Ukraine War Update BUMPER NEWS (20240515a): Pt 1 - Overnight & Other News

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 4. 06. 2024
  • Here is today's UWU NEWS giving you all the nuggets you need to add to your understanding of events.
    Email to enquire about coming to my talk in north Hampshire in June.: atpukrainetalk@gmail.com
    Del's open-source Russian loss stats:
    onedrive.live.com/view.aspx?r...
    Bill's stats dashboard: www.ukrainewarstatistics.com/
    Merchandise for the A Tippling Philosopher blog network and CZcams channel. www.redbubble.com/people/john...
    Buy me a coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/GkxsyfQ
    Paypal Donate: www.paypal.com/paypalme/johnn...
    UA Supporter merch: uasupporter.com/atp
    Check out this website of pro-Ukrainian inks:
    www.heroyam.org/slava_ukraini
    Discord: / discord
    Videos/sources:
    Hits/losses
    x.com/NOELreports/status/1790...
    TrentTelenko/stat...
    John_A_Ridge/stat...
    deaidua/status/17...
    Spartan_News1/sta...
    PStyle0ne1/status...
    CasualArtyFan/sta...
    hizzo_jay/status/...
    Rebel44CZ/status/...
    Rebel44CZ/status/...
    TWMCLtd/status/17...
    NOELreports/statu...
    Strikes
    NOELreports/statu...
    nexta_tv/status/1...
    wartranslated/sta...
    ColbyBadhwar/stat...
    RALee85/status/17...
    blyskavka_ua/stat...
    TWMCLtd/status/17...
    TWMCLtd/status/17...
    TWMCLtd/status/17...
    Maks_NAFO_FELLA/s...
    ukraine_map/statu...
    Osinttechnical/st...
    ukraine_map/statu...
    _____
    0:00 Start
    0:10 Hits/losses
    14:50 Strikes
    26:08 Other
    _____
    DISCLAIMER FOR GENERAL STAFF LOSSES DATA
    1) These are real people with real lives and real families who love them. Don’t let the numbers sap your humanity.
    2) These numbers probably aren’t accurate but they’re the best we have and we don’t need them to be accurate to be indicative of patterns of activity.
    3) All losses are estimates. Losses cannot be counted with accuracy because of the conditions on the ground.
    4) Both sides would see it to be of their advantage to minimize their own losses maximize the other side’s losses.
    5) Neither side releases their losses but we have enough transparency from the Ukrainian side to have confidence in they are indicative.
    6) Personnel losses are hard to count. If a soldier gets injured, heals up, and returns to the front line only to get injured again, is that one loss or two? Also, how to deal with losses from PMC’s or soldiers fighting with RF from occupied territories?
    7) Equipment losses are hard to count. If an AA complex involves several parts and one part gets disabled, is that a loss, or a fraction of a loss? If a tank gets disabled, repaired, back into the fight, then disabled again, is that one lost tank or two?
    8) All recorded losses are vulnerable to multiple reporting. We have already seen numerous cases of multiple drones in the air reporting the same loss from different angles as multiple engagements.
    9) Losses are not always reported on the same day they occurred. It is frequent that drone losses are reported at least 24 hours after other terrestrial equipment losses. Certain losses may not be reported for days or weeks for military intelligence reasons.

Komentáře • 230

  • @papasam1934
    @papasam1934 Před 21 dnem +11

    Since Russia annexed the Ukraine areas all use of military aid in these regions is use within Russia according to Russia. Conclusion: According to Russia there is no difference of using a missile on Moscow or Luhansk. Therefore why do we make a difference or think there is a difference?

  • @mainschannel
    @mainschannel Před 21 dnem +12

    There can be No negotiation with putin. We must put him in his place!

  • @bevr944
    @bevr944 Před 21 dnem +12

    Had the USA and Germany stepped up and helped Ukraine back in 2014 then this full-out war in Ukraine would not be happening now. They are 10 years too late at stepping up and way too slow, and way too cowardly, miserly in the amount of assistance they are providing now with stupid policies..

    • @sk.43821
      @sk.43821 Před 21 dnem

      100% agree. Only cowards in the West.
      Cheers from 🇩🇪

    • @vlakdrak4774
      @vlakdrak4774 Před 20 dny

      Unfortunately this war has floated to the surface all the shit about europe and US. US is not reliable in helping its allies unless they fight banana republics. If they are attacked by a decently strong army power like Russia(and I am being generous) then they cower behind self imposed redlines. The Europeans have lived 80 years in peace and gotten idiotically weak behind their brunches and lattes. Russians are not like us, they are wired differently. The more you allow them to impose rules the more they will attack you. We need to fucking get our shit together for fuck's sake. Its enough! Two years of this bullshit behavior is really infuriating. People die. Its not Afghanistan. Ukraine is Europe and we need to defend them with everything we have!

  • @paulyoung4422
    @paulyoung4422 Před 21 dnem +5

    Russia's new bean counter, won't be able to tell the Tzar any of this.

  • @keithkane7891
    @keithkane7891 Před 21 dnem +14

    Great video as always keep up the great work!! Slava Ukraini💪🇺🇦💪

  • @alanchristensen5735
    @alanchristensen5735 Před 21 dnem +9

    JP you are on fire. I'd just say that you need to pace yourself. Excellent work 👍
    SLAVA UKRAINI from the United States

    • @alanchristensen5735
      @alanchristensen5735 Před 21 dnem +1

      BTW I agree with you regarding the land occupation theory. Rather like a poker chip and the more chips you have the better negotiating power you have

  • @jmtpolitico80
    @jmtpolitico80 Před 21 dnem +15

    Good Day JP, TEAM!!!

  • @Nick-pq4ri
    @Nick-pq4ri Před 21 dnem +15

    Morning Jonathan got my coffee and just tuning in to the first update 🇺🇦🇬🇧✌️

  • @richardrjkspinningwood3537
    @richardrjkspinningwood3537 Před 21 dnem +7

    Hi JP, from the Guardian “The US does not encourage Ukraine to strike targets inside Russia with US-supplied weapons but believes it is a decision Kyiv should make for itself, secretary of state Antony Blinken said on Wednesday” in a press conference

    • @ATPGeo
      @ATPGeo  Před 21 dnem +7

      Not only did the announcement of a two billion dollar aid package come out just after I released this video but also that statement!

    • @mike4480
      @mike4480 Před 21 dnem +2

      And Thanks Johnathan and the Team for the update ,..again … 💙💛💙

  • @axelpro09
    @axelpro09 Před 21 dnem +11

    I l The problem is that we tell ourselves about the red line (stupid), not even the Russians complain, only the Western media talks about these things

  • @_Mary_M
    @_Mary_M Před 21 dnem +15

    Hello Jonathan, team and friends 🙂👋

  • @davidtrotman5990
    @davidtrotman5990 Před 21 dnem +36

    Please give JP a thumbs-up.

    • @paraandy3821
      @paraandy3821 Před 21 dnem +1

      🥇👏👏👏👏👍😊

    • @fredfred4420
      @fredfred4420 Před 21 dnem

      Why? It was obvious that he's biased, and hence unreliable from the first sentence that he uttered. I'm not suggesting that his fans turn to Russian cheerleaders, the flipped side of the coin from this tool. Just start looking for some posts here that aren't posted by bald cheerleaders. This is the first time I've seen this guy. Was he extolling the Ghost of Kyiv's heroic exploits two years ago?

    • @vasilispatsalidis5683
      @vasilispatsalidis5683 Před 21 dnem

      I gave JP a thumbs up, but could you please be so kind as to inform JP that NATO has majestically lost this war, and that exactly the same thing and even worse will happen to NATO in the forthcoming Taiwan war.
      Thanks a lot.

    • @vasilispatsalidis5683
      @vasilispatsalidis5683 Před 21 dnem

      ​@@fredfred4420Fred, unfortunately some people like this Mr.JP do not want to understand that this war is OVER.
      Further more i fully and wholeheartedly agree with your assessment of Mr. JP's hairstyle.

    • @paraandy3821
      @paraandy3821 Před 21 dnem

      @@vasilispatsalidis5683 as this 'war' is still 'ongoing' then your use of English grammar is somewhat lacking

  • @elkiebeerepoot5829
    @elkiebeerepoot5829 Před 21 dnem +7

    Good news on my wednesday indeed! I'm so hoping for strategic successes for Ukraine...

  • @donseyfried3477
    @donseyfried3477 Před 21 dnem +11

    Afternoon all, thanks JP.

  • @andrewplowman1002
    @andrewplowman1002 Před 21 dnem +8

    Thank you

  • @bobrichards6696
    @bobrichards6696 Před 21 dnem +11

    G’day all 👍🏻🇦🇺🇺🇦

  • @jeaniewilliams3274
    @jeaniewilliams3274 Před 21 dnem +8

    When one gives a gift, it leaves their control, otherwise it is not a gift.

  • @roystewart4386
    @roystewart4386 Před 21 dnem +24

    Thanks Jonathan. We can only trust that the Ukrainians wil be able to turn things around in Kharkiv. Much obliged for all your posts.

    • @freethinker4991
      @freethinker4991 Před 21 dnem

      I think they have to move back because we don't let them strike into Russia with our weapons. F... stupid that we restricting the Ukraine this way. like a boxer only alowed to punch the gloves and not the head or body.

  • @louisefoley2683
    @louisefoley2683 Před 21 dnem +17

    G'day everyone 🇺🇦 🇭🇲 🌻

    • @Wolfje9346
      @Wolfje9346 Před 21 dnem +2

      Hi Louise, goodevening!

    • @louisefoley2683
      @louisefoley2683 Před 21 dnem +1

      Hi Peter 👋 😊

    • @surpriseitsus9622
      @surpriseitsus9622 Před 21 dnem

      Good morning Louise 🌅

    • @louisefoley2683
      @louisefoley2683 Před 21 dnem

      @surpriseitsus9622 Well, I can actually say good morning back as it is 20 past midnight, and with that it's time for bed 🥱😴😴

  • @axelpro09
    @axelpro09 Před 21 dnem +7

    26:05 We only talk about red lines on ourselves, this is ridiculous, just to sell newspapers or get clicks

  • @williammore558
    @williammore558 Před 21 dnem +7

    486,000 KIAd and getting close to 500,000 and that will be a bumper payout on my bet. Still needs 14,000 before the end of summer and looking good for me😂

  • @steveclancy7832
    @steveclancy7832 Před 21 dnem +8

    Onya johno you legend !

  • @Wolfje9346
    @Wolfje9346 Před 21 dnem +22

    Hi Team, Jonno and all Ukrainloving others. Have a great wednesday!

  • @delldell191
    @delldell191 Před 21 dnem +7

    Ukraine must buy the missiles, because whenever Russia uses missiles purchased from the belt and now they say they bought it from India, then the missiles purchased by Ukraine can be used in Russia. This is a war in which the aggressor attacks the territory of others but the self cannot be attacked.

  • @markaguilera493
    @markaguilera493 Před 21 dnem +8

    👋

  • @xerolad4086
    @xerolad4086 Před 21 dnem +8

    GM all. Thanks to the team for putting this out.

  • @budwebster1031
    @budwebster1031 Před 21 dnem +3

    Sunshine is out good morning everyone also evening have a beautiful day

  • @johanneslotz3239
    @johanneslotz3239 Před 21 dnem +5

    Thx legend hi all 🎉🎉🎉🎉MUGA🎉🎉🎉

  • @user-sg6or2nu5n
    @user-sg6or2nu5n Před 21 dnem +11

    Morning all. The reason that "shoot and scoot" is not baked into modern US military doctrine is that American always controls the skies wherever we go. Enemy long-range fires are suppressed by air power long before our troops go in. If you read some early accounts of former US soldiers fighting in the international legion, they would ask their Ukranian officers, why are they getting constant russian artillery strikes and why they just did not call in an air strike. Ukranian officers would just smile and say because we don't really have an air force. I heard a rumor that the coming US aid package will include F-16's directly from the US. I hope it's correct!

    • @elkiebeerepoot5829
      @elkiebeerepoot5829 Před 21 dnem +3

      I agree. Of course you're right. But if Ukraine's military can keep up this pace and important strategic targets are hit, then it will be noticed. How this will be perceived by the Russians, we do not know, but we will undoubtedly hear it.

  • @DieselAddiction
    @DieselAddiction Před 21 dnem +8

    🇺🇦🚀🇦🇺👍🤪👋

  • @danielcunningham2394
    @danielcunningham2394 Před 21 dnem +4

    Thank you so much for breaking up the reports between geopolitical and statistical, as American we are fully aware of the mess of our politics.

  • @notodd1
    @notodd1 Před 21 dnem +3

    The lands north of Kharkiv have parrallels to Krinky as well.
    Just found out a membership was gifted to me. Boomer doesn't know how to track the giver down, but I deeply appreciate access to the members only content the algorithm constantly dangles in front of me. Thank you whoever and wherever you are. Recovering from an illness and look forward to paying my way soon.

    • @surpriseitsus9622
      @surpriseitsus9622 Před 21 dnem

      I hope you're feeling better very soon 💐 ❤

    • @surpriseitsus9622
      @surpriseitsus9622 Před 21 dnem

      I do not know who gifted you your membership, but I'm glad you have it.

    • @notodd1
      @notodd1 Před 20 dny

      @@surpriseitsus9622 it is the humble that make a community worth belonging to.

  • @RichardKrom-ul5zo
    @RichardKrom-ul5zo Před 21 dnem +2

    "OUTSTANDING" ! 🇺🇦 👏 MY HAT! IS OFF. "FOR" THE SOLDIERS! "FIGHTING FOR UKRAINE". YOU'RE FIGHTING. THE SECOND LARGEST MILITARY! "IN, THE WORLD".

  • @okeydokey3120
    @okeydokey3120 Před 21 dnem +1

    I remember being shocked at the beginning of this terrible invasion that Russia was losing 300 personnel per day...

  • @taniaryndenko2381
    @taniaryndenko2381 Před 21 dnem +2

    💙💛 HUGS 🌻 wishing all a lovely day...tyJP...

  • @MarksDavid
    @MarksDavid Před 21 dnem +4

    It’s not up to me of course, I say no negotiation. Russia gets out of all of Ukraine pre-2014. There’s nothing to negotiate otherwise except them getting out and stopping hostilities and taking on the cost of rebuilding Ukraine.

  • @denismorgan9742
    @denismorgan9742 Před 21 dnem +2

    Shoot and scoot was a answer to anti battery artillery and still is, the problem now is they have to run the gauntlet of the the drones. However if the oppositions anti battery artillery is bad at aiming or unable to target the artillery then there's no need to move.

  • @andrejsurdevics6476
    @andrejsurdevics6476 Před 21 dnem +4

    Congratulations on getting 42k subscribers.

  • @neilfox3208
    @neilfox3208 Před 21 dnem +2

    Thanks for all your hard work. I have a hard time just keeping up with the news and you manage to make hours of content on it too. Well done.

  • @bevr944
    @bevr944 Před 21 dnem +7

    That is like telling Biden that he can have airforce one but cannot use it to fly outside of Washington DC.

  • @amadeuz8161
    @amadeuz8161 Před 21 dnem +7

    Its funny when armchair generals fight... like an army adapts according to terrain. Ukraine terrain is bad for everything except for air power, like they have tiny strips of cover here and there. If you have a mobile artillery driving in a forest I would say it has a bigger chance of it surviving if it moves after shooting because no camo will hide you after shooting 1 time and you only rely on luck of no one spotting you from the air. So even if its stpd to move its stpd to stay in place also thus saying one is better than the other is neglecting the terrain and how it affects a war.
    There will always be a counter to every weapon after a while, like bunker busters when people figured out hiding under concrete made em safe. Still people fight about wheeled or tracked, mobile or stationary... Like it depends on the terrain ffs but mobile will always be better in the end because when the enemy knows your location they will with a 100% chance hit you same with a normal soldier, you can sit forever in the same spot because sooner or later the enemy will fin a way to take you out and that is why they train you to move around a bit to be unpredictable even if the human eye sees movement better than stationary objects. Yes you might not wanna move around like a crazy headless chicken all the time but after that you open fire you are more likely to survive if you have mobility in the long run else the best soldiers in the army would be those without legs.
    So please stop saying stationary woud be superior to mobile and instead start talking about when to sit still and when to move. My point is that mobile will always be superior to stationary in the long run but it doesn't make a mobile target into a bulletdodging superhero that can't be targetted it only gives the mobile one the ability to change position after fireing thus avoiding counter fire. Also the stationary artillery has to get to that location at some point so its also "mobile".
    Once more, its not the stationary that are better its the users that doesn't adapt to the battlefield. Like if stationary would be so great then why did we even invent flying things when building a high tower would be superior!

  • @I-have-a-brain_and-use-it
    @I-have-a-brain_and-use-it Před 21 dnem +3

    A Slinger is around $ 1,000,000 and can be mounted on almost anything .
    They never get a mention anywhere but AFAIK Ukraine has ordered 200 & Poland has ordered another 200 so I assume they work .
    Hopefully EOS will be able to get enough finance to build a new factory so they can produce at least 1,000 / year .
    Naturally the Australian government will not offer 1¢ of support to enable expansion unless a foreign company buys the company and no Australian banks will ever finance any manufacturing as they only finance land deals or stock market raids .

  • @Wolfje9346
    @Wolfje9346 Před 21 dnem +3

    Nice trick with the glasses at 3:16 😂

    • @surpriseitsus9622
      @surpriseitsus9622 Před 21 dnem

      Was that when his mom came visiting? 👓

    • @Wolfje9346
      @Wolfje9346 Před 20 dny +1

      @@surpriseitsus9622 yes. His glasses were coloured suddenly

    • @surpriseitsus9622
      @surpriseitsus9622 Před 20 dny

      @@Wolfje9346 yes, they change, or the lenses do going from outside to inside. If his frames turned colors, he had to grab another pair after his visiting mom went home. 🤗

  • @davidbowie1996
    @davidbowie1996 Před 21 dnem +5

    Thanks

  • @Aussie_T
    @Aussie_T Před 20 dny +1

    Thanks JP great update, keep up the great work 💙💛

  • @pauldempster1412
    @pauldempster1412 Před 21 dnem +3

    I think it's a Hail Mary move that's just going to waste troops. I also think Russia will be more depleted in the long run by this move

  • @walkish
    @walkish Před 20 dny +1

    Excellent point re North Korean and Iranian weapons. I do think that the Biden government has said they are no longer restricting Ukraine. Just that it is frowned upon. Germany wants Russia not to be able to blame them after the 2nd World War and sent more Patriots after their earlier one was used.

  • @johnhare595
    @johnhare595 Před 21 dnem +1

    Cheers JP 👍😊

  • @johncharlton8911
    @johncharlton8911 Před 20 dny +1

    Hi JP Gabions are wire cages filled with stones. I believe NATO use things called HESCO for a similar function. You will have no doubt seen these being used to create walls around our bases in Afghanistan.

  • @cigarsid7445
    @cigarsid7445 Před 21 dnem +1

    Wow, Comical Ivan has resigned. Don't worry. I'm sure they'll find someone even worse to scream in front of a map.

  • @johncromwell2529
    @johncromwell2529 Před 21 dnem +3

    🙏👍👏🇺🇦🤞

  • @user-lw6zf1cb1f
    @user-lw6zf1cb1f Před 20 dny

    I now listen to ATP before Ukraine the latest - that’s how good it is !

  • @tonypenfold926
    @tonypenfold926 Před 21 dnem +1

    This Kharkov offensive feels similar to the bulge offensive in the WW2, not a lot left in reserve, one last big push to try and gain a position to make a difference. Let’s hope they can beheld and then next year reserve and win the war.

  • @lipgloss202
    @lipgloss202 Před 21 dnem

    👍 Take care team!

  • @brotherbuddha89
    @brotherbuddha89 Před 21 dnem +1

    Belusov looks like a Bond villain.

  • @smith...1
    @smith...1 Před 21 dnem

    💙💛 Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦

  • @geraldmansfield2631
    @geraldmansfield2631 Před 21 dnem +2

    France could thin things out with 3,000 drone operators.

  • @bro_dBow
    @bro_dBow Před 21 dnem +1

    Very interesting reason on northern offensive to get a chip on negotiating table. I think Russian fears of logics being cut to the south lets them have a point of contact that has solid logistics. This offensive also fixes forces that could push on Crimean.

  • @RickFromTheNetherlands
    @RickFromTheNetherlands Před 21 dnem +3

    Hi Jonathan, I would like to add/ask something to striking into Russia, because this really worries me. We soon hope to see F16’s defending Ukraine and attacking Russian positions. How restricted are these F16’s? Are they being provided with long range rockets by the US? In other words, are the F16’s in anyway useful to attack Russian planes that drop glide bombs from Russian airspace or can they only attack targets in Ukrainian territory?
    Strike from a (safe) distance is the best way to save Ukrainian troops. We can craft more rockets, but we cannot print Ukrainian troops.
    That being said, those countries that restrict certain usage of weapons, should rethink and remove the ball and chain. Don’t let Ukraine fight with one hand tight behind their back.
    Cheers, Rick

  • @kenpreston7978
    @kenpreston7978 Před 21 dnem +3

    The teeth: They have been sitting there for some time. Did not military commanders know that? Why did they not act on this? Whoever is responsible, must be held accountable for the territory occupied and the lives lost.

  • @markusleboschka6878
    @markusleboschka6878 Před 21 dnem +1

    I wonder what those pills are. What makes sense would be Amphetamine ('Speed' today, 'Benzedrin' WW2), Methamphetamine ('Crystal Meth' today, 'Pervitin' in WW2) or Fenethylline (I think this was used by ISIS as well). Theoretically, Tilidine also makes sense ... there is this statement by a German policeman: 'If you need half a dozen adult policemen to get a rampaging 16-year-old under control, there is Tilidine in play.'

  • @user-dk5wl9xg8s
    @user-dk5wl9xg8s Před 21 dnem +9

    Jonathan, the 7 month delay in receiving US aid has impacted Ukraine, and as you have stated, Ukraine's long delay in dealing with their manpower issues has been equally damaging to their current efforts at the front. But as reported in the US, the corruption in contracts with private firms to build lines of defense around Kharkiv is unforgivable, and will fuel more distrust in the US and EU among taxpayers who seem to be funding the corruption. Perhaps the mystery surrounding the motivation for Russia's offensive in the Kharkiv region is simple: Russians tracked money moving out of Ukraine back to the contractors, looked at the work that had not been completed, and saw an opportunity to gain some land. But whatever the strategy, they are going to move until they reach the Ukrainian lines of defense, wherever that is.

    • @ericmaclaurin8525
      @ericmaclaurin8525 Před 21 dnem

      When do you losers stop whining about corruption every time you get a chance? The right votes for the most corrupt person they can find and then insult the left for not being able to weed out every corrupt POS traitor that Russia has embedded in governments and militaries all over the world.
      Corruption is always a thing but it's almost never a reason not to act. It's a reason to have redundancy and a reason to develop and maintain good working relationships instead of thinking you can hide in your own country when expansionist countries start attacking their neighbors.
      The global left is anti corruption and the right is literally built on corruption as the primary motivation for joining government.

  • @alandoherty5237
    @alandoherty5237 Před 21 dnem

    Great shout out the other day. There holding kharkiv. 😂

  • @kurtisengle6256
    @kurtisengle6256 Před 21 dnem +1

    Sent a note on your X page.

  • @Nick-pq4ri
    @Nick-pq4ri Před 21 dnem +1

    Further there were a one point 11 airframes on the apron???

  • @robertamity3563
    @robertamity3563 Před 21 dnem +2

    🇺🇦🎯🇷🇺🛢️🚀🦊🔥🇷🇺🛢️🔥👍🇺🇦 !

  • @jamesfaulkner9988
    @jamesfaulkner9988 Před 21 dnem +2

    You can't negotiate with putin the Minsk accord proved that

  • @hakonwaage9604
    @hakonwaage9604 Před 20 dny

    Your reasoning about the motives behind Russia taking land in different parts of Ukraine is actually why we must allow and enable Ukraine to take land from Russia proper. That is the only way to create balance at negotiations.

  • @vbcountryboy
    @vbcountryboy Před 20 dny

    You can’t train and mobilize people if you don’t have money, ammo to train etc.

  • @davidtrotman5990
    @davidtrotman5990 Před 21 dnem +1

    A simple thumbs-up gets trolled out,. Wow

  • @olaf2627
    @olaf2627 Před 21 dnem

    With regard to the fear of escalation and Ukraine uses western weapons inside Russia: the point is not the use of foreign weapons, the point is that Ukraine is our proxy, whereas Russia doesn't have a proxy. Ukraine attacking Russia with western weapons would be equivalent to DPR forces attacking a NATO country (or it would have been, if Russia hadn't officially annexed the Donbass). It's about the proxy relations, not about where the weapons are from

  • @patrickkarlsson183
    @patrickkarlsson183 Před 21 dnem +1

    Under Ukraines summeroffensive there were talk about they had 4 division "standing by" and was never used, are they now in the fight or are they still in reserv?

    • @putin-khuylo_putin-khuylo
      @putin-khuylo_putin-khuylo Před 21 dnem +2

      They were formed by recruiting volunteers from the National Guard and Territorial Defense who participated in the previous battles. They were never physically together.

    • @patrickkarlsson183
      @patrickkarlsson183 Před 21 dnem

      @@putin-khuylo_putin-khuylo thanks

  • @martingilmovitch8133
    @martingilmovitch8133 Před 21 dnem

    French for retreating ! lol

  • @user-tk8cu3bj5h
    @user-tk8cu3bj5h Před 21 dnem +3

    👋🏼🫶🏼🇺🇦🇬🇧

  • @lyncorsham
    @lyncorsham Před 20 dny

    The Russia coffers only some

  • @user-rv4ob4tg9x
    @user-rv4ob4tg9x Před 21 dnem

    Sup bois

  • @kjfjdkiflfkd
    @kjfjdkiflfkd Před 21 dnem

    Algo.

  • @Nick-pq4ri
    @Nick-pq4ri Před 21 dnem +2

    I don’t believe that the Ukrainian missile forces would use 10 300km ATCMs on the airfield attack seems like way too many to me! But hey what do I know 🇺🇦🇬🇧✌️

    • @andrewbielecki6154
      @andrewbielecki6154 Před 21 dnem +1

      I guess it depends on the intel, amount of live targets, dud rates and the ability of russians to intercept a couple. Not forgetting how many long range atacms the US have handed or promised.

  • @stevenphilpott4294
    @stevenphilpott4294 Před 20 dny

    Do you use time placing dragons teeth against infantry or spend the time doing other things? Minefields are probably more effective.

    • @sirsmeal3192
      @sirsmeal3192 Před 20 dny

      Both use with troops to overarching is *_much_* more effective.

  • @JohnC-nl5xs
    @JohnC-nl5xs Před 21 dnem

    And where do the Ukraine losses sit , I wonder ?

  • @clockwork-Chris
    @clockwork-Chris Před 21 dnem +2

    Shoot and Scoot: I think, in context, Andrew's argument was that 'shoot and scoot' is not and has never been in US or UK military doctrines. Movement on the battlefield being the riskiest thing to do, especially with the prevalence of so many drones, staying still and digging bunkers for artillery is the safest option. In his opinion, 'shoot and scoot' is a marketing term, a possible feature / benefit used by manufacturers to sell the systems, although not used in military doctrinal practice.

  • @paulbaines9125
    @paulbaines9125 Před 21 dnem +1

    Captogan pills

  • @onegrail9398
    @onegrail9398 Před 21 dnem

    this whole shoot and scoot argument is a tad silly. It was viable and is less so now but is not predominantly meant to be for unguided munitions.... the reduced viability can be made up for by combined arms tactics but again it is predominantly for high value platforms that launch guided munitions...

  • @joblo341
    @joblo341 Před 21 dnem

    Possible emergency generators - retired locomotives from US & EU
    Train GRAVEYARD
    czcams.com/video/AY1CGnIB9AY/video.html
    I know they can’t be run on Ukraine rails, but I’m sure that the Engines and Generators from some should be reclaimable. Strip the engines and generators out, ship to Ukraine for use as emergency generators!
    Use these “small” generators as start of a distributed power grid.

  • @I-have-a-brain_and-use-it
    @I-have-a-brain_and-use-it Před 21 dnem +1

    Ukraine has thousands of UAVs .
    The same plane packed with explosives that just got shot down in Tartisan could have been used to attack concentrations inside russia
    This is a very very lame excuse that we get from Ukraine all the time
    As for Kharkiv , Ukraine continually braggs about having 20 km, 30 km, 40 km 50 km 60 km 70 km 80 km 90 km 100km fpv drones all of which could have been peppering the russian troop concentrations for the last year.

    • @sk.43821
      @sk.43821 Před 21 dnem

      Where is a battle center of NATO which gives advice? I don't see anything. Perhaps the worst fought war in past 150 years. No vision, no goals, no strategy, no tactic. Braindead as Macron rightfully acknowledged.

  • @tunnakeech1702
    @tunnakeech1702 Před 21 dnem +1

    damn smokey joe.....how many good people have died ukraine ,when you have been sleeping @ the wheel ? god bless ukraine ,from ecosse....

  • @FunnyQuailMan
    @FunnyQuailMan Před 21 dnem +1

    Well said, Jonathan. It is indeed infuriating that Ukraine is restricted from hitting legitimate military targets with ally-provided weapons just because they happen to be sitting even just a short distance across the border from Kharkiv or anywhere else.
    What are the Ukrainians to do but fall back and allow Russia further inside Ukraine's borders if they're not allowed to hit military targets on the Russian side of the border, but only after they've crossed into Ukrainian territory?
    Hopefully, Ukraine has MUCH more carefully & extensively prepared the ground behind them as they pull back.

  • @ericmaclaurin8525
    @ericmaclaurin8525 Před 21 dnem

    An economist in charge of a pointless invasion that is destroying the economy seems much more like an off ramp than getting serious.
    The idea that you have to replace the leader of your military with a bookkeeper in the middle of a war to be more thrifty is honestly funny.
    When the only way something even sounds possible is to call the previous leader an enemy in disguise and the new guy a magician who can somehow win a game he's never played...by saving some money???😂

    • @John_shepard
      @John_shepard Před 21 dnem

      Apparently it was always a civilian position. Shoigu got in because he knows the big man

  • @Mongo_Lloyd
    @Mongo_Lloyd Před 21 dnem +6

  • @vladimirnovakovic3495
    @vladimirnovakovic3495 Před 21 dnem +1

    RUSI is spot on. Plus, to compound effects the Russians don't necessarily need to take Kharkiv city. Any land grab is welcome for them but if they can push at least half of the 1.4 mln inhabitants out of their homes it will create a very serious burden for the Ukrainian administration. Putin doesn't have any reason to start negotiations. He will keep going until Ukraine sues for peace and would impose crushing conditions for the Ukrainians. Tough spot for Ukraine.

  • @raymondmaher1388
    @raymondmaher1388 Před 21 dnem

    Did you ever see the movie made about the early stages of the Bradleys,they were trying to push them out for the troops, initially they were useless for protecting troops..?/

  • @LisaAli-ff9sh
    @LisaAli-ff9sh Před 20 dny

    Look this is not a great game alright what about your own family back home 🏘️ what you think 🤔 that could happen to them without someone that's very much stronger than they are when someone is trying to play the fool around them will you be there for them what about your own daughter who will save her from getting rape and your son from going astray what about your own wife but when we have humble ourselves and pray and put on the full armor of god 🙏 and his righteousness is then we will be able to hear from heaven and get the auction to function in wisdom knowledge and experience in intelligence in understanding in all things so that we can be able to get enough sense just to know that it doesn't make any sense just to die it's like driving down the road without any staring wheel think 🤔 about this one before you do this kind of ungodliness

  • @doug4572
    @doug4572 Před 21 dnem +2

    Agreed that U.S. should remove all restrictions on using their provided weapon systems in and on russian territories. It is logical and in line with the use of russian weapons on Ukraine territories supplier by its allies. However, the suggestion that "because" Ukraine could not use U.S. weapon systems on russian territories, it resulted in the effective push of russian troop into Ukraine northern territories is unfounded. Agreed that using the weapons in Russian territory would have been useful, but if the Ukrainians were truthy aware of the russian plans, they would have targeted the russian troops once the crossed the border. This would have effectively created a massive kill-zone. The truth is, the Ukrainians were taken a bit by surprise, and some of the fortifications were not finished though they were funded. This is not the first time that Ukraine has paid for the construction of fortifications and the work has not produced results. Corruption is killing Ukrainians. It should be dealt. And yes, the U.S. should remove the restrictions as well.

  • @TheQuallsing
    @TheQuallsing Před 21 dnem

    In war and love, all is fair.

  • @SilverWolvesScarletForestSnow

    Russia seems to have a lot of these fires even before the war, you only have to google it and there seem to be several a year lol. So I would guess half of them at least are accidents, they just don't seem too competent.

  • @user-uk5hv6qz7d
    @user-uk5hv6qz7d Před 21 dnem

    Jonathan... the "new tactic" of small groups of Russian soldiers attacking in the Kharkiv area, then attempting to consolidate with other small groups, is most probably a strategy of probing Ukraine defenses. A tactic intent on reducing the initial costs of their actions. That type of action usually implies a much heavier offensive is planned and being prepared for. An offensive involving a push of a very significant number of tanks, and other heavy firepower on the grouond and in the air would typically be expected. It is also possible that Russia will seek to open several such fronts, knowing that Ukraine forces are severely strained and believed to be unable to respond to that type of action. It is very likely that Russia considers itself capable of maintaining its push in other areas along the front line, following the pattern there in recent months. The question is where is the Ukraine intel concerning Russian military movements and build up of forces. Of course that might be being held back as part of operational security concerns, but indications are strong that there ought to be some intel indicating how the Russian action is planned to develop. You cannot hide those types of movements very easily if at all. Russian convoys, traiins and redeployments of mustered assets, on the Russian side of the border would provide the necessary clues. We have to keep in mind that a large new crop of cannon fodder is either deployed or ready for deployment, and is likely to be bolstered by some additional utilization of some regular forces. Particularly in light of the recent changes at the Kremlin. We see a cluster of anti western hawks rising in power, increasing their control there. Expect some major moves in regards to the war. Russia is most probably going too escalate and intensify its military actions in its intent to subjugate all off Ukraine, with the intent to gain control and to maintain control under Soviet style rule.

  • @geraldmansfield2631
    @geraldmansfield2631 Před 21 dnem

    My guess is that North Korea would sell to both sides.

  • @roninrugby9480
    @roninrugby9480 Před 21 dnem

    Reminds me of Truman asking MacArthur to “bomb half a bridge” to keep the Chinese from sending troops into North Korea during the conflict. 🤦‍♂️

  • @kenpreston7978
    @kenpreston7978 Před 21 dnem

    Think of this scenario: My neighbor across the street is shooting at me. My next door neighbor gives me a gun, but says I can only use it if the neighbor across the street enters my property. Get real. What is the US afraid of? nukes? Future business with Russia?

  • @michaelwiwchar3414
    @michaelwiwchar3414 Před 21 dnem

    JP please be careful with the use of Colby Badwhar. I know I harp on you on this, and yes, while we all agree with his sentiment, he is not coming from a position of any honesty. I will say this again to you: you be canadian and support ukraine, however, you cannot be a canadian conservative and support Ukraine. I was hoping that your talk with Mark over the weekend would have made this clear to you, however, it seems to not have so I will continue to harp on you.
    All good with your work still but you have understand that Badwhar isn't for Ukraine no matter he tells you.