Super Mario World Bootlegs & Homebrews|Which is Best?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 29. 06. 2024
  • Let's compare a few SMW bootlegs/homebrews on retro systems like MSX2, NES, Mega Drive/Genesis and see which one has the best Graphics, Gameplay, Sprites, Music.
    Which one do you think is best?
    ⭐Support the channel, become a Member & get amazing Perks.
    / @retromantra
    Please Don't forget to LIKE-SHARE-SUBSCRIBE if you enjoy the video and leave your comments. Subscribe to my channel to help it grow and stay connected for more videos, cheers!
    ⭐Get it here⭐
    drive.google.com/drive/folder...
    #mario #supermario #retrogaming
    Have you seen the Every Super Mario game INTRO 1985-2021 video
    👉 • All Super Mario Game I...
    Have you seen Mario Clones MEGA Collection Vol.1
    👉 • Super Mario Bootlegs &...
    Have you seen the Super Mario Bros. NEON Edition video
    👉 • Super Mario Bros.(1985...
    Have you see the Jumpman Fights Mario & The Nintendo All-Stars?!|Famicom Fighters|MUGEN
    👉 • Jumpman Fights Mario &...
    Have you seen the Which is the Best Super Mario Land (1989) Remake/Remaster|Fan-Made video
    👉 • Which is the Best Supe...
    Have you seen the Which is the Best Super Mario Bros. (1985) NES Fan-Made Remaster|HD
    👉 • Which is the Best Supe...
    check out Super Mario Bros. Clones, Funny & Amazing Vol.1 video
    👉 • Super Mario Bros. Clon...
    check out Super Mario Bros. Clones, Funny & Amazing Vol.2 video
    👉 • Super Mario Bros. Clon...
    check out Super Mario Bros. Clones, Funny & Amazing Vol.3 video
    👉 • Super Mario Bros. Clon...
    check out Super Mario Bros.2 Funny Clones video
    👉 • Super Mario Bros.2 NES...
    check out the complete Mario Mania playlist for Mario games comparison videos
    👉 • Super Mario Bros. Clon...
    check out the PAC-LAND versions comparison video
    👉 • 🏡🧚‍♀️PAC-LAND🏡🧚‍♀️ Ver...
    check out 50 versions of GALAGA, ultimate comparison video, clones, hacks included
    👉 • 🚀GALAGA🚀40th Anniversa...
    Check out the PAC-MANIA versions comparison video
    👉 • Pac-Mania Versions/Por...
    check out the 70 Versions of Ms. Pac-Man, clones and hacks included video
    👉 • Ms. Pac-Man 70 Ports/C...
    check out 70 versions of Pac-man. Ultimate ports comparison video
    👉 • PAC-MAN Versions Compa...
    Check out 40 Clones of Pac-Man, Feat. Among Us hack. Ultimate ports comparison video
    👉 • PAC-MAN Clones/Hacks M...
    Check out the Mr. Do! game versions comparison video
    👉 • 🤡Mr. Do!🤡(1982) Versio...
    check out the Frogger (1981) game versions comparison video
    👉 • Frogger (1981) Version...
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Time Stamps
    00:00 NES [Hummer Team]
    04:44 NES [Remastered]
    This is double patched rom, 1st is an improvement patch by: the jabu and the 2nd is the New block graphic patch by: capnkatie
    08:41 MSX2[Homebrew by Noramos]
    13:23 Mega Drive/Genesis [Bootleg/Unlicensed]
  • Hry

Komentáře • 175

  • @Retromantra
    @Retromantra  Před 2 lety +90

    00:00 Intro
    00:08 NES [Hummer Team]
    04:44 NES [Remastered]
    08:41 MSX2[Homebrew by Noramos]
    13:23 Mega Drive/Genesis [Bootleg/Unlicensed]

  • @NonbinaryFelineArtist
    @NonbinaryFelineArtist Před 2 lety +210

    Nintendo: “Yeah makin’ a funny rideable creature thing isn’t possible, the poor NES can’t do it!”
    Bootleggers: “Are you sure about that?”
    Let’s be honest, this is one of the few times where bootleggers have disproven a well-known game developer.

    • @bumparchive
      @bumparchive Před 2 lety +31

      In 1985 for SMB1 yeah it may not have been possible to have a dinosaur due to smaller cartridge space and less knowledge on the NES Hardware overall. The bootleg came out in 1995, well after the NES has seen some advanced looking games for the platform.

    • @seamistseamist
      @seamistseamist Před 2 lety +11

      @@bumparchive The 1995 thing reminds me that that was how long it took for mainline mega man to come out on the snes the same year as the playstation released (december in japan but still) then after the ps1 game they just go back to making ones that look like nes games again

    • @johneygd
      @johneygd Před 2 lety +8

      While supermarioworld was meant to demonstrate the power of the snes,BUT then bootleggers come with their port of it to the nes to demonstrate the power of their own costumized mapper chip and nes system, and it does amezingly well as the graphics come close to that of the snes version along with detailed & colorful graphics and beind ridible on yoshi as well, now just imagine if this bootlef version just came out in 1991, the nes may would ,ve fly off store shelves as well because if people could efford a snes but still wanted to play that game they could,ve just still bought a nes along with this bootleg,also because it squeezes every megabyte of power out of the nes as well😁

    • @underthetreeproductionsOffical
    • @0DRONZER
      @0DRONZER Před 2 lety +3

      omg i found big text abstract cat guy from marionova server yo (im the lego eater btw)

  • @Itsscottstudios
    @Itsscottstudios Před 2 lety +92

    The NES one is impressive, but doesn’t look so good
    The remastered is basically a refined, better looking version of the original bootleg game
    The MSX is the best one
    And the Genesis version looks most similar to the original

    • @UNKNOWN-zf9yq
      @UNKNOWN-zf9yq Před 2 lety +4

      But the genesis with bad sound effects and bad gameplay like Mario being slow.

    • @Patrick19833
      @Patrick19833 Před 2 lety +1

      @@UNKNOWN-zf9yq That is surprising because Genesis has a faster CPU. I would figure it would play faster than the SNES version because of a faster CPU.

    • @BurnedNoodle
      @BurnedNoodle Před 2 lety +1

      @@Patrick19833 probably the mechanics are just straight up dogshit.

    • @AbbeyYard
      @AbbeyYard Před rokem +1

      @@UNKNOWN-zf9yq and bad music, and no world map?

    • @Joamori1054
      @Joamori1054 Před rokem +2

      I think the remaster nes version should fix some mechanics like make the running speed be not too faster, but also reduce the animations frames to not have limited space and also better performance

  • @FormulaFanboy
    @FormulaFanboy Před 2 lety +27

    Hey, I'm pretty sure I was one of the contributors to the hack shown at 4:44!! Specifically I made the logo on the title screen have the appropriate colours. The guy before me was the one who made the blocks look more accurate, and before that was just the hack by TheJabuu (spelling that from memory so it might be wrong). Super cool to see it featured here! :D

  • @BalancedSpirit79
    @BalancedSpirit79 Před 2 lety +75

    MSX is the most authentic hands down.

    • @ptanker9236
      @ptanker9236 Před 2 lety +13

      Exactly.
      the MSX music feels like heaven to the ears after hearing the dreadful NES version for 8 minutes. (The “Remaster” didn’t even bother to improve the music, godddamn.)

    • @pedrohenriquealvarescabral1520
      @pedrohenriquealvarescabral1520 Před 2 lety

      HELLO. AIMEE. Pedro Henrique. I LOLVI. IU. ITS GOLT BUE SKINSL

    • @ThatOneHuman125k
      @ThatOneHuman125k Před 2 lety

      Excluding the banzai bill, those things were zoomin

    • @Dumbassery2010
      @Dumbassery2010 Před 2 lety

      no snes is the most authentic

    • @BalancedSpirit79
      @BalancedSpirit79 Před 2 lety

      @@Dumbassery2010 *ba-dum chhhh*

  • @wagnerramosmidichannelabso514

    MSX is the best port, and the melody is perfect.

  • @EpicGamer_SansheeFreddy
    @EpicGamer_SansheeFreddy Před 2 lety +16

    I like how the NES one uses the Forest of Illusion theme for the forest levels. And it’s lazy that they used Mario’s Mario 3 sprites when he has a mushroom.

  • @cyrusfire
    @cyrusfire Před 2 lety +7

    Super Mario World on the Mega Drive/Genesis got some goofy ahh sounds 💀

  • @thediegobowlerchannel5690

    i really like the msx one

  • @badenl3057
    @badenl3057 Před rokem +4

    MSX2 version is way better than the other bootleg versions. Not better than the original video game, but A+ for effort

  • @EpicGamer_SansheeFreddy
    @EpicGamer_SansheeFreddy Před 2 lety +7

    The NES remaster. Is it better graphics-wise? Yes. It looks like they didn’t re-use Mario 3 sprites for big and fire flower Mario. And the title letters are fully colored. And everything looks partially better. Is it better music-wise? No. It isn’t. And for the original and remastered nes version, *why* did they use three lava bubbles that look like an arrow point for the Banzai Bills?
    The MSX version. It’s better than the first two versions in both accuracy, graphics, sounds, and music. The story is even somewhat on-point with the original one.

  • @plantman2387
    @plantman2387 Před 2 lety +8

    Msx is the best version. It has the best music out of all the bootlegs, the graphics are good, and the controls look really solid. Also is it just me or does the music sound better in this version than in the original?

  • @fco64
    @fco64 Před 2 lety +16

    There are almost zero videos showing the msx version for some reason

  • @inceptional
    @inceptional Před 2 lety +30

    Kinda crazy how close they can all get, especially even the likes of the NES. Of course, outside of a few little visual tricks here and there, Super Mario World isn't exactly pushing the SNES to its limits--even as arguably best platform game ever brilliant as it is.

    • @ptanker9236
      @ptanker9236 Před 2 lety +5

      I mean, it was a really early SNES game. (1990)
      And the MSX music feels like heaven to the ears after hearing the dreadful NES version for 8 minutes. (The “Remaster” didn’t even bother to improve the music, godddamn.)

    • @JamesIsNotHere.
      @JamesIsNotHere. Před rokem

      @@ptanker9236 because it's pretty hard to change the music

    • @ptanker9236
      @ptanker9236 Před rokem

      @@JamesIsNotHere. bro replied to a year old comment 💀

    • @JamesIsNotHere.
      @JamesIsNotHere. Před rokem

      @@ptanker9236 look nobody's perfect okay?

  • @TheRafaelRamos
    @TheRafaelRamos Před 2 lety +15

    MSX and Genesis look pretty good!

    • @merluzacongelada5361
      @merluzacongelada5361 Před 2 lety +3

      Megadrive looks almost like the original but the gameplay itself is the worst of the bunch imo. Most playable is MSX, then Nes remastered. Kind of a shame there's almost no decent Mario bootlegs on Sega consoles tbh. Master System had Super Boy IV and that's about it.

  • @thomasverslycken2563
    @thomasverslycken2563 Před 2 lety +6

    To be honest, the best smw bootleg is either the NES remaster or the MSX version imo

  • @mischiefthedegenerateratto7464

    I appreciate you putting these games in the description! Now it's time for me to torture my vita with a few of these lol

  • @mediocre.leader
    @mediocre.leader Před 2 lety +3

    The Genesis port sounds like a flash game

  • @nhacamaster
    @nhacamaster Před rokem +3

    That Genesis homebrew is simple horrible in contrast with the superb MSX2 Hebrew.

  • @fernandomenendezsalvador3972

    Msx es una versión maravillosa,dinámica,bonita y fiel a la original...me parece extraordinaria..la mejor.

  • @turbomario
    @turbomario Před 2 lety +4

    I’ve played all of these in the past and i can confirm that the MSX version is the best one

  • @EdKolis
    @EdKolis Před 2 lety +8

    I like how when Mario is invincible on the NES, the music switches to Bowser's castle...

  • @ZERARCHIVE2023
    @ZERARCHIVE2023 Před rokem +2

    Porting SMW on the NES is already an achievement and is the best by far

  • @herrflantier3739
    @herrflantier3739 Před 2 lety +15

    MSX version is pretty impressive!

  • @inceptional
    @inceptional Před 2 lety +5

    Hey, do a similar video with all the bootlegs of Sonic, including that recent SNES version of Sonic that almost looks and sounds and runs identically. :D

  • @GamerAlexYT
    @GamerAlexYT Před rokem +3

    Why is MSX accurate?! All who give respect to the creators, put a thumbs up

  • @nickname_on8725
    @nickname_on8725 Před rokem +3

    I know the bootleg SMW for the NES is bad, but it is by far one of the best bootlegs ever made, which isn't a lot, but is already impressive. If you removed the horrible music and the slow jumps I think it could be considered a good demake.

  • @silveradoz4721
    @silveradoz4721 Před 2 lety +5

    MSX2 sounds the best.

  • @gooolixx
    @gooolixx Před rokem +1

    i used to play the nes one when i was a kid, i never realised it was a bootleg.

  • @staspastukh2005
    @staspastukh2005 Před rokem

    Thanks!

  • @MrJorge-qt9mv
    @MrJorge-qt9mv Před 2 lety +4

    Nes and msx Port has excelent ❤️

  • @HimuGamer
    @HimuGamer Před 2 lety

    Nice try for all of them 👏👏. I will back to my SNES version

  • @I_Love_Om_Nom34.
    @I_Love_Om_Nom34. Před měsícem

    13:22 This actually looks good for a game. It even sounds for a very good game.

  • @CAT12121
    @CAT12121 Před 2 lety

    The 8-bit star man song sounds like someone punching a bed rapidly

  • @kazuyasuwaki2163
    @kazuyasuwaki2163 Před 2 lety +3

    I dont know if is it only me who has the opinion, but the version of NES sounds more like a CreepyPasta

  • @sethhorst6158
    @sethhorst6158 Před 8 měsíci

    Mario has the most goofy ahh jumping sound in the Sega Mega Drive/Genesis bootleg! xD

  • @NatetheNintendofan
    @NatetheNintendofan Před 2 lety

    Nice

  • @panzervpanther933
    @panzervpanther933 Před rokem

    Cool

  • @reneomarsantana5977
    @reneomarsantana5977 Před 2 lety +5

    MSX is very Good

  • @imdumb2024
    @imdumb2024 Před 2 lety +3

    The MSX is best

  • @willthewindmill6024
    @willthewindmill6024 Před 2 lety +1

    Yeah sure, Super Mario World CAN run on an NES- But it’s not the type of thing I’m trusting if I saw it in a back alley one day.

  • @Supergamer_SMM2
    @Supergamer_SMM2 Před 2 lety +1

    Whenever I played SMW for the NES when Mario ran he ran super speed 😳

  • @sonicphoenix7
    @sonicphoenix7 Před 8 měsíci

    msx’s hardware is honestly really interesting i wanna see it get more attention

  • @elrincondelukas
    @elrincondelukas Před 2 lety

    I suscribe your channel. LIKE

  • @dededethesuperstarwarrior

    nice lol

  • @Darkheart_.
    @Darkheart_. Před 2 lety

    I must say these people are great job trying to port smbw in nes msx and genesis

  • @RonZhang
    @RonZhang Před rokem

    For a NES game, that Super Mario World game looks pretty good for my standards

  • @Sparasemi456
    @Sparasemi456 Před 2 lety +1

    Smw msx soundtrack looks like a genesis one

  • @AnWindows7User
    @AnWindows7User Před rokem +1

    MSX 2: missing life time coin counter

    • @Retromantra
      @Retromantra  Před rokem

      It's there 09:40
      It's designed to hide after few seconds.

  • @furybolt1474
    @furybolt1474 Před 2 lety

    The first one actually was mainly the mario character in a style from Super Mario Bros 3..

  • @NatetheNintendofan
    @NatetheNintendofan Před 2 lety +1

    I love Homebrew I love homebrewing my video game consoles

  • @CAT12121
    @CAT12121 Před 2 lety

    Ngl but the 8-bit one (normal) is impressive making a 16-bit game with 8-bit graphics

  • @RetroGaming-gp2ef
    @RetroGaming-gp2ef Před 2 lety +1

    The NES version has to be the weirdest. I mean couldn’t they just have used to graphics from Mario is Missing/Mario’s Time Machine? Also the MSX2 version reminds me of the cancelled Mario game, Super Mario’s Wacky World’s.

  • @DreaDreamzTV
    @DreaDreamzTV Před rokem +1

    hummer team and msx2 is my fav

  • @ZERARCHIVE2023
    @ZERARCHIVE2023 Před rokem

    OMG they succeeded ?? They succeeded at including Yoshi in Super Mario World ????
    I'm amazed

  • @silveradoz4721
    @silveradoz4721 Před 2 lety +1

    Why does the Mega Drive/Genesis have the Super Mario All-Stars title image but recolored?

    • @Retromantra
      @Retromantra  Před 2 lety +1

      It's a bootleg game bro, anything is possible 😂
      Check out my Super Mario Nes hacks video, you will be shocked
      Super Mario NES Hacks MEGA Collection Vol.2|HD|#Mario #Multiverse
      czcams.com/video/ID-UonLJc6I/video.html

    • @zitherq5761
      @zitherq5761 Před rokem

      I think I know why. The Sega mega drive/genesis has fewer colors compared to the Super Nintendo.
      Sega = 4 palletes use 15 colors each, that equals 60, plus the background color, 61 colors. These color palletes seem to share with sprites and background graphics all together.
      Super Nintendo =
      Roughly 240 to 255 usually.
      Upon first look i notice that the Goomba is blue. I think this may be because color is low, color got reused. It looks like the blue is shared with Mario and Luigi's overalls.
      Also I noticed the floor. Using green which looks like Luigi uses. There's other things I might be able to speculate on also lol but I hope what I said sheds some light on to that lol. I'm quite interested in stuff like this lol

  • @LexanderXyX
    @LexanderXyX Před 2 lety +1

    I only have 2 super mario world, it nintendo Entertainment and nintendo MSX

  • @TariqYasiinProd
    @TariqYasiinProd Před rokem +2

    MSX was impressive

  • @spleefian
    @spleefian Před 2 lety

    You should include the fanmade Super Mario World DX for DOS.

    • @Retromantra
      @Retromantra  Před 2 lety +2

      I will make a new video on it in future.

  • @adamthechipsmaster8086

    All of them

  • @kilgincedi
    @kilgincedi Před rokem

    Lets wait to someone to make a good copy of super mario to sega genesis

  • @MYLENOfficial
    @MYLENOfficial Před 2 lety +1

    NES & MSX.

  • @DjulianSMG5LeVrai
    @DjulianSMG5LeVrai Před 2 lety +3

    Ok

  • @gameboyadvance45
    @gameboyadvance45 Před 2 lety +2

    Msx is the best

  • @TheBayerRepublic
    @TheBayerRepublic Před rokem

    yoshi is now kirby

  • @nathansantiago3177
    @nathansantiago3177 Před rokem

    I think the NES Game style is amazing

  • @impossiblestudios77
    @impossiblestudios77 Před rokem

    I have no clue why the sounds in the mega drive/genesis are so weird. Like, I’m sure there is some sort of way to make the sounds more authentic.

  • @luisllanos5047
    @luisllanos5047 Před rokem +1

    EL MEJOR DE LOS 4 SON TODOS🗺️🗺️🗺️🗺️

  • @3nzocarter11
    @3nzocarter11 Před rokem

    1:18 Mario looks like super Mario bros 3 mario

  • @magda7948
    @magda7948 Před rokem +1

    00:08 nes hummer team

  • @chumstinks
    @chumstinks Před 2 lety

    Nes hummer teams forest of illusion star man was a banger

  • @Haterofgreenscreenkids
    @Haterofgreenscreenkids Před 4 měsíci

    Snes and gba was the goat !

  • @Gzxlim.
    @Gzxlim. Před 2 lety

    2025: super mario world bootleg on the nokia

  • @kuma3728
    @kuma3728 Před rokem

    msx version kinda reminds me of the one released on gba

  • @Itz_kingzin
    @Itz_kingzin Před 2 lety +2

    I think mega drive got better especially the graphics

  • @Patrick19833
    @Patrick19833 Před 2 lety +1

    Is it just me or does the MSX bootleg has much better sound than the official SNES version?

    • @mischiefthedegenerateratto7464
      @mischiefthedegenerateratto7464 Před 2 lety

      It's not a bootleg it's a homebrew

    • @Patrick19833
      @Patrick19833 Před 2 lety

      @@mischiefthedegenerateratto7464 Homebrew to me is brand new game with original levels and story. However they pretty much just ported over SMW to MSX. That to me is a bootleg.

    • @mischiefthedegenerateratto7464
      @mischiefthedegenerateratto7464 Před 2 lety

      @@Patrick19833 it's not a bootleg... A bootleg is made with the intention of making money this port wasn't, also most homebrew out there are ports...

  • @EdKolis
    @EdKolis Před 2 lety +1

    Was that a poison mushroom at the end?

  • @k-coolrgs9578
    @k-coolrgs9578 Před 2 měsíci

    How does the Master System version sound better than the Mega Drive? It's not as Powerful?

  • @supermarioman64
    @supermarioman64 Před rokem

    Cosas que solo los piratas y softwers and tolwork lograron hacer
    Poner a yoshi y montarlo en Nintendo nes

  • @thomaspercyandjamestrackma7831

    I own this version but deleted it from my app store and it's gone for good and it's the Hummer team version

  • @jadentejada5202
    @jadentejada5202 Před rokem

    Super Mario World NES Remastered would be a good sample of just a bit of what super mario world is like. Try giving it to a friend who's hesitant because it's "Too old". Just specify that it was originally an snes title, and that the snes version will be WAY better.
    Yeah, the Hummer Team's is garbage.

  • @protocetid
    @protocetid Před 2 lety

    how I wish fans would port SMW to the Genesis/MD they’d do a better job

    • @665guest
      @665guest Před 2 lety

      Someone already ported some levels to genesis, but with a lot of weird sound effects. Not the best work but still good

    • @protocetid
      @protocetid Před 2 lety

      @@665guest got a link? if it’s outside of CZcams it might get shadowbanned

    • @665guest
      @665guest Před 2 lety

      As i know this is for Sega genesis/mega drive

    • @protocetid
      @protocetid Před 2 lety

      @@665guest all I came across while searching was another bootleg

  • @Lilemy_
    @Lilemy_ Před 2 lety +2

    Msx

  • @Paracetamol985
    @Paracetamol985 Před 2 lety

    i hate how accurate the msx sounds are

  • @haroldwyaat
    @haroldwyaat Před rokem +2

    1: msx
    2: nes remastered
    3: nes hummer
    4: sega

    • @haroldwyaat
      @haroldwyaat Před rokem

      i don't know how i described the ranking

  • @mauriciominicuci6544
    @mauriciominicuci6544 Před rokem

    Clash
    Like

  • @marccornea536
    @marccornea536 Před 2 lety

    Fun fact: i have that bootleg or rip off on my android

  • @ZERARCHIVE2023
    @ZERARCHIVE2023 Před rokem

    Megadrive argument to be sold : DONT PLAY THAT SLOW SS PLUMBER, PLAY SONIC. BE AS FAST AS A FART
    Mario : i'm aliiiive luigi, l'm boooorn

  • @pawer_themaw
    @pawer_themaw Před 2 lety +1

    Heheheheh technical limitations, Nintendo? A full fledged SMW is on the NES, with EVERYTHING you need

    • @sc1843
      @sc1843 Před 2 lety

      Actually I've played the nes version to completion, it isn't the ENTIRE game, but it's enough to be pretty fun while it lasts

  • @RacingPoint-io8yk
    @RacingPoint-io8yk Před rokem +1

    Best : MSX Version , worst : Genesis version ( genesis can do it lot better )

  • @jordiortega-bb8uz
    @jordiortega-bb8uz Před rokem

    MSX ❤

  • @yolandazamorahernandez3234

    Sega i love

  • @DexterHill2013
    @DexterHill2013 Před rokem +1

    The genesis is not Nintendo is SEGA!

  • @mariounikittypuppyconlilpe2735

    Super Mario would nes

  • @lukexadrez
    @lukexadrez Před 2 lety

    Super Mario World for NES it´s so copy of Mario, but they forgotten to copy the goodness of game.

  • @nintendo_adventure_offical

    What about SNES

    • @sethhorst6158
      @sethhorst6158 Před 8 měsíci +1

      The video is about bootleg and homebrew versions, not the original SNES version.

  • @Kytk7
    @Kytk7 Před 11 měsíci

    Msx el mejor port

  • @reneomarsantana5977
    @reneomarsantana5977 Před 2 lety

    Sega versión XD

  • @jubieusiva8746
    @jubieusiva8746 Před 2 lety

    IAO