Who is the better carry player?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 6. 09. 2024
  • Show your support for Dota Alchemy: / dotaalchemy
    Buy Dota Alchemy Merch: www.bonfire.co...
    Dota Alchemy compares pro player Miracle- to an Ancient pub player to discover what makes a pro Dota 2 player tick!
    #dota2 #Dota2Guides #DotaAlchemy
    Join us on social:
    / discord Discord
    / dotaalchemy Twitter
    / dotaalchemy Instagram
    / dotaalchemy Facebook

Komentáře • 146

  • @barburasandreiflorian9873
    @barburasandreiflorian9873 Před 4 lety +29

    More of this, do for all postions. Mid, off and so on

    • @tannersuckssoyeah
      @tannersuckssoyeah Před 4 lety +1

      Doing this for offlane would be really incredible IMO. Something like Faith_bian Beastmaster or 9Pasha Centaur/Sand King.

  • @gobahgaber6909
    @gobahgaber6909 Před 4 lety +31

    i really like how this is so unbiased, just pure commentary on mindsets with really helpful tips, really hope youll do hard support, like shadow demon for the next series if you choose to continue this

    • @Andytlp
      @Andytlp Před 4 lety

      pro tip. The best pos 4 heroes are sd and silencer.

    • @Andytlp
      @Andytlp Před 4 lety

      @@edinbhop myb, silencer as pos 5 to zone the offlaners 24/7. No hero can withstand it not even bristle. hes shit as pos 4 or 2.

    • @Andytlp
      @Andytlp Před 4 lety

      @@edinbhop I know but hes good against pretty much all offlaners that have it easy if u have a regular support with a stun. If he keeps his distance even i struggle as an offlaner. cant trade with him, he just steals int and deals more dmg every single attack. His q slows so u cant run up even with a fast base ms and his e deals int multiplier at the end of all the int stealing when you think youre fine but then it hits a damn 200 on lvl 1. because your int is at like 10 and hes at 50. Base dmg is 80 and 1.5x base int. And if u die even once in lane he gets so ahead in int and dmg output even timber cant sustain it. If offlane are both ranged then it isnt a flat out ez win but if both are melee then their morale hits 0. it all depends on how good you are. A good player will style on you even if youre playing a counter hero. His ult is also the best thing there is. it forces people to buy dispels which waste time, u pop it after they bkb and they cant do anything. Ive had enigma pickers literally give up on min 1.

  • @storebjorn21
    @storebjorn21 Před 4 lety +23

    Nice new series! Looking forward for next hero and players

  • @_egghead
    @_egghead Před 4 lety +13

    This actually helps to ancient players like me. I definitely had the same mentality as that ancient from the video every single game and wondering what's the breaking point for me to surpass ancient. Here on this video, I now see why.

    • @steffkepn2
      @steffkepn2 Před 4 lety +2

      well Ancient 5 is better that 90% of all players in the world, so you really need to change mindset if you want to became better player, because people play pretty much ok on Ancient bracket. Im on divine 1 and i didn't go up for full year now, and the scary thing is that i don't blame teamates for that anymore...

    • @montanaapproves1044
      @montanaapproves1044 Před 4 lety

      How'd you get out of archon? Asking for a friend

  • @matthewtham4541
    @matthewtham4541 Před 4 lety +13

    Love the videos Donnie. Would love to see jugg being done

  • @rikirudee
    @rikirudee Před 4 lety +3

    I would love more videos like this hopefully covering all the different roles. I enjoy how it was broken down.

  • @DrZaius3141
    @DrZaius3141 Před 4 lety

    Some caveats: it's easier to take the dangerous farm if you have a Clockwerk providing you vision (which happened multiple times in this video) and it's also easier to go for farm speed over fighting abilities, if you're in a team that has a 100% laid out strategy that revolves around Lifestealer not fighting too early. By no means does that say that your points are invalid, it's just the kind of context you probably should include.

  • @MartinGlazierMG
    @MartinGlazierMG Před 4 lety +2

    I feel it might be more fitting to compare pubs with pubs no?

  • @theneonpython
    @theneonpython Před 4 lety

    this is an awesome idea, many players are blind to their own inadequacies on dota 2 and this helps to give a real time visual

  • @ai.Lofi93
    @ai.Lofi93 Před 4 lety

    hell yeah donney this is fucking great content, show us what a "normal" player decides vs a top tier player does in the same situation! spot on analysis of top players vs the best competition

  • @MAC2322
    @MAC2322 Před 4 lety

    This is a great style of video that really puts a spotlight on how and why pros are so effective. I'd like to see something like this done for Topson, who I feel like is one of the players who can most push his heroes to the limits even in the context of midplayers, who typically are always the one with the most outplay potential.

  • @Mirrale
    @Mirrale Před 4 lety

    Awesome format for videos. I think you should make this a fairly regular thing.

  • @koz9840
    @koz9840 Před 4 lety

    I think this style of video is a very nice touch. Myself being in a lower bracket than these folks really gives me an opportunity to visually see the outcome of the strategies being pursued.

  • @sofaking4779
    @sofaking4779 Před 4 lety

    I would love to see Pos 3+4 off-lane combos pro vs. pubs. specifically how they work together to "ruin" the lane for the opposing carry and when they stay, rotate, etc.

  • @asdasdheh6534
    @asdasdheh6534 Před 4 lety

    good video. the only complaint i have is that the quad-screen view is kind hard to follow

  • @christianbrossette
    @christianbrossette Před 4 lety +1

    Love it! I would like to see this type von content on pro support players, position 4 or 5 :)

  • @ExedraA
    @ExedraA Před 4 lety

    I would like to see any support heroes comparison donnie, this video is really helpful 🙏

  • @MoyoRox7
    @MoyoRox7 Před 4 lety

    Loved this episode, as an offlane player who doesn't know how to get something out of a losing lane would love a video like that :)

  • @christianadrian1256
    @christianadrian1256 Před 4 lety

    Im an ancient player and I beated inmortals top >200 in Battlecups with my inmortal top 2000 friends. I almost beated the ex Beastcoast (Ryoya, ixmike, MoOz, 1437) but I throwed the game sadly.
    I think most of us have the skill to beat them but not the knowledge of how to play and make decisions correctly so thank you so much for the good content!

  • @rafifed8161
    @rafifed8161 Před 4 lety

    Nice vid Donnie, it might be better if u make it larger tho. It's quite hard to see the detail

  • @Ionweopon
    @Ionweopon Před 4 lety

    This is a fantastic video, but it would have been nice if you were going to do a comparison, that it's a comparison under similar circumstances. A game which you have pretty much free-farm looks and plays out entirely different from a lane which you are strongly contested. Definitely very educational, but it would have been interesting to see how miracle plays under the same circumstances as the Ancient player.

  • @raintbowshit6857
    @raintbowshit6857 Před 4 lety

    I would also like to see a video about roles(1,2,3,4,5), their main goal in the game, their timings, when they should leave the lane, when the 2 should gank, when carry should start involving in team fights and these type of things

  • @Dimens1oner
    @Dimens1oner Před 4 lety

    would be nice to see this happen in comparison to games where pretty much everything goes bad from the start, how well the pro makes enemies life hard compared to pubber who probably just end up feeding even more :P

  • @sakibsadman8217
    @sakibsadman8217 Před 4 lety

    Really good video but change the camera layout. Position the two gameplay windows vertically, one on top and one on bottom. It will be much easier on the eyes.

  • @jok3rsgh0st89
    @jok3rsgh0st89 Před 4 lety

    If you can do a Rubick it would be cool, been maining him while I try to climb the ranks from Herald and would like to know how to play him effectively so I can get out of Herald.

  • @synrise8688
    @synrise8688 Před 4 lety

    nice stuff
    pos 1: yurnero - pos 2: kunkka - pos 3: centaur - pos 4: barat - pos 5: jakiro

  • @keelanurnishanth5801
    @keelanurnishanth5801 Před 4 lety

    The main thing I learnt from this video PUBS = Public match making. I can sleep peacefully at night now.

  • @kritinjp1405
    @kritinjp1405 Před 4 lety

    Donnie, this series has some amazing scope not gonna lie, but the drastic shift in the meta since Mad moon has made it so that the information in this video is obsolete to say the least. If you could make It recent content it would be amazing as a series

  • @CarlosLins1
    @CarlosLins1 Před 4 lety

    I like the editing and the mindset of the analysis, great video

  • @babyrage1763
    @babyrage1763 Před 4 lety +3

    Hey Donnie, loved the video. I would definitely watch more of this type of video. On the side note, Whenever you do feature someone's play, I think I have the perfect player for you to analyze. If I remember correctly, The player's name is Jenkins. pogchamp

  • @tusharjamwal
    @tusharjamwal Před 4 lety +1

    Donnie please cover ember spirit! Because he's such a versatile hero. Some different builds/playstyles will be very nice. And perhaps you could guide us/give us some things to look out for that help us decide what kind of playstyle to adopt in a particular game.

  • @agusaris5031
    @agusaris5031 Před 4 lety

    You should use Miracle PUB game cause environment in Pro Scene is so different

  • @AbusingMyRights1
    @AbusingMyRights1 Před 4 lety

    Fantastic video love to see a 4 mirana up against Tims

  • @ajreid1168
    @ajreid1168 Před 4 lety +1

    how exactly do you get yourself into the position to have this free farm like miracle? unless this is a 1 in 30 game where he's got offlaners cutting creeps or is there something about the draft, his laneing partner that allows his farm to be so damn uncontested (talking about miracle still)

    • @marshmallowmann20
      @marshmallowmann20 Před 4 lety

      true, he basically had completely uncontested farm because of the draft. i don't understand this comparison at all

  • @a.alvarez4
    @a.alvarez4 Před 4 lety

    Hey Donnie, love the video. I just wanted to follow-up on the topic a bit: I feel as though the most difficult part about implementing this advice is ultimately knowing when you are killable, or under what circumstances. For example, I know now thanks to this video that naix hits a strong timing with early maelstrom sange/halberd and is nearly unkillable thanks to rage tp, but how were players able to gauge this in the first place? Without the video, I personally wouldn't have known. Does it come from experience, an intimate understanding of stats/ability damage/hero scaling, or what? I can certainly understand the message behind the video, but I think that the hard part is knowing when the time is to take the hard farm.

    • @johnrosales1918
      @johnrosales1918 Před 4 lety

      I think it comes from knowledge of the game such as knowing the power spikes of a hero.

  • @shazec
    @shazec Před 4 lety

    It's a good video and while I agree with the idea and the concept, you simply cannot play like Miracle on Ancient rank or in 4-5k pub in general. Nigma have way better vision and communicate fast and efficient. In a pub you see nothing and nobody tells you if someone who could possibly kill you is gone from their lane. Another thing is the opponents. Secret literally let Miracle free farm because they are trading pretty much equal farm on their cores or simply because it isn't worth to rotate for the reasons you specified. So he can go greedy with his build and rush maelstrom no boots, gets free towers and that opens up even more space to farm. Meanwhile ancient guy clearly had two enemies constantly contesting him. If he goes for the same build, he can get bullied by them way easier. Possibly dove under tower and die because it's a pub and nobody cares.
    I am ancient / divine rank myself and I watch tons of pro games, been playing since way back in DotA 1 and you really have to take the pro games with a grain of salt and use your brain before you try to copy pro tactics in your pubs.

  • @thienfoil
    @thienfoil Před 4 lety

    Can you go over mid game for all roles and rotations game plan. Think a lot of videos focus on early game

  • @moherxd
    @moherxd Před 4 lety

    Good content, hope to see an comparision of techies

  • @kalyans4879
    @kalyans4879 Před 4 lety

    Do some support tips n tricks, ways to play diffrnt heroes as supports, builds

  • @allegroppd6013
    @allegroppd6013 Před 4 lety

    I think it's great for sure. Maybe make the music at the start and end a bit quieter but that's pretty minor. I'd love one on Oracle, i've been learning him lately as a Pos 5 player and think he's super interesting. Loving the content as usual!

  • @HamFam
    @HamFam Před 4 lety +2

    4:24 isnt it 80 magic dmg now?

    • @orange2694
      @orange2694 Před 4 lety

      Pretty sure it was 100 during weplay madmoon thats why naix had like the highest winrate

  • @fawazalturki318
    @fawazalturki318 Před 4 lety

    keep it up with this series !

  • @mreaper2265
    @mreaper2265 Před 4 lety

    Tbh most pubs are 5v5 instead of 2 teams playing, I believe it will greatly benefit if it is not a random pub player. Maybe take a lower level team or find someone you know plays with a team.

  • @beak_essence-
    @beak_essence- Před 4 lety +1

    pls continue these videos donnie these are ur best videos man keep up the content.

  • @Dave-wt9cl
    @Dave-wt9cl Před 4 lety

    Nice video donnie. Can you cover beastmaster next?

  • @Dune355
    @Dune355 Před 4 lety

    im pretty sure if the ancient player swapped with miracle nigma still would have won the game. Ls hit creeps all game and halberd or just sange wouldnt really do a difference in the fight. The biggest difference in the 2 replays are the other 9 players

  • @kennetheugenio2846
    @kennetheugenio2846 Před 4 lety

    Master Donnie this is awesome! Can you please make a video like this for Pos5? I would love to see more of these vids. Keep up the good work man!

  • @helsharidy123
    @helsharidy123 Před 4 lety

    Like Henry said, most players got to their mmr by farming gaster but I don't think focusing on farming faster as why miracle did better here. What about pulling to the big camp? There's more than farming that is going on here

  • @danishshamsul7991
    @danishshamsul7991 Před 4 lety +1

    Love this type of content elevated

  • @TheReclamation14
    @TheReclamation14 Před 4 lety

    great series - keep it up! a mid would be great

  • @MartinGlazierMG
    @MartinGlazierMG Před 4 lety

    Go Go Elevated! I Think there is a lot of value in these for us theory crafters :)

  • @tistrya-424
    @tistrya-424 Před 4 lety

    Dude can we just start to talk about his feast ability please? and why they just removed his main source of damage? isn't there anyway for it's return? and btw can you guys start to compair a hero like LS to his previous version in pre 7.23 patch?

  • @jorgebalbin5170
    @jorgebalbin5170 Před 4 lety

    Nice edition my man keep it up

  • @sweetgokke
    @sweetgokke Před 4 lety

    Loved the video, Donnie!

  • @fouadmerhej8200
    @fouadmerhej8200 Před 4 lety

    Taiga willow ers , gh tuskar or wisp or yapsor rubbick...

  • @frostosaurus3284
    @frostosaurus3284 Před 4 lety

    This is such a cool idea. Hope to see more of this kind of content. Can we get Terrorblade by any chance?

  • @TheSequid
    @TheSequid Před 4 lety

    This is great Donnie keep it up

  • @montanaapproves1044
    @montanaapproves1044 Před 4 lety +1

    Hello to anyone who sees this comment, can anyone give me tips on how to get out of archon so far I know the basics such as:
    1. Item timings
    2. Core bringing detection
    3. PMA
    4. I'm a pretty decent drafter for my rank (I think)
    5. Decent cs for my rank I think I get 50 cs in 10 mins without heavy pressure as core
    6. I pull
    Any feedback/tips or anything is really helpful for someone who really wants to improve at this game

    • @mohamamdazhar6813
      @mohamamdazhar6813 Před 4 lety +1

      In 2k -4k bracket its so hard to have communication and teamwork which will most of the time lose u the game. what I do to climb is just try play my best and play around my team and dont try to create a gameplay ( cause cammunication issue) and wait for enemy to do dumb shit. 1k to 3k people love to do dumb things. Abuse thai guess.

    • @montanaapproves1044
      @montanaapproves1044 Před 4 lety

      @@mohamamdazhar6813 its harder since I play at SEA but thanks for the feedback ill try talking to my team more now

  • @nabinrai749
    @nabinrai749 Před 4 lety

    Really appreciated it

  • @charlycharly4958
    @charlycharly4958 Před 4 lety +1

    Great idea for new content Donnie!!! 👍👍

  • @turuukaito6156
    @turuukaito6156 Před 4 lety +2

    Wow its so educational, love this kind of contents

  • @dhruvrawat5983
    @dhruvrawat5983 Před 4 lety

    Continue the series,Mid role next-about rotations and farming pattern

  • @cyrax-vq5ur
    @cyrax-vq5ur Před 4 lety

    i like it... i watched a lot of tutorials here u can see directly how it works and what u do wrong

  • @botinok37
    @botinok37 Před 4 lety

    Very nice video. Please do more like this

  • @kingdripdrippin
    @kingdripdrippin Před 4 lety

    I like this style of video. Thanks Donnie!

  • @gabrielmpaula1
    @gabrielmpaula1 Před 4 lety

    awesome content! do one with yapzor!

  • @mithren86
    @mithren86 Před 4 lety

    Great series

  • @raintbowshit6857
    @raintbowshit6857 Před 4 lety

    I would also do one for supports

  • @cullin137
    @cullin137 Před 4 lety

    this is a very fresh idea to me. i really like it, keep it up man

  • @brandonunez74
    @brandonunez74 Před 4 lety

    Love the new series!

  • @mashitty1
    @mashitty1 Před 4 lety

    I like this format

  • @harrismazari5484
    @harrismazari5484 Před 4 lety

    Next please do which is brighter the sun or the moon

  • @kristoffergiganto3224
    @kristoffergiganto3224 Před 4 lety

    Good video Sir Donnie!! :) keep it up

  • @Sammysapphira
    @Sammysapphira Před 4 lety

    AWESOME video!

  • @aksanyar
    @aksanyar Před 4 lety

    Rtz terroblade vs pub terroblade

  • @kenttakaishi8138
    @kenttakaishi8138 Před 4 lety +1

    Hi Donnie keep it up man, youre the best

  • @ritzroldennalpajora4742

    who is the better pos 1-5 players....
    SEA/NA/CS

  • @axladas_gamezoned8693
    @axladas_gamezoned8693 Před 4 lety

    nice concept

  • @gamerodnt448
    @gamerodnt448 Před 4 lety

    I learned something from this but something feels bad with comparing pro vs pub team. Still I hope for the best for you and the channel.

  • @blakey7525
    @blakey7525 Před 4 lety

    ty

  • @ahsanhabibabir5887
    @ahsanhabibabir5887 Před 4 lety

    need bigger split-screen

  • @raintbowshit6857
    @raintbowshit6857 Před 4 lety

    Super good idea

  • @kovski8310
    @kovski8310 Před 4 lety

    It isn't as easy as this video suggests. In pro games people sack lanes and dont contest them at all (as it's usually not worth it) but in Ancient 5 you can't really play that aggressive as they rotate fucking 5 people to kill you, even tho its totally not worth it. Not to say that Ancient 5 is any good, but you have to play different in different brackets to succeed. For Ancient 5 to Divine 3 it's enough if you just flash farm jungle and dont play hyper aggressive before the first 1-2 big items.

    • @kovski8310
      @kovski8310 Před 4 lety

      To add to this note - your teammates are also way worse and won't give you the space to pull any of the pro replay off. :/

  • @BigDaddyTCG
    @BigDaddyTCG Před 4 lety

    Donnie I’m a herald player that plays turbo and beats on Archons in there, have me on your channel to show my herald brothers we can do it !!!!!! HERALDS UNITE!!!!

  • @ashleyerriah167
    @ashleyerriah167 Před 4 lety

    THESE VIDS ARE GREAT

  • @LalramnunkimaCE--
    @LalramnunkimaCE-- Před 4 lety +1

    I'll answer shortly, OG Ana is the best carry....
    Ever

    • @agusaris5031
      @agusaris5031 Před 4 lety

      Ana doesn't really play in this patch, so his gameplay is not really relevant for us. But yeah, Ana still hold the best carry in my book

  • @kev6661
    @kev6661 Před 4 lety

    This but with support players

  • @KidTrigger
    @KidTrigger Před 4 lety

    Awesome video 😃👍

  • @nozomi_tailwind
    @nozomi_tailwind Před 4 lety

    safelane luna please

  • @harizhafizi2342
    @harizhafizi2342 Před 4 lety

    So based on the video, from my understanding you mean that pro player aim for fast farm item, and pub player just do a standard build item. Am I, right?

    • @mashitty1
      @mashitty1 Před 4 lety +1

      Hes saying miracle understands when to rush items and when you should buy smaller items first on a game by game basis

    • @renzolatorre8882
      @renzolatorre8882 Před 4 lety

      I dont think the ancient player could have rushed a miolnir in that lane as thing tourned out for him.

  • @dOdAdEish
    @dOdAdEish Před 4 lety

    Javalin is 80 Damage btw

  • @amaterasu7734
    @amaterasu7734 Před 4 lety +1

    necrophos offlane

  • @irsyadipa4750
    @irsyadipa4750 Před 4 lety

    Love it donnie!

  • @NB-ph6cv
    @NB-ph6cv Před 4 lety

    friendly advice, please stop using "best" in any occasion :) my notification bell is on ;) keep doing this amazing thing

  • @markcerwin4733
    @markcerwin4733 Před 3 lety

    hard thing to do in ancient bracket is you need to attack and kill enemy everyday/night/month if you dont hit opposing team, your teammate will cry and throw the game hahhahahahahahaha

  • @Shaharan1
    @Shaharan1 Před 4 lety

    Juggernaut next please

  • @giogio51592
    @giogio51592 Před 4 lety

    i have never ever lost a single game in the immortal bracket 😎

  • @karlzobok
    @karlzobok Před 4 lety +1

    Miracle uses taunts more often, easy conclusion

  • @bigmoose7
    @bigmoose7 Před 4 lety

    Luna pos 4 ))

  • @fromlibyawithlove667
    @fromlibyawithlove667 Před 4 lety

    Awesome