Does G-d Care If We Sin Or Not?
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 08. 2019
- Want to learn more? Book a Chassidic walking tour at www.JewishBrooklyn.nyc/
Visit 11213.org/ for Audio/Video of Rabbi Manis Friedman
Like: / 11213.org
Follow: / 11213org
Subscribe: / 11213org
Being born is not a Need or a want, it's a gift. Use it to the best of your ability and experience giving thanks for Life daily. Amen.
Thank you for the teachings!
Incredible. One of the very important as a basic of understanding ourselves.
The truth is that people should WANT to do Mitzvahs not because they expect the reward but because they want to please their Loving Father(Creator), because He created them for the purpose to give them the reward . So He really loved us first, so why shouldn't we love Him in return? I want to do as much as I can to show my love to G-d, I just wasn't taught properly how to do it. So if I am rejected by God because I didn't do Mitzvahs, it doesn't mean i will stop loving G-d, I'll just won't get a chance to be closer to Him. Doing Mitzvahs is exactly that: being closer to G-d. So i want to learn everything about how to get closer to my Creator.
Yeah I said that, but in shorter words, but you are absolutely right.
Hi it is me again. I wanted to thank you for the insight. Your speech brought me closer to Allah. Praise to the Lord. Elhamdoelilah irabi alamien
The only true human need: to know what we are needed for. My mind needs a reboot… blessed be G-d for eternity.
Thank you for this incredible talk.
Like, i was até minut 15 and thinkin to myself: wtf, this is seriously one of the realest idea i've ever seen about mitzvah, about the structural (fundamental) failure of religions, etc.
But then, he continues, and i'm not thinking anymore, i'm just feeling a glorious sensation that enhances my atention, my awareness, my perception of light and form.
Hakarat HaTov
Commenters who have expressed their rude opinion on the subject have missed the point and the general meaning of the discussion totally !
While iniquity abounds the love of many grow cold❄️
With all due respect, I firmly believe those of you knocking the text have a limited understanding of what the rabbi is trying to convey. Listen again. This may seem like a simple topic at face value, but his overall approach is quite interesting and carries weight.
but its not in english, so he selected his audience. i guess theres not much he wants dichotomised
Yes, if you think about the standard teachings of who and what Hashem is in Jewish thought, everything he says is correct. It seems so out of place now, the almost stand-alone idea that Hashem doesn't need anything. It comes from the idea that Hashem is perfect, but perhaps the understanding of perfection is off.
Perfection is intrinsically perfect. Consequently, hashem, can not need. He can, however, want. In our limited understanding of the divine, we must, unfortunately, make use of human terms and human language in its limited state to ascribe feelings to the divine in order to make sense of our place in creation.
@@franyk7071 I thought you listened to the shiur, but either you didn't or just completely disagree with him, which isn't how your first comment sounded. What you just said is verbatim the statement that he laboured at length to dispel with argument after argument and example after example, the one that is taught in yeshivos
I don’t necessarily agree with all of what he says, but am open to his understanding. In this reply I was merely echoing what most people hold. I hear what you’re saying, and tend to agree that we have a limited understanding of gd and gdly wants and needs.
Thank you
thanks rabbi
Most people have the gift of speech not conversation. Love you Rabbi
Excelent
What's with the pig grunting around 36:54? I can't figure out what that sound is, and its bothering me. Did somebody edit this and add that in, or is it some other environmental sound that I just can't identify?
@Rose Moore I still don't get it tho. Was it added in the editing for effect? Was it some kind of background noise that I'm misinterpreting?
Seems it was the Rabbi Burbing is all
Otherwise he's a beast dressed like
A human
It will someone working in the premises shoe maker or something
What exactly does eibushtar mean? Dankeschön
G-d
Can someone translate the parts from Hebrew?
Beautiful but I still didn't understand the meaning of בעל מלאכתך in regards to Haschem. .
he was saying that it is silly to speak about HaShem as if He is not real. HaShem really is the baal of your actions, and He will reward you.
What is moshel or moshul and what is nimshel or nimshul??
Parable
Thank you very much, quite enlightening.
Please DO NOT listen to him. He is a HERETIC-KOFER! He makes up stuff that is TOTALLY opposite of what the Torah really says!
Mazel tov to rabbi manis Friedman fine spiritual lectures I am big fan of rabbi manis Friedman being a sefardi mashadi pakistani Jew all I can say is that the ashkanazi chassidec rabbi are masters when it comes to Torah Talmud Zohar knowledge well done our chacham rabbi rov rav sages LOVE you ALL may hashem bless you all amen thanks Shahbaz gondal queens America
So, should we thank him for the food (which he needs)? If we thank him, we are taking his credit of needing to eat. Thank you for giving me this food which I couldnt survive without it - but what for I shall survive? for making the Melacha he wants me to do in this World.. dont want to be a Chutzpan, but my Havane is not just that we do not have to thank, but even we should not thank!
What you say? Hope I am clear here..
We bless him. And I think it's in response to the pleasure he gives us. Even if we don't need it - it's still gives us pleasure. But on a deeper level it does more for him
By God having wants God created all these problems for itself not the creation We did not want to be created so how can we be responsible All are desires come from God Everything is genetically passed down by the 1 that wanted creation God Who is the creator Who created mind thought Feelings emotions choice Wants We cannot make up wants we are not the creator We cannot even create sin That's because we cannot create we can imitate things that's about it All that we are is what is with in our design we only can be what we are made like by God.
Did YHVH speak to Moses and Israel at Mt. Sinai?
Excellent video! I wish I spoke Hebrew.
sir on 1st September my & his next monthly donation will be made
Yes! I am convinced He does care!
Of course Hashem cares! Otherwise punishment will not be mentioned in the Torah!!
This man thinks we are ignorants!
That is why I like this video because it makes sense does god really care that we sin
It is written, "Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams.”
How can one claim obedience belongs to those distant from the Creator, so we do mitzvahs, when we are told, obedience is better than sacrifice?
What do we seek ? Love from God!...God exists! I dont exists and cry to God to exists!
Wow
What does abushtah mean???? I don't even think I spelled it correctly
God
@@marcselfani306 is there an etymology?
It's eibishter. The One Above.
@@surikatz123 thank you sooo much !!!
God in Yiddish
This is something people do not understand we cannot create our own carelessness therefore we are not the creators so how is it possible For us to create even something as sin We cannot create sin we are not the creator We cannot even create choice or our own mind or our own thoughts we are not the programmer of creation we are not the designer how can we be responsible?
His ways are OUR ways.
You're so right I'm not content being a human I don't even know why I'm human why am I needed that's another thing too why am I needed why am I here I agree with all this plus I don't even like being a human Why do I need to be human
38:00 - He needs you more than you need him. Powerful.
a powerful lie and a powerful blasphemy against God. God needs nothing we need Him totally.
@@marcokite fly a kite...ur dumb
anonymous anonymous - Have a good life
So God needs others to be holy, to join Him in His need to be holy. Because needing to eat is not a need but a handicap. Whereas God who can choose He does not need anything, nor does He have handicaps. So if He commands you, therein lies His need, because being free neverthless still felt the need to command you to be holy, as He is holy. His need is truth, justice, mercy, kindness, love, laws, order, self control, patience, discipline, goodness, piety, devotion to right doing et cetera. God is obsessed with being Holy, He needs you to be holy, because he needs others to be holy, so He's not alone in doing holiness.
If God needs us more than we need Him.....couldn't we negotiate a better deal?
Rabbi Manis, thank you for this post. G-d is love. I don’t love Him because He is love. I love Him because I am His creation, and He loves me because I am His creation. You said my King would take a bullet for me. What is the bullet? The bullet is death which Adam and Eve brought into this world by means of their sin - i.e. their choice to disobey. G-d had to kick them out of the Garden of Eden as they couldn’t remain in His holy Presence anymore being sinful now. From that moment on, humanity became forever separated from G-d. What does my King do to solve this problem of eternal separation? You said it! He comes down to earth to assume my place and take the bullet for me. But the most brilliant part is that by taking the bullet, He Himself does not remain dead, but rose again and lives forever. He is the High Priest Who has made atonement for Adam’s original sin as well as all of humanity’s sin. But just like Adam chose to disobey G-d’s commandment, we have to choose to accept His atoning sacrifice to live and be united with G-d again. How magnificent are G-d’s ways! Peace and grace to you from our G-d the Creator of the Universe.
Sounds immoral to accept the murder of an innocent for your reward.
A science teacher in KC explained that we’re living in a virtual reality. If you think about it, take a cell - if the nucleus was the size of a marble that you place on the 50 yard line of the KC Chiefs stadium, the electrons would be on the outer edge of the stadium. There is so much space in our cells and in ourselves.
We cannot even create the knowledge of good and evil therefore By God Creating the knowledge of good and evil God' created the problem for itself By God Creating the knowledge of evil God created sin By God Creating curiosity that's what started it We cannot even create Disobedience The way we think is all from God & God gave us choice Therefore God allows us to be The sinners that we are
☺😊😄😃😂😁😀.......👏👏👏👏👏👏........
We cannot even create our own carelessness so does god really care if we sin
It's wrong to say that God needs because God doesn't need, it should be rephrased as a saying that God wants [meaning that is his will]
God needs us and we do not need him please let me understand
שנה טובה
He is misleading ppl
The plastic arm is real too. Then it's "well, the real arm has hair and skin and sub tissues." "The plastic arm has tissues too." "Yeah, plastic tissue." maybe counter back and forth.
People are complaining that God doesn't have needs God has wants Why does God want us We humans are not the 1 that wanted to be created so Gods wants are the problem We would not have Wants But because God has wants that's the problem We would not have the desires that we do like sins If God didn't have Wants God Wants are the problem we are not the problem that's why God is responsible For everything instead of us Because God's the 1 That created life not us We are not capable of being the creator so how could we have created sin Understand why God takes on all the responsibility for us Because We are not the creator who Made everything Like God Who has wants If God didn't have Wants Sin would not have existed God created all things that sin Therefore God Created the problem For having wants All things come from God therefore God is Sinful Sadly We Are not the creator so how can we create sin we are not the Creator of wants All things that are with in our design are from God therefore we cannot create sin That is a part of our design from God We have to understand God has a Disability And is sick and sickness Only can Be genetically passed down from God The reason why people have disabilities is because God is Disabled so it's a part of are design because God is disabled Disabilities are Something that comes from God It's a genetic flaw We have and only can be genetically Passed down from God who is The 1 who wants to create everything We are not Responsible of God's wants and God's creation We are not the creator we are not the 1 who wanted God did.
Why were the nations created through blood?
Abel Chavez the blood is the nefesh. It was on parashat hashavua REA
That doesn't explain all the blood bath that G-d has allowed ...is there any chance or coincidence or maybe that the Torah is signifying or revealing or implying that G-d is a serpent , a being with Good and evil both ..as if Judaism is complaining to God perhaps?
I think that If one forget self(GOD- like), he (she) fall to sin. It is divine plan. If one come to sanity, he(she) rejoice.
The Bible says He created everything perfectly at the beginning. How come He created everything perfectly in the lowest world? It seems human beings have made the world a worse place where less and less people know about G-d.
"Remember that even when those who move you be Kings, or men of power, your soul is in your keeping alone, When you stand before God, you cannot say, "But I was told by others to do thus." Or that, "Virtue was not convenient at the time." This will not suffice" --The King of Jerusalem.
I like this quote.
you do it because it makes you feel good somehow, someway. It's that feeling you get when you give from your heart. But what do I know? I snore.
I went to church my entire life , many many churches and I have never heard something as eye opening as this , don’t do the commandments for the reward
You should do the Mitzvah because you love Hashem.
Doesn't matter if you love Him. You do the mitzvah because He wants us to.
Creating joy, beauty and harmony with the "magic" of love comes from good/ god. Sucking the joy, beauty and harmony (heaven) out of life with absence of good/god (greed)... to create misery, ugliness and conflict (hell) is just plain evil.
Those four constellations of Hades/Shem/Vishnu were lead by the bad ole Scorpion/Scorpo.
In 29:30 when the rabbi mentioned we are created in "his image". He unconsciencly mentioned Yahshua Hamashiach.
ellenfrancis67 i will, first of all God the Holy spirit or ruasch hakodesh does not have a body its like the spirit in our bodies and we our bodies are the image of the spirit inside us. Same thing with God, Yahshua Hamashiach is the image of Yahweh.
ellenfrancis67 its not a ridiculous statement. You are just clouded that you cant see thru the message. An image is the body or physical manifestation of something.
ellenfrancis67 for example, the image of my invisible soul is my physical body. Just so you can understand.
All the world will be filled with knowledge of G-d like water covers the sea!!
G-d is so good!!!!!!!
Humiliating Pooping and peeing is worse why do I need to do that Why do I need to have body odor why do I need to stink Why do I need to have a body that's so disgusting Why does God need me to be like this Why does god need all these things I don't need them Why does God need this Why does god like these things And need them to like Why does god need me to be a Why does god need no permission from me Why does God need me just because God Can create why does God need humans when Angels God has Why does God need laws
Godly man.
Of course it hurts G-d
We have free will...= eating of the forbidden trees fruits
Not agree about obey. God give us life to learn to obey our parent. At first in the childhood usually kid obey their parents out of fear. Because kids are dependent on them. But over time when we grow up we obey our parent because of love and respect(leveticus 19:3). Just like our life. We all are a child in this world. God want us to obey him because of love not fear. And that is true love. Because people usually dont realise the gift from god which is our life. People think why should i obey this god i did not get anything from him? People forget about the gift of life.
If Judaism is NOT a religion, why be observant?
Following rules as a child is not a religion.. so why do it? Because it's the right thing to do.
Judaism is the Only Religion that was handed by G-d directly to the people at Mt Sinai a the same time.
In all fairness, muslim conception of God is Allah is rahman and raheem. Compassionate and merciful. Allah is Ahad. One, unique. None can be compared to Him. Allahu Samad. Ever-living, while all depend on Him for refuge. Allah is kareem. Generous. Al ghafur, forgiving. And Shia do not believe God has any eyes or physical body, or any place. I mention because he diluted tawheed to god is powerful.
But there are some common themes between us, we believe this physical body is only for dunya. Then in barzakh, which is similar to the dream world, our soul takes on a different kind of body that matches the physics of that world. Then after we are resurrected, our soul returns to our bodies in akhira. To be in this kind of gan edem as he says
can a blind man lead a blind man,do not both fall into the hole. luke: 3:39
Without putting your frying pan on fire, you can't be friedman.
without doing all your studying the day before the exam, you can't call it Akram
When real fasting soul release and voices might say: what for your body and flesh created, do you have your own flesh and blood families friends and neighbor. Real fasting can release soul it worthy than your own body and flesh that's why real fasting to release it, if you say it will take long time but how we can still older, cannot older if not yet born, if born you are to way baby than us even try to older than us. GOD WORDS says: I will let those older become younger than the younger and younger become older. When you born baby close to me, you might see you are older or just born baby than me.
What are Mitzvas?
Good deeds
On trouve la même vision chez les "soufi" musulmans
I'm confused.... can you not write out the word God on CZcams now!!!!!!!
The rabbi is contracdicting the scriptures in a few things
Please point these contradictions out? Thank you!
Absolutely!!! He is a philosopher!!
Yeah! He is talking about different Torah
If God "does not care" whether we sin or not, then why The Torah? Why the laws of Moses? By saying that God does not care whether we sin or not only comforts the mind of an immoral man, but certainly does not go according to the will of God. For this "rabbi" to even question such an obvious answer is to dwell in his own ignorance..
Understand that calling yourself a rabbi does not necessarily make you one, at least not before God.
Dear Hernandez, I don't think you understand the Rabbi of that you speak of so unkindly, answers many question put to Him by Children, and adolescents, It would not be wrongful to ignore a question asked in innocence.
Wow!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏I love to read intelligent comments!!
This man has a custom he is not a real rabbi! Pure chillul Hashem !!
GOD, really exists,..do we realy exists? Compared to God, we are nothing, so who and what we do really doesnt mean anything,...yet God is the creator, and we are created from God, so do we exist? Nope we still are nothing yet we are only something if God decides we are someone, ... a person really exists because God God saids he exists, adam and eve exists because of God, all others did not exist....
I have seen most of his videos, he just ask too many questions himself,questions r secular ,like God is not an authentic thing,his answer end up with no conclusion n then in the end he would but Jewish God is real,good way to lure people but not logical
G.d is never a loser , the way the world is today is our responsibility
Do you know or remember what you have been thru,before this life? Do you even believe that you are in a cycle of birth and death? When you believe this, you will find answers.😜
Spirit looks the same as flesh. Spirit flesh. Spirit bodies.
To bring the elvish to the world. This is your idea right? How about his idea? It sounds like you are just like him.
39:36 "he can't stop the attack, but he can die first; he can take the first bullet"
Y'shua?
My friend, you are the classic Christian taking 1 line out of an hour lecture and using it to fit your belief system. Listen to the rest of the lecture and the entire theology in essence contradicts that if christianity. God bless you
@@user-xu1uf3xr2c idiotic
This guy is all over the place. Never answers any questions. Drivel.
@katica bajic It's called bullshit.
The ultimate punishment for impiety is impiety :)
A typical circular logic..No concrete statements just a double talk..
if He didn't create the universe then he is not God. also the rabbi misses the point; God being love and powerful IS what He is like. calling God a 'loser' is blasphemy in any religion. what a truly dreadful talk.
You missed the point
Not in the sense of what we call a loser. The more powerful someone is the more vulnerable he can be. God is all powerful and being a loser doesn't diminish his greatness. It just means that he loses out.
When we as humans beings hurt each other - god loses. It gives him much pain and loss. But it doesn't diminish his greatness.
Thank you