Secret of Mana Remake PS4 | The Completionist | New Game Plus

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 23. 04. 2018
  • Secret of Mana may not be the most known title from Square Enix, to me it is one of the best game released on the SNES. It had enough of a following to get a 3D remake for the PS4, but with these remakes they tend to change or add things. So let's see how the PS4 remake holds up in my Secret of Mana review.
    Watch our Secret of Mana lets play ft. ProJared over on Super Beard Bros: • Secret of Mana | Let's...
    Subscribe: bit.ly/SubscribeThatOneVideoGamer
    Check out the new merch! theyetee.com/collections/the-...
    Curious about New Game Plus and the removal of previous Completionist episodes? The answers are in my update video: • The Future Of The Comp...
    Take on the role of a the unlikely hero Randi as he comes across a magic sword and is tasked with befriending the eight elementals to fight off the evil empire. Secret of Mana is a classic JRPG, and I might be a bit biased because I loved the pixel version and don't exactly understand why they made a 3D remake instead of a HD pixel release. The characters got makeovers in the Secret of Mana PS4 remake, but they are still the same quirky and memorable characters. I've got problems with small details in the game, but they start to add up to become an issue. See how the two games compare in my Secret of Mana review!
    Let me know what you thought about my Secret of Mana review! Which do you prefer: 2D or 3D Mana?
    Also let me know what other games I should re-complete for New Game Plus!
    Help support the show and get access to some cool perks and sneak peaks: / thecompletionist
    Watch Us On Twitch: / thecompletionist
    Find Us On Reddit: bit.ly/TheCompletionist_RD
    Follow Us On Twitter: bit.ly/TheCompletionist_TW
    Like Us On Facebook: bit.ly/TheCompletionist_FB
    Follow Us On Instagram: bit.ly/TheCompletionist_IG
    Completionist Merchandise: www.thecompletionist.com
    The Completionist Theme By Elite Ferrex - eliteferrex.bandcamp.com
    Watch more video game reviews like my Secret of Mana review on on my channel below| The Completionist
    / thatonevideogamer
  • Hry

Komentáře • 1,7K

  • @chrisstone-streetlightinte5629

    I pretty much came to the same conclusion as Jirard...It's good, but its not great and a remake of a game of this caliber should be great.

    • @teneesh3376
      @teneesh3376 Před 4 lety +5

      Yeah it's a really bad remake. But weirldy enough it can still be fun to play because it's based on the original game. Maybe that says something about the quality of the original

  • @NintendoCapriSun
    @NintendoCapriSun Před 6 lety +47

    Still kind of on the fence about the remake myself. It's kind of like I don't love it OR hate it. And in some ways that's almost worse than hating it.

    • @ajiguess3700
      @ajiguess3700 Před 3 lety +12

      The original is so good, I don’t really want to try the remake. Might as well just play the original instead of the remake. Also cool to watch TRGs let’s play of it!!!

  • @user-pm9ci2gg6b
    @user-pm9ci2gg6b Před 6 lety +14

    Loved the first 3 person play through references throughout, even the flash of the good old Elbow pad!

  • @KumaSan13
    @KumaSan13 Před 4 lety +12

    You know this looks more like a fanmade remake when the minimap LOOKS EXACTLY LIKE A RPGMAKER MAP.

  • @joeslickback
    @joeslickback Před 6 lety +44

    The return of Neeko the price gouging cat

  • @clayton_games
    @clayton_games Před 5 lety +19

    Update: the ring system now shows the characters faces so you always know which character you are on.

  • @TheChryystal
    @TheChryystal Před 5 lety +24

    "Sometimes, dead is better."

  • @diggzdoesgames
    @diggzdoesgames Před 6 lety

    Man, I'm so glad you still do The Completionist! Been watching since the "Originals" came back to catch up and wow, it's come so far. Much respect!!!

  • @SpartanJanitor
    @SpartanJanitor Před 6 lety +6

    I guess it's time to rewatch the "First Ever Three-Player Elbowpad Any Percent Completion Run™" of Secret of Mana again.
    Freaking hilarious run that deserves more attention.

  • @TheRasticuss
    @TheRasticuss Před 4 lety +4

    The summer of 1994 was the best summer. Spent all 3 months glued to this on the SNES. Best summer ever.

  • @customxphoto
    @customxphoto Před 3 lety +1

    Just found your channel and am loving it man! Really appreciate how in depth you get with reviews. I just started replaying golden sun then found your videos. Next is chrono trigger for sure. Had to comment once you made the Muppet song reference. Love your channel and I know it was a while ago but congrats on 1 mil!

  • @lfrenot
    @lfrenot Před 6 lety +34

    "you have a 1% chance of drop on the rare loot"
    *Monster Hunter player chuckles in the back*

    • @sirfailalotful
      @sirfailalotful Před 4 lety +5

      Menthols He didn’t say it was. Dial back your aggression.

    • @shenhue7041
      @shenhue7041 Před 4 lety +3

      Real grind starts with 0,01% drops ...

    • @kingkamina4953
      @kingkamina4953 Před 3 lety

      Charmfarming intensifies

  • @MrGRmask
    @MrGRmask Před 6 lety +238

    Didn't watch the episode yet but I hope Jirard will be annoyed by Neeko again.
    Edit: 21:29 OH YES THANK YOU!! I NEEDED THAT LAUGH XD

    • @pokejoseph
      @pokejoseph Před 6 lety +9

      NOW GIMME YOUR MONEY

    • @Nicholasryan17
      @Nicholasryan17 Před 6 lety

      When did the laugh happen?

    • @ChaosKat90
      @ChaosKat90 Před 6 lety +6

      Neeko the "Price Gouging" Cat

    • @Ragnarok1881
      @Ragnarok1881 Před 6 lety

      I honestly enjoy the SNES version. It's so artistic moreraw. Not sure how to explain it. I think it's the bits is what makes it more enjoyable to look at.

  • @ThatOneVideoGamer
    @ThatOneVideoGamer  Před 6 lety +150

    What game, that you purchased, disappointed you the most?

    • @themystikone
      @themystikone Před 6 lety +4

      The Completionist well I would have to say zone of the enders 2

    • @amendoim1027
      @amendoim1027 Před 6 lety +3

      Stuntman Ignition

    • @PK-oc5wg
      @PK-oc5wg Před 6 lety +13

      Evolve

    • @CharmQuarke
      @CharmQuarke Před 6 lety +1

      that’d have to be black desert online after having played ffxiv for months. looked good, played not so good

    • @decusq
      @decusq Před 6 lety +2

      Tales of Heart R for my vita.... that game is a stain on the Tales Franchise and on my download list.

  • @kpag3030
    @kpag3030 Před 4 lety +11

    I’ve always said Mana with the “ahh” sound. Not the “aaa” sound

  • @mlgjigglypuff6280
    @mlgjigglypuff6280 Před 6 lety +158

    Am i the only one that thinks the ps4 version looks like a phone game.

    • @sirfailalotful
      @sirfailalotful Před 4 lety +12

      Probably because the original SD was remade into a phone game and this one looks the same as that.

    • @Masterpain33
      @Masterpain33 Před 4 lety +2

      Mlg Jigglypuff the developers make only mobile games well Xeed does. They got way better with trials tho.

    • @lunch_trey
      @lunch_trey Před 3 lety +3

      I was actually thinking it could've passed as an early 3DS game

    • @atticusstephenson2895
      @atticusstephenson2895 Před rokem

      My first thought was it looked like a mobile game or a crisp 3ds game

    • @OperationFreeSoul
      @OperationFreeSoul Před 8 měsíci +1

      THANK YOU. That is my problem with so many of these reskin "remakes"

  • @michaelrhett4958
    @michaelrhett4958 Před 6 lety +6

    One of my favorite episodes! Thank you Jirard When I was rewatching all the past 120 episodes, I always went to watch that episode. It’s so freaking good!

  • @xebatansis
    @xebatansis Před 6 lety +18

    I was so happy when I first heard about the remake, but seeing the actual result is devastating: It has no soul; No effort. They just took the mobile version and slapped a PS4 label on it. And don' t get me started on the butchered OST.

  • @CRAIGworks
    @CRAIGworks Před 6 lety +2

    Yo, watching the live stream and seeing the the game crashing in real time was unreal and rough as all get out. Loved the episode! Keep up the good work!

  • @spookydonkey42
    @spookydonkey42 Před 6 lety

    Oh man, I just remembered that in-n-out drink cup that used to be in the background of the original intro haha it's been a long ride. Keep up the great work dude!

  • @dentuffakillen
    @dentuffakillen Před 5 lety +6

    my god, it took me three restarts of this video to realize you said "the SNES-era" and not "the ass-in-the-ass"-era right at the start.

  • @michaelcoffey1991
    @michaelcoffey1991 Před 5 lety +4

    Missed this game entirely so glad I get to enjoy it on my PS4.

  • @Hiro-qs3dn
    @Hiro-qs3dn Před 6 lety

    CONGRATULATIONS ON 900K!!!

  • @muticere
    @muticere Před 6 lety +23

    "In the US we know him as "Flame-y" whut? I always said "Flam-me"...

    • @reginaldfairfield2929
      @reginaldfairfield2929 Před 3 lety

      Same here... I'm from the US and all of my friends pronounced it as "Flam-me" too, haha

  • @sleepyeevee6299
    @sleepyeevee6299 Před 6 lety +80

    it's a secret to everyone.

  • @LOSTLEAD8R
    @LOSTLEAD8R Před 6 lety +343

    ah yes the three genders
    Man
    Woman
    Sprite

    • @JackhammerJesus
      @JackhammerJesus Před 5 lety +14

      Actually it is hero, woman, sprite.

    • @riffraff1880
      @riffraff1880 Před 5 lety

      LOSTLEAD8R lmao

    • @riffraff1880
      @riffraff1880 Před 5 lety +1

      JackhammerJesus her0? Really?

    • @JackhammerJesus
      @JackhammerJesus Před 5 lety +5

      Sorry, but my sources refer to them as "the hero", "the girl" and "the sprite".

    • @nowonmetube
      @nowonmetube Před 5 lety +6

      Man and Woman aren't genders, male and female are. Plus they are boy and girl.
      And to me, Sprite is a girl too.

  • @DeathMountaineersGaming

    This was one of your best voice overs, I liked it a lot man 🤙🏻

  • @treelightning2042
    @treelightning2042 Před 6 lety

    Really liked this episode keep up the great work !

  • @ChiefXuligan
    @ChiefXuligan Před 5 lety +16

    3:54 RIP only 3 player run of Secret of Mana to be completed. :’(

    • @KiritoLinkStartGaming
      @KiritoLinkStartGaming Před 4 lety +3

      do wonder if he will get removed from any videos where it won't be much work

    • @ceruleantear1
      @ceruleantear1 Před 4 lety +3

      It looks like the entire playthrough has been re-uploaded.

    • @ChiefXuligan
      @ChiefXuligan Před 4 lety +1

      cerulean tear yep! I made a playlist of them on my channel. 😁

  • @Tdrummer888
    @Tdrummer888 Před rokem +6

    Played the original with my older brother when we were around 11/12. Some of the most cherished memories of my life. The soundtrack single-handedly formed my love for music

  • @raikohzx4323
    @raikohzx4323 Před 6 lety +2

    for the love of god never let 14 guest composers with completely different styles between eachother remix an entire soundtrack as a grab bag

  • @benandthelion
    @benandthelion Před 6 lety

    Anybody else really put of by the pictures not being strait in the intro haha. Great video Jirard, loved secret of mana as a kid.

  • @Devo14218
    @Devo14218 Před 6 lety +25

    The nostalgia glasses are strong with this one

  • @BamadeusTTV
    @BamadeusTTV Před 6 lety +54

    Anybody hear the rumor that Jirard is a sweet, lovely dude?

    • @deconstructionjd514
      @deconstructionjd514 Před 6 lety +9

      Bamadeus ... Not a rumor. He is a beastly love-man.

    • @Nicholasryan17
      @Nicholasryan17 Před 6 lety +4

      You guys are so weird to just comment this

    • @BamadeusTTV
      @BamadeusTTV Před 6 lety +9

      If that is weird then I don't want to be normal.

  • @SkySimonePhotography
    @SkySimonePhotography Před 6 lety +1

    Lol I found your anger at Neko hilarious

  • @kpag3030
    @kpag3030 Před 4 lety +1

    My brother and sister and I did 3 player with this game. It was so fun. One of my all time faves. I was a teenager when it came out, but still... high on my all time list.

  • @BenWyldeZX
    @BenWyldeZX Před 6 lety +5

    I missed the Cannon Travel animations, even when there's a track just for that on the soundtrack as far as I know ...

  • @kirbysmith64
    @kirbysmith64 Před 6 lety +14

    Huh, this actually looks great for a PS2 game.
    ...Wait, what do you mean it's for the PS4?

  • @melissak1525
    @melissak1525 Před 6 lety +1

    Damn it! Now that Mana-mana song's stuck in my head.
    Again.
    Thanks Jirard :l

  • @syrenafury8559
    @syrenafury8559 Před 4 lety

    I felt this review so hard in my soul. Well done video. 👏 As a die hard SoM fan, I concur.

  • @svartfrasr9755
    @svartfrasr9755 Před 6 lety +25

    They could have pleased more by just releasing a translated version of the third game.

    • @Stephenguitar93
      @Stephenguitar93 Před 6 lety

      Riiiight!?

    • @SBaby
      @SBaby Před 6 lety +1

      They were going to, but the problem is they were using the remake of Secret of Mana to test the waters and see if there was interest in the series. When they saw all the people whining about the remake, they immediately gave up on ever releasing a Western port or remake of SD3.

    • @joelbaker9366
      @joelbaker9366 Před 5 lety +3

      You can find #3 with an english translation in emulation.

    • @Stephenguitar93
      @Stephenguitar93 Před 5 lety

      ^^ Yeah, and it's pretty good

    • @Atlessa
      @Atlessa Před 5 lety +8

      Oh boy do I have news for you. :D

  • @bgcvids8006
    @bgcvids8006 Před 5 lety +5

    Jirard: Click the “I” for the playthrough!
    Me: *Clicks the “I” and sees Tony Hawk*
    Me: *I Have Been Lied To...*

    • @Dakayto
      @Dakayto Před 4 lety

      czcams.com/video/QXpY6PI7Mac/video.html

  • @voidling2632
    @voidling2632 Před 5 lety +1

    21:55 i love that little Easter egg from legend of mana

  • @MrShadow2x
    @MrShadow2x Před 6 lety

    I remember clearly my introduction to Secret of Mana. It was toward the end of a summer when we were kids, and my cousin suddenly mentioned a game with a "chipmunk" that was super awesome. I had never heard of it before, but I began a quest to find it. We were able to rent it once and spent the entire weekend playing it. I needed to buy it. Took me forever to find a copy, I even had retro stores helping me. I happened across a boxed copy at a Babbage's and marched it to the counter and paid. Quest complete!

  • @nowonmetube
    @nowonmetube Před 5 lety +7

    SNES the golden era of RPGs

  • @AlKohaiMusic
    @AlKohaiMusic Před 6 lety +33

    The only things I can agree with here are the crashes and the load zones. Everything else, I’m kinda on board for. The remade music, for the most part, is on point. I picked up on the menu system instantly, and everything was pretty enjoyable. It didn’t erase the game I love, just gave me something else to enjoy.

  • @KevinTheTimeGeek86
    @KevinTheTimeGeek86 Před 6 lety

    Another great vid, Jirard. However, you using that Muppet song as a joke reminds me of a video my sister-in-law posted on Facebook of my nephew learning that song. He's 3 now and loves it when someone prompts him to sing it. So thank you for making me feel even more proud of him as his uncle.

  • @AnubisRazael
    @AnubisRazael Před 5 lety

    During the first time i ever played through SoM, I played with my brother and friend from across the street, when we realized that we had to grind, we would grind after school and make progression on Saturdays when we could game most of the day, it was awesome.

  • @TheBanishedWind
    @TheBanishedWind Před 4 lety +17

    12:26
    In defense of "un-DEEN" that's how I always pronounced it.
    I never considered the Long "I" until I met Undyne in Undertale.

  • @aztn19
    @aztn19 Před 6 lety +4

    The remake definitely felt like it came out as a GameCube or PS2 game in 2018. It felt like Mighty No. 9 did: just kinda okay, despite all the effort expected in this. But all the game crashes added to the original quirks left in a game that was supposedly rebuilt from the ground up, made it a rough time. And the because I did miss out on equipment drops only available in the Pure Lands, I had wished for an added Neeko shop to buy the rarest items to make completing the game possible without restarting all over - which I’m NOT doing!!! Choose the original over this

  • @ethos268
    @ethos268 Před 6 lety

    I've been wait for Secret of Mana (remake) since you announced you'd be redoing the original games completions! This is the video game that got me subscribed!

  • @BoggarthVT
    @BoggarthVT Před 5 lety +1

    I never played secret of mana, but looking at the screenshots that you shown us, I like the pixelated ones more.

  • @Ultima228
    @Ultima228 Před 6 lety +41

    I just realized that means you'll have to go through Skyrim again. Poor Jirard

    • @MabinogiKHVidegamer
      @MabinogiKHVidegamer Před 6 lety +9

      But on the flip side this time he can complete Kingdom Hearts 1 and 2 Final Mix instead of the vanilla versions of those games. I think he's in for a treat because KH2FM in particular is fantastic. One of the best games I ever played, if not the best.

    • @deconstructionjd514
      @deconstructionjd514 Před 6 lety

      MabinogiKHVidegamer He and Alex are playing KH2FM on Beard Bros. right now

    • @MabinogiKHVidegamer
      @MabinogiKHVidegamer Před 6 lety

      Deconstruction JD Interesting. Never watched BBs but I may check it out.

    • @deconstructionjd514
      @deconstructionjd514 Před 6 lety

      MabinogiKHVidegamer I prefer them leaps and bounds beyond Game Grumps or the other let's play channels that i won't name. But yeah, good stuff.

    • @gamersinacontainer
      @gamersinacontainer Před 6 lety

      Ultima228 hell probably play the remake

  • @aureliabackup7313
    @aureliabackup7313 Před 6 lety +3

    Squarenix: lets update these early-PS1 graphics to be late-PS1 graphics!
    Me: for what purpose?

  • @Chriselda89
    @Chriselda89 Před 5 lety +1

    I loved secret of mana! It was my 1st RPG game I played n I loved it! I was so happy when the game was on the mini Nintendo Consoles!!

  • @Hayden_O
    @Hayden_O Před 6 lety

    You're almost at 900k subs! Congrats!

  • @SkylerLinux
    @SkylerLinux Před 4 lety +10

    Well this ep hasn't aged well.

    • @magusx1125
      @magusx1125 Před 4 lety +1

      @Menthols he usually receives his games for free ;)
      But, I totally agree with you. Games should be released not-broken!

  • @Howema
    @Howema Před 6 lety +7

    there was a triple pack of mana games that came out in japan with original pixel art but we didn't get it because it might take away from this remake. the GB release, this game, and the sequel we never got.

    • @shupasopni
      @shupasopni Před 6 lety +1

      Should of had Legend of Mana too.

    • @Howema
      @Howema Před 6 lety +1

      would of been great but that would of just made things worse considering we didn't even get the product that did come out.

    • @Atlessa
      @Atlessa Před 5 lety

      Boy do I have news for you. :)

  • @dr.jotarorobotnick813
    @dr.jotarorobotnick813 Před 6 lety

    I have said this multiple times but the new game plus intro is Amazing. I can't stop listening to it

  • @hallodom
    @hallodom Před 5 lety

    I found your channel for the first time yesterday through the hollow knight play through. I love it! Great enjoyable content. Good choice of games. Thank you.

  • @kaneo1
    @kaneo1 Před 5 lety +4

    Solution: play the Android version. It DOES look & sound like an HD remaster.
    But I am NOT dumping my SNES cartridge!
    PS: Ring Menus are still the most intuitive complex interface I've ever seen

  • @MetalSmasherGaming
    @MetalSmasherGaming Před 5 lety +11

    What we've seen so far of the Trials of Mana (Seiken Densetsu 3) remake already looks miles ahead of this.

    • @mac1bc
      @mac1bc Před 4 lety +1

      Good to hear

  • @Herowebcomics
    @Herowebcomics Před 6 lety

    Heck yeah!
    I have been waiting for this!

  • @flyingfist4203
    @flyingfist4203 Před 5 lety

    Jirard was the cool kid on the playground. So what happened? XD
    Great video!

  • @SaviroLPs
    @SaviroLPs Před 6 lety +120

    I've never played either the original or remake, but it just seems like Jirard is too intoxicated on nostalgia and very petty with some of his complaints

    • @s3raphh
      @s3raphh Před 6 lety +2

      SaviroLPs I agree

    • @L1701
      @L1701 Před 6 lety +2

      Yeah, it does feel like that Jirard is way too bitter about his remake. The updated graphics don't look that bad to me. And yeah, I do agree that the menus needed a bit more panache, but otherwise, I don't see why Jirard is so angry about it. Maybe he should have just stuck to the original SNES version.

    • @alistair4909
      @alistair4909 Před 6 lety +1

      I agree I actually really dig the art style just wish the textures and polygons didn't look like an early psn game and that the colors popped a bit more. I probably won't play it though due to price and their being better ps4 games for the same price or less also any game that crashes 30 times kinda scares the hell out of me lol.

    • @WhiteSupreme
      @WhiteSupreme Před 6 lety +11

      "I never played either of them"
      Okay so your opinions are irrelevant.

    • @Dwapook
      @Dwapook Před 6 lety +5

      This remake has 63 on Metacritic.. an iOS port of the SNES version that has emulation issues and touch controls has an 80.. It's not just Jirard..

  • @thecrow1901
    @thecrow1901 Před 4 lety +6

    and the better remaster trials of mana is on the Switch hell yes

    • @timothyroehm4307
      @timothyroehm4307 Před 4 lety

      The Crow :Square better not fuck it up or else Charlotte, Angela, and Reize will be very upset with them!!!

    • @supersaiyaman11589
      @supersaiyaman11589 Před 3 lety

      trials of mana is also on steam and i love trials of mana. the weird thing that i still have not gotten used to is wene steam has a sale it can be a lot better than sales on ebay or amazon lol.

  • @Marscandy1
    @Marscandy1 Před rokem +1

    Now that song is in my head 😂!

  • @lunch_trey
    @lunch_trey Před 3 lety

    Secret of Mana (the original) was actually the first video game I played with my niece (who was 4 at the time). I was playing it on my mini and she saw Popoi's sprite and loved their hair color. I told her the game was 2-player, plugged in the second controller and we even took a boss down together. After that, I introduced her to other SNES games I played as a kid and some I didn't get to play until I was an adult. If she ever decides to be a gamer too, I just want that to be the first gaming memory she'll look back on.

  • @Pixelslayer
    @Pixelslayer Před 6 lety +22

    I love how all these great classics get remade.
    I'm just waiting for Dragon Ball Tenkaichi 2/3 to be follow suite

    • @nothanksfools
      @nothanksfools Před 6 lety +1

      Pixel Slayer dude I wished

    • @kainhighwind2
      @kainhighwind2 Před 6 lety +5

      I'm still waiting for Legend of Dragoon >.>

    • @WhiteSupreme
      @WhiteSupreme Před 6 lety +1

      They all get ruined.

    • @TerdSmasher303
      @TerdSmasher303 Před 6 lety +1

      Oddly enough I would rather have a Dragonball Origins 1&2 remake as one game on the Switch or something.

    • @kainhighwind2
      @kainhighwind2 Před 6 lety +1

      Know what's an unknown gem? Dragon Ball: The Revenge of King Piccolo. It was a Wii 2.5d platformer/beat em up.

  • @noircore
    @noircore Před 6 lety +137

    Not gonna lie, Jirard, the "default name" thing is a silly complaint. Most games nowadays do this, but apparently you're not sure how to feel with it here? That's sorta silly over something minor.

    • @ceruleantear1
      @ceruleantear1 Před 6 lety +13

      I admit it's a strange complaint and yet it's one that a lot of older players will feel. When you play a game and are given sole decision to name your characters it really adds to your connection to the characters. On several occasions I will spend minutes relaxing on my couch contemplating what I should name my character because the name will add to his personality. However, when the characters are given a name already then your decision is to use the name the developer gave them or change it. To be honest, it feels a little odd when I change it.
      Allow me to give you an example which will clarify my point. When you adopt an old dog from the shelter, you are allowed to call it whatever you want, but odds are this dog has already been given a name by his previous owners or by the shelter workers.

    • @noircore
      @noircore Před 6 lety +8

      cerulean tear But the "owners" of the SoM characters don't care if you change the name. Why would they give the option to change the name otherwise? This is coming from one who prefers to use the default names for characters that already have their own unique backstory, customizable or not like Robin in FE13.

    • @Nicholasryan17
      @Nicholasryan17 Před 6 lety +7

      +cerulean tear What a stupid thing to waste time on. "What text do you want to appear a few times that does nothing". It doesn't matter if Link's name is Link or buttfarts. Hes still Link regardless.

    • @XFrozenAshX
      @XFrozenAshX Před 6 lety +7

      Link? Red? Blue? All of these names and others are around in the early games. Unless we're talking even further back. Maybe we shouldn't have named Pac man that and just let everybody else decide what he should be called. It's the stupidest fucking argument.

    • @GeminiTasiri
      @GeminiTasiri Před 6 lety +13

      It's a weird complaint since the characters had those names for a while (as far as I can understand it, the US localization back in the day just kinda erased the names for the more generic Boy / Girl / Sprite - so it's really just getting corrected).
      I also find it weird that he harps on the game for the artstyle. I found the low-poly-ish, cartoonish artstyle fits the game very well and I actually really liked how they translated the pixel-art into 3D models. The elementals especially look very awesomely detailed if you look at them in the Album (they're modelled after their artwork from Children Of Mana onwards)

  • @Version0111
    @Version0111 Před 6 lety

    This review reminds me of my feelings when I played Wild Arms: Alter Code F.

  • @Mystic-Aidan
    @Mystic-Aidan Před 6 lety +2

    Yeah! I love your content, and this is another amazing video! Keep up the awesome work! If I could make a simple request, could you please make a “Defend It” for Labo, or a Star Allies video? That would be amazing. If you don’t, I respect you, and hope you keep pumping out more awesome content!

  • @salmence100
    @salmence100 Před 6 lety +74

    Seeing the chrono trigger rerelease, it makes me grateful we got the 3d remake of secret of mana, even if its not as beautiful as the pixel art. Also I really dont get what you meant from the new music sounding worse. That example you gave still sounded beautiful

    • @paulwilliams8278
      @paulwilliams8278 Před 6 lety +5

      the redid music, isnt bad, it just didnt have anywhere near the same tempo or feel as the old music.

    • @LordOberic1
      @LordOberic1 Před 6 lety +12

      That one song example was a huge difference. It turned from "magical fantasy world music" to "cabin next to a forest music"

    • @RevorDragon
      @RevorDragon Před 6 lety +1

      trust me, theres some tracks they absolutely butcher, like a jumble of noise, like look up the remakes version of potos village on youtube

    • @samus20018
      @samus20018 Před 6 lety +1

      Most of the remix music is fine but the one that did it for me was The Oracle (Dark Lich's battle theme). They took a creepy sounding song and turned it into more of a rock song.

    • @robertnason9420
      @robertnason9420 Před 6 lety

      It doesn't even sound the same

  • @KittyKatty999
    @KittyKatty999 Před 6 lety +39

    I personally like the new art style. It generally has a cute art style, and bad voices can be entertaining.
    I never really cared for this game, but I don't like the hate for the graphics from other youtubers.

    • @christianlopez707
      @christianlopez707 Před 6 lety +5

      I honestly dont see the problem it looks cartoonish which fits with the story and tone, plus they resemble there characters.

    • @michag798
      @michag798 Před 6 lety +5

      Irrational nostalgia blind is always trendy ya know.

    • @Wobbey363
      @Wobbey363 Před 6 lety +6

      It looks kinda bland honestly. They could of done so much more in detail especially since it's a PS4 game.

    • @christianlopez707
      @christianlopez707 Před 6 lety +1

      Wobbey363 If i had to make a guess i think it was originally made for the vita like the previous game but moved it to PS4 to increase sells in the west.

    • @Kuma5655
      @Kuma5655 Před 6 lety

      I think they could've done better for it being on the PS4 , but the aesthetic is pleasing.

  • @NamekuBushi
    @NamekuBushi Před 6 lety

    I actually like the remix example you gave. It sounded soothing.

  • @sirdan1987
    @sirdan1987 Před 6 lety

    Yea, I'm basically the same why you feel about this game too. I will add though they did add something to the item wheel, they now display the character's icon, which actually helped out.
    Aside from that, thanks for this review.

  • @themidnightotaku22
    @themidnightotaku22 Před 6 lety +4

    I’m thinking about completing the Kingdom Hearts series on proud mode since I’ve beaten most of the stories & at least played the ones with unfamiliar mechanics. I’ve also played some of the beginning of KHII on this mode already(I never thought defeating 3 dusks would take so long.)
    Does anyone out there, who’s played this mode already, have any advice for me?

    • @connorhickey2666
      @connorhickey2666 Před 4 lety

      Lol I know this is late to reply but kh proud mode is easy and I began playing the series in 2017 sooooooo
      Yep

  • @c-puff
    @c-puff Před 6 lety +18

    The original's music is VASTLY superior. It's not just you, Jirard.

    • @bottle1211
      @bottle1211 Před 6 lety +2

      VASTLY?? Nice exaggeration. VASTLY blah blah blah nostalgia

  • @TheBrendon67
    @TheBrendon67 Před 6 lety

    That box art though!
    Entrancing!!!!!!!

  • @melrinightwind4824
    @melrinightwind4824 Před 6 lety

    Thank you so much for reviewing this game!! I really love Secret of Mana so this is a perfect opportunity to see what I have purchased. Like you, I am rather disappointed in the graphics quality of the remake version. I hope I do not get turn off from it when I actually play it!!
    And also thank you for adding the rating bar thing at the end. I am very happy to see that!! The new static animated graphics of "review" and the previous one is also a great addition to the video format!! I hope you will continue adding that graphic to your future videos~

  • @LagrimaArdiente
    @LagrimaArdiente Před 6 lety +108

    The graphics look adorable and based on the footage shown of the original, they seem like a wonderful translation. I do feel that the colors look washed out a bit, though.
    I think both versions of the track sound nice. I don't think the remake one is bad/worse. That said, I understand being disappointed in the changes because if you hadn't told me they were the same song... I don't think I would have been able to tell. At least, not in the moment. It sucks when something you love is changed in a way that it's hard to recognize.
    The voice acting sounded serviceable. *shrug* I've had to put up with worse.
    I can sympathize with the menu gripes and game crashes frustration.

    • @Alvilos
      @Alvilos Před 6 lety +8

      Its alright mate, you are allowed to be wrong =P

    • @noircore
      @noircore Před 6 lety +11

      Alvilos Please don't be that guy. This person gave a pretty objective response and their trivial opinion is not "wrong", nor is it "right".

    • @TigerWolf111
      @TigerWolf111 Před 6 lety +6

      *Alvilos* your entire comment is "wrong"...

    • @Alvilos
      @Alvilos Před 6 lety +3

      guys it was an obvious joke. relax people. I might not agree with this opinion but my response was sooo blatantly joking around.

    • @rewt3406
      @rewt3406 Před 6 lety +4

      What I think The Completionist wanted from the game is as follows:
      A feeling that the world is alive and real. The stages and areas just have still three-dimensional figures that do nothing. If they were going to go for a realistic look then it will feel off compared to what it really is. Lets take the part in 13:40 for example. The flowers don't flow in the wind nor the trees, and the lilli pads don't flow down the stream. The grass looks so bright which doesn't work well with characters who are also bright and colorful.
      Going through school and also learning from big company mistakes, you only need realistic looking objects in scenes where it can be used properly. Secret of mana doesn't need this and could had played off of a more Pokemon esc look. Not entirely but just enough of a more darker tone.
      When it comes to music, its also good to note that depending on how you want the player to feel determines what you play during a certain event. The Completionist compares two tracks: one sounds energetic but magical while the other sounds more slow and calm. If I were to be going through a dungeon or battle, I would not play this music. In fact, I might not even play this music even while in a town. The remade music would fit better in a more cut scene like moment.
      And the bugs are a issue. No game should release with problems. It hampers the fun of the game.

  • @KingDanieltheDandy
    @KingDanieltheDandy Před 6 lety +68

    I quite like the remake

    • @Watsabeholder
      @Watsabeholder Před 6 lety +7

      King Daniel The Dandy because of your suspicious King Dedede Avatar, I can only read this as sarcastic.

    • @Doosie0124
      @Doosie0124 Před 6 lety +5

      I also did like it. Jirard is just being a fucking dick, as usual.

    • @domscards
      @domscards Před 6 lety +4

      TheDoos It was bad.

    • @elgigante2001
      @elgigante2001 Před 6 lety +3

      King Daniel The Dandy I like how your DeDeDe avatar is giving the evil eye. Like saying I will kill you for not liking the remake. 😂

    • @Watsabeholder
      @Watsabeholder Před 6 lety +3

      DommY CS it seems like the technical issues are the worst thing involved. He comments on the music, but it can be changed back to the original. The VO is a jrpg VO, so... I fully expected it to be terrible. That just doesn't seem that bad.

  • @coreymichaels3389
    @coreymichaels3389 Před 6 lety

    Ah, the dancing Footloose guy, Neeko the Price-Gouging Cat, and the uncooperative computer-player. I miss those old episodes.

  • @Qramm14
    @Qramm14 Před 6 lety

    Thank you for expressing exactly how i feel about the game.

  • @mattislarsson132
    @mattislarsson132 Před 6 lety +3

    My first playthrough of Secret of Mana was with my best friend, in a snow covered cabin somewhere in a dark Swedish forest. Still one of my favourite games Also Top 2 best soundtracks ever.

  • @OoDarksniper2
    @OoDarksniper2 Před 6 lety +8

    never played Secret of mana but I would rather have a Chrono Trigger remake instead.

    • @OoDarksniper2
      @OoDarksniper2 Před 6 lety +2

      I mean a true 3D remake the Ds version is literally a port of the Snes version but with the cool exclusive Ps1 anime cutscenes.

    • @TheGauges420
      @TheGauges420 Před 6 lety

      OoDarksniper2 and a rack of extra content, not just cutscenes lmao. Regardless, there is already a remaster of chrono trigger just like the other guy said, doesnt matter that its not 3d, its literally what youve already asked for...

    • @ViruZ42
      @ViruZ42 Před 6 lety

      We almost got a 3d remaster during the ps2 era go look up chrono resurrection when you get the chance still say square should have scooped the devs rather than slapping them with a c&d

    • @OoDarksniper2
      @OoDarksniper2 Před 6 lety

      I'll look into it when I have a chance thanks.

    • @natefactor4336
      @natefactor4336 Před 4 lety

      PLEASE DONT RUIN CHRONO TRIGGER, Leave it be.

  • @Manjibutt
    @Manjibutt Před 5 lety

    That's a pretty fair review score. My first reaction after watching this video was too go with "look at it", but then I said to myself "...well maybe I'd play it". And then I saw the brilliance of your rating system.
    Honestly, this game was a nightmare to stream on PS4. With how often it kept crashing, it was nearly impossible for me to stream adequately because everytime the game crashed, my PS4 stream stopped because the PS4 doesn't allow capture of it's UI (which has frustrated so much whenever I've wanted to screenshot anything I've streamed on it lately)

  • @constantinbentlewski6128

    HAHA, i love your palces where you told yoru grinding palces... i use them too

  • @radioactiveriver6718
    @radioactiveriver6718 Před 6 lety +37

    Mananana dudududu Mananana dududu Mananana dudududu dududu dududu dudududu

  • @seangdovic4967
    @seangdovic4967 Před 6 lety +8

    Yikes, the visuals in game are in dire need of post processing effects and better lighting effects. Also, a lot of areas he has shown in the video look really flat because the artists have over relied on textures and normal maps rather than actually modeling the environment. That's bad... That's really bad. I think I'll play the original on my SNES instead. With the exception of the Resident Evil Remake, I have not seen a single remake that has better than or even as good as the original.

  • @deathmansdog
    @deathmansdog Před 6 lety

    I know you won't see this. But I wanted to let the completionist know that I love his channel. I've been veiwing his channel from the start. I know times are tough for everyone. But just knowing that every Friday there's a new video. Brings me peace. Without your videos I'd be lost. Thank you for just being you. You Rock

  • @seawind930
    @seawind930 Před 6 lety

    GITT OFF ME LAWNN, welcome to old age, you are now a nostalgia retrogamer.

  • @pondypoo
    @pondypoo Před 6 lety +5

    This review is heavily clouded by nostalgia, more than usual in fact

    • @mac1bc
      @mac1bc Před 4 lety +1

      Well I agree with him as I'm playing through it. I hate these loading screens the most.

  • @WilkinsMC
    @WilkinsMC Před 5 lety +6

    Everyone I've seen review this game says the original is better, then goes on to list half a dozen things that make the remake better. I've played both and truly do believe the remake is better.

    • @cronoesify
      @cronoesify Před 4 lety

      The remake IS better - nostalgia is what puts the original over the remake. The remake was a directional misstep - but the execution of that direction (choosing to give SOM the AOM treatment) was actually quite fine.
      The problem is people heavily overrate the original game, so when they are looking at those mechanics in a modern light, there is a constant lingering desire for more than what was given.
      Trials of Mana seems like SE understood that lesson - remaking a console game, even a console game from 25 years ago, is almost always going to have greater expectations than remaking an old game boy game that no one played.

  • @sirflimflam
    @sirflimflam Před 6 lety

    I actually enjoyed the minimap quite a bit. It gave you the old SNES map and you could see how it was brought to the new format one-to-one.

  • @yomatokamari
    @yomatokamari Před 6 lety

    I'll fight you, Jirard. My beard can pierce the heavens.

  • @manpig873
    @manpig873 Před 6 lety +3

    I miss “BUT BEARDMAN”

    • @danielpintogouveia5862
      @danielpintogouveia5862 Před 6 lety

      Sansy boy Man No

    • @Casanuda
      @Casanuda Před 4 lety +1

      I don't, that guy sucked and literally dragged down the show for years. This is much, much better.

  • @EXHellfire
    @EXHellfire Před 5 lety +3

    The way it looks I think it's likely that if they had remade it for the PSP back then, it would have looked almost the same on that system. It has zero business being a current gen game with those assets. If they had gone a different route and made it have gorgeous spritework like say what you can see in Crimson Gem Saga, that would have been better received I think. Just keep it portable. If you'll make it a PS4 thing then it's just a cocktease because everyone would rather have a full blown AAA budget style version of it instead...

  • @sclmulti
    @sclmulti Před 6 lety

    I subscribed when I saw the first SoM episode. I laughed so hard I got a stomach ache.
    "REEEEEEEAD MEEEEEEEE!"

  • @jamiewalsh3349
    @jamiewalsh3349 Před 6 lety +1

    The SNES had A LOT of great JRPG's. So much so that I got a SNES Mini for Christmas just to play them. But I never knew what Secret of Mana (Mah-na) was, and that it was getting a remake on PS4