I'm sorry but if you are gonna make a Pi Supercomputer and you are using over 1,000 Raspberry Pis, the only acceptable configuration is 3,141 Raspberry Pis.
More demand for this stuff. I understand that they bought a significant amount. But It is only a positive for the pi market. Supply will catch up with demand
I see A LOT of comments like "but you could achieve way better performance using a single PC or server, or this, or that". If you have students graduating from any university, and those students will follow a career path on distributed computing, they need a safe and sane environment do run experiments regarding their software development. You can't graduate and have access to a bare-metal super-computer that costs 12 million US dollars to start doing research or tinkering with your first development experiences. So yes, you can achieve better performance with less investment, but no, you can't use those same suggestions for this purpose (to enable recently graduated researchers that must gain experience working with clusters).
A locally run bare-metal server could easily spin up a toy cluster in containers or VMs for this very purpose, and wouldn't even come close to approaching $12mil. Hell, a refurbed $500-$1000 blade would be sufficient.
Well the only reason I see this as being useful is if you have a need for a lot and I mean a lot of virtual machines. Or want to maybe rent out virtual machines to people for a monthly price. Plus they don't pull a lot of power so way better for that too. Also a core is still a core. And I know that one core doesn't equal a core from better cpus but a core is still a core!!! I would love to have a big as server rack full of these pi's for my virtual machine needs. 😂🤣 Sever galore! 😂🤣
@Knobcore Good compute blades will still leave these Pis in the dust even on highly distributed tasks, the real issue you might run into is memory and IO bandwidth limitations if you spin up a massive number of VMs, but Pis aren't great on either of those fronts either.
You actually only need 2-4 nodes in order to learn about distributed computing. What benefit do you seek from using several thousand nodes over just, say, 4 or 8?
Yep. A Pi is dramatically cheaper than many solutions that came before it; they're very popular in lots of industries. My company uses them in some of our own products; they were 10x cheaper than the alternatives and they work great.
I saw that as you were building. Perhaps it would be better to plan, design, test theory, prototype and build rather than racing off like a sixth-form project.
Ah... oracle Brings me back to the days when a few of our engineers chose oracle for a 500+million$ critical system. Those were dark days. We now use free open source sw and never looked back
I wonder how Oracle priced this RAC cluster - Per core or Processor - Here comes the Oracle licence audit Police - You owe us 1 Biilllllllllion dollars
@@AnIdiotAboard_ Nearly all software companies are eventually bought up by larger companies just to hammer down on software licensing and leech the customers. Anyone remember the SCO soap from 15 years ago? The only thing I ever use from Oracle is their free Virtualbox.
Raspberry pi foundation: lets make an affordabke sbc for people to learn and sell without profit! These guys: lets buy them out of stock so none else gets!
And the Vega 64 has similar FP performance to Radeon VII for way less. They could have had this much performance for less than $1000, instead they paid like $20k+ for it.
I think it's more for development on scalability and as a model than raw power, though VMs would work too, dealing with real world switches and hardware is probably a good idea.
So how many CPU socket licenses does this count for? Or is it CPU cores now? Is this 4096 cores? Now way anyone outside of Oracle could afford such a thing. Oh.
@@tamaspacso9899 Have you done much thinking recently? Do you seriously think they haven't looked in to the costs of various solutions for the project? Do you even know WHY they're doing this?
Something like this is a great way to test code intended to be used on full scale super computers at a tiny fraction the cost of tying compute time on the real system.
@@akkudakkupl VM's are nice and all but I can't imagine it fully replicates the exact experience of running a real bare metal cluster on real switching with real cables, real nic's, etc. Surely there has to be some nuance in that. Besides, this just plain out looks more fun.
@@ChristopherGray00 they do for sure, but I think the point I was going for is the physical dimension of it. You have to plug a cables in and some fail, some identical machines return slower for no apparent reason, whole nodes will just crap themselves in unexpected ways. Really though, picking up a real server and plugging it in is fun and spinning up vm’s and virtual switching is boring.
Thats probably only one branch of tree...if your gonna get mad get mad at my backyard where these stupid trees pop up...I have to cut back 100lbs of trees every year...
@@DarxusC If you knew you needed over 1000 Pis, then the manufacturer could ship you all of them in a tray. (Just like how they go from the factory to the packaging plant)
And at a stupid price. That whole rack had to have cost around $40,000 to build, and will consume $20,000 a year in electricity (I did the math...I'm bored).
@@CrArC well in fairness the original idea for the pie as someone said before was to make an affordable sbc for people to learn and sell without profit. so that kinda goes against what they wanted
In this case it is not about speed. It's about making a testbed for learning about a large cluster without using a million $ server system that takes huge kilo watts to run.
Could have used the quad racks made by Bitscope to make wiring and networking easier. Or even better, a bunch of Turing Pis with the RPi compute module.
A British Company Offers roughly the same ARM Processor on Multiple Plug in Processor Boards. 4 years ago the entry system was 3x standard server cabinets...able to run off mains power supply. They offered 29,000 Processor Cores and the storage/RAM to back it up.
"A British Company".... So that leaves a few thousand potential businesses to work out from then. Which company in particular was it out of interest, curiosity strikes!
What was the point? To run Oracle Linux and Java? Why? I mean, if that's what's needed to run Java most effectively, a lot of questions are suddenly answered... :D
What kind of performance do you get of this, compared to the same footprint and/or cost of conventional servers? Does it actually make sense to use a Pi cluster over conventional servers?
Testing clustering setups in the cloud gets expensive really quick. Also there are some interesting benefits from physically separated work loads. But I can't speak to the creators intent.
Just for extra potential future proofing, the plastic holding the cards.. it should have been made so you have to attach the power cable then place it in the fixtures so it makes it so the power cable can't accidentally fall out, like what if you need to wheel it to another room/building.
I enjoyed the video. Nice use of 3d printed parts for mounting pi's. I am curious how well the cluster stayed cool, with the full depth rack components blocking airflow.
Pi clusters can because of the many cores be used to test real super computer software without load so you dont use up valuable time on the real thing without needing the power
If only you had done a little bit of research in to high performance/distributed/cluster computing, you might actually have learned something useful... instead of making silly comments. 🙄
Fairly certian the point was to give students an enviroment to practice and learn with using computer clusters, which is something you cant get from a regular cpu
Hi would like to know how dose the computer power on this comparied to a cray 2 computer of the old days ? and using the latest how computers i9 and nvidia gpu cards which would be faster at doing the math using the same amount of units ?
Probably to test the scalability of their applications "on a budget" (a proper server can get expensive real quick) EDIT: see the full article in the description for more info
As they are from Oracle and mentioned using a oracle flavor of Linux I asume they are testing how well / efficiently resources are delivered from many nodes.
Awesome project. Now please watch video tutorial about adding music and leveling it. It was like soft whispers of discussion then blaring music prolly triple the dBs. Otherwise, great vid
Alex Rawson exactly, the code that will run on it needs to be specifically made to scale well on thousands of cores, and has to be flexible with latency. So no usual desktop OS will run anything on something like this.
Cool project. I’m having trouble locating the aluminum extrusions you cut in the video with a bandsaw at 24seconds. Curious, where did you buy them, what is the model number or product name?
Hey Oracle, I am currently an IT student and I have a few questions, let me start with how cool this project is. My first question is why not use Ansible to automate the deployment of the raspberries, second what kind of software do you guys use for monitoring is it something like Zabbix or Prometheus?
Nice to see what can be accomplished when positive like minded people get together. What is the intended application of this cluster? Or was it a proof of concept kind of thing?
Why not using PoE-HATs on those PIs? You would save a lot of cabling and these USB power supplies. I didn't do the math of the cost for PoE switches and the HATs against the USB cabling, but the easier hardware setup would count as well?
You, like so many commenters here, have missed the point. This is a learning process, building a cheap cluster to learn how things work, where bottlenecks are, what problems they might encounter and ultimately whether a full size, high performance cluster is practical. This isn't about ultimate performance, it's about the concept.
apart from coolness is this at all practical ? Are there advantages to this over a pure CPU/GPU cluster with bus interconnects and shared ram optimized for this purpose ?
Maybe typical noise that I used to listen when I was visitting a few CPD disappears with It's RPi clusters or reducing so much than 85 %. Congratulations!!
This is a awesome build and i love the setup. I just have one problem with this is that is one of the Pi die not the Sd card but the pi it's self fails you have to shutdown a row of other pi's just to get to one of them. But other then that it is a great build.
I'm sorry but if you are gonna make a Pi Supercomputer and you are using over 1,000 Raspberry Pis, the only acceptable configuration is 3,141 Raspberry Pis.
Does that mean that the next iteration should have 31,416 Raspberry Pis.
3,142 would be more reasonable as a 5 comes after 1
@@Gamleprofil Not just a 5, but a 9. If it were only a 5 after the 1, the better way to round is round-towards-even or round-towards-odd.
noooooooo. according to last research it can be 31415926
Raspberry Square-pi?
Now I know why the Pi was sold out when I wanted one!
This is why,... I couldn't even find one
Came here to say this. I just wanted a pi of my own:(
I don't understand why they don't use the pi module they were made to do stuff like this
More demand for this stuff. I understand that they bought a significant amount. But It is only a positive for the pi market. Supply will catch up with demand
😂
I see A LOT of comments like "but you could achieve way better performance using a single PC or server, or this, or that". If you have students graduating from any university, and those students will follow a career path on distributed computing, they need a safe and sane environment do run experiments regarding their software development. You can't graduate and have access to a bare-metal super-computer that costs 12 million US dollars to start doing research or tinkering with your first development experiences. So yes, you can achieve better performance with less investment, but no, you can't use those same suggestions for this purpose (to enable recently graduated researchers that must gain experience working with clusters).
A locally run bare-metal server could easily spin up a toy cluster in containers or VMs for this very purpose, and wouldn't even come close to approaching $12mil. Hell, a refurbed $500-$1000 blade would be sufficient.
virtualisation.
Well the only reason I see this as being useful is if you have a need for a lot and I mean a lot of virtual machines. Or want to maybe rent out virtual machines to people for a monthly price.
Plus they don't pull a lot of power so way better for that too.
Also a core is still a core. And I know that one core doesn't equal a core from better cpus but a core is still a core!!!
I would love to have a big as server rack full of these pi's for my virtual machine needs. 😂🤣
Sever galore! 😂🤣
@Knobcore Good compute blades will still leave these Pis in the dust even on highly distributed tasks, the real issue you might run into is memory and IO bandwidth limitations if you spin up a massive number of VMs, but Pis aren't great on either of those fronts either.
You actually only need 2-4 nodes in order to learn about distributed computing. What benefit do you seek from using several thousand nodes over just, say, 4 or 8?
Two words: sound normalization
this cluster is too loud anyway.
Pretty amazing this isn't the top comment, the video department must be deaf!
No music at all would be even better!
thanks! when he is speaking the music is too loud and when he is not speaking the music is way too loud.
Sorry what?
No wonder the Raspberry Pi has been sold out.
Yep. A Pi is dramatically cheaper than many solutions that came before it; they're very popular in lots of industries. My company uses them in some of our own products; they were 10x cheaper than the alternatives and they work great.
these are raspberry pi 3b+ not the 4 which is out of stock
@@joefederico1501 maybee the next Super PI 4 Cluster?
2:50 Note says: "Do not touch these experiments in process, or you will die."
* he touches anyway *
Guess he wanted to die
I'm pretty sure he will die eventually (hopefully after a long life). It did not say he will die the moment he touches it
Funny I thought to myself he works for Oracle He's already dead inside
I noticed that! Glad I'm not the only one!
This is why its a short video, with no explanation on WHY?
Oracle running on pi Cluster. No wonder it’s slow and expensive 😆
Oracle Linux is just a variant of Red HAt Linux
Anton Luka Šijanec r/wosh!!11 epic like for free ipad
very slow expensive, vendor locking and with shady schemes
pass
@@moritzbecker131 with tricky contract stuff inside of it...
Is not really expensive
" Nooo, we forgot to add a heatsink to each
Pi .. we have to disassemble them all to place it ..
"
But the construction is modular
I saw that as you were building. Perhaps it would be better to plan, design, test theory, prototype and build rather than racing off like a sixth-form project.
Heat sinks are not very effective
@@bvashisht9283 What? They are incredibly effective. Literally a mandatory piece of equipment on all vaguely powerful processors.
Love how the music is loud and his voice very quite.
Ah... oracle Brings me back to the days when a few of our engineers chose oracle for a 500+million$ critical system. Those were dark days. We now use free open source sw and never looked back
how is it going on the support with OSS?
@@sefirotsama The source code is the best documentation you can have!
@@sefirotsama plenty of ways to get support for enterprise grade oss
I wonder how Oracle priced this RAC cluster - Per core or Processor - Here comes the Oracle licence audit Police - You owe us 1 Biilllllllllion dollars
Been there. Done that. Never again!
@@AnIdiotAboard_ Nearly all software companies are eventually bought up by larger companies just to hammer down on software licensing and leech the customers.
Anyone remember the SCO soap from 15 years ago?
The only thing I ever use from Oracle is their free Virtualbox.
WOOOOW imagine how many instances of Attlassian software they could run :O
that must be atleast half of an JIRA instance
Missed opportunity to make them 1024 and name it Kilo Pi. With the size measured in KPs :)
1024 that will be kibi Pi ;)
@@theau3907
Beat me to it by ~3 to 4 weeks. :)
@@wompastompa3692 Better luck next time partner ;)
You mean kibi PI
@@wompastompa3692 same xD
Raspberry pi foundation: lets make an affordabke sbc for people to learn and sell without profit!
These guys: lets buy them out of stock so none else gets!
Next step: Oracle buys the Raspbian Foundation and sues everyone who uses a Pi
Or the number π because the thought they had patented it too...
Without profit? That's why it costs more then more powerful SBCs?
what a shitty thing to do
@@universaleliteinc.6554 they are doing this since long Time and are used to do that
With all that wiring involved, there's more data in the cables than on the devices themselves.... ;)
Cool to watch for sure!
Ah, they're oracle.
Thats how that got all that money.
Hello, iam new to pi and linux etc... I see a lot of people commenting this.... Can you explain pls
Oracle make software like browser, Java stuff Idk just everything they can tbh
This cluster has about the same floating-point performance as 3 AMD Radeon VII GPUs.
And the Vega 64 has similar FP performance to Radeon VII for way less.
They could have had this much performance for less than $1000, instead they paid like $20k+ for it.
@@lazar2175 I think they built it just bc they could
I think it's more for development on scalability and as a model than raw power, though VMs would work too, dealing with real world switches and hardware is probably a good idea.
Also, I did the math, and it works out to about the same total processing power as 2 Ryzen Threadripper 3990X.
them network switches probably cost more then all the Pis they have there
So how many CPU socket licenses does this count for? Or is it CPU cores now? Is this 4096 cores? Now way anyone outside of Oracle could afford such a thing. Oh.
Yes, because Oracle Linux is the only distribution that exists...
All hail our Oracle Overlords
Ikr
Imagine the oracle socket cost ...
PLEASE RUN CINEABENCH LOL if it is possible??? would be sweet to see all those cores as blocks doing the thing it does in cinebanch
Editing tip: take down the gain on your 'music' track (or just delete it) and bring up the gain on the voice track.
"Let's jut pretend it worked, eventually they'll forget about it"
XD
This would be more efficient with a compute module
But then you need custom PCBs... Although it would be cool if the network switch and power supply were all on one board
They have a POE header, would have been more streamlined to just use POE switches
@@AndruRomin : For that you would have to do actual thinking.
@@AndruRomin You still have to mount the CM to a motherboard of some sort. Designing and producing boards isn't cheap.
@@tamaspacso9899 Have you done much thinking recently? Do you seriously think they haven't looked in to the costs of various solutions for the project? Do you even know WHY they're doing this?
Left Hemisphere: But... WHY!?
Right hemisphere: SHUT IT, LEFT! AWESOME!
No no, left brain is right: why?
Also: angry because I want about 5-10 of those. Gimme.
Something like this is a great way to test code intended to be used on full scale super computers at a tiny fraction the cost of tying compute time on the real system.
No, then you use a single $1000 blade with VM's on it.
@@akkudakkupl VM's are nice and all but I can't imagine it fully replicates the exact experience of running a real bare metal cluster on real switching with real cables, real nic's, etc. Surely there has to be some nuance in that. Besides, this just plain out looks more fun.
The most expensive part of testing on modern supercomputers is staff time.
@@Alan.livingston VMs run software practically identically to real bare metal
@@ChristopherGray00 they do for sure, but I think the point I was going for is the physical dimension of it. You have to plug a cables in and some fail, some identical machines return slower for no apparent reason, whole nodes will just crap themselves in unexpected ways. Really though, picking up a real server and plugging it in is fun and spinning up vm’s and virtual switching is boring.
I feel like they could have contacted a manufacturer to avoid needlessly recycling 1000 retail boxes
stop the virtue signaling...
Thats probably only one branch of tree...if your gonna get mad get mad at my backyard where these stupid trees pop up...I have to cut back 100lbs of trees every year...
@@eugeniovincenzo1621 Tree cutting is only a half of the problem. Cellulose factories produce a lot of waste.
Honestly, how would you package 1000 of them safely with less waste?
@@DarxusC If you knew you needed over 1000 Pis, then the manufacturer could ship you all of them in a tray. (Just like how they go from the factory to the packaging plant)
Looking at the fans, I thought: ouch! Lots of computation == lots of cooling! I hope it worked out in the end 👍
So that's where all the RPI's were going!! Was wondering why there was a shortage all of a sudden.
how much Pi boards did you buy?
Oracle Developers: *YES*
I'm as nerdy as the next person; but from the outside I just see rich people gobbling up commodity computing for some cheap thrills.
Try to see it instead as a nice chunk of income for the Pi foundation instead. More Pi's sold = good, not bad. Suppliers can always manufacture more.
And at a stupid price. That whole rack had to have cost around $40,000 to build, and will consume $20,000 a year in electricity (I did the math...I'm bored).
@@CrArC Here's to hoping to an unbelievable Pi 5
r00x I hope you’re right! 👍
@@CrArC well in fairness the original idea for the pie as someone said before was to make an affordable sbc for people to learn and sell without profit. so that kinda goes against what they wanted
how was rpi cooling working? didn't see that you put walls to cabinet to get airflow through rpis
*casually spends $35,000 on Raspberry Pis*
.... and expects a volume rebate ...
I hope everyone was this privileged to enjoy building stuff like this.
This is massively parallel excitement, and a perfect date to start! I subscribed immediately.
Me watching this during silicon chip shortage: -_-
That’s impressive, it might be able to run Rust at 13 fps!
Nah, stable 60 fps- (don't woooosh me) wait... A 9 MONTH COMMENT?!?!
the poor guy who prob had to call to confirm they weren't ordering so much pie on a typeo
Oracle Developers: over 200 PI!
Me: *gets higher speeds on an intel vpro*
In this case it is not about speed. It's about making a testbed for learning about a large cluster without using a million $ server system that takes huge kilo watts to run.
Could have used the quad racks made by Bitscope to make wiring and networking easier. Or even better, a bunch of Turing Pis with the RPi compute module.
Socked in mineral oil for improved cooling
A British Company Offers roughly the same ARM Processor on Multiple Plug in Processor Boards. 4 years ago the entry system was 3x standard server cabinets...able to run off mains power supply. They offered 29,000 Processor Cores and the storage/RAM to back it up.
"A British Company".... So that leaves a few thousand potential businesses to work out from then.
Which company in particular was it out of interest, curiosity strikes!
@@longnamedude3947 A british one
@@longnamedude3947 lol its it ARM itself
@@monad_tcp Thank you for confirming what I thought.
Remember that time when we built that ridiculous Pi cluster? That was awesome.
This was unexpected, I guess this is what an unlimited budget can build.
Exciting.. How about the running all of those Rpis efficiently
What was the point? To run Oracle Linux and Java? Why? I mean, if that's what's needed to run Java most effectively, a lot of questions are suddenly answered... :D
Nice set up what USB Power banks are you using?
Thx guys for sharing. I was looking for this type of projects since a couple of months. Beyond expectation!
Good video but the music was a little loud, keep up the good work
Can you provide some details on the USB power supplies you were using...? Thanks.
The thermoplastic you are using will deform and damage the pi cluster arrays over time.
What kind of performance do you get of this, compared to the same footprint and/or cost of conventional servers? Does it actually make sense to use a Pi cluster over conventional servers?
Nice! Also... why?
Yes indeed, why?
because
Testing clustering setups in the cloud gets expensive really quick. Also there are some interesting benefits from physically separated work loads. But I can't speak to the creators intent.
Ya hood question why....
Because kiloPi
Ah, you can now open 1 Chrome tab!
Your joke doesn't make sense, I have a single raspberry pi 4 and it can have 100s of tabs open with no reduction of performance.
@@Zed-Corps lol came to say the same. “Thaaaats not how it works bud”
Just for extra potential future proofing, the plastic holding the cards.. it should have been made so you have to attach the power cable then place it in the fixtures so it makes it so the power cable can't accidentally fall out, like what if you need to wheel it to another room/building.
What kind of monitoring and alerts do you have running for a cluster of this size?
Thats awesome!
What USB power supplies are you using? I didn’t see any mention of the model in your article.
I found them but I can't actually find a place to buy them. They are Armor-x CHR-MT60 power supplies.
I revel in the fact that there is an Amazon box smiling and lurking over the entire build. It's like there is an inferred symbolic meaning to be had.
Its beautiful....
Also, love the note on the one test: "do not touch excitement in progress. You will die".
Experiment*
Cool, Now time for raspberry pi 4 supercomputer.
what are those multi-usb charger you used? i need to know more
I too have a need for one
I'd really like to know as well. Annoyed me that the article only mentions the amount of usb power supplies, but not what type.
first one: why build it?
second one: it was cool and too expensive
agreed
next episode: tapping raspberry pis crosstalk in cheap lan cables
I enjoyed the video. Nice use of 3d printed parts for mounting pi's. I am curious how well the cluster stayed cool, with the full depth rack components blocking airflow.
thanks for amazing work but most stupid presentation and loud music..
"do not touch you will DIE" XD this is nice
Welcome to IT :)
People: Why you do this?
SuperPiBuilder: Yes
Only one word comes to my mind: awesome!!!!
I thought of buying 4 to 10 so I can have a pretty powerful array of them, but it's sold out. No wonder.
So you spent around 35000 dollars for something that is less powerful than a 10000 dollar PC
STONKS
Pi clusters can because of the many cores be used to test real super computer software without load so you dont use up valuable time on the real thing without needing the power
a 10000 dollar PC isn't a cluster though
like mentioned before, it is a good testing platform to test highly parallelized workloads in the field :D
If only you had done a little bit of research in to high performance/distributed/cluster computing, you might actually have learned something useful... instead of making silly comments. 🙄
@@another3997 Because as we all know, you're not allowed to be silly on the internet 🙄 🙄
@@dutchdykefinger You know a $10,000 PC can easily mimic a cluster, right? You do know that? Do you?
Everyone : wowoowowoow sooo strong
Me : how many usb ports on them
4096 USB ports
Thousands of dollars, just for a server rack made of Pi's... What a madman.
and then you realize you need 2x nodes to run oracle on it :))) (and 10x the cash)
Thats cool and all but....
Why?
My threadripper prolly has as much computing power, and uses less power to boot...
Fairly certian the point was to give students an enviroment to practice and learn with using computer clusters, which is something you cant get from a regular cpu
Any reason for not using PoE switches with PoE to USB adapters or native PoE hat?
Hi
would like to know
how dose the computer power on this comparied to a cray 2 computer of the old days ?
and using the latest how computers i9 and nvidia gpu cards
which would be faster at doing the math using the same amount of units ?
pardon the NOOB question, and it's not WHY, because you obviously did..... So, WHAT functionality do you hope to achieve???
Probably to test the scalability of their applications "on a budget" (a proper server can get expensive real quick)
EDIT: see the full article in the description for more info
Is this sarcasm, cuz the installer in Raspberry Pi is called NOOB
As they are from Oracle and mentioned using a oracle flavor of Linux I asume they are testing how well / efficiently resources are delivered from many nodes.
Perhaps they are trying to find out how many Oracle license servers they can run at one time?
@@SankoshSaha_01 i guess this is a good route if oracle doesn't know what docker is
Awesome project.
Now please watch video tutorial about adding music and leveling it.
It was like soft whispers of discussion then blaring music prolly triple the dBs.
Otherwise, great vid
It's like a cart being hauled by a thousand chickens!
Should've measured how long it took to calculate pi to 314,159 digits
Would have been cooler if the pi4 was used, it's so much faster for the same money!
that's one hell of a supercomputer, what is its intent?
@Deon Denis It would probably suck as a desktop, the power doesn't add like that.
Alex Rawson exactly, the code that will run on it needs to be specifically made to scale well on thousands of cores, and has to be flexible with latency. So no usual desktop OS will run anything on something like this.
Mining?
Cool project. I’m having trouble locating the aluminum extrusions you cut in the video with a bandsaw at 24seconds. Curious, where did you buy them, what is the model number or product name?
Hey Oracle, I am currently an IT student and I have a few questions, let me start with how cool this project is. My first question is why not use Ansible to automate the deployment of the raspberries, second what kind of software do you guys use for monitoring is it something like Zabbix or Prometheus?
Nice to see what can be accomplished when positive like minded people get together. What is the intended application of this cluster? Or was it a proof of concept kind of thing?
Cooperate puplicity stunt I'm guessing
Why not using PoE-HATs on those PIs? You would save a lot of cabling and these USB power supplies. I didn't do the math of the cost for PoE switches and the HATs against the USB cabling, but the easier hardware setup would count as well?
Cheaper and a hat is a point of failure.
What did the server benchmark at compared to other computers?
That's one hell of cable management
Ok fine... And what are the number:s costs, performance, latency, etc? it was worth it?
You, like so many commenters here, have missed the point. This is a learning process, building a cheap cluster to learn how things work, where bottlenecks are, what problems they might encounter and ultimately whether a full size, high performance cluster is practical. This isn't about ultimate performance, it's about the concept.
@@another3997 No he definitely hasn't missed the point.
Woo hoo, so cool! At 1:57 my son is in the ball cap on the table on the right and I am in the purple shirt at the end of the table!
Pretty cool looking but what will it be used for what's the specs of the final setup?
Awsome project. I wish that I can realise something like that one day, big up.
why? whats the purpose? this seems very inflationary to me.
What is the point?!
эхх Почему нет иметь компьютер Быстрее тогда бабушка
Description, fascinating really.
i wonder what hash rate you could get with that doing crypto?
The effort needed to play Minecraft without stuttering really is insane.
Why not use PoE hats?
had the question. Would remove a lot of the clutter and ubiquitti poe switches and not that much more expensive then the regular ones.
The hats are near half the cost of the pi again.
More costs, you couldn't fit as many per row and the switches couldn't handle the power draw anyway.
All that effort just to run JAVA smoothly... Poor environment🙁🌲🌳
apart from coolness is this at all practical ? Are there advantages to this over a pure CPU/GPU cluster with bus interconnects and shared ram optimized for this purpose ?
Maybe typical noise that I used to listen when I was visitting a few CPD disappears with It's RPi clusters or reducing so much than 85 %.
Congratulations!!
why was this done? what a stupid waste of time, resources
A bit like your existence :p
This is a awesome build and i love the setup. I just have one problem with this is that is one of the Pi die not the Sd card but the pi it's self fails you have to shutdown a row of other pi's just to get to one of them. But other then that it is a great build.
Admit it, you guys did it to play Minecraft in a super pi computer.
IoT hobbyist: I'm going to buy a pi!
Oracle: NOPE!