Age Of Samurai: Battle For Japan - Netflix Review Episode 1

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 03. 2021
  • Here is a full review of the first episode of Age of Samurai: Battle For Japan, which was recently published on Netflix. Is it historically accurate? Good? Bad? Let's find out.
    Link to the shogunate channel / @theshogunate
    Samurai were the military nobility and officer caste of medieval and early-modern Japan.
    In Japanese, they are usually referred to as bushi or buke.
    By the end of the 12th century, samurai became almost entirely synonymous with bushi, and the word was closely associated with the middle and upper echelons of the warrior class. The samurai were usually associated with a clan and their lord, and were trained as officers in military tactics and grand strategy. While the samurai numbered less than 10% of then Japan's population, their teachings can still be found today in both everyday life and in modern Japanese martial arts.
    As aristocrats for centuries, samurai developed their own cultures that influenced Japanese culture as a whole. The culture associated with the samurai such as the tea ceremony, monochrome ink painting, rock gardens and poetry were adopted by warrior patrons throughout the centuries 1200-1600. These practices were adapted from the Chinese arts.
    In general, samurai, aristocrats, and priests had a very high literacy rate in kanji. Recent studies have shown that literacy in kanji among other groups in society was somewhat higher than previously understood.
    Some samurai had buke bunko, or "warrior library", a personal library that held texts on strategy, the science of warfare, and other documents that would have proved useful during the warring era of feudal Japan. One such library held 20,000 volumes. The upper class had Kuge bunko, or "family libraries", that held classics, Buddhist sacred texts, family histories, as well as genealogical records.
    A samurai was usually named by combining one kanji from his father or grandfather and one new kanji. Samurai normally used only a small part of their total name.
    Follow me on my social networks:
    / themetatron
    Check out my Metatron merch online shop!
    teespring.com/shop/metatron-c...
    / metatron_youtube
    Metatron-153...
    / puremetatron
    / realmetatron
    Royalty free music by Epidemic Sound:
    intro ES_Knights Templar 1 - Johannes Bornlöf
    intro 2 ES_Medieval Adventure 01 - Johannes Bornlöf
    outro ES_Knights Templar 2 - Johannes Bornlöf
    Check out my GF"s Channel:
    / crissangellover56
    Check out my friend Salvo's channel
    / @littlesalvo000
    #Metatron #Samurai #Netflix

Komentáře • 1,3K

  • @spencerday2937
    @spencerday2937 Před 3 lety +730

    Metatron: *puts helmet on*
    Audience: "I've never seen this man before in my life"

  • @StinkyGringo
    @StinkyGringo Před 3 lety +785

    I wonder if a hundred years from now "documentaries" will show U.S. ww2 soldiers all running into battle with their trusty 1911 as if it was their main weapon lol

    • @rhzyo
      @rhzyo Před 3 lety +4

      No they won't. Why would they :/

    • @CDSAfghan
      @CDSAfghan Před 3 lety +195

      Hilarious, but mostly likely every soldier will look like the Rock, hip firing 50 cals and dual wielding bazookas.

    • @Red-S-267
      @Red-S-267 Před 3 lety +87

      Ok just so I’m clear this is because the 1911 is like a katana in that it works well but it’s a sidearm/secondary right?

    • @jwe2378
      @jwe2378 Před 3 lety +98

      @@rhzyo Becuase somehow the backup (and ceremonial) weapon has become the main weapon in popular culture.
      The katana for the Samurai replacing the spear(Yari) or any other of the multitude of mainstay weapons for the samurai.
      And The 1911 for the American G.I. Which replaces the Garand or the m1 Carbine
      To the point of his statement, I don’t really think it will happen either, but who knows, dumber things have happened.

    • @rhzyo
      @rhzyo Před 3 lety +3

      @@jwe2378 your talking about an era with out footage or docos already made, ww2 is very well documented. Just seems like a stupid comment/attempt to make a joke to me, it makes no sense at all.

  • @thomaskuang5074
    @thomaskuang5074 Před 3 lety +924

    As soon as I heard them praising the katana, I immediately realize the documentary is a fun-club level production.

    • @HlewagastizHoltijaz
      @HlewagastizHoltijaz Před 3 lety +134

      Same here. Then they went on to say that the Samurai were the best warriors in human history.

    • @valrond
      @valrond Před 3 lety +63

      Another one. Thanks to metatron and shad I knew it was bs. I told my friends I was waiting for metatron review.

    • @bullet4myex187
      @bullet4myex187 Před 3 lety +6

      Same, and I immediately knew he would review it

    • @minhphan7509
      @minhphan7509 Před 3 lety +11

      did they even mentioned the yumi because i skipped to the last episode after that "katana thing" ?

    • @toecutterjenkins
      @toecutterjenkins Před 3 lety +7

      Did Met do the one on rome? I watched a few episodes and the armor and fighting made me cringe.

  • @thedrakken9199
    @thedrakken9199 Před 3 lety +297

    You know it’s bad when metatron is throwing the term "weeaboo" at them.

  • @geluf4000
    @geluf4000 Před 3 lety +625

    Myself, 10 minutes into Battle for Japan: "Can't wait for the history people on youtube tear this series a new one!"

    • @temperededge
      @temperededge Před 3 lety +51

      Right? I was thinking specifically "Metatron's gonna lose his shit over this"

    • @laterreurrouge1917
      @laterreurrouge1917 Před 3 lety +12

      Same here. That was some severely dramatised bullshit.

    • @velveteensallet949
      @velveteensallet949 Před 3 lety +17

      We are long past the point where this group of history enthusiasts are far more credible than any network documentarian.

    • @ZunaZurugi
      @ZunaZurugi Před 3 lety +3

      I didnt even watch it after seeing the Trailer... im not even that much of an History or Japan super fanboy or so... but that was just sooo obviously bad xD

    • @Ninja.Alinja
      @Ninja.Alinja Před 3 lety +2

      I don’t mean to be extra clever, but the trailer did that for me

  • @DavidM_10
    @DavidM_10 Před 3 lety +341

    "[The katana is] widely regarded as the finest sword ever made in world history."
    I immediately thought of you when I heard that line in the show. lol

    • @MetalFreak187
      @MetalFreak187 Před 3 lety +16

      I literally said no it's not, oh here we go

    • @bandit6272
      @bandit6272 Před 3 lety +17

      When I heard that, I rolled my eyes so hard I woke the neighbors up, set off my car alarm, and all the dogs on my street started barking.

    • @Troupe_Master
      @Troupe_Master Před 3 lety +8

      As someone who love Japanese history that shit nearly sent me into a rage. My wife was confused looking at me and i had to explain to her..and her response was well why do they show them all carrying it then? LOL😤

    • @imper_gaming
      @imper_gaming Před 3 lety +12

      If that’s the direct quote from the show, then they’re not wrong. They’re not saying “it is the finest sword,” but “it is regarded as the finest sword.” A lot of misinformed people do believe it’s the greatest sword ever made. However, it seems the show didn’t clarify or correct the misconception, and they also show the katana as the main battlefield weapon, so there’s that...

    • @lumethecrow9808
      @lumethecrow9808 Před 3 lety +2

      I feel like the Longsword would be superior to the Katana, maybe not for slashing, but it's still certainly more useful.

  • @roguegen5536
    @roguegen5536 Před 3 lety +72

    Me: expecting to hear how the show was.
    Metatron: shows up with seppuku kit.
    Well that escalated quickly.

    • @Zraknul
      @Zraknul Před 3 lety +8

      He was doing what we were all thinking.

  • @twooobee6510
    @twooobee6510 Před 3 lety +183

    After how good The Maandolrian was, there is no excuse for a lack of helmets

    • @aaronclemons2287
      @aaronclemons2287 Před 3 lety +17

      The Mandalorian proves to everyone how to provide a great adaptation by telling a story in a believable way.

    • @lumethecrow9808
      @lumethecrow9808 Před 3 lety +4

      Maandolrian.

    • @TrueMentorGuidingMoonlight
      @TrueMentorGuidingMoonlight Před 3 lety +18

      I remember when Karl Urban played as Judge Dredd and never once took off his helmet. Since only the lower half of his face was visible, I find his performance to be like the predecessor to Pedro Pascal’s performance of covering the entire face. Really goes to show the amount of talent actors can have when they can still convey emotion even without showing their faces.

    • @Dowlphin
      @Dowlphin Před 9 měsíci

      @@lumethecrow9808 Its Marnoldarian.

  • @TheShogunate
    @TheShogunate Před 3 lety +85

    Thank you so much for the shout out!!!

    • @MastemaJack
      @MastemaJack Před 3 lety +6

      10 minutes into watching Age of the Samurai I couldn't wait to see the videos The Shogunate and the Metatron make.

    • @sleepingturtle32
      @sleepingturtle32 Před 2 lety +2

      @@MastemaJack same

  • @LordBilliam
    @LordBilliam Před 3 lety +715

    I stopped watching the "documentary" as soon as they said the katana was the greatest sword of all time...

    • @lionheart6754
      @lionheart6754 Před 3 lety +49

      Totally agree it annoyed me

    • @gaspanifrinzi3318
      @gaspanifrinzi3318 Před 3 lety +36

      Same here. The exact same moment...

    • @TheLawDawg
      @TheLawDawg Před 3 lety +103

      About two seconds later they said that Samurai were by far the greatest warriors of all time. I only heard that because I was too busy vomiting at the first statement to turn it off before hearing the second.

    • @lionheart6754
      @lionheart6754 Před 3 lety +19

      @@TheLawDawg agree that annoyed me as well so many stereotypes in this series

    • @MeisterZtirom
      @MeisterZtirom Před 3 lety +36

      Its generally wrong to say these were the best. Because its individual and swords its to each his own, some are better for certain tasks than others but none is really the best

  • @petrilofberg1758
    @petrilofberg1758 Před 3 lety +127

    After watching the first episode i wanted to commit sudoku.

    • @markhorton3994
      @markhorton3994 Před 3 lety +26

      I commit sudoku every day.

    • @akechijubeimitsuhide
      @akechijubeimitsuhide Před 3 lety +7

      I wanted to defeat the showmakers in battle, have them paraded around Kyoto and hire the Shame Nun to ring that bell and chant "shame! shame! shame!", then have them publicly beheaded.

    • @Symonch_
      @Symonch_ Před 3 lety +18

      No please don't commit son goku

    • @igneous061
      @igneous061 Před 3 lety +6

      yey lets do a mass sudoku guys XD

    • @buukute
      @buukute Před 3 lety +2

      Seppuku is my favor brain game

  • @marcusviniciusmagalhaesdea3779

    9:45 Shadiversity Voice in my head: LIGHTSABER!!!!!!

  • @moriken1234
    @moriken1234 Před 3 lety +71

    Seeing Samurai doing Iai style moves with Katana in battlefields is like seeing Western movie-style quickdraw with revolvers in American Civil War battlefields. It should be blatantly obvious to anyone that it doesn't make sense...

    • @Zraknul
      @Zraknul Před 3 lety +5

      Quick draw stuff makes a lot more sense under the context of my primary weapon is no longer available. Yeah I might as well be immediately fighting with it from the draw, especially if the other dude is in my face. Spear gone, sword out fast good.

    • @shionkreth7536
      @shionkreth7536 Před 2 lety

      The katana is curved in that specific way TO be a draw and cut sword, though; there's nothing that doesn't make sense about using it that way.

    • @shionkreth7536
      @shionkreth7536 Před rokem

      @@HiddenRealm Yes, all stuff I already know. I was just saying that drawing and cutting with a katana is a perfectly normal use of it. I feel like the sensationalization of it is making people think iaodo is not a real martial art. It SHOULD be obvious to everyone a sheathed katana against a guy with a polearm is not optimal when you could start with a polearm AND a sheathed katana, but I understand some people have no working knowledge of this kind of stuff outside of movies, shows and video games.

  • @yoloman3607
    @yoloman3607 Před 3 lety +67

    I can’t believe the series literally skipped Nobunaga taking Kyoto between episodes. Like...that’s the whole idea of trying to be shogun is you need Kyoto, and they skip the taking of Kyoto?

    • @TealWolf26
      @TealWolf26 Před 3 lety +2

      I was like: wut happun? 😐

    • @paulenan9636
      @paulenan9636 Před 3 lety +1

      I had a wikipedia article about this man open on the second screen to see what they actually talked about. At some point in the second episode I gave up

    • @SimuLord
      @SimuLord Před 3 lety +2

      Extra History did a better job of telling the story of the Sengoku period, and they're pretty much "the usual suspects" whenever r/badhistory is in a crabby mood.

  • @spenkerdetanker9067
    @spenkerdetanker9067 Před 3 lety +80

    "I need a drink" *returns with the kabuto on*
    _a_ drink huh?

  • @marcusviniciusmagalhaesdea3779

    6:50 Pop culture Samurai: I will only use my katana, because contains my spirit. Is my soul and my honor!
    Real Samurai: Pointy stick goes brrrrrr

  • @thegator7018
    @thegator7018 Před 3 lety +276

    lmao have you seen this "docuseries" on the Romans? they had Julius Caesar fighting on the front lines, on foot, with no helmet, in lorica segmentata... man these are rough, why not just make it an interesting drama where you don't have to be 100% accurate, making it a docuseries and pretending to be educational then getting everything wrong is just an insult and embarrassing.

    • @badfoody
      @badfoody Před 3 lety +15

      they save money by making both hahaha
      you gotta consider, the actors they use in the reenacted documentaries are just low paid actors. extras given more screen time
      there's barely a script to work with. what they're doing is keeping people engrossed in the spectacle.

    • @Evili555
      @Evili555 Před 3 lety +3

      Ah “Roman Empire”, even though it is quite inaccurate and lacking in a lot of information, I actually enjoyed it.

    • @user-et8vm9cc3t
      @user-et8vm9cc3t Před 3 lety

      What was he wielding? Was it....
      a spatha? an arming sword? A katana?

    • @gilgamesh8334
      @gilgamesh8334 Před 3 lety +6

      At what battle ? Because I recall Caesar at times actually grabbing a shield and joint the front lines. Perhaps it was an illustration of his earlier days ?

    • @Evili555
      @Evili555 Před 3 lety +3

      @@gilgamesh8334 he didn’t join the front lines but he did grab a shield and a sword and “rally” his units by running back and forth between the right and left flank at the battle of Munda(Spain, against Labienus), the battle that ended the civil war.

  • @user-ti4bm4md5y
    @user-ti4bm4md5y Před 3 lety +57

    4:00 some random dude changes Metatron. I can not recognize who it is.
    5:38 metatron finally comes back.

  • @JackWendigo1234
    @JackWendigo1234 Před 3 lety +66

    To my memory, Toyotomi Hideyoshi had one of the most Bizarre helmet designs in Japan. Don't understand why they didn't use it in the show.

    • @RoninDave
      @RoninDave Před 3 lety +31

      I think the production crew largely didn't know much about Japanese history so much of what the talking-head historians were saying to them (and probably ended up on the editing room floor) went over their heads. They went with what they knew and what they thought their audience knew which isn't much. So a lot of things that could have really pushed the docuseries into interesting territories was missed.

    • @imperialtutor8687
      @imperialtutor8687 Před 3 lety +10

      And they focused on bullshit that have been falsely claimed as historical accurate...

    • @nicholasgutierrez9940
      @nicholasgutierrez9940 Před 3 lety +5

      Naoe Kanetsugu: Are you challenging me?

    • @macrow206
      @macrow206 Před 3 lety +1

      That sun ray helmet shaped like the kampaku hat, I think he oy got that helmet after being promoted to the position of kampaku but under nobu he wore a different kabuto

    • @kitsunesamurai7999
      @kitsunesamurai7999 Před rokem +1

      You do see the helmet in the show he just never wears it.

  • @DemTacs
    @DemTacs Před 3 lety +134

    Hope this will brighten your day:
    How do you make a samurai run?
    U sho gun. ;P

    • @Project305miami
      @Project305miami Před 3 lety +4

      Get out

    • @TheJommy34
      @TheJommy34 Před 3 lety +15

      @@Project305miami How about this
      Who is the sharpest Japanese warlord?
      Oda chi

    • @Shadders2010
      @Shadders2010 Před 3 lety +4

      @@TheJommy34 You're fired

    • @jeandupont8501
      @jeandupont8501 Před 3 lety +1

      Except it isn't pronounced like that. Hating being that guy.. 😂

    • @DemTacs
      @DemTacs Před 3 lety +1

      @@jeandupont8501 can you elaborate? I am happy to learn. Wish you a pleasent Day.

  • @axlefoxe
    @axlefoxe Před 3 lety +33

    Characters can't be recognized with helmets on, Characters aren't expressive - power rangers and mandalorian enter the room.

    • @stormveil
      @stormveil Před 3 lety +5

      Or robot characters like C3PO - no facial expressions except his eye lights occasionally go out. Still he's instantly recognisable and very expressive.

    • @CarrotConsumer
      @CarrotConsumer Před 3 lety

      Mandalorian is a very reserved character. It's not a great example.

    • @adambielen8996
      @adambielen8996 Před 3 lety +5

      Karl Urban's Judge Dredd, he never took the helmet off. So all you get to see of him is the standard issue Judge frown.

  • @jebadias1468
    @jebadias1468 Před 3 lety +20

    Before watching this series I never knew every single battle could be "The most important battle in Japanese history"

  • @neobliss2120
    @neobliss2120 Před 3 lety +58

    I don’t even drink anymore and that show made me to be like ..*clears throat *..
    “SAKE”!!!!!!!

  • @zvonimirtomac7896
    @zvonimirtomac7896 Před 3 lety +65

    Oh my god! It's so bad Metatron killed himself!

  • @RHR199X
    @RHR199X Před 3 lety +101

    I was hoping this was a historical war drama about the Meiji restoration and the end of the Shogunate but the seppuku told me enough

    • @balasaashti3146
      @balasaashti3146 Před 3 lety +10

      dude that needs to be made.

    • @camerongunn7906
      @camerongunn7906 Před 3 lety +4

      @@balasaashti3146
      Indeed.

    • @nicholasgutierrez9940
      @nicholasgutierrez9940 Před 3 lety +4

      Based Saigo Takamori destroys shogunate and virgin Ezo republic then rebels against the nation he conquered because it changed too much from his actions.

    • @maleibog
      @maleibog Před 3 lety +3

      there is a Japanese historical drama called shinsengumi you'll learn more history from it than this netflix shit ^_^

  • @Topo167_
    @Topo167_ Před 3 lety +30

    Me while watching the serie: "well that's a lot of bs, can't wait for the history gang to debunk it" here we go.

  • @shadowstyleb
    @shadowstyleb Před 3 lety +22

    Thank you for saving me time. I almost watched that series. I was excited to see it but wanted to wait till I saw an expert comment on it. Thank you for saving me time.

  • @thebigone6071
    @thebigone6071 Před 3 lety +30

    They should have had you as their historian on this project Metatron!!! You’re the greatest historian in world history!!!! Keep clapping those historical cheeks!!!

  • @DanJay1996
    @DanJay1996 Před 3 lety +58

    YEEEEEES! I’ve been patiently waiting for this!!!

  • @k3ps00n7
    @k3ps00n7 Před 3 lety +45

    This video is out for like a few seconds but I already know it's gonna be awesome because of the intro 😂

  • @Gooseygoose14
    @Gooseygoose14 Před 3 lety +77

    I was WAITING FOR THIS!!!!!

    • @williamsavage4147
      @williamsavage4147 Před 3 lety +2

      i watched the first 15 minutes of the show turned it off and waited for metatron to post this video

  • @TrueMentorGuidingMoonlight
    @TrueMentorGuidingMoonlight Před 3 lety +64

    *Perry in full samurai armor takes off mask*
    Doof: “A platypus samurai?”
    *Perry takes off helmet and puts on hat*
    Doof: “Perry the Platypus samurai?”
    *Perry takes off armor*
    Doof: “Perry the Platypus!”

  • @j.d.j9574
    @j.d.j9574 Před 3 lety +58

    As soon as I saw the notification I had to watch this
    Also I like that u shouted out the shogunate I love his videos and I always wanted to see somewhat of a collab between u two

    • @whatthefuck8401
      @whatthefuck8401 Před 3 lety +2

      Same

    • @patrickmulder2450
      @patrickmulder2450 Před 3 lety +3

      Me to, even stopped in the middle of watching something else. I've watched everything but the last episode of this series, and my face still hurts from all the frowning I did. And I don't even know that much (if any) about Samurai...

    • @j.d.j9574
      @j.d.j9574 Před 3 lety

      @@patrickmulder2450 lol

  • @user-ti4bm4md5y
    @user-ti4bm4md5y Před 3 lety +25

    Katana indeed very powerful weapon. I once accidentally cut my finger... and then i died.

    • @salmonfish1145
      @salmonfish1145 Před 3 lety +10

      I took mine out of its scabbard and not even halfway out I died.

    • @laterreurrouge1917
      @laterreurrouge1917 Před 3 lety +7

      I got cut cleanly sliced in half just from looking at a sheathed one.
      From 30 feet away.

    • @MaaZeus
      @MaaZeus Před 3 lety +5

      Quickly made a youtube comment as your death poem. This is important afterall.

  • @Detachedpoet224
    @Detachedpoet224 Před 3 lety +13

    The intro is the most Italian thing I've ever seen

  • @melmeki4422
    @melmeki4422 Před 3 lety +3

    His room that can wear Gusoku in front of Scutum and Lorica segmentata is AWESOME!✨💕
    In Japanese period dramas, "The Twilight Samurai"(たそがれ清兵衛) is well known for its focus on historical research, in spite of it depict fictional Han(藩) at later Edo era.
    I would recommend it, but I don't know if it has subtitles except Japanese.😥

  • @KenpoKid77
    @KenpoKid77 Před 3 lety +32

    First of all, love your channel, especially your review of Ghost of Tsushima.
    Secondly, yes, as far as documentaries go, this was a hot mess. I thought it was going to be a story, Romance of the Three Kingdoms sort of thing. I was looking forward to that, having played Samurai Warriors (not their fault, that was my own expectation), but it just seemed cheaply made to be a Netflix series.

    • @RoninDave
      @RoninDave Před 3 lety

      Yeah, when I first heard of it I thought the same thing which if a drama I could forgive certain details for artistic license but a documentary? Maybe it started that way - the B-roll stuff - then they scrapped it for cost reasons and brought in the talking heads.

    • @TheEudaemonicPlague
      @TheEudaemonicPlague Před rokem

      I had no idea it was Netflix, until you mentioned it. That's so sad....

  • @jovegajo
    @jovegajo Před 3 lety +3

    There was a KDrama, "The Immortal Yi Soon Shin", and all the main characters actually wore their helmets during battles. Honestly the Japanese characters were easy to recognize anyways, since their helmets were usually really unique.

  • @jedyzichterman358
    @jedyzichterman358 Před 3 lety +10

    The moment I viewed this first episode I was hoping you'd deconstruct it. I was actually shocked to see Stephen Turnbull in this documentary. I have a few great books he authored where he directly disputes many of the things in this documentary. Makes me wonder what went wrong here

    • @1D991
      @1D991 Před 3 lety +4

      It's like they made a documentary specifically for weebs that don't know history, but not to educate them on the avtual history but to stroke their Japan boners

    • @borismuller86
      @borismuller86 Před 2 lety

      To be fair, Turnbull has changed his mind on a lot of stuff.

  • @iambob2006
    @iambob2006 Před 3 lety +4

    That intro though - middle of splitting stomach open, casually decides to have have a drink and snack, carries on. Well played

  • @the21Panda
    @the21Panda Před 3 lety +7

    I really enjoy these debunking and analysis videos. It always makes me think, what would a *perfect* "samurai-videogame" look like? The combat, the equipment, the features, the story?
    Much love from switzerland, thanks for your content ⚔

    • @Dowlphin
      @Dowlphin Před 9 měsíci

      Shadow Warrior 🤪

  • @paulaassis3065
    @paulaassis3065 Před 3 lety +9

    Pretty sure I saw a retainer carrying Date Masamune's crescent moon kabuto on one of the episodes thought I don't believe he ever actually wore it either.

  • @raycearcher5794
    @raycearcher5794 Před 3 lety +2

    The thing with the helmets is that important nobles personalized the heck out of them, to the point that the look of many famous samurai helmets is an iconic part of how we think of the men themselves. Like If you're watching a period anime and some badass swaggers up with a big old crescent on his hat, you know right away, oh it's Date Masamune.

  • @Robertoalrz
    @Robertoalrz Před rokem +2

    I heard once that the “Chiburi” was used to test the integrity of the sword after a fight, as the Bamboo pin(mekugi) that holds the blade may break over time after heavy abuse and the blade can fall.. So after a fight they “give a hit” or a fast short cut in the air to check if the Katana looks ready for another engagement..

  • @BertLaverman
    @BertLaverman Před 3 lety +6

    My wife, who is Japanese, is a big fan of historical books "fiction" (stories based on/featuring real events/people) and has read a lot about this period, so when I found the series on Netflix and started watching, she was amused. Neither of us is as well-studied on the weapons and armor side as you, but even I noticed some jarring things, and my wife probably simply won't watch it. The style is typical for the current generation of comic-induced productions. One of my daughters remarked that everyone performing seppuku appears to first go to a room with a nice clean set of tatami mats, so they could get a fly-over shot of the quickly growing pool of blood on it. File under "light entertainment" with a note of "gory" and unfortunately a large dose of accurate history in the storylines, so not so easily dismissable.

    • @Dowlphin
      @Dowlphin Před 9 měsíci

      Natually the one thing they got right was the brutality - because it sells.

  • @nightshadesyrup1624
    @nightshadesyrup1624 Před 3 lety +18

    the moment i started the series something fell off, now i see why

  • @Mike_The_1950s_Historian
    @Mike_The_1950s_Historian Před měsícem

    Thank you for showing that one can love a subject (such as the history of the samurai) without idealizing it. Too many people feel that "love" or "interest" in a subject equals idealization and a position of "superiority." Thank you again.

  • @griffinswanepoelyoung7848

    Great intro, bringing in humor to your videos is a key reason we love these vids. You and the other lover's of history that show it properly etc should be hired....until then thank you for these inspiring videos:)

  • @Wodiac
    @Wodiac Před 3 lety +3

    Your content just keeps getting better! Keep it up, man!

  • @dan_the_dj
    @dan_the_dj Před 3 lety +10

    Thanks for saving me the time to watch it...
    Id rather watch you deconstructing it instead :D

  • @firefly-pd9ho
    @firefly-pd9ho Před 3 lety +1

    dude this is so EPIC! I love the new editing and thumbnails style, and Metatron is being a boss as always ❤

  • @jonathanowen9917
    @jonathanowen9917 Před 3 lety

    Really great points. Thanks for covering this series in detail.

  • @LokiCDK
    @LokiCDK Před 3 lety +38

    Katana were an amazing sword... given the materials and technology available.
    Context is key.

    • @cattledog901
      @cattledog901 Před 3 lety +13

      They were good for the kind of tactics and armor Japan faced. But in terms of the most versitile or all round effectiveness against diff types of enemies it was far behind other contemporary swords

    • @LokiCDK
      @LokiCDK Před 3 lety +13

      @@cattledog901 and thus bow and spear play a larger role on the battlefield, but that's not as romantic a notion to sell.

    • @jamessalvatore7054
      @jamessalvatore7054 Před 3 lety +7

      It's a fantastic, special cutting weapon.
      Shit for European medieval dueling. Blades brittle. Not designed to clash.
      Pros and cons all around. But the weaboo historian at Netflix doesn't know this. Amazingly.

    • @eagle162
      @eagle162 Před 3 lety

      Materials were fine it's a repeated myth on the internet that it was bad Japan even had a solid iron ore comparable to the best in Europe, technology was also comparable to the rest of the world, Japanese swords were used against foreign enemies and did well, Japanese blades were actually adopted all over Asia for combat use, it wasn't a specialized cutter but could stab(can have very tips) particularly with the edge held up or hold sideways and deliver blunt force trauma, Europe had their own versions like the Swiss saber, blades were not brittle ones not from later sword making Traditions anyway which is what people are usually familiar with.
      Sources to check out:
      Iron and Steel Technology in Japanese Arms & Armors - Part 3: Bladesmithing on Gunbai:Japanese Warfare.
      the 2 part article: japanese sword " myth busting" also on Gunbai:Japanese Warfare.

    • @jeandupont8501
      @jeandupont8501 Před 3 lety

      @@cattledog901 You are right. Nothing beats a Gatling gun.

  • @MiloshFitzroy
    @MiloshFitzroy Před 3 lety +12

    I love the metatron is serious and funny at the same time

  • @geraltgrey-mane695
    @geraltgrey-mane695 Před 3 lety

    Thank you for the video, looking forward to part 2

  • @JaneIllinois
    @JaneIllinois Před 3 lety

    Love your channel! Yes, keep these critiques coming

  • @Cdre_Satori
    @Cdre_Satori Před 3 lety +8

    as bad as the age of samurai was, at least it wasn't roman empire series. "that series tried to divide us or hit us from the flanks"

  • @ianduarte1992
    @ianduarte1992 Před 3 lety +3

    "dude thats s crazy, you totally lok like this guy who died like 400 years ago, we should cast you as him"
    "hehe, yeah, he died years ago... sure... *nervously drts eyes around*"

  • @CJLiveFromTheOutdoors
    @CJLiveFromTheOutdoors Před 2 lety

    Great video! Thanks for teaching us.

  • @jomon723
    @jomon723 Před rokem

    Yes, First 10 minutes, I could see were it was going, Happy you showed the Shogunate link

  • @Testosterooster
    @Testosterooster Před 3 lety +8

    Been waiting for this one !!!

  • @robertjabonski9383
    @robertjabonski9383 Před 3 lety +9

    I have watched the series and I must say that expertise of those historians who took part in narrating the series is debatable, at best. Sometimes I think they weren't really sure what they are saying, oftentimes it sounded like someone just gave them a script to read, like it wasn't their real opinion on things. The thing about katana being the best sword in history also kind of set the tone for the rest of this production, as I am aware of at least one blade that is regarded better (Polish hussar saber). I was also expecting more on how the trade-off with Portuguese happened and how on Earth did Japanese came into possession of arquebuses. I think that definitely the series had some specific audience to please and they kinda did. Not meaning to sound rude, but I think it was done in a way that 'eh, Americans are not going to delve too deep into this so why bother?'. Usually documentaries on Netflix are really good, but this one not really. As a show - great thing to watch. As a piece of educational content - not quite.

    • @adamjan55
      @adamjan55 Před 3 lety +3

      Polish hussar saber is regarded better than katana? Since when? By whom? Why? Why not rapier or claymore or shamshir or kilij?

    • @Hekk.
      @Hekk. Před 3 lety

      @@adamjan55 by people who actually know stuff - but hussar saber is one handed, katana really isnt, if you compare both; well made saber and katana - saber cuts better. Hussar Saber is an evolution of shamshir btw.

    • @404Dannyboy
      @404Dannyboy Před 3 lety +2

      Polish guy says Polish sabre best weapon in another fit of weird Polish nationalism. Other hilariously unsurprising news at 11.

    • @Hekk.
      @Hekk. Před 3 lety

      @@404Dannyboy in the time they were made - they were the best in Europe, and to this day are better than katana at what they do - cut, I know only muricans are allowed to be 'the best', sorry.

    • @404Dannyboy
      @404Dannyboy Před 3 lety +2

      @@Hekk. They really were nowhere near the best in Europe and America has 0 to do with this. During this time period German and Italian swords were widely considered superior.

  • @arcadius2569
    @arcadius2569 Před 3 lety +1

    I look forward to your next 20 episodes on this matter!

  • @nrubin45
    @nrubin45 Před 3 lety

    I just finished this documentary and it's awesome you reviewed it today!!!

  • @Goldenleyend
    @Goldenleyend Před 3 lety +11

    I love the self stabbing sequences! 😂

  • @jeffreygao3956
    @jeffreygao3956 Před 3 lety +5

    I actually liked this show quite a bit although I would dispute their assertion samurai were the greatest warriors in history.

  • @jacko6560
    @jacko6560 Před 3 lety

    I have been waiting for you to cover this.

  • @clarencepsaila4743
    @clarencepsaila4743 Před 2 lety

    Thank you for this video! I had watched it and thought it was pretty good although I noticed some of the things you pointed out espeically the easy killing etc... but your video was a bit of an eye opener, very good!

  • @bubbasbigblast8563
    @bubbasbigblast8563 Před 3 lety +3

    "Who is the best warrior caste in history?"
    "Well, that depends on the time and place-"
    "BORING. It's the samurai now."

    • @Chevalier_knight
      @Chevalier_knight Před 3 lety +1

      Not counting todays warriors, i would say Alexander's army it only ended when their leader died.

  • @jlburilov
    @jlburilov Před 3 lety +5

    The Shogunate is a AWESOME channel! I would love a collaboration video! Please keep destroying the Netshit series

  • @engespress
    @engespress Před 3 lety +1

    The Shogunate is a good channel. Fantastic content. The narration is very nice.

  • @donaldbell2554
    @donaldbell2554 Před 3 lety

    I was hoping for this thank you very much

  • @imper_gaming
    @imper_gaming Před 3 lety +3

    On the katana “being regarded [by many] as the finest sword,” then the docuseries is not wrong. They’re not saying “it is the finest sword,” but “it is regarded as the finest sword.” A lot of misinformed people do believe it’s the greatest sword ever made, thanks to Western [and Eastern] media.
    However, it seems the show didn’t clarify or correct the misconception, and they also show the katana as the main battlefield weapon, so there’s that...

  • @debilita9999
    @debilita9999 Před 3 lety +8

    No one with common sense ever:
    TV producers : "When I am samurai I'll use katan cuz can split time and space with it."
    Best quote of a month

  • @paulolamarca5444
    @paulolamarca5444 Před 3 lety +2

    Helmets: wear me
    Other samurais: ok
    Oda Nobunaga: lol no
    Tokugawa Ieasu: lol no

  • @kevinstachovak8842
    @kevinstachovak8842 Před 3 lety

    Yeah it was a fun show to watch while bored at work, but I was a little disappointed that they didn't actually talk much about the samurai at all. Thanks for the link to 'The Shogunate' channel Metatron!

  • @thebadjoker9117
    @thebadjoker9117 Před 3 lety +6

    hey could you pls do a review on the Ottoman documentary series by Netflix? It is very interesting

  • @sonofsueraf
    @sonofsueraf Před 3 lety +6

    I'll watch this on repeat just so metatron can review the rest of this series.

  • @quakingphear
    @quakingphear Před 3 lety +1

    I had a fun time watching this series with my mom. She asked a lot of pertinent questions and enjoyed when I pointed out a lot of these same issues!

  • @Matteo-ej3ht
    @Matteo-ej3ht Před 3 lety

    Didn't see the show since i don't use Netflix, but it's always a pleasure going through and learning with your viedeos!
    P.s. : Even with the bell i've been 4 months at the very least without notification about any of your uploads... shadowban is real man.

  • @kommissarkillemall2848
    @kommissarkillemall2848 Před 3 lety +12

    i guess they will change the series description from "Historical"to "Ceremonial" after Metatron is finished with it.. XD

  • @BioluminescentTree
    @BioluminescentTree Před 3 lety +5

    The Shogunate channel, very knowledgeable guy on the subject, did a review of this show and he basically concluded that it's trash.

  • @lordblenkinsopp1537
    @lordblenkinsopp1537 Před 3 lety

    I've been waiting for you to do this

  • @Rob1971ist
    @Rob1971ist Před 3 lety +2

    Thank you for uploading this. I'm glad it wasn't just me that felt like banging my head against the wall for the weird things they showed about the weapons in this series, especially the helmets. And that bit about samurai being the greatest warriors of all time...yeah.
    I hope you make videos like this for every episode.
    I also have some questions: those books on your desks, could you do a review on them? (Or have you already done so?)
    Also, how do you appraoch reasearching historical topics? For example, I am interested in finding out when the Japanese stopped using bronze for their weapons and started using iron. How would I find out where I could even learn about that? Also, when did they start using curved swords? I only know legends about that.
    Anyway, thanks for all the great content.

  • @rohit_parashar
    @rohit_parashar Před 3 lety +5

    Dat intro was da bomb.

  • @louisdecrombrugghe926
    @louisdecrombrugghe926 Před 3 lety +6

    I stopped watching the series when i heard 'the greatest warriors in history"

  • @connor5689
    @connor5689 Před 3 lety +1

    Great video ,I've been watching the show recently and really enjoy it.

  • @KamiSeiTo
    @KamiSeiTo Před 3 lety +1

    Thank you, super interesting ! I'm looking forward to the other episodes of this Netflix show ! (And any other of your ancient Japan related videos, to be honest. ^^)

  • @tando6266
    @tando6266 Před 3 lety +4

    @0:56 me watching the first 5 minutes of this documentary.

  • @crozraven
    @crozraven Před 3 lety +18

    Are the historians who talks in the show western or actual Japanese ones?? 'cause maybe that where all the weebo elements comes from. There are definitely some historians that Japanophile, just like some other historians that very Americanophile or Romanophile.

    • @404Dannyboy
      @404Dannyboy Před 3 lety +3

      Honestly it doesn't make a difference. Japanese historians are just as likely to Japanophile, if not more so.

    • @crozraven
      @crozraven Před 3 lety +2

      @@404Dannyboy Fair enough. Still could be a lot better imo regardless.

    • @404Dannyboy
      @404Dannyboy Před 3 lety +2

      @@crozraven For sure.

    • @Chevalier_knight
      @Chevalier_knight Před 3 lety

      Was he japanese or an American with japanese ancestry because its not the same thing.

    • @timothyknott2985
      @timothyknott2985 Před 3 lety

      @@Chevalier_knight he was Japanese

  • @jimmydarm
    @jimmydarm Před 3 lety

    I was hoping you would review this show!! Awesome!

  • @TheArthur26
    @TheArthur26 Před 3 lety

    I was waiting for this to decide if i watch the show or not. So, thank you!

  • @marcusholbert2525
    @marcusholbert2525 Před 3 lety +3

    When historians watch “historical documentaries”

  • @ronin47-ThorstenFrank
    @ronin47-ThorstenFrank Před 3 lety +4

    Who is this guy wearing a helmet on Raf´s channel? I don´t know him.

  • @michaeltriola3978
    @michaeltriola3978 Před rokem +1

    “The samurai is the best warrior the world has even seen!” *7 seconds later* “However, the armor is made of butter!”

  • @lpcanilla92
    @lpcanilla92 Před 3 lety +1

    Blood of Christ, I was waiting your take on this. I watched the series but I was not very hopeful since they were calling it the "Japanese Game of Thrones". At the end it was exactly what I imagined, an inaccurate series filled with anime tropes and outrageous portrayals of characters. And why does everyone fight in forests?
    Excellent video as always, I'll wait for episode two and your exploration of Nobunaga's portrayal as a ravaging lunatic and pathological sadist.

  • @JapanatWar
    @JapanatWar Před 3 lety +3

    LOL that was the most appropriate intro XD I felt the exact same way when I watched it, still can't bring myself to watch the rest

  • @JEilonwyn
    @JEilonwyn Před 3 lety +5

    Even the great generals of Tokogawa were called his "Spears".

  • @magnatescompany
    @magnatescompany Před 3 lety +1

    For those who are curious, Cagayan Battles in 1582 is where the Spaniards fought the Samurai and won!! Sounds like the European rapier/side sword at the time were much more effective than the LENGENDARY SAMURAI SWORD!

    • @eagle162
      @eagle162 Před 3 lety

      You may want to take a closer look at that look up the article: "Cagayan Battles of 1582: Debunking the Hoax"

  • @LaNoir.
    @LaNoir. Před rokem +1

    "Tokugawa Ieyasu and his laser sword" that's how I like my history classes