistent updates that you mentioned in favor of New Horizons. This resulted in a game that was somewhat unfinished at launch.
One thing I don’t like about acnh is the repeated dialogue- but I’ve never played any other ac games, so I’m not sure if the earlier games also have repeated dialogue
Consistent updates shouldn't be a point, as they're all features that should've been in the game day one.
I feel like people who played both would choose New Leaf mostly because of the nostalgia factor.
I don’t think I really get to speak on the subject. ACNH was my intro to the series and the only game I’ve played in the series lol
please try new leaf !!
Honestly if New Horizons came with all the updates they added those few years down the line I’d probably love it more, but New Leaf was a complete game for me, so I loved it more. It had or felt like it had more to earn, so, see, etc.
I miss online island
i currently play new leaf on my 3DS and have only ever played that and city folk. from personal experience, new leaf is the best. from seeing other people play ACNH, definitely that.
All animal crossing game i love animal crossing
honestly i think combining the best aspects of both games would be amazing
the characters from new leaf and their personality, the island mini games plus new horizons customisation etc (also wild worlds music haha)