The Truth About Nirvana's Influence: Who Borrowed, Who Stole?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
  • #classicrock #nirvana #alternativerock #kurtcobain
    🔔 If you're new, Subscribe! ➤ bit.ly/subscribeSROCK
    📺 Watch Next Videos:
    Episode 2 ➤ • Who Stole Nirvana's So...
    00:00 - Intro
    00:48 - Fred Durst (Limp Bizkit)
    02:00 - Chester Bennington (Linkin Park)
    04:04 - Chad Kroeger - (Nickelback)
    06:16 - Silverchair
    08:56 - Shaun Morgan (Seether)
    11:50 - Outro
  • Hudba

Komentáře • 118

  • @richardunger3396
    @richardunger3396 Před 27 dny +45

    Shaun Morgan keeps the spirit and sound of grunge alive which I appreciate. He always pays tribute to Nirvana .

    • @aotctd
      @aotctd Před 22 dny +2

      grunge generation is
      we didnt go away
      ?
      😁

  • @Aaron-og2wx
    @Aaron-og2wx Před 21 dnem +6

    The singer from silverchair Daniel johns is NOT wearing a Nirvana shirt in the clip in this video! I have the poster from that day and he's actually wearing a Ministry t-shirt

  • @BWyatt76
    @BWyatt76 Před 26 dny +18

    Carefull calling Nickelback mainstream rock, their fans get mad 😆. However they're 100% mainstream rock

    • @miketaylor2083
      @miketaylor2083 Před 19 dny

      Who cares what their fans think. Their opinion is moot.

  • @NITE_SHIFTING
    @NITE_SHIFTING Před 27 dny +35

    Who got it wrong?
    EVERYONE....
    Except HANSON and SILVERCHAIR.
    😆

  • @mariedouglas4650
    @mariedouglas4650 Před 26 dny +30

    Silverchair was a great Aussie band.

  • @nirvanaduhg
    @nirvanaduhg Před 27 dny +20

    also dont forget that nirvana influenced green day and oasis

    • @maximkraus8181
      @maximkraus8181 Před 26 dny +8

      Definitely not Oasis, dude

    • @soakedinbleach93
      @soakedinbleach93 Před 26 dny +3

      @@maximkraus8181 well, deffinetely not musically, but "live forever" was kind of a sarcastic response to "I hate myself and want to die" (quoted by Noel himself)

    • @nirvanaduhg
      @nirvanaduhg Před 26 dny +2

      @@maximkraus8181 no literally noel himself said that there was interview about it

    • @nirvanaduhg
      @nirvanaduhg Před 26 dny +2

      and it would be surprising but nirvana influenced ozzy osbourne in his solo career, he even invite nirvana touring with him but like everytime kurt didnt want it even if he loved ozzy osbourne

    • @LeeFisher-616
      @LeeFisher-616 Před 25 dny

      oasis sounds like a badger in the mist of dying imo lol

  • @noeldivad
    @noeldivad Před 26 dny +7

    "Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery that mediocrity can pay to greatness" - Oscar Wilde

  • @bishalchaudhary9524
    @bishalchaudhary9524 Před 26 dny +8

    how hard bands try to sound like Nirvana but they are never gonna be like Nirvana not even close

  • @SilentProti
    @SilentProti Před 26 dny +11

    There's a video of teenage Chester singing polly. Great and haunting performance.

  • @IndexFossilchannel
    @IndexFossilchannel Před 26 dny +5

    These are the bands that enjoyed Nirvana's fame more than the band itself. That's why the Nickelback singer doesn't understand Kurt Cobain.

  • @HendrixVital-lz4ld
    @HendrixVital-lz4ld Před 27 dny +12

    Yall just gonna ignore Puddle of mud?

  • @LosPinkCheeseGreenGoes
    @LosPinkCheeseGreenGoes Před 26 dny +5

    Future leaders of the world

  • @heightenedsenses9605
    @heightenedsenses9605 Před 26 dny +21

    Chester didnt die at height of fame, he was past that.

  • @rogerrr1
    @rogerrr1 Před 27 dny +6

    Great vid!

  • @philhogan5623
    @philhogan5623 Před 20 dny +3

    When I hear Nickelback I don't hear Nirvana at all.

  • @BosworthMcG
    @BosworthMcG Před 26 dny +23

    Silverchair’s album diorama is stunning.

    • @jcwareham81
      @jcwareham81 Před 26 dny +1

      Absolute masterpiece

    • @frankkkbard0n315
      @frankkkbard0n315 Před 23 dny +2

      it is, and at the point the nirvana influence was not noticeable anymore, they were their own thing tottaly

  • @leakband9647
    @leakband9647 Před 20 dny +1

    Hey man, great video! Maybe you could include Union Youth on part 2? That would be interesting!

  • @AduderReviews
    @AduderReviews Před 20 dny +2

    Love Silverchair. They were so young when they started but surpassed many of their older counterparts at the time. And their later albums were great, apart from Young Modern.

  • @dantecerda130
    @dantecerda130 Před 26 dny +4

    Soul Asylum was a band I thought seem very similar to Nirvana.

  • @lutesjay
    @lutesjay Před 26 dny +28

    Nirvana smelled like the Pixies.

    • @jarrettchrist
      @jarrettchrist Před 26 dny +8

      See I think Kurt definitely took hella influence in their dynamics, but Nirvana really does not sound like them to me. Pixies is really one of those bands where every member’s contributions shape the sound, and it makes them super distinct from other bands

    • @dakotakoll-is3rg
      @dakotakoll-is3rg Před 26 dny

      You smell like a dork 😜

    • @user-cp5of3nf3n
      @user-cp5of3nf3n Před 25 dny

      From Pixie dust.

    • @enochancient9931
      @enochancient9931 Před 15 dny

      A little

  • @user-tz2zz5ij1s
    @user-tz2zz5ij1s Před 26 dny +4

    Grunge makes no sense. The big four of “grunge” sound nothing like each other. It’s tiresome at this point. Nirvana didn’t invent catchy hooks, quite loud quite, or dark emotional singing/lyrics. Nirvana and “grunge” just happened to be the 90’s response to 80’s rock. This video has to be 90% crappy AI and 10% Nirvana fanboy.

    • @aotctd
      @aotctd Před 22 dny +1

      uh grunge came up in the 80s

  • @ars_moriendi.official
    @ars_moriendi.official Před 25 dny +1

    Days of the new is not a Nirvana copycat... Travis Meeks is largely influenced by the Doors, Dead can Dance and of the Seattle bands he's more a fan of Alice in chains.. Days of the New is a solid band with great original music.

  • @jamesbarrick3403
    @jamesbarrick3403 Před 27 dny +18

    I like all of those bands. I never understood the grunge vs post-grunge labels. It is the same music, it is the same style... it simply got a new label when Kurt died.

  • @bushleague3472
    @bushleague3472 Před 25 dny

    IMO the band that borrowed from Nirvana the best was Face to Face. Those first 3 albums, and "Big Choice" in particular deffinately sounded like it was borrowing more heavily from grunge than any of their punk peers. The percussive "power chord riff" driven songwriting is very Cobain-esque.

  • @jayman9910
    @jayman9910 Před 19 dny

    I hear 90's Metallica more in early Nickelback especially from Chad's voice. Also STP was a big influence on Chester which is why he fronted for them for a album

  • @DaNi-ph1cl
    @DaNi-ph1cl Před 20 dny

    Please listen to "de musica ligera" by soda stereo , it sounds exactly like teen spirit and it came out a year before, then listen to " Ella uso mi cabeza como un revolver" by the same band. Sounds like "in bloom" by Nirvana

  • @shawnsuave5694
    @shawnsuave5694 Před 20 dny +1

    Seether is the most

  • @PrecisionPointTennis
    @PrecisionPointTennis Před 17 dny

    Sun Puddle are the closest anyone has ever sounded like Nirvana.

  • @nimitz1739
    @nimitz1739 Před 25 dny +1

    Fuel can be put in that category. But the truth is everybody knew that Nirvana had done change the scene and the music was going to start sounding like that. Which was a good thing compared to that glam rock.

  • @wnerko7484
    @wnerko7484 Před 22 dny

    In utero was already released.i only heard radio hits.never cared for them.until i heard Lounge Act.and then Bleach album is what got me converted.especially Incesticide

  • @phineas117
    @phineas117 Před 26 dny +3

    and of course...weezer.

  • @ItFigures89
    @ItFigures89 Před 25 dny

    No one gonna mention Future Leaders Of The World?

  • @BijjalyGas
    @BijjalyGas Před 25 dny +1

    Australian band the Vines.
    Craig Nicholls is a Kurt Cobain
    Wannabe.

  • @madshadow25
    @madshadow25 Před 17 dny

    The Glue - The Same

  • @Myownsummer
    @Myownsummer Před 26 dny

    since i was 14 or 15 i never like silverchair, although some of their songs are good. just because i read daniel's magazine inteview that he dont even know nirvana 😂

  • @matthewearlywine5535
    @matthewearlywine5535 Před 22 dny +1

    None of the above singers sound like Cobain..at all

  • @molotovmutt3365
    @molotovmutt3365 Před 24 dny

    You really think that Curb by Nickelback wouldn't feel out of place in a Nirvana record?? 🤣🤣

    • @aotctd
      @aotctd Před 22 dny

      lmao 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @RestrainingHollywood
    @RestrainingHollywood Před 26 dny +1

    Foo Fighters are nothing more than a Socially Accepted Nickelback...Bush was a British emulation of Nirvana...& Silverchair wanted to be Nirvana so bad it was laughable 😂

    • @duck_7482
      @duck_7482 Před 22 dny +3

      Brother… listen to any silver chair album other than their first two.

    • @Aaron-og2wx
      @Aaron-og2wx Před 7 dny

      More pearl jam than nirvana on their first album then each album after that nothing like nirvana! They matured into nothing comparable

  • @wnerko7484
    @wnerko7484 Před 22 dny

    Durst is a joke.but i admire his integrity in not copying nirvana

  • @PanicJackShow
    @PanicJackShow Před 25 dny +2

    Love the video, but I’ll always say that Silverchair never sounded like Nirvana, because it’s true, they don’t sound the same at all. But they’re my 2 favorite bands.

  • @madshadow25
    @madshadow25 Před 17 dny

    The Jins

  • @rogueprince1341
    @rogueprince1341 Před 25 dny +1

    Seether is this generations Nirvana. They even cover Nirvana tunes. You can tell Shaun loves Nirvana when he sings they're songs.

    • @molotovmutt3365
      @molotovmutt3365 Před 24 dny

      This generation? Seether's fat singer is born in 1978

    • @aotctd
      @aotctd Před 22 dny +1

      No one from the Grunge Generation sees them as that

  • @BryanHRBrodie
    @BryanHRBrodie Před 22 dny

    I'm just commenting for @aotctd to disagree with anything anyone says 😊

  • @LeeFisher-616
    @LeeFisher-616 Před 25 dny

    puddle of mudd nailed it loved that band from the first day i heard them because it reminded me of Nirvana

    • @aotctd
      @aotctd Před 22 dny +1

      disagrees in grunge generation
      and wonders if i am in an alternate timeline

  • @krisfrederick5001
    @krisfrederick5001 Před 27 dny +9

    None of the above. It was all in vain. There will never be another Kurt Cobain.

    • @garryiglesias4074
      @garryiglesias4074 Před 26 dny +5

      You don't understand the concept of INSPIRATION... Scoop: Kurt Cobain was himself inspired by other artists...
      Conclusion: your comment is worthless and off topic.

    • @RadicalSharkRS
      @RadicalSharkRS Před 26 dny +2

      Chester got to front stone temple pilots

    • @aotctd
      @aotctd Před 22 dny

      @@RadicalSharkRS Both aren't very Grunge

  • @kryczka1988
    @kryczka1988 Před 20 dny

    Union Youth - Inbreeding

  • @revminTphresh
    @revminTphresh Před 26 dny +4

    nickleback was the worst show ive ever seen.

  • @dishman4694
    @dishman4694 Před 26 dny +1

    Still in the ads as I’m already typing. Puddle of Mudd. That’s exactly why I despise that band!!!!!! You can’t just sing a certain way to make it seem like you’re continuing someone’s legacy or even just to say I miss him. It’s not the way to be. Create your own misery?

  • @babyblue4824
    @babyblue4824 Před 21 dnem

    Silverchair vehemently opposed comparison.... What douches, even tho some of the music they made was great

  • @aotctd
    @aotctd Před 22 dny

    criinges in grunge generation

  • @xlack9gaming850
    @xlack9gaming850 Před 27 dny +4

    Chris Cornell >>>

    • @garryiglesias4074
      @garryiglesias4074 Před 26 dny +1

      Err... Do you know that inspiration is usually "one way", mechanically, or more chronologically ??
      Kurt was inspired by Chris Cornell (who was a GREAT singer, one of my favorite, with Kurt and many others). Chris "invented" grunge, Kurt came after him.

    • @nirvanaduhg
      @nirvanaduhg Před 26 dny +2

      you people need stop to comparing everyone with kurt, chris was his friend all the time even if they didnt talk at all they loved eachother and their music you elitist just cant enjoy music and ruin their fanbases

  • @hosswilder9885
    @hosswilder9885 Před 25 dny

    🤮

  • @luhurpambudi6851
    @luhurpambudi6851 Před 18 dny

    The worst thing about grunge is post-grunge.

  • @1985cactus
    @1985cactus Před 26 dny +3

    This is just a list of five of the worst bands that came out in the last 30 years.

  • @BryanHRBrodie
    @BryanHRBrodie Před 22 dny

    Just commentimg for @aottcd to troll me 😊