सबा नकवी ने सुनाए अटल आडवाणी से लेकर मोदी और शाह तक के किस्से | The Lallantop
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 08. 2018
- Saba naqvi book shades of saffron, qitaabwala, Lallantop book review and author talk series. Saba naqvi talks about atal and advani, structure of pmo and bjp during atal-advani era. Tussle between atal and advani in nda days. Role of Pramod Mahajan in atal government. Pramod Mahajan bjp fund manager. How narendra modi beame strong after Pramod Mahajan. What was arun jaitley’s role in it. Uma Bharti left bjp, why.
Hows amit shah and narendra modi’s bjp different from its earlier avatar. Narendra modi will contest 2019 general elections on these key issues. Saurabh dwivedi, editor Lallantop talks to saba naqvi
Install The Lallantop Android App: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
Like The Lallantop on Facebook: / thelallantop
Follow The Lallantop on Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Radhe shyam
Madam ji,
You should have been discussed your business of media. People are either pro-BJP or Anti-BJP. There is very few journalist who are balanced and loyal for journalism.
ये तो बहुत अच्छी बात है कि अब भाजपा में आपस की मतभेद खुले में नहीं आती,मीडिया से दूरी रखने के बाद।शायद सबा जी को मसाला नहीं मिल रहा,पर असलियत यही है कि मीडिया से दुरी बेहतर रहे तभी अच्छा है,पार्टी के लिए भी और देश के लिए भी क्योंकि इन्हीने खुद कहा उस समय भी न्यूज़ प्लांट होती थी,और आज तो मामला इतना बढ़ गया कि personal agenda लेकर चलते है पत्रकार।
मीडिया को देश और संस्कृति से कुछ लेना देना नहीं।किसी भी देश हित के विषय का इनको कुछ भी ज्ञान नहीं होता ,बस बक बक बेच कर मौज करना चाहते हैं. और कुछ नहीं. अब ये दाल गल नहीं रही तो अपने नाम के मुताबिक, लल्लन टॉप,और इसका बड़बोला, सौरभ जैसा बक बकी अपनी मूर्खता पेश करने से बाज नहीं आता. ये तो इसका बस नहीं चल पा रहा और कोई मुद्दा नहीं बना पा रहा वरना ये तो हिजड़ों की तरह सड़क पर कूद फांद करते मिलेंगे.
Yeh bilkul galat baat hai...sarkar janta ne chuni hai...janta ka sawaal poochne ka aur jawaab haasil karne ka bhi hak hai...
Jahaan tak Personal Agenda ki baat kahi aapne, bilkul sahi keh rahe hain aap...TV toh bekaar ho gaya hai...khud research kijiye aur information nikaaliye aur fir khud decide kijiye ki kya sahi hai aur kya galat...
i am watching this after 23 may 2019...see how much entertainment i am getting..lmao..pure comedy..
First I was amused why saurav is inclined towards anti bjp/rss ideology having studied in rss school upto 12th class. Then I got to know he is also from JNU. Quite understandable.🤐☺
Nirmala Sitaraman too is a JNU product, denounces ur theory.
@@ambalalchauhan3098 there are very few exceptions like her in fact, shes the only exception.
Great discovery,salute to you.
He's not any BJP. Tough questions must be asked to rulling govt
Thanks for the valuable information and rest about Anti - BJP agenda , that will not work with due respect.
8
@Kaifi @@lakshmiduttsharma5928 t u t
Nice
Great information.
Typical Andhbhakt identified
मैम ने खुद स्वीकार किया है कि पहले न्यूज नेताओ द्वारा प्लांट की जाती थी... पत्रकार भी अपने फायदे के हिसाब से न्यूज प्लांट करते थे.... हर चीज को तोड़ मरोड़कर पेश किया जाता है और इसी मे मैम के पश्न का जवाब भी है कि मोदी क्यो इतना मीडिया से दूरी बनाके रखते है...
@@ShaktiSingh-uf7ho bhai sahb hamesh shalinta men apna paksh rakhen aur badzubani kissi se bhi na karen specially mahilaon se
Raha sawal itna bada debate men kuchh khas jankari ya muda dekhne ko nahin milla is umid men k ab kuchh jyada ya khas batlaya jaega ham itna time dekhte rahe lekin aissa laga k itni baten janne ke liy 5 minutes sufficient the.Lalan top se request hai ke progrrame karne men rochakta to hai but informative rather material informative nahin laga
Ajay ji, aapne shaayad dhyaan se nahi suna ki story plant BJP walo ne hi karwayi thi aur fir mukar gaye they.
@@tulsidasshewani6146 aap ko nahi lagega madam ji kyonki gambhir muddon ko gambhir log hi samajh sakte hain.
In log pehle radia tapes k thru journalism main bdhabbe lagaye hain, yeh journalism chhod k ministerial berth fix karte firte the... Abb ko poochta nahin inko
@@sumitroshan7240 aap tho gambir ho gaye🤣🤣🤣🤣
'Family ko touch nahi karna' narrative is not something I agree with. I think anyone who is corrupt should be exposed, as Modiji is doing.
Very good interview, cleared my perception towards Saba.
सवा करीम की बाते सही हैं।
बहुत लगा उनको सुनकर ।
लज्जा पुस्तक की लेखिका तस्लिमा जी के साथ सौरभ द्विवेदी जी को लल्लन टॉप पर सनना पसंद करूंगा।
Aahaa maza aa gaya media ka dard samajh aa gaya...ki pm inko bhav nahi dete,,😅 accha he pm media ke upar aam logo ko prefer kar rahe he.
Members of Luteans (लुटियन्स) Journalist was paid for doing lobby generation. Modi was well versed with it. So he kept all this paid journalist away from him. The way दलाल culture in all ministries...
Tujhse kaun sa mil raha hai modi ??
idiot
Sham Gandhi yes and he satrted paying to zee, India TV, and Arnab instead.
Dictators also did not prefer free media or free press. Modi is arrogant and dictatorial. I hope India will get rid of the duo ASAP.
Sourabh Diwedi enjoying being part of Lutyens Media in lap of Congressi India Today group.
Keep it up, carry on.
God bless you.
Someday you will have realisation & will be ashamed of yourself.
chup dufr, republic dekh jaake
@@preetsingh6794 jnu se ho babua 😀
India Today is congressi??? Hahahaha
किताबवाला से मैं काफी प्रभावित हू आपके इस इंटरव्यू से मेरी राजनीति और उस को कवर करने वाले पत्रकारों की प्रति समझ बढ़ी है आपका बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद
Aur kabhi Anuj Dhar Ko bhi bulaiye.
People like Anuj Dhar are dedicating their life to find the truths but not interviewed even by the lallantop!!
Kartik Sharma yuppp you are right he give so much information about netaji subhash chandra bose or gumnami baba
I have already raised one request to @Saurabh diwedi ji and forward him few links. He promised me too check it when he will have time, but still i am waiting for his response.
@@ujjwalgreen123 let's see. I have never seen them review a debutant writer. And they mostly review memoirs, not researches on suppressed history
Maybe they won't take a risk of going against their parent company!
😊@@kartiksharma7674
what I understand from this interview is that journalists and journalists only have the problem with present govt. as saba said there is no Maza in present PMO. what is Maza?
As you assess and cross question to politicians so you should do also to journalists. Why journos should always be at asking side? They also should be put in answering place.
Because journalist are not elected representatives!!
You fool it is the beauty of democracy that journalists must be in asking side and govt must must be in answering side. People have not voted for media it is not the duty of media to answer politicians. Seriously what the garbage thing you are saying??
Definitely yes Yogesh ji .It is people and not the media that has voted them .
पहले के पीएम मीडिया से ज्यादा जुड़े होते थे, आज का पीएम जनता से ज्यादा जुड़ा है। इसलिए मीडिया को दिक्कत हो रही है।
hehe nahi press conference ka naam sune ho? Janta se judne ka pehla step hota hai
Democracy is for the people by the people and for the people. Modi Ji interacts directly with common people bypassing the paid media & thats most important .....
Its १०००% true
He not has courage to face real media he believes to interview cheap channels like zee news and people like Akshay Kumar
Kaunsi duniya mein hain. All policies are dictated by and for Adani Ambani
BJP IT cell 😂😂😂😂
😇👍
Saurabh is too good and very impressive.. Really liked the interview..
Why there is brahmin bashing all the times. If brahmin are efficient since vedic times thats not thier fault even a shudra or vaishya can be a brahmin if he is well learnt.
The fact is Brahmins deteriorated their stand due to self imposed restrictions, support from the wealthy class and that led to egoistic attitude and their downfall. They misread the meaning of Brahminism. They believed " brahmin by birth" and wearing the sacred thread- Janau- their birthright. They forgot " brahmam janati-iti brahmanah" adage. Never encouraged the lower cast to come up by learning and educating, which was their prime duty from ages. And politics of hatred and decide and rule was already existed from Ramayana Mahabharata era- Parasuram episode- Karna episode- Ekalabya episode to name a few.
@@subir1962 crores of brahmins have sacrificed for the nation unlike the abrahamics which came to divide,rule and loot the nation,Showing fake sympathy towards the low caste.Its the brahmins or other savarna who have been working and studying hars day and night,getting jobs,paying huge taxes to the government to bring the lower caste in the main stream.The first school in dia for women was given by a brahmin to Mahatma Phule in Pune itself.
I was a great fan of Pramod Mahajn, and Modi was his protege. I wonder, if Pramod was not killed, whether Narendra Modi would have become a such an important figure in BJP? He was a PM material, and would he have become a PM one day or not, is a matter of discussion and debate.
It wouldn't matter. Pramod Mahajan could never win Lok Sabha seat on his own. And Mahajan was weaker compared to Modi when it came to mass base.
Issues in 2014 road,electricity,water,corruption
Issues in 2019 press freedom,press confrence....
really???
True Jain Saab ...
True
This was awesome interview.. the lallantop is doing fabulous work. I ordered this book after watching this interview.
Bahut ache jankari di saba di ne
This "Muslim" lady is obsessed with "Maharashrian Brahmins"...
Explain
Your "ignorant" ass can explain why her muslim part was so visible to you
Yeah,bcoz the greatest of Patriots and most knowledgable were born in Maharashtra especially Pune.
When she said BJP needs to get 100 seats for Nitin Gadkari to be prime minister that's where this interview lost all the credibility and logic.
How What wrong she said ??
सौरभ भाई आप की राजनीतिक जानकारी और उचित स्थान पर उचित शब्दों के उपयोग ...लाजवाब लाजवाब!!!
One of the best and honest interviews I've seen in your channel, impeccable trivia!!
I think you should employee Saba as a consultant.
I absolutely adore your interviewing style Saurabh, I think you should circulate related links too, some of us really like to read all the related trivia too.
Note to Indians... Dont be impressed so easily. Take everything with mountain of salt. Do your own research.
We can not trust any media company these days.. Everybody has their agenda.
I agree
Pinki ji , request to you dont go by the smooth talk these people do here. Their motives cant be understood so easily.
I agree
Pinki Choudhury I will not call you Innocent but more innocent like stupid. Reason behind that is you don't understand this media and you will never understand Ms. Saba, she has her agenda to favor Pakistan so listen all news media and you will learn their agenda against India.
Saba naqui analysis is similar to those in CID serial where one smells a Sox and finds who is the killer!! Grow up guys, get some job
Very entertaining though!
Whatever she's saying, finding it true and relevant.
Finding Kashfur Good enjoy. It’s entertaining
धन्यवाद सौरभ जी! किताबवाला सीरीज़ एक बेहद दिलचस्प और ज़रूरी कार्यक्रम है जो आज के दौर की भारतीय और खासकर हिंदी मीडिया की धुंध में उम्मीद की किरण जैसी है. सबा जी के साथ ये बातचीत भी बहुत रोचक और जानकारियों से भरी रही. पर हाँ ये बात ज़रूर है कि किताब के बारे में बातें कम हुईं. राजनीतिक बात चीत का लालच 'किताबनामा' के दौरान थोडा त्यागना होगा क्योंकि अक्सर बातें किताब के विषय से हटकर व्यक्ति के अनुभवों पर केन्द्रित हो जाती हैं. इस दृष्टि से आपने जो बातचीत पियूष बबेले जी से की है वो हमें ज्यादा बेहतर लगी. बाकी आपको और सबा जी , दोनों को अच्छी किताब और बेहतरीन बातचीत के लिए बहुत बहुत बधाई!
What a great interview 😍🤞🏻👍🏻 really enjoy it 👌🏻🙏🏻🤗✌🏻
Very nice interview...it enhance my knowledge about BJP... thanks for the interview
सौरभजी , एक बार ओर धन्यवाद ... पार्टी के फ़ॉर्मेशन से आज तक का सफ़र ओर आपकी बीच बीच में टिप्पणी ... नई जेनरेशन के सामने एक सचाई पेश करेगी ... साधुवाद 💐💐💐
Excellent & truthful interview. I will gona read this book 🙏🌈👌😊💐💐
Very good interview 👍
Agreed with Saba's views.
मैं डॉलर की बात पर सहमत नहीं दुनिया में सारी करेंसी नीचे गिर रही है अगर सिर्फ रूपया नीचे गिरता तब मैं मानता कि भूचाल आ रहा है रुपए में
why should not wary about rupaiya value because India is jarardash growing country ..
@@kumarsushant3247 भाई मुझे जबरदस्त अंग्रेजी नहीं आती
Sachchai ye hai ki US Dollar sabhi independent currency ke mukabale majboot hua hai.
Agar aap compare karenge to dekhenge ki pichhle 4 saal mein INR majboot hua hai EURO, Canadian Dollar, British Pound aur Australian Dollar ke muqabale.
tb 2014 ke pahle kewl india ka rupya girta tha,☺️☺️
Currency against US Dollar, past year.
Venezuela: -2,300,000%
Sudan: -168%
Argentina: -75%
Turkey: -73%
Angola: -62%
Iran: -30%
Brazil: -29%
Ethiopia: -18%
Pakistan: -16%
Tunisia: -15%
Russia: -15%
Sweden: -13%
Myanmar: -11%
Nepal: -10%
India: -9%
By IMF
इतनी अच्छी बातचीत के लिए शुक्रिया आप दोनों को।
बहुत ही अच्छा इंटरव्यू। सबा , मैं आपको लेकर बहुत ज्यादा सकारात्मक राय नहीं रखता हूँ। लेकिन इस इंटरव्यू में अपने खूब अच्छे से रखा। मैं आपकी साफगोई से प्रभावित हुआ। मैंने स्वयं बहुत कुछ वैलिडेट किया और आगे की सोच को परिस्कृत किया।
Congratulations for 3M
One of the best interview in recent times. This was more like a discussion between two learned people
Tc
Worth watching.Thanks Lallantop and Saba Naqvi
Amazing knowledge ...Saurav ! The way you approach to a question is absolute thrill and almost story telling.Indeed surprised to know the details about an individual likes of Brijesh Mishra and Uma Bharati.
This is what you call high quality content. Kudos lallantop! Zordar zabardast zindabad!
very dull interview....she loses train of thought frequently.... doesn't remember the point she wanted to make
I like the Kira wall and duniyadari very much. I live in USA. Came as student in USA 1967.
Nice to hear you still have interest in indian channels and Hindi language. You can analyse India and prospects of India to become superpower . You can add something so that indian senario can be changed. Do share your thoughts.
All throughout the conversation I thoroughly enjoyed the in-depth knowledge of Saurabh more than Saba Naqvi.
Saurabh your passion towards politics shows your political awareness.
The importance Marathi Brahmjn is given in the interview and Delhi makes me feel astonished as we are just 2% for Sharad Pawar in Maharashtra! Thanks Saba Naqvi!
Saurabh aap ek acche politician hai.
Wow - what a conversation..
Love this informal chats which gives insights to that time politics.
Sabaji is very diplomatic person. I especially thanks many events cover Atal Ji period and Pramod Ji
Good interview. Main Saba Naqvi ki baat se sahmat hi.
कुच निकला नही... फीर भी अच्छा इंटर्व्ह्यु..
धन्यवाद लल्लनटाॅप
bahut sahi se 2019 election points diye..
Saurabh Dwivedi....very good narration and articulation skills.....ur shows are always very informative, clean and precise....
Bhai jitna complicated hamari party ko bataya ja rha h utna nahi h 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
batane k liye danyabad, pr aakhe mund kr jina achhi baat nahi.
Ye Psuedo Intellectuals baithe hein. Apani fantasy aur imagination ko duniya per thopane ki koshish karate hein.
Bhai ye aise hi bahas kr rha hai, Modi G will again win in 2019 with 400+ seats
@@sunil17685 bjp naam sunker hassi ati hain
@@devgupta5492 naaa g desh ab rana a haya hain , next pm will be educated , intelligent , intellectual shashi tharoor
द्विवेदी जी आप जिनका इन्टरव्यू कर रहे हैं, उन्हें थोड़ा अधिक समय दे।
धन्यवाद
lol
I feel the same
I agree, otherwise some interesting discussion.
He is Chela of Karan Thapar, will not let Guest speak.
@@A29305456 congratulations with your communal thought process
26:19 - Saurabh bhaiya proves yet again - what an encyclopedia he is...wish India had more reporters like Saurabh...
i liked it ! Just bring her back if you can ... really appreciate it!
बहुत आनंद आया सर जी
कोई कांग्रेस की किताब नहीं छप
रही है क्या ?? कुछ कांग्रेस की भी बात हो जाये कभी अगर मूड हो तो आपका
Mayank ji ye dil se bjp k hai fir congress par story kaise kar sakte hai
Tu kharidega ?
If congress ki Kitab print hogi to sirf Scandal and loot mar ka news hoga.
Advaniji ko rashtrapati kyon nahi banaya gaya is par video banaiye
Kovind ne dhaka mara ab pakistan ke ban sakta hain imran
N
Age factor
Kyuki wo modi ke tattu na hote
arpit garg theek baat
One of the best interview I have seen. Few interviewers are left who ask questions to get something new out of the guest.
Every person looks back at past and say those time were good.... Nostalgic
Madam ji abko Bjp ke struggle me maja atatha lekin success me nahi ata. Achhi bat he,jo kam karte he woh bejaha snan sabab conference nahi karte. Jai Hind
SAROJA PANDA sabne malai khai hai congress ke time pe
Sahi bol rhe ho bhai
Next pm rahul gandhi yes or no
@@gautamtripathi2007 rahul n pm impossible
Nahi madem ji bharatiya rajneeti me impossible kuch bhi nahi
Iska matlab ye nahi ki mai modi ji ko pasand nahi karta next pm 5year ke leye unhi ko hona chaeye
Lekin bjp ka hindu kattar wadita wala swarup aacha nahi lagta jo ki bjp nahi dikhana cahati
Apka ky rai hai rip
किताबवाला के सारे एपिसोड अच्छे रहते हैं बहुत कुछ जानकारी मिलती है देश का राजनितिक इतिहास पता चलता है।
मुझे इस किताब के हिंदी अनुवाद का इन्तज़ार है। किताबों का कोना बहुत ही आवश्यक है। प्रजातंत्र में जनता को कुछ हद तक राजनीतिक ज्ञान होना चाहिए जिससे वो सही फैसला ले सके,अपना भी दायित्व समझ सके। इस तरह के किसी किताब के बारे में जानकारी दें।
Best episode..Congratulations Sourabhji..And To Saba Naqvi too for candid views
Excellent interview, Sourabh ! You will go a long way ! God bless you always ! 👍
So happy Modi keeps the Pressitutes out of PMO.
Enjoyed your discussion with Saba Naqvi. Maany interesting things were never heard of. Best wishes to you both.
You can write to PM..I am not journalist.. Regularly I am writing to our Beloved PM
Sanjay Baru sir ki ek interview please...
assam zindabaad... arnab zindabaad...saba apne aap ko bohot bada journalist samajta hai.
Simply grt interview.. Keep it up
It's awesome Saurabh Bhai, Pls aise hi series Continues karte rahe ,
These people tried and tried to bring the caste factor to stop bjp, but people saw through the bluff
No sanjay baru was right. and sometimes moral value dont work, if your country is at stake. Everyone should come out if he see something against INDIA
Excellent Saurabh keep it up u r d one saver of real democrocy friend
Nice conversation with Sabaji.
Got to know many things.
Nice story
Is pure Interview me Kon Kon kis jaat ka hai ye batane ke liye Kiya gaya..
Would like too see more such in-depth shows about issues, people and parties.
Very good interview with saba,we learn about India politics.
Both the interviewer and the interviewee made the conversation very interesting and absorbing.Looking forward to watch many more such interviews!
Bu gr
khud ka nuksan hua toh bjp bura..😂😂😂🤣
I have started enjoying your interview Superb 👌
Excellent interview
Saba Mam is talented journalist, being very soft, calm, cultured. Dwivedi ji I appreciate your knowledge. Saba Mam also pointed somewhere in the interview about your memory. Great.
My compliments on a good and entertaining episode.
Please read rajiv malhotra's books on indian mind sciences and indian culture and do a discussion. He has written a lot of books on indian traditions and thoughts and i think he deserves to be heard widely. I feel Lallantop discussions shouldn't always be on political matters.
Thanks.
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
स्वर्गीय अटल बिहारी जी का राजनैतिक सफर साफ़ सुथरा रहा है..लेकिन अडवाणी का तो हमेशा विवादों के साथ रहा है.
Bjp Bhai ram Yatra ke Baad hi khdi hui
Atal ji ka Safar Saaf-authra isliye tha kyunki wo seedhe seedhe kisi aandolan se Jude huye nahin the.
Advaiji ka Naam vivaad se jyada hua isliye tha, kyunki wo actually ground pe apne haath maila karte the party ke hit ke liye
Hinu kattar wadita ke kaarn adwani shab ko viwad jhelna pada
Jo atal ji me nahi tha
Gautam tripathi par mitra, us tathakathit kattar-wadita ke Bina BJP kabhi 96, 98 mein sarkar hi nahin banti
Sayad 2019 ka election bhi esi mudye pr lada jay jo ki galat hai
Mera manna hai ki hamare desh me kattar panthi nahi hona chaeye
Excellent interview!
Very interesting n bold discussion with Saba mam
Sir kabhi Sanjeev Sanyal Ko bhi bulaiye. His hindi seems to be weak but his books make a better informed citizen!!!
Why don't u write a book on congress too saba..."no shades of congress at all:from 1947 to 2014-The Gandhi's"
All the best Sabah Naqwi Ji.SabahJi is Highly influential , experienced , sober Journalist , great interview Saurabh Ji ! 😊
सौरभ जी पहले तो आपको बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद।आपके ज्ञान की पराकाष्ठा इतनी कि वर्तमान में मैं आपकी तुलना किसी से नही कर सकता।मेरा आपसे अनुरोध है कि झारखण्ड के एक आदिवासी लेखक A.K. Pankaj है आप उनकी कोई इंटरव्यू जरूर चलाएं।और दूसरी ये कि पोलटिक्स पे आप खुद भी कोई एक किताब जरूर लिखें और वो ऐसे लिखें कि प्रतियोगी युवओं के लिए भी काम आये।फिर से आपको शुक्रिया।
काबिल-ए-तारीफ सबा... यह बात क्लियर है कि मोदी को कोई नज़र अंदाज़ नही कर सकता । मुझे भारत का प्रधानमंत्री बनना है ,बताओ किया करू । भाजपा के एलक्शन कैंपेन कमिटी का मेम्बर ही बना रहूं या फिर हिन्दू महासभा revive करूँ ?
egargs RSS join kro
First View, First Like, And First Comment!
Excellent interview...will read the book
Very interesting and informations also very good. I like both Shaba and Saurabh.
Very interesting interview. There are many shades of saffron bcoz it is the party which can embarrass people from different background, and prepare them for the top job. There no shade in congress bcoz the party starts and ends with one family.
Shrimanji do you mean embrace? PL be sure what words you use. It can convey wrong message. No offence only concern
Talented reporter many things are remaining but it's good for intro our part of politics.. and true af is no one talk about economy and indian rupees..
Very beautiful descriptions with saba Naqvi