Sunnis claim: that the Quran without hadith would have 1000s of definitions, and everyone would be making their own interpretation. #quran #hadith #sunnah #muslims
@@haidar1080First you must be sincere. Free yourself from the man made garbage books. Stop reading the Sunni corrupt interpretation of the Quran. Do some research. Follow the best of it..(Az Zumar 18)
"They are the ones who examine all words, then follow THE BEST. These are the one whom God guided; these are the ones who possess intelligence." 39:18 For any words to be the best there must be no errors nor any contradiction, words to hold His protections that it cannot be altered or changed, where no falsehood can ever enter it. THE BEST IS ONLY THE TRUTH. "Indeed, it is the Glorious Quran in a Preserved Tablet." 85:21-22
"Those are the ones whom God has cursed,so He made them deaf and blinded their sight. Do they not reflected on Quran? Or do the hearts have their locks on them?" 47:23-24 "Those are the ones whom God has sealed their hearts, their hearings and their sights; they are the oblivious ones." 16:108
Salaamun Alayikum brother. Alhamdullillah for this topic. Great one. Only those who believe in Quran will watch this video with open heart. Once you follow Quran you are on the right path no doubt. May Allah reward you. ❤
Say (O Muhammad), "I am not not a novelty among other messengers nor do i know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing but what is revealed to me (Quran). I am no more than a clear warner." 46:9 "Worship God and do not associate anything with him." 4:36 "God bear witness that there is no God except Him, and so do the angels and those who possess knowledge." 3:18 "He is the Possessor of the Highest Ranks and the Possessor of the Throne." 40:15
Regardless of your attempts to justify it, that commentator is still right. The differences of opinion between hadith rejecters is insane. You guys can't even agree on whether "salat" actually means prayer or not or whether the Qibla is in Mecca or Petra. And this is BASIC stuff compared to actually HOW to pray. Whereas there is no hadith accepter that disagrees on the meaning of salat or where to pray etc etc regardless of sect or school of thought. And what's amazing is that hadith rejecters will take the "hadiths" of other hadith rejecters on CZcams on how to pray but they'll reject the hadiths of the Prophet Muhammad(pbuh&f) on how to pray subhanAllah
Other Quran alone following Muslims are not my followers. Those who are confused with Salat are basically Sunni Shia biased. Allah will inform them and you of what you differ. It doesn't matter if you have misunderstood the Quran, as long as you are trying to follow the Book of Allah, you are rightly guided. But following hadiths will guide you to hell. You Quran rejectors don't understand the fundamental command of Allah. That is to follow only the Quran. Allah guides whomever he wills. Not me, not the prophet (passed away). saying book of Allah is a misguidance is kuffr! Hadith following imam worshippers are mushriks!
Salamun alaikum brother. I have commented on your video of salat part 3 but looks like you dont see comments on old video. Anyways thanks for your analysis but i need some clarifications in quran which tells about salat times and verse which says afrer salat do dhijr standing sitting resting etc.also what is importance of juma salah
Walikkum salam, I didn't get any notification on it. I will check it. Well the problem is until you remove your misunderstanding that ritual prayer is salah, you cannot understand the word salah. That's what i have been explaining in my salah videos. I am planning to explain all the misunderstandings people got about Salah when i get some time. *إنْ شاء الله* The Salat you are referring to is Salah sessions. Jummah salah is not Quthbah like in Sunni/Shia masjid, it's a day of gathering for salah session. Not Friday. Muslims later invented this Friday into Jummah day. Jews got sabath and christians got Sunday, Muslims need a day so they came up with Jummah day. Yes Allah says "Yumuh Jummah" in the Quran, but it is day of gathering for Salat session. It got nothing to do with rituals. If you think Salat is a ritual, then how can you explain the big issues: 1. No step by step guide to the ritual prayer in the Quran. 2. why Allah has to say After you complete your "ritual prayer", remember Allah standing, and sitting... so is that mean "ritual prayer" not remembering Allah? 3. can you pray 24/7? 4. and there are out of context in those ayahs when you think it's ritual prayer. you will have to leave indoctrinated stuff out and think freely then you will understand. If you question everything, then you will understand.
Thank you brother. Yes I agree with you to remove this long fed rituals. Iam trying to comeout from that. Just to be confident and make sure i wanted to clarify on this. There are some ayats mentioned on time like before dawn and once you complete salat do dhikr by sitting standing and resting etc. Please help. Also pls suggest any good translation quran in English
@@syedmohammedriyaz3762 Some of the Ayahs talk to just the prophet in singular. It's for him. Some of them are for everyone, for us to glorify Allah. We have to look into the grammar and context of what it is trying to say. In most translations, the translator includes his assumptions based on Sunni indoctrination. The reason why have so much hard time understanding. Even the Arabs don't pay attention to them. Shabir Ahmed Translation is good, but not the best. You will never be able to find a perfect translation. By reading with the context you can have an idea. For example: those who say there is 3 times ritual salat in the Quran, they don't look at the context. Context is Divorce and Widow, why Allah gotta talk about ritual prayer in it? also why is he mixing plural and singular in it? Is there a Ritual Prayer called "Salatul Wusta"? Then which one is Salaul Wusta? Asar or Duhar? Since Allah did not mention them in the Quran how can we accept outside influence? if accept outside influence then we are saying Quran is not a fully detailed book. Then we are rejecting the Quran. So even accepting just one outside element can make us as a Quran rejector. There are many Quran followers who believe in Ritual prayer. But that is without understanding fundamental Quranic principles. 1. Follow Quran alone nothing else. 2. We are not allowed to follow Assumptions, even if its our own assumptions. 3. We are not allowed to reject the Quran.
I have observed base on objective observation there has been a significant variation of Interpretation, understanding and explanation of the Quran from people from different geographic location. How will the Quran only believers reconcile among themselves in the interpretation and understanding of Quran in Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Syria and other parts of Africa is quite different from the practices, interpretation and understanding from the people in Sri Lanka, India, Pakistan and Bangladesh? example is the way in performing prayer, going to pilgrimage, call to prayer, process remembrance of Allah, the Importance of Zayd ( a person mention in the Quran) in the life time of prophet Muhammad s.a.w. etc. So who gives the most accurate interpretation and understanding of the Quran only, the Middle eastern/ north african Quranist or the South asian Quranist group?
No, not really, Significant? that's a bit of a stretch. Arab countries are mostly Influenced by Hambali and Maliki, so their interpretation is based on that. North Africa is predominantly Shafih-influenced. And their understanding and usage of the language from how they were taught. As for Desi (Indian, Pakistani, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka...) countries had to learn from the translations and Saudi influence. Also mostly they are Shafih and Hanafi influenced. But people like me (Quran alone followers) go to the core of the language, root letter study, context, grammar, and usage. We don't need the lifetime of the prophet. If you think we need the lifetime of the prophet to understand the Quran, then you are insulting Allah for sending you an incomplete imperfect book that is not useful for all times. Also, Islam will be like the Hindu religion, where you wait for your imams and scholars to explain the Quran and you follow it blindly. I believe you are a Sunni. You are already on the wrong path and fear Allah. Don't insult Allah. Quran interpretation is just one, understanding can be different based on the individual's knowledge and taqwa. We still have Quran-alone followers who are holding on to Sunni/Shia ideologies, so their interpretation will be based on how they were taught. I totally 100% reject Shia/Sunni ideologies so when i am interpreting something i question myself if i am being influenced by what i was taught. I am working on correcting myself at that as well. Some words I used, and greetings were from how was taught. Most of them are already corrected. But you might be able to catch it in my CZcams videos. i am not talking about Quran interpretation. As for Quran interpretation I use Sunni translations to make them understand so that we won't have an interpretation argument like this.
@@YasirAddaee For example Dr. Hany Atchan being a pure quranist himself used the same methodology, by using the core of the language, root letter study, context, grammar, and usage in all his CZcams videos lasting several hours each. Yet after going thru his lectures I can see a really significant variation interpretation of the Quran from the rest of the mainstream Quranist movement. And there are many people like him. For example, Prophet Ismael in the Quran is actually prophet Muhammad himself if the deeper meaning and understanding of linguistics is really studies and internalized. So needles' to say, who should follow who's interpretation? Shall anyone just follow his guts and follow which Quran Daee to follow? The Egyptian, syrian, tunisian, bangali, indian, sri lankan or pakistani Daee? I am also just curious, how can a pure Quran only follower be influenced by the sunni school of thought ( Handbali, Shafii, Maliki etc..), when it is not even mentioned in the Quran that this should be followed? Who determines what is innovation and what is not base on the Quran only movement?
@@YasirAddaee @YasirAddaee For example Dr. Hany Atchan being a pure quranist himself used the same methodology, by using the core of the language, root letter study, context, grammar, and usage in all his CZcams videos lasting several hours each. Yet after going thru his lectures I can see a really significant variation interpretation of the Quran from the rest of the mainstream Quranist movement. And there are many people like him. For example, Prophet Ismael in the Quran is actually prophet Muhammad himself if the deeper meaning and understanding of linguistics is really studies and internalized. So needles' to say, who should follow who's interpretation? Shall anyone just follow his guts and follow which Quran Daee to follow? The Egyptian, syrian, tunisian, bangali, indian, sri lankan or pakistani Daee? I am also just curious, how can a pure Quran only follower be influenced by the sunni school of thought ( Handbali, Shafii, Maliki etc..), when it is not even mentioned in the Quran that this should be followed? Who determines what is innovation and what is not base on the Quran only movement? //As for Quran interpretation I use Sunni translations to make them understand so that we won't have an interpretation argument like this.// ---Why don't you like engage in debate, 98% of all your video are directed to attacking the Ahlul sunna followers?
@YasirAddaee no not that I said look 20:75-20:76 come as believer and work righteous you get tazakaa so zakat about believe and righteous work Which why I said my bad Also 9:60 said sadaqat is fard which also found in surah al ahzab which link to Sunnatullah as fard impose to rasulullah is Sunnatullah is in 33:38 Nope still not 2.5%
[He] who gives [from] his wealth to purify himself And not [giving] for anyone who has [done him] a favor to be rewarded But only seeking the countenance of his Lord, Most High.92:18-20
Only Allah knows. Why worry about those things. Just follow the Quran. Sunnis and Shias are so focused because they are waiting for Mahdi, Dajjal, and Jesus. It has nothing to do with the Quran. Only Allah knows when the End time will come. No one has that knowledge.
It's a youtube channel name "the muslim lantern" who tries to prove that the hadith are correct and made a video on questions, answers, facts, ect.etc.. how the hadith is authentic and what not.
I don't have time for debates. Muslims shouldn't debate pointlessly on the words of Allah without confirmed understanding. Allah doesn't like those who are arrogant. I have detailed videos on Salat you can go watch them, if you are not happy with it, don't worry Allah will inform you on what you differ in Qiyamah. Baba Shuaib is a Muslim (Quran alone follower), doesn't matter if we have differences of opinions and understanding on some subjects. I don't make these videos to make money or to show how great I am. My job here is to make people think that's all. Be humble with the Quran, so that Allah will help you understand and have mercy on you. WasSalaam
@@YasirAddaee I pray 5 times to be safe. I don’t want any hate. I wouldn’t ask you for you to debate him if you wouldn’t mind people performing ritual Salah. I see you get angry sometimes when people don’t respect your views. Please try to calm down if people don’t agree with you. Salam.
@@Ox1326 I have detailed videos on Ritual prayer go watch them. Please don't waste my time. I get angry when people don't watch the videos and keep on arguing about the subject without understanding while they are committing Shirk. You don't like to watch the videos that's fine! My time is valuable to debate with people. If you like praying 5 times or 500 times that's upto you. If you like following blindly it's upto you. You will be questioned in Qiyamah not me.
@@Ox1326 Do you even know what is the definition of view is? following sunnism is not a view. It's dogma. Following Imams of the past is not a view. view is when you form a theory based on misunderstanding is a view. According to the Quran, all the views are assumptions except for the words of Allah. If you say you have a view on the Quranic Ayah then you are saying Quran is not detailed! Allah says Quran is detailed. But you are saying no its not detailed. If you like to follow your views why do you need Quran?
There seems to be two different extremes when it comes to following Qur'an and sunnah. There are people who totally reject hadeeths which contains sunnah and other information of islamic laws and there are people who believe sahi hadeeths cannot be questioned at all. The fact is Allah revealed Qur'an to prophet Muhammad s.a.w and after his death his followers had this Qur'anic revealation in their memories and also had it in written form scattered,many followers use to recite it in different dialects which use to sometime give different meanings etc. So it was decided by the senior authorities to compile it in a book form and reject quran in different dialects and thanks to their great service we have only one Qur'an which is same all over the world but when it comes to sunnah the practice and preachings of prophet s.a.w without which islam cannot be understood at all because everyone can give their own interpretation of Quran. These hadeeth use to be narrated by different people , some were authentic some were authentic but with the own understanding of the narrator some were totally fabricated etc. Later on the scholars tried to collect and authenticate the hadeeths but it wasn't like quran and naturally it wasn't clean from errors . If we follow quran and judge the hadeeths according to quran and if its in line with quran then there should be no problem because without hadeeths its impossible to follow the deen which was revealed by Allah because we cannot understand quran without the help of prophet s.a.w on whom it was revealed. Our efforts should be applied to distinguish which hadeeth is correct or not but this attitude of rejecting the hadeeths in totally is 100% deviation from the manhaj of sahabas who use to quote both quran and the ways of prophet s.a w whenever they use use to make some laws . I just have one question to the hadeeth rejectors ...just prove the dead fish from the sea is halaal according to Qur'an without using the hadeeth! Or declare its haram to eat dead fish which is clearly mentioned in Qur'an that dead living things is not allowed to eat? Without using the hadeeths write a booklet how to perform hajj according to Qur'an. There are so many things if you reject the hadeeth totally even a kaafir on the street would not recognise you as a muslim .
you don't know what you are talking about. you are repeating what your gods taught you. Learn before you open your ignorance to the world. I have videos explaining all your saitan worship on my channel you can watch those. Do you think you are the first to expose their own ignorance to me? and you won't be the last.
@@YasirAddaee come to the point and don't try to deviate. All dead creatures are haram. Why is not dead fish haraam? Just give the answer from Qur'an? I don't want your explanation because your explanation is nothing in comparison to even a Daef hadeeth. Let me also know how to perform hajj in detail according to Qur'an without using hadeeth or any historical evidence because if hadeeths cannot be followed nothing cannot be followed , you cannot say we have seen people doing this rituals for years so we can follow them,what is the proof that what people have been doing is according to Qur'an because 99.9% of them believe in traditional scholars and according to you they are liars so just let me know according to Qur'an all the procedures. Let me also know who were the sahabas who had similar belief like you ? For whom tradition of Prophet s.a.w was not to be followed except what came in Qur'an. Let me also know what you are against? The sunnah of the prophet or you have problem with the scholars who might have lied according to you so they are not reliable. If you believe in the sunnah but do not believe in the preservation of the sunnah and have doubts about it authenticity then although you need some explanations and you have the right to question it's preservation and might believe in some and not believe in others , if this is the case then you cannot be considered as a unbeliever but if you reject the sunnah then there is no doubt you are kaafir and a satanist who is in a mission to destroy the Islamic beliefs. So to begin with please explain about the dead animals and hajj according to Qur'an only without using hadeeths or any sources .
@@Indianman536 instead of asking 1000 of questions, why don't you watch my videos. Most of your questions have been answered in my videos. Some i will answer in my future videos. I always answer Quran-rejecting Arrogant Mushriq's questions. So don't worry your questions will be answered.
@@YasirAddaee send me the link of the video where you have answered about the particular question I asked. You cannot have one way traffic for yourself where you just go on with your views without answering the evidences others have against you. Why don't you have any videos of debate with well known debaters😂 are you a coward ?
Mashallah brother, keep sharing the truth. May Lord help you and bless you. Quran is enough for us
Thank you
It is difficult to reason when eye, ear and mind are sealed by Allah due to their arrogance.
Exactly!
@@YasirAddaeeYOU STILL DIDNT ANSWER THAT QUESTION, IF EVERYONE READS QURAN, THEY WILL ALL HAVE DIFFERENT INTERPRETATIONS, ANSWER THIS
True!
@@haidar1080First you must be sincere. Free yourself from the man made garbage books. Stop reading the Sunni corrupt interpretation of the Quran. Do some research. Follow the best of it..(Az Zumar 18)
"They are the ones who examine all words, then follow THE BEST. These are the one whom God guided; these are the ones who possess intelligence." 39:18
For any words to be the best there must be no errors nor any contradiction, words to hold His protections that it cannot be altered or changed, where no falsehood can ever enter it. THE BEST IS ONLY THE TRUTH.
"Indeed, it is the Glorious Quran in a Preserved Tablet." 85:21-22
Its very simply just Follow what has been revealed to you by your Lord...that is the Quran!!!
"Those are the ones whom God has cursed,so He made them deaf and blinded their sight. Do they not reflected on Quran? Or do the hearts have their locks on them?" 47:23-24
"Those are the ones whom God has sealed their hearts, their hearings and their sights; they are the oblivious ones." 16:108
Salaamun Alayikum brother. Alhamdullillah for this topic. Great one. Only those who believe in Quran will watch this video with open heart. Once you follow Quran you are on the right path no doubt. May Allah reward you. ❤
walikkum salam, thank you. May Allah reward us and keep us on the right path.
Say (O Muhammad), "I am not not a novelty among other messengers nor do i know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing but what is revealed to me (Quran). I am no more than a clear warner." 46:9
"Worship God and do not associate anything with him." 4:36
"God bear witness that there is no God except Him, and so do the angels and those who possess knowledge." 3:18
"He is the Possessor of the Highest Ranks and the Possessor of the Throne." 40:15
Salamun alaikum
Walikkum salam
Regardless of your attempts to justify it, that commentator is still right. The differences of opinion between hadith rejecters is insane.
You guys can't even agree on whether "salat" actually means prayer or not or whether the Qibla is in Mecca or Petra.
And this is BASIC stuff compared to actually HOW to pray.
Whereas there is no hadith accepter that disagrees on the meaning of salat or where to pray etc etc regardless of sect or school of thought.
And what's amazing is that hadith rejecters will take the "hadiths" of other hadith rejecters on CZcams on how to pray but they'll reject the hadiths of the Prophet Muhammad(pbuh&f) on how to pray subhanAllah
Other Quran alone following Muslims are not my followers. Those who are confused with Salat are basically Sunni Shia biased. Allah will inform them and you of what you differ.
It doesn't matter if you have misunderstood the Quran, as long as you are trying to follow the Book of Allah, you are rightly guided.
But following hadiths will guide you to hell. You Quran rejectors don't understand the fundamental command of Allah. That is to follow only the Quran.
Allah guides whomever he wills. Not me, not the prophet (passed away).
saying book of Allah is a misguidance is kuffr! Hadith following imam worshippers are mushriks!
Lucid fairytale man-made hadiths.
Salamun alaikum brother. I have commented on your video of salat part 3 but looks like you dont see comments on old video. Anyways thanks for your analysis but i need some clarifications in quran which tells about salat times and verse which says afrer salat do dhijr standing sitting resting etc.also what is importance of juma salah
Walikkum salam, I didn't get any notification on it. I will check it.
Well the problem is until you remove your misunderstanding that ritual prayer is salah, you cannot understand the word salah. That's what i have been explaining in my salah videos.
I am planning to explain all the misunderstandings people got about Salah when i get some time.
*إنْ شاء الله*
The Salat you are referring to is Salah sessions. Jummah salah is not Quthbah like in Sunni/Shia masjid, it's a day of gathering for salah session. Not Friday. Muslims later invented this Friday into Jummah day. Jews got sabath and christians got Sunday, Muslims need a day so they came up with Jummah day.
Yes Allah says "Yumuh Jummah" in the Quran, but it is day of gathering for Salat session. It got nothing to do with rituals.
If you think Salat is a ritual, then how can you explain the big issues:
1. No step by step guide to the ritual prayer in the Quran.
2. why Allah has to say After you complete your "ritual prayer", remember Allah standing, and sitting... so is that mean "ritual prayer" not remembering Allah?
3. can you pray 24/7?
4. and there are out of context in those ayahs when you think it's ritual prayer.
you will have to leave indoctrinated stuff out and think freely then you will understand. If you question everything, then you will understand.
Thank you brother. Yes I agree with you to remove this long fed rituals. Iam trying to comeout from that. Just to be confident and make sure i wanted to clarify on this. There are some ayats mentioned on time like before dawn and once you complete salat do dhikr by sitting standing and resting etc.
Please help. Also pls suggest any good translation quran in English
@@syedmohammedriyaz3762 Some of the Ayahs talk to just the prophet in singular. It's for him. Some of them are for everyone, for us to glorify Allah. We have to look into the grammar and context of what it is trying to say.
In most translations, the translator includes his assumptions based on Sunni indoctrination. The reason why have so much hard time understanding. Even the Arabs don't pay attention to them.
Shabir Ahmed Translation is good, but not the best. You will never be able to find a perfect translation. By reading with the context you can have an idea.
For example: those who say there is 3 times ritual salat in the Quran, they don't look at the context. Context is Divorce and Widow, why Allah gotta talk about ritual prayer in it? also why is he mixing plural and singular in it?
Is there a Ritual Prayer called "Salatul Wusta"? Then which one is Salaul Wusta? Asar or Duhar? Since Allah did not mention them in the Quran how can we accept outside influence? if accept outside influence then we are saying Quran is not a fully detailed book. Then we are rejecting the Quran.
So even accepting just one outside element can make us as a Quran rejector.
There are many Quran followers who believe in Ritual prayer. But that is without understanding fundamental Quranic principles.
1. Follow Quran alone nothing else.
2. We are not allowed to follow Assumptions, even if its our own assumptions.
3. We are not allowed to reject the Quran.
Thank you brother for your time and clarifications
@@syedmohammedriyaz3762
You are welcome, May Allah keep us on the right path.
Bro can you please make a video on how the word "ibadah" actually means follow and not worship
I have never said "ibadah" means follow. Where did you hear that? I don't think even Sunnis are saying that.
@@YasirAddaee you know better, but I think the word ibadah was also used for slaves of believers in the quran
@@YasirAddaee I m not sure, you know better arabic but isn't "abd" means serve or slave, in arabic
I have observed base on objective observation there has been a significant variation of Interpretation, understanding and explanation of the Quran from people from different geographic location. How will the Quran only believers reconcile among themselves in the interpretation and understanding of Quran in Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Syria and other parts of Africa is quite different from the practices, interpretation and understanding from the people in Sri Lanka, India, Pakistan and Bangladesh? example is the way in performing prayer, going to pilgrimage, call to prayer, process remembrance of Allah, the Importance of Zayd ( a person mention in the Quran) in the life time of prophet Muhammad s.a.w. etc. So who gives the most accurate interpretation and understanding of the Quran only, the Middle eastern/ north african Quranist or the South asian Quranist group?
No, not really, Significant? that's a bit of a stretch. Arab countries are mostly Influenced by Hambali and Maliki, so their interpretation is based on that.
North Africa is predominantly Shafih-influenced. And their understanding and usage of the language from how they were taught.
As for Desi (Indian, Pakistani, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka...) countries had to learn from the translations and Saudi influence. Also mostly they are Shafih and Hanafi influenced.
But people like me (Quran alone followers) go to the core of the language, root letter study, context, grammar, and usage.
We don't need the lifetime of the prophet. If you think we need the lifetime of the prophet to understand the Quran, then you are insulting Allah for sending you an incomplete imperfect book that is not useful for all times. Also, Islam will be like the Hindu religion, where you wait for your imams and scholars to explain the Quran and you follow it blindly.
I believe you are a Sunni. You are already on the wrong path and fear Allah. Don't insult Allah. Quran interpretation is just one, understanding can be different based on the individual's knowledge and taqwa.
We still have Quran-alone followers who are holding on to Sunni/Shia ideologies, so their interpretation will be based on how they were taught. I totally 100% reject Shia/Sunni ideologies so when i am interpreting something i question myself if i am being influenced by what i was taught.
I am working on correcting myself at that as well. Some words I used, and greetings were from how was taught. Most of them are already corrected. But you might be able to catch it in my CZcams videos. i am not talking about Quran interpretation.
As for Quran interpretation I use Sunni translations to make them understand so that we won't have an interpretation argument like this.
@@YasirAddaee For example Dr. Hany Atchan being a pure quranist himself used the same methodology, by using the core of the language, root letter study, context, grammar, and usage in all his CZcams videos lasting several hours each. Yet after going thru his lectures I can see a really significant variation interpretation of the Quran from the rest of the mainstream Quranist movement. And there are many people like him. For example, Prophet Ismael in the Quran is actually prophet Muhammad himself if the deeper meaning and understanding of linguistics is really studies and internalized.
So needles' to say, who should follow who's interpretation? Shall anyone just follow his guts and follow which Quran Daee to follow? The Egyptian, syrian, tunisian, bangali, indian, sri lankan or pakistani Daee?
I am also just curious, how can a pure Quran only follower be influenced by the sunni school of thought ( Handbali, Shafii, Maliki etc..), when it is not even mentioned in the Quran that this should be followed? Who determines what is innovation and what is not base on the Quran only movement?
@@YasirAddaee @YasirAddaee For example Dr. Hany Atchan being a pure quranist himself used the same methodology, by using the core of the language, root letter study, context, grammar, and usage in all his CZcams videos lasting several hours each. Yet after going thru his lectures I can see a really significant variation interpretation of the Quran from the rest of the mainstream Quranist movement. And there are many people like him. For example, Prophet Ismael in the Quran is actually prophet Muhammad himself if the deeper meaning and understanding of linguistics is really studies and internalized.
So needles' to say, who should follow who's interpretation? Shall anyone just follow his guts and follow which Quran Daee to follow? The Egyptian, syrian, tunisian, bangali, indian, sri lankan or pakistani Daee?
I am also just curious, how can a pure Quran only follower be influenced by the sunni school of thought ( Handbali, Shafii, Maliki etc..), when it is not even mentioned in the Quran that this should be followed? Who determines what is innovation and what is not base on the Quran only movement?
//As for Quran interpretation I use Sunni translations to make them understand so that we won't have an interpretation argument like this.// ---Why don't you like engage in debate, 98% of all your video are directed to attacking the Ahlul sunna followers?
yasir bro dont say wassalam or asslam ...but say like salamunalykum as advised in the Quraan
its a Habit trying to get rid of. but why not wassalaam?
For zakat try 6:141
Watch the video!
@@YasirAddaee my bad 20:75-20:76
Those get yuzakihim
@@muhammadnuralhafiz This means to give Zakat 2.5% and lists of people who are eligible for Zakat?
Why do you try hard to prove your blind faith man?
@YasirAddaee no not that I said look 20:75-20:76 come as believer and work righteous you get tazakaa so zakat about believe and righteous work
Which why I said my bad
Also 9:60 said sadaqat is fard which also found in surah al ahzab which link to Sunnatullah as fard impose to rasulullah is Sunnatullah is in 33:38
Nope still not 2.5%
[He] who gives [from] his wealth to purify himself And not [giving] for anyone who has [done him] a favor to be rewarded But only seeking the countenance of his Lord, Most High.92:18-20
Please the Qur'an talking about the coming of yajuj and majuj are we in their era please hi lights
Only Allah knows. Why worry about those things. Just follow the Quran.
Sunnis and Shias are so focused because they are waiting for Mahdi, Dajjal, and Jesus. It has nothing to do with the Quran.
Only Allah knows when the End time will come. No one has that knowledge.
சலாம் பிரதர் தமிழ் வீடியோ போட்டா கொஞ்சம் நல்லா இருக்கும்
*إنْ شاء الله*
o ma pipl... L. i have Conclusive authority.. 👉 3o
Watch muslim lanterns video about people who reject hadeeths.
What?
It's a youtube channel name "the muslim lantern" who tries to prove that the hadith are correct and made a video on questions, answers, facts, ect.etc.. how the hadith is authentic and what not.
Can you debate Baba Shuaib about Salat, he is ready for people who think Salah isn’t a ritual.
I don't have time for debates. Muslims shouldn't debate pointlessly on the words of Allah without confirmed understanding. Allah doesn't like those who are arrogant.
I have detailed videos on Salat you can go watch them, if you are not happy with it, don't worry Allah will inform you on what you differ in Qiyamah.
Baba Shuaib is a Muslim (Quran alone follower), doesn't matter if we have differences of opinions and understanding on some subjects.
I don't make these videos to make money or to show how great I am. My job here is to make people think that's all.
Be humble with the Quran, so that Allah will help you understand and have mercy on you.
WasSalaam
@@YasirAddaee I pray 5 times to be safe. I don’t want any hate. I wouldn’t ask you for you to debate him if you wouldn’t mind people performing ritual Salah. I see you get angry sometimes when people don’t respect your views. Please try to calm down if people don’t agree with you. Salam.
@@Ox1326 I have detailed videos on Ritual prayer go watch them. Please don't waste my time. I get angry when people don't watch the videos and keep on arguing about the subject without understanding while they are committing Shirk.
You don't like to watch the videos that's fine!
My time is valuable to debate with people. If you like praying 5 times or 500 times that's upto you. If you like following blindly it's upto you. You will be questioned in Qiyamah not me.
@@Ox1326 Do you even know what is the definition of view is? following sunnism is not a view. It's dogma.
Following Imams of the past is not a view. view is when you form a theory based on misunderstanding is a view. According to the Quran, all the views are assumptions except for the words of Allah.
If you say you have a view on the Quranic Ayah then you are saying Quran is not detailed! Allah says Quran is detailed. But you are saying no its not detailed.
If you like to follow your views why do you need Quran?
I have studied other religions. I debate with adults, yet you say I am a blind follower 🤣😂
There seems to be two different extremes when it comes to following Qur'an and sunnah. There are people who totally reject hadeeths which contains sunnah and other information of islamic laws and there are people who believe sahi hadeeths cannot be questioned at all.
The fact is Allah revealed Qur'an to prophet Muhammad s.a.w and after his death his followers had this Qur'anic revealation in their memories and also had it in written form scattered,many followers use to recite it in different dialects which use to sometime give different meanings etc.
So it was decided by the senior authorities to compile it in a book form and reject quran in different dialects and thanks to their great service we have only one Qur'an which is same all over the world but when it comes to sunnah the practice and preachings of prophet s.a.w without which islam cannot be understood at all because everyone can give their own interpretation of Quran. These hadeeth use to be narrated by different people , some were authentic some were authentic but with the own understanding of the narrator some were totally fabricated etc.
Later on the scholars tried to collect and authenticate the hadeeths but it wasn't like quran and naturally it wasn't clean from errors .
If we follow quran and judge the hadeeths according to quran and if its in line with quran then there should be no problem because without hadeeths its impossible to follow the deen which was revealed by Allah because we cannot understand quran without the help of prophet s.a.w on whom it was revealed. Our efforts should be applied to distinguish which hadeeth is correct or not but this attitude of rejecting the hadeeths in totally is 100% deviation from the manhaj of sahabas who use to quote both quran and the ways of prophet s.a w whenever they use use to make some laws .
I just have one question to the hadeeth rejectors ...just prove the dead fish from the sea is halaal according to Qur'an without using the hadeeth!
Or declare its haram to eat dead fish which is clearly mentioned in Qur'an that dead living things is not allowed to eat?
Without using the hadeeths write a booklet how to perform hajj according to Qur'an.
There are so many things if you reject the hadeeth totally even a kaafir on the street would not recognise you as a muslim .
you don't know what you are talking about. you are repeating what your gods taught you. Learn before you open your ignorance to the world.
I have videos explaining all your saitan worship on my channel you can watch those. Do you think you are the first to expose their own ignorance to me? and you won't be the last.
@@YasirAddaee come to the point and don't try to deviate.
All dead creatures are haram.
Why is not dead fish haraam?
Just give the answer from Qur'an?
I don't want your explanation because your explanation is nothing in comparison to even a Daef hadeeth.
Let me also know how to perform hajj in detail according to Qur'an without using hadeeth or any historical evidence because if hadeeths cannot be followed nothing cannot be followed , you cannot say we have seen people doing this rituals for years so we can follow them,what is the proof that what people have been doing is according to Qur'an because 99.9% of them believe in traditional scholars and according to you they are liars so just let me know according to Qur'an all the procedures.
Let me also know who were the sahabas who had similar belief like you ? For whom tradition of Prophet s.a.w was not to be followed except what came in Qur'an.
Let me also know what you are against? The sunnah of the prophet
or you have problem with the scholars who might have lied according to you so they are not reliable.
If you believe in the sunnah but do not believe in the preservation of the sunnah and have doubts about it authenticity then although you need some explanations and you have the right to question it's preservation and might believe in some and not believe in others , if this is the case then you cannot be considered as a unbeliever but if you reject the sunnah then there is no doubt you are kaafir and a satanist who is in a mission to destroy the Islamic beliefs.
So to begin with please explain about the dead animals and hajj according to Qur'an only without using hadeeths or any sources .
@@Indianman536 instead of asking 1000 of questions, why don't you watch my videos. Most of your questions have been answered in my videos. Some i will answer in my future videos.
I always answer Quran-rejecting Arrogant Mushriq's questions. So don't worry your questions will be answered.
@@YasirAddaee send me the link of the video where you have answered about the particular question I asked. You cannot have one way traffic for yourself where you just go on with your views without answering the evidences others have against you. Why don't you have any videos of debate with well known debaters😂 are you a coward ?
i am a messenger of allah, inquire if you were reasonable like you are describing.