So This is Basically RWBY Reaction
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 08. 2024
- The Grizzled Geek reacts to RWBY takes a look at the loved/hated RWBY critique from Jello Apocalypse.
#RWBY #RWBYReaction #JelloApocalypse
Please check out the original and give Jello some love:
• So This is Basically RWBY
Shane's channel: / @g2_shane
Watch all of RWBY Here: roosterteeth.c...
The Grizzled Warmaster: / @thegrizzledwarmaster6921
The Grizzled Geek on Patreon: / thegrizzledgeek
Please use our Amazon Affiliate link: amzn.to/2hYws98
For great Grizzled Geek Merch check out our store:
teespring.com/...
Anything you by within 24 hours, not just the item we link to, helps the Grizzled Geek.* Additionally, anything you put into your cart within 24 hours of clicking the link, and then purchase within the next couple of months will also help.
This reaction video is not endorsed by Rooster Teeth in any way. Views, opinions, thoughts are all our own. Rooster Teeth and RWBY are trade names or registered trademarks of Rooster Teeth Productions, LLC. © Rooster Teeth Productions, LLC.
* We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
This guy's Qrow and Ruby impressions really are impressive.
I know! I swear I thought that was Vic at first.
@Christoper Putt seriously. I agree
I miss Ruby's voice from the first few episodes from Volume 1.
@@TheGrizzledGeek That guy also voiced ruby n the narrator. In other words he was voicing for 3 characters for 1 video
@Christoper Putt Not really, considering how the company is going through.
Isn't it beautiful when a group of fans can accept criticism of the show they like and respectfully disagree without sounding like a crybaby.
Right?
Yup.
This is the way.
I do enjoy 'RWBY Chibi' more than the original nowadays.
I didn't really like chibi.
I like chibi as a palate cleanser after the regular show breaks your heart.
I agree! They are just short and cute and good fun. Rwby is good too but I think for different reasons. You definitely have to put yourself into rwby ready mindset now because of how heavy it's getting. Not that it's bad, just that you're not always ready for the heat, you know?
Yeah, it's like short comics I usually read in a newspaper
It's seems most of us enjoy 'RWBY Chibi'. It's the super bestie better than the restie!
I'm a rwby fan but even i admit this is sadly true
without monty rwby is bad
@@lfz4611 true
@@lfz4611 Bad is a very subjective term. I disagree that RWBY is bad without Monty, but it does lack the focus he had. While 4 and 5 were fairly meandering, there was some good stuff there. Just not enough to justify two different volumes.
I want to see Monty style fights with the current animation quality! They wouldn't even have to have a story then. ;-)
@@TheGrizzledGeek true the fights would be looking like tekken cinematic cutscenes i mean have you seen heiachi vs akuma sorry i butcher the name but if you played tekken 7 you whould know what i mean
It was great and so accurate on everything, from the overabundance of underdeveloped characters in the earlier seasons, to ozpin being not really being that morally grey, to the whole ship pandering with bumbebee
What people don’t seem to realize is the guy seems to be a fan of RWBY as well, but can recognize that it has a lot of issues around its writing. It’s like SAO. You won’t find anyone reasonable who won’t admit that it has issues.
@@goblinsgambits196 This. Absolutely this. Especially with SAO reference. Lol. ESPECIALLY
Well, no series, movie or game today is without some issues. But we still enjoy them nonetheless......
@@TheZero1312 Well yes but no. A series that is followed by thousand usually either get better each season because it's actually listening to criticisms around the plot or fall fast because it have no ideas what to do after and then just decide to give up to pandering. Many, many, of the movies and games can only be done right once, after that, it can't be modified to correct mistakes that are inside them. Series have the possibilities to better themselves each new season.
Which RWBY prove being unable to
And sadly, RWBY isn't the only series that is plagued by this.
I hope RWBY stays "popular enough" until the story is concluded.
NO RubY You don't UndErStaND I turn Into a B1RD Ruby I TURN INTO A B1RD
:Woah thanks for the likes
Uncle Croww I don't.. I don't... why is this baaad!
WHAT DO YOU DO WITH A DrUnKeN SAiloR EaRLy in THE MorNiNg
A BUUUUUURDDDD
@@theblazingace3537 Uncle Qrow, please stop!
WHY IS MY NAME SpeLLed WiTh A Q
These people have the most reasonable response to this video that I've seen so far--and that includes myself! Bah! Where is the overreaction? Where is the bitter sensitvity!? Where Is The Cranky Defensiveness?!? WHY CANT I TURN INTO AN EMO BURD LIKE MY HERO....WHYYYYY?!?!?!?!?!?!?
Yang + Blake = Weiss + Torchwick's Ghost
No sane straight man would refuse to hookup with Torchwick's Ghost.
Equally undeveloped, equally nonsensical, and equally stupid.
Rwby fans are so salty about this parody they're in ARMs against It
@old channel most of the hate is on Twitter I think and it's mostly from the bumblebee fans trying to defend the ship they forced down everyone's throat.
@old channel agreed. I was actually pro for the ship seemed like a nice ship they could build over time and have conflict with on the path as well.
Oh well good things tend to get ruined easily.
Wait really? I’ve only seen positive feedback from the RWBY fandom. Then again, I’m not really that connected with the rest of the fandom
The guy recently did one on trails of cold steel and as a huge fan of trails i found it funny as well as the got some actors from the game to reprise there roles as well it was sponsored by the devs...Some people just see parody as hate thats the snowflake world we live in
Oops!
I mean if you introduce three separate soft magic systems, dust, semblance and actual magic and it takes four to seven volumes for you to actually define the difference that's something of a failure right there. That there is an explanation becomes a lot less important over how long it took to actually give it.
Is it really 3 soft magic systems applied in this fictional setting?
I thought Dust would be the hard-magic system, a system that requires a power source to cast magic. That along with Semblance.
@@mystery8820 No. A hard magic system isn't one with limits, it's one that's thoroughly defined. You know precisely what it can do and what it can't.
In the opening episode we are treated to a display of semblance, of dust, and (though we didn't know it) of magic. They were all completely indistinguishable from one another.
The only hard things we got about dust was that it is generally elemental power and it has a concrete power supply. Otherwise it kinda just did whatever in any given situation.
I love seeing people react to that Yang's arm part
Did anyone catch that he called the Faunis the Laguz from fire emblem? i keep feeling like that joke keeps flying under everyones radar
I heard the Laguz, I just didn't know what it was from.
I don't know anything about Fire Emblem, so I had no idea what the word meant.
G2 Shane laguz are a race who can transform into animals. Basically like fanus plus the transformation ability.
HE'S RIGHT. When will Weiss hook up with Torchwick's ghost?? WHEN?!
My only ship!
Qrow and Ruby = Rick and Morty
Except Qrow actually cares.
@@theblasblas but Rick Also Cares when He's Desperate
Jello has watched RWBY all the way through at least twice. Also, the art was done by @spectralfusion.
I mean I think the problem he's pointing out is that the show has semblances, magic and dust, which all do fantastical things but they never actually explain what differentiates them. A semblance can generate fire, dust can generate fire. That's perfectly normal. But magic generates fire and that's out of this world.
Yo I'm gonna be real i thought that was actually vic for a sec
This dude should be interested in voice acting. He is freakin genius. I also thought that its Vic for a moment.
@@mordredvonumbra154 the guy is actually an actual voice actor.
@@AngelineL. Good. World is not missing out.
You guys get it!
Also, I forgot about the VA for Qrow in this. They should have tapped him to do Qrow's new VA. The current one has been hard on the ears.
I agree 100%! Every time someones says I can't tell the difference, I'm like are you even listening to the same show I am? I'm looking at you Kirsten!
@@TheGrizzledGeek lol, I'm hip!
IKR, Jello should replace Jason Liebrecht, who replace Vic Mognogna due to KickVic.
Jello should be the official Qrow voice.
I kinda see Dusts and Semblances as Fate’s magecraft. While Magic is True Magic.
Magecraft is a science, it still has rules and limitations that to someone well versed in it, are clearly defined.
True Magic on the other hand is essentially; with enough power, you are god. Rules don’t exist for True Magic.
Usual difference between magecraft and science is really well explained in ancient magus bride. Good watch.
Magecraft at it's core is still magic though and it is nothing short of insulting to someone's intelligence to say it isn't magic just because this special true magic is more omnipotent.
Same thing goes with the semblances/dust/aura in RWBY compared to the original/maiden magic. In both RWBY and Fate the writer's just want to make themselves look more clever than they actually are by being smartasses in ways that make people think they are being profound.
i was thinking more on the side of... a different school of magic. i mean "Science" is... not really correct when you realize its a literal superpower FUELED BY THE PERSON'S OWN SOUL. you don't get more "magic" than that.
"So what? Tomaeto, tomahto!"
"More like tomaeto...toNUCLEAR WARHEAD"
So... one is a hard magic system and the other is a soft magic system? Unfortunately, semblances are so diverse in their range that both magic and semblances are soft magic systems... (hard magic systems have rigid rule sets, soft magic systems don’t)
5:25. Geez that's a theory Neo and Roman being Ruby's real parents.
When I first started RWBY I watched it for the comedy, voice acting, memorable quotes and fighting. Starting season 4 it lost all but the fighting. I get the story became more serious but it just got dull for me. Add the pandering wokeness I just left.
I completely understand that sentiment. I think if you want to love a show and characters resonate with you then you are more likely to look past what others can't ignore. I think it's silly for people to assume that RWBY is perfect and everyone needs to love it. We all got our preferences and tastes. Sometimes things just stop tickling our fancy and we got to just jump off the fandom train. I'm still riding the fandom train at full speed ahead but I can see why others would lose interest or just not even want to start to begin with.
@@windekresstadrd you shouldn't when they don't even pay their employees overtime. If you buy merch anything I suggest you completely stop so you don't financially support these scumbags.
Mario Badia I get where you’re coming from, but remember, art =/= artist
@@parkerlund7531 exactly what I think when people mention something like this. One of the best examples I can think of is Johnny depp's acting in the first pirates of the caribean movie. Everyone can agree it was spot on, some of the best acting I've ever seen, but Johnny depp is... not the greatest person.
So what is supposed to be the actual downside of being able to turn into a bird again?
I actaully stopped watching RWBY mainly cause the story got bland and the writing almost feels drawn out when they could do soooooooooooooooooo much
one of the reasons I lost hope in season 4 final fight, Mercury the guy who fights on a daily basis, throws a punch, stands there and allows ruby to heat butt him...and he goes down.....i would have accepted him throwing a kick, her doding and headbutting his groin....atleast going down after a hit like that would make sense
i've been feeling less and less of an urge to watch with each season until the only reason i was watching volume 6 was weiss and qrow. then they fired vic, which was half of the reason i loved qrow, he brought so much to the character with his acting. no offense to weiss, but as much as i love, her, she hasn't been enough to get me to watch any of volume 7. kinda hoping once rt goes under, the animation team behind land of the lustrous get rights to remake it.
Volume 5 sucked, I can agree with y’all about that, volume 6 was great at start them they messed up the end, but volume 7 has been regarded as the best in the series so far, and I have to agree, the fights are actually shot well, characters don’t talk much during them, the music fits, and the actual dialogue of the episodes is well written
@@DelthinTheRanger
Except for Ironwood... he was a horrible dictator. And deserving of his eventual downfall.
@@mystery8820 Lies, RWBY are hypocrites and the writers want to give them the easy way because they feel like doing the right thing and say pretty words but they refuse to make the tough decisions (people die in wars, that’s unavoidable) and yet the shows refuses to call them out and make them face the consequences of their actions. Anytime someone does call them out the show makes them evil, says their wrong, makes them apologize,etc. They are not thinking like huntresses.
I'm more in the Camp Camp camp myself.
could you react to the mark zhang rwby fanmade oc trailers, theyre very very very good.
We will have to check them out.
@@TheGrizzledGeek awesome, ty
I feel like Rwby's villains should be more developed because it's been years and I still know jack shit about most of them
Ironwood is officially worse than Mommy Salami.
Probably not the best example, but remember when Naruto would have episodes that followed other teams? Some of that would be nice. As long as CRWBY gets to go past their annual October release and have more time to work the knots out.
But none of those things are likely to happen.
WhY is My naMe sPELled WiTH a *Q*
no the guy is right the show never tell whats the difference with magic and dust soo dust ar not magic
Only thing that gets me is what he says about magic.
Being that he drew Jinn and Salem it's obvious he knows the story and how Semblence/Dust/Magic are all connected.
I can only surmise that it's a joke reflective on the actual plot of the starting volumes where no one but Ozpin/Salem/Cinder are actually aware of proper magic (being that Ozpin has been the gatekeeper of all information if you think about it over the eras) so everyone else only knows that there has been a '"Semblence" of magic' from time immemorial.
So come the bomb drop that proper magic is revealed with characters going "Real magic, no way!?" It's humorous that it's a shock despite the cosmic powers everyone in this universe already posses that it's crazy to them for some reason.
While I believe there has been a lot of making shit up as they go along; I do love how we're lead on to believe everything due to Ozpin's control, only for everything to unravel over time as we are brought into his secret peacekeeping and eventually the rug that even Qrow wasn't aware he was standing on is pulled out from under him by Jinn.
I have gripes about the rediculousness of Ozpin apparently having no plan despite his age and accomplishments.
But otherwise I'm invested to see where this is all going and I do like me my fighting scenes.
What do ypu think about the fact that quarter of FNDM decided to brand Ozpin as evil for the sake of plot just because. Also i had my theory on what he was doing but people usually dismiss it so i will not bother.
@@mordredvonumbra154 I don't follow the FNDM so I wouldn't know.
I just see him as trying to create an "ignoerence is bliss" world so there aren't more people seeking Salem for power and inevitably finding the relics in another war.
Seeing as she's unkillable I can only surmise the plan is and always has been to simply "pluck the weeds" whenever Salem gets ahold of people and settle the world down in the aftermath, but for some reason; nope, he can't even think of that and so locks himself away in the back of Oscar's mind.
It's a shame he couldn't have such an idea and be it the basis of his peacekeeping efforts with Qrow, but I understand that perhaps knowing your enemy is immortal could tempt you to change sides even if containment and repolsion was a solid plan due to the lifetime dedication it would require.
@@Lupirio23 The thing is that everyone seems to ignore that gods will return and judge humanity when all relics gather together. I would plan to do just that whenever i would achieve 3 or 2 generations of goodness. Not the best plan but if you know you cant kill Salem then it seems like a doable thing. Also plot will make people who are good guys bad for sake of showin how team RWBYJNR are the only really good guys which is a bad thing plotwise but fandomtics (dad joke) will shoot you down if you critize anything. This type of behaviour didnt work so well for GOT. We shall see what it will do for RWBY.
@@mordredvonumbra154 Considering Ozpin is just 1 man cursed with all truth, if he was the King of Vale during the war then I think he's reformed peace repeatedly over the eras. Trying to tame the world is impossible due to human nature seeing even back in Maria's time Salem had henchmen as well as just criminals including the White Fang and Muffet's spider gang. Knowing that the gods COULD judge to just wipe existence for an unknown amount of variables is too great to risk with Salem.
Thus Ozpin has resided to just manage the world as best he can with the only price being incomplete.
I completely understand his methods if I'm correct but his latest decisions I feel do not fit.
@@Lupirio23 Stalling forever seemed like what he was doing and in the end it might be what kept world going. While he made mistakes, lied often and kept plenty of secrets i believe he is judged way too harshly. What was the decision he made that seemed to not fit. Not attacking, just seeking input. What seemed weird to me for example is that while i understand why he didnt unmask lionheart to the public and i would do the same his rationale was partly wrong. How he deserved to be remembered doesnt matter even remotely as much as keeping Lionhearts image intact. If heroes and defenders of the world join forces with evil out of fear, what hope do we have left. I believe they wanted to paint him as very suspicious before big reveal. Also, why not tell that relic pulls grimm to it. If crew is aware of the danger they can work more efficiently to defend themselves. It seemed like making Oz suspicious by any means necessary because..... i dont know why. His decision to lie about amount of questions you can still ask can be understandble even if i have ambiguous opinion on the matter.
Hope you guys watch and react more to these 'This is Basically...' video's by JelloApocalypse
This video just popped up randomly. It seems the author's predictions for Neo has finally come true. Sad...
please try some of jello apocalypse's other "so this is basically..." they are really fun to watch there's even one about the cartoon star vs the forces of evil and one about kingdom hearts game there's also a pokemone game one
I want to check out his My Hero Academia one (because we watch that)
The Grizzled Geek
The first one I saw was So This is Basically Fire Emblem. It’s hilarious.
*"WHY IS MY NAME SPELLED WITH A Q?!"*
The dust they stole in the first two volumes was used to blow up the trains at the end of the volume 2
All of it though? It seemed like there was way more than needed to blow up a wall or four, I'd say the dock full could be used for the train but then you have the stores and other docks, I mean did you see Roman's Map of thefts? There would be 4 trains worth at least.
I was under the impression they used it to blow up the mountain and wake up the dragon grimm. I thought that was basically what was considered canon since that's the reason that I hear most often.
(I know, I know, I'm ten months late but shut up)
As it turns out, this is actually more 'accepted fanon' than canon. Nowhere in the actual show or official supplementary materials (to my knowledge anyway) is it explicitly stated or even implied that the stolen dust was used to create the explosives packed into the train cars.
Mommy salami
Anyone else want to watch that song I’m a bird mf I’m a bird?
Looking back on this video because it came up in recommended for some reason.
Thanks to V7 & V8, V4 & V5 aren't looking as bad as I remember.
Extreme spoilers.
Magic is a gift from the God of Darkness
Semblances are supernatural abilities inherent to the unique soul they come from
Dust is the remainder of what was once magic using humans.
Please watch Jello's So this is basically the Legend of Zelda the one about Kingdom Hearts, those were also hilarious as hell.
HAHAHAA YESSSSSSSS
Man I love watching Jello's video again, but this time with a laugh track and not on his channel so he doesn't get the view.
Ummmmm actually dust is a remnant of magic
Is this confirmed?
I'm pretty sure that's just a theory, an awesome, but still just theory.
From what I gather of Jinn's story; God of Darkness breaking the moon, turned the chunks that landed on Remnant into dust, being that magic was his gift to humans.
It's unfortunate you don't get to see the chunks during that scene to be sure.
@@Lupirio23 it could be remains of all the people that died during god nuking.
@@mordredvonumbra154 Perhaps, I don't think so myself, but if it is; that's a lil creepy.
That intro... uh, could use some work. Pretty cropped out on the text.
Yeah, Shane usually edits these RWBY videos, but we were in a hurry to get this one out and I forgot to resize the intro. This one is on me.
The Grizzled Geek Ah, I see. No problemo, haha.
@@TheGrizzledGeek Finally something that isn't my fault. Time to start selling Parkas in hell.
I actually like 6, 7 and 8 so far but even though I am a RWBY Fan, I agree with the points in the Video. 4 and 5 were real garbage. But 6 with Maria and Winter in Volume 7 kinda saved it for me
Yeah, this guy gets a lot wrong, but so does HISHE and Honest Trailers. Doesn't mean it can't be funny and taken as a lighthearted romp. I don't look too parody videos for an honest review of a series or movie.
Honest Trailers succeeds at actually being satire because they are amping up or ridiculing things that are *truthful* about what happens in the movies they are satirizing. That's where they succeed and this video fails.
Doug Jankowski What did he get wrong?
@@charlietango261
Well, that'll the thing. He doesn't really say a lot of things that are inaccurate unless you count his opinions, which will obviously vary from person to person. So saying he gets a lot long is just you being biased as in reality you guys just have different opinions, which is fine.
@@coranbaker6401 I've detailed exactly the multiple items he gets wrong in the video in other responses. These aren't matters of artistic opinion or judgement, they are things that are flat out, provably incorrect
@@charlietango261
Ah, would you mind explaining them then? Cause I have no idea what they are. Unless you mean that one thing about the dust stealing.
What’s the point of the reaction video if you can’t freaking hear what they’re reacting to
The person watch this but havent watch the rwby series thinks that the bird guy are insane with the bird problem
I still don't get the Yang x Blake criticism. Didn't seem like that at all do me- does _handholding_ really act as a sign of true love?
...maybe to _some people_ lol...
ok
Shippers can get pretty crazy.
@@nathanieldardar4295 Yeah, and then all the people reviewing RWBY believed the shippers. Starting a downward spiral
Blake is a cardboard cutout of a character. Her relationship with Adam was retconned.
I was wondering if he even watched v6. There was almost no mention of it. (other than the Salem thing.) Though it was inaccurate in places, (I like to say extensive creative liberty was taken for the sake of hilarity) It was quite funny! Enjoyed your reaction as well! It too, had a similar level of ............. hilarity! (my word for today) ;)
I've seen several comments wondering the same thing. Jello posted a tweet a couple days after he made this video stating how surprised he was that volume 6 was good.
@@TheSecretLover In my pespective volume 6 had many hype moments, BUT most of them were LTBG fanservice, inspirational and repetitive quotes that sounded good and some questionable choices for our heroes "developments"
@@yiledute Personally, I agree. I meant to simply post Jello's opinion as proof he watched volume 6. I'm just glad that it answered the only questions that kept me watching: what was the deal with Salem and Ozpin and Ruby's eyes.
At the end of the in video add he says he had to cut a lot of jokes so maybe he thought his V6 jokes weren’t as funny as his Qrow jokes.
@@dizzyizzy7403 Perhaps.
The guy at the front on the right looks like a fat Vladimir Putin. :P
It's a fun video, it gave me a hearty chuckle, but I 100% get why it rubs some people the wrong way - after so many people making disingenuous and deliberately misleading slam pieces about the show (often tied closely with "Miles & Kerry are riding on their dead friend's legacy and have no talent themselves" bullshit), of course people are going to be oversensitive.
Basically, RWBY fans would be a lot better at taking a joke if people didn't make a cottage industry out of listing reasons why, if you enjoy RWBY, you're *wrong* and *stupid* .
Sounds like the Internet is too tough for them cause this kind of thing goes for EVERY fandom. Maybe they should try elementary schools.
@@goblinsgambits196 ah yes, victim blaming, because how dare anyone call out the assholes and expect them to act like human beings
M and K are seriously shit teir writers. The writing is so full of holes, undeveloped carboard cutout characters with zero development and retcones that is it makes SAO blush. Hell the racism against the fanaus is nearly nonexistent since they only show it once( rabbit girl doesn't count cardin is a asshole to pretty much anyone and Jaune worse even though he's human). Also
@@mariobadia4553 here we go again. can you even use grammar?
@@S0LAVELLANHELL so instead of addressing my facts you go after my grammer? Wow. Kinda pathetic.
roasted
Those laugh sound so fake
I thought the qrow stuff was funny and his impressions were fantastic (and proof that Vic isn't the gem in the rough everyone thinks he is) but he seemed like he watched the show once through and didn't put much thought into it. He didn't seem to grasp that Salem was playing a chess game that started in v1, that she was thinking 20 moves ahead and building panic that started with the dust robberies that were meant to force the city into disarray and hopelessness. Or that it was used to blow up the trains at the end of v2. Like he makes fun of the fact that they had a small budget, then complains about the animation like... you know why the animation isn't perfect, you're just being a douche now. And did he watch v6 at all? They basically explained what the difference between magic and semblances were in one scene in 6x3... the power man now had was simply a SEMBLANCE of what they once were. Semblances are magic, but not enough to be considered magic, in the same way a AA battery charges stuff, but isn't enough to be considered a generator. Most of it just seemed like a culmination of collecting fandom complaints rather than genuine complaints.
But a battery stores energy, while a generator, as the name says it, generates energy. They are fundamentally different and we can tell specifically how to differentiate between one and another. That is not the case here, just like a drop of water is still water compared to a sea, semblances must also be magic even if they are just a fraction of what it used to be, and yet the show tells us that they are different, but never why or how.
@@yiledute on the contrary. both a battery and a generator supply power, but you can't run a whole house on a AA battery.
@@HaughtBreakerNic that is what I said, both can supply and store energy, but the battery can't generate energy, a generator does. They are very different. It's like comparing a cartridge with a gun, both gave bullets but the gun can also shoot them, very different objects.
@@yiledute that's not a sensible comparison at all but ok. I feel like you're a really big fan of this dude and just need everyone else to be in agreement.
@@HaughtBreakerNic what are you talking about? since when this had anything to do with being a fan or someone? this is the first video I've seen from this channel.
All I'm trying to convey is that the relation between semblance and magic in the show of RWBY is by no means similar to the relation between a battery and a generator
Why is everyone reacting to this? They don't recommend it because it's funny but to try and make you join their side and stop watching the show
Wtf are you talking about
I disagree! I think its healthy to look at other sides of an arguement. It allows you to have a well formed opinion because other people help you see things you might not otherwise see or notice! His opinion might be different from ours but I think there are a couple valid points and it's a good laugh. I dont think the point is to make people not watch it. Its satire which is meant to over exaggerate problems and have a good laugh at those faults. Rwby isn't perfect but despite that we will keep watching. It's not because or how perfect of a show it is, it's because of our relationship and ties to the story and characters. One person on the internet (no matter how good at voice acting or art they are) is not going to convince me to not watch RWBY lol I think it's good for reactors to see the other side of the coin. It's good to laugh at yourself.
@@windekresstadrd
100% agree with you! Love the show and I love this video. Some ppl completely forget that satire exists.
Mew, your way of thinking is horribly skewed.
To add on the what Kira and Blarf said, Jello never really explicitly states to stop watching RWBY. The most he says is to check out RWBY Chibi, the series that arguably does use the characters better. And he's had to have watched the series himself to make a review of it. He's even stated that he really liked Volume 6 and was curious how Volume 7 would be.
At the end of the day, the important part of any show or series is to be able to step back from it and see that it's not perfect and people are going to point it out. Some people may do it out of malice, but some do it to bring those issues up so they get potentially fixed later on. We have to be able to understand that just because we like something doesn't make it perfect. I really love the series D.Gray-Man but holy hell does it have a ton of problems, and people are more than willing to point them out. That's just how things go.
@@Unyubaby
100% agree with. I forgot to mention the V6 thing so I thank you for bringing it up.
I'm really disappointed that you gave this guy even one more view.
Really.
Really.
Disappointed.
If people are going to do criticism or satire, at least do honest criticism and satire. He may have watched the show, but a number of the points he made were mean-spirited, misdirected, or just flat out wrong (like the "two season stealing Dust and they never did anything with that plot" thing. Yeah, they did. Explicitly. ) If you're going to criticize or satirize something, then at least do it the favor of being intellectually honest.
How many times we're you dropped on your head as a child?
@@Hyperiem Really? So you don't consider "clips and clops so much it resembles a horse and lip flaps that look like they were done by a fish on a wall" to be insulting and hurtful, as well as provably false, to not be mean-spirited? Were I an animator who worked extremely hard for long hours etc. on something like this, I'd find it pretty damn hurtful. Are there elements of satire in this? Sure. And a few of them are even funny. But when you put an emphasis on something like the Dust plot and then get the facts about it completely wrong, it's not satire. It's ignorance, or malice. We are told by cinder that they are going to move the dust out of the warehouse. We then SEE the dust crates from the warehouse being loaded into the train cars when Ruby is being dragged to Torchwick and we SEE the crates surrounding the bombs in the train cars. For all the bitching that is done about "show, don't tell", this is something that was BOTH and yet this video focuses on that and completely gets it wrong. In addition, we are explicitly told that Faunus have one animal feature. So it explains exactly why not all of them have tails, or why some have four ears, which this video treats as some sort of flaw in the show or that an explanation for this is missing when it is explicitly explained!
As to the "introduces a bunch of characters and then never develops any of them". The vast majority of those characters are introduced in a tournament arc as opponents or combatants. How many of the students in Class 1-B of My Hero Academia (as an example) do we have deep backgrounds on? Or the villains mooks (out side of the few primary antagonists) when the villains attack UA Or some of the other students in the Training Camp arc of Food Wars (as another example). We see a lot of other students competing in those events, but we don't get deep background on them, or even on the other residents of Polar Star Dorm other than Soma and Megumi. In MHA, a lot of those Class1-B heroes have pretty interesting looks and neat powers like the tournament arc characters in RWBY do, but we're not clamoring for deep dives into hyperdeveloping those characters. It's an unreasonable criticism.
And right after the video complains about not developing characters, it takes shots at V4 and V5 as complete garbage, despite the fact that those volumes are extensively about developing characters, especially our primary protagonists and a number of the primary side characters like Qrow, Ren, and Nora, as well as the villains.
And on the whole Semblances/Dust/Magic issue; we are shown and told in-universe that Semblances and the effects of Dust usage are pretty well understood as part of the natural order of things, but that Magic is shown through the characters' actions and reactions to its existence as being something exceptionally outside of the norm. it's consistent and kept consistent there.
And I'm not even going to need to address the video's comment about the Blake and Yang thing. The reason for the bitching and bias there both in this video and a lot of similar trolling videos is pretty much summed up by the phrase " blatantly obvious homophobia", so the less said about that the better.
The show is not without flaws, and not without some problems. Yes, it has had some stumbles at points, but it has definitely (as shown by V6) recovered from those stumbles in a major way. It's gone back to elements that made it originally successful in the early volumes and that has aided that recovery extensively. If you want to criticize it, then criticize honestly. If you're going to satirize, satirize things that are actual flaws, vices, or issues. Don't create ones that aren't there.
Grow up
Charlie Tango I had a lot to say about your pretentiousness and how wrong you are, but then I read that you think anyone who doesn’t like bumblebee is homophobic and that just told me the kind of person you are and you wouldn’t care or understand it. Just because someone didn’t see the “development” between Blake and Yang in volume 2 and nothing else, doesn’t mean someone is homophobic. that is faulty logic with zero evidence besides bias and shipping wars. You don’t like my ship, and my Ship are lesbians, you’re homophobic despite the fact that it has nothing to do with the ship being between girls but how badly done it was. But it’s a lesbian ship so you can’t say anything negative about it our you’re homophobic
@@BabyGirlTiny no, my issue is that people are assuming it's a sexual relationship. Love between two people doesn't always mean sexual love. There's a Greek term, agape, that roughly translates as brotherly love. There's zero indication that the love between Blake and Yang is sexual, yet that's what a lot of people assume and react negatively, driven primarily by homophobia, when it may not be the case at all.
Mommy salami
In the Uzi Yakusi
The animation is pretty shaky mistakey