Orozco-Estrada really lives all the music that he directs. Quite intensively as one can see by his gestures and facial expressions. In this way (and other) he is quite unique in the world I think.
When an orchestra is formed by fine and excellent musicians, besides all of them soloists as we have certified during COVID-19 crisis, we can enjoy a performance like this: pure and clean sound which is a great pleasure, correct conduction and excellent filming and recording. And Schubert very classic but romantic though. Thank you HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie. Viel Danke!!
Absolut Großartig ! Danke für diese perfekte Aufführung im Profi Format , und ich sehe Ihn im Traum jetzt noch Stundenlang wandern im Wener Wald meinen geliebten und für immer unvergessen Freund ,Franz Schubert .Beste grüße aus Wien !
Orozco-Estrada é genial!!! Suas interpretações são claras, extremamente detalhadas, uma preciosidade. Projetou a orquestra da HR como uma das melhores do mundo. Extremamente agradável! Ouça novamente e de novo. Bravo!!!
@@marliesrabisch784Großartig. Em português a palavra "bravo" vem emprestada do italiano e significa "excelente" A plateia grita ao final das grandes performances nos concertos ao aplaudir.Espero ter ajudado a esclarecer.
A marvellous symphony and fantastic performance. The second and third movements might have echoes of Haydn, but the first and especially the last movements are pure, unique Schubert. Definitely foreshadowing of his Great C Major Symphony in the finale
El orden y la cadencia,elevan al ser e un quehacer espiritual. Esta premisa la he topado en esta versión bajo una dirección juiciosa y nos solistas que trajeron,al hoy, a un Schubert, que nunca morirá
This conductor is really exceptional, what a lively and moving rendition ! In the same channel, check also his Bruch's violin concerto with a sublime Hilary Hahn... breathtaking.
Klare und saubere Aufführung dieser fein komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Töne aller Streicher, brillanten Töne aller Metallbläser und, vor allem, milden Töne aller Holzbläser. Der unvergleichliche Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im lebhaften Tempo mit effektiv kontrollierter Dynamik. Einfach bewundernswert!
Einen sehr ähnlichen Kommentar habe ich doch schon bei Schuberts 2. Simphonie gesehen. Schöne Worte, aber ein wenig mehr Originalität verdient dieses Werk schon!
A tuneful but nervous symphony, with Schubert's gift for lyricism but also for his sudden shifts from p. to f. Another excellent performance by the FRSO however, making it certainly worth hearing.
Wonderful! It's been too long since you've posted one of your concerts and what a lovely program of lieder and symphonies. I've posted this observation many times but your woodwinds are amazing both as individual soloists and as a harmonized unit. It's interesting to see the clarinets and bassoons sitting opposite the way you usually find them with the bassoons on the conductor's right and the clarinets on the left.
Thank you very much for your friendly words! I'm one of the bassoonists of the orchestra. We chose to change sides with the clarinets in order to sit closer to the cello and bass sections which helped a lot.
Thank you for replying. Keeping the darker tones of the orchestra together is a really interesting idea. I've seen some innovative seating arrangements for Schubert's symphonies over the years. Ivan Fischer had the winds sitting in front of the strings for a performance of the 8th (the Great not the Unfinished) with the Berlin Philharmonic earlier this year and the clarity of the playing was superb. The winds carry so much of Schubert's melodies that it was inspired choice. Maybe Maestro Orozco-Estrada might give it some thought. In any event, as a clarinet player, I think your wind section is first-class. Thanks again for the insight and as always, for the beautiful music and hours of enjoyment.
@@Dan-vr3ie Please also pass complements to your clarinetist who presents the first theme of the fist movement joyfully and in an extraordinarily facile way!
@@Dan-vr3ie sometimes I noticed the bass and tenors sections missing in records. It's good you have noticed this phenomenon but is wonderful how you choice this way to sparse this weak. Can you tell the first flute name?
Schubert's 3rd is one of the worst symphonies ever written! After a passable 1st mvt., the remaining mvts. are terribly repetitious , banal and silly. As it progresses, it gets worse and worse as the finale gets increasingly more bogged down in an ants-in-the-pants 4 note bludgeon. This musical humiliation by the composer of 3 of the greatest string quartets ever written, #'s 13,14,15.
Obviously everyone is entitled to their own view but this has always been my favourite Schubert symphony. I adore the trio of the scherzo - though I am a bassoonist which helps!
This symphony, full of beauty,inocense and freshness,speaks right to my heart!
exactly what I was thinking. You can almost see a happy young Schubert composing this :)
This Symphony was written in 1815, a few months after Schubert's eighteenth birthday. That is baffling!
The comfort and wonderfulness of No.3 are irreplaceable , unfathomable and paramount
Orozco-Estrada really lives all the music that he directs. Quite intensively as one can see by his gestures and facial expressions. In this way (and other) he is quite unique in the world I think.
Alondra de la Parra is as well very expressive. Maybe the "latin seasoning" is an important factor 😀
When an orchestra is formed by fine and excellent musicians, besides all of them soloists as we have certified during COVID-19 crisis, we can enjoy a performance like this: pure and clean sound which is a great pleasure, correct conduction and excellent filming and recording.
And Schubert very classic but romantic though.
Thank you HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie. Viel Danke!!
Absolut Großartig ! Danke für diese perfekte Aufführung im Profi Format , und ich sehe Ihn im Traum jetzt noch Stundenlang wandern im Wener Wald meinen geliebten und für immer unvergessen Freund ,Franz Schubert .Beste grüße aus Wien !
I love this orchestra😂
Conductor is so exceptional...!!
Maestro müziği yaşıyor, orkestra tam bir uyum içinde. Hr Senfoni orkestrası dünyanın en iyi on orkestrası arasına rahatlıkla girer...
Orozco-Estrada é genial!!! Suas interpretações são claras, extremamente detalhadas, uma preciosidade. Projetou a orquestra da HR como uma das melhores do mundo. Extremamente agradável! Ouça novamente e de novo. Bravo!!!
Die deutsche Übersetzung dieses Kommentars: Bravo = wütend! ???
@@marliesrabisch784Großartig. Em português a palavra "bravo" vem emprestada do italiano e significa "excelente" A plateia grita ao final das grandes performances nos concertos ao aplaudir.Espero ter ajudado a esclarecer.
@@ricardonascimento6020
Ja, so habe ich es auch verstanden, aber in der automatischen Übersetzung wurde Bravo mit "wütend" übersetzt.
The second movement is brilliant, and is a well known or often played movement, beautiful. Schubert was a kid when he wrote this.
I am astonished beyond the fact that this was written during Schubert's 18th bday. We are also playing this for my Symphony orchestra.
A marvellous symphony and fantastic performance. The second and third movements might have echoes of Haydn, but the first and especially the last movements are pure, unique Schubert. Definitely foreshadowing of his Great C Major Symphony in the finale
Dem stimme ich zu, der 2. und 3. Satz erinnern auch mich an Haydn.
Such fine woodwind playing !!!!
At 2:30 the clarinet player starts the beginning of a joyous passage of music. Absolutely divine
El orden y la cadencia,elevan al ser e un quehacer espiritual. Esta premisa la he topado en esta versión bajo una dirección juiciosa y nos solistas que trajeron,al hoy, a un Schubert, que nunca morirá
Such a charming symphony, reminds me a little of Beethoven and Mozart, of course. And, as always played with panache and unerstanding.
Maybe a little more of Mozart, since this was one of Schubert's earlier pieces. Of course, he really went toward Beethoven in his later ones,
Agreed. And I particularly love the first theme as presented exceptionally well by the clarinetist.
Sounds much more like Haydn to me, especially the slow movement.
Sounds ripped from them.
Yes this sounds like Mozart at first to me but let me second guess if it’s Beethoven the first time I heard it on the radio just yesterday!
More than a superb performance, this is Schubert 5 played with love
This conductor is really exceptional, what a lively and moving rendition ! In the same channel, check also his Bruch's violin concerto with a sublime Hilary Hahn... breathtaking.
Klare und saubere Aufführung dieser fein komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Töne aller Streicher, brillanten Töne aller Metallbläser und, vor allem, milden Töne aller Holzbläser. Der unvergleichliche Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im lebhaften Tempo mit effektiv kontrollierter Dynamik. Einfach bewundernswert!
Einen sehr ähnlichen Kommentar habe ich doch schon bei Schuberts 2. Simphonie gesehen. Schöne Worte, aber ein wenig mehr Originalität verdient dieses Werk schon!
@@johannaschreiber1243 Just take all of my comments as mere date stamps of mine.
Such an amazingly delightful master piece that is as great as many other greatest pieces!
OE is exceptional in Schubert, Mendelssohn, Dvorak and others, some of whom I need to hear. But he's been excellent on what I've heard thus far.
A tuneful but nervous symphony, with Schubert's gift for lyricism but also for his sudden shifts from p. to f. Another excellent performance by the FRSO however, making it certainly worth hearing.
Deliciosa pieza sinfónica ejecutada talentosamente. Orozco director que promete.
9:46 fills my heart with whoop.
Esta orquesta, si en lugar de ser alemana (o también austríaca) fuera de cualquier otro país, sería la más importante del mismo.
Wunderschön
This is wonderful, thank you !
Bravo!!!!!!!!
9:31 ending | 10:09 2nd movement | 10:39 remix | 13:39 remix | 14:52 3rd movement | 24:57 ending | 25:02 ending |
Sehr korrekt interpretierte Sinfonie des zusammen mit Mozart grössten Komponisten aller Zeiten, ein wahrer Ohrenschmaus!!!
Stimme Ihnen total zu.
Danke, lieber Freund!
Zusammen mit Beethoven 🤗
Meiner Meinung nach ist Beethoven hinter Mozart und Schubert, deshalb habe ich ihn nicht erwähnt.
Nicht schlecht.
Чудесный Шуберт в прекрасном исполнении!
Schubert & Mozart should have been brothers. Both of them wrote over 600 works each and each began at such an early age.
Frankfurt pride!!!!
Very Nice!!!!!!!
Wonderful! It's been too long since you've posted one of your concerts and what a lovely program of lieder and symphonies. I've posted this observation many times but your woodwinds are amazing both as individual soloists and as a harmonized unit. It's interesting to see the clarinets and bassoons sitting opposite the way you usually find them with the bassoons on the conductor's right and the clarinets on the left.
Maybe they drive on the other of the road where this conductor is from.
Thank you very much for your friendly words! I'm one of the bassoonists of the orchestra. We chose to change sides with the clarinets in order to sit closer to the cello and bass sections which helped a lot.
Thank you for replying. Keeping the darker tones of the orchestra together is a really interesting idea. I've seen some innovative seating arrangements for Schubert's symphonies over the years. Ivan Fischer had the winds sitting in front of the strings for a performance of the 8th (the Great not the Unfinished) with the Berlin Philharmonic earlier this year and the clarity of the playing was superb. The winds carry so much of Schubert's melodies that it was inspired choice. Maybe Maestro Orozco-Estrada might give it some thought. In any event, as a clarinet player, I think your wind section is first-class. Thanks again for the insight and as always, for the beautiful music and hours of enjoyment.
@@Dan-vr3ie Please also pass complements to your clarinetist who presents the first theme of the fist movement joyfully and in an extraordinarily facile way!
@@Dan-vr3ie sometimes I noticed the bass and tenors sections missing in records. It's good you have noticed this phenomenon but is wonderful how you choice this way to sparse this weak.
Can you tell the first flute name?
Muy bueno
Je trouve ça très bien !!!!
Einige Schubert Sinfonien ähneln denen von Beethoven, Wiener Klassik, diese hier auch im 1. Satz. Der 2. Satz erinnert mich auch an Haydn.
Harikaa👏👏👏👏
Composed during the administration of James Madison
Life!!!!!!
🥰🌹🥰🌹🥰🌹🥰🌹🥰🌹🥰🌹
i want more treble from the cellos.. the bass is too boomy.
Unas pastillas para la tos en la entrada no estaría nada mal.
Schubert's middle name should have been Harmony.
When the conductor is too hard to follow, all eyes are on the concertmaster. Or Clara Andrada?
@@wcsxwcsx Many perform for cameras and publishers more than for the music. A conductor with a clear downbeat or upbeat is good to find!
... or the 2nd oboist?
Quan algú sent a Schubert, sent com si estigués a un altre món. Les seves melodies son tan bones que et fan somiar amb el paradís
Schubert hat einen einen Melodienreichtum in seiner Musik, erstaunlich, und er komponierte so viele wunderbare Musik.
@@marliesrabisch784 Nicht sprach German. English or french, please
@@Johanna650 Google Übersetzung nutzen
👏👏👏
22:13 😂😂😂😂 the concertmaster making mistakes
18:55
23:39 L278
2:50-3:10
Рурскихъ в чаде нетъ .
Рурские в чате есть .
22:10 22:46
I only like 18-19th century classical music basically from Bach to Brahms I can get into easily
2:27
10:08
4th mvmt too fast, IMO.
Ich verstehe nicht warum das Publikum ständig in den Pausen husten muss. Das nervt! Auch vor der Pandemie!!
Schubert's 3rd is one of the worst symphonies ever written! After a passable 1st mvt., the remaining mvts. are terribly repetitious , banal and silly. As it progresses, it gets worse and worse as the finale gets increasingly more bogged down in an ants-in-the-pants 4 note bludgeon. This musical humiliation by the composer of 3 of the greatest string quartets ever written, #'s 13,14,15.
There is more pure joy in this simple first movement than all od Beethoven's ponderous 9th.
@@barthelemylefebvre5877 I'm not arguing about the 1st mvt. It's the REST OF IT that stinks!
Obviously everyone is entitled to their own view but this has always been my favourite Schubert symphony. I adore the trio of the scherzo - though I am a bassoonist which helps!
Ich bi erstaunt über den negativen Kommentar. Wie kann man Schuberts Musik als schlecht komponiert bezeichnen? Er war 18 Jahre alt.
14:52
18:43
14:52
Sensacional, Bravissimo.