Why Dalit Muslims & Christians are not provided Reservation, Why SC status is not religion neutral ?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 23. 04. 2023
  • App Link - pjddn.courses.store/333789?ut...
    For Iphone Users - apps.apple.com/in/app/myinsti...
    Org code: PJDDN
    UPSC Prelims 2023 Revision Course + Test Series - Yearly Analysis + Static GK Topics - • UPSC Prelims Revision ...

Komentáře • 438

  • @manojkumar-dj1vn
    @manojkumar-dj1vn Před rokem +15

    Harshit sir apka bht bht dhanwad apki kirpa se meri Punjab electoral commission mein as kangooo selection huyi aa mene apki video se bht kuch sikha

  • @Internet_explorer_guy
    @Internet_explorer_guy Před rokem +136

    If Islam and Christianity have casteism too.. then what's the point of conversion

    • @jd7886
      @jd7886 Před rokem +9

      Ek hi saf me khade hai mehmud aur ayaz na koi Banda raha na koi bande nawaz

    • @Rohan-ej2cq
      @Rohan-ej2cq Před rokem +2

      @@jd7886 bhai samj nhi aara kya bol rhe thoda clearly bolo

    • @jd7886
      @jd7886 Před rokem +6

      @@Rohan-ej2cq yeh ek sher hai. saf mtlb namaz ki line, mehmud ek badshah tha aur ayaz uska gulam jo ek hi namaz ki line me khade hai, ku ke Allah ke nazdeek badshah ho ya fakeer sab ki haisiyat ek jaisi hi hai isliye Islam me discrimination casteism nahi hota bhai

    • @p_HoE_niX
      @p_HoE_niX Před rokem +11

      @@jd7886 to jb discrimination casteism nhi to reservation ki kya need, bdhia to hai.

    • @AjaySharmaIND
      @AjaySharmaIND Před rokem +15

      ​@@jd7886 bas toh phir baat khatam. Phir Islamic aur Christians SC quota kyun mang rahe?

  • @Bluntabhishek
    @Bluntabhishek Před rokem +14

    Varna system cancer kabse ho gya sir ??
    Caste word apke Priya Param Angrez Master lekar aaye the kabhi NCERT ke propaganda se bahar niklo sadji 😅

  • @uditchhabra1738
    @uditchhabra1738 Před rokem +4

    Can anyone tell me ...which software is being used by sir here and how to learn these kinds of software online ..plz help

    • @ytg6663
      @ytg6663 Před rokem +1

      Editor hire krke rkhte hain. Paid software hote hn.

  • @prithvirajvantagodi3653
    @prithvirajvantagodi3653 Před rokem +12

    Happy to see new styled videos...❤

  • @billybutcher6504
    @billybutcher6504 Před rokem +20

    End Reservation and give separate electorates. Babasaheb wanted separate electorates, but gandhi gave reservation.

    • @bbbabulal
      @bbbabulal Před rokem +6

      Hume bhi alag country chahiye general walo ko

    • @lakshaythapar1
      @lakshaythapar1 Před rokem +2

      ​@@bbbabulal though Gandhiji gave separate electorates to muslim and sikhs in 1919. How about this.....

    • @boi2679
      @boi2679 Před rokem

      Bhai separate electorates kya hota hai pls tell

    • @casualuser2317
      @casualuser2317 Před rokem

      Ambedkar wanted reservations, he got reservations
      Don’t use WhatsApp messages here

    • @lakshaythapar1
      @lakshaythapar1 Před rokem +10

      @@casualuser2317 read his biography and poona pact. Mr. Andhbhakt

  • @nirmala9391
    @nirmala9391 Před rokem +9

    If they want SC status after being converted, then why they got converted. The were able to get SC status by being a Hindu. First they got converted for improving their status but now when they are unable , they are demanding SC status what's the point here?

    • @baviteja9325
      @baviteja9325 Před rokem +1

      Improvement of community doesn't happen in 10 days after conversion but it takes generations. And if they still stay in Hinduism even after 1000 more generation they will still face discrimination

    • @googlesharma4477
      @googlesharma4477 Před rokem

      @@baviteja9325 tu ye bta kyu gye doosre religion mein ,kya woh bina religion ke nastik bnkar nhi rh sakte they , kya jarurat thi doosre religion ki . Aur agar doosre ke religion mein jaakar bhi agar status nhi badla h toh usko chod de aur bina religion ke rhe kisne roka h . Jab lalach mila toh doosre jagah chal diya wahan nhi kuch hua toh ab reservation chahiye gye hi kyun they

    • @-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_.
      @-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_. Před rokem +1

      ​@@baviteja9325 that's just an excuse. World is developing quite fast and so will the social structure. I would say in 200 years or so there would be no value of castism.

    • @rashmitasingh2373
      @rashmitasingh2373 Před rokem

      They're demanding SC status because even after converting they face discrimination. Casteism is so rooted here that even the same community that they convert to discriminates with them

  • @citizenrayagada2037
    @citizenrayagada2037 Před rokem +19

    In converted kuchh nehi mil na chahiye

    • @ashishhiwale6482
      @ashishhiwale6482 Před rokem +1

      Kuch milta he nahiye... General ke andar ate he... Merit based

    • @citizenrayagada2037
      @citizenrayagada2037 Před rokem

      @@ashishhiwale6482 hna janta hu, lekin e bsdk converted log demand karte hne

  • @kaushalsinghrawat9956
    @kaushalsinghrawat9956 Před rokem +43

    No castesim was prevailed during Vedic period. Even 60 per cent students in Gurukuls are from today's shrudras.

    • @sarthakmaurya5938
      @sarthakmaurya5938 Před rokem +9

      Ye Sab Britishers ki history jisme evil Hindus ho Gaye
      Aur *Hero* मुग़ल हो गए 🐖

    • @ujjwalchhatrapal6862
      @ujjwalchhatrapal6862 Před rokem +4

      ​@@sarthakmaurya5938 Kabir Ravidas gurunanak apne app se Ladd rhe the ..😂😂 thoda common sense laao upsc aspirants ho ....Sufism nhi jaante kya

    • @baviteja9325
      @baviteja9325 Před rokem +5

      Then why 99% of temple priests are Brahmins

    • @kaushalsinghrawat9956
      @kaushalsinghrawat9956 Před rokem +2

      @@ujjwalchhatrapal6862 guru nanak kisse lade.. Sikh ke guru aur unke baccho ko kisne mara...

    • @kaushalsinghrawat9956
      @kaushalsinghrawat9956 Před rokem

      @@baviteja9325 Jai bhem Jai meem was prevailed

  • @nitinthakurNTR
    @nitinthakurNTR Před rokem +1

    sir video editing is very good.. and you narrate it very well..

  • @pratibhadwivedi1803
    @pratibhadwivedi1803 Před rokem +16

    Waise "bhadra bhasa" kaun si h?🤔🤣
    Harshit sir apne ishe explain to bhut ache se kiye,👍
    To my point of view, Nhi krna chahiye kyuki SC to ye hindu m bhi tabhi the to aisa kaun se smrajya k raja bnaya ja rha tha ki ye Christian or Muslims m convert huye.?phle to ye batye ushke baad position inki aj bhi wahi h. Maante h phle inke sath hindu m kafi bhedbhaw hua h. "(Par jab ek ghar m aj bhi 5 bhai-behano k beech m bhedbhaw hota h ishka matlb ye to nhi ki ghar chodke k padosi k ghar m rhne chale jao or property ghar walo se mango")aur ek baat padosi k ghar naukar hi banke rhogye chahe kuch bhi kr lo😂😅.Rules change huye inke liye hindu aj jhel rhe h fir bhi inhe Muslim aur Christian bana h to banne par SC k quota bhi chahiye ye kaun si baat h. Caste reservation hona hi nhi chahiye economical reservation hona chahiye India m tabhi india m sab equal hoga nhi to kuch nhi hoga bedha garak hoga bas..

    • @AjaySharmaIND
      @AjaySharmaIND Před rokem

      Bohot sahi kaha aapne 😊

    • @vaibhavdubey9738
      @vaibhavdubey9738 Před rokem

      Completely biased and baseless allegations.....this is video is definately not for aspirants

    • @hellraiser3448
      @hellraiser3448 Před rokem +1

      caste based reservation representation ke liye hota hai. caste permanent hai isliye caste based discrimination bhi permanent hai. gareebi door karne ka program nai hai. gareebo ke liye kaafi yojnaye hai.

    • @truthtalker9375
      @truthtalker9375 Před rokem

      One thing I'm seeing in this video that people who are opposing and criticizing Dalits and reservation are most of from Brahmin community 💀...is not it strange?...why from some community always has issues for Dalits and reservation, muslims, Christians, khalistani,bodos, Bangladeshi, pakistan, China, congress,SP,BSP,AAP?....they think these all are hate them and so on but these UC people don't know that if some person hate you then their fault but when majority people hate you for your deeds then it means you are wrong and you have done wrong which you're not accepting

    • @pratibhadwivedi1803
      @pratibhadwivedi1803 Před rokem

      @@truthtalker9375 kaun se election m khade hone wale ho ??
      dalit aur reservation ki to kisi n koi baat nhi ki h. humne sirf apni baat rkhi h hindu se muslim , christians jo convert huye h unko SC k quota chachiye. tmhe kaise pata itne comment m sirf bhramin h jo bol rhe h aur dusre nhi h , dalit ho kya tm jo tmhe itna hurt hua??aur sach m dalit ho to tmhe pata hona chahiye sachai kya h bhramin bhedbhav nhi krte tm log khud krte ho apas m bhedbhav sirf political batye n kro jo sach h ushe dekho. aur ek baat reservation aj k time m economical hona chaihye ye bola h maine galt bola kya ye , SC caste m bhi crore pati h , aur kuch jo bilkul gareeb khana bhi nhi kha pate 1 time k , to yahi haal sabhi caste m h , paisa hi h jo sabse bada h aj ushe sab kuch kiya ja sakta h kuch families aisi unke pas khane pahne k lale padhe h education m kaha se invest kregi Aur SC K QUOTA k achar dalegi. SC quota k faeyda bhi ameero ko mil rha h. jo christian ya muslims m convert hote h vo bhi sirf paise k liye hote h ground reality dekho 2lac-3lac m ushke baad kuch nhi. yah hindu dharm ki baat hui kisi particular caste ki nhi. mai NGO se judi hu sc- st k bacho ko education deti hu aur bhramin hu mjhe yah batane m koi sharm nhi h. truth talker likhne se reality nhi badal doge ushme kaam kro phle, bakwas nhi ushke liye political parties h.

  • @rameezahmed2826
    @rameezahmed2826 Před 11 měsíci

    Very informative video, I liked your knowledge able video Harshit

  • @rh2400
    @rh2400 Před rokem +9

    Dalit Muslim or Dalit Christian is similar to Veg Biryani. Oxy moron term. Islam aur Christianity Mai castism nehi hota.

    • @AjaySharmaIND
      @AjaySharmaIND Před rokem

      Ohh bhai what an example 😂🤣

    • @SahilAnsari-gw4eh
      @SahilAnsari-gw4eh Před rokem

      Caste nahi hai humme, magar ex Hindus to hai.

    • @arunkapilgaming
      @arunkapilgaming Před rokem

      ​@@SahilAnsari-gw4ehex hindus hai toh caste se bahar hoke allah se mango mango

    • @SahilAnsari-gw4eh
      @SahilAnsari-gw4eh Před rokem

      @@arunkapilgaming Tumlog brahman se mangho agar reservation chahiye to

  • @abhishekkumar2350
    @abhishekkumar2350 Před rokem +11

    Nhi mile to hi achchha h, hinduism khatra m ho jayega,

  • @hgddbnxshjkjgszcbmkkxsfhldwtug

    Good decision.... aarakshan bhi chahiye or hinduism ko gaali bhi dogy.. arakshan hatao desh bachao

    • @gyangaahacademy4246
      @gyangaahacademy4246 Před rokem

      Donkey 🐴 always remains donkey.
      Bhakt can't get my point
      Keep on Ghadhagiri

  • @saheb3500
    @saheb3500 Před rokem +6

    Ager milne lage to.. Convert k wholesale market kholne lagega theke dar log.

    • @AjaySharmaIND
      @AjaySharmaIND Před rokem

      Wahi toh chahte hai yeh log. Inko sabkuch chahiye. No caste based discrimination ka churan bech kar convert bhi karna hai phir baadh mein apne aap ko dalit bhi ghosit karna ha. Yeh toh d0gl@panti hai

  • @avtarps3519
    @avtarps3519 Před rokem +51

    General get seat due to merit.
    Others get seat due to reservation.

    • @smartking581
      @smartking581 Před rokem +7

      Haa mla mp bhi h merit se bane h 😅😅

    • @sheshank3768
      @sheshank3768 Před rokem +11

      Jaise karoge vaisa bharoge 1000 saal tk 100%. Reservation ka fayeda uthaya ab bhugton

    • @smartking581
      @smartking581 Před rokem +6

      Abe reservation h isi liye tum loga mp,mla bana re ho 😂..
      Ni hua to tum 3% loga minority me aonge 🤣🥺🥺...
      Tum logo ki avakat hii ni mla ,mp banne ka anpad

    • @baviteja9325
      @baviteja9325 Před rokem +6

      If there was no reservation for brahmins as priest in temple and no reservation and all kinds of occupations in the society like carpenter, barber etc by their birth. Then there would no need of reservation system in legislation and executive body of government

    • @baviteja9325
      @baviteja9325 Před rokem +9

      Dalits and OBC has seen discrimination for thousands of years. Now upper caste can't bare reservation for 80 years after independence

  • @ankitraje1
    @ankitraje1 Před rokem

    Short crisp conc. Nice video

  • @techisaul9102
    @techisaul9102 Před rokem +2

    Thanks for information video

  • @togetherwecan8638
    @togetherwecan8638 Před rokem +6

    Is they converted for betterment only if what happened with their faith for which they converted not find their betterment there then again change ....change is the only way as it started from change it will ended with change so change it

    • @mknayak9386
      @mknayak9386 Před rokem +5

      Aaree kehna kya chahte ho????........

  • @bollywoodmusicnetwork2501
    @bollywoodmusicnetwork2501 Před 11 měsíci +2

    Minorities & Dalits are dying day by day in India .
    Sad ...but reality!!

    • @ShivaniKumari-ql9di
      @ShivaniKumari-ql9di Před 4 měsíci

      No , bilkul nhi, mere agal bagal sab reh rahe h ekdum Masti mein ,maje se reservation ka benefit le rahe h jindagi enjoy kar rahe h ,nd mujhe bht Khushi hoti h unko ijjat se jita dekh kar,toh pata nhi aapke taraf wale q mare ja rahe h

  • @letslearnandsuccess9586
    @letslearnandsuccess9586 Před rokem +7

    Because they live in an equal status after conversion and the reservation has been granted the person deprived of equality in the society.

    • @asawari520
      @asawari520 Před rokem +1

      Once converted to Christian or Islam they dont have casteism then they dont need SC status . Thats the logic . You cannot have both . This is only for Hindu Lower castes lets be crisp and clear.

    • @limnalouis2970
      @limnalouis2970 Před 11 měsíci +1

      ​@@asawari520 That is the reality but being a dalit Christian I can say we are the most deprived class.. Upperclass Christians never accept our identity they consider we are the only who converted from Hinduism 😇 Sad reality of a dalit Christian who loves jesus very much😇..... We dont have that much reservations only 1% in state psc same fee as general in most of the exam.. But our problems are never come out... #weshallovercome😇

    • @asawari520
      @asawari520 Před 11 měsíci

      @@limnalouis2970 So if there is differentiation in Christianity as well then why not come back to Hinduism .

  • @sanyuktsingh32
    @sanyuktsingh32 Před rokem

    What a presentation sir har videos ko aise present kijiye ga please

  • @globalaffairs6714
    @globalaffairs6714 Před rokem +30

    I think it's the high time for the people of these depressed classes to leave Islam and Christianity and rejoin Hinduism. Because the mindset of the people of Hindu community is changing many Hindu people are doing intercaste marriage. They can join Hinduism and get benefits of SC.

    • @Joker-ve2qe
      @Joker-ve2qe Před rokem +3

      ​@@professor593In future we will be Muslims , itne saaloin k islamic atychaar k baad bhi na huye toh abb kya honge , we have not sold ourselves in the past nor will in the future too , may God give you " Sadbuddhi bro " 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @professor593
      @professor593 Před rokem +2

      @@Joker-ve2qe hamara atyachar to kuch h hi nhi tumhari hi andhbhakti h 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😅😅🤣🤣🤣🤣 gobar dhan ke jaisa dimaag ho gaya tumhara 😅😅😅😅

    • @globalaffairs6714
      @globalaffairs6714 Před rokem +3

      @@Joker-ve2qe 💯💯👍

    • @Joker-ve2qe
      @Joker-ve2qe Před rokem

      @@professor593 dimagi roop se iss tarah vikshit paagal ho chuke ho , ki sabb tumhe har Hindu andhbhakt , gobar aur mutr pe hi abhi tak tike ho, that shows your brain has lots of ammonia & uric acid 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @globalaffairs6714
      @globalaffairs6714 Před rokem +3

      @@professor593 I'm already on right path brother and I thank Lord Shree Ram who gave courage to my ancestors that they did not got converted like your ancestors. I pray to Lord Shree Ram for enlightenment of the whole converted community. Jai shree Ram🙏

  • @abhilashghosh7578
    @abhilashghosh7578 Před rokem +2

    Pardon me. I won't say something I'll regret. But I'm glad to get this information from you.

  • @Banka.7
    @Banka.7 Před rokem +9

    Caste certificate should be given by seeing caste not the religion..
    So sad that discrimination to Christians everywhere in our country despite being secular country

    • @mvasudev236
      @mvasudev236 Před 10 měsíci +6

      Whaa then u say caste exist in islam and christianity

    • @Banka.7
      @Banka.7 Před 10 měsíci +1

      @@mvasudev236 Christianity is open for any caste as No discrimination and restrictions. It only motives to be holy , humble and praise god

    • @ShubhamKumar-vd9xy
      @ShubhamKumar-vd9xy Před 8 měsíci +3

      ​@@Banka.7then you are not eligible for reservation 😏😏😏plus I am SC but not fake one like you

  • @dkaunteya
    @dkaunteya Před rokem

    Good video - though it tilts towards the opinion that "they should get it". One error or clarification I would like to point out that the OBC & ST status to Muslims & Christians is not awarded as blanket. It differs from state to state. In states like Manipur, they get it but states like Maharashtra, they don't get.

  • @j.s.j.8156
    @j.s.j.8156 Před rokem +1

    Thank you sir 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @casualuser2317
    @casualuser2317 Před rokem +4

    Religion don’t change economic status. If they are backward, they deserve the reservations

    • @ShivaniKumari-ql9di
      @ShivaniKumari-ql9di Před 4 měsíci

      Yes , bilkul sahi kaha aapne, isliye economic based reservation milna chahiye naki caste / religion based, qki gareebi ka koi jaat dharam nhi hota ,toh aap caste based reservation ka hak nah mang ke weak economic section ka reservation demand karo wo jarur milega, and if a person get converted to Muslim and Christian, reason jo v ho caste , ideology,it can be anything but inke dwara he claim Kiya gaya h ki Muslim and Christianity mein koi caste Basis discrimination hota he nhi h, toh sc/st kaise claim karoge after conversion, reservation mango jarur mango but economically weaker sections ke base pe mango naki jaati ke base pe🙏

  • @IntArch
    @IntArch Před 11 měsíci +2

    Caste is not the only reason to convert. Spirituality and ideology is also important.

  • @Avi.9793
    @Avi.9793 Před rokem +7

    Ye log paida krte time to bolte hai allaha ki den hai.phir enko ye sb ki kiya jarurt hai.. but enke 10 me se 5-6 bhi abroad jate hai to achi income karte hai.... But sochna chahiye kiya sahi hai kiya galt....
    JAI HIND 🇮🇳💪

    • @anuarhossen326
      @anuarhossen326 Před rokem

      Aapp kk gatiya soch se pata chalta hei ki aap kese family pe belong korti

    • @Avi.9793
      @Avi.9793 Před rokem +3

      @@anuarhossen326 sahi bol rahe ho kio ki hum 2 Bhai hai... Kisi ki allaha ki den nahi hai🤣🤣🤣

    • @googlesharma4477
      @googlesharma4477 Před rokem

      @@Avi.9793 allah kya padosi ka naam h ya mama ,chacha ,mausi ya phoofe ke ladke ka naam h .

  • @vaibhavdubey9738
    @vaibhavdubey9738 Před rokem +9

    Respected sir , you have lack of knowledge about caste system and Varna vyawastha .... please read Baba shaheb bhimrao Ambedkar book in which he had clearly mentioned that both have not such similarity, that Varna vyawastha and today's caste system is not same.🙏

    • @ytg6663
      @ytg6663 Před rokem

      I am happy u know the truth bro ❤

  • @July_Delphinium
    @July_Delphinium Před rokem +6

    When they convert they get money ..... Why they need reservation🙂

    • @TonoLord
      @TonoLord Před rokem +2

      How much money?

    • @July_Delphinium
      @July_Delphinium Před rokem

      @@TonoLord ofc they get GD amount 🌝

    • @TonoLord
      @TonoLord Před rokem +2

      @@July_Delphinium ayoo! Bato na kitna,😆 i need money, soch raha hoon atheist se muslim ya christian ban jau temporary,😂

    • @July_Delphinium
      @July_Delphinium Před rokem

      @@TonoLord subka package bana hua hai acc. To their caste go ahead 💁

    • @alok9307
      @alok9307 Před rokem +1

      ​@@TonoLord chal bhai sath mei. Krte hai convert

  • @Rahulits85e68hlxigi
    @Rahulits85e68hlxigi Před rokem +2

    Reservation is not based on religion. It is a upliftment policy confer by the constitution. It is a social upliftment.

  • @manthanbhandary
    @manthanbhandary Před rokem +3

    Sir app sanatan Dharm k bare main video main jo picture diye hain wo galat hain & cast system by birth nahi thaa British government Aakhe afwah failai hai Kyunki Jab hamare pass Gurukul the tab 97% education rate tha........ Agar cast base Mein Sabko education Mila Hota To 97% education rate Nahi Hota ... 😊

    • @samsonaequilla
      @samsonaequilla Před rokem +1

      Yeh 97 percent ka statistics kaha se mila, i want to read. Any sources?

  • @ytg6663
    @ytg6663 Před rokem +9

    दलित मुस्लिम 😅 पहली बार सुन रहा हूं 😅😅😅

    • @junedshaikh9165
      @junedshaikh9165 Před rokem +1

      Hota he

    • @googlesharma4477
      @googlesharma4477 Před rokem +2

      @@junedshaikh9165 agar hota h toh isko theek karo na ,tumhare majhab ki dikkat h toh jimmedari bhi tumhari hogi isko sudharne ki

    • @junedshaikh9165
      @junedshaikh9165 Před rokem

      @@googlesharma4477 ha to kar rahe he lekin sarkar ka bhi haq banta he afterall we are citizen of the india

    • @googlesharma4477
      @googlesharma4477 Před rokem

      @@junedshaikh9165 discrimination aap log karte ho toh apki jimmedari h ki discrimination khatam karo ,ye mindset ki problem h isko law bnane se khatam nhi kar sakte ,warna law toh itne saare h phir bhi log discrimination, crime ,corruption karte hi h . Jimmedari apki h ki apne logon ka mindset badlo

    • @junedshaikh9165
      @junedshaikh9165 Před rokem

      @@googlesharma4477 bhai pahile baat to hum koi discriminate ahi karte or baat agar reservation he to reservation ka main concept discrimination khatam karna nahi he reservation is for upfliment for the society na ki discrimination se iska koi relationship he

  • @avalahemanth9731
    @avalahemanth9731 Před rokem +3

    Excellent transformation of videos additional to ur commendable voice sir ❤ hope more n more updates to make content more interesting. Lots of love from Vizg .😊

  • @bickydey7903
    @bickydey7903 Před rokem +1

    If in Muslim religion or Christianity or say Bhuddism their is no caste system then how can they be Scheduled Caste or any other caste.

    • @mvasudev236
      @mvasudev236 Před 10 měsíci +1

      hnaaa bhai free ka maal kisko nahi chahiye

  • @crimsonmoon123
    @crimsonmoon123 Před rokem +1

    Two things. Rigveda does not say anything about caste, rather it says about Varna. Varna is not same as caste.
    Second, the SC status in Hindu community is granted on the basis of historical wrongs which have been done to them as they were "untouchables/dalits".
    Therefore, if someone has already converted from Hinduism to Islam/Christianity then they are no longer in Hindu fold. How can the government give SC status to someone who is a non-Hindu?
    Why did they convert from Hinduism to other religions? They already got their share of financial support in form of money and/or rice bags by the preachers of said religion.

    • @TonoLord
      @TonoLord Před rokem +1

      Man you killed your own preaching,🤣
      If they converted for the rice bag doesn't it means they are stills under economic stress?

  • @Chand_ms_
    @Chand_ms_ Před rokem

    Video editing 🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @9826160926
    @9826160926 Před rokem

    Sir sc ka status tab milta hai jab apke cast ke sath kuch bura hua hai or apko social status utna na ho par jab apne apne cast ko hi chor diya or convert ho gaye to apka social status to waisse bhi change ho gaya to phir sc ka jo base hai wo hi khatam ho gaya

  • @jhonsherpa4992
    @jhonsherpa4992 Před 2 měsíci

    does india is a secular n democratic country ? all ans r in inside this qeastions...

  • @rahulnihore
    @rahulnihore Před rokem

    सभी साथियो से निवेदन है लाइक एवं सब्स्क्राइब कर सपोर्ट करे
    www.youtube.com/@rahulnihore

  • @naturegift8632
    @naturegift8632 Před rokem +1

    Sir apka purana tarika hi jada accha hai.kuki isme uncomfertable lag raha h.

  • @criticalpsyche
    @criticalpsyche Před rokem +2

    de dena chahiye sir, but ek progressive reservation jo automatically revoke ho jaye after 3 or 4 gen of such reservation.

    • @Rohan-ej2cq
      @Rohan-ej2cq Před rokem +1

      Fir yeh toh Sare religion pe karna chaiye

    • @criticalpsyche
      @criticalpsyche Před rokem

      reason: by conversion does not mean that decades of atrocities on their ancestors goes in vain plus there will be cases where on might be uplifted convert but in holistic manner there is no guarantee that convert is free from discrimination.
      Plus a good chunk of them converted due to discrimination by upper echelon ranks and lack of dignity not only just love for Christianity and Islamic 'values' and these religion itself carries an expansionary propaganda looking for depressed people to force them to conversion by money or power.

    • @p_HoE_niX
      @p_HoE_niX Před rokem +1

      @@criticalpsyche So, we need to give reservation for another 3000 years.🙌

    • @AjaySharmaIND
      @AjaySharmaIND Před rokem +4

      ​@@criticalpsyche Then why people are getting converted in the name of no caste based discrimination, anti Hinduism sentiments? Jab Hinduism se nikal ja rahe hai phir quota kaise mang sakte hai. Unke sath Jo hua Hinduism mein rehte hue hua. Ab jab woh equal treatment ke naam par convert ho chuke hai toh unko hum kyun compensation de. Jo community convert kiya hai unka equality ka dhyan woh rakhenge ki hum

    • @dhairyadave583
      @dhairyadave583 Před rokem +2

      ​@@AjaySharmaINDExactly bro why is the caste problem sold in the name of Hinduism only? You criticize Hinduism, you convert then you take the benefits of that religion and defame the same after converting. The audacity!

  • @citizenrayagada2037
    @citizenrayagada2037 Před rokem +4

    Converted

  • @mrityunjayjha7869
    @mrityunjayjha7869 Před rokem +2

    Dear Sir,
    Kindly do have a RESEARCH on the actual functioning and management of ancient hindu society , not viewing from a colonial lens.
    Please mind your words while you say Varnashram as Cancer, for you are an educator and not a propagator..
    Thanks and Regards.

    • @mrityunjayjha7869
      @mrityunjayjha7869 Před rokem +1

      as far as discrimination is concerned, actual discrimination is being practiced today on economic grounds , which is far more draconian and injustice than what used to happen based on caste.
      So, past ko sudharo mat. past se seekho and future ko sudharo..

  • @sharatchandra1130
    @sharatchandra1130 Před rokem +1

    If the economic status has not been improved then give them reservation in the basis of economic status because if it is based on cast system which does not exists in their region then how the world would react.
    And if it is based on cast then it is possible that any wrong practices can be done. Another thing in each cases when reservation is provided the aim is to provide them a better economic opportunity, so why cast system is linked with it.
    Another very important thing the cast and reservation system is killing our society when one General candidate needs above 90 percent to get the job the SC or ST candidate just need 30-40% of the marks to achieve the same job or post, So we are allowing a person with 1/3 of intelligence to get appointed. Then how this society can get benefit from this. When any private company hires they check the merit only, so that they can get more productive person in their workplace.
    #Remove cast based reservation and bring economic status based reservation.

    • @ShivamKumar-vc1pv
      @ShivamKumar-vc1pv Před rokem

      Bhai kon se duniyaa mai jee rha h 90 or 34%😂 mai tune farak hi nhi smja bhai konsi naukri 34 % marks lane pr mil rhi h mje bbhi bta de meri lag jayegi 3. Saal to ho gye mje tayaari ke

  • @Anshu.24383
    @Anshu.24383 Před rokem +2

    Jab unko convert hi equality dene ke basis pe kiya jaa raha hai to kaahe ka reservation fir!
    Or agar reservation de diya to Muslims or christian missionaries apna langar khol denege conversion ka!

  • @nivepal327
    @nivepal327 Před rokem +1

    Minorities ka bhi status chahiye aur sc ka reservations bhi chahiye... Aise kaise chalega... No ,its not right. To have both status.

  • @uditnayak1172
    @uditnayak1172 Před rokem +1

    ST reservation also secure tribal culture
    For those communities who are backward there is obc and ews . So instead of fighting for SC status they already get benefits in those reservation, If christian and muslim demand sc status then its it should given to lower OBC community

  • @kaushalsinghrawat9956
    @kaushalsinghrawat9956 Před rokem +5

    जिसको sc st आरक्षण की आदत लग जाती है, उसकी मूल स्थिति में कभी परिवर्तन नहीं होता है, और न होगा। वो हमेशा अपने को प्रताड़ित और सामान्य स्तिथि से आभावहीन ही बताएंगे।

    • @madhusoodanprasad2248
      @madhusoodanprasad2248 Před rokem +1

      3000 saal tak khulla reservation lene walo ki hamare 75 years ke reservation se fat gayi 😆😆

    • @rehanahmed2331
      @rehanahmed2331 Před rokem

      ​@@madhusoodanprasad2248 आ गया भीमटा भीमटी 😂😂😂 समारोह महार डॉ भीमराव सकपाल का भक्त

    • @Banka.7
      @Banka.7 Před rokem

      Are bhai , religion change karne se back wards kaise mit jati hai..

    • @Sandy_ki_Maa_randi
      @Sandy_ki_Maa_randi Před 9 měsíci

      ​@@madhusoodanprasad22483000 saal pehle Tu zinda the kya?

  • @insanisoch1707
    @insanisoch1707 Před rokem +2

    Jo log keh rahe ki muslim or Christian me caste system nhi h wo log ye btaye ki kya shuruwat me hindu dharm me caste system tha?

    • @AjaySharmaIND
      @AjaySharmaIND Před rokem +1

      Baat ghuma ke kya fayeda? Phir main bhi ek sawal puchta hoon kya tab Supreme Court tha? Nahi na. Par ab hai. Jab log no caste based discrimination ke liye convert ho rahe hai phir convert hone ke baad apne aap ko dalit kaise keh rahe hai? 😂

    • @ytg6663
      @ytg6663 Před rokem

      ​@@AjaySharmaINDरिजर्वेशन का लौलीपौप चाहिए इसलिए😅 जाति नहीं चाहिए पर जाति के नाम पर रिजर्वेशन सबको चाहिए😅

    • @insanisoch1707
      @insanisoch1707 Před rokem

      @@AjaySharmaIND dalit community h religion nhi h ek hi community alag alag religion man rahi h to reservation 2 religion ko chodkar baki sabko q mil raha.
      Samvidhan me discrimination ko allow nhi Kiya h fr ye discrimination q

    • @insanisoch1707
      @insanisoch1707 Před rokem

      @@ytg6663 khud bolte ho hindu dharm me caste kaam ke adhar pe bna h fr bolte ho inko hazaro salo tak staya gya yrr ek stand to rakho sc matlab schedule caste not religion caste ka tumhe bhi bta h yha muslim hindu dharm se hi Bane h to caste to wohi h na agar esa nhi h to muslim or Christian ko obc me bhi q rakha h?
      Yani samvidhan me bhi mana gaya h ki indian muslim me caste hoti h

    • @insanisoch1707
      @insanisoch1707 Před rokem

      @@ytg6663 kisi bhi Desh ki study karo to pata chalega ki chetriye adhar pe pehchan milke waha bhi tribe system h or India me kaam ke adhar pe h

  • @marxist6858
    @marxist6858 Před rokem +1

    One think to remind there is no dalit Muslim, it existed in sanathan religion..
    They had divided Muslim into caste for the vote......

  • @user-zc4zx9eh1q
    @user-zc4zx9eh1q Před 4 měsíci

    It means muslim ST tribe's me aate hai???

  • @sushilindian1067
    @sushilindian1067 Před rokem +1

    1.Reservation must be given once . Example ..
    , if one person gets the govt job , then he and his family then onwards should not be eligible for reservation.
    2. Reservation must be given to only those who belong to a certain category but below creamy layer ( based on income ).
    3. Reservation must not be applicable for Higher post like IAS, ips, first class officer , grade 1 scale , PG or specialization in medical field ..and such other . These post must b filled based on merits.

    • @sscasprints968
      @sscasprints968 Před 6 měsíci

      To jo govt job lg jate H unko pandit ke barabar mano

    • @sushilindian1067
      @sushilindian1067 Před 6 měsíci

      @@sscasprints968 Mano..problem kya hai manane me..jisko jo mañana hai Mano...

    • @MANASH4590
      @MANASH4590 Před 5 měsíci

      ​@@sscasprints968ha aa jao apna certificate fadke brahmin ho jao dikha leke,sath me non veg se vegetarian ban jao😅

  • @ItsMe-lz8gw
    @ItsMe-lz8gw Před 19 dny

    SC should be given on the basis of economic condition. And Muslim and Christian school deserve it.

  • @asrabmiah376
    @asrabmiah376 Před rokem +1

    1:36 , is tarah ke caste system Islam dharm mein nehi sir ,muslim community mein exist krta hain ,Islam is free from all kind of segregation

  • @Globalhindu296
    @Globalhindu296 Před rokem +1

    Still in odisha reservation is given for converted religion. There should be complete ban on them.

  • @nandinijha1578
    @nandinijha1578 Před rokem +3

    Respected sir and all of you who might read this comment...
    I want to state something regarding this social and legal issue of our society...
    1. Ved and upanishads doesn't procreate the caste system...as we can proof it through various upanishads.. like kath, niralamb upnishad.. even the vedanta promotes the idea of denying the very identity of a human being...how can it support the caste system..
    2. I m not denying that discrimination had not been taken place...yesss it had it's own history...but the motive doesn't come from upanishads and vedas...
    3. The idea of discrimination comes from an individual's mind...and the idea of proclaiming ourselves superior among others. We can see this even nowadays as well..today we discriminate on the basis of economy class isn't it..??? So can we say industrialization procreate or the source of discrimination...??
    No, we will not bcz it the product of one's own mentality or mindset.
    4. Society grow time to time ...with humans ...and humans have Mind( mannnn) who always try to satisfy its ego through different means...earning money with competition...showcasing urself to be rich among your peer groups...this is the way ...we generally see..people around us nowadays...which is quite absolute.
    5. Conversiom to other religion have many reasons..one of them might be discrimination but why don't we talk about the forcefull conversions... avrice conversions...
    6. Muslim and Christian community definitely need reservation as they are not on the same page economically and socially..there representation in the parliament, employment, education is also important as like other communities..
    6. And lastly I want to say we need to eliminate the idea of discrimination from every individual mind belonging to any community through education so we can make EK BHARAT SHRESHT BHARAT.

  • @carajanji6087
    @carajanji6087 Před rokem

    We need to end cost and cost based reservation.

  • @sassy2712
    @sassy2712 Před rokem +6

    Bro for your information, Vedic system was on the basis of occupation, according to work, caste was made, not work was done according to caste, have knowledge before saying anything

    • @ytg6663
      @ytg6663 Před rokem +2

      I am happy you know the truth 😅

    • @truthtalker9375
      @truthtalker9375 Před rokem

      Why you triggered by something which not have meaning in current time?...kya fark padta hai ki Vedic me occupational tha ki birth base because we never saw that and by just one book rigveda we can't say that in vedik era everything was good 🤷🏻‍♂️...we don't have 1% evidence before Ashoka Empire so how can you give any conclusion?...i know you're defending your religion but first know the whole side and then speak something 😊

    • @sassy2712
      @sassy2712 Před rokem

      @@truthtalker9375 is that triggered answer? I humbly said to give him information, u got triggered by knowing the truth, one book? Brooooo books ki quantity se uski value pta karega ab tu?

    • @sassy2712
      @sassy2712 Před rokem

      @@truthtalker9375 kon bola sab sahi tha? Why u need all the evidence in written?

    • @sassy2712
      @sassy2712 Před rokem

      @@truthtalker9375 i m not defending anyone, i m just stating facts rascal

  • @IntArch
    @IntArch Před 11 měsíci

    If a dalit gets converted tomorrow to muslim or xtian then whats the logic of denying atrocities done to them for 2000 years.

  • @rinasharma854
    @rinasharma854 Před rokem

    Sir, you got it wrong Verna system is based on occupation not on birth 😊

    • @letsunboxing8630
      @letsunboxing8630 Před 11 měsíci +1

      But instead a reality it just based on birth don't be oversmart

    • @MOIN836
      @MOIN836 Před 4 dny

      Rina sharma reservation is happen due to your ancestors...

  • @woman178
    @woman178 Před 8 měsíci

    Kiya bol raha yae pata hi nehi Christian ko reservation Mila huwa hai bharat ka hai ya nehi

  • @opg9712
    @opg9712 Před rokem +2

    If someone from dalit community has converted to Muslim and Christian than s/he is a Muslim or Christian not Dalit Muslim or Dalit Christian....yeh kya baat huyi Muslim or Christian banne ke baad bhi koi kese Dalit Muslim or Dalit Christian ho sakta hai yeh to bass chutiya banane ki baat huyi fir to

    • @AjaySharmaIND
      @AjaySharmaIND Před rokem +1

      Ekdam sahi baat hai😂 ek toh yeh log convert hoke humko gaali dete hai phir inko humse fayeda bhi chahiye

    • @MOIN836
      @MOIN836 Před 4 dny

      ​@@AjaySharmaINDcasteism india me increase ho raha hai....ya sab tum logo ke karname hai

  • @sudhanshupatra5777
    @sudhanshupatra5777 Před 5 měsíci +1

    So it is clearly favoritism to others and suppressing sc Christian

  • @Notolerancetoterrrorism
    @Notolerancetoterrrorism Před 10 měsíci

    The simple solution is the religion based caste system should continue ro avoid people to convert into Islamic and Cheitianity religions.

  • @Abhijeet_Vishwakarma
    @Abhijeet_Vishwakarma Před 5 měsíci +1

    Reservation should only given to those SC/ST who are Hindus. No other religion should be given this status. Kyoki convert karne ke time to yahi kaha jata hai naa, ki Buddhism me equality hai, Christianity me equality hai aur Islam me equality hai, Sikhism me equality hai, aur saari burai to bas Hindu Dharma me hai. To bhai jao lo equality ka maja.

  • @RX-wo3tz
    @RX-wo3tz Před 5 měsíci

    No point in still be considered as sc aftrr conversion

  • @ShiaAzadari179
    @ShiaAzadari179 Před 9 měsíci

    Me Maharashtra ka muslim hu OBC se hu but mujhe 😅kuch fark nahi padhta mere kabiliyat hi meri pehchan hai mujhe koi reservation nahi chahiye

  • @junedshaikh9165
    @junedshaikh9165 Před rokem

    Milna cahaiye.

  • @rohanraj2483
    @rohanraj2483 Před rokem

    🙏

  • @athirasenan481
    @athirasenan481 Před 11 měsíci

    It's time to end the reservation.

  • @anilumale6966
    @anilumale6966 Před rokem

    At present majority of Dalit Cristian used their old Hindu identity for schedule cast reservations but this type of benefits not enjoying Dalit Muslims 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮

  • @kamalrana5087
    @kamalrana5087 Před rokem +1

    Hindu dharm me jati pratha hai isiliye Hindu society ko hi SC ST OBC ka status milna chahiye

  • @anuragrawat2011
    @anuragrawat2011 Před rokem

    Ni dena chahiye reservation, kyuki wo convert hue kyu ki wo castism k shikaar the but agar unko convert hone par bhi benefit na mile toh unki kismat, also unko minority ka status milta hi hai toh sc / obc kyu de waise bhi obc me bhut caste aate hai hinduo me

  • @ShivamJha2002
    @ShivamJha2002 Před rokem

    if they again convert back to Hinduism then it can be happen

  • @extradose
    @extradose Před rokem +1

    Important topic 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻

  • @chandnioram3165
    @chandnioram3165 Před rokem

    👍

  • @CutShort_Review
    @CutShort_Review Před rokem

    Why Bramhin are not eligible for reservation??? Please make a video on the topic and show present financial status of them.....

  • @dhampal5948
    @dhampal5948 Před 4 měsíci +2

    Sc Buddhist ko milta he reservation

  • @nishasingh7630
    @nishasingh7630 Před rokem

    Yes it is right

  • @mr.shivaaysingh333
    @mr.shivaaysingh333 Před rokem

    If any one by birth in SC community in Islam & Christianity.

  • @harerampathak8653
    @harerampathak8653 Před rokem

    Jb ab bhi we dalit hi hai to religion change khuy kiya
    Waise bhi abrahmic religion mein caste hota hi nahi hai.

  • @bickydey7903
    @bickydey7903 Před rokem

    Half learned information about religion is what i get in this video ,no religion is egalitarian specially islam their is discrimination if u can ask someone from this religion.

  • @abhishekkumartiwari5191
    @abhishekkumartiwari5191 Před rokem +2

    Ni milna chahiye ni to aur log hindu se muslim banenge aur reservation ka benifit uthayenge

  • @Rohan-ej2cq
    @Rohan-ej2cq Před rokem +2

    Is se toh general ko problem aur hogi 🤔

    • @ytg6663
      @ytg6663 Před rokem +3

      यहीतो मजे की बात है जातिवाद नहीं चाहिए पर जाति के नाम पर रिजर्वेशन सबको चाहिए😅😅😅
      जाति चली गई तो घाटे का सौदा होगा सब जनरल में आ जाएंगे 😅😅😅

    • @itachi6523
      @itachi6523 Před rokem

      Cut off will go higher for us general category

    • @prateekchaudhary8188
      @prateekchaudhary8188 Před rokem

      Hamari gand maregi

  • @clashwithfriendscolony7195

    Exploitation kare upper caste aur ham bugtan kare

  • @kdprajapati307
    @kdprajapati307 Před rokem +1

    Thanks for dear sir

  • @Abhijit9703
    @Abhijit9703 Před 5 měsíci

    Dalit christian should also be given SC/ST status

  • @itishreedash2157
    @itishreedash2157 Před rokem +1

    Jo convert honge unko koi bhi reservation nhi milna chaiye na Sc na St na OBC

  • @Anime-358
    @Anime-358 Před rokem +1

    cast change kardo fir reservation chaiye to ..simple...

  • @deveshbanaj9156
    @deveshbanaj9156 Před rokem

    Violation of Article 14

  • @Manthan_Bhandary
    @Manthan_Bhandary Před rokem

    Kabhi NCERT ke Se Bahar Aayi aur Sanatan Dharm ke bare mein padhiye Uske bad Jo aapane video ke starting Mein bataya hai usko galat Lagega aapko Kyunki cast system main Jo Jis kam Mein Nipun Hota tha usko wahi cast Milta tha ..... aur Rahi Baat education ki....
    97% education percentage tha gurukul thaa jab Bharat main ((( The first school in England opened in 1811. At that time India had 732000 Gurukuls)))
    Aur jo log convert hue hain to Aur Bhi log fayde ke liye convert Honge Agar ine Logon Ko reservation mil Jaega To😊

  • @sunnykumarsingh8490
    @sunnykumarsingh8490 Před rokem +1

    Reservation is not bhandara ...ki Prasad abhi ko baata jaye

  • @razor-xn2ve
    @razor-xn2ve Před rokem +1

    Ashraf ajla arzal 😂😂😂😂😂
    We don't know any of this

  • @saheb3500
    @saheb3500 Před rokem +1

    Q milega..E sab india k nhi hai...Bahar k hai... Aur muslim , christan m to divide nhi hai..ehi to batate hai . Jab description nhi hai to kisliye reservation

  • @Truth_is_deprived
    @Truth_is_deprived Před rokem

    Abrahamic Religions me To Caste nhi hota fir unko SC kaise mil sakta hai...

  • @prateekchaudhary8188
    @prateekchaudhary8188 Před rokem +2

    General caste : maaro sab milke maaro hamko , salo choodo maat hamko 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @madhusoodanprasad2248
      @madhusoodanprasad2248 Před rokem +1

      Tumko indirectly 51% reservation mil raha he
      Aur population bhi less than 20 % he

    • @sonofgod793
      @sonofgod793 Před rokem

      @@madhusoodanprasad2248 😂 kuch log pichle 5000 se bus ro hi rahe ha or aane wala 5000 saal bhi ro ge likh lo 100 kay 1000% bhi reservation le liya na talented log ka barabari nhi kar pao ge 🤣😂