LIVE: ID v. Chad Daybell Day 17 - Doomsday Prophet Murder Trial | COURT TV
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 06. 2024
- LIVE COURT WEBEX: Day 17 - The State's case continues for the so-called "Doomsday Prophet" Chad Daybell. Daybell is facing the death penalty for the murders of his first wife, Tammy Daybell, and Tylee Ryan, 17, and JJ Vallow, 7, the youngest children of his second wife, Lori Vallow Daybell. He is a self-published author and prosecutors have described him as the leader of a 'Doomsday' cult.
00:00:00 ID v Chad Daybell Day 17
00:20:55 CONT. STATE’S WITNESS #45 Special Agent Steve Daniels, Evidence Response Team (ERT), FBI
01:35:18 Break
02:03:23 STATE’S WITNESS #46 Melani Pawlowski, Lori Vallow Daybell’s Niece
03:05:46 STATE’S WITNESS #47 Ian Pawlowski, Melani Pawlowski’s Husband
03:42:07 Lunch
04:47:13 CONT. STATE’S WITNESS #47 Ian Pawlowski, Melani Pawlowski’s Husband
#CourtTV Catch up on the case against #ChadDaybell in the #DoomsdayProphetMurderTrial. ⚖️ MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/chad-dayb...
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.com/email/
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.com/podcast/
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
CZcams / courttv
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE
www.courttv.com/trials/
HOW TO FIND COURT TV
www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/
00:00:00 ID v Chad Daybell Day 17
00:20:55 CONT. STATE’S WITNESS #45 Special Agent Steve Daniels, Evidence Response Team (ERT), FBI
01:35:18 Break
02:03:23 STATE’S WITNESS #46 Melani Pawlowski, Lori Vallow Daybell’s Niece
03:05:46 STATE’S WITNESS #47 Ian Pawlowski, Melani Pawlowski’s Husband
03:42:07 Lunch
04:47:13 CONT. STATE’S WITNESS #47 Ian Pawlowski, Melani Pawlowski’s Husband
#CourtTV Catch up on the case against #ChadDaybell in the #DoomsdayProphetMurderTrial. ⚖ MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/chad-daybell/?
1) These people are NUTS
2) Melanie is LYING
3) Ian is a FOOL for getting married so fast, AND staying married to Melanie, AND then, having a child with her ......
Yes, seems Ian was desperate to hang on to Melanie, even tho he believed she knowingly played a part in the kids killings.
Plus the fact Mel P just contradicted was Mel Gibb said on the stand! The lot of them were practicing WITCHCRAFT
@@carolynm9638Ian believed it too!
I'm surprised he is alive.
@@mickymitts3031 yes, most likely. He was definitely a member of the Psychotic Squad. He had no selfish reasons as Lori and Chad did - just gullible and stupid.
I now have no doubt that Melani Pawlowski knew everything. She knew about, Brandon , and the kids.
I think that Prior and Pulaski should go have a couple of beers so that prior can get all his questions answered.
How on earth was Melanie never arrested as an accomplice over the attempted murder of Brandon. Knowing that Alex was the shooter, she is like don't tell him that Alex is dead i want him to be frightened for the rest if his life. She likes her protectors, her current husband being one if them. He can defend her till the cows come home. But he must know that she is someone who is dangerous.
There are two ladies: Melanie Gibb Warwick and Melanie Boudreaux Palowski (Lori's niece)
I agree
Melaniece (as some call her😄👍🏽)was never arrested because her husband got her out of it by wearing a wire for the cops. He prob made a deal for her with the prosecutors office.
There are many who are culpable in this case but never charged. Their value was clearly higher as a witness for the prosecution than their determined culpability
Finally a smack down from the judge on Prior constantly interrupting.
He called him out for it the other day too. Prior is gonna give Judge Boyce a stroke by the end of this trial.
I love Boyce. He is clearly a very patient man but has his limits!! 😂
I love this judge....To Mr Pryor "and I'm going to object to you talking over his response! Stop cutting people off." 😂
I realized something while watching this today...Chad was the ringleader. I think Lori was muderous before she met Chad, and so was he. They are both liars, defrauders, grifters, and
murderers. I think Chad is aware that he is a fake, but Lori does not have that self-awareness. Evil met Evil the day that day at the Book Sale table.
Yes I think Lori was a serial killer long before she met Chad. Maybe even her sister, Melanie's mom. Did she get some of her insurance money? How about just get an education and an actual job??? I actually think had they not got caught, it would be a race between Lori and Chad as to who would kill the the other first!
Yep! Well said! I feel they murdered for money! And used certain things they were into as a cloak!!!!!
I agree. They were both already planning to do evil, they just got "lucky" that day meeting someone else as twisted as they were. I wonder what words were used the day they met that confirmed it for both of them.
One thing I realized while watching this trial, is that Chad already was trying to set himself up as a profit BEFORE he met Lorrie. His family believed him, which is one of the reasons Tammy supported the book publishing business, and why his kids did not question the death of their mother. Chad (and Lorrie) would be disquaified as spirital leaders by their community if they were divorced. So it wasn't just about the money (in the case of Charles and Tammy). Even if there was no life insurance, their days would have been numbered. Lorrie had benefitted from her first husband's death, and this was an inspiration to max out Tammy's life insurance, and kill Charles before the divorce went through. The death of the kids was mainly for the money. Alarmingly Chad had inquired about life insurance on one of his kids (Mark?) after his marriage to Lorrie. I wonder if they had intended to do away with him as well?
Why has Melanie not been arrested? She is just as involved… next??
I don't know about this Melanie chick. She seems a bit evil herself. I wonder if she even thinks about how she had a hand in these deaths.
Cunning as they come.
Just had a weird thought, Chad's writing a book on his notepad 😂
Call it .The Persecution of A Profit. He will be trying to make a buck for sure
😂 it looked like he was playing with his pen alot.
I've thought that the entire time. He has a habit of lowering his laptop screen and why does he have a laptop. It is weird
The best thing about being a convicted murderer is when a judge prohibits you from profiting off of any book you might write. This seems to be in cases of paying restitution, which Chad will certainly have to pay, with the fraud charges he is up for.
Melanie (Lori's niece) disgusts me. She is laughing as she talks about Brandon not having to be afraid of Alex anymore. Notice how the prosecution is tip-toeing around Brandon's name. They must have cut Melanie a deal, to not go after her if she testifies against Chad. They are all evil (except Charles, JJ, and Brandon), and both Melanies should be in jail along with Lori and Chad.
Exactly!!!!!
BOOM! Ended on a mic drop! While prior gets overruled again & again!😂
Omg . That blessing. 😳
Yeap!!
It was beyond painful..
I would have burst out laughing!!! Then again I wouldn't ever associate with demented people like him and Lori ..and the rest of their equally crazy family members and followers ... I'm sure he would have classified me as dark!!!😂😂😂😂😂
Listening to Chad perform that so called blessing ...I'd rather listen to cats Screeching!!!!!
Mel P. is completely discredited. She's either simple or lying. She doesn't hurt Chudbelly or help him. She should not be responsible for children. Period.
Never fails. every time Lori is ob the phone. THERE HE IS. Sign of manipulation and control. Not always about their demeanor. Sociopaths do whatever works for them.
Ooo, the phone call recordings do not help Chad Daybell's case at all! When he was suggesting not to move out of Rexburg, but that even there, his visions showed him people starving etc. His lawyer will avoid this or deflect it to make it Lori's fault, but this phone call certainly shows Chad's manipulations through his visions.
Mr. Pryor is is fishing …. There is no defense for the Dark Chad
He's grasping at straws.
Rob Wood should never have given out so many plea deals, instead of doing his job (the job we pay him to do) he gave plea deals out in order to protect the LDS church, all these people were still attending the Temple daily, it is disgraceful that he was more interested in protecting the church, than he was in prosecuting ALL the guilty, there has not been any Justice in this case, Rob Wood should be removed from the position of the prosecutor, let us not forget he is also related to a family member involved in this case.
Exactly. Instead of prosecuting all of them for their roles they drill down on just 2 and keep the church out of it. Mormons protecting Mormons again. I know Heather Daybell would have told them everything about her going to the church if they would have asked. Maybe the defense will put Adam Cox on the stand and play his first call with the detective telling them his brother and sister were Mormons gone wild and nobody was helping
Who is wood related to?
Oh Oh! I'm thinking Chad should have taken a plea deal...
I'm not sure they offer one to him.
The terrestrial world wants him there 😂
Agree plea deal is not automatic he needs to be on trial.
@@Virgo921Chad should’ve at least realised that pleading guilty would’ve been favourable at sentencing. How does he think he is going to beat these charges, particularly after Lori’s disastrous loss at trial? Only difference is she chose not to blame him and he is totally blaming her. 😆The problem for Chad with is that absolutely EVERYBODY can see straight through his crazy bs and can see him for the pathetic, deceitful, murdering grub that he is. You have to think that the only winner here will be Prior (being the owner of a new property in Rexburg). Prior had no reason to remind Chad of any advantage to pleading guilty. It’s hard to imagine Prior, in his first dp case, with no favourable evidence, would be confident of winning this trial. But then again, being the narcissist he is, Chad probably thinks he can keep fooling everybody. 🙄
Everyone 💩 on Prior but there are some witnesses you can’t wait for him to cross examine and hold them accountable for encouraging this ridiculousness. Btw, Thanks for sectioning off the video, CourtTV! It makes it so much easier to catch up.
Priors obsession with making the Jury think the land is so huge that nobody would see anything from the house or road, or ever notice burial sites.
Farms that are huge, at some point farmers/owners/workers notice remains eventually. Chads GARDEN is just that, a garden. Wasn't a HUGE tree either. Apparently the jury members aren't suppose to trust their own eyes
Nearly 4 acres is pretty big though, with 4040sqm each, that's a fair bit of land and especially a horse should be allocated 1 acre. I've owned horses and 4acres is huge as a garden. In England, if you owned an 8th of that, you're talking £££££s
@WolvesinFrance the "acres" are around the garden. The bodies were in the garden. Yeah, it is more expensive in UK, because the UK is the size of a US state. Also, I'm pretty sure you can see a horse in a field, I know I can
I wonder if Chad saw a vision of him burning in hell??
I took Chad Daybell off my screen I have whoever is testifying and the Judge I don't want to look at the devil in the flesh.
I know..wish the thumbnails showed something alive. Sick of seeing his face
Melanie is A LOT more involved than she led on to be. I think she should be charged or at least investigated.
This female prosecutor’s cadence is terrible. 30 second silent pauses between some questions and then she always asks for “one moment” to let whatever she said sink in, then says “I have nothing further”. It loses its luster when you do it EVERY SINGLE TIME.
Still not as nauseating as John Prior is.
Usually she can articulate her interrogations and she is well organized. She is also intellectual so she is mindful of her questionnaire. She is the opposite of Pryor in everyway. I feel like she has been the star of the lawyers there.
Completely disagree. Maybe today she paused but she us sharp as a fricking tack when it comes to objections, being able to articulate questions in a way to draw out the information relevant to the case. I will admit today she seemed to have more difficulty phrasing questions in her usual sophisticated manner. Regardless, she is incredible. She reminds me a bit of Johnny Depps lawyers in her quick responses. But ya, today wasn't her very best day.
I never had Ian being one of the best witnesses on my crazy cult trial bingo card!
I feel sorry for the jurors having to listen to Prior bullying everyone. I can fast forward his nonsense, they have to absorb it!
I’ve been listening in bits and pieces but the way he’s bullying the officer is unforgivable.
Sir; he dug up the child THAT YOUR CLIENT MURDERED. JFC. 🤬
I feel sorry for the jurors having to listen to all this God garbage talk on these taped phone calls “It will be glorious “. Good lord……
I believe it was Ian who said he is separating himself from all religions. Good for you Ian! Good for you. You dont need religion or a god to be a good person and lead a good humble life or to contribute in a positive way to our human community. Most of us already innately know right from wrong, thats all we need.
When Mel said 'Ian knows everything'. I believe she was even referring to the children being deceased, inc Charles, Alex and Tammy, so literary EVERYTHING.
Channelling Warren Jeffs 🤢
Right! Psychopaths
Too funny!!!
Look at Chad looking all proud at his blessing
This witness is very good
Did pawlowski testify to save his wife?? Because he realizes she knows enough to be implicated in the murders?
Mel has def confided in him, so IMHO, he knows tonnes about this case. He's keeping his cards close to his chest, esp if he has a child to protect. Mel P should be on trial, bc I believe she conspired no doubt in my mind. Cmon State, get her bk on the stand.
You can get up and make a sandwich during Chad's "blessing" that and walk the dog😂
👍
Boy, Chad had it wrong. If there was ever a zombie, it's him. No emotion, same chub look. Cartoon character with no character
"Casting" is not a part of the LDS faith in the way they are describing. No one refers to anything as a "casting". Ian is clearly not the best person to ask considering his grasp on the LDS religion was so weak he was open to Chad and Lori's BS. ANY Mormon worth their salt would IMMEDIATELY recognize things Chad and Lori believed and shared were not aligned with official LDS doctrine.
100%!!! I was cringing during his testimony.
Melani: "I can't remember." 👀
Sure Jan.
Melanie and Ian only knew each other 10 before the got married 😮
Nuts!!!! They are NUTS!!
I think zulema and Alec knew each less than 10 days before they got married…
Whyyyy does Defense keep bringing up "Seven Gatherers" to everyone???
I want to know that too!!! Where the heck did do come from?
The 7 is Chad Lori Melanie Melanie Alex Zulema David? It’s a theory out there
@@Nurseydogmom Thank you. It's funny how he's asked everyone, and all witnesses say no, not familiar. Wonder where the Defense is going with that?
Im thinking if David was originally part of the 7, he wasn't going to be for long; he questioned them to much@@Nurseydogmom
@@Nurseydogmom We finally found out in today's testimony from Zulema who the 7 Gatherers were. If I had only waited one day to ask lol.
I’m sorry but if Melanie Palowski were not involved in a an incriminating way then she wouldn’t have kept saying that Melanie Gibb was going to “throw ALL OF US” (not just Chad and Lori) under the bus. Why isn’t Prior after her, she was far closer to them Melanie Gibb
Exactly 💯 % my train of thoughts too. Trust me, Mel P has confided in Ian, he knows EVERYTHING remember. So when state asked him about what Mel meant about EVERYTHING he lied IMHO.
It was painful listening to Chad drone on and on!
3:41:57 and 4:51:34 - absolutely beautiful (yet understated) lawyering. *Chef’s kiss*
Melanie is such a useless witness. She needs to stop saying "I believe" and probably. Things that she for sure knows she sounds like she doesn't know. Just useless.
That girl is a Lori wanna be. She is even wearing a pair of glasses identical to some lenses Lori wore.
She prbs knows the most IMHO. She and her hubby bubbles are keeping 🤐🤐 NB: She is still LDS active isn't she just Ian says he's stepped bk from all religions for the time being. He needs a head detox, but he knows tonnes trust me.
That is interesting Melanie considers herself a faithful LDS member. I guess it depends on how we define "active" or "faithful". Also, I have never heard of this energy work as any part of the LDS faith. I think these weirdos just took a little morsel of any spiritual or holistic medical practice and ran with it. Just made up BS that enabled them to recruit like minded lost wack jobs In their murderous plan.
Say goodbye Chad!!!
Yes, and get stocked up with butt plugs 😂😂😂
This trial is going to take 6 months
I'm thinking 7 years
appeals hung juries retrials and other things
Love Melani's new glasses and hair color. 😂
Shes trying to be unrecognisable...plus thinks wearing glasses makes her look intelligent ..sorry Mel doesn't work!!!
Melanie P. definitely got the better end of the deal if it’s true she got immunity for her testimony. If so, I wonder if prosecutors are kicking themselves?
If she's wangled immunity, that in itself is a crime IMHO. She and hubby bubby know tonnes bc she still 'believes' and Ian IMHO is a liar bc wife would have definitely told him EVERYTHING 😉😉
Omgggg with these 7 GATHERERS againnnnnn!!!! Killing me Smalls 😭
Some of Ians answers.... when he says he had heard of removing curses..... I feel some clarification should be made that things referred to in scriptures, similar to "Have you ever heard of prophets parting a sea???" And the answer would be yes. She should follow up with another question to clarify these things are not things that happen in todays modern day. Right now if a church leader said he was going to part the red sea we would think they were a wacko
Every time i hear any recording of Lori or Chad they sound insane. Not to mention sneaky as hell. How did any if the ppl involved with them NOT see this?
What is on the usb Chad keeps loading and dipping his laptop when seems to feel others can see his screen. He is in jail, should not have unsupervised access to laptop in first place imho.
"..... but also leaving them in the care of your trusted family members". He also really focuses on pointing out their children will be apart from you. Wow. Then trying to manipulate Ian by saying he has great power??? Gag. I am trying to give Ian a bit of a pass because by this point he knew it was wacky. But not sure if that compensates for his stupidity in marrying Melanie so fast.
For anyone who is not LDS.... this blessing is so wacked and pure evil.
If I were Ian I’d sleep with one eye open. His wife is just as bad as chalori
They were blessed by the Devil himself. And I also being blessed with the gift of visions, just saw the exicuted of Chad Dumbell.
How do you get Hermosillo to STOP?!?! You tell him where the children ARE!!! The fact NOT ONE OF THESE people (melonie or Ian) ask where are the kids or turn over the kids….TELLS ME they ALLLLLLL know what happened and the Dis NOTHING to stop it!
If you watch Harvard Lawyer Lee's interview with Adam Cox (Lori's other brother) and her uncle Rex, they say that Alex was found with the same pink foam coming out of his mouth.... Whatever way Prior wants to spin it, if only the prosecution were allowed to make that connection, I think that would have connected a lot more for the jury
A family that kills together stays together. None of them had any common sense whatsoever to believe this BS. Zombies, light and dark, this isn’t a movie. This is real life, and they were buying into it. As for prior, sadly even monsters are entitled to a defense. I see a lot of people hate Prior, but he is a good defense attorney, he isn’t just sitting there. He’s getting up. He’s making objections. I’ve seen a lot of defense attorneys just sit there for a paycheck and not really do much of anything, unfortunately he is defending a monster, but like I said, every monster is entitled to a defense. In the end, we all know Chad is going to be convicted, and Prior is only working with what he has and it’s not much. Ask for Melani, at minimum they should’ve charged her with something, not exchange her testimony for her freedom. They still could’ve charged her with something.!
Everybody, what level of darkness did that? 🤨
Melanie’s lawyers were allowed to watch her testimony but Ian’s can’t?
I hope and pray the jury gets this right! He may not get DP… but he sure as heck better get life(s) in prison without parole!
6:48:09 Ian sounds like a level headed person who could recognize 💩
Why is the defendant table so much darker than the rest of the frames?
Because they have windows behnd them.
The irony of Chad being the darkest person in the room.
@@W_74_16 🎯🎯🎯
@@W_74_16 Great irony, indeed!!!
Looking forward to todays session. What's everyone's thoughts on the first witness today? Plus, are Ian and Mel still married, bc he mentioned he's stepped bk from all religions atm inc LDS. He needs detoxing pronto and run for the hills, IMHO.
The middle of October, Chad needed Alex's help to "do something"... you mean kill his wife Tammy?!
Wow. Pryor is so soft spoken and patient with Melonie….. that says a lot. Guess he doesn’t want to fluster her and make sure she says the right things. How infuriating and disgusting.
Who is Ian?
An utter fool!;
He married Melani 10 days after meeting on a single site!
@jennifergriffith4526 it's unbelievable right?? I keep thinking what's his angle? Is he some fame seeker who maybe things if he is associated to this crazy story he can go on to have a podcast and become some social media superstar, without having any real talent. Why the flip would he marry her so fast???
This is just another Mickey Mouse prosecution .They did not need to strike a deal with Melanie Polowski .She should be prosecuted right beside Aunt Lori Vallow.
See how much Alex helped these murders
Chad was pretending he was a wizard
I don’t mean this as an insult, in no way. You people in this courtroom are so soothing, I can so easily fall asleep with you there. Next day I have to listen to everything over again of course. Especially our judge, he really does have a great radio voice. Thank you guys!
Cult
Celestial telestial triestial, just when you think you have heard it all 🤔🤔🤔 144,000 🤔🤔🤔
Is it just me or does everyone seem a tad bit pissy today!? 👀🫤
Maybe they are all getting sick, 😷 they sound congested, so maybe that’s the sass lol 😅