Something about this version always stuck with me. It's like she feels inclined to sing not because she's good at it, but simply because she feels an emotion. It's for that reason that I find this song to be very beautiful.
All right, I just listened to the most out-of-tone, ungracious, ear-piercing, weird version of a Joanna song and I love it so much. I am quite sure at this point Joanna could just scratch her nails on a chalkboard for a couple of hours and it would be a great album to me.
heart shattering rendition... she sounds so broken, like singing this was too much for her, emotionally... like she didn't want to sing, she just had to get her feelings out... one of her most powerful pieces in my opinion
Just goes to show that captivation is within the character of the voice and not in the obedience of the needless rules laid out for quick selling purposes. We are taken by this because of the sheer expression within the performance.
please listen to this and let me know if it changes your opinion. /watch?v=6EHemagYSs8 its just, that peach plum pear is often the first newsom song people listen to and its very unlike most of her music. shes a poet, her lyrics are just beautiful. ive cried listening to her lyrics.
how many times has she forgotten the lyrics to this fucking song lol she always adds a bunch of "and"s at the start of each line when she does it live and lets not talk about :30. she seems to forget something new every time also the start of this one sounds like she just woke up from a nap
Something about this version always stuck with me. It's like she feels inclined to sing not because she's good at it, but simply because she feels an emotion. It's for that reason that I find this song to be very beautiful.
Exactly. It’s not about perfection. It’s about expression, emotion and poetic
Same here. This is my favorite version of this song.
All right, I just listened to the most out-of-tone, ungracious, ear-piercing, weird version of a Joanna song and I love it so much. I am quite sure at this point Joanna could just scratch her nails on a chalkboard for a couple of hours and it would be a great album to me.
is it just me or is this version just even more heartbreaking?
It's amazing how far she has come.
But...this version is amazing. She truly puts her entire heart into this song.
her voice was iconic _even_ then. queen.
heart shattering rendition... she sounds so broken, like singing this was too much for her, emotionally... like she didn't want to sing, she just had to get her feelings out... one of her most powerful pieces in my opinion
Just goes to show that captivation is within the character of the voice and not in the obedience of the needless rules laid out for quick selling purposes. We are taken by this because of the sheer expression within the performance.
Also love the lines that are at the end of the song.
So Beautiful! This is is my favorite version!
I can't even handle how beautiful she is
i like this version more than the other, but i still love the other one.
lol I had the speed on 1.5 and didn't know, wow that was crazy.
this is incredibly beautiful
She sounds so defeated in this version. It definitely adds a different effect
Thanks for posting this!
awkward how people think this is a cover...
Brava🎉🎉🎉🎉
... Wait she was only like 20 when she did this.
Well fuck, I wasted MY life :(
that's how I feel whenever I listen to her music, although it should be a great source of inspiration.. I'm sure you're very talented. :)
please listen to this and let me know if it changes your opinion.
/watch?v=6EHemagYSs8
its just, that peach plum pear is often the first newsom song people listen to and its very unlike most of her music. shes a poet, her lyrics are just beautiful. ive cried listening to her lyrics.
I love how people are commenting thinking this is a cover hahahaha
This is peak freak folk
But it isn't freak folk?
@@Brokenhill42 no, it definitely is
I need more of this kind of music
how many times has she forgotten the lyrics to this fucking song lol
she always adds a bunch of "and"s at the start of each line when she does it live and lets not talk about :30. she seems to forget something new every time
also the start of this one sounds like she just woke up from a nap
The original version was already to high.. And you're even higher... It sounds really uncomfortable for you. :p
Christ! Sounds like a dying cat in heat.
My god this is awful. There's another version that sounds much better, but it can't be said that she an sing no matter what.