'How Many Degrees Will Global Decrease As A Result Of Moving To Net Zero?': Mike Lee Grills Granholm
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 04. 2024
- At today's Senate Energy Committee hearing, Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) questioned Energy Sec. Jennifer Granholm about the Biden Administration's net zero goal.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
If life was fair, Jennifer Granholm would be unemployed.
After Jan 20 2025 she will be.
unbelievable and she just sits there smiling away gross
Granholm was the second worst governor in history of Michigan until Whitmer 😂
@@johnnymaccool9828100% FACT!!!!!!
But she was on the dating game in the 70s. How Dare You. Lol
She doesn't answer because there is no repercussion for not answering. These hearings are a waste of time.
Exactly. There is absolutely no recourse anymore.
Not a waste of time. It is engrossing to watch, for all the aficionados of the ancient art of pearl clutching.
@@nickolasgenoff4896 you are part of the problem
Yuup. Stolen elections have consequences.
Carbon is dictated by temperature, not the other way around!
Moving to Net-Zero will cause zero drop in degrees.
But, it will stop global temperatures rising further!
@@nigeltrigger4499 No, it really won't. China builds brand-spanking new coal fired generators at a pace of almost 1 every 2 weeks. They do that in order to among other things, create the huge lithium-ion batteries to go into EVs that Americans will be forced to buy, foolishly thinking that they are saving the climate.
@@nigeltrigger4499 *RE: "But, it will stop global temperatures rising further!"*
How would you or anyone else know that? Exactly what is the Earths temperature today? What instrument is used to "record" it? Further, what is the ideal temperature of the entire Earth, keep it to less than 1.5 degrees of accuracy if you can.
Does some rule of nature eschew "changes" in weather? In climate, In anything?
Shall I wait for the crickets?
She is absolutely absurd. And corrupt beyond measure. And she is a liar. Arrest, Charge and jail and throw away the keys.
Except those tasked with doing so are all dancing to the same sheet of music.
What about the wholesale theft of taxpayer monies under the Torys.?
Exactly how? What did she say that's a lie?
@@juni5822 contact the accident helpline, they may be able to get you compensation for your head injury.....
@@juni5822 Not necessarily a liar per se but a morally bankrupt politician who is willing to sell her soul to repeat the party mantra to occupy the position she was offered. Simply performing as a mouth piece for the administration bidding. The same can be said for every other member of the entire Biden executive administration.
Granholm is so unqualified for her job. She's even lower on the scale than a DEI hire.
She looks like the twin sister of Elizabeth Warren.
To support them in anyway when they make the weather/dump stuff in the skies non stop, is the problem
She is a DEI hire.
😂😂
She is the token hire
That woman shouldn't have the word "honorable" in front of her name.
only in an upside down, backwards world
Only when democrats have a lot of power
"Even if emissions of greenhouse gases were to suddenly stop, Earth’s surface temperature would require thousands of years to cool and return to the level in the pre-industrial era." Source: The Royal Society.
@@garysarela4431 The next Ice Age is imminent. Source--Democrat climate activists less than 20 years ago.
Summery--'They' have No idea what they're talking about.
My sentiments exactly!! Should have a prison number there instead!
If this woman cannot understand the question, how can she possibly comprehend the the financial implications on poorer people. It’s a complete sham!
She understands the question exactly...but she has no answer because no one knows how much, if any at all, the temperature of the Earth's atmosphere will be reduced if we attain net zero.
They should never put "Honorable" in front of any of these people....
That is for damn sure.....BOTH LEECHING SIDES!!
If you're serious about climate change and not talking about nuclear power as an option, you're not serious about climate change.
CO2 has nuffin to do with Global Warming. It is a pure believe and a pure faith-based conviction. Net Zero will not fix a thing. The ocean will eat all excess CO2 anyway. We do not have a CO2 problem whatsoever at all.
powerplants house wet surface air coolers that make your rain clouds - see weatherwar101
@@danielboone8748 If you're talking about nuclear waste and think we can't process and use said waste in electricity production until it is inert and safe to dispose of, you're willfully uninformed.
And even if we disposed of that waste outright, we'd be able to manage it. It has an incredibly small footprint. Get with the times.
This is 100% correct. The fact that they aren't talking about nuclear or even using it for comparative purposes should give you an indicator that this is a one sided administration.
@@danielboone8748 France has been doing it for decades. 70% of their power comes from nuclear.
She has no clue what she is talking about , lying through her teeth !
And doing a horrible job at it.
And laughing at all of us on her way to the bank. Sickening
This is saddening. Just because people are too unintelligent to understand her response, that doesn't mean her response wasn't good. Everything she said was true. The climate does not intantly go back to normal at net zero. It takes hundreds of years for it to go back to normal, and it can only do that if we use carbon capture and then bury the carbon rather than burning it again.
@@BrainInJar what have you been studying, if anything at all , do yourself a favor and type in Dr. Richard Lindzen , find out who he is and listen to him .
Exactly how? Can you explain how is she lying? Do you have any in depth knowledge on the topic?
She can't understand such a simple question, yet she has a job with a lot of responsibility and a high salary? Who hired someone this incompetent?
She understands exactly what he's saying. Much like doctor's, when you are in a position like that, saying anything that isn't a blanket statement means you are committing to word. You are touting your credibility, and you are putting yourself liable. That's why she fixated ONLY on stopping the level of increase or keeping it within this margin, not how much lower the climate needs to go down, which is a harder thing. Climate change, does have some bearing, but we're tackling it in the literal worst ways possible. Because it's not about climate change, not really. It's about white knighting, siphoning more money out of people who can't afford things to hoard power over them, and controlling every aspect of their life.
Joe Biden did. Not that Trump has any more competence. Our government is led by biased radicals who don't know the difference between a nail or a screw. And we are being screwed by them.
@@Stargun-vj1uh And even IF the USA completely eliminates ALL pollution from EVERY source....China, India and with all the other developing nations who are increasing their pollution faster than we reduce ours....the supposed problem of 'climate change' isn't going to be any different. But...of course they KNOW that and 'climate change' is just the catch-all excuse for their power grab. Carbon tax everyone into submission, prevent free travel by making it too expensive and move everyone into their '15 minute cities' where everyone can be monitored and controlled. Perfect!
Simple question? There's nothing simple about climate change, there's a lot of things to take into account, most of them completely outside the control of a single government.
Muricans hired her
She is beyond USELESS
Electric vehicle sales are going down, not up. People don't want them.
Do people want government making the weather as they do? see weatherwar101, geoengineering watch
They will be forgotten about in the near future
@@tmklunk We hope.
Nah, it’s not that people don’t want them, everybody who can afford one has already bought one. The only models available for sale are luxury vehicles, with few exceptions.
The cheapest electric car, the nissan leaf, starts at 30k. The cheapest new ICE car is the nissan versa, at 16k. People want them, but can’t afford them.
@@enemyspotted2467i doubt people want a car that has way more less range then an ICE vehicle. Also the depreciation is alot higher with EV's. And people dont like to wait an hour or longer to charge their EV while they can fill up their ICE within 5 minutes. So its not alone about the price.
Calling Jennifer Granholm a clown is an insult to clowns.
Clowns are not crooks.
At least good clowns could make you have a hearty laugh. This woman makes you laugh in disbelief, a groan of disappointment.
I am so proud to call Mike Lee my Senator!
Congratulations. My senators are useless. I hope you guys have another Mike Lee waiting in the wings, because he should definitely be moved to the Supreme Court at the next available vacancy.
I am extraordinarily proud to say that Granholm is my Ex-governor......😂😂.....!!!
Note they’re not doing the obvious and inexpensive solution: planting trees… Their focus is on profit!
@KH-rt3ef since my birth in 1951 there has been massive anhialation of the world rain forests. This too me ties in with the climate change we are increasingly experiencing! I agree with you on tree planting. 😊😊😊
Years ago when rain forests were being at an incredible rate scientists and other experts said this would have effects on the future weather patterns but governments didn't listen all of a sudden governments and globalist are concerned why, because its a money making scheme .to help reverse things the governments need a program to start planting more forests which are the lungs of the earth .
Granholm as Energy Sec and Mayor Pete as Transportation Sec... ABSURD.
But...but...but...he SAID he likes trains and proposed to his...ummm...in a train station. What more qualifications could anyone possibly require?
We have a crisis of competency...everywhere.
I think she may be senile
@@KalleStropp45 Nah. Just the typical level of competence of recent appointees.
But Mayor Pete is gay! That makes him qualified.
This is the woman who had her staff block EV charging station with ICE vehicles, so she could get charged up straight away, to then be able to tell everyone about her 'wonderful' EV journey.
So you are saying her behavior fits right in with how today’s government views themselves vs. the citizenry without directly having to say it…
wasn't that delicious?
Didn't they have to finish the trip in gasoline cars? Might have been a different group.
Your story about Granholm's grandstanding EV trip is a window into her soul. She sees herself as above the peons she rules over, & expects extra considerations & privileges commureasurate with her lofty status. She is perfectly willing to spend all our money till it runs dry, while piling up a small fortune making illegal stock market trades on her inside information.
Why is she not being arrested for having a financial gain here!!!
I'm always so grateful for CZcams's placement of Wikipedia articles to school us on the topic of the video.
😂 thanks for your skewed mainstream worldview wiki.. I'm empowered
Bottom line, ‘Politicians cannot control the climate’.
Even deeper bottom line .. politicians and their World Enslavement Forum masters ARE NOT GOD, even though both George Soros and Klaus Schwab think they are!
Politicians cannot control the their selves.
The United States are only a pin drop in the world. I can’t believe such changes will be of any consequence.
Just the political climate
They think they can, though, in the same way they think they can control people. But as we know, human nature is its own force and when politicians try to screw around with human behavior they turn society into a hellscape.
She was the worst MI governor ever. She wasted so much state money on green companies that all went bankrupt. How she is qualified for this job is crazy.
She actually fairly good 😉She has demonstrated she can do a very good job of putting on a scam which is what the job was greatly about. Her outbursts appear rehearsed so she's not really good, but her appearance presentation is excellent. Her job qualification were better than could reasonably be expected for practicing corruption. She's probably reliable in carrying out somewhat intricate corruption which is hard to come by. She worthless for any real future projects without her own personal decision to rehab.
@@douglasengle2704Granholm's phony outrage when she's called out for her illegal stock manipulations or when we find out she knows NOTHING about Climate, energy, or green energy projections in HILARIOUS.
Woke money = broke money.
She isn't qualified and never was, but she met Biden's criteria of activism.
“Not understanding the question” I’m shocked
Am not Shocked.
"record heat" How far back in time do those records go for a planet that has been around for 4.5 billion years?
It doesn't matter how far back they go because the alarmists will simply crop off any part of a graph that doesn't support their nutty story (for example, the hot 1930s in the United States). Or just make stuff up. We are dealing with extremely stupid people here, as Granholm's inability to understand the question demonstrates. All she knows how to do is blabber gloom and doom talking points, robot-like.
Promptly remove Mrs. liar Granholm from her position, for the sake of our nation.
RIGHT after Pres Trump comes back in Nov.
Point to a person in government that you cannot say the same thing about.
Have you noticed not one appointment by Ding Dong to his cabinet has ever been fired, nor resigned.
Why would they be fired ? They are doing exactly what those appointed them want them to do
Granholm is clueless about energy, another poor pick by Biden.
obamanations pick
She’s a believer, that’s enough.
A great Biden pick. Spouts all the lies of the current administration. Smiles a lot and is a woman. Perfect Department head. No expertise needed; just filling the squares. Square checking being more important than improving life for all Americans. Really sad.
Name a cabinet level pick that wasn't poor
@@yolandascholten2012 No, she's a radical.
Geo engineering anyone ? Government’s weather modification, haarp, extreme weather events uh huh. We have barely begun to uncover the sheer audacity of what’s been happening.
the best pictures to see side by side is the one showing the 2023 "heat map" and then the USGS/NOAA temperature station maps, and seeing that the hottest spots on the heat map are where there are zero temperature stations. which makes you wonder, how the hell did they determine they are the hottest spots when we have no way to monitor those locations.
China has over 1000 coal fired power plants and still building more. Why don't the senators ask about that.
Because they've pointed that out in Senate Chambers ad nauseum...
@@DxBlackOk whats their answer then?
@jeremyboughtono2 The silence is deafening!
Because they know its bad to question their benefactors
Currently putting 3 new stations online every month and have done for years.
They said in 97 the oceans would boil by 2016, yet here we are
"Water levels will rise considerably!" Says the politicians buying posh villas on oceanfront property
The lack of consequences for lying to Congress has got to end! Lying and not answering the questions has to have consequences!
It is guys like this that made me re-think what I had once thought I knew to be true.
Don’t forget the Jennifer grandholm act something that was deemed an attack against the poor she ruined Michiganders lives!!!!
Michigan residents hate her!!
@@loisegan8050yes we do!
Couldn’t be the new population as well?
The answer is it will have zero impact
In the Netherlands we are going to spend 23 bilioen euro for a reduction 0,000036 degrees.
The figures show that there are less extreme weather events, rather than more.
If she back tracks it would hurt her insider trading. Second worse Michigan governor ever. What qualifies her for energy Secretary?? Nothing…
Maybe she went to the heels high harris school of getting ahead.
That is Headboard Harris.
Both DEI.
She believes in the cult and the impact won’t effect her.
She has a strong past history of channeling money to green projects were lots of money goes missing. As energy secretary she can do the same thing only much much bigger. That qualifies her in a corrupt administration more than enough to be energy secretary. What is remarkable is people like this should be convicted of some of the significant crimes they have participated in and spend some time in some type of prison. It could be low security prison and less than a year. That would discourage millions of people from practicing out right corruption.
@ 6:25 This net zero thing is a scam
YOU SIR,ARE TOTALLY CORRECT THE GOVERNMENTS ON THIS EARTH ,MUST THINK WE CAME DOWN WITH THE LAST SHOWER OF RAIN. GLOBAL WARMING IS TOTALLY NATURAL IN MY OPINION ,,EG,,ICE AGES ,,WARM UPS,,WE IN THE UK..HAVE A NET ZERO AGENDA,IE,NO CO2 TOTALLY INSANE ,,NO C02 = NO LIFE WHAT SO EVER ,,DIDNT THEY LEARN ANYTHING AT SCHOOL,MY HONEST OPINION IS THAT SOME PEOPLE ARE BECOMING VERY RICH OUT OF THIS SCAM,,FROM UK.
He should just say: "YOU DON'T KNOW! You're willing to spent $9T each year and you have NO IDEA if it will do what you say?"
These people say sever weather is increasing. They also say we have been moving to NET zero for a decade. So, the observable fact is that moving to NET zero has increased sever weather not decreased it.
Why have these hearings when Josh just proved she is a criminal but yet she still sits there with no consequences what so ever
She can not answer the question on how much temps would go down by, because this is fantasy, she has no idea IF it would even go down.
Well, no one can really validate the temps have went up over the last 100 years.
@@HBFTimmahh I find it a joke because most of these pushing this fantasy is, nine times out of ten they are veggies, n guess what vegetables grow on? yep co2
@@HBFTimmahh the temps have gone up in the last 100 years. And the 100 before that, and the 100 before that. They have been rising since the LAST ice age, one of many.
@@garyszewc3339 So are we going to become Venus or Pluto Mr Weather?
@@HBFTimmahhyes we can. We’ve been accurately measuring the global temperature since, well, since accurate temperature measurement was invented.
Bravo!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Exactly!!!!
Why is the person "in charge" the only one that can't grasp the question at hand?
Oh, she grasps it all right. She's just in thrall to green companies which are financing her.
the temperature will remain the same and we will all be broke
They need to maintain the lie. When in one hundred years and the temperature has not moved wildly, they will say from their ivory towers and piles of money from the massive exchange of wealth from the many to the few, "see, we stopped it", full well knowing it was all nonsense.
And colder !
That's the PLAN.
It's getting colder in Nova Scotia so I don't know what she is talking about.
The gentleman posing the question is hitting all of the nails on the head for other countries as well as the USA!
What's the point of all these continual hearings if they don't answer the freaking questions. From my point of view these hearings is what adds to global warming...A lot of hot air.
When people are trying to understand why a government organization is ignoring very apparently simple issues such as earth's greenhouse effect is always in saturation from the strong greenhouse gas water vapor and can't have its overall effect changed, it helps understanding to be able to diagnose the person in charge is clueless.
No record heat, no increased power of storms, only increased suffering of working people.
You completely left out the reich wing whining and crying, which the adults in America have to listen to.
@@douglemay7989oh aren’t you clever. Reich wing. Just terrific word play. Did you come up with that by yourself? How long did it take you. Whoo boy it’s a good one. Of course the reality is, and history teaches us, that leftists are the shortest path to totalitarianism but hey, we appreciate the bumper sticker slogan intellect.
She should be fired and then taken to jail
Granholm is Canadian citizen and doesn't have to answer any questions about American Energy.
Maybe the government should stop playing with the weather...
It is IMPOSSIBLE to generate enough electricity to charge electric vehicles if we replace them all. And anyone hear of a truck, tractor or harvester that runs for a useful amount of time on batteries? No, that's impossible too, and always will be.
There isn't enough rare earth minerals on earth to build enough batteries to replace every car in the US, let alone the rest of the world, with an EV. Every part of this forced change is prototypical command economy stupidity. The government is handing down (illegal) mandates that they know are impossible. It's just a scam intended to allow them to steal infinite money.
80% of the US electricity is generated from burning fossil fuels. The amount of people who don't realize this is staggering.
The first EV was invented in 1888. The second attempt was made in the 1990's. And we have this latest attempt. They have all failed. They were and still are a fad that only the elite can reasonably afford unless subsidized by the government. They have never been a viable alternative to the Internal Combustion fossil fueled engine. And will not be for the foreseeable future.
So, technology will never move forward?
@@douglemay7989 Technology progresses via consumer demand, not governmental demand. If consumers wanted electric vehicles and electric vehicles were genuinely superior products the consumers would make that technology advancement for themselves. The government *forcing* an objectively inferior technology onto the general populace is never a good idea. It's an even worse idea when it is quite literally impossible with current technology to move entirely to the demanded tech platform.
Net zero is completely unacceptable. 😡😡
The question should be, How many degrees will the temperature rise if we don't.
This woman is a BillGates/Klaus Shwab/EU student. Period.
Did they ever tax Mt. Saint Helen?
Religious exemption on account if being a Saint..
@@Rachel_M_ touché!
The arrogance of the current illegitimate administration is unbelievable. They think they can control the weather.
Should have taxed Washington for that!
@@alexrodgers9247 many thanks ☺
She can't answer because she doesn't know, but is happy for people to pay more. We've got similar minded individuals in the UK.
She doesn't answer because there's no answer she can give, because she nor anyone else knows the answer
I love this. He's one of the few people in congress with a brain.
~all weather is man made
@@MATTINCALIexplain how weather is man made.
@@garyszewc3339 Well, wahmunn didunt do it.
This is coming from a person that pushed electric cars but couldn't tell you where the electricity came from to charge them.
HERE! HERE!
Imagine if the government just stayed in their lane, fixed potholes/provided safety..., and didn't think their job was to influence people for their version of good.
it's literally like 1/10th of a degree over 100 years. she ain't going to say that in public.
I heard approximately 1/1000 of a degree over that time period.
@@user-yh2of2nz2s probably somewhere in the middle. It’s laughably small. Still going to cost trillions though.
1/10th of a degree up or down? 😉
@@raymondo6665 Good question. Would be impossible to measure because of other factors :D
@@kielcemen Well apparently (allegedly) "scientists say" global temps rose by 0.17 degrees C from 2016 to 2023...........but only after the raw data had been adjusted 😂😂😂
Prime example of either DEI or the principle that people get promoted to their level of incompetence.
What is her evidence for her claim of "year after year of record heat"
J. Granholm was a disaster for Michigan as Governor and is a disaster as SoE, too.
Great question. They have no idea What they are doing
Senator Lee is awesome
She was almost as competent in her former job.
One question what happens if you remove too much carbon from the atmosphere = all food sources die
She should be in prison
government makes all the weather, see weatherwar101. you should be in prison if you support these people (government)
If it takes 1.21 Gigawatts to get an ICE car (with flux capacitor) back to the future, how much power is required for an EV?
"a looming demand for energy crisis" means we WANT an energy crisis.
It is all about control today and not about temperatures in the future. What is the optimal global temperature for maximal production? Answer that and then let's address climate spending.
The cause of global warming is not known. Earth's greenhouse effect is always in saturation from water vapor leaving no mechanism that would allow greenhouse gas behavior to cause global warming. Global warming has been paused at about 1°C for over thirty years with officially global warming being reported at 1.1°C in 1991 and 1.06°C in 2022.
There is no science plausible mechanism for greenhouse gas behavior to effect climate. The back of the United Nation's IPCC science report states it took its greenhouse gas samples at 20,000 meters altitude where it is high school level knowledge there is no greenhouse radiant energy. The authors have been legally transparent with their data protecting them from fraud prosecution. This is typical deceptive marketing practice.
There is no such thing as a global average temperature. Everywhere has it's own climate patterns.
You don't understand the term "average" do you...
@@chrismoule7242 You don't understand the term 'climate' do you...
What the efff. Fire this incompetent woman
Barack Obama said under his plan, "Energy costs would necessarily skyrocket." Looks to me to be working like a charm.
She knows nothing. Impact? Who knows? Trillions buy us "???????
We have NOT experienced more and bigger storms in recent years. Just more reporting on the weather disasters that DO happen.
She is absolutely barking mad...
Is there no discussion about why the US Canada and Europe are being made to sacrifice the use of coal, oil and natural gas, but the BRICS nations not at all?
Thank you, Senator Lee, for putting it in a common sense way that even granholm should be able to comprehend.
It would be cheaper to compensate for rising temperatures than going to net zero.
A very astute and incisive American. As rare in your country as it is in ours - England.
Bad weather?? Spend hundreds of TRILLIONS of dollars to stop bad weather?? Hmmmmm.....it's not passing the smell test...
She won’t answer the question because it is so insignificant!
Why is it they aren't having debates like this all over mainstream media like the BBC and channel 4? We all know why
It's not the 'drop' in temperature now, but how much can the temperature be stopped from rising further. We are pretty much past the point of no return, but we must limit it from continuing to increase.
Bottom line: Tremendous cost now for a speculative benefit a hundred years out (with the working class paying the cost now).
WEATHER IS CYCLIC
Best comment! I been saying it for yrs!
@@chrishenicke2052 aside from the man made weather, which is everything unnatural and there is a lot of it, see weatherwar101 and geoengineering watch
Climate is cyclic, weather is not. Weather changes daily, with no pattern. Climate has cycles. We are currently in a warming cycle since the most recent ice age.
@@garyszewc3339 I’m not convinced. 🤷♂️
@@garyszewc3339 wrong. Tell that to the ice age
If were pumping more oil than ever, like Granholm keeps saying, why doesn't someone ask her "if that's true then why are we buying oil from Opec?" .. no one will ask her about that
In NL the decrease in temperature is estimated at 0,000036 degrees Celsius.
Oh boy corrupt Granholm. Michigone where she was a previous Governor was horrible. Now sister friend wichmore is in her place. She stole peoples freedoms making felonies out of many lives because her sister. Dirty deeds done dirt cheap in michigone.
Yes her Phrase as Governor was, “We are in Transition now we are paying but Just Wait”! That was 2000 and still waiting an she moved onto bigger fk ups, the WH ? Bidens Clown Show!
Nobody knows if any of this will have an effect on temperature at all. It's all about money, power, and control.
I agree.
Thank God for Josh and Mike. We need more guys like them in our government. I'm sure Schumer can't stand either one of them. ☕☕☕😎🇺🇸
Nobody will answer this question....
If man made CO2 is causing global warming, why aren't we stopping deforestation, which accounts for up to 20% of man made C02?
Wouldn't that be the logical approach?
She doesn't know. Just likes spending money
She makes the same liar faces that we see on mydorkass and garland.
Oy vey, that's a bit anti-semitic!
Good lad.
They say they able to predict climate temperature rises,but not decreases,because decreases do not not suit their narrative .