Is the BRICS Still Relevant? | Between the Lines with Palki Sharma
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
- Is the BRICS Still Relevant? | Between the Lines with Palki Sharma
World leaders will gather in Johannesburg for the 15th annual BRICS summit on August 22. But as the group looks at expansion, the question remains is the BRICS too divided to make a difference? And should India leave the bloc or stay in it? Palki Sharma tells you on Between the Lines.
BRICS | Johannesburg | India | Firstpost | World News | Latest News | Global News | International News | Trending News
#brics #johannesburg #india #firstpost #worldnews #latestnews #globalnews #internationalnews #trendingnews
Firstpost is an Indian news and media website. Get all the incisive opinions, in-depth analyses and other visual stories that matter to you and the world right here on this channel.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Do you think the BRICS is still relevant in today’s world? Comment below and let us know.
BRICS IS RELEVANT BUT NOT INDIA. IT IS BETTER FOR INDIA TO LEAVE THAN TO BE KICK OUT.
Please be my teacher....😊😊😊😊😊😊😊 I want u as my coach........bcz I like u so much ur such a good a describing things.....
India must never think tht US will allow them to rise n threaten US domination.
Many countries want in as they see benefits in it. India is in dilemma. It is a loss for India to leave. Most new members would be just as influential as India once they join. If India leaves, it becomes like RCEP. It is not a loss to BRICS rather than for India. The wiser decision would be to stay. India should not dream that USA is really a friend, there is no friendship. It is just geopolitical need which can be discarded once the agenda is achieved. Within BRICS, slowly but surely it would benefit India in long term, and members would surely pay sincere respect to India as a big country.
With or without India BRICS will thrive because it's by divine appointment
It's time for the BRICS - New World Order to establish a default reserve currency or consider returning to the gold standard. Dealing with daily fluctuations in exchange rates for each country's currency would lead to excessive chaos.
Investors should be cautious with their investments, especially in times of inflation. Achieving substantial returns during economic challenges often requires the guidance of a professional or a trusted advisor.
I strongly agree. Relying on an investment coach for daily decisions minimises risks and enhances returns. I've earned over a million dollars with their guidance over two years.
How can I get in touch with your advisor? I'm looking for a more effective investment strategy for my savings.
My CFA, Stacey Lee Decker, is highly esteemed for her proficiency and deep expertise in the financial market. She possesses an in-depth knowledge of portfolio diversification and is considered an authority in this field.
Fascinating. I'm currently on her webpage, conducting my research. She appears to be quite skilled. I've sent her an email and scheduled a phone call.
I used to think every investor went broke during recessions, meanwhile some make millions. I also thought everybody went out of business during the Great Depression, but some went more into business. Bottom line, there's always depression for some, and profit for others, it all starts from having the right mindset. That said, I've set asides $250k to invest for future, unfortunately l'm a complete noob.
The market has gone berserk! regardless of experience level, everyone needs a sort of coach at some point to thrive forward.
True, A lot of folks downplay the role of professionals until being burnt by their own emotions. I remember couple summers back, after my lengthy divorce, I needed a good boost to help my business stay afloat, hence I researched for license advisors and came across someone of due diligence, helped a lot to grow my reserve notwithstanding inflation, from $275k to approx. $850k so far.
How can I contact your
coach as my portfolio is dwindling?
Can't divulge much, it's only right you do your due diligence. I'm been guided by Olivia Maria Lucas and most likely, the internet is where to find her deets.
Thank you for this tip. It was easy to find your coach. Did my due diligence on her before scheduling a phone call with her. She truly seems proficient considering her résumé.
Indians are the most successful demographic in US, hold political positions and own some of the most powerful companies. This does not happen in Russia or China. why should India want US to collapse 🤦🏽♂️
India is the kid without teamwork skills. India comes to see the teacher 30 minutes after starting a group project and it is already complaining about members of the group.
In my opinion, countries that are not committed to the mission of this grouping should leave. It will enable the rest to move forward without hindrance. So, India should seriously review her relationship with the current members and that recently enticed by the USA if she wants in or out. She must remember that she will be their stumbling block if she is thinking of having the best of both worlds.
Really worried about your crypto portfolio lol
You cannot leave brics...russia dont like being rejected. The bombs will fall.
For BRICS to work it has to become transparent, reliable and trustworthy. None of those qualities are possessed by BRICS if they have China or Russia on the center.
There are many countries who want to join. So if India wants to leave, they should do so. So that other countries that are pushing can easily come in. BRICS has to stop USA.
@@kwadwoyeboah6476 you can easily get into brics...but you cannot get out. Russia will bomb you.
In any organisation, if any member does not want to see that organisation progress or against the charter of that organisation, then it is only logical and dignify to leave. Otherwise, it is selfish and even evil to stay put to play the spoiler role to put harm into that organisation's progression.
Well said
yes. you are right.
The group is not divided. ONLY you Índia is talking about it because of your beef with China. Get a life 😂🥸
india is doing same. trying to stop BRICS progress in every step.
Strongly suggest BRICS should kick India out immediately
India's intelligence and strong independence has always been admirable. Teaming up with Russia and China doesn't sertheir economic interests in my opinion
People here in SA finally understood and took BRICS seriously, during this summit. And many where asking the same questions that Palki ia aaking of India. Is BRICS relevant? What do we stand to gain? Etc, etc.
Irrespective of what you think of BRICS and you view that the West can never be toppled. She summed it up very beautifully at the end: " It is always better to be on the room, than to be out."
That's why we all need to make BRICS workse.
India doesn’t want a new currency for fear of its own currency, India doesn’t want growth for fear of China, India doesn’t want this and India doesn’t want that. All of these new India’s directions after Moldi visit to DC and Paris. It seems to me India is our new problem. We must address these issues with India if she’s genuinely against BRICS expansion and new currency or she wants to continue serving DC and PARIS which we understand wrt to QUAD aka anti china union. And I don’t trust Sharma’s 😊 coverage wrt BRICS leaders meeting in South Africa, she may hit more on the divide more than anything. And this too I understand.
😂
😂😂😂
Incompetent n corrupt leaders with their small minds n overblown egos r just some of the reasons why India has fallen so far behind China in almost every sphere of development.
India is very jealous of the big brother China 😂
Hers was a garden-variety narrative which is very characteristic of Indian bureaucracy and elites. Which has taken its intellectual cue, from the times of Nehru, from West. Since it is also true that most of the money of Indian elites, is in dollars, plus India does not have any serious homegrown defence manufacturing capacity, unlike Russia and China, since, why work on growing a backbone, when we can easily get kickbacks and defence equipment from our holy Western masters.
It is better to leave if India try to play both side,no country wants to be betrayed later by India.
india should leave out of morality and honesty.
Bingo!
The brics right now is merely turning In to a chinese led war against the west. What exactly does india or other countries gain from this? Only ccp reap the benefits
India will always seek to enrich itself first without paying consideration to others. And India has good ties with the US and it could sabotage the rest at some stage.
India has never betrayed any country but been betrayed itself repeatedly. If India leaves it's Brics loss. China has the same agenda Britain and Europe had to colonise. India and Brazil are an important balancer. Personally I think India is better off without Brics. It has more to lose than gain. 51 other countries are there surviving so are most countries out of Brics. It's just a club really not a force to challenge right now by a long short. It has not dumbed the dollar and never will as china is risk averse. The only benefit is they agree to deal in their own currencies. There is more fluff around Brics but not much substance. It's not as if these countries don't deal independently anyway and after over decades nothing really to see except giving money to a bank mostly from more powerful countries and to weaker countries that are corrupt like SA. So no loss to India only mostly benefit in leaving. India has it's own relationships anyway. It adds value to every group. India has the largest population and a markets as big as the entire population of Africa. Certainly larger than every other Brics member. So actually Brics will have to have many more African countries and other countries for decrease in gdo size population size etc if India leaves. China dominating or Russia is not progress it's surrendering sovereignty and where corruption and bribery and the same as what west did to Africa. No sovereignty. India in the other hand is independent and not interested in colonising. Nor is Brazil. Yet SA adds no value really to this group or rather better choices of African countries to partner with independently.
Always interesting to hear an Indian perspective. Thank you.
Yes, pls leave BRICS. Dont become a trouble maker in BRICS' progress with hidden intentions.
Shutt Up 😡👹
We can replace India with Iran so it will still be BRICS
both sco and brics membership is a tool for us to put tension for china.....indian troops are waiting for chinese invasion of taiwan.....then india will attack china....both usa and india will defeat china and new ussr will happen.
Brics is great for India to piss china off.
We don't want to miss this fun.
Haha the ape trying to attack the human, come please come and try you apes
India is the only one that uses the BRICS to oppose China. China did not use the BRICS to oppose India. India in South Asia withdraws, and Indonesia in Southeast Asia joins, which is the perfect solution.
India opposes the expansion of the BRICS, and India is a traitor to the BRICS. More than 40 countries around the world are queuing up to join the BRICS.
India has joined the QUAD led by the Anglo-Saxon Group, and India has joined the Anglo-Saxon Group to encircle China and prepare to become Ukraine in Asia. India will purchase a large amount of arms from the United States, and the United States will transfer advanced fighter engine technology to India, and Russia will soon lose India's arms market.
Whether it is for interests or for glory, India should take the initiative to withdraw from the BRICS before being kicked out.
@@lainfonetok
So you are substituting A country Like India with small Economy like Indonesia😂
India might be interested by the US proposal to have it a permanent member of the security council, and also keep legs in the West for obvious reasons. I hope India will develop BRICS, because at the end when India starts to be bid, the West will go after. Long term view is the wise decision.
The US can no longer be trusted.....
Either way india will B a joker in d political pack of cards as usual.
''keep legs'' Sound leg India spread her legs apart for hunky men to enter? LOL
When did the US propose for India to be a permanent member of the UNSC? That's a complete lie.
@@yaz2928 really bro....u need to research more
THE WORLD NEEDS A POLITICAL LEADER WHO CAN BE ABLE TO LEAD AND UNITE THE WHOLE WORLD.
My personal assessment was and is that India is not reliable enough partners, because India is opportunist between East and more to west.
India should just look into her distant past. She used to be a super power in the ASEAN region. I just don't understand why India had forgotten her past. India should join Asean. China will be very angry. India has historical connection with most South East Asia countries. Besides, India has common interest w/ Indonesia, Malaysia, Brunei, Vietnam and Philippines. China will be furious. Very furious.. Imagine an arc of countries stopping China. Remember, India once had a kingdom traversing this arc of countries.
@@srebaayao9616what India lmao the Muslim Mughal empire before who was from Central Asia and spoke Persian? 😂 there was never a unified India bro until 1950s, before that it was a British forward outpost built to compete with Chinese trade and tap into the Chinese market versus Spanish and Dutch colonies. It still acts the same way today, no independent thinking, national polity based on Hinduism in a multi-religious country, and lead by lackeys and descendants of the East India Co. 😂 Btw, do not ask SEA countries if they feel any influence from India 😅 the problem with Indian policy is it acts like an island, all isolationist like it’s masters Uk, US, Japan, Australia. U cannot apply that a subcontinent
India is probably the most reliable nation in this group, where you have 2 almost dictatorships as the leaders...
nah Asean doesn't want India lol India always thinks too highly of themselves @@srebaayao9616
@@srebaayao9616
India had connection to ASEAN as a solder and slave labour of their Imperial master, doing their dirty work against their fellow Asians.
Problem is India wants a bigger say than its actual standing warrants. And you really can't be part of Brics and SCO while at the same time be part of Quad and whatever other western groupings India aspires to apply for and be accepted in. So, it should be honorable and leave...
yes, india is conflicted... best it vamoose.... the alliance will continue to grow.
Totally agree with your point on quad.
India can't say they don't want to be isolated into either camp but actively part of a Anti Western bloc which the BRICS is clearly and the Quad which is anti China. (I also understand the geopolitical competition and border disputes India has with China which is understandable)
well said. Nothing to add in your comments. India will be doomed without BRICS.
@@mawazafela6070that's not look like conflict but a bigger game
Yeah, better to leave than kicked out.
As an Indian, I find this thought of leaving BRICS ridiculously horrifying 💀
Good for India for not picking sides. You're an independent country. You got great people. You're very smart. Continue to be that country#Onelove❤🎉
No. Not trustworthy. Like Turkey. India has to pick a side.
The only place where it lacks unity is India doesn't want to see China playing the dominant role, so came up with these execuses. However the reality is China is the dominant trading and manufacturing power and second largest economy, India is not able to change that. Unless India pulls out, or come to terms with the reality working with BRICS, there is no way out.
China and USA both need India more... Anyside India tilts is a clear winner
Exactly. That's being petty-minded in wanting only self-interests at the expense of others who want to participate in the development and cooperative projects..
India is overrating itself, so India doesn't have unemployment issues.... There is too much emotions from Indian media when it comes to China... Whether India likes it or not, China will have a dominant role to play in any group India and China belongs to.... The chines economy is like 5 times bigger than that of India.... Gdp growth is not just by numbers but by the share maturity of the Chinese economy, india's is not anywhere close to the depth and diversity of the Chinese economy, the only country that beats the chines economy in this regard is the US and even they are not going to be there for long.
Highlighting everyone's limitations and pretending india's is any better is laughable....
@@NitinJadhav-cc2xhnot at all India is a pawn for the US whilst trying to entice India its giving weapons to Paxtan 😅😅😅😅 Modi first decided not to go south Africa but after US gave weapons to Paxtan, Modi is gonna go running like a dog, CREP countries are doing amazing without India, Vietnam is growing at a good rate.
"India is not able to change that" I don't think so, China's manufacturing power is decreasing and which countries are benefit the most: India and Mexico. India has the potential to be the biggest economy by 2050.
Realistically India is far too much of a break and a trojan horse for the further constructive development of BRICS. The I should stand for Iran and or Indonesia instead in the future. India can remain of course under + but the organisation must go ahead with integration with possibilities for individual countries to opt out on specific integration areas so not to block development of the organisation as a whole. Certain minimum criteria for membership should be established as well - it cannot be that a NATO members thinks it can join BRICS like Turkey obviously does.
true, cause modi was visit to Biden, India is like a servant to Biden, and got no future plans for
Strongly suggest BRICS should kick India out immediately
INDIA is still part of the british empire but it also has drive, we need everybody in
What nonsense did i just read!!! clearly you can't see whats coming, do you know how an economy works??? Just search for china GDP growth, investment growth, MNC coming to settle in china, unemployment in youth in china or maybe orders or contracts for future developments??? Please read on all this and....
enjoy your time with bliss😊
Both India and brazil is not interested in a chinese led war against the western world. I can understand that you want that, but this is not going to happen with brazil nor India. They have a pragmatic world view. What you espouse will end up with ccp trying to wield third world countries, who doesnt care about the issue at all, and push them to fight a war. It will never benefit anyone but the ccps plans for a world dominance. And that wont be a fun place for India at all
Congratulations to brics, 6 new members bringing membership to 11 next year.
Maybe a change of name?
I think they are going for BRICS+
Thank you for outlining the issues so clearly and succinctly. From South Africa's point of view, the expansion of trade into Africa via a Free Trade Association, and the development of a common unit currency outside of the USD is very important to resolve the employment crisis.
Well it's time for the BRICS- New World Order to come up with a default reserve currency or simply go back to gold as the reserve. It will be too chaotic for each country to trade in their respective currencies with the daily change in exchange rates.
All big corps are just a cohort of centralised system working together, and any damage to one can have a dangerous ripple effect on every other one. I learned a long time ago to not trust corporations. Most of my money is in the stock market and my businesses. I keep only what I need to spend in my checking account.
Iron-ically, these are the conditions in which life-changing money is made by those who remain calm, patient, and take controlled risks. Vola-tility goes both ways. The banks are in a big crisis. The mar-ket looks very shaky. The bigger the red candles, the bigger the green ones. I have made over 280k in the last 4 months by invest-ing through my FA
@@theresahv Could you kindly leave your investment advisor's contact information here? I absolutely must have one.
Finding financial advisors like Julie Anne Hoover who can assist you shape your portfolio would be a very creative option. There will be difficult times ahead, and prudent personal money management will be essential to navigating them.
@@theresahv I just googled her and I'm really impressed with her credentials; I reached out to her since I need all the assistance I can get. I just scheduled a call.
India has its interest tied to the western Cartel.... MY OPINION is that they should choose and if they leave the block Afrika will be happy
😂😂😂
India is one of the Founding member of BRIC and South Africa added later and this group became BRICS and now look at you talking about removing 🇮🇳 and 😂😂Talking about India to leave I mean dude your African nation come to this group with Indian consent
Betrayal has various form 😂😂😂
Where is africa
admission of all oil and gas producing nations is more important than india which is hell bent on dragging brics down, if brics is to make any major financial changes it must accommodate all those major oil and gas producing nations
South Africa isnt africa, you simpleton.
nice try chinese yellow covid bot..cry harder..indian army will not spare your lilliput soldiers at border
The video explains quite well, unlike dozens of others, that BRICS isn't really a thing. It's not a treaty, it's not an union, it's not an alliance, it's not a trade group. It's a group of countries that agree on a few things and disagree on others. I don't see how it can have real relevance now or in the future.
It’s just anti Americans playing politcs 😂😂😂 they make me laugh
the plan of BRICS is to support the currency of BRICS by commodities. Currently, USD is overvalued and the Govt. of the USA is in Debts. But India should leave the BRICS because China & Rassia are leading it. India should not leave the BRICS because it would benefit Indians at a larger scale. It could benefit Indians because India is a big country. But in the BRICS China & Rassia won't give special space to India.
It depends. If India wants to continue supporting the American Dollar hegemony. Or if India respect its own power and Sovereignty.
I think the reason why India will fear BRICS expansion has do with it's inability to meet the demand of an expanded group. While China on the other hand, sits in a position that, even the West is afraid to break away from.
India is the only economical bright spot in BRICS at present. The grouping will suffer more than India if India leaves. Your kind of thinking based on religious fanaticism or political vendetta defeats the very purpose of BRICS. India runs on the belief "Dont get mad, get even", a concept that may not be comprehensible to those who form 'Gangs' based on religion or politics.
@@devannayar6456 On same time India can not dance at the table of the US who is the direct enemy of all BRICS nations, and pretend like this is not happening. India will clearly have to chose, you can't have both. The weakling warmongering US empire or the fair multipolar alliance BRICS. All respect for India and its struggles but the true friends and allies from BRICS have to matter more than the so-called empty partnership with an untrusty US. If you think that BRICS will lose if India decides wrong to leave that is a delusion sorry. BRICS is the future, and NATO/G7 the past.
@@devannayar6456 but i thought so far Indian leaders was voted based on caste and religion no? Not on performance basis. Indian politic concept is always being the in between deriving the most value. They're never loyal to any cause from the get go.. so who can offer more VALUE to them.. india will be there. That's the way of the indian politic, simple really.
Strongly suggest BRICS should kick India out immediately
@@indiegameshark2520 Well, its better than the primitive religious fanaticism you people run on !
BRICS does not need India but India needs BRICS.
India can align itself with America but they will never do what is in the best interests of India.
India can go on its own but it will slow going for them.
US , NATO, the European Union, G7 and World Bank are all the American’s Clubs while BRICS with or without India will be a powerful Club as well representing the present and future.
Without INDIA BRICKS will slowly overtake by China and this group will become just a geopolitical mouthpiece of China against the west as China is building its own block to counter G7 like group but the problem is in G7 every nation is economically strong and in Bricks only china is economically powerful so eventually this group will become tool for china without India’s presence
Nonsense. India is only think that stops BRICS from getting the label of an alliance of tyrants.
Usa gave India Richshaws and bicycles and riots and Power shortages... in 2023 .... it will be same in 2040 ....😂
BRICS is full of clowns 😂
Without India there's no BRICS.
Look at the words carefully, India stands at the centre of BRICS
Six more countries to become members: Argentina, Iran, UAE, Saudi Arabia, Ethiopia, Egypt added to BRICS with approval from Brazil and India a well. Please do good news Palki ji like your Hubby ❤😂
I think the best think brick should do is to be United as one and allows members to join because they are all having one think in common to make stable economy for all it's members
It would be good for the organization if India leaves it. Just my feelings.
No. India should hold it's ground to stop the grouping China led anti America
Lol never … no Indian wants this
Totally agree. India does not really know what it wants and who it wants to be friends with. it might end up with no true friends in the end
I agree.
There is NO BRICS or value in the organization if India leaves . It will be just another group where China has created .
BRICS is special because of India and China .
Well, if India does not want to leave, other members can leave and form a new grouping with many other countries. India can sit alone in there. BRICS carries the hope of the global south and any obstacle should be removed.
Because India has dementia. She forgot completely that she used to be the superpower in the ASEAN region. Why not India reclaim her glorious past here? India why? Why are you ignoring 666Million people. You used to be the super power in this region.
What will be the name brcs 😂
It will be a china controlled block if india leaves
@@fidenahmed2905Just replace India with Indonesia and call it BRICS+
@@celiajames600 😂 come on indonesia is love but nowhere close to India
Do you even know about the idea of brics
Better than having a American stooge hindering the progress of BRICS.@@fidenahmed2905
As per my opinion, India should be a part of BRICS
• At a longer path to walk, India is going to be the power which will dominate the alliance due to it's accelerating growth when compared to that of the other nations in this alliance!
• Onto that, this is the only sort of active alliance which is against the west and India can fight back having a say in the globe, bridging gaps between the two blocs and even portraying the benefits or using Indias trade policies at a global level replacing that of America which is very biased and promotes Western ideology
• India has to have ties with both alliances, that Russia and China and even with the west, the reasons being the very old diplomatic policies of India which propose neutral stance in all cases and the profit we gain from both alliances.
India is like Turkey putting foot on both boats which might be weak link in the long run
Yes, please do so if India doesn't act like a team player, but aligning itself more with the collective West (US & it's poodles.) agenda.
Indiot is a trouble maker, she has no reason to stay BRICs, better fuxx off get out.
All of US poodles (S. Korea, Japan, Britain, EU, and Saudis) are getting super rich with their connection to the US. BRICS members other than China is super poor. Brazil is dirt poor. South Africa is dirt poor. Russia is falling apart. China is falling apart. The only one moving up is India. Aligning with the US is a pretty good deal if you ask me.
Palki Sharma, BRICS is no longer relevant to anyone and very small for India, India should apply for G7 membership immediately.
@@Nesstor01are u sure?😂
Sack INDIA !
Sack INDIA !!
Sack INDIA !!!
With 40 countries interested to join the BRICS, any of the founding members can leave if they can't agree with the majority of the members. BRICS can only get stronger with 40 new members.
Wow. 4 to 40 😂😂😂😂😂😂. This is getting better by the day. Btw. Russia luna just crash. India get rid of Russian junk. Submit timUS for protection. Just don’t play both ways as you always did. Not a reliable partner
Facts
40 countries WANT FREE MONEY FROM THE EVIL EMPIRE LOL! THAT'S ALL BUT NOTHING WILL CHANGE IN THOSE COUNTRIES!
@@ladislaugomes7447 fact. China, Russia and India military are suck. No one want Teja. At least some countries bought the lousy Pakistan and China J17. And no one want Teja. Very sad India.
Actually not. Openness and transparency will make BRICS stronger. Countries with small economies would give up some control of their monetary policy but possibly gain some economic stability. Everyone that joins may want a say so they may want to limit or swr parameters on who can join.
If India's ideas don't allign...they shud leave ..this shud be having an equal say
Hi Palki Sharma !
I always like to watch your presentations ! You are really wonderful
I don't understand why to even discuss this topic. Why should India leave BRICS that it is a founding member of. Sorry!! India is accountable and responsible for brics. Disagreements between two parties within the group is neither any setback nor any deterrent. Roar back at all of them who question this. Eagerly waiting for the sweetness to my ears. Even the earth has diametrically opposite north pole and south pole.
Stay with BRICS.🙏
No one should be surprised after India has been dining and wining with USA lately...
India will give up some of its sovereignty over the rupee. The other included economies could well dampen any positive outlooks on India's economic growth which is projected to be world's 3rd largest in 10 to 20 years.
exactly,
American funded journalist wants brics to collapse
Except the North pole and South pole don't have nuclear weapons pointed at each other.
You can not build an alliance on the basis of common external enemy. It has to be common internal unity. SIMPE.
Good point👍
That is not true sir. Ex : Nato (Only goal was to stop Soviet Union influence)
Exactly, BRICS was never anything more than an attempt at making nations that hate each other draw a temporary alliance against the US. Groups that are formed around a common enemy rather than common principles are always destined to stab each other in the backs to get ahead once the common enemy is gone. BRICS nations are starting to realize that the true greatest threat to all of them is in fact China, not the US.
BRICS was never relevant.
@@snoopysnoops007 We live in the 21st century, time to give up the "US colonialism" shtick.
It wears illusion of democracy
If India feels uncomfortable in BRICS playing second fiddle to China and Russia, then the door is open for it to leave....
The British Empire lost an entire Army in 1842 because they did not want to see India and Russia doing business.
The Brits once again in 1853 lost a half million Me to prevent the same kind of Business that now appears to be forming.
The Unification of Asia as Trading Partners, is probably one of the most fought over concepts in history.
Why would the Governments or the Citizens of India or Russia object to the idea?
Replace India with Iran or Indonesia,simple
India knows how to play all sides. It's in their DNA.
Don't forget India is the mother of democracy, diplomacy and politics.
Today No economic or strategic group in the world is relevant without India.
Don't forget in 76 years India rose like a phoenix from fragile 5 to the top 5 in the world economy.
Even after nearly 1000 years of 2 consecutive colonisation, India is only booming major economy today and for the next 20-25 years.
Try it. You will fail
😂😂😂 Indonesia 😂😂😂😂
请看清楚了，金砖所有国家都是中国一带一路成员，即将新加入的也是一带一路成员国，只有印度一个是例外的。印度这种国力来挑战所有成员是难以想象的，优雅的退出是体面的，否则任何的抵触都遭到大家的唾弃。
而且新加入的国家都是穆斯林国家，印度是金砖国家里唯一的反穆斯林的
WTF Iran ? with Saudi arabia conflict??? the fuck man! Indonesia with teritorrial dispute against china? are you lost? I tell you Brics are not United compared to NATO G7 QUAD ....
India is like the kid on the playground who goes back and forth between bullies and victims, never siding with anyone and only looking out for himself while sending mixed messages. Friendships and allies require sacrifice and loyalty, solidified by time and commitment. India wants to eat all the cake but wants no part in cooking or baking it. You have to make sacrifices in this life ,and stand by your friends during hard times.
What Hard time, ???
India is a grown up adult unlike china who is spreading viruses around the world or russia who is grabbing someones land and killing innocent people. Both countries are horrible!!
@@akshar4253 Palki is saying that S Africa, Brazil, China, and Russia are going through difficult times and india should leave Brics because these countries do not offer anything right now. Brics formed in 2009 when China was on the rise and Russia was doing ok for itself...but when things get tough they want out... seems very sad to me
I THINK YOUR ASSESSMENT IS 100% CORRECT.
@@sew_gal7340 Nope! India has to see its interest like what china has done by spreading virus all around the world and I don't know why chinese eat all things that crawls even human babies.
In fact, India is an dispensable presence for the BRICS organization, where India only engages in destruction and does not intend to develop together! India is a short-sighted country, which is also the fundamental reason why it has been developing slowly for so many years! I hope India can take the initiative to leave the BRICS organization and let Indonesia replace India!
India should. World happy .
India should leave to give BRICS and other countries that want to join the opportunity to achieve its potential. India is always a outlier just like RCEP.
China is an economic super power and thats the reality whether India chooses to stay in BRICS or not , it won't affect China's position . The more & more countries want to join BRICS is that they are fed up of being dictated by The West . I personally believe India can benefit hugely from forging mutually beneficial cooperation with these countries. India shod continue its pragmatic approach to ita foreign policy as it has been beneficial to it as recently as getting cheap oil from Russia & investments from USA.
china is not a economic super power, economic data of china is not reliable, suffering from deflation. a supplier cannot and will not overturn buyers. china was the manufacturing plant of the world, and west realize one fundamental truth after pandemic, placing all eggs in one basket is not good.
Military tech is decades after West especially now when Sweden joins NATO they where India's sole supplier of high-end Military technology. Russia's tech is garbage in comparison.
What do u think about peter Zeihans prediction of China Collapsing do to a crashing population do too 1 child policy.
INDIANS ARE ALYAYS LIKE THAT IF THEY ARE NOT IN CONTROL THEY WILL DESTROY .LOOK AT PALKI SHARMA SHE REFUSES TO ANNOUNCE HER LAST NAME .SHE IS SUFFERING FROM REJECTION.
Modi is working for the US as he can slow down brics!!
For the foreseeable future, China will remain the world's most dominating leader in economy (real GDP #1 since 2017, based on purchasing power parity), technology, development, finance, trade, infrastructures and defence, not only among the BRICS members, but also in the world, particularly over the US, EU and Japan.
BRICS members will have a better chance to stand up against the US, EU and UK, under China's influence on defence, finance, trade and development. However, as BRICS progress, the influence of India will most definitely grow significantly. And this progress will depend very much on the progress of per capita income. China will double per capita to $30000 in ten years and India will triple to $10000 in ten years. And the gap between the two will narrow in a generation. China will not be able further double to $60000 without an India on $30000.
As founding member, India will have to demonstrate to the rest as how to sort out the differences among members. China deployed four brigades along the border with India in 2020. India deployed 200,000-300000 troops under US pressure. But the US would not join India to fight against China. The US simply
dared not go to war against China, particularly on land. Hence the US turned to Ukraine.
China has no intention to fight any proxy war against the US. China only targets to fight the US direct. And this way, China can and will force the US into submission for peace, without firing a shot. The US simply dares not take on China. This is why the US wants Japan, Australia and India to fight proxy wars against China.
Come on India, you don't want to hang out with those squares, you know you're cooler than them.
It's always easier to agree on what you're against, than what you are for...
Wise words.
Your News are becoming useless as you still stands for imperialism You India.
India can leave but BRICS will still be strong
So true
Kudos to India,for not wanting BRICS expansion.
It sounds that China and Russia want to use BRICS to insure their dominance.
I've always appreciated India pragmatism.
@@kingkamaro9442 Yea. It'll become the counter organisation to NATO. Two enemy sides, just like old times.
India should look at it "Looking East" agenda policy. If India choose to leave then it cannot work with ASEAN and will lose strategic position in South East Asia long-term.
"India is too agitated to make a quick move and does not think before deciding on consequences for its country and people."
Very sensible pragmatic evaluation.... again.... "All is not as it seems..."
It would be absolutely foolish for India to leave BRICS. If India chooses to do this, the value of their currency falls with the rest of the western Fiat system.
For BRICS to work though, countries like India and China have to put aside their differences and put in efforts …
Exactly.
I honestly don't see much hope in that one
@@robrak3569if you’ve ever done business with an Indian then you would know that they seldom compromise. The only course for BRICS to move forward is to remove India.
It is wise for India to leave BRICS. It's just another form of Chinese debt trap.
If any country does not find any advantage, it should go gentlemanly and let the others proceed without hindrance. The idea of BRICS is to have win-win transactions amongst the members. Certainly this is very difficult to achieve with all the members every time. Differences will always exist and each member should navigate as far as possible. Certainly the status quo of the existing economic, financial, political, as well as international system is proving to be obsolete today and hence the creation of BRICS.
Well said...BRICS as stated early in the union formation was the cry of WIN-Win and if any discrepancies that arise and find you are the one that doesn't agree just leave but do not burn the house down.
Strongly suggest BRICS should kick India out immediately
Okay wumao
WIN win for China. They don’t Care about India
India should show benign leadership. It is vital to have positive, complimentary relationships that take the world forward in peace.
India seems capable of reflecting those qualities.
Everyone can prosper with the right attitude and that's what's needed. Building wealth with weapons and the misery it brings is obscene.
Greed and advantage taking are not qualities to be admired.
Accommodation, understanding, fairness and goodwill are the bonds needed.
Palki mam why do you have this doubt? CNN putting your test on table to read?
Be objective by stopping comparing India with China because China's economy is the second largest in the world, and its influence in the world is far above India, You should weigh India's economy with countries like Qatar, KSA, etc. If the Indian economy is doing better, there would not be immigrants from India scattered worldwide. Even in small countries like Malaysian and Brunei. BRICS will benefit India beyond your explanation. You should note that BRICS can exist without India because whatever India offers can be substituted by other candidates.
china already surpassed the united states when it comes to economy. only thing left for USA is the military and it is in slow decay...the new superpower will be africa, the new gold backed currency will be accepted by majority of people and africa got plenty of gold left if it fights back the colonizers. Niger started the resistance.
How brics will help india while china is standing at inside india's land
@@fidenahmed2905 what land?? It's Chinese land!! Get the point, old kidd?? Hahaha.. hahaha.. hahaha.. India's Indian?? No wonder!! Typical!! Hahaha.. hahaha.. hahaha. What a shame!! What a shame!!
Economy doesn't influence much ,there are many other aspects like movies , culture, strong foreign diaspora, CEOs around the glob . China doesn't have these things 😂. So they just have money influence, India has many things to offer to influence.
@@harshpatel7250 Chinese doesn't have movies, cultural influence, strong foreign diaspora and CEO of MNCs??? Really??? Hahaha... Hahaha.. hahaha.. India's Indian?? No wonder!! Typical!! Hahaha.. hahaha.. hahaha..
BRICS is about trade and peace, that India will need despite all ideological and political posturing. Think what India can do for the Global South instead of what benefits one can get out of participating. Kudos to the West or stay in BRICS to do some good, India can't have it both way.
So you are going to stop us? 😂
Why dont you start new group of your country, China, pakistan, northkorea, Russia, and Zimbabwe, USA is enemy of these countries and these countries are enemy of usa!
India is blind. She completely forgot her former glory in south east asia. India should just look into her distant past. She used to be a super power in the ASEAN region. I just don't understand why India had forgotten her past. India should join Asean. China will be very angry. India has historical connection with most South East Asia countries. Besides, India has common interest w/ Indonesia, Malaysia, Brunei, Vietnam and Philippines. China will be furious. Very furious.. Imagine an arc of countries stopping China. Remember, India once had a kingdom traversing this arc of countries.
China wants to make BRICS, a tool for itself. We have seen how well Belts and Road initiatives worked for developing countries.
It's a smokescreen.i love indian rupee
You cannot have your cake and eat it too..India cannot have it both ways. Neutrality is not the reality in this new global politics.
Yes they should. They're playing both sides and are quite a nuisance to the coherence and progress of Brics.
Many believe there's a SPY in BRICS and he's no longer a team player after coming back from US ...😢
And there'a a bully in Brics.
Who is danger for Asia's peace.
And I thought indian press is banned in China. 😂
@@thechintangroupIndia's Indian press??? This is YT!! I thought YT was banned in India, just like in China!! Hahaha.. hahaha.. hahaha...
@@DDDrumpf No bro, you are wrong. YT is a Chinese company, run by an American man.
@@thechintangroup hahaha.. you could be correct!! Hahaha.. hahaha.. hahaha ...
India should leave the Brics and join their US master.
We need slaves.
TRUE
@@tommwangi4302and who is ur master? Lol presently most of Africa ruled by western countries, I do understand ur hate for them!
If that so u r slave of us in brics😂
@@tommwangi4302 chinese bots are angry because india exposed china mentioning that china created that covid virus which killed millions of people...indian army beat the crap out of china at border...indian soldiers and british soldiers ruled china after beating them in opium war...china and its puppets fear india...despite all the china's success , it is still a thief and an impersonator ...west, asia, africa and mostly india will expose ccp and break free chinese people...starting with taiwan
It seems that Brazilian government did not go with your statements....
India needs to stay in! Why wonder around aimlessly? Remember it’s priority is to develop for the betterment of its people via working together! We are Asia ❤
President Biden to Governor Modi : India should out BRICS now...!!!
same channel praise brics for new world order before modis visit at america
I sold a lot of state secrets, also Biden to Modi
Fact ......... India should go since they bring nothing to the table
@@evolvedanimeislandWow just wow you stop at nothing to target us Indians how inhuman you are
@@evolvedanimeislandlike you bring anything
The question should be, is India still relevant to the BRICS, and the answer is no, India is always a tool for the western powers to use as a spoiler, India plays that role during colonization, when Indians where imported to the Caribbean to be used as a buffer between the British and the newly emancipated Africans slaves, the British would place these Indians in high places,in their colonial administration, for example ,you would see them as head of police and army units, and that legacy is still present in the Caribbean today.
The British always uses the rule “Divide and Rule” and India and other former colonies were victim of it.
But Indians inherently are not like that.we believe in “Vasudeva Kutumbaka” that means world is one. We value humanity more. We believe in equal partnership.we never exploit other country’s resources.We never believe in forcing our religion on others.
India under Modiji is completely dismantled from colonialism.we are searching and learning our true hindu values from our ancient scriptures and true history.
But there are few colonial mindset fellows who think highly of western culture. There always two sides in a coin.
On that note, I assure you that Modiji will become our PM once again in 2024 because we see developments everywhere in India. He is uniting the whole India on basis of our culture .
Donating covid vaccines amidst pandemic, helping countries on humanitarian basis, equal partnership in Africa are few examples of the good work of India.
Surely your problem will get solved in coming years ..
The question should be, what capability you have to say Bharat is relevant or not ? Are you president or anything.
Bharat is more than relevant to BRICS. If Bharat leaves BRICS is nothing.
Get the hell out u don't understand what Bharat is now u still talking about ur grand maas era😂😂
So true
Exept in Haiti...it was never colonized. Strangely the most unstable carribean island.
India should now join Asean. China will be very angry. India has historical connection with most South East Asia countries. Besides, India has common interest w/ Indonesia, Malaysia, Brunei, Vietnam and Philippines. China will be furious. Very furious.. Imagine an arc of countries stopping China. Remember, India once had a kingdom traversing this arc of countries.
🇮🇳🇷🇺🇨🇳 world superpower must unite😘💪👍👍👍
It's very important that leading middle-income countries team up for their mutual benefits, but what would be the ideal formula? I support the idea to form a group of countries which challenge western hegemony, but are not anti-western or pro-western, like India for example. It would be a bit in the style of the non-aligned movement, but with less members and with more clout and decisiveness ...
"Is Brics still relevant"is not the correct heading & it should read like "is India still relevant in Brics?"
If india is not relevant what does Brazil, SouthAfrica brings to the table.
India won't act as subordinate for China.
We think so it's useless to be in brick , we should join g7 it will be much better 😊
@@akshar4253
And then be a slave of US. We have seen how Germany, UK, Japan, Italy, France and Eu
@@akshar4253 joining the guys who raped and starved you for 300 years lol
@@akshar4253 Stockholm syndrome. Go see a doctor.
“The crack in the block” is the single line of an alphabet. The line that does not see other members to prosper, specifically the one it never has surpassed and never will be able to surpass. The crack is the line of emotional jealousy.
is BRICS still relevant? It hasn't even started yet as far as I'm concern. How do you assess if it's relevant?
How on earth does India and China can have committed and agree on single currency ,
I think India should not leave the BRICS, just be practical & make sure India is not leaning towards western side or china. Just be there
The rest of the developing world does NOT want India in BRICS.
India is offering nothing useful to the developing world.
India needs to stay in BRICS we don’t need india
India should leave , it is a burden for BRICS . I as Indonesia or Iran .
India is securing US manufacturing contracts since the US pulled their business out of china . China lost billions and their economy is suffering while India is on an economic growth. India already had debit card , credit card , cable, etc call tower contracts from the US making the country trillions . China want’s India to stop doing business with the US which means them losing trillions .
No loyalty is key, India should leave
Only time will tell. The shifting dynamics of international politics are sometimes startlingly unpredictable. One thing remains certain: a unipolar worldview is unsustainable in a multifaceted world.
I think it is sad that India is not friends with China. It is the British Empire that created the border dispute. It is imperialist US and EU that want to keep these countries divided.
Forgive me for saying this but India is the stick that has got caught in the wheel. Their friends are not in the West. Asia is a much stronger place with unity between other Asian countries. Asis, Africa and South America havecbeen kept down by West European empires who also control USA. These countries will be much stronger with India's loyality to BRICS
Strongly suggest BRICS should kick India out immediately
Only thing that matters here is what toilet paper do u wanna use,Dollar or Bricks, ill take dollar.
Mingling currency is close exchange?
Difference will exist in any groupings. However the bigger the group the better it is to better their interests. The other is there cannot be separation of economics from politics. US uses economics, its USD reserve currency status, to sanction others in order to destroy or control other countries. Unfortunately India phrases all its move to counter China rather than for the groups' good
says the BOT, who gets a one cent from his master..git back to your stinking hole and worry abt your-poo-shi-ping missing from the summit..chyna needs to quit BRICS, since it wants to use BRICS for its nefarious agenda..
You are correct.
True. Better to be a master than a obedient servant of the cunning west
India cannot take the head of BRICS.
Yes, it is better to be in the room but if the members in the room become more diverse and numerous, it might be suitable for India to leave or be asked to leave to allow the remaining 40 countries to attempt a new world order without India. The division in BRICS is mainly caused by India and it is likely that the rest of the countries see the historic opportunity and no longer want to wait for India's attempts to play both sides. In the end, India runs a high risk to be sitting in between all chairs and is seen as a flaky and unreliable entity that one is better off staying away from. I believe that is what your video really says. INda wants to benefit from USA, BRICS, its own relationships and by attempting to do so is angering everybody when the time comes to choose a side.
china paid agent spotted..usa govt should investigate this axel guy
What happens to Hindi Chinni bhai _bhai?
Why choose side .. India don't need to choose sides .. India is not blinded by the 24 hrs propaganda of Western media..
India knows how to play all sides. It's in their DNA.
Don't forget India is the mother of democracy, diplomacy and politics.
Today No economic or strategic group in the world is relevant without India.
Don't forget in 76 years India rose like a phoenix from fragile 5 to the top 5 in the world economy.
Even after nearly 1000 years of 2 consecutive colonisation, India is only booming major economy today and for the next 20-25 years.
@@davolpatel Noting because its not important enough on the global stage
India has got good intellect in good frame of mind to be wary of china will serve India well
Once I was told India was keeping her independece and sovereignty. No China, no EUA. That is what I wish to my country, sovereignty,
No sheriff. It is amazing how much is known from Brazil abroad: nothing! Just beautiful words, nothing more than words.
Wow! What a shift in Palki ‘s thinking, just few weeks ago she was touting how BRICS currency will replace $$. India shouldn’t have any truck with dictatorships…
Go back and see when she was in Wion/ Gravitas she openly been talking where she belongs (Voice of America)
She has no opinion. She just says what her Master wants her to.
She also said Modi won't be attending and will teach China a lesson, then a few days go by and she says the US are giving weapons to Paxtan and then and only then a few days later Modis says he is going to South Africa 😅😅😅😅😅
Such a liar and anti-China mole for the west. She can get a goid gig in UK Foreign office😊
Palki hasn't been keeping up since she left Gravitas
I think india is already irrelavent as india went to close to usa 😮
Hahaha, There is only four power pillars in the whole world America, Russia, India and China, The future will be merged here, India. Is not irrelevant but the most relevant
@@sanayamishra75
Irrelivent in bricks
As china Russia brazil and south africa are away from usa while usa is against all these countries
@@sanayamishra75 wrong there, China comes first Japan and South Korea and singapore comes after and still outperform you in many ways in asia, your population will not automatically make you a superpower if you don't work hard towards that, India is not a super power as yet it has a loooong way to go, but the Western media surely feeds indians ego and pride so much with their statistics, and the indians seems to believe it with all their heart.
Im starting to think that this BRICS is just a mean to get "closer to your enemy" so you could know better what they are up to.
Correction::: ndb for formed in 2014 not 17
Replace India 🇮🇳 with Indonesia 🇮🇩
And what's their gross domestic product... Terrorism?
Iran and Indonesia
if india joins nato....whole brics will go dust.
@@Amp1771lol indja products nothing either , you GDP is not big nor you make anything, so if indja can join BRICS without anything why not Indonesia
Agreed ...
India should withdraw from the BRICS if it no longer a team player, since returning from US, it has become a saboteur ...🤔
It’s Better To Be In The Room Then Out Of It
It is good for India to mantain relations with the US as much as possible but don't believe that this will forever. As soon as India's economy is growing and getting closer to US economy they will start creating sanctions and applying protectionism meassures as they do with China. India should not deoend on US and have multiple comercial relations and alternstive payments methods.
You are absolutely right. India don't have the strength to counter US onslaught.They are not China which is the only country can head-on with US infact wins it.
US isn’t infringing on India’s borders. India can handle US when the time comes that their economy is seen as a threat to US. Letting China rise will just lead to more border incursions.
"The only growth is India…" Wow! This lady has balls!
I mean, it's true, objectively, so...
@@user-uf4rx5ih3v true according to western statistics? Lol 😆
IMF says different. India's 3.7T with a growth 6%, China's 5% growth with its 19.7T economy. Does that sounds like En dia's the only growth nation?
Palkiji here is merely the propaganda machine for Godiji, the current PM of India. The PM easily defeated a No Confidence vote recently in the Indian Parliament on Manipur mayhem and in his two and half hour speech in the Lower House, boasted to be still in his GODI come 2028 when he expected the next Challenge 😁 from the fragmented Opposition. So a party so deeply entrenched in power, can preach ANY growth story to its citizens through GODI Media aka Palkiji 😂
India should open her own group subtitled with Free cow pee soda and cow dung cake supplies!!
I for India. Can be replace by Indonesia..
Indonesia also the 5th largest population in the world.
Since we trade a lot with China and Russia.
你没有认真想过印度对金砖国家增加成员持消极态度的真正原因，这不是因为美国是不是高兴或中国是不是敌对的问题，而是新加入的成员对印度都是挑战（中国，俄罗斯，巴西，南非都没有问题，只是印度有问题，为什么？）
看看第一批加入的应该是沙特阿拉伯，印度尼西亚，埃及，阿联酋，伊朗等，看出点什么问题了吗？他们都是穆斯林国家！
The BRICS will never be important. But your presentation is very important.
If india wants to jump ship they should, its better than being in the way of progress because the intention of BRICS is for a multipolar world to develop and improve them lives
There's no block without one country spearheading it e.g. NATO is spearheaded by the USA, the EU is spearheaded by Germany etc. So if China is spearheading it's not a problem just make sure that it doesn't have veto power over the others
No, Chinas influence should be reduced in the world. Not increased.
says a pakistani who is depended on china.
@@buntipapu3816 India can increase It's influence in the world without reducing China influence.
You grow your influence in the world by what you bring to the world.
Russia is growing Its influence in Africa by bringing to Africa win win partnership in fields of Security, military cooperation, éducation, technology for mining ressources, health, etc without reducing China's influence in Africa.
India must change his mindset and be pro active.
@@buntipapu3816as a Latin american india does not have much say or influence in the BRICS bloc, you say your economy is growing but yet many are yearning to leave your country, GDP growth does not equal to development, if we were to look at Nigeria that was just a few years ago labelled "the highest GDP and growing economy in the world" look where they are today, India seems to be believing too much in western statistics and the indians ego are getting big, pride comes before the fall 🍂 and yes if you do not want to be led by China 🇨🇳 in a bloc then you should just leave, that's is my take😊
U must be pakistani a servant state of China …
Cracks in the block? Only if you obey the evil empire
There is problem with sound... please amplify
We need India to maintain our standard of living since we are now trying to decouple from China. India needs to join NATO.
Yes BRICS is still relevant in today's world 🌎 absolutely 😊❤🎉.
What has it accomplished? It’s a great idea on paper but with no concrete results so far.
Definitely relevant, it is the global south fighting the global North for multipolar world escapimg US dominance.
@@gwu5698yes China is the good guy😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂💀💀💀💀💀💀