Eurovision 2024 - My Top 37 With Comments & Ratings (before the show)
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 05. 2024
- Hi everyone! Finally, I finished my overall top 37 of Eurovision 2024 before the show with long comments, as I like. But this time, I tried to do something different, namely, take some of my comments and read them with my voice. So, I could see the difference in how the text comments on screen look and how voice comments sound, what's easier to take. To combine pleasant with useful, I put my voice comments only on the videos that had any copyrights. So, it didn't turn out to be that well but come on, at least I tried.
Participants of Eurovision 2024:
France - Slimane - Mon amour
Czechia - Aiko - Pedestal
Albania - Besa - Titan
Slovenia - Raiven - Veronika
Ireland - Bambie Thug - Doomsday Blue
Luxembourg - Tali - Fighter
Norway - Gåte - Ulveham / Gate Ulveham
Spain - Nebulossa - Zorra
Malta - Sarah Bonnici - Loop
Ukraine - alyona alyona & Jerry Heil - Teresa & Maria
Finland - Windows95Man - No Rules!
Latvia - Dons - Hollow
Italy - Angelina Mango - La noia
Germany - Isaak - Always on the Run
Moldova - Natalia Barbu - In the Middle
Estonia - 5miinust and Puuluup - (Nendest) narkootikumidest ei tea me (küll) midagi
Denmark - Saba - Sand
Lithuania - Silvester Belt - Luktelk
Poland - Luna - The Tower
Belgium - Mustii - Before the Party's Over
San Marino - Megara - 11:11
Croatia - Baby Lasagna - Rim Tim Tagi Dim
Switzerland - Nemo - The Code
Netherlands - Joost Klein - Europapa
Cyprus - Silia Kapsis - Liar
Austria - Kaleen - We Will Rave
United Kingdom - Olly Alexander - Dizzy
Iceland - Hera Bjork - Scared of Heights
Serbia - Teya Dora - Ramonda
Australia - Electric Fields - One Milkali (One Blood)
Greece - Marina Satti - Zari
Sweden - Marcus & Martinus - Unforgettable
Portugal - Iolanda - Grito
Israel - Eden Golan - Hurricane
Georgia - Nutsa Buzaladze - Firefighter
Armenia - Ladaniva - Jako
Azerbaijan - Fahree feat. Ilkin Dovlatov - Özünlə apar
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
0:20 "Not into them"
1:40 "In the middle / just below average"
2:40 A Very Long Comment
4:30 "In the middle / just below average" again
6:10 "Above average"
9:00 "Really like it"
15:53 Top 10 - Hudba
Forgot to add the ratings for 4th - 1st places, they're all 9.5/10, I'm not giving any 10s before the Eurovision performances
Yeah, it's a experimental top. I mixed my usual text comments and tried the voice ones at the same time (on videos that have any copyrights, to do business and pleasure at the same time). I even accidentally did both with Poland, the text comment wasn't supposed to be here. Sorry, when I record my voice I become kinda... not nervous but more of intense, so my English becomes more Slavic than I expect and the flow and emotions are lacking. Well, at least I tried, maybe it will be better next time. At least, automatic CZcams subtitles were able to understand me, so I don't have to continue making them.
Its one note song. I only hear Kakakakakakka kakakakakakka kakakakkaka kakakakakq kakakakkq kalakak
@@giannis7123 which one?
@@escserg6731 croatia
There's a new acoustic version of Luna's "The Tower" available on CZcams and it sounds far better than the original version. Here's the link: czcams.com/video/kwynNHP2MSA/video.html
Что ты имеешь в виду под "intense"
Thank you so much, as a Spanish hearing someone from abroad talking so good about Zorra and understanding, embracing and being proud of the message of the song is very touching for me, thank you very much ❤🇪🇦
Yeah, that's what turns this song from just a generic 80s track to something so special
Thank you for praising Megara, they are so criminally underrated! And same with Nebulossa, love from Spain
We are so proud of you Marko and we know that you will represent us worthy in Sweden. Your example is the biggest motivation for all young people not to give up on their dreams and that they can come true. Baby Lasagna go and win.!You deserve it! God bless you !Greetings to all Esc fans from Croatia.😺
greetins to you! hello from croatia :)) the situation is serious thought about migration of new people and immigration of our young people
Finally someone who appreciates Veronika and Ulveham!
Uhm girl I don’t anybody has but ulveham out of their top 10
Even veronika they are no way underrated
Big agree on San Marino, I love them so much but I’m scared cause every year there is that one song/artist that I love, that’s really underrated and ends up not qualifying..
guess I’ll have to send all my votes for them ahah
Yeah. It's especially easy to be underrated when you're San Marino...
San Marino song is in Italian language for the half in this video@@escserg6731
Meow cat please meow back ❤
Finally someone who‘s properly praising Ireland‘s entry 🇮🇪 I‘m so proud of Bambie they‘re gonna slay so hard for us 🤩
Baby Lasagna story is really Eurovision winner story
Well, I'm not sure we have ever had a story with a Eurovision winner like this before.
Nice, but there ara a lot copies from the Finnish song cha cha cha 🤨
@@tiel9908 Influenced by it? Maybe. Copies it? No
@@tiel9908cha cha cha is in Finnish but Rim Tim tagi dim is in English
There's a party in my head, Woah ohh
czcams.com/video/5nl7sKwPQo4/video.html
Finally some one think Spain deserve to be the winner ❤
Perhaps the ranking (with a couple of exceptions) on CZcams that is closest to mine. Interesting comments too! Well done! 😊😊
Thanks from Spain!!!🩷🦊🦊
as an spanish THANK YOU SMM
most of spain's entries for eurovision always end up being so underrated in my pov, and even if they arent as ood as other entries they are still not so loved. Thanks
Thank You! From Portugal
France, , 🎉🎉🎉 Wonderful Voice, Beautiful song,🎉🎉🎉 Beautiful message to Europe and the World, we have to Love❤ Germany and Belgium 🎉🎉🎉
My Top: Norway, Australia, Luxembourg, Azerbaijan, Sweden, Italy, Switzeland, Bellgium, FRANCE.
Thank you from Azerbaijan
Greece🇬🇷 is my number one!!!❤
Thank you for taking the time and giving us your honest commentary the video is very nice
Yeah, it was an interesting experiment, what will look better, the usual text comments or the not confident voice comments in my Slavic English.
Why are people so hateful when they see a opinion different than theirs... its beyond me. Anyways, great video, thank you for sharing your opinion and much love from Portugal ❤🇵🇹
Bambie thug is going to slay the show. They said in an interview they are keeping there cards close to their chest about staging. We hope we can get the good of people of to open their minds to it. We would love to get into the final at least, it would be like a win for us.❤ For Europe xx
hopefully😎
i love irish entry ❤ pozdrav iz hrvatske
yaaaaay! thanks for appreciating san marino, malta and ireland!
I love that you have Finland in your top 10❤
I like your explanations and how you express your own opinion and taste. 👍🙏
Portugal ❤❤❤goo Iolanda thanks from Portugal ❤
Portugal needs to pass to the final ❤
With the running order, I guess it will qualify easily. We'll see
Portugal ❤
I'm agree with your rainking and especially with comments about some entries example : Ireland, Belgium, Australia, Malta, San Marino, Finland, Portugal or Serbia.
Thank you from Spain! New follower
Thanks for 🇵🇹♥️
Iolanda ❤️🇵🇹
To be fair, “I’m still wet from this October Rain” was an unfortunate line anyway. Kind of up there with Anna Bergendahl’s “And if my knees are weak, I’m still a Desert Flower” from “Kingdom Come”. Some things you just shouldn’t put in the same sentence…
Just popping in to say I hugely enjoyed your top! Very well argumented comments and pleasantly edited
Thank you!
Entirely agree with Ukraine down to the score ngl, it’s a NQ for me as well. Voyager were right with saying it needs more “umph”
I prefer Jerry’s Vidbir 2023 entry a mile over this
Croatia for victoty❤❤ Idemo Hrvatska na pobjedu❤ Greetings from Slovenia
Love Ramonda serbica❤ Love singl Dzanum❤🎉 Love TeyDora❤🎉😊
Zorra zorra zorra 🦊😍 we have some differences, but quite agree with some of your opinions too, great top!
Thank you for Portugal❤
Galera, Portugal não vai ter chance, não. Tinha de escolher o Leo, assim não vai dar.
@@LusoRagtimer o leo ficava em último na semi final, com a iolanda temos chances de passar ao menos
Your top 10 it’s all over the place my brother, I’m not complaining it’s your taste but they were some surprises there I wouldn’t expect in a top 10.
This is one of the strongest years since I join the Eurovision fandom in 2014 I’m so excited
I mean, top 10 being all over the place is kinda my thing. I usually put there the most interesting and different to each other entries there (and mostly the faster ones as it's more to my preferences).
C'mon Portugal is not a probable non qualifier! And yes, I'm tuga 🇵🇹
Yeah, right now, with the running order they will probably qualify. Just before people weren't sure
Well if you are tuga ! you shouldn't make that comment
find something better to do
but I'm guessing you got not enough skills
lol
@@joaomauricio5696I think you need to read what he wrote again
my deepest apologies
didn't have my morning coffee when I wrote that comment 😅
Nemo for the win
Iolanda ❤❤❤ Portugal 🇵🇹
Wow Spain first thats an interesting viewpoint. I mean its quite catchy and dope but it never came close to my top 10 😅 but Switzerland is pretty cool too, I think it could be juries winner if will performed as good in live
Spain being first is just a pure emotion, a complete irrational feeling... Just because I want, it's my top. Just feeling of the whole package here, especially the message.
Bambie 💙 Ireland 🇮🇪💙💙💙💙💙
Thabks for Spain, Megara, Ireland Armenia and Latvia, everybody put this song down and is a masterpiece
ZORRA is in the place that it deserves, thank you ❤🦊🎉
❤
Your English is better than mine when spoken. It sounds good, don't worry about that
Yeah, it's not that bad. Thanks) Still, I put too much effort into right pronunciation of words, so there're a lot of pauses in my speech and the lack of emotion. Practice and only practice.
I adore emotional and powerful songs and Belgium/france both hit the spot
I don't think the outro of Europapa passes the 3 minute limit! On Spotify the 'main song' is 2:40, with the part of the outro used in the video it's exactly 3:00. He has to keep it, that's what makes the entire song a masterpiece
I hope so too!
I hope so too!! Also the longer outro version really made me cry😭
thanks for sharing@
What do you mean?
@@escserg6731 oh i meant thank you for thsaring the music
Switzerland and Spain are the ones I listen to on loop at the moment, along with San Marino, so I totally agree on those ones! I like Greece more and more every day I prefer that one to Italy's even tho I'm italian, but I'm already fed up with La noia, tho it's not a bad song... also think Ukraine is overrated and Ireland a bit underrated
My number 1 and 2 are Ukraine and Belgium. Enough said.
😂
We're all big ZORRAS 🦊🇪🇸
Hate and dislikes are always gonna be there with a eurovision video with opinions. Personally I thought this was a amazing video with alot of diffrent and interesting thing to say and comment about. While I ofc do not agree with alot of the placement I do love to see this kind of detailed commentary which I can very much agree on alot of the times!
Thanks. I don't really see that much of hate here though
@@escserg6731 Oh no sorry didn’t really mean hate but more alot of people that usually cannot take it when someone has different opinions an either give video dislikes or go into the comments :)
Iolanda ❤🇵🇹
Hiya! One Nordic opinion here My favs 10/10 are 3:
Croatia, Belgium and Switzerland ❤. Thank you for the analysis ❤
Im not from Ireland but i absolutely love Ireland's entry they are my number one this year!!! I really really hope they qualify!! 🙌🇮🇪
I have Ukraine ranked lowly as well, and for the same reasons. The more I listen to it and learn about it, the less I like it. And while Jerry and Alyona are talented individually, I don’t think they have much chemistry. I’m sure it will qualify but if this even comes close to winning I’ll be disappointed.
SPAAAAIN!!! :D
I love Israëli song! Your commentary is very artificiel!
Nice ranking but I wanted to ask one question if I can, how do you know that this year’s song from Cyprus was supposed to be Russian 2022 entry? I would be very thankful for the information
I don't know that for sure but that's a rumor that seems to be the true one since 2022 was supposed to be the year with Kirkorov doing all the stuff for Russia and this song (Liar) is written by Kontopolous who is kinda in his team. So, it was very likely. But certainly, that song was going from one broadcaster to another and was supposed to be the Greek one last year.
First of all, thank you for voicing thoughts on the lyrics of Ukraine's entry, it's making me hold my breath every time from how icky I find it. It's a really good format of your video, it keeps me hooked to see what you'll say and write, and I like that idea. Watching on, I really agreed with A LOT of your thoughts, disagreed on very few... but you have my respect. Have a meow from a very corrupted and almost a complete failure fairytale Croatia. :D (I still can't believe I'm rooting for my own country this year).
Thanks❤️❤️❤️
My favorite entry are :
France (obviously💜)
Germany
Belgium
Croatia
❤CROATIA❤ 12 point ❤Marko goooooo❤❤❤
I do not like your Top 10 (just different taste), but you are the first one to break a myth of Ukraine song! Great job!! Also, I like your vision of Germany, Latvia & Australia. Regards frrom Greece!
Malta ❤
I gave up once France was ranked so lowly. Clearly we have different tastes.
Yeah, it happens. Actually, not that many eurofans have it very high
@@escserg6731 that's not the win you think it is 😉
@@Pdjohnners I'm not trying to win anything here ☺
Yolanda ❤Portugal 🇵🇹 beautiful sond
Thank you for not ranking Germany on the bottom I think it's a decent song it should be in the top 20
I like a German song from the start. I said many times that the dark horses are Belgium, Germany, Latvia, Australia & Denmark. Will see!😊 Regards from Greece! (My favs are Angelina, Marina & Teya!❤)
Well, Belgium isn't really a dark horse, it's around 5th in every poll and in the odds.
@@escserg6731 Dear, not now. Before 2 months this song was underrated. I like it a lot. Regards from Greece!
Thank you for your comments about Mama Teresa. It's baffling how many people ignore the actual facts about her - I'm not sure if they're that callous or genuinely don't know
Yeah, sadly, many people don't dig deep, they just believe in stereotypes which are really easy to digest for a casual brain. Mama Teresa is just another kind of a stereotype everyone believes in.
Szerbia🎉🎉🎉🎉
I know It's too late to ask...but what happened to your post-show 2023 ranking?
Never got published. I'm usually busy/not in the mood after the Eurovision, so I usually make almost no videos at that time, even the top after the show I publish like 1-2 months after. But last year was specifically tough: I accidentally deleted a lot of my videos, the Eurovision week itself was kinda disappointing (not just the predictability and Loreen winning over Kaarija, but also Unicorn and Due vite finishing 3rd and 4th, flop of a lot of interesting entries and overall feel like plastic world completely won) and I was even more busy. But I have this video almost done, so maybe I will publish it somewhen in April.
Oh okay, cool. I don't blame ya, I was also super disappointed by most of the results.
Bro australias music video is weird as fuck
It's just a lyric video actually, so it had to be just lyrics and... just anything else happening, for example, just them two the whole 3 minutes.
Very valid ranking, pretty close to mine:D
Also a funny coincidence, in Finlands clip I read the lyric in the comment at the exact moment when it was sung, leading me to be like huhh
My top 10 from Armenia🇦🇲🫶
1. Switzerland
2. Lithuania Belgium and Ukraine
(I can't even choose🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️)
3 The Netherlands
4 Sweden
5 Portugal
6 UK
7 Czechia
8 Israel
9 Azerbaijan
10 Spain
Good Luck🫶🫶🫶
shitty top 10 lol i agree w seitzerland 1st tho
Azerbaijan voises fantastik!!🎉🎉🎉🎉
Надоели шумные шоу.Вся наша жизнь сплошная какафония и уши вянут от высоких децибел😂.Однообразие участников в музыкальных пристрастиях..Скучно.🇦🇿намного высший класс,синтез очень удачный❤
Loved for Portugal top 10 and Norway and Italy...actualy I almost agree with all the top!😊
2:39 Did my girl Jerry really open her ear piece 😭, she knows she sounds good
She had technical issues in the national final, so getting rid of the earpiece was a good idea.
Thank you for Malta ❤
Lila Ramonda🌸
Spain ❤❤❤❤❤
My god Slavic English during the commentary of the Israeli entry is comedy gold😂😭
It’s like you know me or something this song is a guilty pleasure
I JUST REALIZED SLIMANE AND THE TWINS ARE ALSO BEEN COLONIZED BY THE SLAVIC ENGLISH
AND GERMANY 💀💀
Not only during the Israeli entry, but during all my other voice comments here where I couldn't use the song due to the copyrights. It's so fitting here, I can't - I voice those comments speaking Slavic English, and there was a song about it in this national final season. It was perfect to use it here.
Statement regarding Israel:
I personally wouldn’t wanna play that stupid game of not including it cuz it’s Israel either. I get it, Israel bad and all that, but to automatically not even RANK them is just dumb. Maybe I’m biased cuz I actually watched Israel’s NF, HaKokhav Haba, with a few other people (mainly other Israelis), even tho I’m neither Jewish or an Israeli.
As for the song itself, I’m kinda with you on it. Kinda boring and artificial. I just like it slightly more then you do. It’s currently in my 24th spot on my list.
Agree
@@escserg6731another thing: If this song was from say Switzerland or France, people wouldn’t be so fucking weird about it.
Great comment about Slovenia🇸🇮 I agree 💯 but I know it will be interesting live, best live from Slovenia. Ok it's not commercial but it's unique that should be appreciate more.🥳 Mostly all other songs are something we have already heard...80's, 90's, dancing here and there, we had a bad copy of (almost) last year winner, bad vocals ... sorry but, yeah ...
Sorry, but all the music are influenced by something from the past, it's just how our world works. You can't just say that it's a con of the song if it's something we've heard before
Putting Ukraine's entry in below average is where i stop watching this calamity
I explained why. Opinions can be different. I usually have Ukraine very high but this year I just have too many issues
who are you gonna vote for in the semis?
I can't vote, but if I could... I don't know yet.
Ojala sea asii
👏👏👏👏👏
my top 10 from the netherlands 1 my country netherlands banger 2 austria banger 3 croatia banger 4 belgium beatyful dark ballade 5 sweden bop 6 cyprus bop 7 georgia bop 8 armenia bop 9 slovenia beatyful dark ballad 10 greece very etnic bop
Wow! Your explanation about the Ukraine song was just so powerful, to be honest I don't like this song anyway but I now don't like it even more, it's going down more.
Yeah, that comment was less about the song and more about what's around it. And it's OK as I rank the whole package, not just the song itself as a melody in studio version
Belgium ❤️ Poland ❤️ Switzerland ❤️ Germany
There is a live performance of the tower
Not official one, just someone recording the live concert. And she wasn't ideal there.
Germany is very underrated. (I am from Finland)
Top 5 1🇧🇪2🇳🇱3🇨🇭4🇱🇹5🇺🇦👍👍👍👍🎵🎶🎶🎶
Ulveham❤
I don’t mind that you’ve spoken some commentary in, it kinda makes it a interesting video, but I would like if you put subtitles to the video, so you can read what you’re saying. Maybe it because I’m a little bit deaf, that I would like that, but yeah just see what you’re going to do with it
Actually, I planned to add subtitles on CZcams,even started writing them. But then, CZcams automatic subtitles turned out to be good, so I advice to turn them on
@@escserg6731 ahh okay, yes I’ve turned them on, but on the first few spoken commentaries there were subtitles, but from France’s entry not anymore.
@@escserg6731oh wait never mind🙈 I needed to do the automatic subtitles😂
@@melaniegoossen yeah, that's the thing. I started writing my own subtitles, but then I saw that automatic CZcams subtitles are good, so I just stopped. I guess, I need either finish them or delete.
@@escserg6731 yeah I think that’s for the best, finish them or delete them. Because now it looks a little bit weird. But if you need to delete the video for that, and have to re-upload it, I think you can leave it like this.
Good night, sleep well
You definately like Slavic English -Nazva (Vidbir 2024)
One of my favorites of Vidbir this year, yeah. But I used it because of how relatable it is here, when I speak Slavic English myself.
Croacia es otro país que me gusta su canción ,pero si quieren algo diferente voten a Finlandia 😅
10:24 I don’t think you realise what the title translates as…
I do😅
About the comments with your voice, it's an understable idea but it needs to be more polished imo. Sometimes, it feels a bit unnatural (i have the feeling that you talk by reading your comments (idk if I'm clear here)) and a bit monotonous (some intonation could made it better). However it still such a pleasure to have your comments.
About my top 37, here it is (with some comments):
37.🇦🇱
36.🇲🇩
35.🇮🇸: oh god, Iceland's journey is already a mess. About the song itself, it's at the same level of the two previous one: generic and not interesting enought.
35.🇨🇾: well, it looks dated, generic and arrogant. Maybe it can grew on me with the live but for now, it's just here.
34.🇬🇷: I know she's a fan favorite and that nearly everybody loves this entry. Personnaly i have the feeling to hear a succession of melody that didn't match together without any transition. The result in the end is pretty flat and annoying. Sorry but I can't.
32.🇬🇧: well, I already know that it will be overhyped by so many eurofans because he's a famous artist (I'm maybe the only one who didn't know who he is before he was annonced). And the song is... well generic and uninterresting again.
31.🇺🇦
30.🇮🇱
29.🇦🇿: I thought that I will place this one higher but this year still strong despite some disappointment (imo). The path that choose Azerbaïdjan here still interesting but it's clearly not nought to stand out.
28.🇫🇮 (grew off a bit)
27.🇦🇺
26.🇦🇹: Sorry but here I can't place this higher. I don't find something particular here, it tries to be atmospheric and very catchy but doesn't work imo. It sounds more flat, generic and overproduced. The live performance will be crucial here.
25.🇪🇸
24.🇵🇱
23.🇩🇰
22.🇱🇺
21.🇱🇻
20.🇲🇹
19.🇸🇲
18.🇩🇪
17.🇸🇪
16.🇷🇸: well, even if I was for Zorja during pze, it still a very beautiful song from Serbia (especially with the meaning) and the staging is very good too.
15.🇵🇹: Portugal continues to do their own thing and thiw time with a very unusual entry and god, it's so gooooood and enjoyable. Maybe something missing to be a bit more memorable but still a good effort.
14.🇨🇿
13.🇳🇱: I will never expected this country choosing internally someone who usually does this type of song and yes, it's very funny. The chorus will stuck in my head during the rest of my life I think😅
12.🇪🇪
11.🇱🇹
10.🇫🇷
9.🇸🇮
8.🇦🇲: I just LOVE the way Armenia choose this year: a ethnic pop entry with few lyrics interpreted by a multicultural duo. Well done, seems to be the Moldova 2022 of this year
7.🇬🇪: I'm usually not a fan of girls bop but this one seems promising (Maybe it's a bit too high for what it is but I kinda believe that in live, it will be very memorable)
6.🇮🇪
5.🇧🇪
4.🇮🇹
3.🇨🇭: learn Greece, this is how to do a good mixt of genres. I don't know how they manage to do it but Nemo is really amazing. Pop, Opera, Rap, Ballad in one song and the result is here unbelievable. Wow just nothing more to say.
2.🇭🇷
1.🇳🇴
Have a nice day❤
Thanks. Yeah, voice comments were just an experiment and I see all the issues. Yeah, I read them, I couldn't do it otherwise. And I become intense while recording, so the emotions are lacking, there're a lot of pauses. Well, at least I tried to pronounce the separate words more or less right, even CZcams auto generated subtitles understood me. So, people at least can just turn them on.
you killed all my faves bro-