'One of the most important events': Key meeting on jury instructions to be held in Trump trial
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 05. 2024
- Judge Merchan and the lawyers in former President Trump's hush money case are going to work out what the jury will be told about the charges ahead of deliberations. MSNBC legal correspondent Lisa Rubin and MSNBC legal analysts Chuck Rosenberg, Catherine Christian and Danny Cevallos explain more.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
'One of the most important events': Key meeting on jury instructions to be held in Trump trial
#Trump #Trial #HushMoney
My husband and I had jobs that required each of us to keep client or customer confidentiality. We both have been on juries and never discussed the cases with each other until after the case ended. We played by the rules.
Yes, but you are Honest people. DJT used NDA's to keep crimes & misdeeds secret.
As a juror once myself - i did not share anything at all and told my wife simply not to ask and that it was very important to follow the process. I learned so much in that time. Jurors don't talk to eachother ether until deliberating together by lead of the chosen foreman. We felt accountable to each other and to respect the rules. We never had an issue with it everyone did their job and we went home when done. For the most part our case was not very interesting anyway. And when people asked all they wanted to know was the very basics ( hollywood drama) and the truth was that it was far more intricate than that and was real life.
So what we got here is a thief and adulterer.
Dont forget draft dodger
I don't see how instructions are going to somehow make Trump not guilty.
BECAUSE, THERE IS NO CRIME
Laws only exist when enforced. No one is above the law. Prove it.
And the law needs to be applied equally to all
When a law has not been broken, making one up is illegal
@@ecurewitz That's been hard for humans from the beginning, since it has always been the powerful and wealthy who come up with the laws and the mechanisms of enforcement.
@@MDK75345 You don't need to make anything up against Trump. Just take your pick of all his offences.
@@mitchhills4747 It's made up, this court has no jurisdiction over election interference and they had to literally escalate a misdemeanor to justify the case.
Having served on two juries that got to the deliberation stage both juries were different. The first jury was a court martial jury and as the junior officer on the jury there was no way I was going to bring up the case during our breaks prior to being handed the case. So I sat there quietly and absolutely nothing to say. Having said that rest assured that I did not hesitate to challenge the opinions of the senior officers during the deliberations. I did not feel put upon, my input was in fact welcomed. On the civilian case, my behavior was exactly the same. While the other jurors had discissions about the case sometime, I sat quietly and said nothing, which led them to believe that I was opposed to the opinions they were expressing and that they had their work cut out for them to convince me to their point of view. In fact I agreed 100%. So once we were handed the case, everybody wanted to hear what I had to say because I was backing up with evidence what they had already said. It was a civil case and in my state there are two juries. The first jury determines liability and the second damages if any. This was the first jury. Most people take being on a jury seriously. Once they have been selected they want to do a GOOD job.
Before Donnie can have a unified Reich, doesn’t he have to spend time in prison for a failed coup and then write a book about his struggle as the bigliest victim?
You know to be an accurate historical parallel.
Maybe when he's found guilty, he could have the court send his ghost writer to jail for him. That way his writer can get the full feel of the victimization the orange one has had to put up with for the last 9 years.
Donald Jessica Trump - write a book? 🤣
The man can barely write his own name!
They may be instructed by the judge not to talk about the Knicks.
Or Trump's face paint.
I am surprised Frump, doesn't call himself. GOLDFINGER
@@zukewashere1539 Goldfinger with backwards pants - depends I guess
See you next Tuesday, Trump!
The Cunny Runt.
Once heard a federal prosecutor say that he had attorneys on two juries and they $crewd him both times, hope that doesn't happen here ....
Katy sure is casting some strange doubt on the jurors.
Very disappointing . Sounds dumb .
Are we going to discuss PROJECT 2025 the republican handbook? I think people have a right to know before they vote. How many people want to wake up to that reality? How do you explain to your kids? What will you tell them you did? Please, the world is watching.
Talk talk talk. I’ll testify. They have a name in texas for guys like orange man. All hat, no cattle.
That may in fact be the case for his real estate empire.
Did you know that Trump doesn't own the land under his 40 Wall Street office building? It belongs to a wealthy family in the ship brokerage business. When you have cargo to move by ship, that's who arranges a ride.
Because of the Trump stink, and general office vacancies due to work from home, he may not be covering the land lease and general operating expenses. In that case the building isn't worth anything to a buyer, despite its size. When the NY Attorney General is finally allowed to collect on the civil judgements, there may be nothing to collect.
The January 6th trial would have been the most important one to have before the elections. Trump is playing America against herself. Register and vote BLUE ion November! 💙💙💙.
Exactly. Brit here - I'm so disappointed for you all that it wasn't remedied before your General Election in Nov. Rooting for you! 🩵
i hope they are fast to decide
They've said one of those attorneys is a corporate lawyer. Don't know what type of the lawyer does.
Maybe the jurors in the E Jean Carrol case didnt look at her because they felt sympathy for what she had been through, and was going through.
Wait for the decision and then we know
Catherine Christian's perspective is always so insightful and intelligent.
Yes, she has the IQ of a grasshopper. Negative five.
Trump's more of a Mormon than Romney I just hope Melanie is okay with it.
I hope these jurors reach a decision that helps begin healing this country. tRump needs to be held accountable.
So does briben
@@Americasinertialmao Biden isn’t the one under indictment and he never will be 😂
Deflect more Trumpanzee
@@Americasinertiawho's briben?
They just proved Cohen stole hundreds of thousands of dollars from Trump. Trump is a victim.
@@apt1smith51 He just says things we stopped caring about months ago, like when we heard most of Comer's witnesses had been indicted by the FBI for working with Russia. Or when Biden said a weird thing about an uncle vanishing in Peru, that literally no one cared about when it happened.
This conversation is inappropriate, as is information about the jury. We have to wait for their verdict, Speculation and storytelling is not what this trial is about.
he's no Mandela
Trump has until next Tuesday to skip town. I hear Siberia is lovely this time of year.
Putin wouldn't want him either. Nyet!! 😡
I hear The Democratic People's Republic of Korea is stunning in spring time.
Why don't you move there?
@@leonblack2651 Tucker says it's better than America.
Why would he? Even if convicted he wins. the radical left simply doesn’t have the ability or aptitude to lead or win elections ever again except maybe in Cali
Netflix works, too.
Wait a minute I just found out that Stormy Daniels is married.
Two attorneys on the jury. Wow. What did they think of Robert Costello's performance?
It reminded them of Abbott and Costello - a comedy act.
Costello destroyed Cohen's fragment of credibility
I guess they were profoundly embarrassed by it if they are competent lawyers.
@@julianciahaconsulting8663 No, he did not. If anything, Costello did a lot of damage to the defence. It just supported Cohen's stance that people will do just about ANYTHING for the gangster Trump.
@@julianciahaconsulting8663lol yes, and his own as well.
“Do you really think that you are going to con 12 New Yorkers?”
Easy if they are democrats 😅
NY might be the most fair place for him to get a trial. They've known him his entire life, they were never fooled.
@@mile_high_topher It must be awful to be as stupid as you.
I grew up in New York City. We KNOW Trump, from decades of adultery, bankruptcies, and just being a big fat blowhard. He only got 12% of the vote in Manhattan, and that 12% are the Wall Street types who like his tax cuts.
Trump certainly tried
LOOKS LIKE COSTELLO COMMITED PERJURY
Experience as a juror who sat on several cases. Honesty, common sense and jury instructions are the most important and critical part of reaching a decision. Honesty deals with that part of you that want to do what's right. Common sense is that part of you that wants to be comprehensive. Jury instructions is the part that directs and guides you, to a decision you think or believe is right both morally and according to law. (There you have it from my opinion).
Trump is cooked, bbq cooked😂
He's the leader of the Unified Reich, he's gonna be laughing like a mad man.
He didn’t testify because those old bonespurs were acting up again.
True. Went from Cheating Stalin briben. To Hitler trump.
Meanwhile Biden openly is supporting Netanyahu over the ICC
naw he be wafflin like a juan kerr
Don't worry guys... we super duper for real without a doubt pinky swear have him this time.🤣
But they have this time. Just wait until they hand down the verdict.
I have that book. It's great.
Couldn’t take their eyes off or Alina Habba? I wonder why 😂
Oh man, looks like they got him this time!
WHAT CRIME????!!
Wouldn't take the stand like he said he would. Only people with something to hide don't take the stand he once said...He's so GUILTY!!!
but but but he SAID he would take the stand so his sheep think he did and when they kinda realize he didn't they'll think back to him saying he couldn't because he was gagged. If THEY weren't so stupid I might think he was pretty smart, but he's not... just a conman with lota lotsa lotsa marks
Get ready to lock the stink up make stinky stand back and stand by while you slammed the cell doors
Throw Trump in prison and you just handed him the White House - thats the reality the Democrats just refuse to accept.
You every saw anyone come court without any type defense. Well look at trump case the silence defense😂😂😂 if I were a jury member of this case my first question is where’s the witnessed for defense. And then I probably would vote guilty for that reason but for many many many reasons also as jury member I’m looking for some from some type defense from trump period not just silence defense
Could you try that again, squire, but in English this time?
That was edited??! I’d have loved to have seen the original.
Jury will convict
@@TheDiamond2009You're complaining about grammar like your Aurora account.
Well, not only witnesses for the defense but how about lard butt testifying on his own behalf? I mean, he's constantly pimping his idea that everyone but him is lying so why didn't he get on that witness stand and prove it?
Isn’t it that lawyers retainer fee has a certain description of what is the need for retaining a lawyer. But if the retainment of Michael Cohen is for contingency then Trump may be acquitted but the collaboration of Trump and Cohen validates that )130k as hush money payment.
He's not even a witch he may be a warlock.
I wonder if she claimed that money on her taxes?
My experience as a juror was base all on facts of the truth under our constitutional law that govern us all because we are all innocent until proven guilty to acknowledge the law versus denied the law for we all know the law but our failure is not to obey it
Its going to be a mistrial.
How facile and immature, to attempt judging a stranger's behaviour from their appearance.
“their”
It's called unconscious bias - and we all do it to some degree, because we're human.
Which makes my point.@@Ron-Ayres
Except for Catherine , seems a little silly.
Can the jury discuss before they vote? Or do they just vote then discuss if it a hung jury
Usually when a jury is sent to their room to decide,they'll take a hand vote to get an idea how people are thinking. It rally depends on the foreperson. They may immediately start discussing what each person's individual take was,too. I always think of the movie 12 Angry Men. How one person's view point can sometimes sway the others.
They have an opportunity to go over all the evidence and court transcripts (what the court reporter wrote down) and compare that to the jury instructions. But if their minds are already made up, they can vote and come back as fast as they can fill out the necessary paperwork (each charge has to be recorded yea or nay),
lots of debate first, they can swing ither way before making a decision
Wait… these jurors are not sequestered?!?!? A high profile case like this and they’re letting them go home where they can watch all the partisan media on either side swaying them? 🤦♂️
No the Democrat jury was picked to give a pre set verdict of guilty before the legal proceedings even began. This is a kangaroo court pure and simple
If you're listening to andrea Mitchell you'll be there a long time as she takes hours to say anything. She needs to go.
Democrats are a Danger to our Democracy
Innocent Days are Over.
PLEASE jury, convict this monster!
Put him away in the big house
Just checking in as I have done daily for the past 7.5 years to see if, in fact, the walls finally closed in today. I will check back tomorrow.
You can't be checking in that diligently because he's been fined close to 500 million for fraud and defamation. The CFO of the Trump organization served time for fraud and is now in prison for perjury.
Lock him up
Lock up demokkkrats
for what crime? Whats the crime here?
The only crime I've heard of is that Trump was defrauded by the ex-lawyer... If that is who you meant then yes, lock the ex-lawyer up for fraud & conspiracy of election interference.
Excuse me but did you all see it michael cowen's male full of himself
The orange criminal refused to testify. 🤣
Because this case has failed.😆
There was absolutely no need for him to testify in this b******* case
You know what happens to all the oppressors once he gets back in right? Yeah, we’re gonna end up a bit light in the population count for decades following that
Yep
@@whiteprivilege912 It didn't fail the dude is guilty and change your profile pic it's trash please recycle! ♻️
Use AI to find out what the juries are thinking about 😊.
They're thinking why did somebody waste 3 weeks of their time with a bulshit case
@@bobevans9955 The adults can't wait to say guilty for the orange criminal.
@@bobevans9955the prosecution is lucky to have your dear leader in their corner!
@@DarthSailorMoo good luck with that
@@bobevans9955 Thanks to under oath they don't need luck.
These womenndint known anything about anything and the lawyer is useless lol what a c team lol
I just hope none of the jurists were threatened and are able to vote their minds
Trump and his minions have been intimidating witnesses and all those involved with the case from the start, so I trust that they will be safe because Trump and his flunkies are dangerous people. When they don't get their own way, we have mayhem.
Is that Katy Tur? I'm out
Why?
Shes a secret Republican
Trump crushed her in an interview a few years ago
This was a very bad spot. Wait until you have news.
lol if the railroad TRUMP this whole party will be history!
Collective delirium.
The liberal echo chamber is so strong
Maga so true so much Collective delirium
@@DeltaTango2024 Will you be the one who isn't too embarrassed to tell us your source for news?
@@mile_high_topher certainly no MSM. Do independent research
@@Muttinchopsforeverandalways aren't you blind?
Guilty as charger!
You're absolutely delirious
If I was on the jury I'd be voting guilty. They had me at the first witness and the evidence just kept pouring in!
FDJT 😮😅🇺🇸
@@apt1smith51 Me to. I would be so bored and asking if we could get to the conclusion of guilty already.
@@bobevans9955says the trump cultists 🙄
Tur casually goes on about "profiling" people based off their appearance, you're not low kkkaren- we see you
These jurors have been through this for weeks knowing that at any moment Trump could sic his crazy January 6th folks on them. Do you honestly think they're going to mess up over the weekend by chit-chatting at a Memorial Day barbecue? Really having a hard time believing that they're suddenly not going to take this seriously after all they've been through.
Hopefully, Trump never got the names of the jurors
Go hug Mommy, you will be ok
@@ecurewitz We all know their name, dem.hacks.
@@Bob-bb3ur Adorable, but vague threats against jurors from an anonymous account aren't exactly convincing people that the MAGA crowd aren't terrorists.
@@Bob-bb3ur do you plan on threatening them
The Trial could prove DJT committed crimes. Once Trial started the Jury did not change. That could imply Solidarity or they Concur so we'll wait & what The Jury decides.
Katy Tur is a trump mouthpiece 😬
Most MSM....especially msnbc, is literally liberal propaganda
I've thought that recently. Maybe she is playing devils advocate but I think shes a secret Republican but not maga. But then anchor alicia mendez dad is a total crook with actual gold bribes whose off to prison lol
Trump for prison,
LOCK HIM UP
Never going to happen snowflake
Best place for him
Oh boy m s n b c flunkies
DA Bragg 👏👏 sir u put together the A team on this trial they are eating the defense witness for lunch ❤
Guilty guilty of everything changes
guilt of what crime?
What is the penalty for 34 misdemeanors that are past the statute of limitations? 😂
because of covid, those limitations were put on hold...trump committed the crime in late 2016
These are felonies
Less than for the felonies he is actually charged with.
They are felonies and there is one charge that he could serve 5 years for. Cohen got 3 years for a lesser offence....
Wait and see how his limitations stack against RICO in the grander theatre.
MSNBC … Trump backers mostly don’t pay attention to him - Project 2025 - Project 2025 - Project 2025 … that’s ALL I want to hear about!!!
🗑
Can I just vent here? I hate the transitional expressions, "Having said that..." or "That being said..." They are the most clichéd filler phrases ever. The person speaking is just showing off. They lo-o-ove to hear themselves talk.
Brit here - I don't find this fancy at all! It's in quite common usage here, simply expressing a caveat or exception to their previous comment.
I'm now curious, how would you express the same sentiment?!
I really don't like the red and black x's and stripes graphic you put on your front desk. It's ugly and sends the wrong impression. Bad choice.
Andrea Mitchell denigrating the entire Juror Judicial system in one sentence - oy vey!
Gossip...
First
What are you 5 years old
It's good to have goals in life
Well it’s “we finally got Donald Trump” day…………….again.
They say we’re young and we don’t know. We won’t find out until we grow. 🎶🎵🎶🎵
Is that what anyone is saying? Did anyone on the show say Trump is getting convicted?
We're ALL smart enough (right?) to see how bent the system is to favor the rich.
None of us would ever get this kind of favor in court. No one. You think you'd get ELEVEN opportunities to violate a gag and STILL not go to jail? Merchan has been more than fair and you know it. The entire world does, even you goobers.
None of us would ever get this kind of favor in court. No one. You think you'd get ELEVEN opportunities to violate a gag and STILL not go to jail?
2nd term 4th reich!
The walls are closing in
there's so much delusion in these comments it's unreal. you people are not well.
Juror 1, 2 and 8 see an opportunity to make some money should a representative of trump confront them.
These guys are instigating
That judge needs to dismiss this case so The jury does not have to make a decision
How is this jury not being sequestered? This is about as high profile with as much biased media coverage as it gets. All it’s going to take is one juror’s CZcams app to automatically cue up a musical guest on Stephen Colbert show and the whole validity of the case will be in question. 🤦♂️
The ideology of people coming into our country is sick and twisted, to think that these ruined countries are just victims is Highly questionable!!!!
Katy Tur is AWFUL
Hummmm let’s see how well liked is the judge after the ruling
What ruling? The Judge has done a fine job so far, in spite of all the antics of team Trump lol! In any event, The Judge is not doing this to win a popularity contest.
No crime
NOT GUILTY
Guilty as charged. On the evidence, the testimony, the DOCUMENTS, the recordings.....etc....and of course all the publicity stunts that Trump pulled these last weeks in order to get the case thrown out because he HAD no defence...
will all 12 new york jurors lie and say "guilty" when they have heard the truth for 20 days? (the trump case)
You assume too much because you've been listening to the orange one's lies lol!
@@mitchhills4747
it was a question not a statement, i did not assume.
How much time does one serve in prison for 34 misdemeanors with the staue of limitations already up?? Anybody know?? Anyyyyyone....😂😂
Less than the felonies he is actually charged with.
There is plenty of commentary out there. It's time for you to research it.
Anyone know how much tax dollars have the Democrats wasted with these kangaroo court proceedings just because they cant find anyone without dementia that would be better than Biden with dementia to run against Trump??
Ohhh I just researched it. The law clearly states once the statue of limitations are up one cannot be charged with said crime. Oooops. 😂😂🤣👆
@@Haywood118 One of the most powerful district attorneys offices in the United States made the charging decision. And you know more than they do? SMH!
women can keep a secret for abour 3 hours, i have heard.
TRUMP IS GUILTY. 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮
Thank you Captain Obvious
You really think these people in the jury in New York would do the right thing and find Trump innocent don't think so they would lose everything they own and have
On the contrary, it's Trump and his minions who have been threatening everyone involved in this case from day one! Why do you think he is innocent anyway? The jury will make the decision, based on the solid evidence.
Robert Costello just won the case for Trump.
Go home bot you're drunk
100%
@Chnmmr Keep Drinking MSDNC Kool-aid Stay Miserable and Misinformed 😂
@@Chnmmrdrunk like Rudy fooliani
@@Chnmmr go back down in Mommy's basement and play video games
Sounds like a kangaroo court too me 😆
"This is it! Trump is going to jail THIS time!" - Democrats in 2050
Lots of misinformation you spreading
@@apt1smith51 You want me to hold your purse so you can cry about it little girl?
@@apt1smith51 Wahhhh😭
Trump is leading nearly every battleground state and swing states.
The American people overwhelmingly agree that Trump’s policies are better for the economy.
Trumps rallies are breaking attendance records, even in blue states.
😂 how do you come home with this stuff?
Your comment is laughable at best
Biden's policies have given us 50 year record low unemployment and a booming manufacturing sector. Would republicans like to get together with democrats and do something about all the jobs AI is taking, and will be taking? Bueller?
@@slayeroftrolls1200A simple google search or CNN👈🏻😁
@@Muttinchopsforeverandalways You see what Peru classified you as?😂