Great video. Interesting to see them both together. I've just ordered the FMS. Looking at the reviews the flight stall rate looks higher on the HK version. Good insight on your video . Helped me make a better buying decision for myself. Thank you!
Hi this is an old video - but thanks for your comment, if you do not mind me saying you have indeed ordered the better Aircraft (FMS) - I sold on my HobbyKing version and kept the FMS one it is just all round better...I have also sold my HK P51 and Kept the FMS P51...
Thanks for the review. We're working on restocking them along with spares. Stuart's TX16 radio settings and Gyro instructions are now available on the Corsair product page
Good to know and I will spread the word - I do say in this video that the Gyro installation document is available to down load and it is an easy replacement ... I also conclude that the HK Corsair is more true to scale and will indeed be the first one I build and fly once our UK lockdown has been lifted - thanks for your comment... the HK Corsair is a nice bit of kit - but I will ask when can we expect a Spitfire in the 750-800mm range ?
Thanks. I love your channel and appreciate the unbiased advice. I was shocked how much more the fms planes are in the uk. The 1400mm Corsair sells in the USA for for $299 and I see it listed for 339 pounds n the UK (!) ouch Fly to live....live to fly Cheers
Thanks for your comment and Yes it is - I did a lot of checking on the Internet after I made this video and came to that very same conclusion the HK is much more scale like than the FMS version.
I have flown them both - and crashed the Hobby King one more than once - it has been rebuilt and flown - but I sold it on and Stick with the FMS version - which I feel is a much better aircraft than the Hobby King.. check out the videos and let me know what you think - the Arrows F4U beats both of these - nice ....
But still a great video!! and I’m really keen on seeing these fly because I really want to purchase one! Since the hidden costs of having to buy a radio system and a battery for the hking Corsair make the price closer to that of an rtf Corsair from FMS ( More expensive in fact), the way they fly is what will ultimately help me make a decision!
yes i have many planes ..stopped buying them a couple years ago...prices are nuts now on certain ones... i did pickup a nice fms 800 mm t-28 pnp 2 yeas ago off ebay for $105 shipped... have not flown it yet...very nice little bird imo...cheers!
The 800mm FMS T28 is the best of the lot - it is really stable and so well made - good price - I purchased a lot of aircraft during 2019 and 2021 - and put them in storage for the very reason you say and they have - Prices have gone nuts.....
Thanks for the comparison I have been looking at both of these closely. Do you know if the fms wing has carbon reinforcement? I’m sure the hk (which is a rebranded top rc plane) does not. Do you think the nanotech 3s 850mah would fit in either plane? I have the hk 750 hurricane and took the orx out and put a spektrum ar630 in it. It flies very nice. Do you think there’s room in the hk Corsair for an 850mah 3s and an ar630? Thank you! Love your channel
I have taken a good close look at the FMS wing in the making of this video and the unboxing and to tell you the truth I do not know - what I can tell you is that it does NOT have th tell-tail little rectangular holes in the wing - which i have found on every other RC Foam aircraft that does have a carbon or Fibre rod imbedded into the Foam .. so based on this and this alone - I would say NO it does not have a carbon spar in the wings... The HK one defiantly does not - I have seen one crash , it break the wing in half and no sign of a spar... Yes the Nanotech 3s will fit and that is what I intend to use on both of mine... - its a tight fit but I think I can get one in as I plan to use AR620 in both of mine....I know someone who has put one in the FMS one and had to glue it upside down on the underside of the canopy .. Thanks for watching my videos and leaving your comments...
Hi martyn Good vid massive difference between the sizes put my corsair along side my hurricane.... Made the hurricane look like a dwaf....i think when it comes down to it it's swings n roundabouts your cables certainly looked crowded in the fms... I've done a reworking on mine ill post a vid. Stay lucky Brian
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I can’t wait to see your flight comparison. Here in the USA both planes are currently available. The hk one is $94 and the fms one is $109. Would you still lean towards the hk version if the price difference was only $15? I hope to belly land so I don’t see the wheels. I would think the one-piece prop should be more robust. I fly my Fms 1.1 zero as a belly lander and it’s fine but then again it has a 3-blade one-piece prop. Cheers!
It a hard choice to make - but I would go for the HK version - its more scale accurate and with the Orx it handles like a much bigger aircraft , the three blade prop really is not a problem its solid - also (when they have them) a set of three blades is only £3.00 in the UK - and really easy to replace - the FMS 4 blade (here in the UK) can cost £9-13 !!!! - not that one goes around breaking props all the time lol - the 3 spare 4 blade props I got with the FMS - were about £4.00 each ... we really get ripped off price wise in the UK...
Well presented Flanker....My HK version will measure as I will add lights!! They are sold out here as well A$140 delivered. i probably won't use the tanks & rocket as I have not on my P-51, Tempest etc. I feel they fly better without.You should have given your nails a tick as mine would have been a XI I looked at a wrecked Corsair & the elevators were like the FMS ones.
I fly with it all tanks and Rockers on - I might try and gently remove them and see what the difference feels like..... I did quite a lot of internet research and did not find a single F4U-4 with elevators like the FMS one - I have even checked on a site dedicated to the Corsair and they are all like the HK versions - even took a look at other makes and sizes of RC ones and they all have the same Elevator as the HK 750mm Version, I just don't know what to say - can you send me the link as I would like to correct it , or at least make a comment about it in the video Thanks -
It was under the google search heading ‘Pacificwrecks’ a place i have been to but not see these Corsair elevators. It is in Micronesia You can search under Corsair elevators Hope that helps mate Have a great day
@@Bellairvideo Yes already done that search (ref Corsair Elevators) and all are like the HobbyKing not the FMS - Oh well as the majority would seem to be like the HK - I will stick to my Cross and Tick allocations (LOL)....
Here in the U.S. they're both about the same price....but....the HK has a 40a ESC and can run on 2s or 3s. I'm not sure, but I think the FMS has a 20a ESC and 2s battery. I like them both, but HK F4U is me. AirHammer out!!
Thanks for that - the TOPRC models of course did not have the Orx Gyro... the Gyro really does make it feel as if you are flying a bigger Aircraft.. just more stablility....
They are both made from EPP / EPO Foam as are almost all of the foam aircraft made by the Chinese manufacturing companies and retailed by reputable brands such as FMS, Horizon Hobby, Durably, Dynam ,..etc...etc....
Big, big difference between EPP and EPO. Both of these are EPO. No molded EPP close to this size. Largest I know of is the Big Ultrix from eflight . But great, detailed comparison. I have the FMS with a Lemon gyro receiver. Underpowered on 2s not recommended for 3s. Not fun to fly. Flies fine just not fun. Have to land with considerable speed not to stall. Still, only one crash which only ripped wheels out on takeoff.
Half the price? Could you check that again? Because on the fms website, the 800mm Corsair pnp is less than $110. Compare that to hking version which is $93 only because that batch has defective defective stabilisers. Prices are expected to go up after that batch. Also apparently, the fms is also available in an rtf version for only $143..
at the time of purchase and the places I purchased from the HK was 50% of the FMS price - the HK was £72.00 and the FMS was £140.00 - The HK price of £72.00 give to take a few pounds is standard for the 800mm , so they did not reduce it in the UK for the faulty stabiliser but they did provide a replacement one.
totally agree with you having had a few years with both now and then selling them on - the FMS is better all round including the Flying quality.. Cheers
@@MONTY-YTNOM Yep - Hobby king stocks run out really fast - (I do not think they ship large enough quantities for a first release product..... disappointing for customers, I got the HK version on the day it was announced, I normally get two (one for spares) but for some reasons did not this time - then just a few days later decided I want another one and - NOOOOO - Sold out !!!
@@FlankerTanker FMS. I figured out how to get at the motor, the cowling just pulls of. It separates about 3 inches back. I removed the motor, behind that is the metal motor mount that is screwed into a plastic piece. The plastic piece is glued into a foam piece. The foam piece is only a quarter of an inch thick. Is it supposed to move around? Mine does. That might have been caused by the prop going out of balance on one blade broke off. What do you suggest?
Lovely planes but cant seee no carbon rods when we get warbirds we take them apart and use carbon fibre rods in the main fuselages shame so hard to find n uk hobbyking closed down n shipping is like £250😢😢😢😠😠😠😠gutted
Yes I have given up with Hobbyking have done for about 7 months now - but I tell you what Richard the FMS 800mm Corsair is a much better handling aircraft than the Hobbyking one ever was - I still have both but the HK will become a Hanger Queen, also HK Never had spares when you needed them FMS spares are all over the place...
@@FlankerTanker i think every one has due to them closed down or shipping £250 what's that all about 😡🙄🙄🤔🤔??i did see the fms corsair on ali express £120. And kit version is £85.00.but as i have a 3d printer i mite print one at the moment ive just printed a 400mm fw190 and doin the 400mm stuka i can see that more guys n girls will be printing planes abd and scale Fuselage for heilys.
Great video. Interesting to see them both together. I've just ordered the FMS. Looking at the reviews the flight stall rate looks higher on the HK version. Good insight on your video . Helped me make a better buying decision for myself. Thank you!
Hi this is an old video - but thanks for your comment, if you do not mind me saying you have indeed ordered the better Aircraft (FMS) - I sold on my HobbyKing version and kept the FMS one it is just all round better...I have also sold my HK P51 and Kept the FMS P51...
Thanks for your response and I like your thinking! @@FlankerTanker
Thanks for the review. We're working on restocking them along with spares. Stuart's TX16 radio settings and Gyro instructions are now available on the Corsair product page
Good to know and I will spread the word - I do say in this video that the Gyro installation document is available to down load and it is an easy replacement ... I also conclude that the HK Corsair is more true to scale and will indeed be the first one I build and fly once our UK lockdown has been lifted - thanks for your comment... the HK Corsair is a nice bit of kit - but I will ask when can we expect a Spitfire in the 750-800mm range ?
@@FlankerTanker you'll just have to wait and see.
will there be a 750mm p47 razorback, PLEASE
can you sell on amazon hobbyking?? because my card only work on amazon only if you sell on amazon i buy 1
@@HobbyKingOfficial Spitfire yes please
Thanks. I love your channel and appreciate the unbiased advice.
I was shocked how much more the fms planes are in the uk.
The 1400mm Corsair sells in the USA for for $299 and I see it listed for 339 pounds n the UK (!) ouch
Fly to live....live to fly
Cheers
Thanks Nathan - that's if you can get it - all orders I have seen here in the UK are still Pre Orders Its Expected in March ? who knows -
Great video , The Elevator on the Hobby King is as on a real corsair :) Perfect match .
Thanks for your comment and Yes it is - I did a lot of checking on the Internet after I made this video and came to that very same conclusion the HK is much more scale like than the FMS version.
I want to see them fly now! I'd probably buy the Hobby King version, but I have the Arrows 1.1m with retracts and lights now.
I have flown them both - and crashed the Hobby King one more than once - it has been rebuilt and flown - but I sold it on and Stick with the FMS version - which I feel is a much better aircraft than the Hobby King.. check out the videos and let me know what you think - the Arrows F4U beats both of these - nice ....
But still a great video!! and I’m really keen on seeing these fly because I really want to purchase one! Since the hidden costs of having to buy a radio system and a battery for the hking Corsair make the price closer to that of an rtf Corsair from FMS ( More expensive in fact), the way they fly is what will ultimately help me make a decision!
Both flown HK Crashed several times, FMS (only flown twice) but no issues at all it is much better than the HK version..
Great review !
I just ordered this plane as a filler to get free shipping , hope it flys good
Hi Ironmover - which one did you order - I guess the FMS - IT IS THE BETTER ONE -....
@@dynevor6327 the cart showed $41 for shipping international, so for an extra $69 I got another plane
I look forward to seeing them fly.
Might be sometime due to the Covid-19 Lockdown - build videos first :-)
Will be a interesting showdown 👍🏻
Both have now flown Chris - Showdown coming soon
yes i have many planes ..stopped buying them a couple years ago...prices are nuts now on certain ones... i did pickup a nice fms 800 mm t-28 pnp 2 yeas ago off ebay for $105 shipped... have not flown it yet...very nice little bird imo...cheers!
The 800mm FMS T28 is the best of the lot - it is really stable and so well made - good price - I purchased a lot of aircraft during 2019 and 2021 - and put them in storage for the very reason you say and they have - Prices have gone nuts.....
Great presentation
Thank you
Thanks for the comparison
I have been looking at both of these closely.
Do you know if the fms wing has carbon reinforcement? I’m sure the hk (which is a rebranded top rc plane) does not.
Do you think the nanotech 3s 850mah would fit in either plane?
I have the hk 750 hurricane and took the orx out and put a spektrum ar630 in it. It flies very nice. Do you think there’s room in the hk Corsair for an 850mah 3s and an ar630?
Thank you!
Love your channel
I have taken a good close look at the FMS wing in the making of this video and the unboxing and to tell you the truth I do not know - what I can tell you is that it does NOT have th tell-tail little rectangular holes in the wing - which i have found on every other RC Foam aircraft that does have a carbon or Fibre rod imbedded into the Foam .. so based on this and this alone - I would say NO it does not have a carbon spar in the wings... The HK one defiantly does not - I have seen one crash , it break the wing in half and no sign of a spar... Yes the Nanotech 3s will fit and that is what I intend to use on both of mine... - its a tight fit but I think I can get one in as I plan to use AR620 in both of mine....I know someone who has put one in the FMS one and had to glue it upside down on the underside of the canopy .. Thanks for watching my videos and leaving your comments...
Hi martyn
Good vid massive difference between the sizes put my corsair along side my hurricane.... Made the hurricane look like a dwaf....i think when it comes down to it it's swings n roundabouts your cables certainly looked crowded in the fms... I've done a reworking on mine ill post a vid.
Stay lucky
Brian
Brian I agree ...i must say that I prefer the looks and scale detail of the HK Corsair
@@FlankerTanker you might be right BUT the extra size of the fms might give it the edge on flyabilty. It's going to be a close run contest
@@BRIANFORWARD1 And unfortunately will have to wait ..........
Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
I can’t wait to see your flight comparison.
Here in the USA both planes are currently available. The hk one is $94 and the fms one is $109. Would you still lean towards the hk version if the price difference was only $15?
I hope to belly land so I don’t see the wheels. I would think the one-piece prop should be more robust. I fly my Fms 1.1 zero as a belly lander and it’s fine but then again it has a 3-blade one-piece prop.
Cheers!
It a hard choice to make - but I would go for the HK version - its more scale accurate and with the Orx it handles like a much bigger aircraft , the three blade prop really is not a problem its solid - also (when they have them) a set of three blades is only £3.00 in the UK - and really easy to replace - the FMS 4 blade (here in the UK) can cost £9-13 !!!! - not that one goes around breaking props all the time lol - the 3 spare 4 blade props I got with the FMS - were about £4.00 each ... we really get ripped off price wise in the UK...
Thanks ,very helpfull video
in the end after building and flying both - I Sold the Hobby King and Kept the FMS
Well presented Flanker....My HK version will measure as I will add lights!! They are sold out here as well A$140 delivered. i probably won't use the tanks & rocket as I have not on my P-51, Tempest etc. I feel they fly better without.You should have given your nails a tick as mine would have been a XI I looked at a wrecked Corsair & the elevators were like the FMS ones.
I fly with it all tanks and Rockers on - I might try and gently remove them and see what the difference feels like..... I did quite a lot of internet research and did not find a single F4U-4 with elevators like the FMS one - I have even checked on a site dedicated to the Corsair and they are all like the HK versions - even took a look at other makes and sizes of RC ones and they all have the same Elevator as the HK 750mm Version, I just don't know what to say - can you send me the link as I would like to correct it , or at least make a comment about it in the video Thanks -
It was under the google search heading ‘Pacificwrecks’ a place i have been to but not see these Corsair elevators. It is in Micronesia
You can search under Corsair elevators
Hope that helps mate
Have a great day
@@Bellairvideo Yes already done that search (ref Corsair Elevators) and all are like the HobbyKing not the FMS - Oh well as the majority would seem to be like the HK - I will stick to my Cross and Tick allocations (LOL)....
That is good. I would prefer the HK that way.
Have a great week
Here in the U.S. they're both about the same price....but....the HK has a 40a ESC and can run on 2s or 3s. I'm not sure, but I think the FMS has a 20a ESC and 2s battery. I like them both, but HK F4U is me. AirHammer out!!
That's interesting - because BOTH of these have a 20A ESC (one from the UK and one from New Zealand) - and both are rated from 2s or 3s -
The HK Corsair and the others they sell are rebranded Top RC models that have been out for many years
Thanks for that - the TOPRC models of course did not have the Orx Gyro... the Gyro really does make it feel as if you are flying a bigger Aircraft.. just more stablility....
What's the foam used for each plane? EPP? not keen on a EPS built plane.
They are both made from EPP / EPO Foam as are almost all of the foam aircraft made by the Chinese manufacturing companies and retailed by reputable brands such as FMS, Horizon Hobby, Durably, Dynam ,..etc...etc....
Big, big difference between EPP and EPO. Both of these are EPO. No molded EPP close to this size. Largest I know of is the Big Ultrix from eflight . But great, detailed comparison. I have the FMS with a Lemon gyro receiver. Underpowered on 2s not recommended for 3s. Not fun to fly. Flies fine just not fun. Have to land with considerable speed not to stall. Still, only one crash which only ripped wheels out on takeoff.
Half the price? Could you check that again? Because on the fms website, the 800mm Corsair pnp is less than $110. Compare that to hking version which is $93 only because that batch has defective defective stabilisers. Prices are expected to go up after that batch. Also apparently, the fms is also available in an rtf version for only $143..
at the time of purchase and the places I purchased from the HK was 50% of the FMS price - the HK was £72.00 and the FMS was £140.00 - The HK price of £72.00 give to take a few pounds is standard for the 800mm , so they did not reduce it in the UK for the faulty stabiliser but they did provide a replacement one.
i built 2 fms kit versions years ago...very decent planes ..i made some mods which is real easy...
I have been told that the Tail plane and elevator needs a mod?? is this one that you did ?
You may be impressed with HK elevator, just wait for that torsion bar to bend. Like mine did. FMS better build.
totally agree with you having had a few years with both now and then selling them on - the FMS is better all round including the Flying quality.. Cheers
Visually I like the HK one more
Same here and the HK one is more scale correct...also a really good price....
@@FlankerTanker Annoyingly , again, I was looking at it last night, went to buy today and they had all gone
@@MONTY-YTNOM Yep - Hobby king stocks run out really fast - (I do not think they ship large enough quantities for a first release product..... disappointing for customers, I got the HK version on the day it was announced, I normally get two (one for spares) but for some reasons did not this time - then just a few days later decided I want another one and - NOOOOO - Sold out !!!
@@FlankerTanker Im waiting for the Tempest. That's the one I really want. Had it in the cart, went to pay and it was sold out :(
Can you show us how to get at the motor? Mine is loose and I will need to fix that.
Which one the FMS or the Hobby KIng ?
@@FlankerTanker FMS. I figured out how to get at the motor, the cowling just pulls of. It separates about 3 inches back. I removed the motor, behind that is the metal motor mount that is screwed into a plastic piece. The plastic piece is glued into a foam piece. The foam piece is only a quarter of an inch thick. Is it supposed to move around? Mine does. That might have been caused by the prop going out of balance on one blade broke off. What do you suggest?
I had the hobby king hawker hurricane park fly version the gyro ruined it,flyed better without it
I have also had problems with the ORG Gyros that are in the Hobby KInk 750mm warbirds ...
Which one flys best? That's the crux of the matter!
Indeed it is - Due to lock down in the UK I have not flown yet - Hope to do some over the Easter Bank Holiday now that the clubs are open
2:43 'Suecifications...'
Well Spotted - looks like the chines to English translator was not working at 100% the day they set up Printing for this box ...😂
Lovely planes but cant seee no carbon rods when we get warbirds we take them apart and use carbon fibre rods in the main fuselages shame so hard to find n uk hobbyking closed down n shipping is like £250😢😢😢😠😠😠😠gutted
Yes I have given up with Hobbyking have done for about 7 months now - but I tell you what Richard the FMS 800mm Corsair is a much better handling aircraft than the Hobbyking one ever was - I still have both but the HK will become a Hanger Queen, also HK Never had spares when you needed them FMS spares are all over the place...
@@FlankerTanker i think every one has due to them closed down or shipping £250 what's that all about 😡🙄🙄🤔🤔??i did see the fms corsair on ali express £120. And kit version is £85.00.but as i have a 3d printer i mite print one at the moment ive just printed a 400mm fw190 and doin the 400mm stuka i can see that more guys n girls will be printing planes abd and scale Fuselage for heilys.