Sapient Thoughts #21: Is what the Quran says about the function of mountains inaccurate? | M. Hijab
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 02. 2021
- Sapient Thoughts #21: Is what the Quran says about the function of mountains inaccurate? | Mohammed Hijab
1. van der Meijde M, Ashrafuzzaman M, Kerle N, Khan S, van der Werff H. The Influence of Surface Topography on the Weak Ground Shaking in Kathmandu Valley during the 2015 Gorkha Earthquake, Nepal. Sensors. 2020; 20(3):678. doi.org/10.3390/s20030678
Though Hamza is not on screen these days. But he's the founder of the Sapience institute, and we do appreciate your efforts from behind the screen, brother Hamza may Allah bless you. I do try read your articles on the website though, from time to time.
Hamza who
Hamza Tzortzis
@President-Caliph Dhuku It’s funny because the Quran itself also states that mountains, despite appearing firm and strong, are actually moving like waves. The Quran describes plate techtonics by giving the imagery that the natural slyscrapers we see in the world are moving.
Moreover there is nothing wrong with the way the Quran describes mountains as pegs. Maybe you didn’t watch the video enough
“How can you use such a weak and speculative statement to try and disprove the Qur’an?”
*Anti-Islam websites have left the chat*
@Joker I'm sorry that you're blind & deaf.
@Fernandez Gustavo and they have valid reasons...
@Joker The main problem with your mindset is the fact that Truth can only be found via an empirical, tangible, and testable basis.
This is very dangerous because it literally would break your perception of reality and leave you in a state of confusion and contradiction, one of which being:
How can you empirically test the claim that Truth can only be found via an empirical, tangible, and testable basis, via an empirical, tangible, and testable basis? It's already self defeating unfortunately.
@Fernandez Gustavo Don't waste time on the likes of @Joker. He neither understand Islam nor the info he is regurgitating from the likes of Christopher Hitchens who said "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence." Hitchens never bothered to define what qualifies for extraordinary; he merely made the remark to sound clever. For us, Muslims, the existence of God is not extraordinary but a self-evident truth that is inborn in every human child.
@Joker You can test the Qur'an my friend:
1) QUR'AN makes the claim, "if you are in doubt that this was revealed from other than Allah, then you would find many controdictions within it" - There's not one single controdiction within it.
2) Quran describes the process of embryology and it's steps which involves the development of the fetus within the womb. An embryologist (can't remember his name) converted to Islam after discovering this, he realised there was no way a Bedouin Arab over 1400 years ago could have known this.
3) Quran states that moon light is reflected light. Whereas it states the sun has its own source of light. (Bible gets this wrong)
4) Allah SWT mentions in the Qur'an "it is we who have sent down the Qur'an, and it is we who will protect it (from corruption)" You may know that the Qur'an has been preserved letter for letter since it was revealed. This is a prophecy.
5) Quran talks about how the planets are on their axis.
6) QUR'AN mentions the big bang "do not the unbelievers see, that the heavens and the earth were joined together, then we clove them asunder".
7) QURAN claims everything is made from water. This was recently discovered.
THERES COUNTLESS MORE I COULD MENTION. HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN THESE? HOW COULD A MAN OVER 1400 YEARS HAVE KNOWN THIS. PLEASE ANSWER.
Our old Hijab is back again!!
He is not yet 30
Allah put mountains on earth so earth does not shake. Allah is very wise Alhamdulillah thank you golden shower boy
Hijab speaks: * *me grabs dictionary* *
1:23 can you explain what does his mean Jazak Allah khair
@@abduladil7332 That phrase means that you can't anthropomorphize Allah literally, like in Greek mythology for example, where Zeus literally controls the weather and throws lightning bolts.
@@abduladil7332 Asalaam Aleykum warahma tullahi wabarakatuhu. It just means to give human characteristics to God. For example to say that God is a man is to make God anthropomorphic. We as Muslims do not believe God is like us humans in shape, form, with limited characteristics etc.
[He is] Creator of the heavens and the earth. He has made for you from yourselves, mates, and among the cattle, mates; He multiplies you thereby. THERE IS NOTHING LIKE UNTO HIM, and He is the Hearing, the Seeing.
(Ash-Shuraa 42:11)
@A A Al-Qamus al-Muhit by Fairuzabadi (He mentions it is a classical dictionary)
classic hijab !
The hair😢, it was so curly. But alhamdulilah, he looks sharp with his short haircut
Keep up the great work Sapience institute 👍
I was looking an answer for this bro Jazak Allah Khair
This is a brilliant series 👌
For morons.
Blessed be upon us all (including the other sides) to your presence amongst us all. TQ sir.
Keep up many thoughts.
Happy debating, happy revealing
Happy making many back to the right path
This topic alone is what holds me stronger in faith of islam. We see that ring of fire, the chain of volcanic mountains, are situated at the edges of tectonic plates, which means, it must have an effect on the tectonic movements since the deep "root" of mountains should create a form of friction because outer mantle is like liquid, or viscoelastic fluid for someone who are more familiar with engineering terms.
Prophet Muhammad (pbuh.) lived far away from these mountains. The fact that he spoke these words, as he was just a mere merchant, not a geoscientist, is mind boggling. These are clearly not his words. Considering how honest he was, these must be the words from the owner of the Earth, the maker, the creator.
SubhanAllah. Indeed
Alhamdulillah... your body language improve. Now I feel kore comfortable. Thanks a lot for information, ilman and all... May Allah increase you and your team in many ways of good things and granted jannatul ma'wa...
Mountains don’t stabilize the earth or are pegs your book is wrong
بارك الله فيكم
Amazing content ma sha Allah
The curls gone 🥺 but the Haqq still there! Alhamdulillah keep it up Ya Akhi .
اللهم بارك عليك آمين 🤲🏾🤲🏾
Looking clean Sheikh🍃
FANTASTIC. AWESOME. Thank you.
How were the himalayas formed?
😄When Will Ustadh Hamza appear in video? Haven't seen him.
Since the verses (and relating verses) refer to the creation/formation of earth to make it hospitable for life, I'm pretty sure the Quran is talking about continental collision as it is a fundamental part of how the earth was formed, thus the "creation" of mountain range, the mountain range acts as the suturing that sutures the continentals together, thus hindering them from "moving". This is from a geological scientific perspective. If we look at the vast mountains ranges that exist across the globe, such as the Himalayan mountain range or the Alps, they all are created from continental collision, acts as suturing and hold the continentals in place. And for everyone not believing, just Google Continental collision and suturing of mountains.
@Joker Your smileys totally convinced me of your intellectual argument.
What about verse 78: 6-7 which says mountains as pegs/or to stabilize earth when mountains ARE THE RESULT OF instability or movement of earth's crust?
@@rationalskeptic2193 Quran 78:6-7 - "Have We not made the earth a resting place? And the mountains as stakes?"
@@saifklee178 Yeah, but the problem is mountains aren't stakes/pegs
@@rationalskeptic2193 Why are they not? Give your reasoning from a geological understanding. I dont care what they are the result of, I care about what they ARE.
ALLAH HU AKHBAR✨
Masha Allah
السلام وعليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Good video brother. Excellent refutation. All they have are speculations anyway.
Great bro ✌️
Please add subtitles for deaf🙂
Love you bro
Good work
This is simply an opinion ( could be wrong). As Qur'an describes it, the mountains and hills indeed are one of the major reasons for the stability of the tectonic plates. Afterall the frequency of earthquakes has been increasing with the large-scale increase of mining and quarrying activities ( recall the end-time hadith which talks about how 'mountains will be moved from their places'). We keep hearing about sinkholes, earthquakes, landslides. And the fact that they are being dug and moved from one place to another, to create parks, artificial mountains and what not, also means the stability of plates is being toyed with. It isn't very difficult then to believe in the verse describing the event of "Ardu zil zalaha" i.e. 'the great trembling of the earth' that is to come
اَللّٰهُ أَعْلَم❤️🕋🕎
So Bro Hijab went those all those hairstyles only to shave his head in the end????
2017 hijab look 😭
Hijab starts speaking English
My mind to me: 2:07
😂😂🤣
Can you please enable English captions on your vidros, I am deaf than you
The translation I read it was "mountains are placed as pegs " pls explains this.
That’s in surah al naba. The word awtada meas pegs or stakes. It’s the thing that stabilizes a tent for example. So god says mountains function as stabilizers of earth. And it has been proven that this is indeed true. The head of science in the USA wrote a book called EARTH. Which is recommended by almost all geology universities states that indeed the mountains are stabalizers for the earth. Quran is 100 percent correct in everything. Some anti islam geologists make up theories to reject the truth that’s mentioned 1400 years ago. Nowadays most geologists if not all agree that it stabilizes the earth. What they discovered mentioned 1400 years ago
Allahu Akbarrr
The bold head Hijaaaaab
4.21 your misrepresenting this paper its only referring to this one valley that its geography redirects quakes. It does not mean you can put this effect unto all mountains. Infact the process that makes mountains is the same one that makes quakes the shifting of tectonic plates against each other. The thing is it's foolish to try to force a modern scentifc standard until the quran
@@OmarAhmed-iv4uv Dude it the main energy realse was anywhere the results would be devesasting this was a fluke not routine event. Most earthquakes happen near mountains because the same geolgoic process that make them also cause earthquakes
@@jacobpilavin9981 Look up the san gabriel mountains. Also, look up effect of sea mounts on tectonic plates and earthquakes. The latest research discusses the lubrication of plates as a cause of seamounts. Other researches also prove that seamounts leave behind wet material which does in fact muffle earthquakes. This was tested using a model as well!. The topic of this video was by no means a fluke either, due to the fact that it has also happened with other mountains, San Gabriel mountains is an example. You should definitely read into seamounts though, very interesting topic and it is the best interpretation of the Quranic verses imo. I would post the links for you, but I believe comments with links get instantly removed unfortunately. Peace
nice hair cut 😊
وإذا الأرض مدت و (ألقت) ما فيها وتخلت
ألقت يمكن ان تعني من تحت إلى فوق
بارك الله فيك
Wow
I love brother Hijab for the sake of Allah.
So why do some flat lands have far less earthquakes and why do many mountainous areas have more earthquakes?
Umm because Allah put the mountains in the place with the earthquakes and didn’t put mountains in the place with no earthquake. If you take the mountains away there would be even more stronger earthquakes
@@eesakhan7837 you can’t take away mountains they are created by tectonic plates
@@walterhartwellwhite8022 he is saying if mountains never formed, then stress would have to be released differently, and this would of caused more frequent and intense earthquakes
Can you make a video on whether the dhob lizard is halal or not
Oddly specific
What dr weijde of twente university said in full in that article is that mountains can move the earthquakes to a different place creating an even more powerful and destructive earthquake.. so mountains don't stop an earthquake contrary it can act as a pathway and even create a more destructive earthquake
His point was it doesn't happen in the area of mountain rather it goes to a different place, listen to the video again.
The paper models the interesting impact of topography on the propagation of seismic waves in a specific valley, either amplifying or reducing the impact on the population in the valley dependent on the direction and / or origin of the waves. This paper doesn't say what I think he wants it to say.
@@inegom1735 precisely
@@inegom1735 thank you Mohamed hijab is clearly lost and selecting information to fit what the Quran says mountains are stabilizers to the earth or pegs because they are created by tectonic plates the very thing they should be doing is stabilizing the earth not being created by it as the Quran claims
@@user-sc6uu5iq2b mountain ranges still get earthquakes and are shocked by earthquakes
New haircut 💇♂️ 👍👍👍👍
I chuckled a little when you pronounced the name of the Dutch guy. You were right indeed when you mentioned that the pronounciation was probably wrong.
In dutch, its pronounced as: mark van den maide. With the e of maide also pronounced
From Twentie
It would be great if these videos can be dubbed into Urdu, Turkish and arabic languages..so it can reach to masses..
New hairstyle 💇♂️😎
Was it necessary to make to make a comment about 'zeus'?
Haircut?!?!?!
﴿وَأَلقى فِي الأَرضِ رَواسِيَ أَن تَميدَ بِكُم وَأَنهارًا وَسُبُلًا لَعَلَّكُم تَهتَدونَ﴾
[An-Nahl: 15]
The same word ألقي is used for rivers and pathways. So clearly it doesnt necessary mean throwing something.
@Joker you mentioned examples that it means cast down, the guy clearly said it doesn't necessarily mean "cast down"
@Joker But there are verses where it doesn't mean downwards, hence..... not always 😉
Good hairs mashallah
Like it's we're dealing with children in adult bodies. Unable to rationalize the simplest of things
@Joker not even children believe something comes out of nothing by nothing
@Joker The fact that you actually think we believe that is indicative of two things:
1) you’re an uneducated ignoramus.
2) you’re 12
@Joker your name suits u well!
@Joker it was certainly not meant in a positive way
@Joker we believe in an uncaused first cause that causes everything else because if not it will create an infinite regress fallacy. If everything is dependent on everything else than realistically and logically, this moment in time would have never arrived as there would be an infinite gap from the start to this point in time. As such it is mandatory to have a necessary existent that kickstarts reality and that being not being caused by something else because if not then you'd still have an infinite regress fallacy
Nothing causing something is in itself a logical fallacy. But let's just say it is true for the time being then why are we not witnessing things popping up out of nowhere? If something coming out from nothing is such a basic fundamental law of reality then it should be a daily occurence for things to spring into existence out of nothing
I found more clues about this verse, by default Earth is not static at all or dynamic, so in this case the word "ardh" means the soil, Imagine there is no Mountains which mean the soil is soft so it will create more dynamic in the earth crust, the only solid elements in the soil is basalt that always beneath the mountains created by chemical heat mixture and rock that became colder.
In my point of view the word pegs is like basalt.
interesting
@@OriginalAndroidPhone MashaAllah Amazing😎
I already miss the hair
Some people spend their whole lives trying to disprove the Quran. What will they say to Allah SWT...
Seas don’t mix Quran but seas do mix the Quran is wrong and your scholars are playing mental gymnastics gymnastics to prove it’s right
M .hijab allah protect him
WHERE IS YOUR HAIR ??
Don't remind him! Thank Allah!!
Jazzak Allah Khair brother Hijab. Shukr Alhamdulillah you cut your hair. 🙈 it was looking very scruffy. BarakAllah Feekum Sapience Institute 🥳🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
They don’t peer review anything when you scratch the surface there is no depth to their arguments May Allah Swt protect us from the mischief makers Ameen Yaa Rabbi 🤲🏻💐
@President-Caliph Dhuku ‘modern geology’ came about after the plates. So who put the plates there in the first place? Everything created has a creator my friend.
Watch this link- with an open mind☺️
czcams.com/video/RhsdUu-mLNk/video.html
It’s wrong buddy get over with it mountains are not fixed or firm they move and grow as time goes on plus they don’t stabilize the earth nor does the Quran says it has roots
This channel NEEDS a better video editor/producer.
He finally cut his hair
Why did you cut your hair?😢😭
*I liked ya cut G* 😏
Head top garrrnnn
Good old hairstyle
Ur hair man
These should be taught in university , too much quality content for CZcams
Brother I think a classical interpretation of the verse is that mountains are used to know the location, and if the land was flat in the dessert without mountains you'd get lost. See this video czcams.com/video/vaDFYzF-TRg/video.html
I think this classical interpretation makes the most sense.
Mouhaamoud Hijoubii
He shaved his Head😁
i think i have a crush on him
I hope your a female
@@Hamza00011 lol that killed me
@@Hamza00011 yes i am :v
Nadir Ahmed said Allah threw mountains down onto the Earth in his debate with Apostate Prophet.
That’s why nonMuslims will keep bringing it up too.
Also, when tectonic plates smash into each other, there’s three things that happen, one of them is formation of mountains. So in that way, they don’t keep sliding against each other as much.
I wish he stops debating people. He's only doing a disservice.
@@NeoLegendX absolutely. A debater needs to have actual knowledge on the subject, not layman stuff.
@@notionSlave
That's why people call him and he comes singing.
What fors he have to prove anyway...
He aint a good debater ex muslims are using him to make them look good😐😐
You look better with curly hair 🤣🤣🤣
*The Quran believes that earthquakes don't exist:*
“And We have placed on the earth firm mountains, lest the Earth should shake with them”
[al-Anbiya’ 21:31]
But earthquakes happen all the time and mountains do shake and they don't stop the earth from shaking.
Maybe a little bit in the Kathmandu valley according to the Dutch study bc of its unique topography, but not in general.
I dont know the person who dont know even alphabet of arabin is teaching the word is used here tameeda bihim which has many meaning and its mean disbalance roll down one side etc this ayah actually prove quran is from divine bczz today we came to know mountain play a big role in earth centre of mass to make it stable
@@hifzushaikhshaikh7511 but during an earthquake *the Earth shakes from side to side* so the Quran really says earthquakes don't exist bc mountains prevent Earth from shaking side to side..
@@hiqhduke indont know what i should tell about ur IQ LEVEL. Earthquake is a phenomena which is known from ancient time. So why quran say it doesn't exist when i tell u that its mean to disbalance and roll down one side then why same thing
@@hiqhduke i dont know why r u so silly there were earthquake in arabia if for sake of argument u r right then there should be no earthquake as u told before but now u r telling different dont be hypocrite. As i already told it has many meaning which mean imbalance or roll down one side
@@hifzushaikhshaikh7511 if this verse doesn't deny earthquakes *the Quran is still wrong* bc it actually says: mountains prevent continents from moving around the ocean. That's WRONG and big scientific error.
When are they going to realize science is not going to get them any where😅 they try so hard to figure out how Allah created creations while disregarding what Allah said about how he created the creations. They also change or add on to science everytime it's debunked or proven wrong may Allah guide them they are in confusion and are lost😭🌷
You cut your hair! 😅
test
Hijab is 👍 🙏
Let's be honest majority of these anti Islamists barely now any basic Arabic or any Arabic at all. This is why we Muslims need to be stronger in mastering the Arabic language because its the biggest shield against anti Islamists.
But if you Muslims don't know any Arabic or even the basics then I suggest to keep your tongues shut in case you say the wrong things and make things worse for our deen. That's just my opinion
Ciao Hijab! Hard the life of an apologist Muslim eh? You need to justify many things....🙂
Hijab doesn't really have to do all these things. He is doing it because its good in islam.
@Joker we have evidence outside of quran to say Allah swt exist
@Joker pardon
@Joker what trees ???
@Joker Get out of this confusion and have your own life.
But you can't! How can you? Living without knowing where you came from and where you are going? of course not!
When you got confused and become jealous of Muslims life, you wander around Islamic Channels 24/7 in the hope of confusing them. But don't get tired, because no one will follow your blind journey.
No,everything in Qur'an is wrong.