Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
The New BEST Multi-Item Sorter (Quiet, Super Simple) (Original Creator)
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 09. 2022
- I have improved my quiet design so much that its now my simplest sorter ,and still quiet! In this video I showcase the build, show how to build it, and share this new design.
Advice from another smaller creator that does in depth things that it's easy for bigger creators to reference. They will take your design regardless what you say, so you have to use it to your advantage. Item sorting is painful in Minecraft. Ask them to give you 5 seconds of credit and actually reach out to you. Even if they don't see the video, someone will show them. I found you through a big creators comments. You should embrace being the expert item sorter guy. Have different types of videos geared at different audiences. Multiple for the same system. Maybe a short showcase, a in depth build guide, detailed description of the inner workings (how hoppers lock and different ways to do it), and finally, ways to change it. Extensions, stacking on top, troubleshooting, USING LESS RESOURCES, etc.
Love the stuff! Keep it up! Don't burn out!
That is so unbelievably nice of you to say all that, I really appreciate it! That's some solid advice too, thank you :)
I converted my sorter to your new design last night. I love it! I had a switch for your old design because of the noise so there was always a backlog. The fact that this runs all the time makes it a HUGE upgrade for me.
Sorry for the super late reply, but that is so awesome to hear, and yeah I'm so glad it's quiet now :)
Just upgraded today. I have to agree. So much nicer.
This is the best storage system ever its cheap customizable can hold all of your excess crap items without depleting all of your iron wood and redstone
Sorry for the really late reply, but thank you so much!
Best sorter i found yet, super simple, compact, silent, works like a charm, great for smallish bases.
This is amazing. Such a simple design for something I thought was imposible. You deserve a lot more views
Love the schematic of the build he explains how to build it SO well.
This is genuinely so good! and making adjustments is super easy. I'm really impressed at how simple this is compared to other designs I've seen. Great video.
Really nice upgrade! I love this design bc its so much better. I hope shulkercraft dont steal your design again :(
Yeah me too, there's a few big channels that took the last design :(, but thank you so much :)
@@BlockyBryson this design its hopper speed or lower?
@@juanjosequintero2719I just tested it, it's about 1/2 hopper speed, but items can be feed into the first dropper at hopper speed with no problems
Great design, man! Simple, easy, smaller footprint than some other sorters. I may do this in a live stream very soon! Great job - keep it comin!
Thank you much! That sounds awesome dude :)
@@BlockyBryson Hopefully I do it justice!!
The fact that is silent make this system 1000 times better
As others have said I keep getting items stuck at the first dropper pair. The redstone torch beneath the first up dropper locks whatever I put next to that dropper to feed it. Leaving either 1 or a stack of things stuck. Sometimes it works flawlessly, but in testing just now I've had it clog and stop moving items 10 out of 15 attempts. I look forward to any updates you come out with as I don't need one of the huge multi-item sorters and yours is the perfect size for my storage system.
I had the same problem. Then I realized I never put the redstone torch under the droppers 😅 Now the problem I'm having is getting items stuck in the system until I throw more items into the input chest. It's as if the entire system turns off when the input chest is empty and any items in the system cycling through just stops where it is...
With this design its just always going to leave some behind the only way around it is to force the entire system to continue activating after the items have made their pass which would kinda defeat the purpose. You need a clock to do that.
There is another way to circumvent the issue though. Hook up a farm that produces a few items passively and pipe it into the input line. And store it in the last chest this way items are being continuously flushed out7
@@casperghost9808 There is another way. I have an item filter (standard impulse filter) at the ver end which filters out paper named "X" just before the unsorted chest. This picks up any bits of paper named X and puts them back in at the start. You need exactly the same number of X papers in the system as there are modules. These will continue around the system until they have flushed all other items out (at which point each top dropper will have an X paper stored in it).
@@casperghost9808 how do you connect a clock to this?
Does this need to be built in spawn blocks? I’ve built mine a bit outside and I think when I move outside of the blocks this runs in it’s getting a bit messed up if it’s still processing.
Also running it with about 40 chests in two rows joined with a soul sand duct/stream.
Works nicely overall.
Only other issue is needing to only take with right clicks while it’s operating otherwise random items can drop in.
Unfortunately there always will be one item left behind in the top droppers, these items will find their way to the destination chest eventually, but I’d call that a flaw
Yep, I have the same problem. I tried putting a button on the top of the top dropper or the block from the comparator so I can manually push things along, those solutions don't work either.Guess I'll just leave access to the droppers and pull the items out and sort them manually
UPDATE: Using wooden buttons on top of the blocks receiving the signal from the comparator will push items along. However, the longer the chain of chests (ie, the more modules) the more items that get stuck from the beginning (first module after the input) until the chest holding the sorted item. In my case (so far) that is 5 buttons to press to get the 5 items unstuck and sorted.
I like that this design isn't much more complicated than silo sorters with the item filters in hoppers. I also really like that it's silent. Biggest pet peeve about dropper based systems SOLVED! I wonder what would be required to insure the items in the droppers flush out reliably? That was a flaw in previous versions that I was hoping would be fixed here. Lastly, does a sorter like this have any compatibility with bulk chests underneath. What I mean is, can it stack horizontal AND vertical (for more bulk). Either way, awesome work!
Not an issue if you have a regular feed of items into the system.
Or you could just flush the items out with a stack of dirt as the last to go through.
this is a very minor flaw if you use your sorter regularly. Just put as last chests the ones with the item you mine most (dirt, stone...) and if you get paranoid that some diamond or netherite ingot could be stuck somewhere, dump in the system a couple of stacks of dirt. Or build a clock at the beginning and activate it periodically. Or really just ignore it, everything would go in its place the next time you use it.
Seei it like this: it's like complaining that your water pipes always hold some water in it and don't get completely empty when you use your faucet :D
See my reply above for a simple solution to this.
is there a way to stack the chests so its not in one line??
I love the design for how simple it is. Will definitely use it 👍
Amazing design, just move to this from the last design you created.
Great work! Thanks for sharing. Looking forward to the next one!
You're welcome :) and thanks
Oh this is awesome! I'm definetly gonna implement this on my world, and I'm subbing too! Can't wait for you to post your god tier item sorter! Also, really curious if you could also stack this vertically, so different chests are above each other instead of in a long line
Do u mind showing us how to wrap this softer around so we have layers in stead of one long line?
Also love ur videos, keep it up!
I have been trying to make a design similar to this with more than one chest per row. As far as I can tell it cant' be done simply because of hopper mechanics. I've been also toying around with observer clocks to speed the system up to hopper speed. I just cant get the hoppers in the bottom to lock no matter the timings. I haven't Redstoned in years so i have a bit of a head ache!
This is such a great design; it's cheap, silent, easy to build, tileable, small... what more could you want?
This is a very late comment, but just in case you still want to answer it regardless: what are the pros and cons of this design compared to more complicated ones?
I'm trying to decide whether to build this or the moony MIS v5, but this one is considerably simpler and more resource-friendly.
This is exactly what I wanted, thank you!
Best sorting system ever, so simple, honestly perfect
Hey, looks real simple and so on compared to other sorters. I'm definitely gonna use this for some special items I don't have a ton of. Perfect size for my existing setup. You need more credit for your builds. Keep it up. Got a sub from me.
Really easy to build and understand even for a redstone noob, and it works great! thank you
Are you able to make a tutorial of how to turn corners? Or do you mind just explaining it? Thanks. Great design by the way :)
Connect to the exit hopper of the one side of the orner to the entry hopper of the other side
Thats so cool dude. That design is so simple!
Thank you :), I'm really proud of how simple it is
Sorry for the late reply, I'm in love with your design, but Is there a way to turn this design to the left or the right? I don't want it to be too long? I tried to use another 2 hopper to turn but it doesn't work
you have to run a line of redstone from the previous torch
@@emymacleodcan you elaborate the detail? Just got back to Minecraft after a stressful period of time in my life and I want this thing to work, thank you for even answering tbh, I'm a total noob at this
Do you have any additional videos on this design? How do you use bulk storage, move around corners, etc.
I built this in bedrock but it doesn't work can you do a bedrock tutorial of this multi item sorter? Also I love your design its extremely cheap and useful for survival minecraft and looks really good
It works in Bedrock 1.20 as long as single items are placed in the chest. Once multiples of the came items try to stack in the bottom dropper, it locks the previous hopper and stops the flow. It's a great little sorter, just need a way to slow down the input to one item at a time.
this is a really cute lowtech MIS! definitly worth having in your starterbase...how far are ya with the more complicated system? having issues with the design?
Love this sorter, noticed that the last few items get stuck in the dispensers so you need to flush the system to push everything into chests completely. Not a big deal at all when you're constantly depositing building materials, ore, etc.
It is simply not activating for me, all items sit in the first two droppers. I've had this same problem with other dropper based systems as well. Any troubleshooting tips?
Me too the item get stuck at the first dropper and are not moved to the chests
Me too im truing to fix It but It dorsnt work
This looks awesome but now I'm torn between building this or waiting to see what your "ultimate" item sorter design is! I guess at least this one's really simple and shouldn't break on my server, I don't see how Paper's going to mess with the timings here like it does on some of the fancier ones.
I have tested both Moony MIS V5, and Tangotek's Chest hall, and neither broke on paper. not saying they are all functioning with paper bc paper is goofy but at least those two work. but those two are on a different order of magnitude than a design like this.(this design is really nice for smaller scale projects)
@@restart_life. it worked super well on my Paper server. There are advantages to running at half hopper speed.
Hey man, no items are leaving the output chest, am I missing some wiring?
Can this design be converted in 1 wide tileable design???
If possible that would be great although I have built this design.
By the way you are really amazing sir 😗
is this for 1.19.2 ? The older one doesn't work
Can I stack it? I'm still using the old design where you can sort only one item per chest using a hopper and 41 of the item to be sorted + 4 place holders...
I got tired of it, because I have a lot of items and only so much space. I wanna be able to stack this. How would I go about it?
Any one else who is getting "leftovers" out one of the last item you sorted in every dropper up until it's location chest? It does eventually reach the chest once another item get's sorted but then that item get's stuck
Same for me
same here, haven't figured out a fix
I have used this this design on my solo world and it's been fine other than needing to flush the system from time to time.
But no on my smp I'm noticing the entire system backing up. Hoppers and droppers filling up with items and clogging the whole thing.
Any idea what's causing this? Right now my best guess is it either can't handle me dumpling a full chest worth of inventory or it's from leaving loaded chunks while the machine is still active.
Can you show the turns and stuff like in the previous design?
Looks a little bulkier than the previous, but maybe that's a price worth paying for the silence.
YAY!!!! I have been waiting for this :D
Well thanks for sticking around :), and sorry for the long wait
Thanks for the video! I'm using this item sorter and it works great except for it often gets clogged. I check the hoppers and droppers behind and they have items left in there. And often it will won't find where the item is supposed to go and end up in the chest at the output. It works most of the time though! I'd also love to see how to get this to go up!
Name a stack of cobblestone something like "Filter Cleaners" and drop that in when you are done to flush the system out
Super simple, super straight forward, no wasting time, no bullshjt. You should, however, show us how to place the redstone down, even if the design is simple, because not all people can understand redstone. Other than that, I like you, and I like this design, you got a sub and a like.
Wow. Good stuff. Love the upgrade.
Hey no way, thank you! How have you been?
@@BlockyBryson Not bad. Working to long and hard as always. Living my current mincraft life through youtube 😄
@@muzzawood lol gotcha, glad you're doing alright tho
Thinking about using this design as overflow for my Shulkercraft storage system.
it has been a year since this video. what happend? where is the other item sorter?
Amazing Design!
Thank you so much
Doez it break when unloaded? Ive been baby sitting mine all day 😂 love the design tho, genuisly compact
I have this issue for every item oraganizer ive tried using, but after i put it into the input chest it gets stuck in the first dropper
Does this work in Bedrock? I'm pretty sure I recreated this accurately, but items just get stuck in the first dropper and the hoppers stay locked
Same. Does not seem to work in bedrock
Such a good tutorial i could tottaly follow it thanks man!
I cannot get it to move past the first dropper it just stops
hey, my sorter gets stuck on a server. an item is left on one of the top droppers and it doesn't go forward, what could be the problem?
nvm lol
This seemed like a great idea, however items just end up at the unsorted chest and nothing goes into the chest they are meant too. Copied it identical. Any ideas why? Its like the hopper at bottom isnt locking (how is that meant to be locked anyway?)
nm found the issue - server im on had slower hopper speed, so i set the repeater to 2 ticks and it seemed to fix things
Heyo! Long time no see!
Bro my some items are getting stucked. What should i do?
Thanks!
Wow, that's the first super thanks I ever got. That's incredibly nice, thank you! :)
I followed along on how to build this and it doesn't work. I'm very much a redstone novice but I did it block for block. (LOTS of pausing the video)
Edit: I got it to work but it seems kinda slow? Is there a way of speeding it up?
not working for me
It runs all the time? i keeps filling up my hoppers without going foreward. I have to clean out all refill then it runs. the moment i get out of range it clutters
Seems like you have to be there afk, and keep it loaded. Or use chunk loaders
Everything is working well, with one tiny exception. One single item is stuck in every upper dropper. Is there a fix for that?
I just built mine yesterday and had the same issue. I added several stacks of a named item (blue glass panes) to the item flow right before the sorter, pull them out before the overflow chest with an impulse filter, and then reinsert them back in the flow before the sorter again. This "flushes" all the items through the chain. Seems to be working for me now.
@@Bluejay327 exactly what I did to temporarily fix it.
Tene cuidado de que Shulkercraft te copie el tutorial y lo resuban a su canal.
si, nadie ve mi video ahora que todos los grandes youtubers lo tomaron, no es bueno :(
interesting but looks like I would have to be carful about pulling items out of the chest for use
hi nice video i like but can you tell me what shaders you are using?
Thank you, The shader I'm using is just called "Complementary Shaders" and the mod I'm using to run it is "Iris + Sodium"
Wait, how are the top droppers being powered?
Yeah, I don't understand this part
I think it might have to do with the redstone torch that is under the bottom hopper. I think it will pass the signal through the bottom dropper into the top dropper or something.
The top Dropper gets powered by the bottom one since it is being charged by the torch, this does seem to be taking advantage of sub-tick mechanics. Both droppers are being powered in the same tick but since the bottom one is closest to the torch it will fire first and the top one second.
P.S. Sub ticks mechanics are not involved, both droppers get powered so the item at the bottom dropper gets shot up, while the one at the top shoots it out, these 2 steps happen at the same time, which is way items get stuck in the system if only one item is sent the first bottom dropper will shoot it up and it will stop there, if a second item gets sent trough the top dropper will shoot it out
Hi, how to make a turn for this type of sorting?
Amazing! Is there a way to efficiently stack this design?
Hmm yeah that's definitely going to be tricky, I'll look into it though
Finally got around to building this and... It doesn't seem work on Bedrock... 😢
Everything worked perfectly but then for some reason when i put an item in input chest it gets stuck in the first top dropper it dosent send redstone signal anymore
@blockybryson plis do a video with this sorting sistem but in vertical layers not in one horizontsl line
How do u turn it just have hoppers ?
Yeah exactly, every module is self contained so you just have to have the items flow from one to the next, sorry for the late reply
Why didnt you add a build toturital for that one layer!!
For anyone wondering, no this does not work on Bedrock, I tried for a long time to get it to work, even making revisions to the design, but no luck.
is there anyway for this to work with the chests facing vertically?
hey so ive been having issues with alot of items getting stuck in the old design has that been fixed?
So the thing where items would slowly get stuck in the first dropper is completely gone, but the thing where one item stays in each dropper is still there on this design, although I did make a design where it doesn't do that
I noticed that the items were mostly getting stuck in the turns and also would end up further in the dropper-hopper line than the chest they were meant to be in was. Can u send me a link of ur other design im curious to try it out.
@@BlockyBryson Would love to see the design where that is fixed. You have done an amazing job!
Does this work on bedrock as well?
This doesnt work for me at all, Im not sure what im doing wrong but its not working for me, The first dropper always locks and only sorts one and then just doesnt work
It works after putting a block and redstone dust check silent whisper but I am unable to understand how it works
Make sure you are using droppers and not dispensers. That should solve the issue.
Make sure you remember also to place the redstone torch under each dropper (attached to the block the comparator sits on)
There a way to get this to be the other double chest arrangement?
I tried to make this and the items just shoot out of the dispensers instead of going into the chest
they are droppers, not diispensers
For some reason mine gets locked on the first dropper. I'm on Xbox one
Same, I followed the design exactly. The first up-facing dropper (off of the input chest and hopper) gets locked by the redstone and I can’t figure out how to fix it. Same happened on the old design, too. I want it to work so bad, wondering if you found a solution?
@@atoms_named2189 I actually found another video that worked
@@atoms_named2189 czcams.com/video/n-DotUTvSjs/video.html
@@shiftrapidz3426 thank you so much, this worked great!
I’m having the same problem. What video did you find showing the solution?
How long can it be?
Can this design be stacked?
i CANT SEEM TO GET THIS TO WORK ON BEDROCK 1.2+
Is it possible for bedrock?
Hey can i suggest a flying machine?If yes,can you make a food truck that can carry food inside with minecart chest.
and where do you show how to create it ???
Can it work for bedrock ?
Does it work for bedrock?
Build Tutorial pls
Does this work on 1.20 java?
well.. it requires you to fill an entire chest, and one item always gets stuck. on top of that its pretty slow and you cant easily expand it, but i think it will be perfect as some kind of initial filter. use this to sort cobble/dirt/coal and other things you have a lot of, and then hook the output out to an actual sorting system and you should be golden. this way your main storage isnt busy with filtering some garbage because it all stays in here.
What are the resources dude
It keeps a single item in every dropper at all times. Not a reliable design unless you don’t care about the items permanently stuck in the system
I have a stack of diorite that I throw in after sorting that I renamed Dropper Declutter.
A quick note bedrock players that .......
It also works on bedrock perfectly 😃😃
@Дж yes perfectly if use a repeater, a redstone dust,and a block towards the hopper on the right side. Just place the block on the right side of redstone torch, then redstone dust infront and then a repeater towards the hopper. EASY:D
@Дж but actually my design is different 😅
@@saikatbarai3050can you post a screenshot? I cannot figure out where to place the block/repeater without locking the hopper 😂 - and the bottom dropper does not get powered. Any tips?
@@skyblueday 😶☹️😅😅😅
Am I make a youtube channel???
@@saikatbarai3050😂 so do you keep the original placement of blocks/torches and just add one new block to the right of the torch? Is it at the same height as the torch block? And level with the torch block or in fromt/behind? Thank you!!!
Do you want to collaborate with me?
First
This does not stack like your other design. Irresponsible to release this without making that clear. I've now got to painstakingly rebuild the whole g.d. thing with the previous design.
It diesn't work. None of these dropper designs work and you're not replying to anyone whos having issues.
Downvoted.
comparator on top, repeater on bottom. torch below hopper.