Ariana sounds like an old classic, Beyonce sounds Majestic, Mariah sounds like she's in church, Jennifer sounds like a Broadway Star 😅❤ They all sounded beautiful
Even Patty LaBell stood up. Mariah for me 🎉❤however all are very successful and amazing singers. Jhud gave me goosebumps 🎉 can't choose my top 2 Mariah and Jennifer ❤❤
@@LAERON_messy boots, the comment said “her take” not the total summation of her gotd@mn vocal ability or inability. Y’all get offended if an ant break its leg 🤦🏾♀️ it was just LOUD!! The caption asked who did it better? And you giving opinion speeches. Go live!
I think only patti stood up which is dumb because that was the most impressive vocal performance I’ve ever heard, maybe ppl weren’t supposed to stand idk
Ariana- the old class❤ Bey- the beautiful tone❤ mariah- the incredible riffs❤ Jennifer- the powerful belting ❤ Can't find the best, they sang differently yet its all beautiful.
@@earthsangel9502Jennifer Hudson truly loved Whitney Houston She ate everyone here Her Vocal range and power are unmatched No tricks gimmicks or whatsoever 😊
@@maddiejung974but did you listen? When she starts to sing she doesn’t just scream. The ocean parts, mountains walk, the sun rejoices and the moon roosts. But I understand if people can’t hear it through the “screaming”
Mariah's vocal "tricks" are getting old and tired. After all these years the tricks are nothing if they don't come from somewhere deep, real and are an almost soul filled explosion coming out of her. Years ago when she first started performing i remember how she was ridiculed for moving her hand as she sang higher and higher as if we couldnt hear it ourselves. It was a showoff not erupting from a truly soulful place. Notes without subtext. Jennifer's powerful voice doesn't need tricks it is soul from her soul.
@@josepho.8317you can hear it pull her voice to the notes( A4, B4, &C5).it doesnt sound like she corrected it herself. Try and listen before getting all defensive. Beyonce is an amazing singer, but there is pitch correction on this particular clip.
@@JessieKeeksJennifer Hudson, and EGOT winner? R&b singer, former American Idol contestant, Oscar winner for Dreamgirls, talk show host, coach on The Voice?
They need to cast her as Dorothy in a remake like last year or year before that! 😅 She is really fitting the singing style of Dorothy. RIP Judy Garland. She's smiling from heaven!
@@euphoriaissleepy4207 I prefer powerhouse voices. Support? What do you mean, her stance and the fact she was in the studio? This rhetorical. I didn't put the video together. Just gave my opinion 🤷🏿♀️ not going under other ppl opinion/comment talking about this and that.
@@QueenDivineLove …By support I mean she needed the ability to support the note that she was singing via support from the diaphragm. So to say she didn’t need “nothing” is straight up false
She’s amazing. I think Ariana and Beyoncé did it more to the style of the song thou. I don’t think the song is Mariah or Jenifers style. Something about it didn’t feel right for the specific song. Still beautiful. I just don’t think this is the song choice for them.
Yall so fooled Beyonce has a special Mic yall are behind time I grew up with this Era shes another Cardi b with a Country sucker not free suit on the lied nobody bought no Texas toast or whatever she did the world dragged her a d she gets a #1 Beyonce needs to go back where she was making ivy park wasn't thinking about her fans AFTER TAKING YALL MONEY AND DO THE SAME THING.....AT THE END OF THE DAY BEYONCE SHOULD NOT BE IN THERE HER ENTIRE LUFE WAS NEGOTIABLE NOW SHES PRETENDING TO BE BRITNEY SPEARS SHES TRAPPED SHE CRAZY JUST LIKE HER ENTIRE FAMIKY BEYONCE HARD DEEP VIICE WHEN SHE SANG THAT SONG WE KNEW AND MARIAH IS SINGING TBE SONG THAT WAY ARIANA AND JENNIFER MARIAH ARE UNTOUCHABLE, HER OWN SISTER KNOW ITS A JOKE
But she did get a standing ovation from Patti Labelle. And Mariah is a diva and that girl definitely loves her church I don't know I couldn't tell. I mean she ain't no Madonna I mean have you seen her in like a prayer girl that girl is touched by the spirit. That's the only time you can dance like that and at church and not get in trouble okay. 🤣🤣💀💀
@biochemica2 Orrrrrr, it's what I said, honey I'm a classically trained vocalist as well and I said wtf I said: At times, Mariah Carey does too much. PERIOD
@@joberry877 first of all that was patti's arrangements in her cover and she was doing a tribute to patti so if ur saying mariah is doing "too much" that equals to patti doing too much with the glissando bffr
@imsodonewithlife69 Check this out, THIS is MY OPINION just like everyyyyyyyyy one else jumped up on here and said wtf they felt, I'm doing the same. And Patti is Patti, what's for her is for her. Just because she did it like that does not mean Mariah had to, dear. It didn't give what it was supposed to for me coming from her during that particular performance. PERIOD. Shit happens. I was not feeling it. As an artist, you can be creative and come up with your own style of singing a song. She does it all the time. So, no need for that 'first of all' like you really thought you read me🤣 I said what I said. Good day.
Ariana...walking through a meadow
Beyonce...ice skating
Mariah...a concert
Jennifer...bellowing to the gods
😊 I can see how you see this.
Well analysed💯
🤗
Correct is right
❤🤍✨
Ariana sounds like an old classic, Beyonce sounds Majestic, Mariah sounds like she's in church, Jennifer sounds like a Broadway Star 😅❤ They all sounded beautiful
Yes, Ariana Grande gave us the
Judy Garland version ok.
MATTERS PEACE&LOVE
My daughter can sing any of “woman” under the table any day
Shes mimicking that's all she's good at
Accurate 😂
Perfect assumation and analysis!!
Jennifer Hudson’s voice is amazing 😍
Annoying she will never tap Whitney Houston
@@Uzziah33Random comment. Odd 🤦🏽♂️
@@Uzziah33bro no one said anything that has to do with whitney LOL
Ariana = gusts of wind
Beyonce = bursts of lightning
MC = rumbling thunder
Jennifer = Intense Storm
Ariana - sweet and soft
Beyoncé - clear and pure
Mariah - soulful and passionate
Jennifer - powerful and strong
Mariah/ 10%
Jennifer/8.5%
Ariana/ 8.%
Beyonce/ 6%
@@patricedavis3889I'd switch ari and bey but basically the same rating
@@patricedavis3889Mariah wasn't 10. That glissando was weak. That's definitely Patti's territory.
Agreed!❤
Best description
Ariana - Disney
Beyonce - Broadway
Mariah - Madison Square Garden
Jennifer - Super Bowl
😂🎉❤
These are all out of order😂😂
100 legit
Even Patty LaBell stood up. Mariah for me 🎉❤however all are very successful and amazing singers. Jhud gave me goosebumps 🎉 can't choose my top 2 Mariah and Jennifer ❤❤
@@patriciaellis490QUEEN MC!! 👏👏🙌🏻💯🐑🦋
JENNIFER JUST KILLED IT!!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤
Mariah sang the shit of 3 words lol ❤
Facts lol
Ariana: classical
Beyonce: beautiful
Mariah: soulful
Jennifer: powerful
All wonderful.
Wow 1.1k likes!! Thanks guys .
Ari sounds like a child singing
Beyoncé did that
All wonderful I’m a soprano so I love the. soft n graceful of Beyoncé vocals everyone else did amazing as well 💯💖😍🥰
Perfect response yes 🙌
👏👏👏👏👏
Jennifer sang that like she was really asking GOD "why can't I?"
Thats funny 😂😂.. cuz thats exactly how she sounded too
That way!!!❤👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
THAT PART!!
She was mad about it
😂😂😂😂
Beyoncé did it in such a satisfying way... ❤❤
Ariana... Disney Princess Singing
Beyonce...... Broadway
Mariah..... Musical
Jenifer..... Opera
Opera? 🌚
Jennifer is a powerhouse!!
She's on a other lvl her and Mariah
Jennifer hands down
Belting to the heavens and beyond so casually.😩 Just hand on her hip.
She’s just screaming and made my dog bark.
@@CherryJulibelting is technically screaming on pitch
Jennifer's voice just hit the target so clear
I never understand folks' awe of her. Her take was just loud. Lol. Idk.
@@blewprent so you want us to understand why you don't like her voice? should everyone and everything revolves around your opinions huh?
Why Jennifer just made my hair grow 12 inches?? Powerful
Lol omggg 💀@@LAERON_
@@LAERON_messy boots, the comment said “her take” not the total summation of her gotd@mn vocal ability or inability. Y’all get offended if an ant break its leg 🤦🏾♀️ it was just LOUD!! The caption asked who did it better? And you giving opinion speeches. Go live!
Mariahs switch up was fire 🔥 you can tell everyone was blown away and gave a standing ovation
Period
She’s truly amazing
I think only patti stood up which is dumb because that was the most impressive vocal performance I’ve ever heard, maybe ppl weren’t supposed to stand idk
Umm. I don't know what you saw but the only person who stood up was Ms Patti Labelle.
Ariana : talks to her doll
Beyonce: talks to her lover
Mariah: talks to the society
Jennifer: talks to God
👌
I like this one!🙏🏽✨✨
😅
Well put❤
❤perfection
Ariana- the old class❤
Bey- the beautiful tone❤
mariah- the incredible riffs❤
Jennifer- the powerful belting ❤
Can't find the best, they sang differently yet its all beautiful.
Oui
Yes!! 😊
Beyonce has the better riffs but true
Whtat is the orginal song name
Well said! There s no winners n losers in art…it ain’t sports
Jennifer Hudson, hands down!
Mariah
Mariah and Jennifer took us to church! Ariana and Bey took us to a Disney movie. None of them did bad
Perfect comment.
I don't think they didn't bad however I do agree they did give us more Disney
Mariah was not good, sorry. 😔
Best comment
Not Disney ...lol 😂
Ariana and Beyonce are singing the Judy Garland version and Mariah and JHud are singing the Patti Version
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Facts
Very much this 💯 😂
😂😂😂❤❤
😂😂😂😂
Beyonce ariana
I am sorry, but JENNIFER KILLED THAT!!!!!
Sorry but Jennifer scream 😂😂
No Mariah
She gave me chills🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Mirked it lol
You only look into power,,thats why you said it like that lol
Jennifer Hudson voice is theatrical mixed with church it’s just heavenly😩❤️
What’s the name of the song and by who?
Under the rainbow, the wiz/ the wizard of oz
Young Michael…like Jennifer…
Ariana
mariah !!
Ariana-Dreamy
Beyonce-Romantic
Mariah-Gospel
Jennifer-off the richter scale
Agree
Facts
Not off the Richter scale lmaooooooo 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Jennifer gave me goose bumps. She's singing in a frequency that goes deep in your soul. 🫡🫡🫡
Yesssssssss
Hitting them Whitney notes 👏
rip@@earthsangel9502
@@earthsangel9502Jennifer Hudson truly loved Whitney Houston
She ate everyone here
Her Vocal range and power are unmatched
No tricks gimmicks or whatsoever 😊
AGREED
Jennifer and Ariana
No contest. Jennifer’s voice is like bringing a bazooka to a water gun fight
What an Amazing analogy 👏 👌
Loud and shouting doesn't mean better.
@@maddiejung974but did you listen? When she starts to sing she doesn’t just scream. The ocean parts, mountains walk, the sun rejoices and the moon roosts. But I understand if people can’t hear it through the “screaming”
@@maddiejung974do you know what belting is?
@@paigenotpage do you know what volume control/technique is?
Jennifer Hudson sent a chill up my spine!!!! Bravo🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Me too
Yes Ma’am and that’s how you know ❤
Jennifer
Mariah.
Four different approaches and they each nailed it. Great vocalists just sangin!!! 👏👏👏👏
Yep, and you nailed it!
🎉❤
Jennifer sounds like the entire church choir and the congregation
Yesss 🤏🏿❤️🇧🇷
😂😂
Yesss
Yesss
😂😂😂😂
Ariana and Jennifer Hudson.
Beyonce
Jennifer hits it with the ancestral power backing her up.
Mariah's vocal "tricks" are getting old and tired. After all these years the tricks are nothing if they don't come from somewhere deep, real and are an almost soul filled explosion coming out of her. Years ago when she first started performing i remember how she was ridiculed for moving her hand as she sang higher and higher as if we couldnt hear it ourselves. It was a showoff not erupting from a truly soulful place. Notes without subtext. Jennifer's powerful voice doesn't need tricks it is soul from her soul.
😂😂
@@lourena5678JENIFER THEN BEONCYE
girl shut up.. @@terrygladney5362
@@terrygladney5362i feel you 😂
MC is talented but so fake and dramatic
Jennifer casually breaks the sound barrier 😂
Right! 😂 SO CASUALLY! I’m looking at her like wow how? She belts on a regular ol exhale 😂
🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀💀💀👏👏👏👏
Ariana and Jennifer!!!
Beyonce's tone on that "I" was amazing.
bc it's pitch corrected
@@jameswood1318 it's literally not
Fr soo beautiful
@@josepho.8317you can hear it pull her voice to the notes( A4, B4, &C5).it doesnt sound like she corrected it herself. Try and listen before getting all defensive. Beyonce is an amazing singer, but there is pitch correction on this particular clip.
Flat 😂
The power in Jennifer’s voice!!?🙌🏾😮💨❤️🔥
BLEW MY HAIR BACK...THROUGH MY PHONE!!!!
She is Dramatic Soprano
Jenniffer 🫶
Jennifer definitely gave powerhouse singer! Super star presence🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Jennifer for sure. Her voice had so much power and soul behind it.
Yh but no emotion
Big facts
true
But it wasn't perfect though...Maria's almost was n it had alot of power n emotion
@@scorpiocara6798 how did that not sound perfect? Just admit you're a Mariah fan and go 😂
Beyoncé
Mariah 200%
Ariana: Dreamy
Beyonce: Broadway
Mariah: Soulful
Jennifer: Epic
Who is Jennifer??
@@JessieKeeksJennifer Hudson, and EGOT winner? R&b singer, former American Idol contestant, Oscar winner for Dreamgirls, talk show host, coach on The Voice?
Oh jennifer is an EGOT winner, forgot. That just goes to show how crazy she went.
@@lissandrafreljord7913Let her KNOW❤
Jennifer blew that roof off. With Beyoncé I felt that in my soul. Maria killed that. And Ariana’s so soft, like a sweet lullaby.
They all nailed it
Jennifer does it best.. don't like Beyonce at all.
@margarettewest254 it was a bit screamy, Jennifer can belt more naturally. I like them all though
( Beyonces start was the prettiest imo)
@@angelbabyy5606it was not screaming try again
Jennifer ❤
Jennifer Hudson... Effortless!... Hands down.
I agree!
Mariah Carey
Cringe just she sings loud doesn't mean she's good
Why you hating 🤨
ariana- soft classic
bey- pageant pretty
mariah- church soul
jhud- ancestral power
Ancestral power! I love that description.
Yeah Ancestral Power is definitely the word ! 😮
😂😂😂ancestral power.😅
I’m cracking up 😂
Jennifer ❤🎉
Jennifer🔥 ❤👑❤️
Ariana was a Disney Princess
Beyonce was my favorite clean crisp with breathe control.
Mariah was givin concert
Jhud was Broadway
They need to cast her as Dorothy in a remake like last year or year before that! 😅 She is really fitting the singing style of Dorothy. RIP Judy Garland. She's smiling from heaven!
Best description
From the early 1900s
I agree w this 1000%
I like the way Jennifer does it best. Simple, clear, and full of emotion.
Agree. No adlibs needed. Sorry Mariah, just too messy & overkill. Jennifer did the assignment!!
She gave me the most goosebumps! My whole body felt her voice❤
Jennifer song straight notes with power and execution that’s why she was the best
They all did it simple fuck you mean
Ditto
JENNIFER HUDSON
Arianna
Jennifer's like "hold my drink", places hands on hips, and just slays effortlessly ✨️
YES 🙌🏾
Flat foot and sassy
😂😂😂😂
That woman's voice only god can do that miracle fosho❤❤
🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀👏👏 And you both ate. Love this comment so much. Truth.
Ariana sounds like a Disney princess from a movie made in the 1950’s.
😂😂😂😂
A Disney princess homewrecker? 😂
@@ClanToreador pfttt 🤣
@CommanderShepardSR2 she ate 😘
Ew, not bratty Ari...ew her voice is like everyone else's, nothing unique
Ariana sang it the best .❤👑
Beyonce for me
Jennifer Hudson’s voice is so powerful and clear. It’s out of this world that someone can sing at that level. God gave her the voice of an angel.
Honestly, she is so strong with it, and really rarely loses control. But sometimes she does. Listen to "My heart" it's, my fave song from her.
❤️❤️❤️❤️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🙏🏽🙏🏼
They’re all amazing but Jennifer’s actually gave me goosebumps🤯🤯
I literally came here to say this….
Mariah 💣💣💣💥💥💥💯💯💯👌
beyonce
Jennifer’s vocals are so STRONG and I love it, like she just belts like it’s nothing
Jennifer Hudson! Phenomenal voice, and very powerful ❤
Jennifer
Jennifer always taking you to church hunny!! It's kinda annoying though.. lol
Arianna protect 💯
@@amandaburke1808?
Ariana and Beyoncé
Btwn Beyoncé and Jennifer for me ❤️
Jennifer Hudson can blow a house down with that voice! ❤ That is pure power 😊
J all day!
Jennifer gives me goosebumps every time she sings almost a celestial note. She's beyond words my heart drops for Jennifer ❤
Mine blowing she might not have as much money as those 3 but she can't hit some notes 🎶🎶🎶 that touch your soul
Beyonce sounds like she singing for a movie that makes you tear up and jhud is a powerhouse
Beyoncé’s was beautiful and graceful.
I agree on Jennifer. She truly is in a whole nother level!
THIS
Jennifer Hudson didnt need nothing, not a run or nothing. She unmatched in this one. Her voice divine.
Definitely
She needed a lot of support to even hit that note though-
@@euphoriaissleepy4207 I prefer powerhouse voices. Support? What do you mean, her stance and the fact she was in the studio? This rhetorical. I didn't put the video together. Just gave my opinion 🤷🏿♀️ not going under other ppl opinion/comment talking about this and that.
@@QueenDivineLove …By support I mean she needed the ability to support the note that she was singing via support from the diaphragm. So to say she didn’t need “nothing” is straight up false
JENNIFER
Mariah with diference
Beyonce sounded like a 90s Disney princess, Mariah is giving church-preacher vibes and I am digging it, and Jennifer is pure soul, power, and grit.
Ariana just does not exist? 😅
@@josvera7289 don't have anything to say about her, so nothing 🤷 not that deep
I only agree about what u said about Jennifer ❤
I'm not that big of a beyonce fan but I think hers was the best it sounded straight up magical
@@josvera7289While they all did a good job singing it in their own form, Ariana's version sounded more like the classic Judy Garland version.
Jennifer does it. Clear , clean , no tricks and foolishness. Just voice!!
The shade😂😂
@abjolute I'm here for it, lol!
My face is wet with tears I laughed so hard but you didn't tell a single lie 👏🏾🤣👏🏾🤣
Amen
@@abjoluteshade to who??? There's no tricks
Jennifer Hudson reached my soul.
Mariah gave it flavor and Jennifer gave it soul ❤
Halle would kill this
EXACTLY
Jenifer
Jennifer’s voice is pure power.
I agree completely! Jennifer definitely did it best!!!!!
She’s amazing. I think Ariana and Beyoncé did it more to the style of the song thou. I don’t think the song is Mariah or Jenifers style. Something about it didn’t feel right for the specific song. Still beautiful. I just don’t think this is the song choice for them.
Mariah's is so soulful...I JUST LOVE IT. But Jennifer...DAMN MAMA 👑
Beyoncé.. marvelous
Jennifer has such a POWERFUL voice.
Literally unbelievable
Jennifer hands down! Such a powerful and true voice!
Jennifer is just shouting bruv
@@stacyjd2759 and still is somethin u could never
@@sonyajennings6721 well duhhhhhhhhh! 🤣🤣🤣
Agreed!!!!🎉
Shout. Everyone can do that
Mariah and Jennifer are just beasts, they're way too good!
😊yass
Yep
Beyoncé, I just love her ending note. Everyone here is a good singer though too.
Can’t really tell what this jennifer sounds like but all are very goood just diff styles id day byonce
@@daileighnovember yes, exactly, they are all amazing people and singers. I hope to be at that stage in life. A singer once found but now famous.
agreed
Legit. I gave up. Basically. “Just going with a different dream” im too old now anyway 🤣🤣
fr
jennifer
Jennifer for the power and Beyonce for just perfectly sounding beautiful ❤️
Ariana - color
Beyonce - vibrato
Mariah - melisma
Jennifer - resonance
O que é ressonância?
Called that!🔥
Me- Cat in pain!
Very good!❤
Na Mariah seria mais um crescendo
Jennifer
Ariana
Beyonce
Mariah
1Mariah❤ 2Beyoncé ❤3arianna4❤jennifer
Beyoncé’s volume control on that last “I” and the vibrato that followed was so seamless and clear 😮💨🤌🏾🔥
It was perfection❤
Yall so fooled Beyonce has a special Mic yall are behind time I grew up with this Era shes another Cardi b with a Country sucker not free suit on the lied nobody bought no Texas toast or whatever she did the world dragged her a d she gets a #1 Beyonce needs to go back where she was making ivy park wasn't thinking about her fans AFTER TAKING YALL MONEY AND DO THE SAME THING.....AT THE END OF THE DAY BEYONCE SHOULD NOT BE IN THERE HER ENTIRE LUFE WAS NEGOTIABLE NOW SHES PRETENDING TO BE BRITNEY SPEARS SHES TRAPPED SHE CRAZY JUST LIKE HER ENTIRE FAMIKY BEYONCE HARD DEEP VIICE WHEN SHE SANG THAT SONG WE KNEW AND MARIAH IS SINGING TBE SONG THAT WAY ARIANA AND JENNIFER MARIAH ARE UNTOUCHABLE, HER OWN SISTER KNOW ITS A JOKE
What you say!!!!🔥🔥🔥
That's the mic, something only she can afford & something yall will never understand!!! 🔞
@@Barbiedangerouspt3 Cry about it why don’t ya 🥱🤡
ALL ARE BEAUTIFUL, YET DIFFERENT..THAT'S WHAT MAKES US AMAZING 😊
Beyoncé 👑
They're all good but Mariah made me laugh out loud... That long riff followed by that short "I" 😂
She was like "yep, done"
Indeed! 😂😂😂
Me too, you made me laugh, seems you don't know how difficult to sing from low register to belting.
It looked like when someone is playing “the distraction” in a movie but then the team gets the job done so they can stop lol
But she did get a standing ovation from Patti Labelle. And Mariah is a diva and that girl definitely loves her church I don't know I couldn't tell. I mean she ain't no Madonna I mean have you seen her in like a prayer girl that girl is touched by the spirit. That's the only time you can dance like that and at church and not get in trouble okay. 🤣🤣💀💀
Jennifer is GOAT on this song
What song is it who is it by
@@jonahvick2name: Why can't i
@@khanhkhanh1060Lol. It's called Somewhere Over the Rainbow. It's from the movie, "Wizard of Oz."
Yes she is, just stood in studio, hands on hips, nothing extra and blew it out the 💧
@@jonahvick2Over the Rainbow from Wizard of Oz...originally performed by Judy Garland
Bey👑🐝😍
Patti stood up like “I taught you well🥹🥹🥹” 😂😂😂😂
Facts. Patti keeps a good octave slide in her performance repertoire
I’m a Mariah fan but Jennifer really HIT this one ❤
Mariah did too much
@biochemica2 Orrrrrr, it's what I said, honey I'm a classically trained vocalist as well and I said wtf I said: At times, Mariah Carey does too much. PERIOD
@@joberry877 first of all that was patti's arrangements in her cover and she was doing a tribute to patti so if ur saying mariah is doing "too much" that equals to patti doing too much with the glissando bffr
@imsodonewithlife69 Check this out, THIS is MY OPINION just like everyyyyyyyyy one else jumped up on here and said wtf they felt, I'm doing the same. And Patti is Patti, what's for her is for her. Just because she did it like that does not mean Mariah had to, dear. It didn't give what it was supposed to for me coming from her during that particular performance. PERIOD. Shit happens. I was not feeling it. As an artist, you can be creative and come up with your own style of singing a song. She does it all the time. So, no need for that 'first of all' like you really thought you read me🤣 I said what I said. Good day.
@@joberry877 u thought u ate IJBOL mariah was doing a tribute to patti so obviously shes going to use HER arrangement bffr