IAS Grilled in HC, You're Unfit ? Part-2
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 06. 2023
- IAS Grilled in HC, You're Unfit ? Part-2 #GauhatiHighCourt #SupremeCourt #LawChakra
Patna High Court Karnataka High Court Live Stream.
#Patnahighcourt #SupremeCourtofIndia #Supremecourt
Courtesy :- Supreme Court of India
Books on Constitution:- amzn.to/3rqFpbh
Tools Used for editing:- amzn.to/3EelR1r
For business Enquiries:- eqnuire@lawchakra.in
#SupremeCourt#Mussorrie #advocate #lawyer #legal #livehighcourt #indianlaw #law #live #court #argument #criminaljustice #guiltyminds #learnadvocacy #courtlive #justicelive #lawmotivation #beajudge #ias #judge #law #legal #patnahighcourt #justiceashutoshkumar #judiciary #motivation #learnlaw #IAS #supremecourtofindia #IPS #2022 #Patnahighcourtstream #orissahighcourt #SupremeCourt #Orissahighcourt#GujaratHighCourt
#Law #Chakra#JusticeAshutoshkumar
*This Video is strictly for Legal Awareness & Education Purpose only.📚
🙏 Follow us on twitter, Instagram and facebook.
@Lawchakra
👉Twitter
/ lawchakra
👉 Instagram.
/ lawchakras
📑*Fair Use Policy -*
Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.
My Lord word is being repeated 1000 times😂😂😂
how is he sooo poor in english being an IAS officer 😮
🤣🤣🤣
My first time seeing an ias officer struggling to speak English 😅
@@Z.NagamiEWS se aya hoga 😂😂😂
@@creativekunal339Why only EWS? Not SC/ST/OBC?
For all the people who are sprouting venom for language issue, pls read the constitution. Article 348(1)(a) of the Constitution states that all proceedings in the Supreme Court and High Court, shall be in English.
Constitution British time mein likha tha isiliye english ko hi priority mili aur aise judge discrimination karte hai
@@fanishgarg i dont understand hindi . hindi is not the national language
@@fanishgarglol
@@fanishgarg constitution hamate logo ne likha tha mere bhai
❤de courts can provide translators if there is language issues atleast learn from the articles rather than reading it only
Speaking in regional language is no crime. But court language is English and being an IAS officer one must know English.
100%
There is no national language in India.
@@pVlog-panoramicthat’s correct …but that’s not the matter here …IAS is considerd to be the most intelligent and knowledgeable post where knowledge about language is very essential… especially English as many verdict and policies comes in English
Unlike a promotey IAS.
@@slaptoface4417 unless he/she is from the reserved catagory 😂😪
Being an IAS he is expected to have good communication skills in both English & Hindi, Judge is not wrong , the officer is incompetent. Period
Are you serious? Why should one be fluent in multiple languages. Are we living in England or you people still lick boots of Britishers
There's 300 marks of compulsory paper in UPSC mains. Don't know how the hell he qualified.
@@loveu5045 there is difference in speaking and reading. There are people in Hindi medium who have better reading and writing skills in English but they can't speak because of lack of practice. You guys are living in a parallel universe where you think everyone is getting to study in English medium schools.
@@Exciseinspectorlife Don't give lame excuses. It is because of such lame excuses India is so behind. Since you don't know, English & Hindi both are our official languages. IAS officers are Gov. officials who execute the policis and laws made by the Gov. An IAS officer can't give excuse of not speaking English properly.
@@loveu5045 Lame excuse?? First of all English is an official language because of people like you. Our Constitution makers didn't want to keep it for so long. And officials execute policies and laws but since you don't know government itself is promoting Hindi and asking every office to do as much work as possible in Hindi. I work for Indian government and our officers can read and write English. Speaking a foreign language becomes difficult for those who haven't studied in English medium schools and when it comes to courts one has to express himself flawlessly and courts have translation department, why are they even getting salary?
Anyways, many countries have just realised including Spain that work can be done in their own language in much better way. Sooner or later we will have policies for promoting local languages than British language. In CAG they have made compulsory for DAs to learn the state's language where the officer is posted. IAS/IPS generally learn local language because they have to interact with locals not British slaves on day to day life.
this video should be watched by those students who get highly motivated by IAS officers entry videos with background Dabaang music.
😂😂😂
Nailed...
😂
😂😂bro
This ias officer entertained the court room with 1000 my lord 😅
Hahaha true
He though this was a 1000 word essay like upsc exam.
😂😂😂😂
Abea koi chup kara isko kitna my Lord bolega😅😅😂😂
This guy almost made me forget my english 😂
So you haven't forget till now Good luck .
🤣
😂😂😂
Your English is wrong brother, this guy almost made me to be forgotten my English
@@samratbhuniya231 ok mylot 😂😂😂😂
Pathetic .. not expected from an IAS officer. Honorable Justice sir is absolutely right. He should choose his words carefully.
He is IAS officer?
He is not even able to express himself properly.
He is an IAS officer there are some grammatical error in your sentence
@@educationalvideosandfact.6182 He is an IAS officer. There is a grammatical error in your sentence.
@@aadhithiyan7452 what kind of error can you explain it to me?
@@educationalvideosandfact.6182 two full stops and a capital T is missing
@@aadhithiyan7452 dear it is not a grammatical mistake.
It's great to see Judge sir to teach legality. I would like to see you soon, sir.
This is the Main Problem in India.. Hindi speaking people are given jobs in Non-hindi speaking states. Neither can they help the local language nor understand local culture.. Most of them donot make any effort to understand or respect the local people & culture.
It has become worse after the BJP came to power... The BJP is pushing its cowbelt policies in every corner of India.
Hope you will ensure that U and ur family do not work outside your STATE and if yu step out of your state ,to make a living,you will learn the local language, culture etc first
Khela hobe
Why give jobs to these half educated IAS officers😂
What is your demand ? Hindi speaking people should get all India service like IAS /IPS in Hindi states, while these are All
India Service and the politics is that to accommodate as much hindi speaking candidates as possible in all India service. Anyway, one point is correct,
a translator/mediator is necessary, and here his lawyer is there to support him
FOR PEOPLE ARGUING FOR HINDI-
Our constitution clearly mentions that all proceedings of hc and sc shall be in English language. He is supposed to know this. There are so many languages in india English is the only solution.
So who doesn't speak English properly should not go to the court? No where in the constitution it's written that IAS officers must speak English.
Shut up, if someone doesn't know English doesn't make him ineligible to go to the court.
There can be a translator for that or even lawyer are there for that.
If the court wants every officer to know English, they should tell UPSC and other examination bodies to conduct exam in English only...
@@KingsonKeshav he is expected to know the language of communication. Its his job.
@@kautilyagautam8468 as much as I know every language is the language of communication.
If the judge wants every officer to be fluent in English, he should order the UPSC to conduct examination in English only.
There is nothing called - he is expected to...... Bullshit!!
The only thing he is expected to is managing the administration and he is doing that.
Well i will say that him being an educated officer. He must have understood the constitution of India now constitution of india recognises both hindi and English as official language along with many others. Now this guy must have understood it and if he knew that his posting would be in such a case where his vernacular language is not used i would say hindi. And he is posted in bengal he is either supposed to know bengali or a common mode of communication being English. There's a reason why orders of the court are in English so maybe they can reach the common people. The problem is your argument is based on EGO and yes i do agree that a translator should be there but isn't he supposed to know this being a citizen who should be upholding the constitution? Not everyone knows what is constitution, but he does and he studied it to pass the exam thats it. What's the point of logical part of brain if you don't want to use it eh?
For those who are making a case for English not being necessary for an IAS officer, just think how will he/she communicate when posted to Southern Indian states
Agreed. Whole India doesn’t know hindi, we should realise this.
@@LawChakraonly 20% cant that judge knows hindi because after assamese hindi is the most common language in assam and every assamese knows how to speak hindi that judge was just bullying an IAS thats all
An IAS officer always has his subordinate to assist him in such cases. Even here also he has the lawyer, but judge didn't allow his lawyer to put the case and wanted him to tell him everything that too in a language he is not comfortable with..
And whole of the India also not know the English as well properly in remote area.. then how can manage then it shall help on official Indian language in Hindi.
Then it's also a matter of shame that South Indians don't speak Hindi right? Language should not be a barrier.
The Counsel for the IAS officer has rightly said that he has lack of expressiveness which is not acceptable from an IAS officer. Being an IAS officer, he must have good communication skills. A bookworm can't run the administration efficiently. Hindi is important but english has become part and parcel of the official communication and one can't ignore this fact.
Very well put by you.
When UPSC is conducting the examination in Hindi language, taking interview in Hindi language, giving training in Hindi language.
How is the officer at fault here?? This judge didn't allow his lawyer to present his side and wanted the officer to speak everything. He could have said everything in Hindi but he was not comfortable in English.
It is often possible that that the complainant and the judge don't speak the same language. And that's why there is a provision of legal counsel.
English was made official language by the congress. A stooge of the britis
@@KingsonKeshav this has only 1 solution. abolish hindi completely and make english a national language.
Rightly said
The only English word he knows is "My Lord"
Only one question is going on in my mind,.... How could he able to SCORED in the personality test for IAS with his English😮😮😮
Backend appointment 😐
He can give his interview in anyone of the official language . Is english a yardstick to measure someones knowledge?.
English is just a language not a knowledge.
ST hoga
High court language is English...
Alot of people give interview in Hindi
Hi di me kya hi problem hai 😌
It is pity that an IAS officer does not have the adequate knowledge of english.
Quality of UPSC exams are evident
Ah ah, no it could be reserved category candidate
For those who are against English. For us Northeastern people we do understand Hindi but have problem in Speaking Hindi . And if it we are to give our explanation in Hindi we people will never win a case nor say anything . And in this case Been an IAS officer he should be fluent in speaking as high rank officer he is not fit even if he have 200 IQ . How can he deal situation in places like northeast or south India.
Bro this happened in Northeast i.e Assam and the Judge was Assamese. Kudos to him for standing up to these Hindi sympathizers.
Lalu Prasad speaks better English than this IAS officer..How big a shame it is to get reprimanded like this in court, while he clearly understands that court proceedings are in public domain..
😂😂
yes
Right
Hindi local speakers have the advantage of their language along with English in UPSC at the preliminary exam level. This is the greatest injustice in India.
U,r right
this is like saying hindus have advantage in religion
Exactly!
Quality IAS from Bihar!
If even you can be a constable atleast...Mr. Scavenger
Some time appear for IAS EXAM, Then you will be able to judge about your self. Because of language you are passing comment on State.
The UPSC recruitment process needs to be overhauled.The quality of the candidates are seriously horrible.
Advocate's English is better than IAS officer😂
What do you mean? Advocates usually possess good speaking/orator skill
@@yiangpa5236 yes that's what I'm saying
What's funny?
Shame on the authority when they select such people to serve the people .
It should be mandatory for IAS officers to know a minimum of 3 languages. If IFS officers can then why cant these guys
We appreciate the hearing of Honourable Justice Medhi.
With all due respect, the IAS officer’s choice of words and answers DOES NOT reflect lack of English comprehension, rather his inability to explain briefly and his promptness.. To all the people arguing about what an “ideal” UPSC aspirant should be like, language is a barrier across the country, and sadly a stellar marker of skill and ability.
Its not about english or hindi , IAS should have a personality to present well im public
He should learn English from sharukh khan and how to present oneself publicly .
How can a man like him become ias 😂😂
😂😂😂
This teches an important lesson that life is not fair
Reservation
Salute to the honourable judge for refusing to hear arguments in Hindi.
Hindi is one amongst the Indian languages but let's not forget Hindi can't claim any special attention.
Common South Indian ☕
95% knows Hindi in India , Hindi become worldwide recognize by the Develop countries..
Idli Sambhar
Pani Puri northies keep crying 😂
@@kunwarsinghrawat3732 Hindi is spoken as a first language by 14 percent of Indian Population. Then comes Tamil with 8 percent of Indian Population, and Bengali with 6 percent of Indian Population. An IAS should be proficient in English. That is a pre- requisite.
90% of civil servants are tuned to do routine jobs, so by by-hearting in studies they become civil servants.
Most of them are wont even got select for a private job in a descent private company
kitabi keeday i call them who close doors for 18 hours a day and just clear an exam and think they open the door being Leaders ... These kind of people are dangerous to the Administration when bestowed power suddenly.
@@amitdangwal3041bro i can see your desperation, because you are powerless.If the education system is like this than what a aspirant of government job will do?
The demand of exam is that you have to go through a regroup process, multiple phases of exam, upsc conducts a paper of english in mains which is necessary to pass ,,, he cleared cse then obviously he passed the english paper as well. He was capable to match the expectations of upsc that's why he is a civil servant.
And the matter of english in general administration is very limited ultimately a civil servant have the responsibility for the person who is last in row. And the person who is last in row certainly communicate in local language not in a European language ( english).
@@amandhyani1810UPSC crack kar liya aab chalo reel banate he hawaldaro ko aage piche dorake 😂😂😂... They are the one making the schemes and all, working for the betterment of the country with executives and legislators and can't even speak the official language 🤦🏻♂️ what will the Officer do if he is posted anywhere but North....jabba jabba?😂😂😂
@@dynamicshows2135 they will do whatever is their job but one thing they will never do that is ba#ch@di in CZcams comment section
❤💚 IAS trying to misguide the Court and trying to OUTSMART thinking that just because he is IAS he is always MIGHTY and CORRECT .. I appreciate the court to have brought these IAS to a realisisation that IAS are here to SERVE not to OBSTRUCT justice
What a shame... Although knowledge of English is not a measure of one's knowledge. However, an IAS/IPS/IRS is supposed to be and ought to be proficient in English... For gods sake these are bureaucrats... They have no other work like scientists or inventors...
Ratta wala IAS 😂. Huge brain with lot's of memory space 😂. Seriously,,, the recruitment process of gov jobs in India need reforms.
😅😅 RIP UPSC Status 😂😂
This man is an IAS officer 😮
Judge kaise bante hain ,upsc always zindabad
An IAS officer best speech... What a English ... How he become IAS OFFICER...
All of your sentences are grammatically incorrect. Go grab an English book first before insulting others.
Din me 16 hour ratta marke
🤣
CSE 2010, Rank 204.. He is a good person and a good Administrator...you can't judge anyone's ability by the language...
This exam rank became meaningless in the practical world my brother he should have the ability to speak english this is what they r trained for at mussoorie
@@gc3377I guess there is something wrong in training but not in recruitment..... Bcz the way syallabus has been framed, it's not possible some dumb person will get selected.
@@gc3377they r trained how to run administration not spoken English😂😂
Administration needs English to administer an area where people know neither Hindi nor the local Language@@abproduction2272
Must have been posted in a major hindu speaking state & lost the touch of English accent & the nervousness got the best of him. Sad.
How he became IAS officer lack of confidence, lack of knowledge. How he would handle the officers. Such a shame
How he became IAS officer if he is not qualified in required language!!! 😮😮😮
UPSC selection committee mention clearly, no need to be Excell in English language
General understanding is enough
That judge should know the regional language
Regional language is Assamese not Hindi.
@@chethands3862IAS officer's language is not Assamese..he can have translator if he wants ..judge has no right to insult him just for not being fluent in english .
@@bookbuff Mr. Buff Official language of Supreme court and all High court is English.
Our original constitution was written in English.
Region C states have English as official union language.
Moreover English is the food and shelter for crores of poor educated people, So love, learn and speak English.
I really often wonder whether upsc is competent enough to select right candidates and every time upsc proves me correct
Well-done justice. Long live
How did such a person become IAS officer? He is not a ordinary Govt officer. An IAS officer needs to be proficient in both the official languages of India, both Hindi & English.
Yes an IAS office should be able to converse in English period otherwise he is not fit to be a bureaucrat.
Justice Medhi has done a very noble hearing . These days all court work , police work , Id ,it , or any responsible works are being done by officers who might have bribed their way through or come to their position with influence . The biggest reason for our country to be ruined .today the education is marginalised , even Military has bhakts . Judiciary is full of sub standard lawyers , sone obe has to demand a certain level of professionalism by the book . Thanks from us all who want to see India excel 🙏👍🏽
My Lord......My Lord......My Lord ......My Lord ........My Lord.....
Well, in the Northeast and South Indian only those IAS should be posted who could communicate in English... Otherwise, get a translator for the Hindi language. It would solve all difficulties related to language.
That's what his lawyer was doing, he was presenting the case in English but the judge wanted the officer to tell everything only...
@@KingsonKeshav you're correct. The judge was clearly arrogant. This is why we have so many pending cases, cause our judges too busy with trivial matters and wasting time on none issues. Our judiciary system also needs a major overhaul. There are lots of absurd laws and regulations in India which have no relevance in the modern day.
IAS is not ONLY for his/her own state of domicile. Common Man. Those criticising the judge for not letting him speak in Hindi, imagine an IAS from South started speaking in his/her own native language in Northern courts. An IAS should know the Native, Hindi, English and at least understand the local language unless how can he/she will deliver.
make ur own country then , separate india please
He is a state psc officer promoted to IAS
An state😂😂
It’s not an English issue …many dignitaries often tremble in a court atmosphere !
My brain went haywire listening to conversing strategy of the “IAS” officer.
To all the people who will try to impose Hindi, it's not going to happen. He is in Assam rather he should speak in Assamese why Hindi because he is comfortable. A lot of people is not comfortable in Hindi.
I have 12 years service experience with Army ,Navy, Airforce
The Officers are very very intelligent, english is super
The IAS officer seems not comfortable in english which is very shocking. He couldn't even explain the matter to the court being the District Magistrate/administrative officer raised question on his competency.
Ow does he deal with those english comprehension section? 😂😂
The hon'ble judge is worthy to be appreciated for saying in such a nature that I don' t know Hindi .
There is no excuses for any IAS officer to overcome without having a English fluency
By the way English is a Language but getting fluency is about Knowledge when you learning a second language
Good Judge 👍 Bihari IAS . 🤣🤣🤣
This is the quality of civil services officer in India.
This IAS officer is quite possibly a promotee within the esteemed IAS cadre. My confidence in this assertion stems from the fact that individuals who successfully clear the UPSC CSE exam and undergo training at LBSNAA are expected to possess a basic understanding of the English language. Hence, it is reasonable to infer that the officer under scrutiny is, indeed, a promotee IAS officer.
Having had the privilege of interacting with numerous IAS officers, I have come to notice that those who directly ascend to the IAS ranks usually exhibit commendable knowledge and effective communication skills. Nonetheless, there might be instances where some of them lack proficiency in English.
Now, let us delve into two contrasting perspectives concerning the importance of English proficiency in the realm of civil services:
The first viewpoint ardently argues against evaluating an individual's competence solely based on their language skills. Language proficiency, in no way, serves as an accurate measure of one's intelligence, and numerous examples substantiate this claim. Additionally, our society seems to carry a lingering colonial influence, wherein expressions in English often garner more respect, while the same sentiments conveyed in Hindi or other regional languages might be undervalued.
Conversely, the second perspective vehemently emphasizes the indispensable role of English proficiency for an IAS officer. As the highest administrative authority, effective communication becomes a paramount necessity. The rigor and exacting nature of the UPSC CSE exam ensures that only the most competent candidates succeed. Envision a scenario where a crime involving a foreigner occurs in your district; seamless communication in English becomes an imperative. Furthermore, as IAS officers ascend to prominent positions such as Cabinet Secretary, National Security Advisor, Principal Secretary, Finance Secretary, and beyond, proficiency in English becomes instrumental in formulating policies and fulfilling their duties effectively.
In conclusion, the debate surrounding the relevance of English proficiency for IAS officers encompasses multifaceted perspectives. While language should never be the sole determinant of assessing an individual's capabilities, the importance of basic English proficiency in the civil services remains undeniable. Aspiring IAS officers ought to recognize the value of a well-rounded skill set that encompasses effective communication in English, alongside other indispensable attributes. This holistic approach ensures their readiness to confront the diverse challenges faced by civil servants in India.
U lack basic understanding of India diversity. There are states which wud go to the extent of separation from the union if English lost its position.
No he is direct recruit. He is young in age.
He is a direct recruit. Why there is comparison between direct and promotee on who can perform better?
How come such people are being selected in IAS. Shameful
Some quota may be
His knowledge and skills make ias not how he is fluent in English
Judge does not agree with your thoughts , he shamed him for bad communication skills of being an IAS officer
@@aceravi10 There is no rule that being a government officer you should have fluent English speaking skills
@@aceravi10 It is shameful not only for an IAS officer but for every Indian that no one has the right to speak in their own language.
.The framers of our Constitution were fools and followers of the colonial legacy that they did not give Indians the right to speak in Indian languages in court or arrange translation facilities for the judge.
This judge sir is my mama ji ❤
The way he is saying my lord😂😂😂
Rank inccompetence bolstered by fumbling intransigence. If the law does not make an example of such dimwitted office bearers, we will face a great financial crisis. We are already in the midst of a global recession, and global banks are on the prowl to seek additional monies thru extensions and procedural goofups in their current project investments.
He should understand that he should be equally adept in English language.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Frustrated justice uncle, no manners.both are servents of law. Give respect take respect.
Why this person does not ask from central govt
Literally in indian judiciary there is a huge reforms is necessary because civil servant works on local ground therefore he should learnt local languages or hindi / english but this judge easily said that he dont know hindi but an ias officer which is not so good in English tries to speak in english but judge don,t know hindi .These judges works only with a colonial mindset .
How could a dm couldn't able to speak in English. Joke of D decade. Who selects these ppl?
Reservation
For selection of IAS officer, language is not a bar , it just needs the knowledge and efficiency to control any situation. Now in these days in 'English schoo'l under primary section most of students can speak in fluent English .
A great channel.
His English as an IAS officer 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 are you comedy me 🤣🤣🤣🤣 oh my God English 🤣🤣🤣🤣
As a indian judge he should also learn hindi for your kind information a civil servant always do work on the ground basis instead of a court room therefore upsc select candidate on a knowledge base not even a language base ok
@@bharatchauhan3301reservation quota always rocks lol
Reserved got selected and not deserved
Hindi & English are official Language of GOI, doesn't apply for Courts tho.
It is rule only in High court and supreme court, in reginal courts you can speak in local language.
One time exercise to be done and all such officers to be identified and booked for intensive training
My lord I am paavam😂😂😂😂 school headmaster vs student
This is the level of education in India where a IAS officer is unable to speak two sentence in English...He is lacking in communication skills and question arises that how does he take administrative decision without having basic skills????This officer might be selected as IAS either either through bribe or reservation.
Of course an IAS officer must be fluent in English and must understand local language,this is what happens when u eliminate deserved candidates just to over empower a specific reserved candidate
Then why the hell UPSC conducts the exam and takes interview in Hindi??
His job is to manage the administration not to present the case everyday before courts. There is a reason why lawyers are there - to assist them and present their case.
You're being a racist. Get your facts straight. Getting into the list itself qualifies anyone, where more than 10 lakh aspirants appear every year. Make it to the list then comment.
Many aspirant clear upsc in hindi medium..
@@KingsonKeshavyou are correct..
For your kind information this is ias from general candidate 😂😂😂but you not able to digest 😆😆
He was very nervous and nothing else
It raises question on the standards of UPSC exams
this is the result when POWERFUL political parties appoint IAS OFFICERS
He?????? Political parties doesn’t appoint IAS officers… there’s a exam conducted by upsc for such officers 😊
@zeelgamit1998 is actually true, but if you're closely watching the recent trends, even the Supreme Court judges . last year, high court suggested a judge to SC CENTRAL reject it or kept pending many many cases
It is shameful that how upsc a strong pillar of India is appointed such people as IAS 😢
There's something we call hindi medium besides that we can't judge anyone's ability or knowledge based on the language he speaks
If a person can clear UPSC and become IAS officer with this vocabulary skills, calober and knowledge i regret not appearing fornthe exam.
This type of reservation candidates secure the nation.even now the reservations should stop .jai ho judiciary.
Most of the bureaucrats are not from reserved category(>95%) still the situation is so bad in bureaucracy. Why?
Because they are just a generalist suffering from superiority complex just because they have passed an exam.
Obviously 0.0001 % are creating impact.
Moron, he is a Bihari Sudama.
@@spiritedlearner7143 more than 60% seats are reserved for EWS, OBC, SC, ST and PwD.
@@spiritedlearner7143n civil services and other government jobs 17% to 35% seats are reserved for different casts.
LoL, So how could u say, they are less than 95%? Other went missing or what? 😂
If a ias officer is not comfortable in English how can you blame the reservation
It's not mandatory for a person to know English. Many aspirant clear UPSC by Hindi medium, people who come from rural Bihar, UP, etc finds it difficult to converse in English, it's not about lack of knowledge rather lack of expression. It's an expectation that he/she will gradually learn the english language as a mode of communication. The reason why HC/SC prefers English because it will help the person from any state to file a case in the place of residence. Hindi cannot be an langauge beacuse NE and South India doesn't recognize Hindi as state language, regional language is not a solution so we are left with English as lingua franca of the HC/SC.
Someone who is going to hold office of government, I expect them to learn and speak English at the very least. I am glad people of rural India reach high in government office, but they should have ability to listen, speak, read and understand in English.
You have to speak English in a High Court...thats the rule...
Arey bhai . English court Language hai. Ye rule hai . That’s it . Baat khatam . Ye IAS aur ye Justice thori personal level pe baat kar rahe hai ? Galti IAS Ka hai , kyunki court language baas English hai , Jisme Wo baat nai kar rahe the . Ye rule hai bhai .
Judges and lawyers should learn the particular regional languages wherever they posted in the country to understand the nature of the issues comprehensively and give JUSTUCE. Huge expectation of having conversation and conducting the court procedure through english which every citizens are not comfortable (as it is not their first language) would lead to fail to deliver the justice. Our top priority should be giving the justice, not the language. #needreform
Reservation ka nayab namoona hai ye. 😂
How can you assume he achieved IAS through reservation? If he was from general category will you say the same thing?
despite cracking UPSC in Hindi, I think that all selected IAS officers go through same training in English?
They are specially trained to understand Hindi.
And I am saying this because I know some officers very closely. In states likar MP, UP, Bihar, Rajasthan, all the administrative proceedings are done in Hindi language. And that Hindi becomes too hard at times even for them who generally speak and understand Hindi.
The only word i can hear is "my lord" from beginning till end.
This gentleman somehow managed to clear the IAS exam and interview, which is a very challenging feat. I suspect he may have taken the exam in his native language, likely Hindi, and attended the interview in Hindi as well. It's also possible he benefited from the quota system. Regardless, becoming an IAS officer requires meeting certain minimum standards, as it is an all-India service and not limited to Hindi-speaking states. Perhaps his interview was conducted in Hindi, which could explain how he successfully navigated the process.
Judge don't know hindi , so insisted for English, IAS should know english, that is the toughest exam of India and still don't know English
He does not seem to be a real IAS officer( fake IAS ? ) Or promoted from the ranks. One of the first things taught in the training at LBSSNA ,is clear and effective communication , proficiency in langauge, legal procedures of court and its decorum . This man doesn't seem to know any of this !
quota se hoga maybe
@@DefenceIND Or promoted from the ranks or parallel entry as now being done at Joint Secretary/ Secretary level at the center by the current government !
@@DefenceINDsir what quata sir?kindly explain sir. everyone has their own quato sir don't you know
CSE 2010, Rank 204.. He is a good person and a good Administrator...you can't judge anyone's ability by the language...
English m talk krna jruri nhi h ....
This man must have not passed UPSC. He is a joker.
IAS can take an interview in regional language, not necessarily in English.
Reservation ke base pe IAS banega to yahi hoga 😂😂😂
Forget about Language skills , even his administrative capabilities are serious question. The Laughable aspect is he admits in court on record that he gave executive order based on a telephone call 🤣🤣🤣without due diligence.
I am overwhelmed at his poor of IQ, what he thinks would happen when he makes such statements.
Nothing will happen lmao, he will probably be suspended worst case for 1 month, then he will do all this again. Act on WhatsApp instructions lol.
When the government can make changes or amend the constitution, Hindi written in Devanagari was declared as the official language of the union by the Indian constitution in 1950. The use of English for official purposes was to end 15 years after the constitution took effect, or on January 26, 1965, unless Parliament voted otherwise.
😅😅😅you forgot 1965 act... State has right to follow their language..
Article 348(1)(a) of the Constitution of India states that all proceedings in the Supreme Court and in every High Court, shall be in English language until Parliament by law otherwise provides.
If a person allowed to take ias interview in regional language if cabinate minister's have permitted to take oath in hindi than why a ias not permitted to communicate in hindi if judges not able to communicate in hindi he should may used translator😊
He is not normal person he is ias officer he should have good communication skills
About not knowing regional language is understood.. there a translator an be availed and that too at onsite operations... but before the Hon'ble High Court it is necessary to converse in a language which is understood pan India
*can be availed
@@user-dc2qu7hu6ythe person cleared IAS with hindi medium ..when UPSC allows hindi medium how come the judge question him about his competence? In so many countries their leaders can't speak English but that doesn't mean they are incompetent . Judge lacked basic sense as he was mixing language and competence.
Our judges are of colonial mindset
If person from rural background
It is very much possible that he is not able to speak fluent English
Judge is not a native Hindi speaker so your point is irrelevant
Ias officer is not any other rural villages who has come to court
If he cannot conduct himself in English apart from his mother tongue how will he discharge his official duties when posted to non Hindi speaking states
@@drdutt2916he can have translator and he stil knows basic English and understands it so why shame him .
It's a clear indication that the quality of the IAS officers has gone down. Its like half baked bread
This is the difference between South and North.