”I met a girl who sang the blues”- Janis Joplin. ”The Jester”- Bob Dylan. ”A quartet practiced in the park”- the Beatles. ”The father, son and the holy ghost” - Buddy Holly, Richie Valens & The Big Bopper. ”The King” - Elvis Presley. ”The king and queen” - John and Jackie Kennedy ”Jack Flash” - the Rolling Stones. At least I read all this somewhere. Love your reaction to one of my favourite songs. Love your channel! ❤️
Yes, the King was President Kennedy, his thorny crown is a reference to the crucifixtion of a good man with new if not revolutionary ideas who was killed for tryinf to change the status quo. Kennedy was a man with new ideas, and was assasinated for it
"Vincent" is my favorite Don McLean song. I never really appreciated Van Gogh''s art, I had only ever seen prints of his paintings. That changed when I visited the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam and saw the real thing. Suddenly I understood and the song Vincent then took on more meaning for me.
All the way up to Altamont. If you really know 60's culture and history then the song makes perfect sense. For younger people it might not. My favorite line is about Joplin. "I knew a girl who sang the blues". It's such a sad statement of how many great musicians were lost at that time.
Waylon Jennings was supposed to be on that plane. Ritchie Valens was sick, the bus didn't have any heat. So Waylon the fine man he was, eventhough he was drinking whiskey and rye, he gave his seeat to Ritchie Valens. It wasn't the way the movie did the scene was.
'American Pie' by Don McLean, released in Nov. 1971. Certainly a song about the loss of innocence in American culture through its music. A 10-year period from the sock-hop to the Woodstock generation at the Altamont Free Concert. For the artist, the begining of the end started with him as a 13-year-old paperboy reading about Buddy Holly's death in Feb. 1959. The era of Elvis being overshadowed by Bob Dylan and the British Invasion (The Beatles, Rolling Stones, etc.). Like Adam and Eve in paradise until their being driven out by corruption.
This is one of the most beautiful songs ever written, I'm so glad you reacted to it again with the lyrics. i've been listening to this song since I was a kid- I don't remember a time when I didn't know this song- and I still get teary eyed at the last verse every time I hear it, it's so beautiful. I agree with others, Vincent by Don MacLean is a beautiful song that will break your heart. Great reaction!
You might not know the initial meaning behind the song, but this song is giving you an emotional response BEYOND it's context. That is why it is ART. You are taking something from it that is based on your own life experience. It is ART. It helps you discover something within yourself.
@@chicoandtheman7599 Good link to a great interpretation of the song. Don't know if I agree with every one, just that DM made it known that "the day the music died" is the day Buddy Holley died.
@@PK1971PK Yea. I think you're right. I think DM meant Buddy Holly, but also Richie Vallens, & The Big Bopper. "and the 3 men I admired the most, the father son & the holy ghost". (Holly, Vallens, Bopper) But in that context, I never understood the line "they caught the last train for the coast", in less that's just a euphemism for death. In any event, it's such a powerful song & there will always be a certain degree of mystery surrounding some of the lyrics. Up until a year ago, I always thought "them good old boys were drinkinh whiskey and rye" just meant like.....rye whiskey. It's actually "drinking whiskey *in* Rye". (Rye, New York) "The Levee" was a bar in Rye, NY, that DM frequented.
@@chicoandtheman7599 You may be right that it's about the death of all three that day, but what I read--and this was back like a year or so after "American Pie" came out (Rolling Stone or Crawdaddy or Creem magazine, just don't remember where)--gave me the impression it was just about the death of Buddy Holly. I think he was much more influential on the music scene and its future than the other two. Remember that the Beatles took their name because it was so close to the Crickets. Back then we had no idea at all what the lyrics were intended to mean--sort of like JB here. Just since the explosion of CZcams have I given any thought to what all the rest of the song is about. Honestly, those three you said being the Father, Son and Holy Ghost doesn't make much sense to me. As a trinity, yeah, but specifically who is which I can't see. And it's not in the article you linked to. It comes too late in the song. But more importantly, you can't take the last train if you're dead--which also negates another thought that they were references to the asassinations of JFK, RFK and MLK. Unless, as you've said, taking a train for the coast means to check out. In which case it would be more likely a reference to the song "Abraham, Martin and John", which would make Father Abraham (Lincoln), JFK/RFK the son and MLK the Holy Ghost (Holy equals a pastor and ghost the spirit that haunts us for the sins of slavery). But one interpretation I think makes the most sense is that it isn't that they represent any particular person of the time period, but the symbols of the Holy Trinity themselves--the last holdouts for an age of innocence gave up and headed for the coast--we've all lost faith. " ...in the wake of this decade's disillusioning cynicism and fragmentation, the 'Father, Son and the Holy Ghost' represent a faith in America that had once permeated American life, and that-hope against hope-might still redeem the disorder that had befallen us. But the holy trinity, finding no sympathetic hearing and resigning themselves to the inevitable (having held out for "the last train"), pack up their bags and retire to the coast: the believers had lost faith in their gods, and the gods can only retreat." understandingamericanpie.com/vs6pg2.htm
This song is history of the music of the 60's, after the death of Buddy Holly. Some of the main characters are "The King" who is Elvis, the Jester is Bob Dylan, the Sergeants/ marching band is The Beatles, the Devil is Mick Jagger of the Rolling Stones, though there is reference to the real devil. There are all kinds of references to different events in the 60's.
James the important thing is that u listened to it again... I know sometimes I have to listen to a song a few times.... this song was about 3 musicians back in the 50’s who tragically died in a plane crash... Buddy Holly... who by the way started dubbing.... the Big Bopper and Richie Valens... all died very young... sometimes I imagine what kind of music they would put out today? That thought just takes me away... anyway James. I absolutely love ur channel.. ur an AMAZING young man... someday I would love to talk music with u!! That would be a highlight of my day... 😃✌️
Our younger generation need to be introduced to this music and all the words had real meaning no matter how the years have gone by we can take ourselves back to it remembering all the words the music will never did so happy to have found you lovely manxx
American Pie is a classic rock song and one of the greatest songs of all time. Don McLean only had one other big hit and it was titled "Vincent" and was about the painter, Vincent Van Gogh. It's a beautiful song.
There is so much in this song that you didn't even get my bro (and no wonder cos you have to know a lot of the back story). It's really a song about history and music history. There is so much in it. The best is you wikipedia it. Could talk 2 hours about it alone! Great song, wonderful lyrics and so much meaning.
When this came out you rarely heard the whole song because it was so long. I had the 45 record and you had to turn it over to the B side to hear the whole. Brings back great memories. I agree with previous reaction, “Vincent” it is one of the best songs ever!
Not to be a troll but... it actually went down like this... Lori Lieberman, who sang the original version of the hit "Killing Me Softly With His Song," claims that "Empty Chairs" inspired that song. A press release tells the story: Don played a show at LA's Troubadour Club. Singing Empty Chairs inspired Lori Lieberman to write the song Killing Me Softly on a napkin. "I was actually blasé about going," says Lieberman. "I didn't know who he was, but from the moment he walked on stage, I was spellbound. I felt as if he knew me and his songs were about my life. I felt like he sang into my soul." Originally called killing me softly with his blues, Lori's poem inspired songwriters Norman Gimbel & Charles Fox to write the song for her. It was released on her debut album in 1971.
One of the greatest songs (words and music) ever written and performed! Use to play it on an 8 track driving on gravel roads at night drinking beer in Iowa 1971! High School!
Since you listened to Patsy Cline, you should listen to Jim Reeves. Beautiful baritone voice. He and Patsy both died in plane crashes. “Am I Losing You”, “Four Walls”, “He’ll have to Go”, “Adios Amigo”....those are just a few of his hits. My mom adored Jim Reeves. Just hearing his voice make me think of her.
That'll Be the Day" by Buddy Holly is just one of the inspirations for the lyrics; the day the music died refers to the tragic plane crash that killed Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens, and The Big Bopper on their to a show through a snowstorm. The "Jester" is Bob Dylan, and there are plenty of other musical references in the lyrics.
The times of my childhood. I was almost 4 years old when JFK died. Not in school yet. I remember my mama crying. Vietnam, my brother is 17 years older than me. He was a paratrooper. As early as 1959 they were dropping him & others into the jungles of Vietnam. Their job was to scope it all out & find their pick up point. American citizens were unaware. So many things happened during those times. The Civil Rights Movement. Assassinations of good men trying to make positive changes in our Country. So much turmoil!!! Too much heartache!!! Yes I believe Satan is laughing with delight when songs that are celebrating & condoning horrible nasty things become popular. When people are mistreating each other. I look at people just a few years older than me that were protesting horrible, corrupt, & evil behavior when they were in their teens & twenties & wonder what happened to them. They have voted for & condoned the behavior of many of the most corrupt government officials in our history. This song is still very pertinent today. Young people should listen multiple times & find out what was going on back then. Old folks need to remember & everyone in between. We need more Love, kindness, & compassion in our souls.
This is one of America's greatest songs. There is a whole Wikipedia page explaining the lyrics more fully. Every word he places is thought out and perfect! I highly suggest you look up what he was singing about! Great reaction as usual! Thsnks!
There are some GREAT analysis of this song and what and who are all the characters are in the song. One article I read suggested that "the marching band" is a reference to the Beatles "Sgt Peppers" album.
Yes. They are also referred to as "the sergeants" just a few lines earlier. Also, a "marching tune" was 1960s slang for a song you couldn't dance to. It would appear that Don McLean wasn't a big fan of the Beatles. Then again, given that he refers to Mick Jagger as literal Satan, I imagine him to be not too big a fan of the Rolling Stones either. Of course, the song explains why: _The players tried to take the field, but the marching band refused to yield._ "Beatle Mania" was such an all-consuming force, that there simply wasn't any room for new artists to make it during that time.
@@AhsimNreiziev The Mick Jagger reference is about the Altamont fiasco. It's not a poke at Mick Jagger. it's about the murder that took place when The Rolling Stones were singing Sympathy For The Devil. The line, No Angel born in Hell...Is because upon Jerry Garcia's recommendation the Hells Angels were charged with security for the concert. And, they were paid in beer. As the concert went on the Hells Angels got drunker and drunker. Then chaos ensues, then death.
Its sort of like "We didnt start the fire" by Billy Joel. The references are to events and things that happened before you born James! Beyond reading the lyrics, you almost need to read up on every reference in order to pet all the meat of it. I think it would be worthwhile if you did, or even talk to an elder of yours and ask what they remember.
"His widowed bride" refers to the young woman who Buddy Holly had recently married and of course Buddy,The Big Bopper and Richie Valance all died in a plane crash soon afterwards.
I always considered American pie to be a classic song that tells the history of rock and roll going from when the day the music died to when the song was written. I’m not sure I would say the song is cryptic,unless you aren’t familiar with music history from the time frame. Song titles, lyrics and nicknames of rock stars were all in the song.
What a wonderful experience for you to share!!! This was before all of us were alive but we all feel the meaning and importance!!!!! You are an artist in your own right!
just wanted to say how much i appreciate your videos man. this one is one of my favorites. I know you have been thru the shit so I just want to send you some love.
American History, set to music! I’m over 60 years old....and this is the FIRST time I have ever cried at the words to this song. You made me slow down, listen, feel and really comprehend the era I grew up in! Wow .....thanks man.
Thank you soooo much for this second reaction. You can listen to this song a thousand times and still come away with a new understanding. One of the greatest songs of all time.
I really like your reactions because you can appreciate all genres of music. I have favorites in every genre and there are some that I prefer not to listen to on a regular basis but, I appreciate each style. That's why I subscribe ♥
You may want to listen to Buddy Holly ( & the Crickets) " That'll Be The Day", The Big Bopper " Chantilly Lace" and Ritchie Valens "La Bamba". The plane carrying them and their pilot crashed on February 3, 1959. Buddy was 22, The Bopper 26 (I think) and Ritchie was 17. Everything in American Pie took place within about a ten year period.
Would also recommend watching The Buddy Holly Story staring Gary Busey( before he went crazy) and La Bamba staring Lou Diamond Phillips. To see their upbringings. Sad to say, I don't recall a movie about Big Bopper being made, but you can find his performances on line.
I missed this! Enjoyed your reaction so much. I am old enough to know what the song is about, was born just after the crash, but I understand your application to a new generation and your reasoning, I was on the edge of my seat because I couldn't believe how apt the song is now, if for different reasons. Art is always open to interpretation and beauty is in the eye of the beholder (or ear of the listener 🙂) Thank you for an enlightening 15 minutes 🎭😁💜
I taught my grandchildren this song from the time they were wee little ones. It is still one of their favorite songs of all time. Today, they have impeccable taste in music and understand that music can do both harm and good.
Thank you for going back to listen more carefully, I subscribed for that. I liked both of your takes on how this song is history and yet can also be a general narrative and lamenting for the loss of music and all walks of the American Dream, both here and in how the world sees us now... it's sad to lose such a precious dream. I also find interesting to hear so many plays on words and meanings in this song even through his use of the chorus being sung by us, (the people), the devil and the father, son and the holy ghost, perhaps speaking both to the universality of music and to how the same song can be so different based on who gives it voice.
I’ve been watching your channel for 3 hrs now and what a treat! Some of the best music ever and your reactions are precious and sweet. (Hope that’s not condescending)
After this song came out in 1971 people started calling the day that Buddy Holly died in the plane crash, "The Day the Music Died" since that's how Don refers to it in the song. So if you hear someone talk about "The day the music died" they're talking about the plane crash that killed Buddy Holly, The Big Bopper Richardson, and Ritchie Valens Feb. 3rd, 1959.
I was 7 when this song came out. I heard it over and over on radio as I came up. It became more powerful as I grew older, and I now watching you, it made me cry. Don McLean was a genius lyricist. Get behind me satan..
Music was beautiful in the 70s. I was blessed to grow up in the 60s and 70s. I’m 58. I love listening and watching someone like you that truly appreciates music from this time. Keep up your reviews and reactions. Satan has taken over so many things. Music, for sure is crap. Full of violence, sex, drugs, suicide. Not ALL but a lot of crap out there. Thx for your hard work. Love you!!!!!!
The music died was when Buddy Holly and the guy that did the song La Bamma. died in a plane crash. When he talks about the King he is talking about Elvis being replaced by Bob Dylan. It's one of those songs everyone has to listen to several times to get all the hidden meanings. It is deep. . Good choice.
The man is a master lyricist and song writer! I was in high school in 1973 when I heard this for the first time. You need to react to Vincent. A very beautiful song!
This song is about the 3 lives that ended short by a tragic plane crash... The Big Bopper, Richie Valens and Buddy Holly... the plane crash is in Clear Lake Iowa.. 4 miles north of my house:)
This was actually a song to Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens and the big bopper. It was said when they died was "the day the music died" and the phrase "this'll be the day that I die" is a reference to Buddy Hollys biggest hit "that'll be the day when I die".
Its a natural reaction to a masterpiece of a song it is so full of so much history and yes you a very smart an receptive man to grasp all the meaning of this song and us old boomers can't listen to this without tearing up its one of if not the best song ever written or sung thank you very much for the reaction of how powerful this song is !
I was ten years old when this song dropped on WLS AM out of Chicago Il. I was to young to comprehend the nuances of popular music but I knew that this song was something special.
Great classic song about a sad tragedy. Iconic song. Glad you discovered it. Listen to it several times and to Buddy Hollies and Ritchie's , and Big Boppers music and then you will see what a tragedy it was. Then you will understand this songs lyrics.
At face value, the lyrics are esoteric, the meaning has been largely debated over the years, but you can find the references online. Largely about the crash that killed Richie Valens and the Big Bopper and the loss of innocence.
Don't feel bad, they've been arguing/discussing the meaning of these lyrics since they were written! You're a very courageous young man to admit his befuddlement over these cryptic lyrics. Join the crowd! Also, you can stand tall in declaring your opinion that this song is truly one for the ages. You are the first person I've ever heard bestow such an exalted opinion, and I realized, you're absolutely right. I heartily agree with your judgment on that point. You're very thoughtful and intelligent, and if you see it as such, I knew I would have to examine it again in that light. Thank you for taking the time to review it a second time, admit your failing to give it the consideration it deserved the first time, and then delivering such an eye-opening view-point the second time around. One word describes you my man. You are absolutely courageous. Keep it going!
I read somewhere Don McLean was a paperboy as a kid and he heard about his musical hero, Buddy Holly along with The Big Bopper and Ritchie Valens, dying in a plane crash. For him that was the day the music died. The rest is sort of left up to interpretation, with all the references that other commenters have mentioned. There've been books written about what people think the song meant, the only one who really knows is Don McLean. I feel like it almost doesn't matter what he meant by it, it's what we take from it and how music moves us. It sounded like it really moved you James and I think that's what matters even if you don't get all the musicians he references here.
This song came out in my 5th grade year in 1971. My friend would bring this record to school and we’d dance during recess. This song is about Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens and the Big Bopper who died in a plane crash.
I like that you saw and heard a message... Your journey to discover music is opening up your mind.. and hopefully you'll see in comments what the interpretation of the song was at the time. Many things about the tumultuous times the song was written in. But.. we still live in tumultuous times.. and I am a believer that music can mean different things to different people at different times. You should own whatever meaning you hear... I think that's the transcending aspect of the song.
What a great reaction to one of the greatest songs written. Lyrics can be so powerful ! I agree with others in saying please listen to Vincent, one of my all time favourite songs ever ! Thanks for sharing. Lerv from down under \m/ \m/
This song is deep, people are still trying to decipher it, you're not alone. I remember my kids when little thought of this as one of mom's fun road trip songs; when they were teens we'd talk and they started realizing the depth in every lyric, it's a poetic history lesson of American culture from the 50s-70s, it's always fun to look up different interpretations of it every now and then. His original notes sold a few years ago at auction for over a million dollars.
This song is influenced by historical events and is full of metaphors that are confusing to younger listeners that maybe don't know some of the inspiration behind the song. There is a VH1 Behind The Music Documentary called The Day the Music Died. Excellent. Should have won an Emmy. It's on youtube.
This all started with the death of Buddy Holly, Richie Valens, and the Big Bopper in a plane crash outside of Clear Lake, Iowa. That was the day the music died. There weren't as many great performers in 1958-59 Elvis ( the King in the song ) had just left for the army. Many people thought Rock had died with the plane crash. In the rest of the story he talks about the Jester ( Bob Dylan ) the girl who sang the blues ( Janice Joplin ) the quartet practiced in the park (The Beatles ) and all the others The evolution of rock and culture in the 60,s and early 70,s. When he says "this will be the day that I die " Buddy Holly had a song called "That'll be the day that I die" . Buddy Holly was an inspiration to a lot of bands and to Don himself. Good for you to have relisned to the song and check out the lyrics . You are my favorite reaction person on youtube your honest opinions are truly what keeps me watching. God bless
Parts of the song are based on his personal experiences. For example, the line about bad news on the doorstep, comes from the fact that Don was a paperboy in high school, around the time The Day the Music Died. It could be perceived as experiencing most of the main artists and the effect they made in music from the point of view of a songwriter from 1959 to 1972 when the song came out.
this was my era, when I first discovered there was FM on the radio. I will probably be able to sing along with this til me end. Song like this are why the 60's-80's say they had the best music. We grew up on the older that our parents listened to, but this was a whole new genre.
It is a seminal piece. Extraordinarily well received and popular. Very touching. I had the pleasure of hearing him sing it live at a free Billy Joel concert in Central Park. It was in T.V. but it was great all the same.
The first time I heard this song was in school, when I was 15. A substitute teacher didn’t know what to do in the lesson so he put in a video cassette taped from TV music documentary about “old music” (according to us). This song stuck in my mind among all the 80s pop I was surrounded by, and is still my best song ever!
My older sister bought this album when it came out. It seems like I've heard this song my whole life. It's definitely one of my all-time favorite songs.
ItsallGood Same! I used to steal the American Pie album from my older sisters‘ room and play it for hours, laying on my bed awash in my tweenage angst. Vincent was my absolute favorite.
This is the classic example of the song that whenever you hear it you have to listen to the whole thing no matter what else is going on. They even made a commercial that played off that, I think it was a Pepsi commercial.
This song is so iconic. It's kind of in a class by itself. Another long story song you should check out. It's a Thanksgiving tradition on a lot of stations,atleast it used to be."Alice's Restaurant " by Arlo Guthrie
James, hats off to you for going back and hearing this again, in a way that was mu h more meaningful to you. When asked to explain the lyrics, Don McLean has generally declined stating that it means what it means to the listener. While the allusions seem to be fairly clear, Bob Dylan, Janis Joplin, Kent State (possibly), the Beetles, etc...,to me this song evoke the loss of innocence and hope resulting from major events that my generation experienced. Most people know about the events that happened in the past such as the assignation's of John F Kennedy, Martin Luther King, Robert Kennedy, the Kent State Massacre, the deaths of Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin, and Jim Morrison, etc...These are events that people my age experienced in real time. I remember exactly where I was and the circumstances when I learned about the assassination's and the other events that sobered us up and, in my case, quenched many of my hopes. So to me, this song ids a eulogy for the hopes of my generation.
My memory of this song.. I was a kid of 9 or 10, and my older brother came into my room one morning and woke me saying 'Pete Duel killed himself'. Pete Duel was an actor on the T.V. show 'Alias Smith & Jones', a western series that was on in the late 70's. Well, I was madly in love with Pete Duel, and my jerk brother knew that, so he delighted in waking me to tell me of his death. I cried and called him a liar..but then later I saw the news, and found it was true. I spent the rest of the day standing in my bedroom window sobbing, and playing American Pie on the record player.. lol
The song is about the plane crash killed Buddy Holly, The Big Bopper, Ritchie Valens, and J.P. Richardson. Waylon Jennings was supposed to be on the flight, but gave his seat to J.P. You might enjoy their music...Buddy Holly's "Peggy Sue" and Ritchie Valans' "La Bamba" are classics.
Here's a video I just found, gives a bit more of the story. Two movies were made about these musicians: "The Buddy Holly Story" and "La Bamba". czcams.com/video/r9M6u7-9yNE/video.html
”I met a girl who sang the blues”- Janis Joplin. ”The Jester”- Bob Dylan. ”A quartet practiced in the park”- the Beatles. ”The father, son and the holy ghost” - Buddy Holly, Richie Valens & The Big Bopper. ”The King” - Elvis Presley. ”The king and queen” - John and Jackie Kennedy ”Jack Flash” - the Rolling Stones. At least I read all this somewhere. Love your reaction to one of my favourite songs. Love your channel! ❤️
Yes, the King was President Kennedy, his thorny crown is a reference to the crucifixtion of a good man with new if not revolutionary ideas who was killed for tryinf to change the status quo. Kennedy was a man with new ideas, and was assasinated for it
Helter skelter is a reference to Jimi Hendrix
@@007hwm LOL! I always thought it referred to the Manson Murders in Aug of 1969!
@@foots-qt4pk Yes. 'Helter Skelter' was written on the wall in blood at the Manson Murder scene. It was the title of a Beatles song.
@@blizzy6392 I had never heard of the song before, so I listened to it. Im 60 and never heard of the song! lol!
Listen to "Vincent" Another of his beautiful songs. Seemingly about Van Gogh and his fight with mental disease....
Pia Slatcher Love that song!
I second that... Listen to "Vincent", without question one of the most incredible songs ever written.
Yes! I'd love to see a 'Vincent' reaction x
"Vincent" is my favorite Don McLean song. I never really appreciated Van Gogh''s art, I had only ever seen prints of his paintings. That changed when I visited the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam and saw the real thing. Suddenly I understood and the song Vincent then took on more meaning for me.
I love that song but Vincent likely had heavy metal poison from the old oil paints..
Brother this song pretty much talked about everything that was going on during that time period. It may just be the greatest song ever written.
All the way up to Altamont. If you really know 60's culture and history then the song makes perfect sense. For younger people it might not. My favorite line is about Joplin. "I knew a girl who sang the blues". It's such a sad statement of how many great musicians were lost at that time.
Indeed. 👍
"The Day The Music Died" was about Buddy Holly dying in a plane crash in Clear Lake, Iowa along with Ritchie Valens and J D. Big Bopper...
Waylon Jennings was supposed to be on that plane. Ritchie Valens was sick, the bus didn't have any heat. So Waylon the fine man he was, eventhough he was drinking whiskey and rye, he gave his seeat to Ritchie Valens.
It wasn't the way the movie did the scene was.
'American Pie' by Don McLean, released in Nov. 1971.
Certainly a song about the loss of innocence in American culture through its music. A 10-year period from the sock-hop to the Woodstock generation at the Altamont Free Concert. For the artist, the begining of the end started with him as a 13-year-old paperboy reading about Buddy Holly's death in Feb. 1959. The era of Elvis being overshadowed by Bob Dylan and the British Invasion (The Beatles, Rolling Stones, etc.).
Like Adam and Eve in paradise until their being driven out by corruption.
i still remember every word after 40 years , thats how much we listened to this .unreal!
This is one of the most beautiful songs ever written, I'm so glad you reacted to it again with the lyrics. i've been listening to this song since I was a kid- I don't remember a time when I didn't know this song- and I still get teary eyed at the last verse every time I hear it, it's so beautiful. I agree with others, Vincent by Don MacLean is a beautiful song that will break your heart. Great reaction!
allie L This is the 1st song I remember hearing. My mom was singing the chorus. It’s probably one of my first memories actually..
You might not know the initial meaning behind the song, but this song is giving you an emotional response BEYOND it's context. That is why it is ART. You are taking something from it that is based on your own life experience. It is ART. It helps you discover something within yourself.
😊 krna.com/the-true-story-behind-american-pie-lyrics/
@@chicoandtheman7599 Good link to a great interpretation of the song. Don't know if I agree with every one, just that DM made it known that "the day the music died" is the day Buddy Holley died.
@@PK1971PK Yea. I think you're right. I think DM meant Buddy Holly, but also Richie Vallens, & The Big Bopper. "and the 3 men I admired the most, the father son & the holy ghost". (Holly, Vallens, Bopper) But in that context, I never understood the line "they caught the last train for the coast", in less that's just a euphemism for death. In any event, it's such a powerful song & there will always be a certain degree of mystery surrounding some of the lyrics. Up until a year ago, I always thought "them good old boys were drinkinh whiskey and rye" just meant like.....rye whiskey. It's actually "drinking whiskey *in* Rye". (Rye, New York)
"The Levee" was a bar in Rye, NY, that DM frequented.
@@chicoandtheman7599 You may be right that it's about the death of all three that day, but what I read--and this was back like a year or so after "American Pie" came out (Rolling Stone or Crawdaddy or Creem magazine, just don't remember where)--gave me the impression it was just about the death of Buddy Holly. I think he was much more influential on the music scene and its future than the other two. Remember that the Beatles took their name because it was so close to the Crickets. Back then we had no idea at all what the lyrics were intended to mean--sort of like JB here. Just since the explosion of CZcams have I given any thought to what all the rest of the song is about.
Honestly, those three you said being the Father, Son and Holy Ghost doesn't make much sense to me. As a trinity, yeah, but specifically who is which I can't see. And it's not in the article you linked to. It comes too late in the song. But more importantly, you can't take the last train if you're dead--which also negates another thought that they were references to the asassinations of JFK, RFK and MLK. Unless, as you've said, taking a train for the coast means to check out. In which case it would be more likely a reference to the song "Abraham, Martin and John", which would make Father Abraham (Lincoln), JFK/RFK the son and MLK the Holy Ghost (Holy equals a pastor and ghost the spirit that haunts us for the sins of slavery). But one interpretation I think makes the most sense is that it isn't that they represent any particular person of the time period, but the symbols of the Holy Trinity themselves--the last holdouts for an age of innocence gave up and headed for the coast--we've all lost faith. " ...in the wake of this decade's disillusioning cynicism and fragmentation, the 'Father, Son and the Holy Ghost' represent a faith in America that had once permeated American life, and that-hope against hope-might still redeem the disorder that had befallen us. But the holy trinity, finding no sympathetic hearing and resigning themselves to the inevitable (having held out for "the last train"), pack up their bags and retire to the coast: the believers had lost faith in their gods, and the gods can only retreat." understandingamericanpie.com/vs6pg2.htm
The whole song is metaphors to actual people, places and events.
This song is history of the music of the 60's, after the death of Buddy Holly. Some of the main characters are "The King" who is Elvis, the Jester is Bob Dylan, the Sergeants/ marching band is The Beatles, the Devil is Mick Jagger of the Rolling Stones, though there is reference to the real devil. There are all kinds of references to different events in the 60's.
James the important thing is that u listened to it again... I know sometimes I have to listen to a song a few times.... this song was about 3 musicians back in the 50’s who tragically died in a plane crash... Buddy Holly... who by the way started dubbing.... the Big Bopper and Richie Valens... all died very young... sometimes I imagine what kind of music they would put out today? That thought just takes me away...
anyway James. I absolutely love ur channel.. ur an AMAZING young man... someday I would love to talk music with u!! That would be a highlight of my day... 😃✌️
I would love to talk about music
JBLETHAL TV James I’m in.. somehow we need to connect. Umm, FaceTime? Whatever u want.
Our younger generation need to be introduced to this music and all the words had real meaning no matter how the years have gone by we can take ourselves back to it remembering all the words the music will never did so happy to have found you lovely manxx
American Pie is a classic rock song and one of the greatest songs of all time. Don McLean only had one other big hit and it was titled "Vincent" and was about the painter, Vincent Van Gogh. It's a beautiful song.
That's my era and it was a beautiful era. Best music era ever!
There is so much in this song that you didn't even get my bro (and no wonder cos you have to know a lot of the back story). It's really a song about history and music history. There is so much in it. The best is you wikipedia it. Could talk 2 hours about it alone! Great song, wonderful lyrics and so much meaning.
😊 @t
😊 @t
When this came out you rarely heard the whole song because it was so long. I had the 45 record and you had to turn it over to the B side to hear the whole. Brings back great memories. I agree with previous reaction, “Vincent” it is one of the best songs ever!
This song is so complex and deep that people who are reacting to it miss the absolute beautiful quality of Don Mcleans voice!!
Trivia: Roberta Flack's "Killing Me Softly" is about Don McLean.
Not to be a troll but... it actually went down like this... Lori Lieberman, who sang the original version of the hit "Killing Me Softly With His Song," claims that "Empty Chairs" inspired that song. A press release tells the story: Don played a show at LA's Troubadour Club. Singing Empty Chairs inspired Lori Lieberman to write the song Killing Me Softly on a napkin. "I was actually blasé about going," says Lieberman. "I didn't know who he was, but from the moment he walked on stage, I was spellbound. I felt as if he knew me and his songs were about my life. I felt like he sang into my soul." Originally called killing me softly with his blues, Lori's poem inspired songwriters Norman Gimbel & Charles Fox to write the song for her. It was released on her debut album in 1971.
I remember watching Don McLean on TV singing this back in the day!!
Definitely - listen to "Vincent" (sometimes called Starry, Starry Night) - beautiful words and melody...
I see the song as an elegy for the USA at a certain place in time.
One of the greatest songs (words and music) ever written and performed! Use to play it on an 8 track driving on gravel roads at night drinking beer in Iowa 1971! High School!
Since you listened to Patsy Cline, you should listen to Jim Reeves. Beautiful baritone voice. He and Patsy both died in plane crashes. “Am I Losing You”, “Four Walls”, “He’ll have to Go”, “Adios Amigo”....those are just a few of his hits. My mom adored Jim Reeves. Just hearing his voice make me think of her.
Lol, I used to dj the morning show at a classic rock station and this was the song we always put on if we had to step out for a smoke!
I love your reaction to this wonderful song. Another great song from Don McLean is Vincent, with wonderful lyrics once again.
You have to tell him thats its about Vincent Van Gogh! He can google him before he listens!
I have watched your videos for several hours now. I love these videos. They really make me happy.
That'll Be the Day" by Buddy Holly is just one of the inspirations for the lyrics; the day the music died refers to the tragic plane crash that killed Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens, and The Big Bopper on their to a show through a snowstorm. The "Jester" is Bob Dylan, and there are plenty of other musical references in the lyrics.
The times of my childhood. I was almost 4 years old when JFK died. Not in school yet. I remember my mama crying. Vietnam, my brother is 17 years older than me. He was a paratrooper. As early as 1959 they were dropping him & others into the jungles of Vietnam. Their job was to scope it all out & find their pick up point. American citizens were unaware.
So many things happened during those times. The Civil Rights Movement. Assassinations of good men trying to make positive changes in our Country. So much turmoil!!! Too much heartache!!! Yes I believe Satan is laughing with delight when songs that are celebrating & condoning horrible nasty things become popular. When people are mistreating each other.
I look at people just a few years older than me that were protesting horrible, corrupt, & evil behavior when they were in their teens & twenties & wonder what happened to them. They have voted for & condoned the behavior of many of the most corrupt government officials in our history.
This song is still very pertinent today. Young people should listen multiple times & find out what was going on back then. Old folks need to remember & everyone in between. We need more Love, kindness, & compassion in our souls.
That is the best complex explanation I've ever heard.
That summed up the entire song!
This is one of America's greatest songs. There is a whole Wikipedia page explaining the lyrics more fully. Every word he places is thought out and perfect! I highly suggest you look up what he was singing about! Great reaction as usual! Thsnks!
Honey we don't mind at all that you are reacting to this for a second time. This iconic song never gets old lol
There are some GREAT analysis of this song and what and who are all the characters are in the song. One article I read suggested that "the marching band" is a reference to the Beatles "Sgt Peppers" album.
Yes. They are also referred to as "the sergeants" just a few lines earlier.
Also, a "marching tune" was 1960s slang for a song you couldn't dance to. It would appear that Don McLean wasn't a big fan of the Beatles. Then again, given that he refers to Mick Jagger as literal Satan, I imagine him to be not too big a fan of the Rolling Stones either.
Of course, the song explains why: _The players tried to take the field, but the marching band refused to yield._ "Beatle Mania" was such an all-consuming force, that there simply wasn't any room for new artists to make it during that time.
@@AhsimNreiziev The Mick Jagger reference is about the Altamont fiasco. It's not a poke at Mick Jagger. it's about the murder that took place when The Rolling Stones were singing Sympathy For The Devil.
The line, No Angel born in Hell...Is because upon Jerry Garcia's recommendation the Hells Angels were charged with security for the concert. And, they were paid in beer. As the concert went on the Hells Angels got drunker and drunker. Then chaos ensues, then death.
Its sort of like "We didnt start the fire" by Billy Joel. The references are to events and things that happened before you born James! Beyond reading the lyrics, you almost need to read up on every reference in order to pet all the meat of it. I think it would be worthwhile if you did, or even talk to an elder of yours and ask what they remember.
That's a, truly, awful comparison for McLean's song, in fact, it's rather insulting.
@@malcolmdrake6137Relax dude
"His widowed bride" refers to the young woman who Buddy Holly had recently married and of course Buddy,The Big Bopper and Richie Valance all died in a plane crash soon afterwards.
Mrs. Maria Elena Holly (née Santiago), the "widowed bride" of Buddy Holly (d. Feb. 3/59).
Buddy's widowed bride didn't pass in 1959, Buddy did.
@@matthewdrake4385 Thanks.
@@matthewdrake4385 look up the word cryptic the whole song is
I always considered American pie to be a classic song that tells the history of rock and roll going from when the day the music died to when the song was written. I’m not sure I would say the song is cryptic,unless you aren’t familiar with music history from the time frame. Song titles, lyrics and nicknames of rock stars were all in the song.
What a wonderful experience for you to share!!! This was before all of us were alive but we all feel the meaning and importance!!!!! You are an artist in your own right!
just wanted to say how much i appreciate your videos man. this one is one of my favorites. I know you have been thru the shit so I just want to send you some love.
Excellent review/reaction...this tune is, by far, one of the best songs ever penned...
American History, set to music! I’m over 60 years old....and this is the FIRST time I have ever cried at the words to this song. You made me slow down, listen, feel and really comprehend the era I grew up in! Wow .....thanks man.
Thank you soooo much for this second reaction. You can listen to this song a thousand times and still come away with a new understanding. One of the greatest songs of all time.
I really like your reactions because you can appreciate all genres of music. I have favorites in every genre and there are some that I prefer not to listen to on a regular basis but, I appreciate each style. That's why I subscribe ♥
Thank you. This is wonderful.💕💓🤗🥰🙏
You may want to listen to Buddy Holly ( & the Crickets) " That'll Be The Day", The Big Bopper " Chantilly Lace" and Ritchie Valens "La Bamba". The plane carrying them and their pilot crashed on February 3, 1959. Buddy was 22, The Bopper 26 (I think) and Ritchie was 17. Everything in American Pie took place within about a ten year period.
Would also recommend watching The Buddy Holly Story staring Gary Busey( before he went crazy) and La Bamba staring Lou Diamond Phillips. To see their upbringings. Sad to say, I don't recall a movie about Big Bopper being made, but you can find his performances on line.
I missed this! Enjoyed your reaction so much. I am old enough to know what the song is about, was born just after the crash, but I understand your application to a new generation and your reasoning, I was on the edge of my seat because I couldn't believe how apt the song is now, if for different reasons. Art is always open to interpretation and beauty is in the eye of the beholder (or ear of the listener 🙂) Thank you for an enlightening 15 minutes 🎭😁💜
Don McLean's songs were literally music and poetry together and it's so beautiful
I LOVE your reactions because you really pay attention to the lyrics and meaning!
I taught my grandchildren this song from the time they were wee little ones. It is still one of their favorite songs of all time. Today, they have impeccable taste in music and understand that music can do both harm and good.
Thank you for going back to listen more carefully, I subscribed for that. I liked both of your takes on how this song is history and yet can also be a general narrative and lamenting for the loss of music and all walks of the American Dream, both here and in how the world sees us now... it's sad to lose such a precious dream.
I also find interesting to hear so many plays on words and meanings in this song even through his use of the chorus being sung by us, (the people), the devil and the father, son and the holy ghost, perhaps speaking both to the universality of music and to how the same song can be so different based on who gives it voice.
Young man, please don’t apologize for your artistry and your desire to explore. God has you exactly where you are supposed to be!
I’ve been watching your channel for 3 hrs now and what a treat! Some of the best music ever and your reactions are precious and sweet. (Hope that’s not condescending)
So glad for your honesty. You seem to have a beautiful soul. I'm a new sub and really admire your heartfelt reactions. Namaste. ❤
After this song came out in 1971 people started calling the day that Buddy Holly died in the plane crash, "The Day the Music Died" since that's how Don refers to it in the song. So if you hear someone talk about "The day the music died" they're talking about the plane crash that killed Buddy Holly, The Big Bopper Richardson, and Ritchie Valens Feb. 3rd, 1959.
Haven't heard this in a while tears and chills. Love it.
I was 7 when this song came out. I heard it over and over on radio as I came up. It became more powerful as I grew older, and I now watching you, it made me cry. Don McLean was a genius lyricist. Get behind me satan..
Music was beautiful in the 70s. I was blessed to grow up in the 60s and 70s. I’m 58. I love listening and watching someone like you that truly appreciates music from this time. Keep up your reviews and reactions. Satan has taken over so many things. Music, for sure is crap. Full of violence, sex, drugs, suicide. Not ALL but a lot of crap out there. Thx for your hard work. Love you!!!!!!
You have great taste my friend, I’ve been listening to this song for many years, and I swear every time I hear it something else clicks in my head.
The music died was when Buddy Holly and the guy that did the song La Bamma. died in a plane crash. When he talks about the King he is talking about Elvis being replaced by Bob Dylan. It's one of those songs everyone has to listen to several times to get all the hidden meanings. It is deep. .
Good choice.
Buddy Holly, Richie Valens and the Big Bopper.
The man is a master lyricist and song writer! I was in high school in 1973 when I heard this for the first time. You need to react to Vincent. A very beautiful song!
This song is about the 3 lives that ended short by a tragic plane crash... The Big Bopper, Richie Valens and Buddy Holly... the plane crash is in Clear Lake Iowa.. 4 miles north of my house:)
We can't stop singing along with this song.
This was actually a song to Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens and the big bopper. It was said when they died was "the day the music died" and the phrase "this'll be the day that I die" is a reference to Buddy Hollys biggest hit "that'll be the day when I die".
I really like your channel. I check you out every day. I grew up with this music ❤️Rock On 😎
Its a natural reaction to a masterpiece of a song it is so full of so much history and yes you a very smart an receptive man to grasp all the meaning of this song and us old boomers can't listen to this without tearing up its one of if not the best song ever written or sung thank you very much for the reaction of how powerful this song is !
I love your reactions....you love all music
I was ten years old when this song dropped on WLS AM out of Chicago Il. I was to young to comprehend the nuances of popular music but I knew that this song was something special.
Great classic song about a sad tragedy. Iconic song. Glad you discovered it. Listen to it several times and to Buddy Hollies and Ritchie's , and Big Boppers music and then you will see what a tragedy it was. Then you will understand this songs lyrics.
At face value, the lyrics are esoteric, the meaning has been largely debated over the years, but you can find the references online. Largely about the crash that killed Richie Valens and the Big Bopper and the loss of innocence.
Don't feel bad, they've been arguing/discussing the meaning of these lyrics since they were written! You're a very courageous young man to admit his befuddlement over these cryptic lyrics. Join the crowd! Also, you can stand tall in declaring your opinion that this song is truly one for the ages. You are the first person I've ever heard bestow such an exalted opinion, and I realized, you're absolutely right. I heartily agree with your judgment on that point. You're very thoughtful and intelligent, and if you see it as such, I knew I would have to examine it again in that light. Thank you for taking the time to review it a second time, admit your failing to give it the consideration it deserved the first time, and then delivering such an eye-opening view-point the second time around. One word describes you my man. You are absolutely courageous. Keep it going!
I read somewhere Don McLean was a paperboy as a kid and he heard about his musical hero, Buddy Holly along with The Big Bopper and Ritchie Valens, dying in a plane crash. For him that was the day the music died. The rest is sort of left up to interpretation, with all the references that other commenters have mentioned. There've been books written about what people think the song meant, the only one who really knows is Don McLean. I feel like it almost doesn't matter what he meant by it, it's what we take from it and how music moves us. It sounded like it really moved you James and I think that's what matters even if you don't get all the musicians he references here.
This song came out in my 5th grade year in 1971. My friend would bring this record to school and we’d dance during recess. This song is about Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens and the Big Bopper who died in a plane crash.
I like that you saw and heard a message... Your journey to discover music is opening up your mind.. and hopefully you'll see in comments what the interpretation of the song was at the time. Many things about the tumultuous times the song was written in. But.. we still live in tumultuous times.. and I am a believer that music can mean different things to different people at different times. You should own whatever meaning you hear... I think that's the transcending aspect of the song.
What a great reaction to one of the greatest songs written. Lyrics can be so powerful !
I agree with others in saying please listen to Vincent, one of my all time favourite songs ever !
Thanks for sharing.
Lerv from down under \m/ \m/
60's and 70's music had allot more of a god and peace to it.
This song is deep, people are still trying to decipher it, you're not alone. I remember my kids when little thought of this as one of mom's fun road trip songs; when they were teens we'd talk and they started realizing the depth in every lyric, it's a poetic history lesson of American culture from the 50s-70s, it's always fun to look up different interpretations of it every now and then. His original notes sold a few years ago at auction for over a million dollars.
This song is influenced by historical events and is full of metaphors that are confusing to younger listeners that maybe don't know some of the inspiration behind the song. There is a VH1 Behind The Music Documentary called The Day the Music Died. Excellent. Should have won an Emmy. It's on youtube.
I appreciate you , you understand its music and should be enjoyed
Thank you for everything bud! Don't worry we lov ya!
This all started with the death of Buddy Holly, Richie Valens, and the Big Bopper in a plane crash outside of Clear Lake, Iowa. That was the day the music died. There weren't as many great performers in 1958-59 Elvis ( the King in the song ) had just left for the army. Many people thought Rock had died with the plane crash. In the rest of the story he talks about the Jester ( Bob Dylan ) the girl who sang the blues ( Janice Joplin ) the quartet practiced in the park (The Beatles ) and all the others The evolution of rock and culture in the 60,s and early 70,s. When he says "this will be the day that I die " Buddy Holly had a song called "That'll be the day that I die" . Buddy Holly was an inspiration to a lot of bands and to Don himself. Good for you to have relisned to the song and check out the lyrics . You are my favorite reaction person on youtube your honest opinions are truly what keeps me watching. God bless
Thank you. This song deserves a real close look. Again, thank you!
Parts of the song are based on his personal experiences. For example, the line about bad news on the doorstep, comes from the fact that Don was a paperboy in high school, around the time The Day the Music Died. It could be perceived as experiencing most of the main artists and the effect they made in music from the point of view of a songwriter from 1959 to 1972 when the song came out.
what a great song to react to...I love this song...one of my all time favs
Awesome song with lots of hidden references. A fun song you should check out is Arlo Guthrie...Alices Restaurant. It’s a story you would dig! Promise!
this was my era, when I first discovered there was FM on the radio. I will probably be able to sing along with this til me end. Song like this are why the 60's-80's say they had the best music. We grew up on the older that our parents listened to, but this was a whole new genre.
Absolutely! I remember listening to this album on our console hi-fi stereo.
It is a seminal piece. Extraordinarily well received and popular. Very touching.
I had the pleasure of hearing him sing it live at a free Billy Joel concert in Central Park. It was in T.V. but it was great all the same.
Love your reaction it's so real. Please carry on the good work and listen to Vincent one of the most beautiful songs ever written!
The first time I heard this song was in school, when I was 15. A substitute teacher didn’t know what to do in the lesson so he put in a video cassette taped from TV music documentary about “old
music” (according to us). This song stuck in my mind among all the 80s pop I was surrounded by, and is still my best song ever!
Look at the soul on your bright brother! you make me cry.
I agree with you sir. One of the best songs ever written. Regards from Bob in Canada
My older sister bought this album when it came out. It seems like I've heard this song my whole life. It's definitely one of my all-time favorite songs.
ItsallGood Same! I used to steal the American Pie album from my older sisters‘ room and play it for hours, laying on my bed awash in my tweenage angst. Vincent was my absolute favorite.
Big JB awesome blessings🙏🏼
Imagine a world without music.....it brings so much to our lives. It would be terrible...thankfully we still have music in our lives
This is the classic example of the song that whenever you hear it you have to listen to the whole thing no matter what else is going on. They even made a commercial that played off that, I think it was a Pepsi commercial.
This song is so iconic. It's kind of in a class by itself. Another long story song you should check out. It's a Thanksgiving tradition on a lot of stations,atleast it used to be."Alice's Restaurant " by Arlo Guthrie
this song is about loss of an era.. the passing of a time meaningful in your heart and a whole nation
James, hats off to you for going back and hearing this again, in a way that was mu h more meaningful to you. When asked to explain the lyrics, Don McLean has generally declined stating that it means what it means to the listener. While the allusions seem to be fairly clear, Bob Dylan, Janis Joplin, Kent State (possibly), the Beetles, etc...,to me this song evoke the loss of innocence and hope resulting from major events that my generation experienced. Most people know about the events that happened in the past such as the assignation's of John F Kennedy, Martin Luther King, Robert Kennedy, the Kent State Massacre, the deaths of Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin, and Jim Morrison, etc...These are events that people my age experienced in real time. I remember exactly where I was and the circumstances when I learned about the assassination's and the other events that sobered us up and, in my case, quenched many of my hopes. So to me, this song ids a eulogy for the hopes of my generation.
Every line is about the people at that time!
My memory of this song.. I was a kid of 9 or 10, and my older brother came into my room one morning and woke me saying 'Pete Duel killed himself'. Pete Duel was an actor on the T.V. show 'Alias Smith & Jones', a western series that was on in the late 70's. Well, I was madly in love with Pete Duel, and my jerk brother knew that, so he delighted in waking me to tell me of his death. I cried and called him a liar..but then later I saw the news, and found it was true. I spent the rest of the day standing in my bedroom window sobbing, and playing American Pie on the record player.. lol
One the greatest songs ever written, lyrics are incredible
So much history in this song...
Vincent! Vincent! Vincent! One of the saddest and most beautiful songs ever written.
Great review. As kids we could never figure out what this song meant. Drove us crazy.
My favorite of all time!
The song is about the plane crash killed Buddy Holly, The Big Bopper, Ritchie Valens, and J.P. Richardson. Waylon Jennings was supposed to be on the flight, but gave his seat to J.P.
You might enjoy their music...Buddy Holly's "Peggy Sue" and Ritchie Valans' "La Bamba" are classics.
Here's a video I just found, gives a bit more of the story. Two movies were made about these musicians: "The Buddy Holly Story" and "La Bamba".
czcams.com/video/r9M6u7-9yNE/video.html