REPLAY: International Court of Justice hears Israel's response to Gaza genocide accusations
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 01. 2024
- Israel on Friday rejected as "a grossly distorted story" accusations brought by South Africa at the UN's top court that its military operation in Gaza is a state-led genocide campaign aimed at wiping out the Palestinian population. South Africa, which filed the lawsuit at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in December, asked judges on Thursday to impose emergency measures ordering Israel to immediately halt the offensive.
#Israel #genocide #Gaza
🔔 Subscribe to France 24 now: f24.my/YTen
🔴 LIVE - Watch FRANCE 24 English 24/7 here: f24.my/YTliveEN
🌍 Read the latest International News and Top Stories: www.france24.com/en/
Like us on Facebook: f24.my/FBen
Follow us on X (Twitter): f24.my/Xen
Browse the news in pictures on Instagram: f24.my/IGen
Discover our TikTok videos: f24.my/TKen
Get the latest top stories on Telegram: f24.my/TGen
Shame on all people who support Hamas
Shame on you for watching an entire people be oppressed and make a statement like this
facts
Shame on all people and ideology that supports and encourages atrocities of innocents. Shame on you.
Shame on all the people who support the murder of thousands and thousands of people, men, women and children that had no knowledge at all of what was planned for Oct. 7. Every Palestinian isn't part of hamas. A 7-month-old baby isn't part of hamas.
Jews and Palestinians are all human,,Israel has always ready to seek peace,,,what about Hamas,,,always thinks of violation,,killing,rape etc,,,,I say again and again shame on all of you who support those who thinks of annihilating Israel,,,shame on you who never value peace,but always support violation
You can"t break in someone"s home and claim self defense
@@in-x-orable2769 So by your logic everyone has the right to go back to Africa, murder people left and right since all our ancestors came from Africa?
Can you make a deadly violence and hide yourself at home and then accuse of attack?
Actually in some rare cases, you can
@@temetade4562lauuuuuuuuuud have mercy on poor souls
@@in-x-orable2769 Since when did Eastern Europeans claimed heritage in the Arabian peninsular?
People have an amazing capacity to rationalize hatred and cruelty.
Why hasn't this channel aired South Africa's side of the argument from yesterday? .. We all know why
By Hamas ?
By South Africa?
Especially the Hamas supporters
@@hakunamatatatata it was aired. I watched it. Not sure what channel but you can find it anywhere.
100%
How do you minimize harm when whole apartment blocks are bombed?
The isreal lawyers will demonstrate how is that possible.Because 23 000 people are dead mostly women and childres are very few confirmed Hamas MILITANTS.
And Is-a-hell cut off water, food and electricity, starving the population
@@mcata3625What they did you dam right To late October 7 2023 I thank you for standing with Isreal
If an apartment block has explosive and terrorists firing rockets from there, does that make it a legitimate target or not?
The enite block? No. If you were in a block with a serial killer, is it proportional for the police to bombard it?
23 , 000 is protecting civilians what is a Shame
you realise that that is restraint on Israel's part, right?
It is your/hummus choice to fight on the battlefield or the court, you can't have both.
@@agnelomascarenhas8990hmmm now i understand why the IDF shot their own while escaping from Hamas…
Don't forget the 7000 missing
@@in-x-orable2769lol restraint. Yeah since the United States didn’t use a nuke in Iraq or Afghanistan that is an example of restraint as well.
The Amount of lies that comes from their mouth is Unprecedented
Who's mouth ? There's 5000 years of hatred & persecution to party over, if you know your History.
Barely 3 minutes into the speech, he is already screaming SA doesn't recognise Israel's right to exist. Lol! These guys are so predictable.
@@railwaymechanicalengineer4587 This is not a 5000 year situation; it's 75 years.
@@sivuyilemtsi9840 the price of copium is up this year
@@sivuyilemtsi9840 Predictable?Israelis?? I wonder why.... I really do 🤔🤔
did they ever find the command centre under the Al shifa hospital?
They find lot of tunnels though !!
@@vromano9543They built bunkers.
It was found the tunnels do not even connect to the hospital. So in other words no. A few guns by an MRI machine only which of course makes no sense for anyone who actually understands an MRI machine will suck them in
@@PearlBooysen yes you are right, they did build bunkers underneath hospitals and in other "sensitive places".... former israeli prime Minister Barak even said so during an interview. But, He also mentioned tunnels connecting said structures as well. i think its safe to assume hamas built more tunnels (from what isreali built first)
No
The South African effort is futile, it won't hold water.
How can a group of hyenas are holding my family in dungeon and someone who is seating in his country peacefully drinking coffee and eating fat burger come to court and asks me to stop fighting!
What???
SA claims: "You did genocidal acts. Here's the proof."
Yisrael defense: "Yes, but.."
HAMAS did no crime? the hostages they are holding what does that mean?
@@BillionDollar-os9vdhamas is a non state actor and israel is one of the most well equipped militaries in human history. No way you can convince me October 7th warrants a genocide, especially after all the wrongs Palestinians have gone through since 1947
Who said yes? You failing already.
What about 1948-2006 , before smart phones and the widespreading of social media showing what is really happening there and has been for 75 years none of that matters !!
No palestinian share in this mess?
Thank you! Everyone acts as if Palestine didn't have a reason for Oct 7. Did anyone ask how it was possible for Israel to exchange 3 to 1, so many Palestinian women & children? Everyone is concerned about kidnapped Israelis, what about the kidnapped Palestinians?! Are they less important? Were they sent over to be imprisoned by Hamas, since everything is Hamas' fault? Unbelievable!
@@FlorenceEluexactly
Shame on South Africa and the actors behind South Africa.
Stop the lies😂
South Africa, which stars in the list of 10 countries with the highest murders per capita in the world, can blame another country?
SA is not committing genocide
Shameful bias
go say this on some more clips champ
@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763 Its doing its best against white farmers.
@@joblo6394 Why are you threatening?
Why non of the Israelis look middle eastern meaning ethnic Jews?
@@samihade2853 real palestinians are also gone
Most of them are from the Europe and USA ZIONIST"
To be an "ethnic Jew" has nothing to do with what you look like and a lot to do with what your DNA reveals. Remember the Jews are "the twelve wandering tribes" as they themselves declare frequently in the Old Testament, and over the last 2000 years have spread themselves, like a financial plague across much of the planet.
Don't forget little Bernie Madoff (now in jail for the $57 BILLION he nicked) & that pervert Epstein, who topped himself in jail. Both Hebrew Jews. The Jews have been persecuted repeatedly for the last 5000 years, beginning with the Ancient Egyptians & Sumerians and most recently by Joseph Stalin, who sent near 10 Million of them, to the Siberian "Gulags" up until his death in 1953.
So the question is "What is it that the Jews repeatedly do, to get themselves persecuted by virtually every Nation they have tried to settle in for the last 5000 years" ? !!!!
Hey ...how many Israelis have you seen? 85% of Israelis come from the MIDDLE EAST. FACT CHECK ME
Cos they are converts
No-one with eyes in their head will believe this spin.
We do
@@PearlBooysen yeah cause you yourself are an oppressor and land stealer. Of course you'll flock together
I do believe it
I believe it big time!
@@Bar_Bar27 whereas killing children isn’t?
Half the world, or more, can tell if someone is lying. It’s like a fake smile, some people know exactly what it looks like, some people are convinced the other one is smiling.
So , you have no clue and you talk abou "smile" ????
So you'll shoot someone because of "smile" ?
@@GoodMan_000 what is your point?
Wot?
They brought so much shame onto themselves
Big shame
how?
Yes Hamas did
@@julietspaintings diaper force😂
Is that an argument against an accusation of genocide?
Big hypocrisy
All of existence, space and time, and the Big Bang seems to have happened on 7 October. The irony of this guy talking about context.
Exactly. "All of history began on October 7 and we will not talk about the context of our occupation, but dare you accuse us of something and we will complain that your court appeal about our ongoing actions is 'obscuring the context' of what happened on October 7".
More countries need to bring cases to the ICJ.
Like who for what?
Against themselves especially.
They talk about one day what about the 100 days after 😢
And 75 years before
@@riagiv01 75 years ago they lost and refuse to make peace. that's why they are living in misery
Israel could have solve this in one day, I guess.
But Israel is not Hamas.
Thanks for pointing this aspect.
They can't disprove what they did.
Thats horrible what Hamas did...
Response was worse!
Yes because they are terrorists. Hammas.
Biden is chancellor palpatine 😂😂😂
What a no lame argument. He needs to stop. It’s embarrassing to see him defend the indefensible
and somehow you find excuses for hamas
So you did not his defend as right, o yes,indeed 😅
@@BillionDollar-os9vd As expected from a fellow nodding western fascist.
Like South Africa supporting Hamas (Terrorist Organization).
I guess you like killing Js? Whatever.
As I understand figures “statistics” used by Hamas before have been found generally accurate afterwards.
The health ministry just counts the number of dead bodies. In previous conflicts the numbers have been very accurate compared to UN reviews afterwards
Yes, they've always reported accurately, and the UN has no reason to doubt them and their record.
I seriously doubt that.
@@RobespierreThePoof thankfully you aren't in the UN.
@@tobastiananderssonplease share article where this was stated
Numbers over time don’t lie. We know who the aggressor is
Where is the evidence?
They don't have any. You have to just believe them or you're anti-Semitic
🤦♀️
In the Geneve convention, the supressed are allowed to take up arms again oppressers. The story does not start with Hamas, but with annexing other's homes.
What HAMAS did is NOT defensible!!!! PERIOD ....
@@juliareichenbacher2478Yes it is, adding "period" doesnt make a statement to be true,just for you to know
@@juliareichenbacher2478ya I don’t think you understand periods, even in capital letters, doesn’t erase history
Trying to claim we are trying to help with aid, when that only occurred because pf US pressure and you still have the water turned off, isn’t an easy sell.
Why must they even be burdened to provide for the enemy is beyond me.
@@PearlBooysen when you claim children are your enemy you loose.
@@PearlBooysen if not for evil intentions, why should you have control over it in the first place?
@@PearlBooysen An occupying Force may not cut off the water supply to an occupied population.
@@PearlBooysenah yes 1 million children are the enemy, what next should we take away their iPads?
Still lying in front of a court😅😅😅😅😅😅
They can't help themselves, it's in their DNA
Ridiculous argument: NO ONE is denying the Hamas attack. Also, attacking South Africa is waaaaaaay off base.
I said South African leaders,you know those championing this. I know there are others not for this.
whos paying south africa to bring this case? someone is funding it and behind it . Hamas?1
I almost broke my TV never took everything in my power to withhold throwing my shoe at the screen
South Africa is 'just another BRICS in the wall' LOL
OMG!!! He said, they are blowing up their own buildings with boobytraps.😂😂😂 These people are ruthless💯
Thats the truth
@@dortebrahe7359another liar😂
It very very true!
Its true get over it.
@@edmurks236 Get over genocide! Wonderful human you are💯
Two wrongs dont make a right,blaming game has begun i pray for all the innocent soul...
Exactly
Oh dear......now he's denying casualties on the civilian population of Palestinians. Disgusting, just disgusting.
Who even gave you those figures all of you so much cringe on, is it not Hamas. Were you expecting those figures to be real?.
@@winnersfootballtv5517all lies from Hamas. Hamas is their Idol
@@winnersfootballtv5517don't you see WHO and other health organisation also update on the death and MIA list? how long will you feign your ignorance?
Shame
The amount of LIES!
Be more specific, they're all lying !!!
@@edmurks236 Yea yea sure, exactly that 👏👌
@@sohaybelgendy4919 No genocide no ceasefire.
@@edmurks236 No brain either!
What about the tunnels they found in the synagogue in New York lol😂
Those tunnels are for hiding so please don't mention them because we will hide in them if you like it or not
And the bloodied mattresses!
@@user-gh9qv5yn7glol...they will say it's Hamas
@@cognitionup5211 Wot?
@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763 They are not like Hamas blaming Israel all the time. Get over it.
Heartbreaking and terrifying
There’s a lot of projecting going on my dude and that’s just in the first minute
by whom?
@@edmurks236israel be lying for fun
@@tray8928 NO.Clearly not!
Joint airstrikes, led by the U.S., targeted Houthi military capabilities in Yemen. The strikes received support from Australia, Bahrain, Canada, and the Netherlands.
"It's not our fault."
Oh, and a drinking game: take a shot every time he says "unprecedented."
I don't want to die of alcohol poisoning. Thank you!
We heard 30 minutes of "poor me" from a 'professional victim'
17 mins in... still hasn't explained how it's not a genocide.
Ángela Diffley’s account is so bias in favor of Israel in that her summary of Tal Becker’s leaves the impression that Tal Becker’s presentation was somewhat sufficient to counteract South Africa’s accusations against Israel!
They could not defend very well. We all know who will win.
South Africa WINS ALWAYS! Doesn’t???
@@sandindamae.iwantmetowin5652no they won't.
How much was South Africa paid by Hamas to bring on this case?!
@@edmurks236 JOKER.
@@edmurks236 probably not much AIPAC and Zionist pay too many players especially in media and courts. If you kill 11000 children and get sunak to say it's not genocide, then Zionist sure pay well
Abused and starved in captivity- he must be talking about Israeli “administrative detention”.
Whataboutism, the argument.
😂
South Africa must be losing the argument people can see through their lies.
@@edmurks236 state one lie
How poor their argument comparing with the lawyer of South Africa. Yet they are not ashamed.
Why would they be ashamed? Hamas and terrorists South Africa is supporting terrorists.
How can this man outright lie to the ICC. He should be charged fir this also.
You and who should charge who hope you brought your judge 😂
ICJ
You would think they would know not to give evidence in Arabic written or audio without knowing for sure what it says! The man on the audio said he killed soldiers not women. Liars.
He is tiny hatter. Lying and stealing comes naturally
Some times you need to discern the truth. It's sometimes difficult to understand the truth because man is by nature a lair.
I don't think Jewish people are in your hearts 😢🥺💔
Surgery for Angiosarcoma - a medical success story
No they aren't ! They've been persecuted by virtually every Nation in Europe & the Middle East for the last 5000 years. Beginning with the Ancient Egyptians & Sumerians, then in the Middle Ages, the British, the French, the Spanish & the Italians. And by WW2 the Germans & then the Russians ! Which beggars the Question "What is it that the Jews repeatedly do, that usually results in them being persecuted within 50 years of their arrival in any country" ? !!!
@@aleejones7508 why should they care about others? They believe they are gods chosen, making everyone else disposable.
@@iMeanWell857 Is that a bit of Hamas brainwash doctrine?!
Antisemitism is everywhere but the Jews are God's chosen people and God's covenant with them is everlasting.
Zechariah 8:13 ESV
[13] And as you have been a byword of cursing among the nations, O house of Judah and house of Israel, so will I save you, and you shall be a blessing. Fear not, but let your hands be strong."
Lol Hammas rockets damage cars this guy is a joke
😂
We missed the video they found tunnel.....
France 24!
Are u for palestine / hamas bcos ur report is always on lsrael's response. We hardly see ur report on what is going on in lsrael and Ukraine 🇺🇦, why??
We hardly see what hezbolla is doing against lsrael and all that,why!
Do the work of complete report.
The "in whole or in part" definition renders the term so nebulous as to be almost devoid of meaning. Attacking an opposing army would fit this definition.
The real question is whether the world will tolerate the insult of these word games.
.
No, it doesn't.
"the world" has already made a decision based on evidence presented. The world is just waiting to see if ICJ agrees.
The damage to Isr is already done. It won't get "better", but ICJ saying Isr is committing Gennie will make the damage a whole lot worse. It will literally make being friendly with Isr the worst thing any democratically elected leader could do.
And that's just the start! Imagine a world where something like Starbucks can legitimately and with legal evidence be shown to be a part of Gennie! Havoc.
For those accusing Israel for genocide, what started with anger, will end in shame.
Rudy Giuliani would have been a perfect fit for the Israeli defense team
He has a point a very weak point
No, as the case is to hear Israeli crimes, since then
He has nothing.
If he believes humus committed genocide he'd should bring the case forward 😂
You just want it to be weak. He has many strong points.
Bravo🙏
I cannot find the corresponding replay of the South African charges ?
South Africa spoke yesterday
hopefully SA's move of taking israel to court will give other countries the same confidence to do so against other countries who are doing bad
yeah like Russia
This is a court of law. You need to give a proper rebuttal, not an emotive monologue. The settlers have employed cheap lawyers with no substance!
They are so hung up on October 7, but not their barbarism every day since. They are nuts. They don't understand the freakin question is regarding everyday since. Bored of their bloody whingeing.
did Hamas stop after Day1?
Crocodile tears 😢
Dont insult crocodiles
so nasty
Those rape allegations have been debunked 😅😅😅😅
Let's see if evidence will be presented in it.
@@winnersfootballtv5517 there really is none, otherwise they would have shown it a million times already.
Incorrect the evidence has been shown to representatives, officials of America and including UK government. Now this case is raised I would expect that the evidence will be presented to these judges and if proven to be true, then the UN will have to move against Hamas !
I have seen the guy from the greyzone try to debunk them. Unfortunately, he fails and it is all guesses by a guy that never stepped foot over there. He also uses quotes and several different things that are false. The greyzone is a conspiracy website that loves to go on opposite narratives on several conflicts.
@@winnersfootballtv5517they have none, they said all the victims are dead and no forensic evidence were taken at the scene, but they are 100% sure women were raped including a 14 year old, that's how sick they are
Useless talk. Save your salvia and zip it.
Now they are trying it cannot apply to them
Al Jazeera has excellent proffessional coverage.
I disagree. Very partisan
Has CIA in...
Yes, to the Muslim side of things.
@@andrewmuleba8883gahah😂 entire western media especially bbc , cnn , fox , CNBC and more is extremely biased towards isreal, entire western media in supporting isreal blindly. U say Al Jazeera is biased 😂😂 what a joke, .
When all the media is biased to one evil side , there must be media to show the other side .
@@andrewmuleba8883
Al Jazeera has non biased worldwide news and political coverage presenting all sides complete with accurate history.
South Africa of all countries. Some historical irony here. 😄
South Africa has this in the bag.
South Africa has a weak case.
Becker for the win!!
Israeli’s and Palestinians alike…did he really say that!!!!!
When heart gets harder the eyes goes blind!!
remembered someone said it
Truth first,God's Jutice,then peace can happen.
How can this lawyer sleep at night?
Stop the cap
I wonder what those families want.. With ceasefire there's chances of getting their families alive then with the indiscriminate bombing
Stop Genocide in Gaza
He forgot to bring the Violin
Maybe he was up on the roof
Weren't you hearing it in the background
All wars in mwdetranian countries becoming strong but needed strong legal on the court opposite illegal articles in the war contineusly
Other wise if doest stop Wii spread all over the world
International court of justice must support legal articles in the accusation and support for the law judgement
Words and words yet no proof!!
Not a lot of evidence is there
Khamas 😂
Why hasn't this channel aired South Africa's side of the argument from yesterday? .. We all know why
it has wakeup
What are they defenses against the accusation of Africa?
May Justice be served.
Following
This is the lawyer from jeffrey epstein
what a pathetic statement.
Long live the descendants of King David and continue to rule their Promised Land
The Jews of the Old Testament are long gone you moron. Most are from Europe! Descendants of David?? What a sad joke
U make a genocide "what the evidence of" hole..."who proved?
What about Al jahere?????
The world can see through the lies
Hamas lies ? there's evidence to support the fact that Hamas terrorists are lying.
Both the actions of Hamas as well as the actions of Israeli settlers and extremists are genocidal. Both parties hold the peaceful majority in agony by perpetuating this whole conflict. Both have to be designated as the problem SIMULTENEOUSLY.
The settlers were not displaced from their homes , the settlers have an entire state apparatus including army. What do you even mean ? lol Resisting displacement and abuse is not genocide.
@@Valkyri3Z The settlers ARE displacing Palestinians which makes them extremists. They pursue in principle the same goal as Palestinian extremists, namely the displacement or eradication of the ones they deem "lesser".
Hope that explains it.
You are a Neil Chamberlain. A pacifist. Like South Africa you think you can please everyone
There would be no hamas , if there was no occupation, apartheid, massacres committed in 1948. You need to understand oct 7th didn’t just happen.
Survey's by Palestinian Universities have shown that over 70% of Palestinians approve of the attrocities that were committed on October 7th. There is no just silent Palestinian majority.
Wow to you South African leaders championing this. Shame with be your portion for picking a wrong fight from a wrong end putting yourselves on wrong side of history. These men can never be my heroes.
I understand and totally agree with you @andrewmuleba8883
@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763Don't if only we, say if only I, meaning you alone.
I seriously can't tell which side you're on. That comment was a grammatical train wreck.
@@WobblieSkellie don't worry about it. You will lose nothing if you don't understand it.
I'm 20 minutes in...at some point is he going try to defend Israeli actions or is his argument literally that "Hamas bad"
Israel and Israelis one thing is certain because you are God's people and his inheritance this is bone of contention. Never mind any kind of accusations any nation or nations may bring against you. Since the world could not rise up and demand immediate release of a ten months old baby just turned one year old. What a wicked and evil world. God is your defense. One thing is important you are a special people. I love you all and I always pray for the peace of Israel. Shalom! Shalom!! Shalom!!!
Were ther prove prove
Mouth can lie but heart cannot
To some people, lies come out NATURALLY like LANGUAGE