Are You Using Enough Terrain?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 151

  • @RandomFactor
    @RandomFactor Před 6 lety +54

    i accidentally overcomitted to how detailed my Kill Team starter box terrain was going to be and spent four weeks painting pillars and features by hand and going for an acid-rain stained, grimy stonework and god damned if im not using every single fucking piece. This terrain is now my homes fine china and my children will eat off of it at their damn weddings

  • @EngineerJeff
    @EngineerJeff Před 6 lety +88

    Good terrain placement helps make the narrative and gives my imagination more room to roam. I rate my games on how much I enjoy the experience, not so much on winning, so a good battlemat and proper terrain go a long way towards enhancing the fun. This was another great video man. Are you in my head Uncle Atom? Scary! :)

  • @spencergorman366
    @spencergorman366 Před 5 lety +6

    I play 40k when I can, and my local games workshop has a city table with the gw city terrain, and it always bothers me when people put the buildings in the road. What I have found works well to break up sight lines while keeping it thematic is putting barricades and tank traps in the streets and cramming all the buildings into the non-road bits. I really like your videos, it feels like there are a lot of "angry" youtubers when it comes to war games and RPGs and its nice to see someone who is pretty objective when it comes to those topics. Keep it up!

  • @maxxon99
    @maxxon99 Před 6 lety +15

    It also depends on what kind of terrain you have.
    If you can place your models on or in the terrain instead of just around it, you can get away with a lot more terrain. But things like rocks or solid house models often end up eating away the usable tablespace.

  • @Crizzly122
    @Crizzly122 Před 5 lety +59

    "Some guys run with like 30 skeletons, thats a lot"
    *laughs in Skaven*

  • @CesarIsaacPerez
    @CesarIsaacPerez Před 6 lety +5

    I got into Wargaming 2 years ago with AoS and I have bought a lot more terrain than I ever thought I would. Frostgrave influenced my Terrain buying frenzy but games are simply much more fun on a packed table. I love Kill Team because of the terrain sets too!

  • @steve-xt1zg
    @steve-xt1zg Před 6 lety +2

    I'm a recent convert to your channel and must say I find your insightful look into the hobby refreshingly inspirational and thought provoking. Yours is a stand out channel sir keep up the great content.

  • @hmint1615
    @hmint1615 Před 6 lety +3

    I find this very interesting in the light of the fresh 40k FAQ, that gives the player going second the option to put his whole army in cover.
    A lot of reactions I read online for this new rule are along the lines of 'this is super strong', 'now I can finally have cover in the first turn and not be shot off the board! amazing!'.
    But then I think of my games, and I generally deploy everything (except maybe some very large vehicles) in some kind of cover on the first turn anyways...? Some things are even completely out of LOS. We generally make sure both players have something LOS blocking and quite a bit of smaller terrain pieces in their deployment zones.
    So there seems to be a huge difference in the amount of terrain players use in 40k, but it's not obvious what position they come from when they discuss the game balance and such.

  • @pumpernickelpickle7243
    @pumpernickelpickle7243 Před 3 lety +1

    I just gor in the gothic ruins set from gamemat. I love it and it looks great with my home made terrain

  • @shawnmccuen6908
    @shawnmccuen6908 Před 6 lety +2

    At the risk of tooting my own horn. Kill team was my first terrain build and paint. And it came out pretty darn good! Makes the game play a lot more emersive.

    • @Sorrowdusk
      @Sorrowdusk Před 5 lety

      :D gotta agree, Have any pics? This is my first shot at terrain imgur.com/a/kxbPfWf

    • @shawnmccuen6908
      @shawnmccuen6908 Před 5 lety

      @@Sorrowdusk Just checked out the pics. You went far and above. Good show.

  • @jasonmoorman534
    @jasonmoorman534 Před 6 lety +2

    I worked on the Kings of War rules committee for two years. The rules are designed to work with 10ish pieces of terrain of various sizes on a 4'x6' table.

  • @Smaakakor
    @Smaakakor Před 4 lety

    I'd forgotten how fun it was to roll and play with terrain before. The all importance of hills and having stuff in the way... thx for that really fun reminder. I could almost tell if i was going to win or not on what terrain i rolled :)

  • @benjaminstorace6699
    @benjaminstorace6699 Před 4 lety +6

    I want to know where I can get the "Thats how I roll, unfortunately" shirt

  • @ArdWulf
    @ArdWulf Před 6 lety

    Excellent commentary on an often overlooked aspect of gaming with miniatures... especially in terms of the scope/level of the rules and their mechanics. Well done.

  • @aurenian8247
    @aurenian8247 Před 5 lety +1

    Personally I figure out scenario first and then set the table to match. That way the terrain suits the mission being played, and the various cover and LOS blocking pieces make sense for the way the armies are expected to move. Nothing worse than setting up a table and then rolling mission only to find that your deployment zone has no cover.

  • @johnhaines4163
    @johnhaines4163 Před 6 lety +6

    I think this discussion highlights one of the key differences between historical and fantasy wargaming. Most of Uncle Atom's talk was about the right amount of terrain to make a good game, while for historical wargaming the issue would be realism.

    • @tomg7913
      @tomg7913 Před 6 lety +2

      It's more the differences between games with firearms and games with melee weapons. You want terrain for cover from ranged weapons but not so much for swords and spears action

    • @GeneJordan
      @GeneJordan Před 6 lety

      I've found most historical wargaming to be seriously lacking in realism while having way too many heated discussions about the same topic.

  • @idiotproofdalek
    @idiotproofdalek Před 6 lety +2

    A clarification on Uncle Atom’s statement about Kings of War - add the word ‘scatter’ to the word ‘terrain’ and he’s correct. You still need to have a lot of terrain that units can move through, such as woods, hills and swamps etc. If you play Kings of War on an open field with a couple of things in the corners like WFB, it will favour certain armies in the meta.

    • @MurderHoboRPG
      @MurderHoboRPG Před 5 lety

      Most scatter pieces are scenery rather than terrain. Unless you are talking about hills and trees and rock formations

  • @malcontent6524
    @malcontent6524 Před 5 lety +2

    Great video, once again an absolute help to a newcomer such as myself. I love the shirt!

  • @SciFiPorkChop28
    @SciFiPorkChop28 Před 6 lety

    Excellent video... one more thing I'd add is that depending on the game (Kill Team vs Infinity vs Malifaux vs AOS, etc) if you find that your faction or your army is either doing really well, or vice versa, really poorly... consider looking at the terrain and your opponent's style of army and see if that is part of the problem... Most recently, with Kill Team, this has been something I'm interested in discussing because the 'standard' KT boards have very little actual full LOS blocking and fairly sparse terrain as they come in the boxes (see the most recent Trench set... it has 3 trenches and no other terrain... nothing tall enough to block LOS to anything taller than the trench)... and I've heard posts where one person 'can't win with their Genestealers or Close Combat Army' and another person 'can't win with their Tau or shooting army'... and my suspicion is that the Genestealer player is probably playing on too little terrain.. while the Tau player is probably playing with too much terrain.... (of course, too much and too little are relative to the players and the mission)... but it is a big variable in gaming that is often not discussed.. unlike army lists or points values or mission objectives.... so something to think about and consider tweaking if you are having too much or too little luck in your games =p

  • @plaidpvcpipe3792
    @plaidpvcpipe3792 Před 6 lety +2

    I'm a Guard player in 40k, and I cant wait to get the 5 man Scion squads, I've now realised the danger of large squads fighting against Stygies 8 Xenarites (Traitor Admech).

  • @stevenwhite7763
    @stevenwhite7763 Před 6 lety

    The last "big" game I played had three 4x4 foot and one 4x6 foot interconnected game boards. A harbor, open farmland, scarred and haunted wood, and Sleepy Hollow.

  • @adrianthom2073
    @adrianthom2073 Před 6 lety +49

    What’s a good age to get your children playing 40K?
    I have not played for 20 years but thinking of playing with my kids when they are old enough. Just not sure exactly what age is appropriate.

    • @MrWhite5150Duke
      @MrWhite5150Duke Před 6 lety +37

      12 to 14, depending on aptitude and maturity. 🍺💨

    • @hadago7630
      @hadago7630 Před 6 lety +25

      About 10 years old is a good age. It is best to start them off by telling them how far they can move and shoot but for the first few games, you simply give them the number of dice they need for everything instead of them checking the rulebook. Summarize special rules and the like, this will give them a feel for the game, from there show them where you get the numbers for the amount of dice to use from.

    • @adrianthom2073
      @adrianthom2073 Před 6 lety +2

      Duke5150 , thanks Duke.
      I have many years to wait then.

    • @hadago7630
      @hadago7630 Před 6 lety +9

      Adrian Thom Adrian Thom It generally depends on how much you water down the rules for them, I have seen a post where a parent has taught his 5 year old. With rules simplified but still a great introduction

    • @tharmekhul
      @tharmekhul Před 6 lety +20

      It’s never too early to show them the glory of the emporer

  • @williamwinn948
    @williamwinn948 Před 6 lety

    Sometimes when there is so much terrain it's like there's nothing left to the magination it's almost like playing a video game without a controller. I love the creative aspect more then anything.

  • @motorboot2822
    @motorboot2822 Před 3 lety

    My friends and I are working on a random terrain generator. That always creates really interesting games.

  • @MurderHoboRPG
    @MurderHoboRPG Před 5 lety +2

    Yo uncle Atom!! Can you do a video on your favorite terrain and scenery builders on youtube? I want to discover more builders.

    • @samueloconnor2938
      @samueloconnor2938 Před 4 lety

      Would recommend Black Magic Crafts. He does videos on how to make terrain more for beginners

  • @treybaker5440
    @treybaker5440 Před 6 lety +2

    I noticed you said "Back when I used to play 'Flames of War'". I have recently been thinking about Flames of War, being a big fan of tanks. Is there a reason I shouldn't?
    Big fan of the channel by the way. I've been painting for the past 2 weeks after being inspired by several of your vids!

    • @jonathanp1621
      @jonathanp1621 Před 6 lety

      Trey Baker I would go for 1/285, if you prefer tanks. It looks way better than the car parks that you sometimes see.

    • @treybaker5440
      @treybaker5440 Před 6 lety

      Jonathan P Thanks! I'll look into that. In theory though, wouldn't that just depend on the players? For example: I know the rules ALLOW me to take enough tanks to fill up the battlefield, but for thematic, tactical, and FUN reasons, I have decided not to?

    • @jonathanp1621
      @jonathanp1621 Před 6 lety

      Trey Baker Well, for city fights, 15mm is fine, even better than 6mm. However, it looks just weird to see artillery and long range guns like Flak 88mm's on the table in 15mm, in 6mm it looks way better. Especially in the desert, 15mm feels to cramped, or you must be playing with like a platoon or something. Company level tanks in 15mm just don't look that good on tables with space for maneuvres.

  • @madmalik4473
    @madmalik4473 Před 6 lety

    Cool video! You have more pics of the buildings that show up when you talk about sniper alleys? They’re quite nice!

  • @colonelkilling2425
    @colonelkilling2425 Před 6 lety +1

    Cool video. I'm a big fan, Uncle Atom!

  • @jooshjooshministhetics8048

    Was just looking for 3D printable terrain on Printable Scenery when this went up!

  • @kimmokinnu903
    @kimmokinnu903 Před 5 lety

    You can't go wrong whit lots of terrain and strong points like sniper lanes, high ground, bottle necks. We usualy even use some kind of center piece that separetes battle field into two fields. That way you most divide you're army or get flanked. Many times you see people using these 3 terrain piece shooting gallery battlefield. When other plays whit Tyranids and other whit Space Marines you know who's gonna win.

  • @forgefathereli8354
    @forgefathereli8354 Před 5 lety

    its about the correct amount of terrain in context. For instance putting two large line of site blocking pieces of terrain at the very center of a 6x4 or 8x4 board when playing 40k can often make the game more tactical and less just about dice rolls than an entire board having thematic terrain that looks cool and gives +1 to cover but doesn't block Line of sight except for really small squads or really small dudes like grots/ Ratlings /hormagaunts/ termagants etc... we took my theory for a test drive amongst 10 games, all 20 people agreed with me, yeah i know thats barely above singular anecdotal experience but the point stands. Do u NEED huge los blockers? no. the big faq 2 rules change really helped. but games with los blockers are still *more fun*

    • @aurenian8247
      @aurenian8247 Před 5 lety

      Yeah I've generally found that if you don't have LOS blocking terrain then the more shooty armies have a major advantage as they can just pour fire into the scariest enemy units until they die. Cover bonus or not.

  • @hamoclease
    @hamoclease Před 6 lety +2

    I saw this come up and thought to myself, "am I using TOO MUCH terrain?" I'm a self confessed terrainophile..

  • @sjhhej
    @sjhhej Před 6 lety +2

    In many historical wargames, terrain is integral to the game, as it should be. In ancients/medieval tournament rulesets, terrain and its placement are essentially the first part of the game and can be vital. That GW games have always treated terrain as an afterthought, or ignored it completely is a huge error. Tactics should be inherently tied to the terrain over which the battle is fought.

  • @dominicparker6124
    @dominicparker6124 Před 6 lety

    Getting an appropriate amount of terain on the table as to not tip the balance of the game stresses me out, and I really don't like it when games don't give some guidelines to tell you how much you should use. Games like Infinity can break down if you set the board up wrong, and I have 'fond' memories of playing 40k as orks against tau tau or space marine players at the local shop and the accepted board was basically 2 pieces of terrain or fewer.
    It always felt like the game was stacked purely because there were no options to avoid long range fire and to request more terrain on my part was seen as trying to tip the scales towards my strategy (even though the game was already tipped way too far towards them IMO).

  • @josephskiles
    @josephskiles Před 3 lety

    That was one quick pachow, need to hold back n ease into those

  • @TheCimbrianBull
    @TheCimbrianBull Před 6 lety +1

    9:31 "... very shooty..."

  • @knightwolf4612
    @knightwolf4612 Před 6 lety

    Fun, what is this word you say? It's all about dice, stats and competition. I kid. The immersion of the terrain should reflect scene trying to be played out. Shorter points, or whatever it is called in the system, even more narrative play would make better effective use of tiny table scene being played out.

  • @GonnaDieNever
    @GonnaDieNever Před 3 lety

    One thing I would say is that you should never have a map without firing lanes if you're in a long ranged game. If you cut off all long ranged options then you are actively punishing players who paid additional cost in their army to bring long ranged options.
    Essentially: Snipers cost a premium, don't make them suck.

  • @LordTechnopants
    @LordTechnopants Před 6 lety +4

    Always sound advice and dare I say wisdom? I'm going a little off topic, but having not played anything since Adeptus Titanicus (1988-1992) I was thinking about getting Kill Team (if it is ever in stock again in the UK). I really like the terrain and the idea of just having small groups of different factions to paint (and the set looks like good value). Looking at the Kill Team faction boxes, do I need the cards/tactics included in them or am I OK to just buy the (cheaper) miniatures on their own? Any advice very much appreciated.

    • @THKSkywalker
      @THKSkywalker Před 6 lety

      You don't need the cards; they're for convenience. All the rules you need are in the rulebook. Minimum you need is the rulebook and a squad. The benefit of the boxed sets is terrain and a few extra rules you can (but don't need to) use.

    • @LordTechnopants
      @LordTechnopants Před 6 lety

      David Frost Thanks, I suppose I'm thinking I'd be handicapped if I didn't have the specific tactics (having watched a few bat reps on yt).

    • @THKSkywalker
      @THKSkywalker Před 6 lety

      @@LordTechnopants I've only played a few games of KT, but for what it's worth I think it depends on what the strats are. Some are really situational, some you use as often as possible. If you want the terrain anyway it's a no brainer, but otherwise I'd do some research first. Also remember that the rulebook only comes with the big box, not the smaller ones! (You can get it separately of course.)

    • @LordTechnopants
      @LordTechnopants Před 6 lety

      David Frost Yes, I was going to order the main starter set, but to be honest - some of the terrain in the faction boxes is not for me. I want the Deathwatch miniatures, but those Death World trees are not on my list of wants! Is there any other way to obtain the tactics included?

    • @THKSkywalker
      @THKSkywalker Před 6 lety

      @@LordTechnopants Doesn't look like it no. But I doubt it'll be a game breaker. I got the main set and have played against guys with the faction sets and it was still fair and fun!

  • @robertcapestany6019
    @robertcapestany6019 Před 6 lety

    I've got a kitbashing question for 40k. Are Space marine terminators compatible with normal SM heads? I'm pretty new to the hobby and wanted to use some forgeworld heads on some terminators for my army.

  • @bernardmillerjr.1487
    @bernardmillerjr.1487 Před 6 lety

    You don’t necessarily have to buy terrain. A little modeling clay and wood shaped like trees can be made with household items. Styrofoam which you can get from department stores can be made into terrain.

  • @19Crusader91
    @19Crusader91 Před 5 lety +1

    A friend of mine is horrible at terrain making terrain.. as in placing them on the map. Just last weekend he made map.. where we played narrative game.. but still insisted on Matched played rule (equal point armies etc) that was so fucking unbalanced i was on the verge of declining to play. 80% of the map was shotblockers and if that wasnt enough he placed all the objectives at the very far end of the map where he could just sit on them without ever being threatend while only having a few choke points which he could very easily block.
    Yea im not letting him build maps on his on anymore.

  • @Super-Sheepy
    @Super-Sheepy Před 6 lety +2

    My issue is, I'd like to paint my turrain but I only have a tiny box to throw em all into so the chance of ruining the paint job is high. Any idea on a good way to store them?

    • @michaelinOZ
      @michaelinOZ Před 6 lety +2

      Super Sheepy hm. If you give it a layer of gloss varnish (more durable) and matte varnish (no gloss) afterwards you should be fine. Put some Kittchen towels in between the pieces and there shouldn’t be an issue. Well unless you throw it from bridge that is.

    • @Super-Sheepy
      @Super-Sheepy Před 6 lety

      @@michaelinOZ il keep that in mind :)

    • @TheRunesmythe
      @TheRunesmythe Před 6 lety +1

      Wrap them in something like paper towels, old newspapers, or something similar before storing them; same principle as when you buy something fragile at a store and they wrap it before putting it in the bag so that whatever the material its wrapped in takes the abuse. You'll probably need to swap out the wrapping material every so often, but it'll help keep your paint job intact.

  • @MarkMilarkyCampo
    @MarkMilarkyCampo Před 6 lety

    . I find most games have rulez for difficult/hazardous terrain is often over looked.. ..not used.. and they usaly have units for it too..

  • @SwashBuccaneer
    @SwashBuccaneer Před 6 lety +1

    My group needs some more terrain. Our tables are pretty bare and it's just a shoot out and little strategy. :(

    • @Sorrowdusk
      @Sorrowdusk Před 5 lety +1

      :D Build some imgur.com/a/kxbPfWf I really enjoyed making this

  • @cronlv16
    @cronlv16 Před 6 lety

    As a player who runs his own table, ide appreciate some tips on how to build a good gaming board.

  • @LobsterOminous
    @LobsterOminous Před 3 lety

    Atom is to tabletop wargaming what Matt Colville is to D&D, and you can quote me on that.

  • @RamseyEassa
    @RamseyEassa Před 6 lety +3

    Love you

    • @Demortixx
      @Demortixx Před 6 lety +2

      Thanks

    • @kellyaudia
      @kellyaudia Před 6 lety +2

      I love you, too, but I do still feel the need to see other people.

    • @Demortixx
      @Demortixx Před 6 lety +2

      @@kellyaudia rude. I should be enough for you

    • @TheCimbrianBull
      @TheCimbrianBull Před 6 lety

      @@Demortixx
      But why, though? Remember, sharing is caring! 😀

  • @seankavanagh3742
    @seankavanagh3742 Před 6 lety +2

    This is the issue I have with some of the Killzones for killteam they are just sparse 😣

    • @HeadHunterSix
      @HeadHunterSix Před 6 lety

      They're intended to add the terrain from each of the team boxes.

    • @seankavanagh3742
      @seankavanagh3742 Před 6 lety

      @@HeadHunterSix Yer but then you have to buy the exp team too, not that this is a bad thing I've loved every team so far but its a bit cheeky 😉

    • @MurderHoboRPG
      @MurderHoboRPG Před 5 lety +1

      Add your own extra terrain

  • @witlessfop36
    @witlessfop36 Před 6 lety

    Try getting terrain set up for two 15'x6' tables for massive Napoleonic battles 😱

  • @AdeptusRidiculous-2025

    Also... To be fair, put most of yur blocking terrain in the Centre of the table rather than sparsed out, why? Bcoz then you both have equal amounts of opportunity to score points and as you get closer, you'd be forced to use your melee sense over shooty!

  • @RyanC1984
    @RyanC1984 Před 6 lety

    Love the ideas. Any chance to get I video about pinning models? I live infinity and arena Rex but the models always fall apart on me..

    • @tabletopminions
      @tabletopminions  Před 6 lety +1

      I’ll add it to the list, but it’ll take a good deal of work to shoot and edit. Also, I’ll have to dig up a metal model that’ll need it. As don’t play Warmachine or Infinity, that will be a hurdle. Thanks for watching!

    • @RyanC1984
      @RyanC1984 Před 6 lety

      @@tabletopminions I'd be happy to sent you a couple Arena Rex models that I've been too nervous to attempt.

  • @Subcomandante73
    @Subcomandante73 Před 6 lety +1

    I concur.

  • @jamatheo
    @jamatheo Před 6 lety

    Terrain in KoW is not as problematic as it was in Warhammer FB. It is a hindrance, but still not as annoying and does not make maneouvres impossible.

  • @keysersoze9469
    @keysersoze9469 Před 6 lety

    Why are there any map rules in the rules? Or even a few preset maps to choose from if you wish?

    • @brandonden795
      @brandonden795 Před 5 lety

      I like that idea, I want to have something that's balanced

  • @BrokeJoker04
    @BrokeJoker04 Před 5 lety

    Hey would you possible stream, or record some games you play, so we can watching it? I would be interested in watching something like that, from the terrain distribution to the end. Would you possibly be interested in doing something like that?

  • @the_algorithm
    @the_algorithm Před 5 lety +2

    My brother plays Tau... he always wants a table with NO terrain... He tries to justify it as if Tau were defending a city they would of clear cut the forest so the enemy has to cross open ground... if it's a battlefield they'd choose open terrain and would not fight in a forest/jungle etc...
    I want tons of terrain for my harlequins to get into melee with his pathetic Tau...

    • @kmvoss
      @kmvoss Před 5 lety +1

      That's just terrible. XD

  • @bethanygraham427
    @bethanygraham427 Před 6 lety

    Simple answer - you always need more terrain. As a terrain fanatic I am completely unbiased in this.

  • @dakkawaaagh13
    @dakkawaaagh13 Před 6 lety

    Trying to get myself on the TT paint showcase club, join request sent over a week ago but not allowed in yet

  • @redgreen09
    @redgreen09 Před 6 lety

    sounds good to me big game a lot smaill litt good thing to know

  • @bocktordaytona5656
    @bocktordaytona5656 Před 3 lety

    "The block its the block"
    block for the block god.......
    BLOCK FOR THE BLOCK GOD!!!!!
    I had to make that Joke sorry

  • @absolutmauser
    @absolutmauser Před 6 lety

    Are you playing against IG, Tau, or Eldar? Then no. You don't have enough terrain. More terrain!

  • @derekdrake8706
    @derekdrake8706 Před 6 lety

    ....I use soda cans and cereal boxes.

  • @mw28945
    @mw28945 Před 4 lety

    In 40k you could play 150 guardsman and a command squad for only 800 or so points

  • @Ghost3210
    @Ghost3210 Před 4 lety

    Looking at my table that is like 120% terrain.

  • @AdeptusRidiculous-2025

    My solution is a 50/50% or less on both sides of the table. Why? Because if its less to zero, then your army has little to no surviveability factors... And its an unfair advantage, if one side is bear naked (less cover) and the other side is floral as hell. Lol... Unless you wanna challenge yurself! Or, yur shooty army is in bearen terrain and yur melee armies are covered in terrain evens out this score... So yeah compensation is key!

  • @thepenismightier
    @thepenismightier Před 6 lety

    I have watched 5 seconds and I know the answer is NO. There is NEVER enough terrain. Ever.

  • @Fr0z0rz
    @Fr0z0rz Před 6 lety

    Most players don't and should use at least two pieces per 2' square.