Ranking Every MCU Phase One Movie & TV Show - A Tier List
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 03. 2024
- Kicking off in 2008 with Iron Man the Marvel Cinematic Universe built it's way to a huge superhero crossover in The Avengers 2012 pulling off what many thought would be impossible. And we're here to determine the very best from the two mentioned plus The Incredible Hulk, Iron Man 2, Thor, Captain America: The First Avenger, plus some other bonus mentions including some Marvel One Shots. Thanks for watching
Check out BigSandwich.co for early videos and bonus podcasts
Ranking Every Spider-Man Universe ► • Ranking Every Spider-M...
James' Twitter ► / mrsundaymovies
Maso's Twitter ► / wikipediabrown
Edited by ► / resdolph
SUBSCRIBE HERE ►► bit.ly/1IQB3kh
TWP Itunes ► podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast...
TWP Direct Download ► play.acast.com/s/theweeklyplanet
TWP CZcams Channel ► goo.gl/1ZQFGH
Patreon ► / mrsundaymovies
Amazon Affiliate Link ► amzn.to/2nc12P4
T-Shirts/Merch ► www.teepublic.com/stores/mr-s...
#Marvel #MCU #TheAvengers #IronMan #Thor #CaptainAmerica - Zábava
Hoping that they will eventually rank their past Tier lists
The would be great :D
That's a fantastic idea!
that would be so META
S tier idea
Has to be a ranking though. Not just a tier list
James "I wouldn't feel comfortable giving Iron Man 2 a B".... Gives it a B
If there is one thing James excels at, its discomfort
he didn't like it, but he had to go along with it
He wasn’t comfortable doing it though
It's a C+, but only because of War Machine.
I still remember the Honest Trailer for the Avengers and they said Captain America was “no one’s favorite”. Oh how times have changed.
He’s still no one’s favorite sorry pal
@@calebford6318He's my favorite!
@@calebford6318speak for yourself buddy. The Cap movies never dipped in quality unlike the Iron Man and Thor ones. And I shed a few manly tears not when Tony died, but when Steve finally got his dance with Peggy.
@@calebford6318 Objectivevly untrue.
@@ashb7if you cried at a dance they weren’t manly tears my guy
So glad First Avenger is S tier. I love that movie, perfect origin story and casting.
I thought it was a B when I first saw it, but over time and seeing how much they did the character right, I've definitely elevated it and agree with this ranking.
I love that opinion has come around on it. I remember when it came out I loved it and everyone around me felt like it was okay. Now it seems to get a strong ranking from most fans.
I don't always agree with James and Maso, but I'm so glad they put The First Avenger at S tier. I think it really does deserve it.
They gave it an A., So I guess you still don't agree with James and Maso.
@SubwoofBarks they put the Avengers at A tier but "The First Avenger" at S tier.
The core concept of Captain America is that he does not represent America. He represents what America should be and I think they nail that.
Avengers was an amazing theater experience. I love the writing style of he who shall not be named. It was everything I always wanted in a comic book movie
Yeah, I don't know if they were saying the Whedon stuff is why they would not rate it higher but I hope not because that is stupid. I hope they are just rating it on its merits
S tier all day everyday
4:10 Primo Stuff right there. I chuckled out loud on the bus for that one.
I love ham
Fuck yes, I love the original Thor. Finally some love.
I cannot and will not get past those brows
The scenes in Asgard are still great. It's a shame the tone of the Thor films took a huge nosedive from this point on.
Thor First Thor: Original Recipe Thor
Maso mentioning that people who saw Agents of Shield in its entirety would be furious it’s not an S was so spot on. You two said B tier and I’m in my car shouting NO ITS AN S
Don’t worry, he misspoke
There are S tier moments, and there are absolutely F tier moments. Personally i would've split it up by season cause otherwise i would have no idea how to rank it. The highs are so high and the lows are so low.
If it makes you feel any better, I think it's F-tier garbage. I haven't seen 1 minute of it, but I feel like I'm right and I will never revisit this subject again.
@@quintus920Truly understandable and have a quaint day.
Psh, it's the middle of mid. So incredibly middle.
WERE THOSE ACTUAL PICTURES OF LITTLE BEHBEH MASO?!? I'M DEAD! I'VE DIED!
My condolences
WAIT WHAT? I was eating while I watched this and missed it 😮
@@ZachBobBob got it, 1:33
@@demon-goat Holy shit! Thanks
We must know
This list got me in tears
*tiers
Can't wait for James and Maso to get to phase 4 which will be a 3 hour long video of Cs Ds
That first season of AoS was only good in the last five episodes when the hydra twist happened in sync with Winter Soldier, before that they were spinning their wheels doing a monster of the week but MCU Jr.
They did a whole British avengers bit with zero context😂
Agents of Shield was great ! I loved it a lot : it's silly, it's weird, they go in all the directions.
It went in the same directions as the rest of the MCU. Because that is what the MCU fanboys demanded it do.
If you think about it, they caused the multiverse just as much as the Avengers did in Endgame with all of their time traveling branches they created in the last 3 seasons.
Its what Legends of tomorrow is to DC its so goofy fun that its definitely not bad
Season 4 is obscenely good
I think season 4 is on par with the best stuff the mcu has done.
What a pair of rankers
You guys should do a "The Crow" movie franchise review
When you do phase two, I hope you’ll include Agent Carter (the series) - it’s just a matter of time before it will be put back into the official timeline.
Agent Carter is the series I still hold a torch for, it was amazing and definitely deserved more love (and seasons!)
Jarvis in Endgame feels like evidence enough
Looking forward to what you come up with below F for Inhumans
James I definitely recommend checking out Season 4 of Agents of Shield! It's the best season in my opinion and its also the one that does Secret Invasion the right way. Something happens!
The best Secret Invasion adaptation is the one from the Avengers Earth's Mightiest Heroes cartoon
I used to watch Agents of Shield every Wednesday with my dad. It will forever be a great memory. And yeah the show was very interesting. I'm not going to say I loved it but as it kept coming out it was great
The MCU made me actually like Iron Man and Captain America. It let me see them at their best and appreciate them. Because before the MCU kicked off? I couldn't stand either of them. In fact, this whole 'Avengers' corner of the Marvel universe was a big shrug from me. I was much more of a DC guy. But they REALLY brought me around and now I fucking love them. :)
I really wish with the Netflix series that they kept them self contained like they are but have a bonus one-shot episode where you see what they did during the battle of New York.
Daredevil helping to evacuate apartment blocks and has a big fight with an alien at the end to demonstrate his street level powers. Maybe Jessica Jones and Luke Cage have episodes where they are helping out but also trying to hide that they have powers.
Punisher just help up in a building mini gunning.
Agents of SHIELD is an A for me. James, I really hope you check it out someday! It's worth watching as a standalone series even if nothing in it ever connects back to the larger MCU.
I hate to get political, I HATE to get political, but before November you should do a fictional movie/TV Presidents tier list.
Harrison Ford and Martin Sheen are already S-Tier, there you go, got the hard stuff out of the way.
Wtf no
Only if they do one for the royal family first because you know how the Aussies love royalty.
Martin Sheen, definitely not. His presidency was one disaster after another.
@@lyndsaybrown8471F-Tier. All of them.
The only thing I can think of with this is Jon Bois' video on 24 and him going through all the presidents who keep getting killed off by the writers.
"Oh my god Palmer's brother you're such a NEEEERRRD! I'm sorry I HAVE to kill you off now"
Agents of shield definitely gets better!! And worse.. And better again!! It’s not perfect but i love it
Every Spider-Clone, tier listed. We're talking Ben Reilly, the skeleton with a quarter of a Spidey mask on it, Spidercide, maybe others.
@3:05 Can we stop mulling around and give Incredible Hulk it's flowers; it was the official start of the MCU. Iron man was just the pilot.
The Elon dig makes this an S teir video.
Love how they will take a dog at Elon, but not mention the genoc!de that he supports along with Disney and Marvel. Don't want to get all political! Don't get political while people are dying and your country is supporting it and the companies you make money talking about are supporting it.
@@toddhollen probably because there isn't a genocide. Also Elon is on your side, he loves to tell everyone how theres too many Jews and they're replacing everyone.
@@toddhollen womp womp
@@toddhollen strange world you conspiracy theorists live in, but Elon is one of you. He believes in the replacement theory too.
This channel makes the only tier list videos that are actually fun.
Love the Sunday bonus videos. Makes worrying about the work week coming up a little more tolerable. Thanks guys.
Sunshine is one of my fav movies too. That and 28 days, all by Alex Garland and Danny Boyle.
Two of my favourite director/writers working today. I think "28 Years Later" is the only sequel I've been genuinely hopeful for in decades.
@@Psilocybin77 You also must be looking forward to Civil War?
Putting The Avengers anywhere that’s not S tier is absolutely criminal
It was an amazing first time at the cinema, but on repeat viewings it doesn't really hold up as well so I think an A is fair
@@nathonso_edits I saw the movie 7 times in theatres and about five more times at home. Holds up for me.
Love the tier lists 👍
2:50 I love that hulk design more than the current
Which current one? The smart hulk?
I agree. This is probably my favorite Hulk design. I used to have a picture of this Hulk roaring with his arms wide as my Facebook banner (no pun intended) for a long time. Back when I still had Facebook lol.
As someone who sat through all of Agents of Shield, B tier is the perfect placement.
If anyone is hesitant on watching Agents of Shield, just watch the Ghost Rider arc tbh. Theres other good stuff but that’s easily the highlight.
10:48 you now have to do The Avengers (1998) for Caravan of Garbage!!
The old switcheroo for Capt America 1 and Avengers. Guarantees comments/interaction. Smart lads.
Accurate placement.
100%
I had read I think... Joss Whedon had said that Agents of shield takes place in an alternate universe where Coulson lived, and he is dead in the main movie universe.
Man I loved AoS. To be fair, I didn't watch the last season after what was very clearly a wrap up of the show because it felt tacked on and I didn't want to ruin a good ending. That show though was so much better than most the crap we get now. And at the time I remember feeling like while the Marvel movies were more afraid to take big risks and felt formulaic, AoS would just go wild with it's plots doing things like time travel, dream worlds, other dimensions and all sorts of things while movies during that time were still relatively grounded. It felt really fun and comic booky in a way the movies didn't yet. Ironically, now all the time travel and multiverse stuff feels like crap once the movies all did decide to delve into it.
Still really odd how the Cap costume was so good in First Avenger and so bad in Avengers Assemble?
Pretty sure you can "thank" Whedon for that one. That style of helmet/headpiece never works in live action.
@@RenoisticNor does the onesie style costume. Aside from Spider-Man, really.
He thought comic accurate might be looked on more fondly. Since Xmen ditched comic accurate fun colours for black leather, he thought fun colours were back in
@@johntonssen7231 But then X-Men First Class proved that comic accurate colours can work, without looking like cosplay. Funny that Avengers Assemble was the only bad Cap design.
The editing of these videos never disappoints.
The only thing Hammer made that didn't work to my memory is his attempt at an Iron Man style exosuit. His drones worked wonderfully and Ivan had inside access to hack them. It's just that he doesn't come off as super intimidating since he's a pretty goofy jovial dude.
Also the ex-wife or whatever that little missile that dinked off the baddie at the end was called, but your point is correct
@Peweskimooxy oh yeah I forgot about that, I have no idea how with that entire introduction but tbh that was also hilarious that it had that whole Wikipedia article introduction and then was a dud lmao
6:43 Yes you are upsetting people... That short is totally an S tier.
The intro is literally every tier list lolol let's goo 😂
how did both The Avengers and Justice League ever get made if it wasn't directed by anyone? really makes you think. maybe more studios should take note from these two great movies, and just not have any directors.
I think Invincible and Agents of Shield have the same story trajectory, where they both start off very familiar with the stories they tell, but after a while they really branch out and go off in crazily interesting and entertaining ways.
The Consultant was basically just meant to retcon the context of the pre -credits bar scene in The Incredible Hulk.
I love that they can’t talk about Iron Man without mentioning the “you can have two slices of pizza” improve line.
the first avengers movie in my eyes is perfect and the fact that it came together im such a good way… chefs kiss. we had a good run
I think B is a solid ranking for Agents of SHIELD. It was a good show, but was hampered early by having to be tied to the movies #itsallconnected. Once they just started doing their own thing; it got great. Really crazy storylines (Matrix/simulation season, future space station season, dimension hopping "evil" Coulson season, etc)
I’ve seen AoS in entirety, love the show! I think B is fair
Nah. S tier is the only option.
11:23 I can’t comprehend James’ inability to not bring up the personal dramas of the artists who worked on the film. Here and there, sure. Especially if it’s a Kevin Spacey. But it’s practically every video now where we get the newspaper and the “not gonna talk about it 😅” and it’s always James. Never Mason.
It's not just that Iron Man wasn't popular before the film, even in the comics community everyone hated him at that time because of the Civil War event.
Best editors on CZcams! ❤
AoS is definitely a B, I dropped off in the last series as I didn't care about the plot by then but I enjoyed it up until then and I think they did the Hydra stuff quite well.
Absolutely incredible achievement for the Avengers, hatsune miku knocked it out of the park on her debut
Agents of Shields is my comfort show and I have seen it all the way through multiple times 😅
Now I kinda want to watch it.
This rambling entertains me so greatly
It really can't be overstated how much Joss Whedon flattened the characters in Avengers. I saw it before any of the other MCU films and felt like it was clever and stood alone well, but was surprised that characters with such wildly diverse backstories would be so similar. My friends at the time set me right with an MCU education and the emotional depth in what could've been brainless action movies really stunned me. Even Thor, which didn't hit me the same way, was Big and Exaggerated in a hyper-theatrical way that made up for it. Avengers just did all that dirty, even as good as it was.
To hear that he only watched 2 seasons of Agents of Shield is a true shame. Seasons 3 and 4 are A-tier content.
The Norton Hulk is the best design imo
Agents of Shield was genuinely great between Seasons 2-4 but I can't say I really cared for any of the other seasons
I know I watched a portion of Agents of Shield but I genuinely cannot remember anything that happened other than Miss Shield Girl (idk her name) eventually got like earthquake powers or something.
B seems fair.
Can't wait for the DC version of this which happily includes the rankings for all the movies in the name.
Very thoughtful of DC to warn us off like that
Rarely see people give First Avenger and Thor their proper due. They're still among my favorite MCU movies for a reason.
Jimmy and Nicki never miss.
Engagement!!!
2008 Hulk is the best design. overall the hulk should have resembled Edward Norton
They forgot to rank "New Adventures of Old Christine"!
Love it. Keep it up.
Oh boy, my favorite comic character as a kid was Carnage. I don't know what that says about me. 🤣
Whoa! I totally forgot about The New Adventures Of Old Christie. 😳
Whenever I think of Julia Louis-Dreyrus, I think of Seinfeld, Vero, and the MCU.
I never think of Old Christie, despite having watched several episodes. 🤦
Watching this really made me miss the old MCU. When it was new and pure and you had to wait for things.
Couldn't believe my eyes as a kid when I saw them all together in one film for the first time.
That's what Marvel has lost now and what they seem to have forgotten by forcing it down our throats constantly - it isn't special anymore.
Phase One is definitely the most "Tyrese" of the MCU 😊😅😂.
The tier list I never knew I needed
This was an ‘S’ tier Mr Sunday Movie vid
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. is my favorite thing in the MCU
2008 is an amazing Hulk design, you’re the only person I know who likes 2012 Gorilla Hulk and Avenegers is by far S tier, yall must be drunk lol
Please please more More!
I Need More of These!!! just a bit. 🤪 I need it going through withdrawal
Avengers in A is crazy
The line I always think about with MCU Justin Hammer is how Jon Favreau said he wanted him to "be the Daffy Duck to Tony Stark's Bugs Bunny".
Iron Man 2 is my absolute favorite Marvel movie to this day. S tier.
Baffling take
Pretty spot on, good stuff.
I disagree on Hulk, I very much like the Incredible Hulk design, and wish it had stayed. I've come to love what we had for a few years before Hulk and Banner merged, but there's something about the very spindly Edward Norton turning into a wide brick wall of a green monster. The massive hands and feet also work. I'm not crazy about the gorilla-esque posture of the Avengers and so forth design, although I do get it. Zero Percent body fat Hulk from 2008 though, I really like that design.
This video is an S for the New Adventures of Old Christine reference
TIL (thanks to the video making me look it up) why she's called "Old" Christine. Huh.
A funny thing about a funny thing happened on the war to Thors hammer. I watched this on Disney Plus a few months ago and though it was funny, so I wanted to show my siblings and a friend who was over. I basically said its just a fun little short with Agent Coulson. I pressed play and it started where I left off, with Coulson getting gas and then driving away. Then the short ended. Maybe this was funnier in my head.
you two better continue with the other phases and always use the same tier list! just continue on it!
Mr Sunday Movies and Maso, I am SHOCKED to say the VERY least to hear you both give THE AVENGERS an A Tier grade and not S!!!!!!!! I remember watching that film with my cousin in the very first morning showing and WE WERE IN AWE OF SUCH AN AMAZING FILM soooooooo much that we WENT TO SEE IT AGAIN THE SAME DAY!!!!! We have NEVER DONE THAT BEFORE AND HAVEN'T AGAIN SINCE THEN!!! THE AVENGERS IS A SUPERB S TEIR MOVIE GENTLEMEN! Would you be so kind as to give more explanation on you how both came to this conclusion on your podcast The Weekly Planet come Monday PLEASE!
Agents of Shield is S tier...I will die on this hill!
Honestly these arent bad, thor may be too high but for the wonderful controversy you gents go for, this is pretty great and reliable, looking forward to phase two
Agents of Shield is in my S tier, but I am not offended you guys don't think so. I like all the references in the first couple seasons, but I think it shines in the last few when it for most part gives up trying to be directly connected. A lot of the Kree stuff makes a lot of sense in the light of The Marvels now.
This made me miss phase 1 Marvel so hard
You should rank mcu movie actors by the movie they did last before signing on for an mcu movie.
I'm glad Captain America is in S tier, People keep on telling me they hate that movie. And I'm like, why?
Always found the character alienating before the Movie. Chris Evans sold it.
It’s just so bland to me, someone who likes mutants and magic. Compared to my faves, the Marvels or Strange 2, it’s almost like a documentary hahaha.
@@nailinthefashion That's the point though. He isn't fantastical. He was just a soldier on "super steroids".
@@pious83 yes! Which is why I was not the target demographic hahahaha (claps like a trained seal)
@@nailinthefashion Not being from the US, I wasn't the "target demographic". Which is an irrelevant point to make. Doesn't even make sense in respect to any earlier comment???
The real homies prefer the character design of the hulk in The Incredible Hulk
Whereas the Hulk from 2003 is the most comic accurate.
I never understood the 'hate' on Iron Man 2. That movie is a helluva good time.
So bad
peak Scarjo too
I don't mind it, but as they mention in the video, Whiplash is kind of a weak villain
Facts @@Alexus1138
The worst part of the Iron Man movies is how they did his villain roster so dirty.
Give the people what they want: Ranking every original Weekly Planetverse character. Corn of Coblin. Little James. Old Rey. Maso's Twin Brother. Some other characters.
I really loved item 47, and was hoping to see Lizzie Caplan and Jessie Bradford return in some way. I was really disappointed when they made Sitwell a hydra agent, so I assume they were probably recruited into hydra eventually. But they didn’t strike me as evil so I’m hoping that’s not the case. I’m still hoping to see them return in later MCU projects, although nothing has happened yet, I’m still holding out hope.
I'm a big fan of Agents of SHIELD, and I can live with a B. A good chunk of it is A+, but it does have it's dips, so I can accept it leveling out to a strong B. ;) That said, AoS really came into it's own as the series went on. I recall much distress over whether it's "actually canon" or not, but by the time the series finished, AoS basically forged it's own reality thanks to multiversal shenanigans (before they were cool) and said "fuck you" to any need to be validated by the MCU. And I love it for it. AoS remains in my top 10 favorite shows of all time. It more than earned it.
Lets face it.. phase 4 has made most of the infinity saga into masterpieces