So I hired 5 different editors on Fiverr and here is the result..
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 23. 04. 2019
- 5 different CS:GO editors from Fiverr and the exact same ugly ace to edit..
đč SUB FOR MORE: czcams.com/users/NadeKing?sub_...
đ·TWITCH: / nadeking
đ·TWITTER: / nadekingcsgo
đ·WEBSITE: www.nadeking.com
⌠Moviemakers âŒ
1 - Davencsgo - urlzs.com/HrJYg - 6.53 EUR - song: Julian Calor - Whalphin (No Copyright Music)
2 - Shufflexcs - urlzs.com/ZUosi - 11.19 EUR - song: Paint It Black covered by Hidden Citizens
3 - Muratthaqi - urlzs.com/Fkxis - 20.47 EUR - song: Hjalteidd - Jaloux X Jal 0 Ux
4 - Pikuest - urlzs.com/xD8sj - 11.19 EUR - song: Letgo - Fortune
5 - Justatiramisu - urlzs.com/qJHPP - 12.40 EUR - song: Self Deception - The Shift
⌠Professional judge âŒ
My friend STF - / stfvfx
This video is about the first that type of "Fiverr editor" experiment in CS:GO. I managed to hire 5 different editors who all edited the same demo for me.. Here is the result.
So, I hired a CS:GO coach on Fiverr and he told me I'm cheating:
âą So, I hired a CS:GO co...
How much better is a pro CS:GO player than a regular player?:
âą How much better is a p...
Audio credits (CZcams Audio Library)
Freedom Trail Studio - The Current Blues
Freedom Trail Studio - River Changes
#csgo #nadeking - Hry
Another Wednesday. Another experiment delivered..
NadeKing SUP
Sup
I love u â€ïž
Pls giveaway skin again nadeking
Nadeking do a challenge
"I will make an edit for a CSGO frags"
"What is demo?" Ok...
Stop mocking me lmao
@@AERIUSvfx I mean... n3rdCS is right.
Ok...
@@AERIUSvfx what is a demo lmao
Le Virre CSGO : ok
What a demo though I honestly don't know
First guy is A++ quality, if he just ups the FPS and has a little practice, he could be charging double, no problem.
He had wayyy too many slo mo edits. It felt staged out.
@@blcklstd6156 that's how cinematography works
yep the third one is a piece of garbage,
killerjerick mcjerick first guy was ass
#1 obviously went for a cinematic look, so i don't think there is a fps problem. 23.956/24fps is absolutely fine.
Can't believe they all charge so little for such a service..
The first guy should bump up his price for such good quality of editing
He's inexperienced but creative. He's charging the right price to get the most of what he needs - tons and tons of work. That creativity + added experience will build his resume and get him much more in the end.
The first edit sucked. the 4th edit was the only good edit in here.
Yeah but he makes it look more of a compilation than a highlight
@@NaueroFX The first edit was the best one there tf you mean. Check your eyes.
@@splatter1324 You obviously have no understanding of editing. Just because it looks nice doesn't mean its good. The first edit doesn't suck but its not as good as the 4th edit
"Terrorists win"
"Has a wholesome end"
Lol, I was thinking the same thing as the blood splattered.
Me: Nobody can charge 20 Bucks for simple Video-over-Drake-Copy!
3rd guy: Hold my Sisters Laptop!
1st one in 60 FPS 'd be best
Ein deutscher! Was ein seltenes Pokemon!!
3rd guy: You know what. Hold my PC and give me my sisters laptop.
SMOOTUBE đ
Even tho it was bad, i feel like 20⏠is way too less?! I mean does he do the full job in 15 minutes or what?
wow the 3rd guy srsly charged 20⏠for some blackscreens every couple of ticks tho?
he also rushed it so bad he couldn't get to his own pc. I mean, he had at least a week to do it, that was just lazy and dishonest work.
The one that the editor said was the best, the fourth one , the fucking flashing white lights almost gave me epilepsia :v@@eusoumaniaco
He danish
@@eusoumaniaco He could have at least said it might take awhile before he can use his own PC again. Now hes been named and shamed for this.
@@d4n3ftwttv91 Ved du hvad sangen hedder mate?
Editor #1 : "It's hard work, but it's honest"
Editor #3 : "It's easy work and I'll fuck this up"
I thought the lag in clip #3 was part of the Clip...
It is the part of clip, its very unprofessional and expensive
I thought my pc was lagging...
LOL
Same
Honestly looks like he doesn't know the difference between Ctrl+drag to shorten a clip and velocity..
Last guy has editing ideas but he lacks experience i guess....that CCTV camera into the real fight was creative tbh
yeah his ideas with the editing of the 4th editor would be really nice imo
@@maarcoo97 lol I voted for the fouth one aswell it really stood out
@@oof2209 i also liked the 3rd
@@maarcoo97 ok
Not necessarily creative he was just not lazy 4th still my fav
For 20 euros you could go to ebay and buy a graphics card which provides more fps than the clip you received.
That was a pretty good one, this comment was better than that clip
@@DegenWeb hahahahaha
Benjamin Brandis this comment is way better then 20 euro clip
Your comment has more FPS than the clip
This is so true, just built a 200 Buck Gaming-PC for a friend because he has no cash with used parts, with i5 2500k and Radeon 6950 2G and it runs BF4 High Settings 60 FPS FHD no problem, CS-GO 300 FPS + sometimes. I just thought wow - why do i even have my expensive PC...
NadeKing: *No one really likes outros anyway.*
Also NadeKing: **uses an outro**
4th was the best one by far. also the cumulative killfeed is 10/10
nade says the fourth one is 11 years old but i checked his fiverr arent him 17? lol
@@ftxnatsuz3z845 He doesn't say 11 years old :D
Garagenrusher I think you mean the 3rd
ikr as soon as I saw the comments they all said first one, which wasn't really good lmao
@@ftxnatsuz3z845 he said it cost 11 eurous
The first editor was the best
not only with the edits but because of the fact that they used non copyright good music to save you the trouble
also the price
All of the editors were garbage.
The first editor deserve cost 20 euro
@@10pmmemes88 really well make better then
@@10pmmemes88 can't call someone garbage when a professional disagrees
@@rohanmuppa213
that's not how it works, but okay. still on your side btw
Number 3 is really REALLY bad for what you've paid. Lmao
Yeah the stuttering made it painful to watch, it would've been better if it wasn't like that.
its pathetic.. tbh
it should been free
everything was trash đ i could've have done better
Yâall clearly have 0 knowledge of editing whatsoever
The switch to the camera and the black and white with 1v3 being pointed out was a nice touch and shows that this person knows some about the game, looked it up, or at least cared enough to pay attention. That was my favorite of the five.
clip 4 made you look the best by far. The kills were much cleaner
1st edit with 60fps and audio corrections would just be the thing.
60 fps is not editing standard, 24 or 30 is
@@GriefCentre vegas pro lets you export at 60
@@GriefCentre but should be
@@GriefCentre 60 fps is gameplay editing standard
the trick is to record the demo at slower speed and speed it up in your video editing software to get more fps.
Honestly the first one was the best for its price and quality, only problem was the 30fps lag.
And the Music was kinda too slow I think
He needs to tweak the interpolation settings I think.
Dude i make my vid 24 fps because it looks good what are you talking about
not only that, the graphics werent maxed, so i think he has pc problems rather than not having editing skills.
30fps isnât lag. He probably capped it at 30. Lag is when frame rate dips drastically or when itâs something ridiculous like 5 FPS.
This video really brought back my editing feels, got straight into one! Thank you!
Would like to see something like this again. It was really fun and interesting to watch
It was fun to take part in your experiment. Good job to all the other editors aswell!
Thanks to STF aswell for the proper feedback! :)
( 4th editor here )
Your clip honestly looked the best, like a really professional montage :D
i loved it.
They really don't know how a montage has to be, yours was the best, but try to add some s_shake, it looks cool :)
Yours was by far the best one :)
nice style gj. harsh competition btw ;)
>hits a moving 1tap
"Nothing special really..."
GG skripe me feel honoured man LOL love ya vids as well. :p
He stopped before shooting...
that was as bad as me when i opened a knife i didnt even realize it for a solid 10 seconds. (in my defense i was reading chat) lol
he didn't move tho
supah generual
6:13 this one is the best in my opinion!
I really like the simplicity of your videos nadeking.
Also thanks for your tips in de mirage it really helps and make my ladder to master :)
1st editor is under valuing his work
2nd editor is over valuing his work
3rd edit no comment
4th edit was cleanest/smoothest and my favorite overall
5th was most creative
Feels like the 4th guy should do car videos, got the same vibes from it.
First one was the chillest and the one i liked the most
Exactly
Literally couldn't have said it better!
I definitely agree. 4th would be amazing if he had just dialed back the over use of visual effects.
I like how only 1 guy mentioned that u won a 1v3 in the end
what
@@kipchickensout 5th editor put a "1vs3" on the security cam
That's because at that point in the video it was 1v3, watch the original clip again.
@mizo - Marko no they can't see the hud so you're wrong
Ondra Havel heâs not
Personally speaking 5th one is the best with the most creativity with angles from knife, AK, security cam and many more, also the clip included all highlights, cut out the bs in between, and even added interesting extra details at the beginning :D
Wtf is that 3rd edit, what a scam jeez
The first one was the best. Not only for the price but for the chillness, editing style and it made it look so quick and clean. Also, the train edit will not go un-noticed! That guy wins in all cases in my books. Props to every other editor as-well.
MEME FACTORY lmao except for the third one
@@thomyang2538 he did suck
His style reminded me of ShutteR. watch?v=gqD6M3dwHA8 (Its not a csgo clip tho)
MEME FACTORY chilness Is not a word dumbass
Botniter You canât even spell what he originally wrote, dumbass.
Last one was SICK
Besides the colours, i think the ending was great finale!
i also like the last one the most
@Silve0_ CS:GO my name in csgo is SilverZero xD...
when someone asks my rank im like : 'silver'
'zero'
i think colors are sick - kinda looks like a trip
I like the 1st and the last one. First one is chill and nice, last one - very creative and leave good impression.
pikuest would be my favorite except for the flickering which is really hard on the eyes. all the transitions and camera angles are on point.
The 1st and the 5th were best in my opinion. My fsvorite part was the gopro type of angle on your rifle
Same! :D
The angle on the AK was indeed sick. I love shots like that! Check this one: czcams.com/video/PjoXLq7fqXY/video.html
That was cool tho.
Does anyone know how to pull that off?
How to record in that angle?
Security camera angle was sick in my opinion
no
easy to do
111tykatypka of course, but the idea is great
@@111tykatypka At least he has some creativity. ^^
Because of this video, I subscribed. Please do more of these. Make this a series.
pikuest is a great editor for that price holy shit
I think I forced the ending a little. Glad to be in your video tho
shufflexCS nice
Yours was the best in my opinion
yeah yours was fire
Yours was pretty good man
yours is the best of them all in my opinion .
"What is even demo?"
Guy definitely knows his stuff
4th edit was op. Killfeed, colors on point, CC camfeed đđ€
That was the last one with the CC feed
To me as an editor The Fourth (pinkuest) is definitely the best. Good execution . Good sfx . Good velo .
chr1s exactly
delivered fast.
charged 20euros
is bad.
used sisters laptop (should've said he can't do it atm etc)
he did it for the money.
..and he used Danish music (I'm a Dane, so found that to be a fairly odd choice..)
If you're going to make something that fits an "international audience", you don't go with music like that..
@@tagger_
Not to mention the music he picked was absolute garbage 14 year old "I wanna be a gangsta drinking in clubs" music.
@@rickyr.nielsen9494 and tbh as an editor, paying fucking 20 eur for something that shit is just garbage, thats something that somebody can do in 10 minutes in fucking movie maker, feel bad for nade
probably uses same excuse for every sale tbh
Should have give his sisters number instead
Nr 4. Was the best in my opinion. But nr 5. with the security camera was also really cool.
Last clip was the best for sure! I suscribed:)
I like when the cut tells the story, like when the molly forces the guy.
man i had to skip the third edit (the 20 euros vid) it hurts my eyes .
dearest freind Zuhn' clips are better than the 20⏠edit (i never thought i would ever say that)
@@wAVE1337 true
The vid makes me laugh
7:28 tracking the gun barrel in focus like this look great.
The first edit is pretty cool tbh!
The last one. The camera snaps to the weapons were cool. It seemed like the little extra time spent made a big difference.
Agreed, it showed the most creativity out of them all.
Dat knife angle was... killer. (didn't initially mean to come up with a joke)
and good music
My condolences for the âŹ20...
Even tho it was bad, if that was more than 10min of work 20⏠is nothing.
@@Andrew-tl9gk If 20 ⏠is 10 minute work, 120 ⏠per hour, 960 ⏠per day? I want this job right now o.o
@@bedsdt plus the rising amount of csgo players and hackers increase the demand
âŹ20 for 30 minutes sounds right not 10 mins.
I am so amazed by the quality of these edits
I like clip 1. The music the sync the angles. Its so good.
It's been a fun challenge (I'm justatiramisu)
For future edits i'll be more careful with the colors ,i just liked it when i made it :3
Gj to all the editors , gl in the future
Good work dude, loved the camera view and ending
I voted your edit over Twon's cause of all the great camera angles you used, you included that it's now a 1 v 3 and the gopro type stuff, that was a really nice touch. You had a bit of a think before diving straight into it, impressive. After watching all of them many times your use of a lot of yellow kind of grew one me :D
Your edit reminds me of several legendary CSS fragmovies, good job!
Few things.. maybe it's just personal feeling but some of the parts are faster than the music which is kinda wierd. Also I don't really like the part with the camera. It's great idea don't get me wrong, but the build up feels longer then the actual clip from the point of view of the camera.. and because of that it looks rushed (that part).
Otherwise I liked the colors, the begining was good. I really liked that take at A sign/mark (what word am I supposed to use, I don't know)đ.
The gopro effect was way too cool. Voted for you
Hi NadeKing, thanks for letting me participate in this project. Keep up the great content! :-)
Your one --> 7.5/10 I actually love the slomo at the third kill. Love the sync of the video in general. Also the "Throwing a grenade" voice is cool. I like the idea of the mountain in the ground, but it was not only on the ground but also at the wall.
Didn`t like the very last cut, made no sense. You were indoors and all of a sudden he flew into the sky?
All in all, very nice editing style. Keep it!
@@BMXaster Thank you for the detailed analysis, my thoughts at the last scene was that I want to end the video where it began. But yes you're right, I could've done such a smoother ending! Appreciate your words alot
Ur was sick
What's the song mate? :)
I would pay you to make me an edit I love yours. Yours was the best. 9/10 (10/10 would be when 60fps)
The first edit was actually pretty sick.
Cmon nade! Make another video of this, it was so good
I love the transition at 7:53 how it rotates around the gun barrel.
honestly looked jank to me /shrug
Yep, looked cool af
6Twisted looked cool but could be cleaner
6Twisted could have lasted longer than a couple frames, and he could have eased into it from the clip before.
thats object tracking looks dope tho
Dude that picked up on the CT falling in the smoke... That guy is going places.
And followed the smoke nadeking shot after the last guy was killed
Thereâs not many places you can go with this tbh
what second mark?
Please do more of these. I love them so much. Would love to see cod edits to :)
The edit from Shufflexcs was amazing, great song, slow motions etc everything was fine as hell :)
Hate the fifths color grade but his edits looked dope :)
You can change it easily
Over-saturation or a very warm filter.
1st for value, 5th for visuals and appeals. Both were very well made.
3th for most trash
@@yigita3190 *3th* I agree
To me the first guy was awesome. He set up a story for himself and tells it. ''nobody likes outro'' I loved it, it matched the pace and the tone. The way the first kill makes the Ct fade in the smoke... Was the most enjoyable thing to watch of the entire video.
I don't know why I am watching this, I don't even play CS but this is very interesting video
love it, thanks
@@NadeKing 1st guy was great don't see the fps bruh see his price it's worth it
#1 is very nice, especialy for that price.
if it was 60fps it would be my fav i think
I agree, it gave me sort of a goose bumps feeling with how chill it was
@@deltahl when you use 100% of your brain
@@farang9260 lol im still lost. as an editor, you are supposed to render in 30fps, unless you all mean he edited it in 30fps then just why.. :/
@@deltahl it doesnt even really matter if your pc can run the game with max graphics in 60 fps. just use host_framerate and choose whatever fps you want. to capture it i would also use the ingame recorder. people with good enough hardware can use a 3rd party software i guess. afterwards just render it in 60 fps. its not that hard. the thing that really annoys me with cs go moviemaking is that the hud_deathnoticetime command doesnt exist and just because of this single command moviemakers are forced to use hlae wich granted has some other usefull features but not really necessary for a simple highlight movie.
Editors: What kind of edit do you want?
NadeKing: Yes
r/inclusiveor
Great profile picture.
JMiguel overdone joke
JMiguel not funny
lol
OMG I LOVE THE COLORS IN THE LAST EDIT
that second one gave me goosebumps
4th is my favorite and 1st is next, because in those two I can actually follow the players and tell what the fuck is going on in the game, which is the most important bit.
HRC3D itâs not about the clips itâs about the edits...
My favourite edit was the fourth one by PIKUEST, it was so sick!! 6:12
Great vid Nade King :)
same
I hate that one so much.
The best one for me was at 7:05
Lol, i didn't liked it either. I hate this kind of effects on the highlight.
Love his transition
IKR
i like the fourth one because it keep thing short and speed up some non highlight moment, also i can keep track the time how player did amazing thing. not just edit jump from one moment to another moment very quickly like the fifth one did.
This kill feed in the 4th edit was unique and pretty cool
With some changes and at 60 fps i think first one would be the best
You usually make 30 fps edits with rsmb
yes 60 fps edits are a no go, you can see the frame drops
First was the best. He had the most artistic talent. Especially in 2:29. The way CT faded into the smoke felt so natural and beautiful, I would say it's equal to the "camera shot" of the 5th edit. The first work had one of the best feelings of motion and gameplay details, such as molotov, jumping out of smoke in 2:25. Positioning of the progranist is well shown, so there is no "guessing" how he teleported from one point to another. Ending was also quite satisfying, although I don't understand the showcase of the sky (maybe flashbacks?) in the end and 2:42.
If you the first editor combined some elements from the 4th and the angles of 5th he would make hands down best stuff here.
In my opinion, strong second is the 5th. Almost perfect in every single thing but the colours, too quick ending, extremely over-forced "1v3" message 7:23 and a few minor things.
Third place goes to the 4th edit.
And obviously, the last place goes to the overcharging guy who made 3rd clip.
Agreed
Agree
Didn't read
Honestly the first one didn't even feel smooth. The ideas are good but when it's executed like that, you can't call it the best.
@@striveedits Agree :)
lmao
I think the last one is the best. While I did find the contrast they used strange, the creativeness was spot on. I just really enjoy how they were able to turn such a long slow clip down to a faster pace. The first one just felt too slow to me, but that's mostly just my personal preference.
The second is the best one. The music and editing is spot on.
1, 4 and 5 were all incredibly good, can't decide which I like best, props to all the creators!
4:56
Minecraft.exe has stopped working.
My man using velo for slowmođđđman dont know shit
I loved the last 2 and also the first one... cant decide which one is better, tempos are different and i just think they r pure gold
Well this was interesting, not sure how I got here but I subd lol. 1st and 4th clip was very nice.
4:45 Rip your money bro, it was really laggy
Why did you change your comment??
Shittest edit i've ever seen xDD it's lagging, and it's 144p quality....
He used the laptop of his sister, but ok.
@@mealy7891 But still, 20$...
it was danish
I liked Daven's edit was the most. I liked the pace and the vibe of the edit and it was cool how he showed the first CT dropped into the smoke. Well done, Daven! :) I liked Pikuest's edit the second most. I liked the transitions and how the edit was straight to the point while having a good beginning, main part and ending. Nicely done, Pikuest! :)
Great video and idea, NadeKing :) Thanks for showing this!
I really like the first! But, the second one.... Ooooh man... It was also amazing! It made me feel like I was watch a trailer to a new riding CS:GO Pro team! They would just have to add this at around the beginning of the song:
This Summer! THE NEW ACE RISES!
Cool video, some of those edits were pretty sick.
Clip 1 DAVENCSGO (âŹ6.53) : 2:14
Clip 2 SHUFFLEXCS (âŹ11.19) : 3:35
Clip 3 MURATTHAQI (âŹ20.47) : 4:37
Clip 4 PIKUEST (âŹ11.19) : 6:18
Clip 5 JUSTATIRAMISU (âŹ12.40) : 7:09
PIKUEST did actually pretty good job in my opinion! Just saying.
@@MrArska04 Yes
Pikuest Estonian?
I liked first and 4th the most
@@MrArska04 I totally agree with you.
Really love these type of videos (as well as all of yours lol), keep it up nade!
I probably would have swapped the last kill with the 3rd and 4th kills. The one tap was rather sudden but the back to back kills were pretty good. If not for a swap, I might do a 3d bullet animation to follow that 1 last bullet from your gun to the CT. The bullet might even have something engraved in it as it traveled like "to whom it may concern" or something.
Ahahaha i love the 3rd guy, just playing some danish summer music on.
Please make this more, so fun and interesting!
3:44 that sync is so good
I like the sister's laptop clip, it reminds me how everything needs to be from my own effort!
I absolutely love the last two
bananagaming would love that yellowish editor lol
my thought
Pikuest killed it. Insane edit, this guy knew what he was doing. You should get in contact with them and help them out tbh. Support creative minds!!!
I think he used too much of the distortion effect instead of syncing it to the music which detracted from the whole thing
@@Guineapig300n60 I disagree, I think oppositely, it added a fluid flow to the video, sort of warping effect, not just fast-forward
I think Daven's was the best besides the stuttering due to framerate imo
Hi Pikuest
Idk how nobody praises that awesome idea of the first vid and the first kill when the ct falls into the smoke first vid hands down is the best
1st and the last one. just on point. great edits
Philosophers said âTheres a man puke because he dislikes the edited videoâ
The 1st and 4th clip were clearly the two best for their prices. I could go on and on about what could be changed, but those two were definitely the best. I'd like to try my editing against these with that clip
honestly the first one was the best, if he bumps up the fps and smoothness it would be perfect, anyway top 1 of the day, saluted sir.
I love this kind of videos