Disney's Pinocchio vs Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 30. 05. 2024
  • If you wish upon a star, will you wish for a Pinocchio remake? Well, you don’t have to because 2022 was the year that Pinocchio came to life in a bunch of new ways. Disney released an almost scene-for-scene remake of the magical story in live-action. Mexican filmmaker, Guillermo Del Toro decided he wanted the tale to take a more mature and darker turn using the timeless art of stop-motion animation. With two remakes happening in one year, we couldn’t help ourselves from putting them up side by side and finding all the ways they are different - and the same!
    Just when we thought an old story couldn’t get any newer, Del Toro swooped in and gave us a whole new Pinocchio to dissect. From Jiminy Cricket’s recognizable name and attire to Pinocchio’s nose and quest to become a real boy, you won’t believe the ways that this story was changed. Not only are we seeing how filmmakers can take the reins and switch things up big time, but we’re even getting new backstories and theories that are seriously making us question the original.
    If you want to know more, check out this video that is sure to give you everything you need to know. We can assure you that most of what we found will surprise even the biggest Disney fan out there. Don’t forget to like this video if you enjoyed it and let us know what change you liked or didn’t in the comments. Subscribe to The Things Animated to get the inside scoop on all things animated.
    Subscribe: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Things
    Chapters:
    0:00 Intro
    0:26 Pinocchio’s Design
    1:00 Pinocchio’s Nose
    1:44 The Blue Fairy
    2:13 Honest John
    2:53 Gepetto’s Backstory
    3:27 Jiminy Cricket
    4:08 Adaptation of Story and Themes
    4:55 The Setting
    5:20 When You Wish Upon A Star
    5:58 Pleasure Island
    6:34 Animation Style and Tone
    7:07 Impressive Cast
    7:40 Outro
    Our Social Media:
    Facebook: / thethingscom
    Instagram: / thethingsofficial_
    For more videos and articles visit:
    www.thethings.com
    Written by: Kate Belliveau
    Narrated by: @blakelylindsey
    Edited by: Joe Morfin
    For copyright matters please contact us at: legal@valnetinc.com
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 1,2K

  • @TheThingsAnimated
    @TheThingsAnimated  Před rokem +110

    Anybody think Disney's version is better?

  • @canal_zero
    @canal_zero Před rokem +2476

    Saying Disney is original and DelToro is a copy makes no sense. Both are versions of a book and DelToro’s much more accurate.

    • @gerardoresendiz6731
      @gerardoresendiz6731 Před rokem +211

      that’s the short term memory of Americans ask any n they will tell that Pinocho is American 😂😂😂

    • @canal_zero
      @canal_zero Před rokem +33

      @@gerardoresendiz6731 so true! 😂🤣

    • @YourLocalInquisator
      @YourLocalInquisator Před rokem +60

      Yeah one had been in work for like 10 years so…
      *America moment*

    • @dveight08
      @dveight08 Před rokem +49

      Came here to say this, glad to see other people are smart enough to realize this!

    • @blandwagon374
      @blandwagon374 Před rokem +7

      That’s exactly what I was gonna say

  • @aviizynx
    @aviizynx Před rokem +1066

    The thumbnail shows both disrespect towards Del Toro, and a complete lie. Disney was in fact NOT the original for Pinocchio. Both Del Toro’s and Disney’s movie are inspired by a book. There is little similarities in style, and in story if comparing the two movies. One is completely hideous, and more CGI than it is even live action. It has a more wholesome touch to it than Del Toro’s. And over all just being the same as the first Pinocchio they’ve made in the past, just far worse when it comes to the style and effort. Del Toro’s far more accurate when it comes to the story of Pinocchio when looking at the book. It takes darker turns than Disney’s. Del Toro by far made the best Pinocchio out of the three this year.

    • @kyleighcampbell4311
      @kyleighcampbell4311 Před rokem +24

      Very much agree. I absolutely loved Del Toro’s Pinocchio.
      I’ve never read the original story (the book) but based on the versions I have seen and what I know about the different takes on the story, I’d argue that it’s the best version of Pinocchio.

    • @helmenhjelmen1955
      @helmenhjelmen1955 Před rokem +6

      Well they also take place in different time periodes. Having it take place in fascist italy is very interesting and del toros unique touch. Both disney and del toros are much nicer then the original pinocchio but del toros is closer.
      Del toro made a movie with his heart. Disney made it with their wallet. And while the 1940s disney pinocchio is still beautiful by todays standard was it also a clusterduck story wise.
      Somehow the new version of that movie are among the worst looking and most disrespectful movies of all time.

    • @allaninaet2835
      @allaninaet2835 Před rokem +2

      Pinocchio was my first Del Toro movie and it didn't disappoint, so I agree that this video is much disrespectful. Knowing the book's version was not good at all made his version of the character my favorite version even above Disney's version. Del Toro has been trying to get his version off the ground since 2008 or so, so this video calling his version a "copy of Disney" holds no water. I'm a Disney adult but Disney is not the original .

    • @doofusboy7054
      @doofusboy7054 Před rokem +2

      I know, this video is just a bit poorly made

    • @a_wizard1103
      @a_wizard1103 Před rokem

      TLDR, take the like anyways

  • @tailsfanidk869
    @tailsfanidk869 Před rokem +681

    There’s no ‘copy’ because Pinocchio is on the public domain 😂😂😂

  • @Cosmic_Lemon
    @Cosmic_Lemon Před rokem +935

    Del Toro’s is the best version of Pinocchio

    • @DArX0241
      @DArX0241 Před rokem +21

      Agreed

    • @Thecreaturedrawingkindaguy
      @Thecreaturedrawingkindaguy Před rokem +7

      Del toro's is creepy

    • @MarioRmz1996
      @MarioRmz1996 Před rokem +71

      @@Thecreaturedrawingkindaguy Del Toro's Pinocchio is closer to the Book than the one from Disney, Disney doesn't own Fairy Tales they are just lucrative and earn profit with tales that have centuries existing.

    • @SpringFredGaming
      @SpringFredGaming Před rokem +4

      FR

    • @Anon_Amos.
      @Anon_Amos. Před rokem +2

      Hey!
      Someone tell Ms. Lemon to stop stating the obvious!

  • @ivanelugo
    @ivanelugo Před rokem +540

    I'm not sure if you're joking or are you really unaware that Disney's Pinocchio is not the original, but that the original is a book and that there have been many live action and animations of Pinocchio long before Disney's, obviously Del Toro's is not going to look like Pinocchio's Disney because he is based from the book

    • @Aeries1480
      @Aeries1480 Před rokem

      💁‍♂️

    • @battybuddy
      @battybuddy Před rokem +14

      I'd say that Del Toro's CHARACTER of Pinocchio fits the book BETTER- but lets face it- book Pinocchio was a LOT more cruel and troublemaking- I mean, he threw a damn HAMMER at the cricket... Del Toro's Pinocchio is more like genuinely good intentions but doesn't really understand the ramifications of his actions... Biggest connection to book Pinocchio would be the fact that he works purely on "If I want to do it, I'll do it, if I don't want to- I'm not going to"

    • @MinakoOfficial
      @MinakoOfficial Před rokem

      This mf trying to get a paycheck she doesn't actually believe what she's saying.

  • @chaoticfisherman373
    @chaoticfisherman373 Před rokem +421

    Del Toro definitely has the best take on Pinocchio more than Disney could ever had

    • @ProkofNY
      @ProkofNY Před rokem +11

      I think both the original Disney and Del Toro’s movie are good (although this is subjective, and the movies have their own takes and target audience, but perhaps they are somewhat on par). The substandard film here is Disney’s new version. They really need to stop with those low effort remakes.

    • @mza.2
      @mza.2 Před rokem +1

      And your profile pic really shows how cultured you are. Glad that you spammed Agi on Pino not the Minotaur

    • @chaoticfisherman373
      @chaoticfisherman373 Před rokem

      @@ProkofNY yeah true true

    • @Nick_thekid
      @Nick_thekid Před rokem +1

      @@ProkofNY you just summarized everything for me you are a walking w

    • @TheMysticGod1587
      @TheMysticGod1587 Před rokem +2

      I recently watched both versions (the 1940's version to be precise) and I actually ended up enjoying Del Toro's version more

  • @jonahkeele7851
    @jonahkeele7851 Před rokem +438

    Del Toro's is the best by far in my opinion

    • @bncumali1555
      @bncumali1555 Před rokem +43

      It is not an opnion; it is a fact

    • @jedicake3177
      @jedicake3177 Před rokem +6

      @@bncumali1555 TRUE

    • @superaverageisnotme
      @superaverageisnotme Před rokem +3

      @@bncumali1555absolute facts

    • @imdliamdragonlucha6827
      @imdliamdragonlucha6827 Před rokem

      *MY GOD MY FAVOURITE TERRARIA BOSS THE EYE OF CTHULHU*

    • @justamoogle5268
      @justamoogle5268 Před rokem

      - Carlo Collodi
      - Del Toro = Disney Animated
      - anything not Disney Live Action version
      Plus points on how creative Del Toro depicted the Blue Fairy/s

  • @nobody-wk6ej
    @nobody-wk6ej Před rokem +276

    ... Thumbnail seems kinda disrespectful...Considering how trash Disney's latest effort is.

    • @oddcause98
      @oddcause98 Před rokem +32

      True
      guillermo del toro's version is amazing to be honest

    • @hungrywarnergaming5263
      @hungrywarnergaming5263 Před rokem +12

      Ikr?!! One took 15 years...

    • @BlizzardTycoon
      @BlizzardTycoon Před rokem +12

      1 was made with love and care for 15 years, the other was made to get peoples attention and money

    • @secretinc4181
      @secretinc4181 Před rokem

      @Blizzardjin which one are you talking about?

    • @BlizzardTycoon
      @BlizzardTycoon Před rokem +2

      @@secretinc4181 if its the 2nd option its disney. all live action movies

  • @izi5150
    @izi5150 Před rokem +235

    That’s not the original. There have been many Pinocchio’s before there was a Disney Pinocchio.

  • @saiyanmynamee5109
    @saiyanmynamee5109 Před rokem +112

    Not watching the video simply because of the ridiculous thumbnail suggesting that DelToros wonderful and imaginative is a "copy" of Disneys soulless cash grab when the Pinocchio story is 130 years old with countless adaptations

    • @ivanelugo
      @ivanelugo Před rokem +16

      I saw the video and it was a comparison from both movies, but you clearly see that the one that made the video didn't ever know that Pinocchio was a book on the first place and there was so many Pinocchio movies before Disney's, even one of the comparisons was that Del Toro version doesn't had the songs like "when you wish upon a star" or "Strings on me" when those songs are from Disney, it's obvious that Del Toro don't to include those songs on the movie without being sued by Disney

    • @omarlopezrincon
      @omarlopezrincon Před rokem +3

      @@ivanelugo Del Toro's song Ciao Papa is already nominated for the Academy, not to mention that the Movie itself is nominated too.

  • @indiethesilly
    @indiethesilly Před rokem +208

    There are a LOT of problems with the thumbnail. First of all, the first photo is completely wrong; Disney’s remake of Pinocchio is not the original. While I haven’t seen either Disney versions, I’ve heard almost nothing positive about the remake and it does not deserve to be associated with the word “original” or mixed up with the REAL original 1940 film. Second, Del Toro’s film is in NO WAY a copy. There are hardly any similarities other than the general story, and even that is vastly different from either of Disney’s films. Del Toro’s film is not even lightly inspired by Disney’s, it’s a completely different film and shouldn’t be thought of as the same movie at all, let alone a copy. The remake is not the original, and Del Toro’s film is not a copy. The thumbnail of this video is blatantly false and should be changed.

    • @ivanelugo
      @ivanelugo Před rokem +17

      The problem is that Disney's was never the "original" the original one was the book, there was so many Pinocchio movies before Disney's, Disney sweetened the story so that it is for all audiences, because the book was dark, even on Del Toro filled a pothole of the book, that Pinocchio die like 2 times but came back to life without explanation

    • @indiethesilly
      @indiethesilly Před rokem +9

      @@ivanelugo that’s true! the book came out several years before disneys film, and in that time there were a few pinocchio movies before what we call the “original” came out. Thanks for pointing that out!

    • @Duff404
      @Duff404 Před rokem +2

      @@indiethesilly The first pinnochio movie was a live action 1911 film with no sound and amazing technology for the time
      (If my sources are correct)

    • @indiethesilly
      @indiethesilly Před rokem

      @@Duff404 I’ve definitely heard of it! There were certainly different pinocchio movies before Disney’s, thanks for pointing it out

    • @Duff404
      @Duff404 Před rokem +2

      @@indiethesilly czcams.com/video/c6IPiyHe1XA/video.html Yup. That's what I was talking about

  • @EviLMoNkEy1203
    @EviLMoNkEy1203 Před rokem +75

    The stop motion version of Pinocchio is the one I appreciate and admire the work and effort they put into it than just CGI

    • @jamespapandrea6726
      @jamespapandrea6726 Před rokem +4

      and even the CGI is trash lmfao

    • @simpostor_
      @simpostor_ Před rokem +4

      CGI also requires a lot of work even when It never seems as passionate as practical effects and I usually admire it too but...
      CGI in Disney's remake is just simply garbage.

    • @MauAmzArr
      @MauAmzArr Před rokem

      CGI is a craft as difficult as any other and it deserves respect. It is a tool that when properly used, it can achieve beauty in a very particular way. Although there will always be something about handwork that makes things a lot more earnest to people, just like a handmade clay mug will make coffee taste and feel overall better and cozier than a serially produced ceramic mug with a generic printed image on it.

  • @jackdaniels3240
    @jackdaniels3240 Před rokem +144

    Pinocchio is not even from Disney lmaooo

  • @Mark73
    @Mark73 Před rokem +68

    Of course the song couldn't be used in Del Toro's version. It's flat-out owned by Disney.

    • @ivanelugo
      @ivanelugo Před rokem +8

      Yeah, Is obvious that none of the Disney song going to be on a Pinocchio that doesn't not from Disney

    • @obitosenju3768
      @obitosenju3768 Před rokem +10

      You are using logic and reason. Something this chanell never uses

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem

      @@obitosenju3768 ong

    • @MrKyogreOfTheSeas
      @MrKyogreOfTheSeas Před rokem

      Ofc

  • @giuliamarchesi7041
    @giuliamarchesi7041 Před rokem +61

    The Disney one isn't the original, both Del Toro's and Disney's are adaptations from the novel by Carlo Collodi. Honestly they're both different from the original book, but the Gullielmo Del Toro's one is more interesting than the Disney's one

  • @roanokeay
    @roanokeay Před rokem +16

    This movie took 15 goddamn years to create. Show some fucking respect.
    I loved this movie. It was so dark. It was very thought provoking and taught a great lesson. The amount of effort put into it was absurd. The animation is amazing.
    Disney was not the original Pinocchio. It was a book. You are aware of that, right?

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem +3

      ong, some people really got some nerve spitting on Guillermo’s lifework like that

    • @phoneofmom_usedbychild
      @phoneofmom_usedbychild Před rokem +1

      SHEEEESH THEY DONE TRASHED DEL TORO’S

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem

      @@phoneofmom_usedbychild FR **loads shotgun** AND THERE’S NO WAY TO TAKE THAT BACK

  • @adalyncoronado1153
    @adalyncoronado1153 Před rokem +54

    Finally, Jiminy finally looks like a cricket😌

  • @jadeesquijo92
    @jadeesquijo92 Před rokem +78

    *GASPS* HOW DARE YOU CALL DELTORRO'S PINOCCHIO A COPY

  • @JordanFN15
    @JordanFN15 Před rokem +29

    Deltoro’s Pinocchio is not a copy, it’s just an interpretation of the original source material of the book, pinocchio

  • @clintwyatt8517
    @clintwyatt8517 Před rokem +32

    Fun fact: It took 15 years for Del toros pinnocchio to be made

  • @Micsquzzy69
    @Micsquzzy69 Před rokem +19

    Del Toro took 15 years to make the film and put passion into it with his team. The same cannot be said for Disney “original” remake.

  • @ryttza
    @ryttza Před rokem +48

    Como niña preferiría a Disney pero como adulta prefiero a del Toro, son dos visiones diferentes de una misma historia. He amado este nuevo Pinocho , sobre todo porque ahora soy madre y conozco las dos perspectivas: la de madre y la de hija

  • @veronicapiccinini7956
    @veronicapiccinini7956 Před rokem +107

    Guillermo del Toro’s Pinocchio is better than Disney reboot. The later was a soulless “copy and paste” of a movie we already know.
    At least Del Toro went creative and even fixed some problematic morals of the original story, without losing its spirit

    • @Filename46_fnaf_edits
      @Filename46_fnaf_edits Před rokem +3

      Even pan's labyrinth and hellboy are both the same with world war 2 cuz they're are cool

    • @NoName-hg6cc
      @NoName-hg6cc Před rokem +1

      Problematic morals?

    • @Filename46_fnaf_edits
      @Filename46_fnaf_edits Před rokem

      @@NoName-hg6cc hello no name

    • @veronicapiccinini7956
      @veronicapiccinini7956 Před rokem

      @@NoName-hg6cc for instance, in the book, it makes look The Fairy with Turquoise Hair like a saint, despite the fact that she isn’t above of using moral blackmailing or psychological abuse (like faking her death because Pinocchio was too naive to believe the Fox and the Cat; or giving him fake food that could kill a child in real life just because he was tricked into skipping the school by his jealous peers). I understand he needs discipline but this is overkill in my opinion.
      Then, there’s the fact that it implies that you need to conform with a never ending satisfied society with insane expectations, to reject everything that makes you unique as a person, to turn into something/someone you’re not, just to be loved. You know what, screw it!
      But I understand that it’s not only Carlo Collodi’s fault. I mean at the time, Italy only recently became its own country or having an identity of its own. Meaning that there were many uncertainties inside Italy.
      But we are talking about things that used to be normal 2 centuries ago. They have little to no value today (or they have but are still controversial)

    • @NoName-hg6cc
      @NoName-hg6cc Před rokem

      @@Filename46_fnaf_edits Ehm...Hi?

  • @JR1ckDoodles
    @JR1ckDoodles Před rokem +39

    Pinocchio is public domain

  • @TheSUPERWIND2023
    @TheSUPERWIND2023 Před rokem +17

    The thumbnail is disrespectful! Pinocchio is an original story not made by Disney or Guillermo Del Toro, Guillermo added some twists into the story that I really loved! Pinocchio looks and moves around much like how a puppet would in the Guillermo movie than the Disney remake or the Disney original. Guillermo Pinocchio is no copy, it's an amazing movie.

    • @helmenhjelmen1955
      @helmenhjelmen1955 Před rokem +3

      The new disney movie on the other hand its an ugly attempt of a copy and an awfull cash grab being highly disrespectful to the animators of the 1940 movie.

  • @Rusty_0
    @Rusty_0 Před rokem +69

    i think we all know which Pinocchio movie is better right?

    • @lemonyde9940
      @lemonyde9940 Před rokem +71

      Del toro's

    • @Rusty_0
      @Rusty_0 Před rokem +46

      @@lemonyde9940 heck yes

    • @maxtull21
      @maxtull21 Před rokem +22

      I think we all know that both the Disney 1940 film and the Guillermo Del Toro version are the better versions while the Disney 2022 live-action remake is horseshit.

    • @misifusito1
      @misifusito1 Před rokem +14

      @@maxtull21 true but imo Del toro’s was better than Disneys

    • @TarbosaurusBaatar
      @TarbosaurusBaatar Před rokem +4

      @@maxtull21 The Pinnochio LA had the worst story and CGI out of any of the LAs. It was going to be literal shit but they made the LA even more shit by rushing the movie so they could outcompete Del Toro’s version.

  • @Soupreme2
    @Soupreme2 Před rokem +44

    Saying Disney is the original is the most obvious way to tell everyone you're American

    • @deaconplayz5789
      @deaconplayz5789 Před rokem +3

      Nah I hate Disney and I’m American

    • @ExploreTheWorldWithBri
      @ExploreTheWorldWithBri Před rokem +2

      I know the Disney one isn't the original and I'm American 🤷‍♀️

    • @ivanelugo
      @ivanelugo Před rokem +3

      Im American and i know that the original is the book and there was so many Pinocchio movies before Disney's

    • @TayoEXE
      @TayoEXE Před rokem +2

      I am American and this is accurate. It's like asking the average American if they've seen "the original War of the Worlds" and they refer to one of the Hollywood movies set in the U.S. whose setting and plots are far removed from the novel while over in Europe the most popular adaptation is Jeff Wayne's version (my personal favorite).

    • @thatgamerdude9389
      @thatgamerdude9389 Před rokem

      😂😂😂

  • @ischeele7203
    @ischeele7203 Před rokem +70

    I'm so sorry you're a Disney Adult, you're brave to look at things Disney hasn't processed. Hope you're on the mend 💕

  • @cyxlesdevs8847
    @cyxlesdevs8847 Před rokem +20

    the blue fairy looks like an accurate look of angel

  • @bbqreal
    @bbqreal Před rokem +18

    Ah yes, something with actual creativity behind it instead of a soulless cash grab remake, dEfiniTelY a CoPy!

  • @laflaca6666
    @laflaca6666 Před rokem +27

    Del Toro's Pinocchio has been on work for 15 years before the live action remake of Disney.

  • @lucideandre
    @lucideandre Před rokem +13

    “Not much of Del Toro’s looks like the Disney version”
    Yeah, because it’s a completely different version. It’s also a more thoughtful, thought-provoking, and impactful story. Intensely political while also exploring interesting themes of family, death, and identity.

    • @MrKyogreOfTheSeas
      @MrKyogreOfTheSeas Před rokem +1

      “Not much of Del Toro’s version looks like the Disney version”
      NO SHIT, THEIDIOTSANIMATED, ITS NOT DISNEY!

  • @useyourglutes
    @useyourglutes Před rokem +15

    Disney doesn’t own Pinocchio. Disney has their own version of Pinocchio.

  • @Mark73
    @Mark73 Před rokem +34

    In the original story, didn't his nose go back to normal by birds coming and pecking it down?

  • @saiken811
    @saiken811 Před rokem +14

    Oh God, never watched the live action remake but the blue fairy's wings are freaking haunting… they are like alien tentacles…
    And I don't think it's right to call Disney's version original…

  • @kolpkii
    @kolpkii Před rokem +9

    Del Toro’s Pinocchio really shows that not everything is all sunshines and rainbows.

  • @tfox3777
    @tfox3777 Před rokem +11

    Don't these people know that before the movies there was a book?

  • @YourLocalInquisator
    @YourLocalInquisator Před rokem +11

    The lion, the witch, and for calling del toros a copy the audacity of this bi-
    Coming out this summer

  • @theliz13
    @theliz13 Před rokem +12

    Disney's Pinocchio and Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio are both based off the SAME BOOK

    • @helmenhjelmen1955
      @helmenhjelmen1955 Před rokem +2

      Disneys new pinocchio is arguably based on the old disney version that was based on the book.
      But the old disney movie wasnt that great either other then thematically and visually. Which is stunning in some scenes. Especially under water.
      Del toros is a master piece in every shape and form. Its art beyond out imagination and it a long with the how it is made film should be what we send into space to show our humanity.

  • @bluefoxgalaxy6057
    @bluefoxgalaxy6057 Před rokem +45

    Del Toro made his remake way better. It’s much more realistic and accurate compared to Disney’s.

    • @RafaelHR17Arts
      @RafaelHR17Arts Před rokem +2

      Del Toro version is not a remake

    • @bluefoxgalaxy6057
      @bluefoxgalaxy6057 Před rokem +8

      @@RafaelHR17Arts oh sorry I didn’t mean remake i meant something else. I’m not very good with words

    • @hungrywarnergaming5263
      @hungrywarnergaming5263 Před rokem +4

      It's Del Toro's reimagining of the Pinocchio

    • @bluefoxgalaxy6057
      @bluefoxgalaxy6057 Před rokem

      @@hungrywarnergaming5263 yeah that’s more of what I meant

    • @ErikDaVinci
      @ErikDaVinci Před rokem +3

      You certainly mean Del Toros own adaptation of the book.

  • @gemoy8925
    @gemoy8925 Před rokem +19

    I like the storyline Del Toro's

  • @John_Stafford07
    @John_Stafford07 Před rokem +3

    Del Toro has actually had this idea for 14 years. I’m willing to bet that Disney hasn’t had the idea for a live action Pinocchio for that long.

  • @MythosFilmsYT
    @MythosFilmsYT Před rokem +15

    Did you actually just call Del Toro's version 'a copy' in the thumbnail? Wth. It's no more of a 'copy' than Disney's version is.

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem +1

      It’s literally a masterful reimagining/interpretation of the ORIGINAL book, Disney is not the original. The thumbnail is incredibly disrespectful towards Guillermo’s work and I hope it gets changed to something else.

  • @zedisenpai6265
    @zedisenpai6265 Před rokem +18

    deltoro's pinocchio is a masterpiece. Voice actors are great and perfectly fit for the characters

  • @reukem
    @reukem Před rokem +7

    I still prefer the Netflix version since it made me cried when i see Pinocchio became a real boy to save his father, a true movie you must watch

    • @Theboredgod
      @Theboredgod Před rokem

      nawbro live adaption bad

    • @reukem
      @reukem Před rokem

      @@Theboredgod live action be bad, lol true,

  • @lorenzopiscosi9566
    @lorenzopiscosi9566 Před rokem +7

    “Disney Pinocchio: original”
    *laughing in Carlo Collodi’s Pinocchio*

    • @ellarose7114
      @ellarose7114 Před rokem +4

      *laughing in Carlo Collodi’s Pinocchio with you*

  • @belmatalet
    @belmatalet Před rokem +8

    Originali vs Copy? Seriously? Pinocchio Is a story of Carlo Collodi.

  • @maxtull21
    @maxtull21 Před rokem +39

    Both the Disney animated 1940 film and the Guillermo Del Toro film are both masterpieces! The Disney live-action remake is horseshit!

  • @sapphirethealpha5005
    @sapphirethealpha5005 Před rokem +5

    there is no copying
    Pinocchio himself was NEVER owned ny Disney
    It's a FAIRYTALE

  • @toastertime5640
    @toastertime5640 Před rokem +7

    When the copy is better than the “original”

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem +1

      When the “copy” isn’t even a copy, and is a masterful interpretation of the original book that took 15 years to make:

    • @raflyfaturrahman9441
      @raflyfaturrahman9441 Před rokem +2

      Better 👍👍

  • @HexterXD
    @HexterXD Před rokem +5

    Just by looking at the comments, I can already tell that this video is derailed and burning. If you seriously still think Disney has any actual respect to its stories now, especially over someone who whittled for years to make an artistic masterpiece, there is no way I could back you up. Del Toro’s story made me feel legit joy and sadness, while the new Disney one just made me feel dead inside.

  • @jonatanaguilar9961
    @jonatanaguilar9961 Před rokem +4

    This is Disney trying to convince you his version is better.. it's not.

  • @ASlickNamedPimpback
    @ASlickNamedPimpback Před rokem +7

    This video is stanning for the wrong movie 😂

  • @yall_idk
    @yall_idk Před rokem +8

    its not suppose to look like the Disney version since it is based off of the fable. Del toro's is more accurate to that fable, plus actual human emotions are in this one not just sunshine and rainbows throughout the whole film. coming back to the fable Pinocchio was a brat who got in trouble a lot, but he got better and more likable in the end or smth idk haven't read the fable in years. So no, it is not a copy.
    Edit: also del toro's Pinocchio was in the process before the remake was in process, still not a copy.

  • @mrd6984
    @mrd6984 Před rokem +9

    Del Toros Pinocchio is more realistic it talks about life and death but in the Disney version who the hell calls their dad father?💀

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem

      idk people from late 1800’s and people who act “professional” lol

  • @JohnDoe-fm1pb
    @JohnDoe-fm1pb Před rokem +13

    clicked this video just to dislike it immediately for the thumbnail lol

  • @lemonyde9940
    @lemonyde9940 Před rokem +17

    Pinocchio isn't owned by Disney...

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem

      Exactly, it’s public domain, so there’s no such thing as a “cOpY” for Pinocchio

    • @NoName-hg6cc
      @NoName-hg6cc Před rokem

      ​@@noturboi909Well, Disney is a copy since the original is from an Italian book

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem

      @@NoName-hg6cc Like i said, none of em are since pinocchio is public domain

    • @NoName-hg6cc
      @NoName-hg6cc Před rokem

      @@noturboi909 As I said, Pinocchio is originally an Italian book. The rest are copies

    • @noturboi909
      @noturboi909 Před rokem

      @@NoName-hg6cc it isn’t tho since it’s public domain, a copy would imply copyright infringement, however, this isn’t the case

  • @annacoribioanna
    @annacoribioanna Před rokem +7

    And Disney's is the COPY of the ORIGINAL NOVEL by Colloti.
    Disney did NOT create Pinocchio! In the original novel BTW Pinocchio even kills the cricket, that's how dark it is.

    • @ivanelugo
      @ivanelugo Před rokem +2

      And Pinocchio died twice on the book, Del Toro take that plot hole to put that he would never really die because he not supposed to be alive on the first time

    • @ellarose7114
      @ellarose7114 Před rokem

      i mean to be fair he does it on accident

  • @proproductions15
    @proproductions15 Před rokem +4

    BOTH DISNEY VERSIONS WE KNOW AND LOVE, MORE LIKE 1 DISNEY VERSION WE KNOW AND LOVE

  • @GoDzillAFanKM14
    @GoDzillAFanKM14 Před rokem +12

    Well, it’s true many people grew up watching the version of Pinocchio from the Disney animated movie. But surprisingly Pinocchio existed long before any of those movies ever existed. Pinocchio was a book that was a lot darker than the Disney film. We’ve come to know and love… or at least one of them. Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio stays true to the dark themes of the old book. And in my eyes, it is the best adaptation of Pinocchio by far. Sorry Disney, you can’t win them all. But like Guillermo Del Toro said “ either you make the story the way it needs to be tall or it’s just as good as not making it” and the latest Disney film of Pinocchio was an epic disaster. It did not need to exist!

  • @elryano2384
    @elryano2384 Před rokem +10

    Well obviously when you wish upon a star wouldn’t show up in Del Toro’s version, it’s Disney specific

  • @sealy1
    @sealy1 Před rokem +6

    Sad thumbnail. That’s just sad.

  • @elsakristina2689
    @elsakristina2689 Před rokem +18

    1940 Disney’s Pinocchio walked so 2022 Del Toro’s Pinocchio could run. It’s that good.

    • @SaruuPro
      @SaruuPro Před rokem +2

      actually the 1940 disney's pinocchio wasn't the original, the two movies were based of a book. And the original book was way darker in the story, so del toro's pinocchio is actually way more accurate compared to both disney's pinocchio movies.

    • @elsakristina2689
      @elsakristina2689 Před rokem

      @@SaruuPro I know, I just mean I think they’re the best Pinocchio adaptations.

    • @melodyscorpion6606
      @melodyscorpion6606 Před 11 měsíci

      ​@@elsakristina2689 they're the only adaptations that matter in my opinion

  • @greenblue76
    @greenblue76 Před rokem +3

    As someone commented already, the Disney is not the original.
    The original is a book written in Italy in the 19th century.
    What ignorance!

  • @paulocerioni6375
    @paulocerioni6375 Před 7 měsíci +2

    Disney's Blue Fairy in the Pinocchio remake is far more likely to give me NIGHTMARES than Del Toro's, to be honest!

  • @timothypeterson4781
    @timothypeterson4781 Před rokem +2

    The amount of people that don't realize this is just a content farm and they don't give two ****s about the accuracy is amazing.

  • @KPGS
    @KPGS Před rokem +8

    The ending of the 2022 one made my cry like shit

  • @ikea3652
    @ikea3652 Před rokem +4

    u can’t claim about every copy of Pinocchio,they are many types of those movies,so far Del toro’s is the best,it tells and describes it like many movies do.

  • @leomorgan2118
    @leomorgan2118 Před rokem +2

    Whoever copied Disney is Disney himself with his new version, and honestly it was not a good copy, Pinocchio del Toro, like Disney's Pinocchio, are 2 more than dozens of adaptations of the original book by Carlo Collodi, each adaptation is a different one way to tell us the story, each one chooses the version that they enjoy the most and love as their favorite, if you love the Disney version you will have your reasons of the heart as well as others have their reasons for loving this adaptation or others

  • @Lostforstories
    @Lostforstories Před rokem +6

    I would really love to see the dislike ratio lmao

    • @OverLorD768
      @OverLorD768 Před rokem

      3,4 thousand likes to 15 thousands dislikes.

  • @lauracortez3904
    @lauracortez3904 Před rokem +3

    The Disney movie is not the "original" story. The version of Guillermo del Toro is not a copy it is a great adaptation of the actual italian story.

  • @jorger5777
    @jorger5777 Před rokem +6

    What about the sea monster in both versions?

  • @tygriscalcutta729
    @tygriscalcutta729 Před rokem +2

    Disney: he does the same thing that I do
    Del Toro: but better

  • @Fever_Man
    @Fever_Man Před rokem +1

    The fact that you didn’t recognize Christof Waltz as an actor is insulting

  • @Ash.James.Aulner
    @Ash.James.Aulner Před rokem +3

    With Gepetto's backstory, The Disney one makes a backstory for him, only showing a picture of his son, unlike Del Toro's (superior) showed a full backstory so we could feel his sadness and guilt.
    Edit: Also with When You Wish Upon A Star...that's Disney's song. Not Del Toro's.

  • @rubenquiros4859
    @rubenquiros4859 Před rokem +3

    I know the thumbnail is clickbait so I won’t give you the pleasure of watching the video.

    • @ivanelugo
      @ivanelugo Před rokem +4

      Actually, on the video never mentioned the book, it looks like they really thinks that the original is Disney's, they also said that the Del Toro doesn't had the songs from Disney's

  • @elmono6299
    @elmono6299 Před rokem +2

    Pinocchio is a public-domain story that's been adapted over time and allowing different directors to make their interpretations. Both Disney and Guillermo Del Toro have their distinct retelling of the classic Italian fairy tale. There's no such thing as either one being original or the copy. The only copycats that exist are the mockbusters made to copy Disney's interpretation which Del Toro is not.

  • @moonie888
    @moonie888 Před rokem +3

    The stop motion is more violent. He almost dies and the of course the eyes. The monkey is good towards the end , which is Pinocchio's best friend. At the end it shows three graves and Pinocchio knows better now

    • @SaruuPro
      @SaruuPro Před rokem +2

      yeah it is more violent because the original pinocchio was this way, both disney's version of pinocchio aren't that accurate to the original story, wich was really darker.

  • @olivianwokolo3254
    @olivianwokolo3254 Před rokem +4

    It's been two days but the ratio of likes to views is hilarious

  • @LazyOldFusspot_3428
    @LazyOldFusspot_3428 Před rokem +4

    Don't forget Monstro and the Dogfish

  • @signal_noise8041
    @signal_noise8041 Před rokem +2

    Why would you even call del toro’s Pinocchio a copy? The story is reused loads of times, It’s even meant to be more based on the book.

  • @JuanThaSilva
    @JuanThaSilva Před rokem +2

    No attacking. But from a filmmakers perspective. Even Stephen King himself considers Toro's film astoundingly impressive.

  • @kimishere7240
    @kimishere7240 Před rokem +3

    clickbait thumbnail 🙄

  • @HarrisonMcKee
    @HarrisonMcKee Před rokem +3

    Maybe u should do you research on what the story of Pinocchio is first before fueling the fires
    Del Toro's version is his own adaptation of the source material, whilst Disney's latest is a modern remake of they're older, more child-friendly version. If anything, the Disney 22 film is the copy, not Del Toro's.
    Both adaptations exist outside of the true original story, that u also didn't consider.
    Don't make points for click bait whilst not factoring in things behind the curtain kids

  • @maromalul9134
    @maromalul9134 Před rokem +2

    We're in a day and age when a "Copy" is so much better then the Original

  • @BurntToast78830
    @BurntToast78830 Před rokem +2

    You do realize Disney's version isn't the original? Not only that but there can be multiple versions of movies with huge differences, Del Toro's Pinocchio was in development for 10 years so I'm not sure why they would spend that much time on copying Disney's 💀 please do research

  • @battlefard3736
    @battlefard3736 Před rokem +3

    Tell me you're Disney fan without telling me you're a Disney fan 🤡

  • @Quole1234
    @Quole1234 Před rokem +3

    I love it when the like/dislike ratio tells you how awful a video is immediately and completely accurately.

    • @noboaff9578
      @noboaff9578 Před rokem

      You can see dislikes? How, can you enlighten me?

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 Před rokem

      @Noboaff there's a chrome add on

  • @obitosenju3768
    @obitosenju3768 Před rokem +2

    Welcome to:" How the hell this video happen!" show. How do you think 10 year old movie in work is a copy of a thing that started the making 3 years ago at max

  • @nucleardino8992
    @nucleardino8992 Před rokem +2

    Technically Pinocchio didn't belong to Disney, as well as Cinderella, princess and the frog, etc. So it isn't right that Del Toro "copied" the "original" film

  • @miguelangelc.a.5268
    @miguelangelc.a.5268 Před rokem +5

    Best of all : Carlo Collodi original tale is the Best. Disney's 1940 Pinocchio is an enchanting movie BUT ...Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio is a MASTERPIECE from this moment on.
    Sorry Disney, years of shitty material ( when Disney betrayed Disney Soul with this woke movement and New animated movies with no sense ) makes me take my own choice.

    • @ellarose7114
      @ellarose7114 Před rokem

      thank you !! i agree that the novel is the best, i think ive read it at least 10 times.

  • @DEDUBBING
    @DEDUBBING Před rokem +3

    You said that was copy yah right that why they won Oscar 😼❤️‍🔥

  • @savp4945
    @savp4945 Před rokem +1

    You mean, "Disney's version and Del toro's version." Deltoro's version is literally a masterpiece. The whole production is amazing.

  • @brockparson4939
    @brockparson4939 Před rokem +2

    To be honest really don't appreciate the Disney version but on the other hand the Netflix version to me is super good ...... AND THE GUILLERMO DEL TORO'S is not a copy I agree with most of the people in the comment section. :(

  • @locomotivetrainstation6053

    Yeah the original was totally released in September 2022....

  • @jurassicjohncretaceousback6386

    Del toros Pinocchio is better than disneys

  • @vianeyboruel504
    @vianeyboruel504 Před měsícem

    If you dont cry like a baby with del Toro 's version you're dead inside

  • @claz8632
    @claz8632 Před rokem +1

    I love how everyone hates the thumbnail

  • @BonnieDoggy123
    @BonnieDoggy123 Před rokem +3

    It’s not a copy and the Disney one isn’t the original