Is Roland FP-30X Better than Yamaha DGX-670?
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 08. 2024
- Info & Best Prices
🎶 Yamaha DGX-670
geni.us/ENkZX5
🎹 Roland FP-30X
geni.us/cd1sKzh
🎹 Best Piano Video Course
bit.ly/35i5Mq6
📱 Best Piano App (Android/iOS)
bit.ly/2EUP0SJ
🎧 Budget Pro Headphones
geni.us/GHXON
🎶 Best Beginner Pianos
Yamaha - geni.us/FCpSg9
Casio - geni.us/F5sL8
Kawai - geni.us/Ar7sJ
Roland - geni.us/cd1sKzh
🎹 Best Beginner Keyboards
Yamaha - geni.us/XQyDB
Casio - geni.us/PkvVaY
Korg - geni.us/w0N3Z
🎹 Best Software Instruments
geni.us/kJBo
🎶 Best Value Home Piano
geni.us/cZRNKo1
🎼 More Reviews
www.jeremysee....
☕ Support Jeremy with a coffee.
www.paypal.me/...
🎹 Free 25 Piano Lessons
bit.ly/3knm5Gs
🎹 Beginner MIDI Keyboard
geni.us/zpNH
✅ Beginner Music Workstation
geni.us/NUp4JX
✅ Sustain Pedal (All Brands)
geni.us/BgYE
🎼 Beginner Audio Interface
geni.us/aB5D4ox
✅ USB MIDI Cable
geni.us/mqNsG
📙 Beginner Keyboard Book
geni.us/gANHP
📙 Beginner Piano Book
geni.us/kNWb
🎼 Download Sheet Music
fave.co/340HK0x
Jeremy See is audience-supported. When you buy through his links, he may receive an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate he earns from qualifying purchases.
Instagram : / jeremysee.keys
Facebook : / jeremysee.keys
Info & Best Prices
🎶 Yamaha DGX-670
geni.us/ENkZX5
🎹 Roland FP-30X
geni.us/cd1sKzh
🎹 Best Piano Video Course
bit.ly/35i5Mq6
📱 Best Piano App (Android/iOS)
bit.ly/2EUP0SJ
🎧 Budget Pro Headphones
geni.us/GHXON
🎶 Best Beginner Pianos
Yamaha - geni.us/FCpSg9
Casio - geni.us/F5sL8
Kawai - geni.us/Ar7sJ
Roland - geni.us/cd1sKzh
🎹 Best Beginner Keyboards
Yamaha - geni.us/XQyDB
Casio - geni.us/PkvVaY
Korg - geni.us/w0N3Z
🎹 Best Software Instruments
geni.us/kJBo
🎶 Best Value Home Piano
geni.us/cZRNKo1
🎼 More Reviews
www.jeremysee.info/
☕ Support Jeremy with a coffee.
www.paypal.me/jeremyseekeys/10USD
My Roland fp30x has been delivered 3 hours ago, right at the moment when you have published this video. It’s like „11 reasons why I have made a right choice“ for me. Thank you so much for the video 🤗
Great choice, have fun!
Very well put together Jeremy! I feel the FP - 30X is a better choice for those intending to play classical piano pieces by Mozart, Beethoven, etc. The Bluetooth Midi function is something really unique & useful as players don't have to carry their midi cables around. The DGX - 670 is a better choice for those who would love to play their favourite songs with super realistic voices and accompaniment. Another advantage is that the DGX - 670 comes with the 'Adaptive Style' feature that arranges accompaniment to suit the mood of the music.
I don't know. I love playing classical on my DGX. Haven't tried the FP30X yet, however I did try the HP702 with that PHA4 action and I much prefer the action on my DGX670🎹🎶
Between now and 2 hours from now, my FP-30X is gonna be delivered and I am beyond excited. I've never really been able to stick with learning the piano, because I used to have a cheap keyboard that I just didn't enjoy the sound of. With the amount of money I invested in this, I'm dedicated to start learning and be consistent.
Have fun!
Good ! Glad you are getting to the point of no return ! I had free intro organ lessons at new music store when I was about 6 or 7 . Dad never bought lessons past the free ones & I have wanted to play since 1959 ! Finally have the time at 70 years old & I am encouraged by your enthusiasm ! See you at The Met ! ! Nick , NavyBlueSmoke LST-1195
@@WilliamRNicholsonLST-1195 wow William!
I must say I am inspired by your story! Definitely encourages me to keep pushing and learn. 😀
Hi Jeremy I agree on all points excepted that if I had to choose, as a composer, I would certainly buy the DGX670 because of its numerous sounds and effects, styles and arranging functions. Are you going to foot another video to explain why the DGX 670 is a better choice than the Roland FP-30X for pianists wishing to compose and arrange songs? Have a nice Sunday 😎🌈
Yup! My conclusion at the end of the video recommends this more for piano only players. The video on DGX is better has already been recorded. 😅
Jeremy See I don't know why am not surprised... 😸
Agree, but... if you’re a composer you probably use a daw and a midi controller, but maybe you compose effects, etc live on the piano, normally that stuff comes in on the daw after composing the basics but yeah, I can kinda understand your point
The DGX also has the 16 track sequencing available which is nice for those who like to utilize MIDI in their compositions and tracking.
I almost don’t care about extra sounds, playing the roland fp30x made me happy to be alive in 2021, it connects with the Soul, I played for 1 hr in the store and forgot where I was…
I have it and it's really cool, but damned, the bluetooth midi experience is so bad. You need to reset the bluetooth, unpairing the piano everytime you start the app or the piano. It's so frustrating.
Team Yamaha. I own the DGX-650, and I love the versatility. It can do so much, and the 670 is even better.
The key action might not be THE BEST, but it's still quite realistic. I don't miss an acoustic piano for a second.
If the only thing you care about is piano, get the Roland. But you can have so much more fun on the Yamaha.
As a writer and arranger, the DGX was an easy choice. I’m incredibly pleased with it.
Great choice. Have fun!
Thank for these differences were minor for me. DGX just ordered, total beginner, should last me for ages.
I just bought the DGX-670 for my family entertainment. I love it. The best feature of DGX is the Bluetooth facility. I play my favorite songs from Spotify, connected to the DGX then I follow the band and the singer. Made me feel like playing music and sing together with them. Duet with Fank Sinatra - My Way :). It's a best way also to learn a song (chord and melody). Thanks
Great choice!
I played with all of the sounds on the FP-30x and the sounds I liked the most are the first sounds you get by pressing the first key and I can use it with my computer so it was still worth the price to me. I love how deep and warm the first Piano setting sounds and I like one of the old piano sounds on it too. I also have a M Audio Oxygen 49 which has knobs and sliders which are great for mixing. I would say that some inexpensive midi keyboards can be good for music production because of all the knobs and sliders.
Thank you Jeremy for this video! I’ve been waiting for it!
If anyone need only piano they can go for Rolland... But I need electric keyboard, 88keys piano, styles, vocal input, all those stuff together in dgx 670...
it's worth noting that if glossy/untextured keys bother you, you can quite easily scuff them up with a very fine/high grit of sandpaper. but I'm talking VERY high grits, i'd be looking at something like maybe 1200. you can always go down or up a grit depending on the result. it may void your warranty, but worth considering
At 2:00 you can see the lateral movement of the keys. It seems they didn't fixed that yet, it was one of the things that bothered me about the action.
It's not a bug, it's a feature!
@@abohsukampret why is that concerned a good feature? I’m only an intermediate player, but I too get annoyed when keys do that lol
The hustler is back! He doesn’t skip a beat! Thank you for this great and anticipated review
Thank you for your kind compliments buddy!
Hi jeremy, Hi thank you for your demonstration very nice, I am an owner of a Roland G1000 and sadly the LCD is fading and I can't find a part, so I am looking for another portable keyboard, what my dilemma is I have always used the GS MIDI via the floppy discs for backing me up as a one man band, I realise that is very old technology, I am wondering as you say the Roland plays midi can I download all my midi files to a USB and plug it into the keyboard for playback as I dont want to mess with Ipads ect. or do you know of another model of any brand that can do this, your advice would be great await your reply with thanks Kind regards Noeline
Glad to hear about the hammer effects on the Yamaha. Now I know I am not the only one. I can really notice the big difference between my Acustic Jun109 and the GDX. Yes I agree I not comparing apples to apples but, I also have a very low quality digital piano from Alexis and the keys effects are much better than the other digital Yamaha. Yamaha makes greats digital pianos but they need to level up their key effects. Thank you.
Have you try the FP E50 yet???
This would be the best rival for the DGX 670
I would like to see you do a comparison between the Yamaha P515 and the DGX-670. These two keyboards seem to be much more similar than the Roland FP-30x vx DGX-670.
p515 !!!
If you want a PIANO with a smattering of additional sounds the Roland rocks. If you want great piano sound, not as good as the Roland, but hundreds of additonal patches, rhythm, accompaniments and a pretty decent keyboard get a Yamaha.
Roland has modeled, computer algorithm, sounds and it makes the piano sound terrible, Yamaha uses real sampled sounds for real instruments.
I love how straightforward you are and start right away with the verdict at the beginning, so i can start googling the price as i was watching your video 😂😂 most vloggers just try to drag out the verdict at the end 😤
I already play Pianoteq Pro powered by a Casio PX-150 with hi-res MIDI and triple sensors. From a key bed perspective it seems Yamaha could be a step down. That said, I think the arranger features of the DGX would be fun for me. As 78 year old pianist, I can fool around with just playing melodies and using the auto-accompaniment styles feature. While there are negatives to the DGX-670, I think I will go ahead with it. Of all the digital slab pianos on the market today I would actually prefer the Roland fp90x, but it is even heavier than the DGX and costs 2.5 x's more. Given that I already have a good digital piano set-up, the question is do I need to spend money on another piano at all?
Thanks for sharing.
I truly enjoy your videos. Hopefully you make soon an review on Roland RP/F 701. As far as I understand the BMC the FP-30x and 701 is the same. Keep on posting🙂👍🏻
Yes we need this review.
Not quite an apples to apples comparison, but everything Jeremy says here is sound. I still like the Yamaha's piano sound a bit more but at this point, Roland's piano qualities and timbre changes and dynamic control is closer to an acoustic experience than Yamaha's. However, if you want a low-priced piano arranger, the DGX-670 is quite a good value. Yamaha just simply needs to update their action on their lower end and start adding value because Roland and Casio really give you a lot of bang for the buck. And Roland is the bigger challenger because their name is big in the industry as professional instruments while Casio is still struggling to be seen as a major player in the middle and higher markets (though they should be, IMO).
I'm playing devil's advocate here. 😉
@@JeremySee Ah!
Hi Jeremy, thank you for this very helpful comparison. I have a question for anyone - Does the FP-30X or DGX6670 allow me to record and broadcast in real-time via computer? (Like for a live CZcams video?)I have had the Yamaha DGX660 for several years and have enjoyed it. However, I would like the ability to set up live-streams to platforms like CZcams and record directly on a computer. Although the DGX660 has the USB to Host port, it is my understanding that it does not allow live broadcasting or recording directly to my computer for both audio or MIDI. For recording, I have had to record directly on the device, then plug in a flash drive, transfer in real-time to the drive, then plug into the computer to save and upload. This is tedious/time-consuming and does not allow live performances online. So I am now looking at buying a second digital piano that will allow me to both live-stream and record directly through a connected computer. Do you know if the FP-30X or the DGX-670 (Or both) allow this feature? Or do you recommend a different digital piano altogether? Any info would be extremely helpful. Thanks!
For anyone interested, the comment was true. And the Roland FP30x makes direct audio input as simple as plugging in to your computer! Audio quality is awesome (speaker quality not so much) l. Really glad I snagged this (in white).
An excellent comparison. I love the DGX-670 I just purchased but your review is unbiased and much appreciated.
Luck you!
i just saved up, and bought the fp-30x as my first piano. I was going to go with the fp-10 but they were out of stock and after looking further into it i saw that the fp-30 was being upgrade, so i am really looking for to it's arrival
Have fun!
I guess I'm about to take the same decision since FP-10 is out of stock, but I already paid for it, let's see if I can order the FP-30X instead.
@@luis.barragan the small extra price is worth every penny, you will enjoy it. i also recommend the reviews of Merriam Music with Stu on the FP30X, the comparison with the Casio 3000 is interesting.
I just bought the DGX-670 - I had the 660 and 650 models. I'm going crazy trying to access the XG & GM voices...can't find them yet I see a list (Found it online) of all the additional voices within those areas for the 670. On my previous models (660/650) I could scroll through and find the all the voices together...what am I missing and how do I access the GM/XG voices - they should be loaded up onto my keyboard and not something I have to purchase additionally correct?
Great Review. I listened to both of your videos comparing the two ’pianos’. Yamaha seems to be a keyboard with a piano type action. The Roland is a piano with additional features. If you want to learn to play the piano then the Roland is the choice. In real life I’ve recently heard the comparison of sound and touch of the FP 30 X against the Yamaha. Frankly I don’t think there is a comparison. One sounds magnificent in comparison to the other. For an arranger on a budget the Yamaha might do. The operative word is budget. With the FP30X the operative word is piano. Keep up the good videos.
i m so hyped!!!my fp-30x is due to arrive in 3 days !!!hope my piano journey that starts at a boomer age of 33 wobt be too hard
Have fun! Try out my recommended apps in the description and see if it works with you.
@@JeremySee i had not noticed it in the description ,i had allready downloades flowkey but i think i will also get a teacher so i can also learn theory
Very Good Solid info I loved it.😇
Very good review, thank you Jeremy !!
2:38 this is so satisfying
Great video and the bonus cat cameo at 3.54 made it perfect.
Glad you noticed!
The FP 30x with speakers below would mean that one cannot place it on a flat table?....as the speakers will be blocked out?
Thank you brother. What do you think piano sound cfx dgx670 vs supernatural fp30x? Do you think both equal?
Gracias Jeremy. Acabo de decidirme por el Yamaha DGX670 después de ver tu video, y otro más donde también hablas de este teclado. Saludos.
Personally I like the high end of the Yamaha grand better. Yamaha multisamples sound far more dynamic and realistic, to me anyway.
Psychoacoustics play a big part.
Nice analysis, really helps the decision process. Looking forward to similar reviews on the FP-60X, as I am already leaning toward that board. Thanks Jeremy
Have fun!
Although I already own a Fp 30x (yes, I bought it because of your previous videos), I still watch your videos just like how I watch other CZcamsrs' videos for leisure.
Always good to watch and informative! Good job 👍
Have fun!
GREAT REVIEW! WHICH OF THE TWO HAS A BETTER ACTION? SWEETWATER SALES PERSON SAID YAMAHA DGX 670 HAS BETTER ACTION? AND WHAT SOUNDS MORE LIKE A BABY GRAND? THANKS!
Im waiting for this video THANK YOU SOOOO MUCH IT HELP ME A LOT 😍😍😘😘🥰🥰🥳🥳🤩🤩
Thank you for your support.
Jeremy, what do you think about Roland FP E50? Especially comparing with DGX 670. Thanks
Price and functionality is more comparable between p515 and dgx 670. Can you please do a video comparison for the two?
guy from piano forever channels says roland fp30x had worst keybed for an aspiring pianist. this guy says roland had best action. dont know whom to believe.
Sorry if this reply is late, but the roland fp30x’s action is geared to feel like an accoustic piano’s action therefore making it feel heavier than other weighted actions like yamaha. Aspiring/beginner pianist might need a little time getting used to the rolands action.
Interesting comparison. I think the high quality samples of the Yamaha is what everyone raves about and tends to influence the rest of most reviews even causing some to disregard important shortcomings such as key action and lack of a line out. Hopefully, Yamaha's next DGX version will have a better quality keyboard with triple sensor and matte finish keys and also a proper line out. I had the original Roland FP-30 and using headphone out for an external amplfier didn't sound great. I now have the FP-30X and it's better. I do wish some of the Roland sounds were higher quality samples.
Sir I really appreciate your content it's ver helpful sir I had a few doubt that I would like to get clarified such as:Sir does CTX 700 has full size keys & does the CTX 700 lacking pitch wheel make a major difference as compared to cts-300 ,sir is the 20 piano rhythms in CTX -700 would be sufficient for a 'beginner' ? Would be thankful for your reply!
Your thankfully,
Tejas.
Thanks for the great videos. Do you ever review synthesizers?
I would but my audience demographics would mean I get little views. I have access to the Nautilus and OpSix but no point spending 40+ hours to study, review, record, edit a video and 500 people watch for 20 seconds. 🥺
@@JeremySee No worries. I do YT videos to and yes it is a ton of work. Keep dong what you are doing. It’s working.
Thank you for another great review Jeremy.
My FP-30X arrived yesterday. I like it, but am considering returning it as the output speakers seem muffled. Is this a common complaint or do I need to configure the settings somehow? The sound is fine with headphones in. Thank you
I cannot determine without listening to it in person. Quite many variables affect the sound from the speakers. Size of room, materials in room, how close to wall, how loud it's cranked up etc... Ultimately these are small speakers limited by physics.
Jeremy made the point ; that speakers on Roland aim towards the ground & that is probably the reason sound is not too good Unless you have a stand that allows the speakers to aim at the ground with nothing blocking the sound . Try to have hard surface for your ground surface as this will help the sound bounce off the concrete , hardwood , etc .......... If you want great studio to practice in , go to Hyde Street Studios in San Francisco ! I helped set up that place & many great musicians have made fantastic albums there . I am positively certain it has to do with my contribution ......... Yep , I got a bridge in Brooklyn that I'll sell ya ; real cheap , slightly used ............ Nick , NavyBlueSmoke , LST-1195
Different types of instruments should not be compared. The Roland FP-30X is a stage piano, the YAMAHA DGX-670 is a combination of a piano and an arranger keyboard. The Roland FP-30X can be compared to the YAMAHA P-125 stage piano, but the YAMAHA DGX-670 can be compared to the CASIO PS-S3000, a hybrid piano and arranger keyboard.
Hi Jeremy compliments for your video!!!Can you make a review Roland fp90x vs Yamaha P 515? I must buy One of these
Bye bye from Palermo
Which one is best to buy ? Difficult to choose.? Which one do you recommend to buy?
My friend, it’s allways interesting to watch your video’s!
Thanks for watching.
I truly enjoy your videos. Hopefully you make soon an review on Roland RP/F 701. As far as I understand the BMC the FP-30x and 701 is the same. Keep on posting🙂👍🏻
Hi Jeremy, great video thanks so much! I would like to know if fp 30x can play back what’s been recorded on the track and record at the same time? (Instead of overwriting the same track) thanks so much
very informatibe video. I would love to see a video of all the sounds of the fp 30X. I need a digital piano with good strings sound :
I own a Fp 30x. The digital piano only comes with around 50 tones, but there are lots more in the app (to be connected via Bluetooth). I found one string tone in the app which sounds really good to me (well, just in my opinion XD).
Hi Jeremy
Please help i am confused between Roland Fp30x & Roland RP501R. Which one is good?
What piano do you think is the best for me to practice my practical piano class , p125 or fb30x ?
all pianos in my college are acoustic and i don't want to feel any difference when i switch
The microphone feature was not mentioned. Does the FP30X have a microphone input like the DGX670?
Hi Jeremy, nice video comparison. I would like to add that the FP-30x is sleeker and more aesthetically pleasing to look at than the dgx-670 especially if you are placing them on an X stand, the dgx just looks odd even on its oem stand.
The DGX-670 new design gets polarizing views. 😁
@@JeremySee yea but I wished Roland would give us some more premium tones on the FP-30X though. I tried the guitar tones on the DGX in store and it’s so detail you can even hear the scratching on the guitar strings. When I heard that, it was so hard for me to make the decision that the FP-30X was the right piano for me.
wondering how is the sound of the DGX670 compared to your casio pxs3000 ? they cost the same. Also wondering about ES520 vs dgx670 which is also pretty similarly priced.
Hi Jeremy, what would be the set up with roland fp30 in music recording or making cover worship music
Jeremy! Thank you for another super helpful video :D Another quick question: I know the Yamaha DGX 660 (and I assume also the newest DGX 670) can be used without a stand. Does the Roland FP-30X also allow for this? I am looking into most effective integrations of either of these keyboards into my home studio setup, and though I notice you use it right in front of your desk with the included stand, would it also work just as well as a standalone unit?
Thanks so much, SERIOUSLY helping my search here! :)
Both can be used without a stand.
@@JeremySee great thank you!
Hello. Is the fp30x good for boogiewoogie style? Thank you.
I'm only buying an beginner model for my kids, I don't know how to play piano at all but his video is really fun to watch while I'm eating some chicken and beer.
Well, double check your Bluetooth connectivity, mine connects easily and works perfectly… just press and hold the menu button and pair it with your other device 😊
Can you please please please make a video on Roland Rp 302 Digital Piano??? Can I have your feedback on the Roland Rp302 here?
I thought about an Yamaha YDP Arius 144, for that classic look. The 3 pedals. The seat. But I recall trying one out and not finding the sound "full" enough. Beautiful digital piano. My "noise room" is starting to get a bit cramped. I have a home built keyboard stand to hold my Keystation 88ES and then a regular stand behind that to hold my DGX220. Then behind THAT a laptop and Cerwin Vega VS120 speakers. In one corner I have a drumset, my Marshall halfstack and atop that a Fender 2x12 amp (I use this for my DGX 220, and use the Vegas for the Keystation while making music in FL Studio... need to get some good monitors some time, I know haha)
Thanks
Find it helpful.
Glad it was helpful!
Dont forget the CLICKING KEY NOISES that all Roland FP-series models have. Just google this issue and you will find that this is an unacceptable flaw of the piano line. Go for YAMAHA.
What's an affordable, for hobbyist pedal for an FP-30x?
ROLAND FP 30X ELECTRIC PIANOS, DRAWBAR TONEWHEEL ORGANS & PIPE ORGAN SAMPLES ARE FAR SUPERIOR TO THE YAMAHA DGX 670 - ROLAND FP 30X 88 KEY GRADED HAMMER PIANO TOUCH IS ALSO PERFECT FOR ELECTRIC PIANO & PIPE ORGAN PERFORMANCE !! WELL DONE, JEREMY - YOUR AUDIO VIDEO PIANO REVIEW IS BALANCED BETWEEN ENTHUSIASTS & PROFESSIONAL MUSICIANS !! PROFESSIONALS KEYBOARD MUSICIANS KNOW THE SONIC DIFFERENCE !!
The best electric piano samples I've heard are from Keyscape.
I'm wary of the fp10 and fp30. I've read a lot on forums about the PHA4 keybed getting clicky soon after buying it - it's to do with the internal lubrication. Do you have any thoughts on this?
I think this will affect every digital key bed. The question is Is Fp30 this issue will come earlier or not.
Regardless it can be fixed very easily, by servicing it in a music store shop.
What is the difference between FP30 and FP30X please?
can you save MIDIs from the DGX-670 you record and transfer to your DAW through USB? Cause after hearing about the Bluetooth MIDI on the Roland, I'm kind of going for the FP30X
They are different types of digital pianos, aren't they?
So tough trying to decide what to buy. An amazing piano sound is a 100% MUST. I want that deep, fully rich grand piano sound (or best as I can get for under 1500 bucks Canadian taxes in ideally), BUT I also enjoy dabbling with synth sounds (though I mostly do that with FL Studio plugins). I generally use things like Piano/Strings/Orchestral Brass Section, a nice cathedral organ sound would be good. I have an ancient DGX 220 that's getting pretty beat up (mostly by the previous owners), and the actions getting bad, keys sticking, keys banging, and I just want a really good upgrade that will keep me happy for the next decade or so. I looked at things like the Juno DS 88 for synth and piano, but found the piano lacking a bit. All the sub $1000 keyboards sound unpleasant.
Thank you for this video. It's really difficult to find this specific comparison because I guess they're kind of meant for different things. Could you compare the strings sounds as well? I really love piano+strings.
PS: small feedback: it'd be great if you could include Kilograms for weight (and metric stuff wherever applicable). I'm really bad with unit conversions. 🙈 Thank you!
I did say in my DGX videos, you can't compare with usual digital pianos but the sheer number of people asking for a comparison, I just have to make this video. I have another video comparing DGX to FP coming up.
Jeremy, again you have explained everything very well, as did some of the others, elaborating on what you stated.
My very talented keyboardist and singer friend Jeannette Casuga Trevias here in Honolulu is highly trained and accomplished, but gigs with an older Yamaha arranger keyboard most of the time. She has a CZcams channel and goes live on Facebook, performing often several times a week, with other local music artists. She knows how to use the arranger keyboard very well.
The DGX-670 is an awesome keyboard for what it does, and has great features for the price, but the FP-30X has a proven more professional keyboard action, keys and other features and connectivity.
It all depends on what kind of keyboard player you are, your experience from you first learning and playing, your level of proficiency and musical training, knowledge and expertise, and technical acuity in regards not only to musical prowress and playing technique, but comprehending, and mastering alk the technicsl features and functions of these electronic keyboards, musical instruments and related sound and other gear.
Sound quality of tones or patches are comparable, but if you were raised with traditional acoustic pianos, especially high quality upoer line ones, trained in serious classical piano and possibly pursuing that venue as a professional, the keyboard action like that of the FP-30X is essential.
For others more interested in playing for enjoyment, entertaining friends, or the weighted hammer action and escapement is not a big deal, as they are just happy to be abke to play songs at various levels, or more pop synth and other music, the keyboard action is not as vital, and they may prefer the action if the DGX-670 or lighter action.
For myself, coming from a long exposure to music, from playing piano, other instruments, especially clarinet for most of my school years, with relatives and friends as professional musicians and singers, I have learned to appreciate and constantly listen to music fron those with the utmost musical and technical abilities, but have a profound admiration, regard, and respect for those with superlative playing technique, creativity, improvisation, arranging and composing giftings, besides learning all the peripheral things I mentioned. Just to memorize everything, the knowledge, discipline and tenacity to perservere to their level of excellence is to be commended.
Some doing it for recognution, wealth, and other goals, but most ultimately are driven and motivstiin by their love and passion of music.
The most beautiful thing is, unless your livelihood depends on it, you are free to enjoy listening, learning and playing music to whatever degree or level you desire, and strive for whatever your goals, dteams, and aspiration are.
But like I mentioned in my otevious long comment, be practical, and don't let it be an obsession and a compulsive thing and lose perspectives. Be practical and take your time. Use discretion and discernment and don't go overboard beyond your means or need to get something that will mskebyou neglect more important things in life. If you are an enthususst abd hobbyist, something like the $200 Yamaha PSR-E373 or Casio CT-S300 would be ideal. You can upgrade to something better when you reach that point and csn make use of it.
I am willing to spend money on things I really want, but I have soent so much in the past on music gesr I did not make much use of or needed.
Music is not my career, and time and energy impedes me from playing and getting back into learning and improving, so my Roland Go:Keys 61K is perfect for me at this point. Other than maybe another keyboard for my sister, which might be the PSR-E373, so I csn play that, too, and my JD-Xi synth, I will probably not may another keyboard other than one for church I can enjoy, but make use of there, so the purchase is justifiable.
I took another look and listen to the videos, and like I decided to get my Go:Keys over the PSR-E373 for a little more, I would spend the $1200 on the Roland RD88 over the FP-30X and DGX-670. The sounds and features are incredible, and much more professional, along with that keyboard action.
Both the FP-30X and tge DGX-670 are winners if it suits the needs of those that get it, and brings them joy. But for many here, the PSR-E373 or other affordable keyboards like those digital pianos with weighted action will suit many fine. Other than price, avaikability is a major factor.
Beautifully sound advice, my friend! Thank you for taking the time to share your years of experience.
@@JeremySee Your reviews are like the automotive ones. We all go ooh and ah over the new mideks, toys, tools, and shiny new objects, and the sounds and features. But for me, as much ad I like the incredible super performance and luxury vehicles, I would only get the most dependable and practical for myself. And the same goes with keyboards and music gear.
And I have the knowledge and real life personal experience to mske better evaluation and choices, where so msny other here are overwhelmed and confused, even with your simple explanations which in my comments now and previously explained why, and with hopes that those will read and learn what I have learned.
I'm a techie, but no longer need the $4000 Roland Fantom 8 or the sightly ess expensive 61 and 76 key variants. My Go:Keys and JD-Xi is all I need now. It's just that the RD 88 or the Keyscapes shound are tweaked by the musical angels to sound etheral, but heaven can wait. And the 88 keys and action. And cost less than the Keyscapes, a good 88 key controller and powerful laptop. The Keyscapes has so much sound choices and variations, but the RD 88 has the best of the Fantom, RD 2000 and FP series and a more affordable price and portability.
The FP-30X will be great for those it is more suited for than the DGX-670.
We are blessed with all the choices and options at affordable prices. But when I get that $1400 stimulus check, I may be tempted getting that RD 88. 😅
@@jjacob25101 I had the rd88 and shipped it back in 2days,I’m going to get this dgx670 and give it a go,will ultimately go for a korg nautilus 88 key
A ver tengo un yamaha Dgx 650 con su soporte original, estoy pensando en comprarme un dgx 670 el problema es que en mi país (España) el soporte original aun no ha llegado
Pero yo creo que prácticamente son iguales
Me serviría el soporte del 650 para el 670??
Porfa necesito respuestas
Is yamaha P 125 still worth it in 2021? And is Yamaha P 125 good for advance or professional players? ADVANCE THANK YOU❤️🇵🇭
No. Wait for the replacement. Trust me it will be better.
I agree with AMusic 98's comment. Yamaha is bound to release an exciting mid-level product soon in its portable piano range.
The P-45 needs retiring. P-125 is slightly overpriced for its features and should become Yamaha's entry level 88 portable piano. The P-121 has a fair price despite having only 73 keys, so it's still a good buy.
In theory, most digital piano actions are not good enough for classical piano students taking the higher music exams. The GHS piano actions on the cheaper Yamaha pianos are clearly unsuitable for ambitious piano students. The FP30X has the minimum quality action required, but even then.... Another good and cheap contender is the Korg D1, which (incredibly) uses Korg's flagship action. I think it has no internal speakers, since it is a pseudo stage piano. There are plenty of excellent powered stereo monitor speakers available (such as iLoud) which blow the inbuilt speakers on most portable pianos out of the water.
Portable pianos are the cheapest way into high quality sound. But if you spend 1200 to 2400 euros, you can get a great home digital piano, which will feel better, look better and last better than nearly all portable digital pianos.
@@amusic9825 ok.thanks 💗💗💗💗💗💗💗
@@Zoco101 thank you very much for the advice 💗💗💗💗💗 I kinda want roland fp 60x and I'm still waiting for the replacement/ Upgrade of the Yamaha P series.
Hi ...
I have recently purchased Roland FP 60X digital piano. But Piano Partner 2 app is saying incompatible with this model while installing the required data files. Piano Designer app is working normally. Is Piano Partner 2 app is incompatible? Then how to access in-built Rhythms and other hidden functions?
Thanks
One is not better than the other. They are different and aimed at different kinds of people.
The Roland is better for people who value the most piano authenticity.
The Yamaha is better for people who are willing to sacrifice a little authenticity for more versatility.
Ideally, you wouldn't have to decide between the two, and you could have it all, but I would take the Yamaha. It's still authentic enough for most people, and it opens up a lot more creative possibilities. It's fun, and it keeps you engaged with all the different voices and rhythms. And, for pure piano, it still sounds great to my ear.
It just depends on what is most important to you.
I heard that the action is not as responsive. Some players have problems with thrill or faster pieces.
Ordered my FP-30X yesterday. Should be here in a couple days! Now I'll be able to practice without disturbing my family at night and play on my acoustic piano during the day :)
Have fun!
Have it arrived yet?
@@Thadnill yes, sorry just saw your question. Arrived about a week ago. This is my first digital piano. I have a Yamaha baby grand so the Roland has taken some getting used to. Key action actually felt a little heavier than my Yamaha baby grand but I have gotten used to it. Took a few days to get used to the sound.. it's not bad, just different. So far I am enjoying it and it feels really good to start practicing again after many years of neglect 🙂
Have you had a chance to play any kawai digital pianos for review? The es model line specifically, 110, 520, and the 920.
Kawai DP are totally neglected by the local distributor where I live because selling Kawai grand pianos is way more profitable with thousands of dollars margin. I cannot review something I cannot get my hands on. Not to mention Kawai global PR has made no attempts to get in touch with me to provide me with review units as I am just a tiny channel with no influence.
@@JeremySee that’s too bad because those models are highly sought after, and we get a lot of calls for them. The other issue is that they are so hard to get , just like the rolands are almost impossible to locate. (Maybe that’s why he doesn’t have any.) I’ll ask my rep to send you some for review, if they ever get my orders filled first.
I always enjoy your videos, and these manufacturers need to realize the value you bring to the brands.
It seems this guy is pro-Roland - he disses the Yamaha DGX for being a deal breaker with only one output for both headphones which doubles up as an aux out to connect to 2 speakers - you can still connect the yamaha dgx to 2 studio monitors - the jack he is referring to is a stereo jack which if you have the right cable, can run to a left out and right out - should you insert a mono jack - you have mono - stereo jack gives you stereo. The piano sound on the DGX through it's own speakers is more realistic and not as tinny as the Roland. I learned on a YAMAHA grand piano and the graded hammer action is different from the grand, but honestly it is good enough for a piano touch and doesn't interfere too much with other sounds which the yamaha has a host of - If you're playing an organ part and need to do a slide - the yamaha is easier and then the action of the roland is a pain. So if you want to have a piano touch and feel, yes - just a pity the sound sucks - get the roland, if you want to sound good and have a versatile keyboard - get the yamaha.
I'm so pro Roland that I made this video. (Totally dripping with sarcasm) czcams.com/video/IdsQ9gn2mKM/video.html
How many of my 500 videos have you watched? 🤔
This escapment alone on roland fp30 doesn't make it the best action over yamaha dgx 670.
previous video convinced us to buy Yamaha DGX-670
wait till you watch the next video!
@Corporeal Undead I agree with you!
施老师，真希望牙膏厂能给这些稍微好点的电钢琴配上GH Action，每次都是GHS🤦♂️
Yes... It's time all the better action on the Clavinova trickle down to the P-Series and DGX
Hi Jeremy , I am planning to purchase yamaha PSR SX900 in next 3 months, can you please help me know if yamaha is gonna launch any new equivalent keyboard in 2021 ? is there any way to find out same.
I do not work for Yamaha and do not have the information.
Seems like this is a bit of an apples vs oranges comparison with the DGX allocating a good portion of its cost on arranger features, but the Roland is excellent for its price point. If you are just planning to play at home, then the lower power, forward facing speakers and lack of dual output jacks are probably fine. (but we always want more..) You mention how heavy the DGX is with stand, but then don't mention the weight of the Roland with stand. I would imagine there are half a dozen features where the DGX stands out too. I would think that students should be concentrating on the piano and not have much time to get into the arranger features as well, so the Roland is better suited there. Thanks for your great video reviews!
My next video will interest you 😉 Roland with the stand is light. I can lift and move entire 30X with stand and pedals.
@@JeremySee Nice! I need to hear to good things about it! (I have one on order.... :-0 )
Sir i am going to buy roland fp10 is it still worth buying?
Watch this Friday video
Only if you get it at a much reduced price. The 30x sounds much better. I heard the fp-10 is being discontinued. It tends be a buyers market on used digital pianos. You can probably find a good used instrument for literally a steal.
Jeremy, you've hit on the obvious differences of the actions, but the worst thing about the GHS action (on the Yamaha DGX670) is how spongey it feels. The old Yamaha GHE action, however, while also lacking all three qualities you mention, manages to give a satisfying experience for many users including concert pianists who use it for finger exercises when travelling. These things you mention are niceties, but not deal breakers. The Roland action is the better of these two actions, full stop, unless piano is not the main voice the user wants to play.
Can you say whether inbuilt speakers or "line-out" were used in the demo? It affects how we judge the main voices. I suspect that the DGX670 can hold its own against the FP30X sound engine.
They are all direct outputs to a digital audio interface
@@JeremySee Good to know. What I cannot understand is the incredible weight of the DGX670 with only a GHS action. I agree that for many/most players the FP30X is a better deal.
I see from a Merriam Music review that the the 30X is a big improvement on the 30, particularly in the middle register notes. That is hugely significant IMO. The weak FP middle register was always a big disincentive for me.
DGX670 vs PXS3000 vsXE20, FP30X vs ES520
Which one has warmer piano sound?
"Doubling the amount of amplifier power ONLY produces an additional 3 decibels of loudness"
Yes, 3 decibels in fact mean 2× more power. :) In terms of acoustic (sound) pressure level it should be square root if I am not mistaken, so √2 ≈ 1.413× more max loudness in theory (if the electronics would allow it directly like this). So still significant improvement imho. :)
right!
A change of plus or minus 3 decibels is defined as the smallest difference in sound level that is easily heard by most listeners of speech or music. In other words, when you increase or decrease the volume of your music by an almost imperceptible but still recognizable amount that is considered a 3 decibel difference! You could easily use only 1 to 10 watts of a 100+ watt guitar or bass amplifier / speaker to overpower any audience or studio to uncomfortable sound pressures depending on room size & acoustics.
3 db is not a doubling of actual sound levels as sensed by the human ear ! I would never have bothered talking about such a trivial amount of sound level difference ! Whatever you're listening to , I would recommend you try Geezers Amps ! If your hair is wet after a shower , just stand in front of his amp while he plays his Black Sabbath songs & your hair will be dry in no time ! You also will have lost most of your hearing ! Geezer Amps toast bread too ............ Nick , NavyBlueSmoke , LST-1195
Dang. You are really active in your comments section.
The CZcams algorithm demands it. 🥺
Having a hard time finding one from one of my preferred dealers, but I'm not gonna lie - I'm a die-hard Roland fan, so the FP-30X will be the choice for my daughter. 🙂
Your cat really cute.
Yes! I know who really watch my videos. Thank you.
Considering the one line out and weak speakers, what do you think is an easy external speaker solution for better quality sound at home on DGX-670 outside of using headphones?
I have loved the Roland keyboard because of its genuine sound ability, smoothness, warmth, and restful sound that generates pure beauty. I've also owned the Yamaha DGX650, and one of the older models from Yamaha, both models were definitely for the inexperienced musician, but I guess I've grown out of the need for bells and whistles.
Good video but I think you are comparing apples to oranges (as you said when I asked you for your input comparing the DGX-670 to the P515. I expected something like this comparison you just did, despite one is an “arranger” and the other is a “digital piano”)...
At the end of my DGX review, I have already stated who and Arranger piano is for and who it isn't. Since every one INISIST on a comparison, here goes. Another video on why DGX is better is coming up.