What allottees think of the 3,000+ flats inaugurated under Kalkaji slum rehab project
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 11. 2022
- Two days after Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated over 3,000 flats on 2nd November for the rehabilitation of slum dwellers in Delhi’s Kalkaji Extension, under Delhi Development Authority’s (DDA) 'in situ rehabilitation project', the beneficiaries gathered to get the first glimpse of their new homes on 4 November. Watch ThePrint Ground Report by Sukriti Vats.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our CZcams Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
As a young architect in New Delhi in the last decade we had theorized on many such projects but deep down I never really imagined there will be enough political will to have one to these built. Dont get me wrong there are multiple EWS housing throughout India but they are never transferred to the poor. Pretty cool to see one actually go to the slum dwellers.
Apparently, they sell it or rent it out and go back to old lifestyle
@@thedeadwalkingguy some of them will do that here as well, but now it will be much more difficult and they may even be penalized for that.
@@PseudoProphet i don't think they will be able to. EWS generally is privately built. Although they are supposed to be cheap they don't actually end up with the poor because the distribution is handled by developers. This on the other hand will have policy backing it up. Not saying it's impossible, just improbable. EWS are successfully sold to highest bidder because all of them are sold off (in real estate neighborhood also matters). Now that the housing is handed over I think the stigma of it being a slum redevelopment housing will save it
Dharavi should be next....
But that would that would drastically impact foreign tourism in India !!
@@sagnikdebsarkar169 😂😂😂
People complaining about apartments size. They don't know the value of land in Delhi. If your family is of 8-10 members. Then it's not govt. fault to provide each of you home. People are living in worse conditions in slums. Govt can't raise you from poverty, it can only help or give you a push.
True
Right bro 😊..
It is a good home for a family of 4. Also if ppl are having 4 or 5 kids then it is not the problem of the govt.
How's not a problem?
@@ashishsunny7963 govt cannot keep on providing free things for non stop procreation of human beings, you have to stop somewhere. that lady had 4 sons, 4 daughter in laws and 7 children. hadd hoti hai, u have to stop somewhere.
@@shashanksharma8748 Dude,I'm asking the commentator as to how he can say that people breeding like rodents is not a problem?
@@ashishsunny7963 breeding like rodent? Have you forgotten you are speaking about human beings?
@@newsjunkieish Then they should behave like human beings...ok fine...breeding like swines...
I really want to feel happy for them. But the way some of them are complaining I don't think I should feel happy for them. You have got a free house whether it is small or big. No EMI, No loans, Nada, nothing. Be greatful for it. If you want a bigger house then go earn it. Are they expecting government to give them 2,000 sq.ft house with full furnishing? Come on, I see over and over again Indians never stop complaining and are never satisfied if something is given for free or at affordable prices. They keep asking for more and more.
I think what they are complaining abt is that in a slum area they were able to spread out but now they are boxed In … something was taken away from them and they were given something else in lieu which is not matching up on certain criteria’s … but she still said it’s a good apartment…. Seems a like a fair comment to me
Haha you should read Singapore PMs book. About how some Singaporens complained about vertical housings, and how enclosed it was compared to their slums. Many where even growing cattless, poultry inside their flats!
Exactly , I want to criticize the people's comments but i think if i do, than i would become the negative person. They should be happy thay they are provided.
@@LuckyBombay yes, now they cannot illegally occupy government land as much as they want... yes
Exactly....in India, ppl want free and also premium things.....pathetic...
I never imagined i could live to see such projects come to light. Good initiative none the less
These have happened in the past in multiple cities and failed though. Let’s hope this one works
@@terrybatman that time the buildings were made very far from the place where they were living...but with jahan jhuggi wahan ashiyana scheme they don't have to leave the place where they were living for so long
You can die peacefully now
I have seen somany towers like this in my city those are built under pm Avas yojana
One wife n Two children,lead to a happy n prosperous life ❤
But sad “afterlife” for certain categories of population. They care about THAT PART. Have u been living under a rock??
@@RojaJaneman what 😝😝😝😝😝😝😝😝😝peaceful people I guess
I dnt knw y but I hv to admit that I hv becme an admirer of PM Modi in Civil projects it needs guts to execute such plans, 🇵🇰👏 Modi is defeating Land mafias, who hv criminal background in subcontinent politics.
Not only civil but being a person from construction and infra industry , he has also launched projects in infra and power in the last 3 to 5 years.
There many negative point in this government obviously they also a human but still the modi goverment maybe the first government who focus on infra i mean project complete on time mostly
And project which start 20 yrs back also completed
The negative points if any are minuscule as compared to the mammoth positive work done by this govt....if u start counting the positive work you'll be called a bhakt...be careful...b very careful
Indian Subcontinent
Pakistani bhakt😆😆
The government should be aware - this approach has been used in Mumbai in the early 2000s. Most of the slum dwellers rented their apartments and went to the outskirts of Mumbai to build new slums.
Whaaaaaat
@@bopedope5227 Yes a lot of slum dwellers did that. They run their small business (if you call it a business) & also earn rent from those rehab houses whilst living in hellish conditions in slums near sewers. They do that coz they want money & don't care about a better house.
@Maina B Only way to end this problem is to make them self sufficient. Giving free homes or whatever is not going to solve anything.
@@dreadfulbodyguard7288 how can you enlighten us
@@niravmehta7295 Instead of giving free homes, spend that money on improving quality of education. Improve school, college curriculum to make it more aligned with industry needs. More scholarships for bright but poor students, make education loans easier for deserving candidates.
Basically don't give stuff for free. Just support the hardworking poor students by providing them opportunities so that they can lift their families up themselves.
Only request is that people living there should keep it clean and they should be taught about family planning, 4 kids in this era is totally not correct...
They won't, they still have that jhopadpatti mindset
@@whocares5584 true
Thanks Modi Ji, we got our dream Homes ❤🙏💐
🤗❤️☺️😊🥰
Fir bhi vote to congress ko hi doge aap log
@@bhaveshtontiya7152 sad but true
@@bhaveshtontiya7152 Congress kuch kaam nahi karegi bas minority ka rona roti rahegi kaam kuch nahin karegi 🤬😡
God bless you my son.
Wishing you all the best
Keep smiling!
Thanks!
Don't have money to feed themselves but have 4 kids !
Problem with low education and low income group.
I think unki mentality hoti h agar 4 bache honge toh voh log bhi kaam karenge aur income badh zayegi but isska ye drawback ki unki development nhi hogi generation by generations voh log low income group me he rah zayenge
@@leyvithanTech extra 2 bacche zada kuch nahi kama lega, low income job karenge, jo kamayenge khud me hi kharch ho jayega, to kuch fayda nahi 4 bacche ki. ulta wo 4 bacche ko kaam karne ki umar tak khilana padhga, akhir me sab me ruksan hi hay, justify nahi kar sakte.
Good initiative from central government. All the state governments across India “keeping politics aside” work with central government and uplift poor from slum and settle them in proper housing. 👏👌🙏
Still people are complaining 🤦
With all facilities and space
If you have 5 children this is not goverment problem
Hope dharvi also redevlo
I live in agra same work happen in an area
But they also complaining for same reason
South delhi me villa Dil Wade kya 😑
Private jet aur ek limousine to sabko milna hi chahiye.
Last line is just perfect 🤣
Bhai government or kya kare ab government itna hi kar sakti hai kyuki government ko desh bhi chalana hai bhai ☺️😊
@@ashfaaqmir7869Dubai me mil jata hai islmabad me toh maze hi maze
We should have a very strict policy on who is getting this deals, so that there can be no corruption and quality architecture that will stand the test of time.
So true. I sincerely pray from the bottom of my heart that it's not another morbi bridge in waiting. 🤞
now its tagged to aadhaar of all family members...if they are caught encroaching govt land there will be jail time
Wish to see more such projects,,,,, If people get good place to live their life Will definitely change , they can think & do something else than worrying basic needs
Feeling happy and inner satisfaction that our tax money is invested in a really good projects .. hope government will frequently take these types of steps in future .
Aur ye bhadve usme khush nahi hain inko kya pata Delhi me itna flat lene me g fat jati hain
Truly appreciate projects 🙏
Well done Modi ji 🙏🇮🇳🙏
It's good to see that nice flats been allocated...I hope people keep it clean and don't ruin this ...the way people are complaining is like give us everything in free....at least feel gratitude for the tax payers
Although I agree with you on ppl complaining. But this constant rant of "I am paying tax" --- is grabage. You are paying tax bcoz u are privileged class. You able to earn bcoz u had good education and other support. These ppl are mostly labourers.
@@Prvn708 honest tax payers always get such replies...we pay tax coz we work hard and harder every day....and no benefits....at least others should respect and aspire to be that
@@inderobr Labourers also work hard. The metro you ride is built by poor labourers by slogging in hot sun, dust, in dangerous conditions. Not by sitting in swanky ac buildings, with long week end holidays. Finally how much they earn ? peanuts in front of ur remuneration...
@@Prvn708 this is the problem of always having a bias towards one section of society.... people usually have a downward bias for middle class for some hidden jealousy....
@@Prvn708 Dude People Work hard and with smartness as well as Taking Risk to Earn More by setting Up Bussiness... Even my father earn less at his young age.. but saving more and spend less he saving up some money and start new Bussiness.. than taking loan he expand Bussiness... So if Bussiness faces loss.. and unable to Pay Loan for sometime he loose everything he earn in his lifetime... Thats not case for other working class..
Nothing is going to change In couple of months/year you will see same people selling/giving these flat on rent and moving to another jhopdi
Strictly can't be sold
sab aap nayak dekhke aaye ho ?
I think it'll be different this time.
@@DipayanGhosh Mumbai me ye hota hai Nayak dekh ke nahi ye sach hai .
@@simba_thelabra9995 there are policy measures that can stop it from happening but easily applied if it's not a developer implementing it. That being said BMC is known to be one the most corrupt bodies, so maybe it will be more difficult without the political will.
These apartments should be leased by the government instead of transferring ownership to these people. There have been many cases where these flats gets sold to others.
this kind of work 'rehabilitation' is need more and more in India..
Ni brother they are simply wasting our tax money
@@Anjalisingh-bw5dg are you joking ?😂😂🤣
@@bot_nemetronicus seriously
It’s not problem of govt that people have 4-5 kids.
So according to your logic rich people also shouldn't have so many kids. If have nothing useful to say, at least stop hating on the poor!
@@socialistsolidarity idiot having kids is in the hands of people, government doesn't force them to have kids if they two kids they will live a better life it's for their own benefit only.
@@socialistsolidarity lol, are you stupid? Rich people have economic background to provide better lifestyle to their kids than these people who don't plan for their future. If you are poor it's ok but don't deliver kids for which you can't even provide a decent lifestyle.
@@socialistsolidarity I have seen rich people they have 1-2 children at most . he is saying useful thing , people need to learn how to plan family it saves resources both financially and physically
@@socialistsolidarity how is it hating on poor?
All i am saying is have 1-2 kids raise them well
Educate them well
They will have bright future instead of having 4-5 kids knowing you’re poor and you can’t provide them with quality life and will eventually end up even more poor due to financial strain of raising so many kids .
Is it that difficult to understand.
People also have some responsibility for their nation as well
its a two way street
not one way begging and blaming govt for your unresponsive behaviour.
Marvellous job. PM Modi you are doing wonderful job for the poor in India.
Hello sir ye project Congress ka hai Sheila dixit ne shuru kiya tha Manmohan Singh ji ne iska budget pass kiya tha jhoot bol rahe hain
@@sidstars5877 Congress ka projects sirf Paper hoti hai....Isliye ye desh Khaangress ko ab Itihaas ke paper pe bej rah hai..
@@dhi1083 ha ha oh really please upgrade your knowledge then talk
Will vote for modi in 24 surely.
@@sidstars5877 Acha aur main construction Kab hui
so glad to see this transformation. Hope it happens all over the country. 😇
I hope they'll be able to sustain the maintenance charges. Usually comes to 3-4 ₹ per sqft a month.
Normally Maintenance is 2 Per sqft... It's Very Less
Also
122Lakhs Home "awas Yojna"
And
Water, toilets
Modi Ji 🙏
No source of income, living on govt subsidies and freebies...but have 4 sons all married and 7 grandchildren and many more to come. Lagey raho
Just, there contribution is zero. They deserve concentration camps not apartments
One lady is saying, she has 4 sons and their wives and children, and all dnt hav space. Wth.. Ask your sons to work hard and build a house of their own. Gvrnmt is not here to built 4 houses for all your 4 sons🤦🏼♂️
Excellent work done
Mumbai's Dharavi needs similar thing. It's a shame that people are still living in such condition in India's financial capital. I heard of some progress being made recently. But it needs to be expedited.
It's always going to happen. Some people add more value to society than others. Even in NYC, SF, these problems exist and are increasing.
Great start. Hope they can maintain this as handing over projects is different than having a budget aside for maintenance and supplies. All the best
This is proud moment for all Indians
😂 nope. Maintenance for a building is very expensive. These guys can’t afford it. Taxpayers will take that burden. Which is theft for some votes. Their taxes should b used for them first.
I'm amazed and happy for them.
Dharavi should be next....
But that would that would drastically impact foreign tourism in India !!
As well as foreign media.
HHAAHAHA You are right
Wow nice work. This scheme needs to be implemented in every state. A percentage must always be spent on these projects to uplift the poor. There should be no slums in india in 2030. Everyone also should be provided free and compulsory education.
Dream project, thank you
God bless all those families.❤️
It is really important to have good quality affordable housing for everyone. Sometimes while paying high taxes one feels the pinch. But seeing real change is heartwarming. Hopefully government curbs corruption that will bring down cost of building. And also there needs justice for tenants and landlords because of lawlessness people are wary of giving out their homes for rent.
Great work indeed.
Excellent coverage as an impartial reporting.
Modi government should do more to advertise this accomplishment. Kejrival is so adept in tom tomming his government's accomplishments--learn from him and his AAP.
BJP IT Cell is shit.....
Yup that dirty little kejri will start advertising this as his brainchild.
Can't replicate it. Delhi spends close to 200cr on advertisements alone.
@@rutvikrs shi kha. Or kejriwal se congress k time par bane flats allocate nhi kiye ja rhe h abhi tak khandar ban gaye
@@rutvikrs How much more BJP spends on ads? The newspapers are full of their ads.
Wow! ❤️❤️❤️❤️ God bless all those involved! A very good a d proud initiative! 🔥🔥🔥
My mom always asked why such projects were not there. Since 20 years. And now it's a reality. Wow.
Even after getting such a big help, a house! People still find things to complain about....
Lots of people lives in those by their choice not by situation I have seen them they had ac and led tv inside jhuggis they earn in lakhs but only stay their just because they know government will give flat one day
Wonderful. Lets do same all over Bharat. GET EVERYONE INVOLVED FULLY
Have 1 kid space would be ok .
so happy for them .
Good initiative 👏
Good to see people moving to better life. The numbers however are miniscule. Hope every family gets good shelter.
Will this be considered Revdi going by PM's past utterances?
Very very happy to see their happiness
These flats look better than the previous DDA flats given to the people in Congress government
Congress never gave them to people they sold them to other people mostly
Suprised Kejriwal isn't there to steal credit lol 😂
Does their all childrens need free houses also they can't earn ,the flats itself are at least of cost 15 to 20 lakhs each
Please report in an year or so to check in on the living conditions.
Their eyes are beaming with hope and positivity for future- the most pristine human emotion.
I could never understand people who produce children knowing that they can't properly take care of them. What is the need to produce 4 children if you're not in a position to properly take care of even one. 🙄
its because they cant afford condom
Well many may agree to this initiative and some might disagree but it is an initiative atleast to make India cleaner. Yes we all understand that people in slums might not have the knowledge to maintain it but if go back 50 years, we all were in the same situation. We learnt and still learning. I know people might hate my comment but paying tax anywhere in the world is a benefit or else situation will be like 🇻🇪 Venezuela. Now we also have to understand that things cannot change in few years and will take sometime. Atleast this is a Ray of Hope. Yes govt charge approx 1.42 lacs but that is not just for the flat but other amenities as well e.g. electricity, registration and trust me this cannot be free or else it will backfire. Service class will have to pay taxes and that is inevitable. Let's not make this great initiative look worst. Appreciate the efforts. Only thing to keep in mind is a timely survey if every memeber is staying in that flat and not creating another slum to stay.
Bro you know that before 100 years india was the richest country and we had clean cities before 50 years ago and all people were educated in their fields before invasion and british. So stop thinking that we indians were some barbarians before the british thought us everything. British did nothing but steal our wealth and knowledge from india
It is great movement by Modi and it has given an opportunity for the poor to move up the ladder
This is not done by Mr Modi This project was approved by Congress government and project budget also give to Delhi government by ex prime minister sh Manmohan Singh ji, late smt Sheila dixit ji start this project and this project structure already stands at Sheila dixit ji government time project was hold late by 7-8 years by bjp government only to show unaware people's that they done this but this is wrong and I know everything about this project because I live opposite to this society
@@sidstars5877 lol nice try to spread fake news.
While I'm happy to see these poor families getting apartments but at the same what is the government is doing for housing those who paid for these apartments aka taxpayers. If the government can build homes for slum dwellers then surely it can provide some form of public housing for middle class as well. Obviously the priority for housing should be homeless and slum dwellers but there are a lot that governments can do to ensure housing for all
The prime objective of slum redevelopment is to improve urban sanitisation and streamlining other facilities like water and electricity connection.
It serves as beautification and also solves the waste management problem.
Buying an apartment in a metro will be a dream for many people because of real estate investors hogging up all land.
Lol 😂
Man if you belong to middle class and want government housing ,you should check u belong to middle class or lower income groups.
@@omprakashmahanta5547 i didn't say that I want public housing.
Government does work...but the problem is dealers in Delhi NCR. For sure, the owner itself sell these flats to others via dealers...!!
Man this should be done at rapid page to all our cities
No matter what, you can't make everyone happy
It will eventually get resold , I grew up in a similar JJ colony .
God bless us all ❤
Excellent 👍👍🙏🙏🙏
Would love to see the Dharavi slum transform into like this
Dharavi is already deacreasing in size
By 2050 in Mumbai there would be very less slum
Modi ji now took away the foriegn tourist's one and only attraction... slum...
Its a good move Modi ji... i feel kind of sad when people come to India deliberately want to go to Slums to film... even though here in USA LA has pathetic slums... all Druggies robbing people.
They have lived in home without rent, electricity,water bill,no taxes and at the same time middle class just have to bear all the costs.They can't beg for money but must pay n number of taxes so that government will build 🏠 for slum people n middle man lives all his life paying home loans.. 👏
Bro, have some sympathy. So much hate for poor people is not good for your mental health.
Most of these poor people work hard, just that they don't have good opportunities and education.
@@dreadfulbodyguard7288 my parents lived in slums...but they decided to give us good environment to grow up n worked hard. These people are living in slums for more than 10 years..how come they can't even afford a rent house? think about it.. you can't even get out of slum in 10 years??? and mind you all slums are mostly located in prime locations..road touch ..just to be clear I don't hate them..but i think living in slum is more about mindset and not just poor financial condition..I don't have problem with government providing them home but instead of giving it free government can come up with loan scheme...like in Korea or Japan.. after we all are paying taxes n these schemes come from our money..this appeasement of one community is what i'm angry about..we middle man are suffering the most in this society.
People complaining that this place is small!! So much ghamand!! Give them 1bhk they want 3bhk. Next they will ask for pool and club and a car. Wait for a couple of years, these folks will sell these apartments and move back to the slums.
Good Coverage.Keep it up
People were complaining that the flat were small and I was rolling my eyes. Then the architect said that total area of one home is 25m². Then I understood their plight. 25 m² is too small even for a family of 4-5. Although thankful, people aren't exaggerating that it is small.
Bhai, Jitna mila wo bahut hai. Delhi mein free mein flat mil raha hai worth 20-25 lakhs. Ab budhiya ke 4 jawan bete hain phir bhi jhuggi mein rah rahi hai to ye uske karma hain.
Bro just visit their current homes at slums and you'll start rolling your eyes again when they are complaining
@@darkknowledge8243 I did. many Indian cities have slums. Tell me how's the area of these houses any different than those slum houses.
I am doctor earning 1 lakh per month and still living in an rented apartment because it's very difficult to afford a home in Delhi...if someone is getting this much it's a lot ....and moreover that lady wants free home for 4 of his young sons is pathetic.
@@shaorong2020 she has 4 sons and all of them are married. Watch the video. And earning 1 lakh and still comparing yourself to people living in slums is the real pathetic behaviour.
I don't understand about the people complaining about small size of the house, when they were in slums did they live in 2000 sqft space or what?? Now they have a pucca house and they still complain.. fate of India
India needs Grand Ayushman scheme like social security many European countries have. Best medical services at minimum cost. Atleast for taxpayer middle class.
Read about UHI.
It's a good initiative par aisa na ho ko yeh log inhe aage rent par dede and again slums Mei shift ho jaye
Baaki God bless everyone.
Goverment should make a database for those who are getting these flat and in future if they sell or renting it by living in slums again government should stop them by checking it from database
Govt is planning to rebuild the slum area into corporate parks
@@autistictutor that's very nice jobs bhi milegi logo ko bhai 😊❤
I stay in such gated community and major problem will maintaining the lift, STP, common area cleaning, common area electricity charges.. these all expenses will add up to 1500-2000 monthly.
Great.
that jaali and other renovation should be done by the house owner only. thats how middle class people live. they solve the problem on their own. they dont call for the government to come and do everything for them
Exactly khud lagale matlab Government modular bhi banakr
Gently explain to them how to use the facilities
It's free
Now they will rent out it & will again move to slums
The problem will be in maintaining the project. I am sure there will be challenges in the garbage collection and other things!
Nice to see our income tax being used for rehab projects and we are paying everything from our own pocket. Giving 4 houses to one family is the most idiotic thing as nothing comes for free in the whole world. People work really very hard to buy homes, giving them for free is not logical at all. I have seen people getting these homes, putting it on rent and goining again in slum for free stuff. PR stunts cant help us in growing our country.
Keep up the good work our honorable pm
Thnks modi ji
इन लोगो की इक्षा को भगवान भी पूरा नही कर सकते ।
ये लोग झुग्गी में ही रहने लायक है ।
इतना अच्छा घर मिला फिर भी कमियां ढूंढ रहे है।
Many will give it on rent and go live in slums again.
Which slum! There slum is taken over by govt. Yes, these things happenin so it need strict govt. Check up time to time se o that no one can able to earn by rent or sell .. flat hai tooo muskil na do tooo vi muskil .. kaare tooo Keya kare
@@jaymabharti982 india Hai ye
Good information 👍
We love you Modi sir, yesterday I was against you, but now I know you are the true leader who will lead our country to next level. God bless you Sir
This should be done all over the country
Great
Good initiative take by government
I can't understand how people are this much greedy . Even govt arranged south Delhi villas then also people will complaint . Use it properly with the tx ppayers money u people gett.
Modi hai to mumkin hai 🇮🇳🙏
I highly doubt that these people will actually live there. Their main concern is income. They will simply rent the room to someone else and again will go to slums to make more money.
Ek toh free main diya hai en nakli gareebon ko upar se additional facilities chahiye...bahar nikaalo.. general public bus kya tax bharte rahegi
👏👏
👏👏👏
Middle class indians will pay
1. Income Tax
2. GST
3. Loan
4. School fee
5. Hospital charges
6. Insurance
7. Retirement plan
8. Investment for Children...
These people everything is free.... Because they are poor😂😂🙏🙏
dont declare income, govt willl not know about you. stay poor
they dont have any of those things still they are living and growing
baby machines will have space problem