Robert Strauss: America’s Worst Presidents

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 11. 2016
  • Michael Gerhardt, Center scholar-in-residence, and Robert Strauss, author of Worst. President. Ever., offer an enlightening - and highly entertaining - account of James Buchanan’s presidency and explain how historians rank presidents over time.

Komentáře • 33

  • @Fireball_
    @Fireball_ Před rokem +2

    You can tell he's not doing research he says he memorized a book so he will be biased towards the book so if he does other research it won't mean much to him

  • @Joepacalypse1107
    @Joepacalypse1107 Před rokem +1

    Pickett is the guy who lost the confederacy? What a weird statement.

  • @patkottcamp6970
    @patkottcamp6970 Před 2 lety

    Perhaps not that elaborate but you can learn something from just about every historian, worth hearing + he's a Philly guy!

  • @orihoola
    @orihoola Před 5 lety +2

    Fantastic talk!

  • @user-zc3do8vk4q
    @user-zc3do8vk4q Před 6 měsíci

    John Kennedy said no one has the right to grade a president.Some things are simply beyond a president’s control.

    • @suarezguy
      @suarezguy Před 3 dny

      Some, maybe many things, but other things are their decisions and responsibility, they should be blamed or praised for them.

  • @suarezguy
    @suarezguy Před rokem

    He didn't make a good case for that Buchanan was and did really bad, I don't see how it would have been really good or better for Buchanan to have militarily challenged secession, started the Civil War in January or February 1861 rather than in April 1861.

  • @earlpaulson7164
    @earlpaulson7164 Před rokem

    Strongly disagree. This guy might know his sports, but he obviously only skimmed through Buchanan's history. If you want a much fairer assessment of James Buchanan, read Philip S. Klein's Biography, James Buchanan.

    • @Joepacalypse1107
      @Joepacalypse1107 Před rokem +1

      He referred to Pickett as "the guy who lost the confederacy". I think sports is all he knows well.

  • @jerrybrenton6140
    @jerrybrenton6140 Před 3 lety +4

    Waste of my time

  • @sjwoz
    @sjwoz Před rokem +1

    This guy is like a brother in law at Thanksgiving-simplified explanations that are not exactly accurate.... or wrong. I'll pass on the book.

  • @elhombredeoro955
    @elhombredeoro955 Před 4 lety +4

    Theodore Roosevelt was better than FDR.

    • @MLDEG45
      @MLDEG45 Před 4 lety +2

      A lot better. FDR was an average president at best

    • @speedweed6747
      @speedweed6747 Před rokem

      Bull!

    • @thefreeman8791
      @thefreeman8791 Před 6 měsíci

      Both were bad but yes you are right. FDR’s policies prolonged the Great Depression and he ruled by fiat issuing over 300 presidential vetoes. The veto was never expected to be abused in such a manner. Teddy created the FBI and FDA illegally and without the consent of Congress.

  • @paulaltfornorge
    @paulaltfornorge Před 3 lety +3

    I am not particularly impressed by Robert Strauss as an interviewee...doesnt seem terribly polished nor energetic

  • @billkeogh639
    @billkeogh639 Před měsícem

    The snide comments about Trump are pretty embarrassing.

  • @billkeogh639
    @billkeogh639 Před měsícem

    This is complete fiction.

  • @AmericanTestConstitution

    Brandon

  • @gregoryl.mcgarvey1042
    @gregoryl.mcgarvey1042 Před 4 lety +4

    The only criteria that should be used to judge the presidents. That is "WHO PROTECTED AND DEFENDED THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES"

    • @999reader
      @999reader Před 2 lety

      “The only criteria”!

    • @deoglemnaco7025
      @deoglemnaco7025 Před rokem

      Winnebago!

    • @thefreeman8791
      @thefreeman8791 Před 6 měsíci

      You mean who kept to their oath of office. Most presidents are ranked on what they did rather then if what they did was Constitutional.

  • @Fireball_
    @Fireball_ Před rokem +1

    James buchanon is only the 3rd worst

    • @stevebenaszeski9153
      @stevebenaszeski9153 Před 3 dny

      Buchanan, Pierce, Biden

    • @Fireball_
      @Fireball_ Před 3 dny +2

      @@stevebenaszeski9153 buchanan, Wilson, Andrew Johnson. But those are bad presidents too

    • @suarezguy
      @suarezguy Před 3 dny

      @@Fireball_ Not sure what Pierce or Buchanan could do particularly different or better, how any president would have been able to not have secession/Civil War coming soon.