Deer stalking - Patrick Barkham in Scottish Highlands

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 12. 2013
  • Patrick Barkham stalks deer in the Highlands
    Subscribe to the Guardian HERE: bitly.com/UvkFpD
    Deer numbers in Scotland have soared in the last couple of decades to around 750,000, creating a growing paradox traditional stalkers want to conserve the deer, while conservationists are calling for a substantial cull, arguing that their browsing activity is degrading the landscape. Patrick Barkham goes to the Highlands to investigate and stalk deer.
    Click for full Guardian article:
    www.theguardian.com/commentisf...

Komentáře • 32

  • @georgewashington4007
    @georgewashington4007 Před 4 lety +23

    LET THE PEOPLE MANAGE THEIR LAND THE WAY THEY WISH TOO, STOP FORCING ORGANIZATIONS AND GOVERNMENT INTO PEOPLES LIVES AND PROPERTY.

    • @hapnin6353
      @hapnin6353 Před 3 lety

      thank you Mr President, I agree

  • @fraserthomson1041
    @fraserthomson1041 Před 6 lety +29

    A terrible account of the highlands and Deer Management.
    Deer must be managed by man or there will be too many on the land and they will starve to death or spread disease amongst the heard.
    Conversation groups in my eyes are not one bit good for the countryside or wildlife management. Let gamekeepers manage the wildlife as they have successfully for many many years instead of a student who has lived in a city most of their life and decides they know about the countryside

    • @catchercat_yt3503
      @catchercat_yt3503 Před 4 lety

      Fraser Thomson HEAR HEAR! I thank you for your common sense

    • @oogaboogaman9631
      @oogaboogaman9631 Před 3 lety

      @@catchercat_yt3503 really bad take but wouldn't it not hurt to add reintroduce wolves

  • @erichaun4529
    @erichaun4529 Před 3 lety +9

    Estates managed for shooting are always diverse and rich in wildlife. Unmanaged ground or ground managed by those disconnected from the land and game are sterile landscapes. The same thing has happened in the eastern U.S. where the so-called conservationists have turned vast national forests into a land full of trees and barren of wildlife in just 25 years.

  • @tgeo2880
    @tgeo2880 Před 3 lety +6

    Oxymoron of the week: a barren wilderness of trees

  • @edbutler4784
    @edbutler4784 Před 4 lety +7

    Also in winter they starve to death that’s why me and my dad do it a week befor snow hits in Scotland

  • @daviddrysdale8866
    @daviddrysdale8866 Před 3 lety +7

    Bring back Wolves and Bears

  • @MrQualityMeats
    @MrQualityMeats Před 8 lety +6

    Hunting porn! I do agree the deer population is out of control and Scotland should look a tad more like scandinavia. Right now it looks more like a windy cold heathered sahara.

    • @jrw3349
      @jrw3349 Před 4 lety

      Most of the highlands are like cold deserts

  • @rcr76
    @rcr76 Před 6 lety +1

    Oh

  • @daveslow84
    @daveslow84 Před 5 lety +7

    introduce wolves...? :D

    • @Siritos
      @Siritos Před 2 lety

      As long as you're prepared to manage their numbers. Wolves are incredible predators that quickly de-populate entire herds of animals. They easily take down Elk in North America, an animal 2-3 times bigger than the largest Red Deer.

  • @Eduardorodrch
    @Eduardorodrch Před 5 lety +1

    isnt the same allan savory with elefants in africa ?? it didnt work

  • @safdarmohammad4357
    @safdarmohammad4357 Před 4 lety +1

    Nice video

  • @moneytttt1140
    @moneytttt1140 Před 4 lety +9

    Bring back the wolves

    • @Siritos
      @Siritos Před 2 lety

      As long as you're prepared to manage their numbers. Wolves are incredible predators that quickly de-populate entire herds of animals. They easily take down Elk in North America, an animal 2-3 times bigger than the largest Red Deer.

  • @nakedeagle3828
    @nakedeagle3828 Před 3 lety +1

    m'lord's estate

  • @Isochest
    @Isochest Před 3 lety +3

    Wolves and lynx needed

    • @Siritos
      @Siritos Před 2 lety

      As long as you're prepared to manage their numbers. Wolves are incredible predators that quickly de-populate entire herds of animals. They easily take down Elk in North America, an animal 2-3 times bigger than the largest Red Deer.

  • @pagamenews
    @pagamenews Před 10 lety

    That man did not kill one deer - he killed three. It was a doe, a female, and late in the season. So that means it would have been carrying a pair of fawns in its womb that would have been born in the spring. Mamma deer plus two babies equals three deer.

    • @RoestalkerCoUk
      @RoestalkerCoUk Před 10 lety +12

      It looks like a yearling hind so unlikely to be pregnant but even if she was twins are quite uncommon in red deer...

    • @leeroyjones76
      @leeroyjones76 Před 9 lety +7

      Most does or hinds that are shot are pregnant. Given that culling is neccessary for both the deers welfare and that of the other animals that share its habitat the seasons are set out so that dependant young are not left alone if the mother is culled. Which is worse? Shooting a pregnant one or leaving a youngster to starve to death?