IAS,DM Not in Court after Summons, Cabinet Minister above HC? Angers the Judge MP High Court
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 10. 2022
- IAS,DM Not in Court after Summons, Cabinet Minister above HC? Angers the Judge MP High Court #law #legal #Advocate #LawChakra
In this video the honble Judge at MP high Court justice Vivek agarwal gets anger with a Collector IAS as she didnt appear before High Court. Patna High Court Karnataka High Court Live Stream.
#Patnahighcourt #SupremeCourt
Books on Constitution:- amzn.to/3rqFpbh
Tools Used for editing:- amzn.to/3EelR1r
For business Enquiries:- eqnuire@lawchakra.in
#SupremeCourt#Mussorrie #advocate #lawyer #legal #livehighcourt #indianlaw #law #live #court #argument #criminaljustice #guiltyminds #learnadvocacy #courtlive #justicelive #lawmotivation #beajudge #ias #judge #law #legal #patnahighcourt #justiceashutoshkumar #judiciary #motivation #learnlaw #IAS #supremecourtofindia #IPS #2022 #Patnahighcourtstream #orissahighcourt #SupremeCourt #Orissahighcourt#GujaratHighCourt
#Law #Chakra#JusticeAshutoshkumar
*This Video is strictly for Legal Awareness & Education Purpose only.📚
🙏 Follow us on twitter, Instagram and facebook.
@Lawchakra
👉Twitter
/ lawchakra
👉 Instagram.
/ lawchakra
📑*Fair Use Policy -*
Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.
Civil servants are still live in colonial era
Kudos to these kind of judges who treat everyone equally 🙏
Dont generalize.
Judiciary is still live in colonial era
The whole Indian bureaucracy is living in colonial era. And the population is living in 1600a with the caste system.
There has been major improvement in Bureaucrary, but Indian judiciary is still the same. Atleast bureaucrats clear OPEN exams to join services with transparency unlike............
Kabhi bare act padh ke dekhle, crpc dekle.
The PROBLEM IS NO ACTION IS TAKEN AGAINST SUCH OFFICIALS AND UNTIL THEY TAKE STRICT ACTIONS AGAINST THOSE WHO MOCK OUR CONSTITUTION, NOTHING WILL CHANGE FOR SURE.
What's with the caps bro?
I love this judge,i still believe in my judicial systems because of this judges.
Four Pillars of democracy-
the Legislature, Executive, Judiciary n Defense
dont keep ur hopes up so much. these are all petty cases compared to the ones the court dont want to touch but impacts all of us hugely - rafale, abuse of contstn spirit for 370, caa/nrc, forest land grab, activists/students/journos nder uapa, sedition, election bonds, demo, gst, states losing power and resources, NEET, engineered riots - delhi, farm laws, etc etc.
One should be blind to trust judiciary.
But melord not worried about minister above the law ...it's hurts his own ego ...we have seen melords actually behaving like lord .... 😂😂😂😂😂
@@guru_hindu It was her mistake, still she didn't apologize. Why so much Arrogant Governance
Court view is praiseworthy..sometime it's very must to rebuke the irresponsible bureaucrats who considers themselves above the system
There is no attrition in Civil Services why ?.. TWITTER CEO is sacked along with two other senior executive .. But IAS cadre enjoy immunity under law made during British era -- IRS is now preferred more as it is CORRUPTION READY cadre where 100 % people are corrupt. IAS cadre is busy in identifying some remote clause in 1935 British law to say " THIS CAN NOT BE DONE " .. People say IAS has to search for answers to the Minister question -- What is that -- can we not use computer for these mundane job ? DC office is filled with Tons of paper and one young chap of 25 years old is sitting in front of desk top and doing something on computer and that is called Computerization -- Go to IBM office GO TO AMAZON office -- No paper No pen all are digital including signature -- Everything means everything .. Why not our DC office become like that -- I know the answer -- All our IAS cadre hate computers as it is the main competitor for their job. Ready made work flow softwears are there SAP is gigantic can be used for any complex Enterprise resource transactional work ERPs
Actually agar ias minister ke liye wahan nhi hoti to wahan fatkaar padti ya transfer hota.
IS REALLY THE CASE OF ABOVE AND BELOW? People are above everyone and below them everyone are equal both Judiciary & Bureaucracy..
We can't genaralise without getting complete facts.there are good and bad elements in all sided
These types of judges is useful for society 👍
Our jurisdiction is very strong. Law should be a compulsory subject to each and every student in academics.
It is not jurisdiction, it is judiciary. Jurisdiction means area over which an officer has power to control.
Why, do you have law degree 😁
Thanks for the knowledge
Today the conduct of these IAS and IPS officials are a question mark for the democracy that being highest cadre government officials they challenge the judiciary and think judiciary can be taken into granted
IAS ab chatukar ban kar reh gye , moral khtam ho gya inka
Most IAS, IPS busy in Instragram photo shoot. Reality
Exactly....🙏🙏...
FARJI policies ko implement karne wale IAS log desh me croro berojgar ko janm derahe hain....
@@navajitkhound1900 lol, I agree. Most of them want to get the blue tick on Twitter as well. 😅
@@Rookie_22 😆
Judiciary is above executive as per constitution of India 🔥🔥
Thats a wrong comment. Constitutional framework is based on principle of separation of powers. Executive judiciary and legislature have separate powers exclusive to each other.
@@itsAnanth at the end of the day, you have to present yourself in court na ?
@@realmoonknight not necessarily.
@@itsAnanth no beta u must ias must appear before judge but not vice-versa
@@VOTER_indian the appearance of not to show institutional superiority. Its not fit progress of a case.
Great respect for our honourable courts.
This eastern trible district of MP i.e Anuppur., has very much illegal activities by local people and politicians as if there is no one to look after any thing... This IAS madem is right.. SECL is coal india company ,of which land has been given by... Pressure of local leader of 2009 time.
Every govt employee of this area is very much corrupt. This IAS lady has been frustrated by imposing fine on employees for not completing govt tasks on time. You can see the names of various officers being imposed fines on LokSeva website of MP. Though under the infulence of the MLA and Cabinet Minister of MP Bisahulal a converted BJP leader from congress . Not a single govt task is not completed on time in this district . Very much corrupted area and people also.. in the name of tribal region. ..i have seen it since my childhood. Coz i lived there.
Same every where -- IAS also involved in the corruption racket -- that is why they became IAS -- If they are really interested in doing something they would not have joined IAS and joined NPCI or somewhere else
seems u r favoring bjp converted frm cong..... ha ha ha ha
@@raymanrahman5598 : not at all...just told about minister and his....deeds
@@raymanrahman5598 well congress fools go to bjp. Bjp will become fool good for you aimim bro
I salute the Honorable Judge Mr. vivek Agarwal for his extraordinary efficiency.
True dispensation of justice. May the world be blessed by such judges than adharma practising judges
Sir I always salute your judgement
Though her conduct towards HC is not acceptable, but after seeing whole video, I understand she is doing good job standing against corruption and also assuring to take action against culprits. This is very difficult job to fight for forest land and stand against big cooperates and her own department and authorities.
I have no doubt the reason behind her bad conducts on HC orders are all because of corrupt govt bodies forcing her to withdraw this case.
God give her power to fight against corruption and protect forest land rights
table ki niche ki kamai
Yeah she woke up only after intervention of courts. And now she pledges to take action.
Do you think this matter would not have come to her before ?
She didn’t act intentionally and therefore should be penalised for her incompetence.
Nobody is greater than judicial...🤩
Politicians are.
@@batman_2004 he also has the right to arrest cm 😂😂😂
@@priyanshugaming485 but we all know he can't. Nobody ever arrested CM.
@@batman_2004 brother I am just telling about his power not talking about any cases like that 👍
The Great judge..
Aapko bar bar pranam
A rule should have been issued against the concerned officer for contempt of court.
UPSC NHI AB TO JUDGE BNENE KI EXAM CRACK KRNI HEIN😅😅
Why judge sahib always kind and generous towards ias and ips. Unless some officers jailed, they continue to ignore and casual to court orders.
Ji
I know the answer why court is soft on government establishment
Btaye
@@dhirendrasao6263 They are soft not only with government but with many other people also and that is why cases take 20 to 25 years in the name of delievring justice -- You know what I mean
जी
कितने ही
लेनदेन
पेशी पर पेशी
बच्चा का विदेश का खर्च
Really very nice Judge.
Superb judge sir respect ❤❤
Most of the time Court act like Monopoly in system.
They are....💣
हमारी नोकरशाही दूसरे ब्रिटिशर्स ही है जो जनता पर नियमों का धौंस जमा के सुलटा देती है।
judge is very humble
Had goosebumps 🙏😇 Jai hind
The Honourable Judge really has a good point for admonishing the civil servant. Inspite of being served summon from Court of being present in Court, she defies the same and such is the audacity that she is justifying by saying that her summon was clashed with the meeting of Cabinet Minister. So the Honourable judge is absolutely correct for it.
This is the power of lawyers and judges,
Ias and ips kitne powerful hai yha pta lgta hai
You are judge ?
Power kya bhai yei powerful wo powerful .. they r doing their respective duties .. murkh kahike
POWER SHOULD BE USED RIGHT DIRECTION WITH RIGHT APPROACH .
POWER KISKA KITNA HAI MATTER NEHI KAR TA 🙏
They have a two different sphere of work , one is executive another is judiciary , pr hamare desh k aise jaahil logo ko kaun samjhaye , power ka match nahi ho raha yaha , koi video game nahi h ki ek jyada powerful dusra less powerful yahi ignorant behavior ya illiterate crowd hamare india ki hone k karan ye haal h desh ka . In gadho ko ab kaun samjhaye ki dono me face off nahi batman vs superman nahi ho raha hai dono bs apne kaam ko kr rahe hai .
Leader and law is better always
And honourable court is our pride
Well technically cabinet ministers rank higher (at rank 7) than high court judges..
Having said that, the officer is responsible to file an affidavit informing the court of her inability to attend.
Excellent !
Nice. Misconduct hai. Disrespect of courts time
The biggest problem is all these IAS and IPS are living in British Era. They treat common citizens as their slaves. That’s a shame
Ms. Cabinet Minister should be punished with fine. So that every minister on the summons by Hon'ble court will be present without any delay.
Itni aukaat ni h
These broadcast improve confidence in system.
Very much professional in his job
I know about this case personally, and at the end secl won the case and the person parnikar was released and collector was fined 50 k .
!!! Shat -shat naman, 👏👏👏 !!!
Salute u judge saab
Court restores some faith.
Can courts pull up Election Commission of India and ask why they have not stopped VOTE BANK politics ? that they can not .. Massive misuse of REPRESENTATION OF PEOPLE ACT through various blatant dubious means which is very well known by all -- Vote spliting -- Dummy candidates -- Scientific rigging -- horse trading -- coalition drama -- CM staying in 5 star hotel for 6 months at government cost -- can courts stop all these ? calling one small less than 30 years old IAS officer front restores faith -- what is this
Outstanding judge
Public servants need to behave like "public servants"..not only them but police, ministers, everyone must act as per their designation..One must remember they are working for the "people". The hon. Judge is perfect with his analysis
Why TF is an IAS officer procrastinating this? 😂😂😂
Today IAS does not make sense. Quality is degrading day by day.
Great respect for the judge.
In reality cabinet minister enjoy huge power. In reality
Mai to upsc ki tayyari ki soch rha tha ab to law hi kar leta hun😂😂
Law is best
Grand entry of ias😂
Kuch punishment milegi ya sirf bla bla bla🙆😂
Is there anyone who can question judges
Or
Is judge above everything
Off course,Judge is Above than all Politicians
Wonderful judge
Sonia Meena, IAS. From Reserved Category in Rajasthan. Judge asking her do you have Regard on the judiciary. She replied she went to meet a Cabinet Minister.
In most of the highcourt cases in Bihar, UP, the SDM, DSP, SSP, DGP, COLLECTORS are reprimanded by the Judge for their lakadestine handling of cases with total disregard to the rules. Many of these people are neither intelligent or have benefited from the Training they undergo. This is the Bane of Reservation in India.
Let the honourable supreme court shall clarify in a public petition to know who is superior. Real victim is small business person and common man. Who is going to compensate them? Neither the number of court cases nor elected officials programs come down.
Meena sun ke samjh gya pura case
Actually relatives came to my house sir.. school time reasons 😅
The whole executive is answerable to the respective state High courts .
Awesome judge
IS REALLY THE CASE OF ABOVE AND BELOW? People are above everyone and below them everyone are equal both Judiciary & Bureaucracy..
Modi ji is above supreme court 🤣 waha to sir sir
Sir salute ⚖ dil se...
❤❤❤❤
They should come to the court,this will cndmpt.
Fabulous judge 👨⚖️
Legislature and Execitives/Burocrats are under judicial review judiciary is check point for both organs H.C.and S.C are constitutional courts meant for throught out india denials will be treated as serious
Wow
Grand entry 😂
Kiya huya 😂😂judge ka samne 😂hakre nikal gaye 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
problem is court just let go these kind of adamant Officials but for a change Court did put some question on this official credibility and work ethics
She is miss Sonia Meena
Our annupur dm
H’ble Judge shouldn’t compare cabinet ministry above high court….. They are two different systems shouldn’t interfere with each other. Cabinet is indirectly( al most) directly elected by people whose so.e purpose is to serve people.
Actually cabinet secretary is above judge... 😂😂😂
No the Judiciary is superior as per constitution.
Shame on this corrupt DM...
Biggest problem is which is more supreme if there no legislation there is no judiciary. And looking at the history Administration is supreme. So Judge asking who is more important, this being supreme myth should be withdrawn. Well respect for all.
The Cabinet does not pass legislation, the Parliament does! Judiciary interprets the ACT/Statute - made by Parliament within the framework of the constitution.
Mr. Judge, why simply you NOT crack down with strongest power that you would have as HC judge for such a worst BLATANT contempt of HC....... why do you act helpless in spite of power that HC has.
😂 Court will not publish the leaves of employee but expect from everyone.. Court judge must travel out of earth then only they will realise that in universe many things above the court. You are just a unmovable particle. 😂
Tree types of cabinet.
If the word cabinet.
One reason is that there's hardly any person left who can ' proudly ' say yes I am an IAS or IPS officer. The first letter is 'india' means service to the nation. But in reality it has become a service to the corrupt politicians . E. G. In Kerala swapna suresh ( and others ) are PAS - Pinarayi Administrative Service. Where has the ' I' gone.?
Your comments based on some falsehood fouls spread by some digested Sanghis in Kerala who couldn't get a political positions in Kerala. So you have heard the uncivilized news created by Sanghis of Kerala.
@@rajasekharan2743seriously. You should be stupid enough to believe these accusations as propaganda even after the solid digital evidences are out
Those politicians should give arrest warrants if they do not apear before courts and govt. Law agencies. They are to be treated like a commenman before the court.
Isme ias entry wala video laga do tho aur maja aa jaaye 😂😂
Good morning Madam
Video conference me b ho sakta hai yaar.
That's the best debate I have ever hear.🙂
all these ias ips are corrupt
Till date, this system of British civil service is going on. Once some body selected for this civil services, they feel they are above law as was seen during British period. Most unfortunate indeed.
Lol Why don't you focus on your Netas.
It's them who are above the law and get away with everything.
Cheks and balance sirf executive and legislature pe hi itna kyu hai ....inn judiciary ne apne aap ko itna mahan kyu bana rakha hai....
I donot know these people become ias( infact i know how ? people who study with privileges and have no relation with ground, sardar patel would have disabandoned whole civil services ). She should suspended immediately. Have no shame to tell the court that minister is coming for tour. What service will she give to poor citizens.
That is not true. we cant generalize this about IAS/IPS. there are good officers.
@@LawChakra they are single handedly responsible, there is no individual gratification/specialized concession when society fails . Courts come in picture much later. Not that courts are not at fault.
Reservation system
@@nikhilranjan9264 it's not about reservation system. There are many non reserved people doing the same. Core competency of being civil servant is absent .
This is the biggest problem court doesn't understand, minister k age present hona padta h fir chahe tumhri khud ki Tang kabar me kyu na lataki ho, it's the pressure, because they don't go with rules
What is the name of this IAS officer?
Who may be above or below in society people representatives and good offices getting respect and honour. No judge or lawaris received good honour and respect from the general public judiciary system have a lot of gray area in it.
👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿
They are only to enjoy the privilege for being an IAS or IPS
IAS means Big car -- Bungalow and servants for bringing tea -- Only these 3 comes to my mind -- What they do ? perhaps I am doing far better job in IT - This is totally British system still existing.. New trend is both husband and wife are IAS and its policy of central government they have be posted near by so that they can live together .. it is now becoming head ache to the government to manage their family matters . There Conflict OF INTEREST clause does not apply as they are above cloud - no rains there
I have 3 personal servants, and a team of 43 people working under me at the office. I am only B. Tech.
@@i_fuk_religion You pay them .. but DC servants are paid by TAX payers money including DC herself is paid by tax payers money -- They are Public Servants Not publci masters
@@sureshpolali8685 bro ias officer are government servant not public
Can those lawyers plz give the officer some space. Jeez...the Mike is adjustable. Just move man.
Judge grilled 😂...now do ias entry 🤣
wah madam ji aap badi responsible malum hoti ho.
Why is she just staying silent. Verbal skills is so much lacking amongst civil servants.
Right no one is above the law.
The one sitting in the judge is not the law.
Sometimes the judge is speaking like he is the law.
He is just a presider of the law.
He is not the law.
Peoples are the law.
Bold collector.Congrats.
Subse upper hai paisa jiske pass aa jaye vahi upper
In andhra the present Chief Minister is in bail for corruption cases, of an Amount 43000 crores, he spent 16 months jail for the last 10 years he is in bail, he supposed to go every Thursday and Friday to Court, but he never goes This is the situation in Andhrapradesh And the so called judges of Andhrapradesh, what A democracy
Aisee Loogo ki Job se nikaal dena chahiye.
This is why just rutt ke Civils clear karna professional job karna different hota hai...
Private sector employees are 100 times more efficient that so called people servants.....
Yeh koi apke school ka exam thode h ratt ke upsc nikal liya. Dur ke angoor khatte lgte h.
@@studywithconcepts4689 school students and everyone else in this country contribute to the society in a positive way than people these people extremely Theoretical, and Non sensical exam. Infact all these officers are the roadblocks and red tape warriors to curtailed development of this country
@@studywithconcepts4689 country will develop much fater tomorrow this UPSC shitt show will be closed and replaced with some good logical exam..
Cabinet ministry is definitely above and more important over HC.
Wrong, nobody above judicial.
अरे प्राइम मिनिस्टर इंदिरा गांधी को आना पड़ा था इलाहाबाद हाईकोर्ट में और हाई कोर्ट ने 6 साल के लिए उनके चुनाव लडने पर प्रतिबंध भी लगा दिया था,
और यहां कैबिनेट मिनिस्टर को हाई कोर्ट से बड़ा बताया जा रहा है कितनी मूर्खता की बात है।
Cabinet minister chapri ha...high court ke samne aur supreme court ke samne naukar
Judiciary is above all