Why is the Indian Economy bleeding talent? Socio-economic case study
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 08. 2024
- Learn Website Development from Apna College using this link -
🔥Join New DELTA Batch : bit.ly/3snpY7G
for International Student (payment link) - buy.stripe.com...
📌 Details about the Delta 2.0 Batch :
- Start Date : 31st August, 2023
- Alternate day lectures (at 8PM)
- Duration - 4.5 months
- Each Class duration : 1.5 hour-2hour (alternate days)
- Access to the course is for 2 years
- Complete Frontend Development with HTML, CSS, Javascript & ReactJs
- Complete Backend Development (NodeJs, ExpressJs)
- Complete Database -( SQL & MongoDB)
- Complete MERN Stack (MongoDB, Express, React, Node)
- Real Life and Industry Grade Projects
- Live Mentorship Sessions
- 500+Topic Videos
- Certificate will be given on Completion.
(Taught by Shradha Ma’am)
⭐️ Think School’s flagship Communication course with an exclusive workshop on Chat GPT included:
thethinkschool...
VIDEO INTRODUCTION: India is one of the biggest traders in the world economy!!! But do you know what is the most valuable resource we export??? most people might look at the stat and say it's engineering goods and petroleum products!!
but In reality, the most valuable resources we export are the goddamn people of India!!!! and you must have seen this every August when our friends proudly leave India and take out a 30-60 lakhs loan just to go and study in the US!!! and while most people think its, not a big deal at all,
I gotta tell you, that when Talented people like you leave India, it costs the Indian economy an insane 17 billion dollars or 1.36 Lakh crores every single year!!! You know much money that is, it's more than 2 times the profit of Reliance Industries, 19 times the profit of Bajaj Finance, and 28 times of the profit of Adani ports!!!
This my dear friends is bleeding the Indian economy every single year!! and as citizens of the country, this is one of the burning issues that we need to focus if at all we want to become a 10 trillion economy!!
So in this special case study, let's try to understand,
What is so terribly wrong about the design of Indian education that India has become a dalal of talent for the world?
What are the fundamental reasons for the talent drain of India?
and most importantly, as citizens of the country where do we need to push the govt to fix this brain drain problem of India???
Think School is a Digital School that we all deserved, but never had
►►Check out Think School's Online courses: www.thethinksc...
⬇️Our Top 2022 Playlist
Geopolitics:
India is Trapping China - • How India is TRAPPING ...
Oil Giants Crushing Europe - • How Saudi Arabia & Rus...
Israel’s Secret Strategies - • How did Israel become ...
China vs India Military Strategy in Ladakh - • Why is China taking ov...
Upcoming US Recession Affects Indian Economy - • How US Recession will ...
Best of Business:
1. Asian paints - • How Asian Paints Built...
2. Amul - • How Amul beat its comp...
3. Haldiram - • How did Haldiram Build...
4. Malboro - • The Genius Marketing S...
5. Lijjat Papad - • How 7 Mumbai-based wom...
►Books Everyone should read:
1. Sapiens: amzn.to/3wIqqtG
2.Jab Jab Jab Right Hook: amzn.to/3eb36ym
3.Presuasion: amzn.to/3nF4Xi8
4.Start with why: amzn.to/2R7UHCW
5. Culture code: amzn.to/3tfaxsZ
6. Hooked: amzn.to/2R9G9CM
7. I will teach you to be rich: amzn.to/3AUDLSO
8. From Third world to First: amzn.to/3yQSjAV
9. This is Marketing: amzn.to/334VNlL
🎧 Want to buy the equipment we use?
1. Our Laptop: amzn.to/3z66odv
2. Our Mic: amzn.to/3liQQyi
3. Camera Stand: amzn.to/3z8l3ov
4. Mobile holder for stand: amzn.to/3xgCF25
5. Laptop: amzn.to/3gMYXRi
✅Study Materials:
✅To support our work you can donate here: www.instamojo....
#thinkschool #businesscasestudy #geopolitics Credits: CNN-News 18, WION, NBC News, Money control pro, Business standard, TV18,Business Today, ABC news, CNBC, ET now ,Bloomberg originals, Financial Times, DW documentary, AL Jazeera English, BBC news, Firstpost. Fair use - This video is for educational purposes only. All materials used in this video, including images, audio, and video clips, are the property of their respective owners and are used here under the doctrine of fair use. This video is intended to provide commentary, criticism, research, and education on the subject matter. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law.
You can learn Website Development from Apna College using this link -
🔥Join New DELTA Batch : bit.ly/3snpY7G
for International Student (payment link) - buy.stripe.com/bIYaEQ9beek610sbIS
---------------------------------------------------
📌 Details about the Delta 2.0 Batch :
- Start Date : 31st August, 2023
- Alternate day lectures (at 8PM)
- Duration - 4.5 months
- Each Class duration : 1.5 hour-2hour (alternate days)
- Access to the course is for 2 years
- Complete Frontend Development with HTML, CSS, Javascript & ReactJs
- Complete Backend Development (NodeJs, ExpressJs)
- Complete Database -( SQL & MongoDB)
- Complete MERN Stack (MongoDB, Express, React, Node)
- Real Life and Industry Grade Projects
- Live Mentorship Sessions
- 500+Topic Videos
- Certificate will be given on Completion.
(Taught by Shradha Ma’am)
Bro every video has detailed information ❤❤
In India engineers have no value.
Most engineers are making around 15k per month.
Web developer with some experience only get 20k-30k.
In US web developer can make atleast 40-50lakh per year.
There is nothing wrong with sending all of your students to study and work abroad.
But India's biggest mistake is to just stop there and do nothing
Once that is done, India should come up with policies to lure these youngsters back to the country so that they can contribute the knowledge and experience they learnt from studying and working in the west.
Countries like China and Singapore are experts when it comes to luring talented people from the west back to their country. India should learn from China.
First: eliminate homework in the primary stage and just focus on personality development.
Second: use less rigid semester systems and cce system.
Third; in higher education bring industry collaboration
Fourth ; Hire professors from Japan and Korea as PhD heads , and advisory panel of experts , next: increase funding
I think you missed one more point ARAKSHAN. This is the biggest mess in history of indipendent India ever created.
Can you make a video on this particular topic?
Some group of economists have projected that both the U.S and parts of Europe could slip into a recession for a portion of 2023. A global recession, define as a contraction in annual global per capita income, is more rare because china and emerging markets often grow faster than more developed economies. Essentially the world economy is considered to be in recession if economic growth falls behind population growth.
It’s a delicate economical season, so you can do nothing or little on your own. Hence, I will suggest you get yourself a financial advisor that can provide you with valuable financial information and assistance.
That’s why I always make it a point to speak with a financial advisor before choosing any investments. Apparently , I’ve been using one since the pandemic, using profits oriented tactics and minimizing risks as a buffer against inevitable downtrends.
In addition they have valuable access to insider knowledge and analysis, making failure virtually impossible for them. I’ve made over $1.5million passively working with Gregory Thomas Patchak, my advisor for over three years now.
__
Your advisor really seem to know this stuff. I found his online-page when I made a google search of his full names online, read through his resume, educational background and qualifications, it was really impressive. I left him a note and booked a call session with him..
__
With the help Sir Gregory Thomas Patchak, I've gained perfectly well from my investment. The quantity of capital you invest, though, ultimately determines everything. With a substantial start-up budget, you could be able to earn more Gains..
Mohak Mangal recently made a video on Indian education system's incapability to nurture innovation. I think that's a good reason why most Indian students leave India.
It is not education system ..the same Indian guy works in petrol pump super store McDonald's every shop
The same guy will not do work in india
Dignity of labour problem
Also not appreciation in childhood,, and many more reason
Just like GDP per capita in India is very low.
Ye sab Chaachaa ki galthee hain!
Achcha hua ki 2014 ke baad sab vaapas aa rahe hain to our SMART cities 6 times size of Shanghai!
Vishwaguru 🎉 🥳
@@shyamraahatt bskd
My wife is a doctor and now a researcher at one of the world's top three pharmaceutical companies and they gave her an entire room with cutting edge infrastructure and tech to conduct her experiments. This is how Westerners value our work.
price of cattle is different in every country but it has nothing to do with actual value of the cattle.
@@maklame3318 But the quality is different.
why don't you go back? why are you taking those westerner's jobs?
create your own company in india.
It takes months and sometimes a year worth of red tape and bribes to make things happen in India. Not to mention high taxes without any benefits.That is a major reason why even Indians usually aren't very interested in coming back until these things change.@@Sanyu-Tumusiime
@@Sanyu-Tumusiimegive them one reason to go back from what he has said?
Few reasons which were missed in video
1. Reservation (its required but wrongly implementation)
2. Outdated syllabus starting from school. We are taught many things which never use in our daily lives or in job.
3. Paying taxes has no benefits. Road in major cities are still in pathetic condition, health infrastructure is poor. Which is not the case in US/Europe. They take taxes but in return provide better health infrastructure, schools and roads.
4. The above point also contributes to "Better quality of life"
In spite of all these issues, "Mera Desh hai India" and I wouldn't want to leave my beautiful country.
Reservation is only in government sector the main reason is lack of private sectors
India's talent pool is draining because young population is fed up of corruption, reservation, impractical education system and lack of talent recognition
Mostly it's overpopulation and better infrastructure in developed countries. Maybe in next 10 years we will some downwards trend.
+ Standard of living
so what our last to last pervious generation (freedom fighters) conditions were even worst still they serve their motherland our conditions is even better
I am not saying don't move abroad for study or work just give your best and best for India
in fact I work in usa making about 60K yearly and saving 30K and that saving I invest in Indian stocks every years once I cross 1 millions in stocks I will return back
@BULLYMAGUIRE.Overpopulation is more dominant so even govt is unable to provide facilities.look the population of even all developed countries.
ppl fed up of dysfunctional judiciary, haphazard urban development, daily struggles of travel, stifling of innovation and businesses, devalued currency, weak passport, weak implementation of rule of law.
Bureaucratic professor's obsession over MARKS and 75% ATTENDANCE‼️ 😅.......So true 💯
True😅
Oh I love this one.
They will decide whether you will survive or not based on how you talk and what kinda marks you get.
My 12th maths teacher told me you will be nothing. You might have eto beg on road for a living.
Now I am a researcher with lots of funds and good research papers.
I send papers to my other teachers, and they do talk about it.
Just met one a few hours ago. He told me Uska na chehra laal ho jata hai tere bare me sunke.
Seh nhi paata woh teri tarife.
Once this year is over, I am gonna make a list of all the papers I have published, all the grants I have received and send to my teachers. And ask them to put it on School's notice board, as one of their student is a Scientist.
Wanna see him burn with jealousy
Finally Some one Talked about it thanks but the system won't change here
@@sameerquazi2626Most of the Teachers Curse won't work bro😂😂😂 it is the truth
@@Cool_smileybefore removing reservation,
the caste system should be removed and should also stop caste discrimination.
Then they should give only reservation on the basis of financial status and merit only.
Then all this will end.
When people speak of reservation they should also speak about ending caste system and caste discrimination.
This video and Mohak Magnals' recent video combined helped me connect all dots, and reinforce my decision of first studying and learning how their ecosystems are created and function in the US and then come back to India and do something incredible!
1. Accesible education to motivated individuals(loans, grants, scholarships, work study programs, co-ops)
2. put the workforce to work by creating more jobs, incentivize companies who provide jobs with tax cuts
3. Make sure hard work pays off and there is no unfair advantage for some sections of the community(not entirely perfect in USA but still better than in India)
Reservations should be removed in IITs , IIMs and AIIMS and in Promotions.
Also , Reservations can’t be based on Cast and Religion, it should be based on Economical condition of the Family .
I run a animation company in rural India. Here I felt the social conditioning is such that employees by default start hating employer and it's a daily struggle to make them understand their work responsibilities.
Indians learn from childhood through movies and other media that business owners are crooks. There should be a campaign through movies or in media to demonstrate the struggles of business like the western media.
There comes the"sab chalta h attitude " the businessman r crooks so we should do the same too
because most business are crook in India , as i graduated from top college of India started working in unicorn startup , earlier they have wasted funding money on useless things and now forcing us to work like slaves and firing large number of employees directly or indirectly.
Indian business are mostly pathetic
Do u need a employee?i do 3d animation.
@@eren-qu9uuSee, we have a live example. How can you conclude that their investments are useless? Are you that smart and experienced to judge them?
Mostly business in India more towards crook type biggest example is Byjus where they are screwing the employees
I have done my PhD from IIT Bombay. Last year I have applied for Assistant Professor position (50-60K salary) in private college in Nashik. In Interview, I tried to explain my research on Molecular dynamics simulations to study polymer nanocomposites and colloids, but they were not interested. Instead, they asked me some Mass transfer equation which is available easily in books (may be they expect me to remember as I have degree in chemical engineering). Currently, I am doing research in my field of MD simulation to study colloidal gels in US university ($50k+ salary). But I still want to come back to India and work in my field.
When The old batch gone then India will top 🔝
@@kiran-chilukurihopefully
@@kiran-chilukuri No, unless the loss in money is shown in every newspaper everyday and ask everyone to stop pulling others down, India will always remain service to other countries.
dont ever try to come in India
@UmeshDhumal007
Please keep working on USA, the country of dreams, the world's number one country.
Don't come to India because you will get lower salary, no facility, no equipments, and no support from any authority
Don't make the mistake of returning to India and living a life of missed opportunities and suffering, instead settle in US and lead a happy life
Very correctly said by one of our friend. INDIA has chosen reserved people over talent. 😢😢
@Ritesh-pv4yi genral cut off is too high
@Ritesh-pv4yi Yes, better we move abroad. Enjoy your India.
Till my high school, I was determined to build my country and ready to sacrifice for my India. But after giving Jee I understood the horrific condition of our education system even though due to reservation I was unable to get into my desired college but seeing the conditions of doctors and engineers i understood it is better to leave country as soon as possible
I always knew I wanted to move abroad. When I was younger, in middle school and high school, my friends laughed at me and kinda hated me for it. They said I'm traitor, they should evoke my citizenship and what not and swore they will never betray their country. Now they're all in abroad right after 12th and I'm still on my plan to move after my degree.
Tell me you're incompetent without telling me you're incompetent, if not iit, at even 98% you could've went to a nit, just simply say you couldn't even manage to do that rather than blaming reservation.
Tell me you are ignorant without telling me you are ignorant @@Iwill_beback
SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
@@indiasuperclean6969😂
Everything you said is true and correct. However, as someone who lived in the US for 21 years and then returned to India, one thing that I found most difficult to deal with is as follows. In the US, I used to spend 80% of my time on real work and 20% on administrative and other bullsh!t stuff. In India, that equation gets reversed: 80% on bulls!t and 20% on real work. I hated it so much that I retired after working for three years in India. Indian workplace is rife with politics, gossip, and other assorted nonsense and there is very little focus on real work. Why would a talented person work in such an environment? You can blame the education system all you want but it is how we behave that is a very big impediment to progress.
hey I'm about to start working abroad! in north America how is the work environment there? since you have spent a large portion of your life there would love your insights!
Good luck in America/Canada or wherever you end up! Every single indian i've met and worked with as an engineer in the us has been great, and their american kids they have here are even better. Good luck!@@Vibhu_Kishan
That’s why we need to change our political system. India need political reforms at first and for that politicians and voters need proper education and awareness about democracy and their rights and duties.
@@rahul28 Huh? I was talking about the corporate world, not the politics or education system. Which brings me to another point: Stop blaming everything on politics and politicians. Take responsibility for your own actions.
SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
I am from IIT and now working in the US. I think the biggest challenge for me to work in India is the mindset of people in India. In the US, we are allowed freedom to think, take risks, come up with solutions and the work culture is very inclusive. In India, the managers and the company managements are very strict, and they don't allow us to experiment and "waste" time. So, in India, we have to keep doing the same repetitive tasks without any innovation. Also, casteism, favoring people from same states, or favoring only people from the north or south creates a rift and the work culture becomes toxic.
Hello brother I just completed my graduation in finance and I'm. Currently working in a PSU
I want my ways to be open so which country would you advice me to go and study further and get well paying decent jobs and work life balance
I have a balance here but I feel like I have more capabilities to nurture than working in the current organisation
Don't you face racism there, bro
Word.
I work in a giant service based mnc , and I have noticed this favouritism towards people from a certain state.
They don't even bother to change the language when they add other people to the call.
Plus the managers make life hell , making peope work for long hours, weekends without any compensation. Absolute 0 concern .
u r 100%True,North dominantion and castism always works in MNC s in india.I faced that.
@@vedantchapale1262india 👍
0:27: 💼 India's brain drain is costing the economy billions of dollars every year.
5:13: 💡 India's business ecosystem hindered the growth and retention of skilled engineers from IITs.
7:39: 🌍 The brain drain in India is caused by a lack of job opportunities and exclusive education.
11:14: 💔 The quality of engineering and medical education in India is poor, leading to a high number of unemployable graduates who either leave the country or become a liability.
15:33: 🧠 The brain drain problem in India can be addressed by improving industry-academic connect, providing inclusive education, and investing in research and development.
18:19: 💡 The government of Israel invested in research and development and built an ecosystem for entrepreneurs, resulting in the growth of the tech industry and billion dollar acquisitions.
Recap by Tammy AI
SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
Which part of the country you are in??
Getting out is gains to others now and yet gains to Indians in the futures
I work in Dubai and did masters in UK. For me, most important of all reasons is people around us. I am not talking about socio economic status but manners and conduct of people.
Damn right
As a software engineer, I feel good talents feel exploited in India, that's why tech talent leave India. Indian employers like Infosys, Wipro TCS give pennies as salaries and make them work on weekends. Even after that there is no recognition. Sad reality but true. Indian employer needs to create an environment where a talent's hard-work is recognised and appreciated.
haha they pay peanuts that even not working usa citizen earns more than that just by sitting at home. they have pensions there
That's not peanut, Western companies outsource works to indians due to cheap labour cost
True fact about indian IT companies.
@BULLYMAGUIRE.There is no reservation in private sector lol.
Best comments.
100% Truth, For tech talent this is the Reason for most of the people, Why they leave.
I am a Civil Engineer from BITS and no matter how good I am at the things I was taught in college, I cannot get a job of more than 7 Lakhs per annum. I now have a choice to leave Civil Engineering or leave India because at 7 Lakh per annum I cannot afford to pay back my rent and loan at the same time.
Go for masters outside india
Go outside and come back
7 lakh in pilani ??
@@shashi2331 yes for Civil Engineering
@@Naruto-ux3lx never come back.. norway and luxembourg are good nations. i'm a finance student but imma leave asap... coz govt ko votebank appeasement ke alawa kuch nahi dikhta.
general category + male = indian govt doesnt care whether u live or die.
Firstly I want to thank you for bringing up this serious issue and would love to have your insight about the medical field scenario in India the next b tech.😢
“padega India tabhi toh badega America ” this line is too accurate for current situation :-(
Hi Ganesh, Passing by IIT BOMBAY and watching this video. I can see pain in your eyes for this video. Not even in a single frame you smiled.
I have been looking for answer to this questions from longest time and nothing other than your video could address this issue better.
Thank you very much for your extensive research and all the hard work you put in to bring this top class content to us.
Amazing insights! Another problem is that as a person ages, opportunities gets much more restricted in India. I have seen that 15+ years expert coders and architects are forced to take up management roles while they wish to continue in being technical in IT field. And many fear loosing job or not able to get any more opportunities just because of the age. In USA, they value experience and people have opportunities to work even after 60+ years and remain relevant, while continue in the field of thier interest.
What you said is not true…the same happens in USA too
The same thing happens in the whole world... what's important here is the scale of it and how widespread it actually is. Most indian people i've met/worked with in the us are just extremely tired of it... and while there's plenty of bullshyt here in the states, they much prefer that bs to indias for whatever basket of reasons. But there's no perfect country/industry/job/etc.@@SchoolOfUnlearning3
Mine is a private university considered a top institute in my state(I won't name it), few major problems I could see are:
- You can literally get more than 8 CGPA just by regurgitating the answers before the exams.
- They make you write codes on paper(in few examinations).
- Each question paper is a mixture of previous year examination questions(they don't even change the data provided in questions!)
- Poor quality of faculties, only interested in going through PPTs and done.
- Useless lab practical files. They just throw hundreds of them in the dustbin at the end of the semester.
- 85% freaking attendance, else face consequences.
It is so easy to get a 8+ CGPA with zero, literally zero actual skills.
Great content! But you seem to have missed one of the major reasons which is deplorable work conditions and environment even after getting good skills.
I did my graduation from IIT Kanpur and joined the R&D dept of a famous Indian motorcycle company.
There I found some amazing as well as toxic people. The worst thing I had to face was the hate some people had for me just because I was from IIT background. They used to say that since I was from IIT, I didn't have to work hard to get a placement, unlike them who had to work hard for it.
They didn't consider that I got into an IIT at the first place because of my hardwork, not because of any preference or "sifarish".
Resigned later. Some of my friends went for masters in the US and are staying there. I guess I'll find my way there too.
Edit: I'm the only child of my parents, mother being a homemaker and father a retired officer. It's upon me to earn and I can't afford at the moment to work in a small company with tiny paycheck. Opportunities exist in India but I'm discouraged by the atmosphere.
So while I'd not want to comment on reservation or education or employment policies, one thing I can definitely say from my experience is that people need to respect talent instead of dismissing them and taking them for granted. It feels like an insult to your hardwork.
I don't know whether this is special in UP. People are proud about things that they shouldn't be proud about. It was a cultural shock for me.😅
Its not only just in education or work ,be it business growth ,growth in ur wealth , most people in India get jealous of the persons achievement and ridicule it by saying he is 'Lucky'. Generally people see outcome not the the risk taken ,hardwork and time spent to reach where they are . Its people mindset ,so dont worry that it happened to you and only in the workforce :) .It happens everywhere in India and in all spheres .
Of course you didn't have to work hard. Others have to work hard to match your level.
@@MrKorlepara now, that's also because of the parents and society's mindsets. In India people just can't praise someone else's child without comparing and degrading theirs. This in turn makes the child always feel threatened by their peers' achievements and hence the bitter and toxic attitude. Our country is f**ked in multiple ways and I already lost the count of things holding it back.
They didn't know how hard you worked to get into IIT.
I liked the way you prevented to touch the Reservation issue while also just brushing past it under the guise of 'exclusivity'. Cudos to your communication skills brother!!!
Even after getting 10 EWS reservatikn some people still cry about reservation
It's not just reservation. There are many adavantages that developed economies have over India. Apart from the more obvious benefits like better employment and business opportunities and better wages, advanced economies have the following advantages:
1. Lower crime
2. Lower corruption
3. Lower pollution
4. 24/7 electricity and clean water supply
5. Good waste management facilities
6. Less competition for things like jobs, resources etc.
7. Better quality education
8. Better quality healthcare
9. Forward thinking and rule abiding society
10. Better infrastructure and urban design
11. Stronger passports
12. Stronger currency
13. More variety of products and services with better quality
14. Better customer service
15. Easier to save money
16. Better social safety net
17. Rule of law
18. Better technology
19. Better sense of organization and cleanliness
20. No events that cause public disturbance like bandh and harthal
21. More global exposure
22. Better opportunities for personal development
23. Better opportunities for career advancement
24. Meritocracy
25. Better climate
26. Better natural disaster management
27. Better governance
28. Better work life balance
29. Better recreational options
30. Better convenience of doing things
31. Better access to credit
32. Better maintenance culture
33. Lesser wealth inequality
34. Better collection and usage of tax revenue
35. No interference of politicians and bureaucrats in everything
36. Availability of certain unique products and services
37. More avenues to make good money
How is reservation related to engineering talent moving abroad.
@@coconutpunch123 cut-off dekhi hai EWS ki kabhi? Jhunjhuna pakda Diya and who says we are not in favor of removing it as well?
@@coconutpunch123 reservation should be made only on basis of income groups wether it be from whatever caste
Being an immigrant to the west the only answer I would give is there is a lot of focus on non-necessary value added stuff rather than value adding stuff in education be it a high school or university. Students are not asked to be creative they are asked to be scared and fed doses of anxiety, plus the contributing factor is also society which only gives respect if you are an engineer or doctor. Hence proved "Padhega India tabhi toh badhega America".
There's also one minor point, which I believe is also very important and that's infrastructure and safety. (Specially for women) even after just visiting US/UK it was so hard for me to adjust with the insane honking, lack of infrastructure, lack of safety and unnecessary moral policing by people. Whereas in abroad, the public space is public space you can have beer, enjoy with family friends. Here public spaces are all about govt. property and nothing is allowed. Some people counter argue that even the people of India are uneducated and will misuse. But then should we never expect a better standard of living? its like one person had a car accident and cars all across city is banned. In short people here are not happy everyone looks irritated, struggling whereas out of India everyone are happy, smiling, greeting. It's hard truth!
great videos btw!
Excellent study.. Need to be addressed on priority. .Bureaucrats/government should watch this and need to start working on it...Even our education is draining..
I worked in USA for 6 years, then come back to India 3 years ago. At this point, it seems like it was my biggest mistake. If I had stayed in USA, I could had worked for OpenAI or moved to London to work for Deepmind and contributed to development of AI. But in India there are no such opportunity.
India don't believe in it's own talent. Most people think that building AI in India is not feasible.
India Govt think AI Mean America India
@UniverseHZ If RESERVATION is the reason.....then why these NRIs are happy to work in private companies abroad but not in private companies in India??? There is no reservation in private sector😂merit only
@@Rdev845reservation to get into college .
If sundar pichai was student in todays time there is lesser chance for him to get into IIT , as he is brahmin and reservation increased upto 75%, it was half in his time.
India is famous for providing services to American clients. If you want to have good tech experience join some ai startups in india .
@@busypandey Yes it was half in his time...50% for ST SC OBC and other 50% indirectly reserved for generals....when OBC started giving competition to generals and started capturing seats outside their quota thats when it hurt general most.
Another Brilliant episode and included very pertinent points. What about Open and Individualistic cultures Vs. Closed and collective cultures?. I am more of a culture guy - so I was looking for some points on Cultural differences, work culture differences, as well as professional culture and professional aspiration. I wanted to serve my native town but could not secure general medicine so got into Radiology. Still, I worked in Govt service for three years and in 2007 decided to give it a shot to move to the West - I succeeded and settled in the USA now. I have mixed feelings about what is right and what is wrong. 1. For the economy part I have to agree - this is a loss for India but I have a question - all the loans students take for higher education in the USA - will it have any positive impact on Indian banks and the economy? 2. I have tried the private practice of radiology - and the way Medicine is practiced in India is not uniform and not everybody's cup of tea- it is very cut-throat and - very few are succeeding. (Not saying this highly expensive American System is right - but profession part I am happy). 3. Can India come up with plans like taxing their Citizens who are making certain amounts of money abroad - Of course - this gets political (I just do my personal work in areas of interest in India though). 4. What is the role of cultures in this entire migration process - I always tell to my kids that Migration for Culture fits my mindset and thought process (I am not justifying the damage it can do to my home nation). I am just processing. Open and Individualistic Cultures vs. closed and Collective Cultures. That is what I am debating more on my CZcams channel.
During Junta Govt (1977 - 79), Govt asked the then Planning Commission to check how much of Technology was actually transferred in Electronic Industry they various collaborations in private and public sector. It came out that IBM instead of leasing (IBM never sold computers, only leased) the latest systems for which they charged, actually leased 2nd or 3rd hand systems in new boxes. When the then Industry Minister George Fernandes saw the report, he asked IBM to leave India. That is the story of why IMB left India in late '70s.
CocaCola also
People are migrating out of India for multiple reason & not only for Better Job Opportunities. As per latest report, most of the Indian millionaires are leaving India for better lifestyle & social peace.
If we make our government policies better and focus on growth rather than dirty politics than most of the migration can be reduce drastically.
Our country is known as "Country for Reservation" & not "Country for Deserving People" hence most of the talent pool is moving out of the country.
Reservation has nothing to do with this.
@@seepranavgIt has everything to do with this
@@seepranavgHow come , my class mates with same ranks of mine got into iit .
While I was left behind.
I govt having different tax rated for both oc and non oc.
Why should I pay same tax as of you while I am getting less opportunities compared to a obc candidate.
Fyi many of sc and st students of my batch and in general are filthy rich who get reservations.
@@seepranavg keep fooling yourself :)
@@seepranavg Right, I don't know why people blaming reservation when the reason is something else.
I gave CAT' 22 last year. I scored 99.92%ile in it but still did not get even an interview call from the top 7 iims of india. I am currently studying in a decent mba school in India itself because i was clear about not leaving India from start. But my point being that any other person who can score such good will definitely give GRE and GMAT and get into a very good bschool abroad. It is not only about the other 9 lakh people who couldn't score, it is also about some laws and criterias these colleges follow that doesn't allow capable students to study there.
which college are u in bro? i can relate to you
@@sayantanmaity5061 sorry brother I would rather not say but it is definitely one of the top 15 bschools in India
will suggest anyone capable to go abroad and get their life sorted and ditch the stupid idea of deshbhakti in this corrupt country where there is only reservation and politics
This reservation really sucksss....it snatched the opportunity from the more capable persons
What are your academics?
India should think twice about its happy participation in G7 and QUAD, neglecting on policies in poverty eradication, retaining the talented young Indians!
@ThinkSchool Swayam NPTEL portal is an initiative taken by IITs, IISc, IIM and other premier institutions of India which is quite similar to MITOSW. Only difference being that you can give an exam after completing the course to get a certificate for the nominal fee of 1000 INR only
In India, there is a preference for "reserved individuals over talented ones", and the government tends to allocate funds towards the former rather than the latter, despite the actual needs.
That's such a cap on a real issue though. All the people saying reservation. It doesn't exist in the private sector or business, which is actually the back bone of india. And people will be surprised that the kind of reservation (private sector) exists in western countries which our india people are going to in the form of minorities quota. So how is reservation the main issue? Indians even after IIT leave india and don't come back and give up their citizenship . A record number of Indians gave up their citizenship last year. Reason is better quality of life and future opportunities.
@@theemperor4901you can get better education in top universities like IIM, IIT, IIIT NIT, AIIMS etc, but again only the reserved get most of the seats there with lesser effort and hence only they get better opportunities for education and jobs and not the deserving people who worked equally or much harder. Hence, those people leave India to study abroad and eventually settle there because at least it is better than India's reservation system. That is how most of the brain drain is happening.
@@mohanaraga6477 You completely missed my point on how there's no reservation in private sector or businesses. And you'd be surprised if you read into how there's a minority quota in even private sectors of western countries. If that were the case why would people who already made it to IITs would leave india? They even adopt their citizenship instead of coming back. Those countries have way better infrastructure and future prospects and obviously pays great. Most people who left India in record numbers last year were millionaires.
@@theemperor4901 Copy pasting under all comments doesn't help bro .
Govt jobs tera baa ka hai kya ?
@@vishnusaitejanagabandi9009 Not saying your issue is not real but this is not the case for this specific topic.Why are you getting mad? I am just making a counter argument against many ( comments )people saying is the main reason for brain drain. Which I don't think it's even a top 5 reason. Cause mostly the already academically successful or well financially families send their children outside India and some who get through scholarship or education loan. The IITians I know want to go there for better future opportunities. The countries they go to literally have a minority quota and many types of " reservation " policies to level the playing field. Do you really think people will stop going out of india if reservation is removed today? I Think School made a pretty good video on this.
I just happened to see the title and decided to watch. Thank you. Your information has hit the nail on the head and a must watch for all thinking Indians. I'm and educator and I have been singing this tune but the people in power are tone deaf. I'll check out Apana College for our young talent. I'm running a high school for the poorest and do come across some amazing talent. Aptitude testing and Career guidance needs to be nurtured in India's educational institutions also..
I'm currently in 11th in commerce stream, and after seeing the situation of India on my elder brother, who managed to get into an IIT, I am willing to take heavy loans to go abroad for my BBA and permanently settle there.
How to broadcast this video on 9 pm news in every media outlet. The whole nation, especially the policymakers needs to see this.
In IIT, students don't rely on what subjects are taught by the institute. They go open source, learn from youtube and vast online material according to their interest. This states most of the student in IIT gets educated on their own with the help of youtube and other learning platforms.
Then comes the question of where the money spent by the government goes?
It can be better answered: it goes as the salary of profs and staffs, carrying on research and development works.
Thus can state that whatever money the government is spending on IITs are utilized by researchers for their research work.
Agreed, my experience was the same, gfg and CZcams were the sources for studying
same here lol yt no teacher @@navdeepsugandhi6476
@@financewithsom485
Yepp! humare me bhi core studies jyada kaam ki nhi lagti. Syllabus outdated hai!!
You didn't have awareness about coding till your final year? damn!
Konse IIT se ho?
Humare
Name some of the IIT professors who invented something or made some tremendous contributions to nations progress. They spend tax payers money for living lavishly and attending "foreign conferences ".
Don't blame us for wishing to emigrate to Dubai, Saudi , US ,UK or CANADA
Blame the education system for following an british clerical system and suppressing creativity and innovation.
Blame it for not giving us the youth enough opportunities to excell and prosper, instead follows a ridiculous reservation system that kills merit.
Blame the socialist hangover that runs in society's mind which forces youth to waste years on years to get clerical government jobs.
We just want high standards and quality of life and wherever we go we represent our country and religion with pride🇮🇳🇮🇳
Country and religion? Why Religion?
@@Muktijit why? What's the problem with that?
@@Muktijit Religious beliefs keeps Indians away from excessive sexual activity, drugs and other addictions in foreign countries. I was educated at a Christian school in Rajasthan and moved to America for 2yrs. Their country was 91% Christian in 1960 and is now only 61% in 2023. Lots of stupid police officers, silly laws and broken dysfunctional families. Not to mention ignorant bosses and foolish politicians. After returning to India I enjoyed 20yrs of the good life here, married had a kid and look forward to a peaceful retirement among my family instead of no kids around living in a retirement home in Florida with PhD Psychologists trying to care for me.
Why not religion ??? religion comes first then country, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Pakistan all were India once, but all got separated, when Hindu religion declined there, those countries are still there, but they are not called Bharat and Hindus can't live there even visit, so religion is first and foremost 🙏
@@sarakumari3179 abey gadhey they take their religion 1st so their situation is bad & value less for today... India chooses secularism & so India is on progressive path... If RSS ya hindu atankwad PM were appointed that time they would have done same as the today's Pakistan ya Afghanistan are...
as an IITian i can agree that IIT teach all the modern technologies like blockchain or ai or cybersecurity but there are no opportunities in it , at last we all have to do Software development
create ur own employement take risks!!
This persistent issue is multifaceted both government and individuals have to play their role. Hope this government take a giant leap in the direction of the ecosystem for business in line with global order.
Mother India is grateful to have tutors like you .
Truly praiseworthy content .
I think schools and colleges should offer a subject called 'Think School,' where both teachers and students can learn about business and real-world problems.
i have been a student of think school from the beginning and this is the best research they have put up till now..but some suggestions like pls dont stop there can bw made a series on other various aspects left out like the rural urban gap, this episode mostly focuses on STEM maybe other backgrounds can be considered. thanks for the effort.
Very well put best example is MIT open course In order for us to get back the talent the entire education system needs to be reformed and should have a uniformity in the standard or quality of education even to the remote areas to top tiers as one categorises and should also broaden the streams an individual can choose at 11th 12th and societal thinking should change precisely but well made video !
1.The country (States and Central) doesn' t wanted the talent pool, (main reason is political clout) they need the fools under them to say "yes" for them. 2.Reservation system is killing the interest of the talent pool. Mr. Ambedkar recommended the reservation system for only 10years. But, even after 76 years of Independence, no political party dare to touch this, futher all political clout goes for increase the reservations. Provide the additional facilities to compete with others for the reserved, economically backward rather giving the reservations. I dont understand that, even in Promotions in PS and Govts' they have this reservation cota. Once you selected the candidate with reservation, again why in the promotions you provide this reservation. No questions, no one dare to ask the governments. Since, their interest is on vote bank politics. In another decade the whole Govt. and PS undertaking will be filled with these sub-standard fellow assets. All the value chain will go down and India's talent pool will go out of country (already going) in search of their meal. Now, it is happening in High Networth People leaving India for tax heavens. Same thing will happen for the talent pool also in Future.
Don't say all these. As you might get canceled for telling the truth
@UniverseHZ 🤫
Why do you guys keep cribbing about reservation idk. Is there reservation present in private? Nope!
@@nitroman8929 reservation root goes way deep than you think
@@nitroman8929they need to crib it's how they cope with life😂😂😂
As an IIT undergrad, I can safely say that we weren't provided with the most funding, either (this is in early 2010s). The funding went to PhDs, and post-graduates. We were like any other college. Just that since we are a pool of top students due to IIT tag, we got higher visibility in the job market. While PhDs (in making) got the maximum funds, they themselves were not that motivated because undergraduate students were treated like first-class citizens in the university whereas research scholars were treated as left-overs. On top of that, around 30% of the students at all levels were quota-students (reserved categories excluding BCs) who were already demotivated because of the hard academic demands from the curriculum. A substantial portion of them struggled to get passing grades and weren't able to complete in time. Those who completed in time went to govt. jobs that were unrelated to the education they received, leveraging their quotas. It was a purely messed up situation.
He isn't telling about funding for research only - he meant funding in general, which IIT's get a LOT more than other colleges for infrastructure development.
I hope everyone understands this problem well explained
In the past 10 years, millions of Indians have applied for Citizenship or PR in western countries and most of them are talented youth, while political leaders are only really concerned about winning elections at any cost, by hook or by crook.
Day by day I'm starting to like my college more and more. It's not recognized, probably tier 3 college but the environment, people and education seems amazing now. Maybe some things do happen for greater good.
Mee chelli kuda chala sarlu cheppa mee chelli kuda 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😅😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
Questions - 1. If No Colonization and if English was not this popular in the subcontinent - Would this much amount of migration be possible? 2. The loan to go abroad is taken from the Indian banks - will this help the Indian economy? 3. Information on Israel is not totally right - one out of every third Israeli graduate wants to leave the nation - perils of the rise of Right-wing and undemocratic governance 4. For some people closed cultures and Dogmas and Deities in every aspect of life can be suffocating and they may be leaving to breathe some free air.
"Padhega India, badhega America!"
This Braindrain ecosystem is the biggest 'silent' scam of Congress.
Thankyou for covering this topic🙂
Ha ismein nehru ki galti hai
It's sad that you didn't mention about reservation. Certain caste people can score less marks but still get selected for IIT, they get scholarship, fee waiver etc. Then in Govt. Jobs as well. What will the other skilled people do? We leave 🙃
He can't do that. Bcoz he too know the consequences of that. Either his comment section will be flooded with nonsense comments of those reserved ass communities or his video will be taken down by CZcams.
Thats the agenda of Khangrace party and it's ilk.
Divide the Pagans in Caste......
Unite the Abrahamics and cover their differences of Denominations & Firqas.
Reservation is everywhere even in us, just hidden in plain sight
Do you know you have lack of knowledge bro, research about seats after reservation and before reservation. Just because you people society get dirty mind
@@areyoustillalive....7729 Lack of knowledge! I have lived through and suffered the consequences of reservations personally
It’s because in India Marks=Talent where as in US Skill = Talent. Even though how capable you are you will still be compared with marks to get into a premium institution. You will always be assessed on the capability to solve some random math problems which will never be used again in life. And as a closing statement Marks≠ Audacity.
This is not the case in just IITs or IIMs or NEET doctors, this is true for UPSC aspirants also. We work hard everyday for 10+ hours, build all the skills required, study more than every damn student and still our chances to become civil servant are less than 0.5%. WOW🎉
Job and education entrance exam cannot be a direct comparison
India must do below things:
1. Remove reservation from system and create merit based education system.
2. Create world class digital library and give free subscription to all students via apps and allow AI Bot to teach students and convert teacher to role of mentor or facilitator.
3. Reduce Income tax to 20% and balance it from tax on agriculture produce.
4. Revoke all free trade agreement and transfer such benefit to India startup and business houses.
5. Simplify GST collection using digital ecosystem and reduce tax terrorism by IT department.
What you said is absolutely correct.I just want to add 2 positive sides,
1st- the remittance which comes to India in the form of dollars.
2nd side is few Engineers after learning skills, do come back to India and establish a start up and eventually create employment.
Only taxing the middle class, corruption, lack of social security, and harsh conditions and low paying jobs in India can crush our hope to stay. Sadly, people's lives don't seem valued, and patriotism fades when friends thrive abroad with better lives.
India is only safe for cows and cow vigilantes. In the past 10 years, millions of Indians have applied for Citizenship or PR in western countries and most of them are talented youth.
damn thats what i am thinking bro
Why not mention communal hate politics and crony capitalism by BJP?
@@coconutpunch123 Only education is solution for this, can't be solved by government policies and might take a generation or more time.
Now I know why I had to study so so hard and even then I couldn’t get selected to IITs in my teens years .
Thanks for the eyeopener video bro ! ❤ So I am an engineer working in a descent company in India. My question is,
Why cannot each and every B and C grade engineering colleges take the Alumini programs bit seriously and make use of Aluminis (Who are well experienced) to give back their professional knowledge and exp to the upcoming students (This will break the biggest barrier which most of us face ! WHAT NEXT AFTER ENGINEERING? THATOO WHAT TO DO IN INDIA ?)
No cost, No help requested from govt & students get benifits as well, also they can create contacts as well.
I am surprised that nptel was not mentioned once. There are world class lectures on most of the topics from IIT professors here. The quality of some courses are better than mit open courses. You can get a certificate from IIT as well, by taking an exam after the end of the course. I would argue the barrier for knowledge is gone, you just have to look for it. Everything is available for free, you just have to have desire to learn. It only make sense to pay for courses like Apna college, if you can't motivate yourself to sit and learn something on your own.
Swayam
NPTEL is an amazing source for sure
Theory can be learn,core engineering civil ,mechanical requires good college that garbage Aman dhattarwal is selling courses in apna college to make money
Totally agree, NPTEL is the best free form of learning globally. Even students and adults in US and english speaking countries watch and appreciate NPTEL lectures.
I am working in IT industry for almost two decades. I have worked in the US as well as here and hired on both sides 1000+ people in my career. You are absolutely right on the fact that our freshers are not employable and most time we end up teaching them what college should have. Industry-connect is also exclusive to a few colleges. There are some exceptions to this (like PICT from Pune) but then again those seen to leave jobs and go for MS in the US just to settle there.
This is really important topic and needs to be analyzed at something like Neeti ayog. I hope they do soon. Thanks for one more insightful video!!
I’m a Mechanical Engineer. We are by far the most exploited sect in the field of core engineering. The pay is inhumane but on the other hand manufacturing sector is the backbone of any economy.
One of the big reason why Mech graduates are the highest in number while enrolling for the GATE exam. It’s out of sheer helplessness. When you see your Data Scientist friends earn 30 lakhs and you are still earning 6 lakh p.a after 5 years of experience, imagine the mental pressure that we go through. 85% of my Mech undergrad batch are either in US, UK or Germany. Why would you want to suffer the exploitation with such harsh pay scale. The supply chain is so flawed to the point that we have to leave the country to find decent pay to compete with our CS or IT counterparts.
Competitive exams are not everyone’s cup of tea. Check the acceptance ratio if you have a doubt. Once these mechanical engineers leave the nation, gradually the economy will get affected. This is the general scene in India and every mechanical engineer will agree with this. Obviously there are jobs that give good pay but that does not reflect the problems that majority of the population are facing. Some serious thinking has to be done to rectify this situation.
I do love India but to live in India was a terrible experience. Even though being qualified and highly skilled I was jobless for 7 months. I was so hopeless by rejections from the Tech firms in India that I questioned myself if I was human. I didn't have money, no place to stay for a few weeks, no food, no job. Eventually, I borrowed money & went abroad, got hired on the 5th day of my visit, and have driven tech projects worth millions of dollars. The harsh reality of the Indian market. Though I love India, the socio-economic conditions in India don't allow me to thrive in India. It's such a misery. I hope it will change in the future.
Nailed it!!!
The humongous spending on the top tier colleges, churning out a paltry bunch of kids, waiting in the wings to fly out, was a revelation.
I also had to leave my country due to these reasons..Now when I am studying in Canada, I realize the quality of education is sooo good here, if we had this in India, we would have been a great asset to the nation, but sadly no one is interested, plus only the super smart or reserved category students get good education in India, and we are treated as useless creatures
I am also planning to study abroad. I heard that students are not getting jobs and living expenses have increased.
@@debanikgoswami4834 Yes expenses are very high and jobs are very less. And again due to Indian students increasing abroad, competition is increasing
that is so much true , infact everyone should get chance best informative video
Firstly to reduce Brain Drain Problem in India We Must Be Remove the BABU'S concept In Politics and GOV jobs which create a harmony in Society
Also tax cut is a must for high paying jobs. 30% is too much
yes true government should decraese direct tax and increase indirect tax@@JayamuruganDhanasekaran
@UniverseHZThat's such a cap on a real issue though. All the people saying reservation. It doesn't exist in the private sector or business, which is actually the back bone of india. And people will be surprised that the kind of reservation (private sector) exists in western countries which our india people are going to in the form of minorities quota. So how is reservation the main issue? Indians even after IIT leave india and don't come back and give up their citizenship . A record number of Indians gave up their citizenship last year. Reason is better quality of life and future opportunities.
@@JayamuruganDhanasekaran Forgot surcharge?
@@theemperor4901I think The Crux of your thought is, Lack of Investment in Human Resource field like education,health care,funding in startups Problem, and over working time. Which is easily available in Western World Right? If yes then I agree with your thought.
I am from 97 percent of engineers no doubt about my capacity and capabilities but I am from general category. In 2005 I appeared for AIEEE and got 96 mark but the very next student with 47 mark got into NIT trichy all because he was an OBC candidate 😢 . Luckily I got into Jain college (being in the same religious community) and completed my engineering. So I don't think the government has done anything for my education rather come with katora and asked for taxes. After college in 2009 it was difficult to land a job just because USA economy was blown out of recession. Father funded 25k for a NIIT coaching 😊 (thankful for him) which helped me with my first 8k job. Until 2016 I was Ernst-whilst tax payer taking 20k each month from my pocket to government katora. Now it was high time to become an NRI and just give peanuts to the government taxes.. happy to settle and pay taxes aboard😂❤.
I am not ashamed or having hatred of being Indian. But the government of India has to respect tax prayer. Instead of treating as tax cows. Try to help us with infra, tax free roads and reservation free society.
In india either you got government job or become NRI, you got respect and money. Private companies in India basically give peanuts salary dont forget you give tax (ITR) and even schooling, college, medical facility you apply on private mostly.
Kindly go and read the data of minority ministry website to know the actual thinking of this gov 🙏🙏
@@sarakumari3179 tum hi baata do
I agree with everything you've mentioned
Perfectly Made Video, Well Researched, Thank You For Sharing !!!
You pointed out the great issues. I'm an E&TC Engineer. I understood 60% of E&TC electronics devices, equipment, etc. In the 4th year of engineering because of the final year project. What is the purpose of that equipment and devices? All this I understood when I had a hand on them at home and learned how to do soldering? Wire up devices, PCB design, etc. mostly via CZcams videos. Didn't understand much via lectures which were taken in classrooms or practical labs.
Almost my entire circle of friends (myself included) who have come from middle-class Indian backgrounds have either moved abroad or are planning to in the very near future. This video sadly only served to highlight that fact and the reasons behind it. Unfortunately, no matter how interested an Indian living overseas is in returning to the country, in the current environment of instability and constant crisis finding a place where one feels appreciated is far more important than risking the trip back for the sake of nostalgia (if nothing else).
I feel that that solutions to India's problem have already been discussed, repeated and have been echoed by people far more intelligent and passionate than I. Only to have these voices be drowned by corruption, nepotism and the politics to maintain a strong ill-educated voter base for those who want to stay in power.
TL;DR This brain drain wont stop till either the world becomes too dangerous for Indians or India becomes too dangerous for the world.
In India only Politics wins
People loose
I'm assuming by referring to me you mean NRIs in general. First of all the US isn't the only country they move to these days. More Indians have started to explore other countries recently. Secondly, most of the people who leave are doing it because they would rather not " fight the system ". Indian politics has shown that there is no reward for those who try to challenge the system, whether they succeed or fail. And 90% of NRIs are not politicians or activists. It is not their job to make the rules, rather the rules are what make them look for jobs elsewhere.
@@snoopysnoops007 fight and get killed? Indian politicians are highly threatened by this topic alone. They want to keep their current powers, by any means. These people are basically gangsters and will kill who try to rise against them before they even rise. Not to mention people got families to feed. People choose what's the better and safer option which is clear here.
@@snoopysnoops007general class has a tiny population
Your vote are just not coutable
Politician policies are made on the point to get maximum votes
The system is against us
Really true especially the last lines about political parties not wanting its citizens to become smarter as they fear losing votes. Biggest scandal going on which doesnt get talked about enough.
Hi Ganesh! I've been following your CZcams channel since 2022 and I'm really impressed by the quality of content you produce. Your videos are really informative and insightful. I have a suggestion for a topic that I believe would be of great interest to your audience.
I would love to see videos on the role of Chartered Accountants and their significance in the economy. It would be fascinating to delve into how Chartered Accountants contribute to financial stability, compliance, and the overall economic growth. Exploring their impact on businesses, audits, and financial reporting could provide valuable insights to your viewers.
Additionally, a detailed analysis of investment bankers would also be highly informative. You could cover their historical evolution, the diverse roles they play in financial markets, and their contributions to shaping the economic landscape. Understanding their functions in mergers, acquisitions, and capital raising activities would be particularly interesting.
Your ability to present complex topics in an engaging and easy-to-understand manner would make these videos a valuable resource for your audience. I'm sure many of us would greatly benefit from the insights you could provide on these subjects. Keep up the fantastic work!
one of the best valuable video on internet for youth of india ...thank u bhaiya 🙏🙏 now its our tym to build a strong nation 💪 jai hind
The education system in rural India presents a problem: students study in local languages at first, but higher education like engineering and medicine is in English. This makes it tough for them to compete fairly in entrance exams for IITs and NITs. If they can't join top colleges, they end up in regional ones with poor facilities.
As a guy who studied in regional govt school I agree . The entire entrance exam system favours CBSE students . Very few students are in ITTs or NITs are from regional board .
One extra problem which can be associated for the brain drain is the population explosion. Due to uncontrolled increase in population, it becomes difficult for the government to administer and nurture the public with lack of infrastructure. Even though the government starts building infrastructure the population would have increased manifold by the time the infra projects are completed. So,according to my opinion population should also have to be controlled.
India's population started to get stable decades ago. It is the uncontrolled and open migration of people from Nepal, Bangladesh and Myanmar that has kept India's population rising. Nepal and Bangladesh are unofficial states of India. I have lived in states bordering Bangladesh and let me tell you the borders are open. There's no security or fencing. It is open and free for all to cross over and since 1971 millions and millions have poured in. There are an estimated 15 crores (150 million) illegal Bangladesh immigrants living in India generation after generation. So don't blame Indians alone for this issue
Spot on
Population control is almost always a bad idea. The population explosion is happening in the poor states like UP, Bihar....otherwise it's not the case everywhere. The brain drain isn't happening in poor states but in economically successful ones.
Make a video on CAs bro. Despite hardwork we are not getting recognized and not payed well by the companies.
I was also ca student but i left . i am now doing mba from good college in pune
Amazing.Hope The All Students and Talented peeps Get a better future
Hey @ThinkSchool what you are doing today of india, for india and by the india is really great and appreciated for your efforts in contributing value and change is phenomenal keep it up!!!
One of the best case study based channels I have ever come across ❤
*All of my wealthy friends have already begun relocating to the US and Canada, saying that because things in India won't change, you also should leave as soon as possible, scored 167 but I'm still here due to financial difficulties !!!*
the depth of dissection of each topic is so good, thanks for making these videos and understandable to everyone!! :)
I’m a doctor and i know how difficult it for a unreserved candidate to get into a premier institute like NIMHANS, Bangalore, without reservation. Even after getting that with so much of difficulty, its very difficult to get a job in government with reservation being there for appointment too!!
😂 looks like an unemployed youth and a common man preaching about it . India doesn't have any diversity unlike US nor the discriminaton is well acknowledged in private sector. The present reservations aren't similar to the 100% reservations that uCs enjoyed
India is only safe for cows and cow vigilantes. In the past 10 years, millions of Indians have applied for Citizenship or PR in western countries and most of them are talented youth.
@@meghanath5045if you have known anything about caste and economy, you wouldn’t have been saying it. Lower casts almost had a monopoly on many fields too. Remember, buisness and dealings were done by vaisyas, which were considered second lowest cast in India.
@@arijitpalit2756 monopoly on untouchability vaishyas come under upper class societies
I agree with you , as a doctor the reservation system is pathetic
Thanks for wonderful & detailed studied content!
Yes you are right sir, please it is a request to you to make a part 2 episode of this topic and tell what is the position of INDIA from 2013 to date. Whatever you have said is till 2013 as you said, so please sir, make one more episode.
For context, I’m a British expat living in India for the 2nd time. I’m acutely aware of the problems. It’s worth noting that in recent years’ the salaries of those Indians who have >10yrs experience (and work in a sector where there’s not a surplus in the labour market) has vastly improved.
The pay gap in real terms (factoring cost of living) between them and those residing overseas has significantly narrowed. This is relevant because it’s vital to understand what are the pull factors for migration. My assessment is that “quality of life” is the main driver.
If India wants to fix day to day issues for most middle class families, it needs to resolve the problems that reduces quality of life. Pollution (including dust pollution), basic infrastructure, parks, transport and the general look of the street scene need to be addressed. Most Indians think of shopping malls when planing how to spend their weekend. That’s really sad. Overseas, you’d always think of picnics and BBQs in the parks, the beach etc. No chance of that in India’s dusty cities.
Also, introducing obligatory quality standards for Indian produced goods, so people have a chance to make their homes the same quality as overseas. Removing punitive customs duty on imported goods would be one way of making Indian manufacturers up their game.
As a Keralaite who saw politically left ideology from childhood, I was an ani-capitalist person but going through the business case study helped to change the view. I think our society should celebrate the entrepreneur of our country. I think you should do a video about them.
How a left ideologist is anti- capitalist? Right wing mostly support traditional aka socialism.
@@lone_warrior665lol those terms aren't the same in India buddy. Left wing here means socialism
@@lone_warrior665same in Punjab left wing shut ideology has caused the state to remain poor
If you become pro Business what will happen to "Free" World 🌎 economy!?
We need more slaves until Skynet A.I is ready.
Left ideology is definitely socialism. Right wing is traditional and money making i.e Capitalism. America is a good example for capitalism and the nordic countries are of democratic socialism
Great content as usual. You could have touched how horrible the tax system in India is.... especially squeezing it from salaried classs.....more painful thing is how these tax payers are left on road once they lose employment or taxable income....Indian diaspora definitely have the Indian connect at their hearts which is reflected from the Remittances and the strong foreign relations India enjoys today... Let's hope we can see better days
You don't know the tax system in USA is then. At least in Europe they take 50% Or more and give you everything you need. In the US, you pay for everything despite the tax load. No it's not taxes.
@@srinitaaigaura I live in Europe :)
Simple. Make a bond and restrict movement abroad for 3 years after graduation (with some exceptions such as education courses). Similar to how MBBS and MD/MS doctors are required to serve in rural areas or govt hospitals or else they pay amount as per bond. And MS/MS doctors are actually working and contributing while doing their PG course. If they can have restrictions, so can the IIT/NIT graduates. Now it will cause some issues, but as a side effect, it could also attract more MNCs to open new offices or expand existing offices to avail cost efficient pool of talent. Many of these people will also end up creating start-ups while unable to move out of India. All this is assuming that a conducive business environment is maintained in the country
What an amazing case study and analysis. I wish our govt takes note of this, and invests more in education and research and development. I highly agree with your take and education should be democratized.
Caste reservations are not the only reasons why so many want leave India, I have a friend who belonged to a low caste, identified as a Christian and grew up with a middle class family. He also was a good enginerring student. Despite everything favoring him in Indian society, he chose to leave India because he simply wanted live life like an American. He's been living in the US for nearly a decade and recently became an American citizen and according to the last time I talked to him, he's happy there and I'm happy for him.
A few reasons for working in developed countries is
1) More convenience of commuting and living
2) More safety and a better police and court system
3) More better paying jobs and research oriented jobs
4) better currency conversion rates for remittance
5) better social welfare programmes for old, disabled, children, unemployed
6) free , better quality education for children with no reservation policies based on caste or religion or race.
1) The major reason is the taxes. Taxpayers get literally nothing in return for their taxes. Whatever they get is also given to those who pay no taxes, there is no exclusive benefit for losing 30% of your earning.
2) Lower salaries compared with the US and Europe.
Quality education matters for development, India should focus more on this area of quality education.
I think the reason could be reservation, because i belonged to a lower middle class General category family and during my academic years i never got any scholarships, qouta or other benefits unlike my friends from the government.... but now when i and my family struggled through all the miseries and got a job. Now the government deducts 20-30% of my hard earned money as taxes which is unfair.
Stop playing the victim card of general category. Ews is provided, scholarships are given for poor , majority of the jobs are in private sector, if you were middle class you would be getting better subsidiaries. If you pay 20-30% you are upper middle class . The present reservations aren't similar to the 100% reservations that Ucs enjoyed it merely account's for 1% of employment. People who sit at their homes often speak about people who leave india .
but how does eliminating reservations create more job opportunity in india 😂
@@jamesrhodes522 did I ever talk about increasing job opportunities? I'm talking about the impact on the morale of people who suffer from caste based reservation instead of income based
let me explain you how.
These low caste people do enter the premier institutions on the reservation basis. They barely need any marks to make it through. Where we peopel in general have to score in 99th percentile, these people merely need 40-50.
Now they have already proven they are not worth it.
Now either they will be among the last rankers in a given class, or just drop out.
Now this seat, it will remain empty for 4 years. It wont be filled. Its a position wasted.
In last 7 years, Sc St dropout rate is 46%. That's a lot of seats taken away from deserving candidates from General, OBC, EWS.
Additionally, the students that are unemployable, these last rankers are among the pool. So they just didnt waste the seat and resources, they are even screwing up the job market for other deserving candidates.
Not to forget, general boys pay 100% of the examination fee, while Girls, Sc, St will pay only 50 or 25.
For exams like UPSC, its just general men who pay examination fee, Women dont, Sc, St and Disabled people dont.
@@jamesrhodes522
@@meghanath5045honey , I belong to poor general class.
My friends all of them are sc/st , their parents are rich govt employees.
Most of my friends got less marks then me.
Still they enjoyed scholarships and laugh at my face .
For exam I have to pay fees , they give it for me.
Reservation is not the only reason, i agree .
It's one of the reason.
Why people have to leave India.
This evokes a profound sense of frustration and sorrow towards the education system, given that I personally experienced its challenges. It's disheartening to see the need for significant improvements that have yet to be fully addressed
During our time there was a saying "Brain Drain is better than Brain in Drain", do you think the situation has changed much? I keep on hearing about the initiatives such as startup India, Make in India...
In my opinion, govt needs to create the business infrastructure (which I believe current govt doing a better job) and make sure students from the premier institutes such as IITs, IIMs does not leave country without serving a decent amount of time. Highly skilled human brain is the greatest commodity ever existed, India can't afford to lose them at such rapid pace and expect to be an innovation superpower. Govt needs do much better job at retaining them.
I have worked in indian IT companies for 4 years and working in Australia for 2 years now. In india I had degree in computer science but I was reduced to filling Excel sheets and emails. Here I am doing cutting edge research in AI which usually needs a PHD and I just have my Masters. The harsh reality is even electronic engineers who should be designing the next intel amd competitor is taking crash course c++
Considering the living cost, its almost same. but the facilities and health care provided by other countries are great. It does not mean every foreign country. If India can continue with the current level of development, India can surpass them in 10 years.
Healthcare provided by other countries are great 😂😂😂.
Expensive is not always great
After recollecting my visit to the chemist shop,felt like it's the same as the ayurvedic jaadi butti mobile trible van shop except that it's more organized, corporate,etc.
@@SR01995yes u right but not applicable on countries
For your information, our healthcare services are miles ahead as Europe countries and UK struggle with doctors and waiting list is huge. Also in US healthcare services way more expensive so have some research and comment sensibly