@@butterflyera Then we are not watching the same video. She hit the F5 like nothing here. Also in the MSG 2009 she even attempted the last belt part hitting another F5 that she only used to hit in the emotions era, not even in daydream…
people say her voice changed i think her style changed not her voice in her new projects she sounds different cuz its not the same style of music she used in the 90s but if she still can be amazing singing her old songs n sounds great as she sounded before then her voice is still amazing like always has been
YES!!!! i don't care what anyone says that was GREAT! she even sang 2:37 like the cd version, she wasn't even singing that part like the cd back in 1992 so i'm really proud of her, AND WISHING HER A HAPPY BIRTHDAY or as she says ANNIVERSARY!!!!!!!!
the ascending whistle was real good and nice and clear as well. The same goes for the ending whistles. They were really good. some of the best i have heard from her actually.
@@Guest-wb8gx well different tracks now and most songs like hero she sings more parts live now than then and sure since I made that comment Mariahs voice has become even better healthier sounding
Olha o poder desse ser maravilhoso e único que é Mariah carey, olha essas notas depois de anos, mostrando pq ela é uma das maiores Cantoras e vozes de todos os tempos. Respeito e admiração por ela . ❤
Thanks for sharing this!! I recorded audio of the entire show but unfortunately the obnoxious idiot behind me decided to scream "WOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!" the entire time and essentially ruined the recording. I swear, Mariah could have went on stage and said her mom died and he would have responded with a "WWOOOOOOO!!!!!" lol... anyway, nice to hear this performance without the distraction. :)
THAT WAS AMAZING!!!! GAVE ME GOOSEBUMPS ALL OVER!!!!!:).......However, i don't think the should have went on tour.. She needs to save that precious voice as much as she can because i want her to be around so my grandchildren can see her one day..and im only 15!!!:) I love her sooo much!!!!!!
@banantwon I hope she never ever stops either, I want my grandkids to love her too, I've loved her since I was 2 and I'm 23 years old now, it never ends the love for her
maybe in 2023 or 2024 she'll sing in that key again, I wouldn't doubt it, as she currently hits F5s and even F#5! I think it wouldn't be that difficult, since most of the music the notes are up to Eb5s
@ j cast if i wer you you should go and look for a magic water to make your vocal chords not aging... ofcourse !!!! mariah is not that young!!! everybody changes! but still she killed every single song of her!
Right now 13 years later, we would kill to have this Mariah back, who would still go for the notes even if they didn't sound perfect, still very resonant and powerful and with so much confidence, she hesitates to go for a Eb5 now , and in no fucking way will she go for a E5 like here or a f5 for the matter, D5s are nothing for her here , and now it's a struggle , it would have been awesome for people to have appreciated her in this time, 40 year old Mariah had no problems, people were making them up , thanks to that , now 53 year old Mariah does have confidence and more sever vocal issues , can't we just appreciate that she's still here ??
![[4K 60fps] Mariah Carey - Emotions (Live in Sydney, Butterfly Tour - 1998) Pro Shot](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7pWTEA3IFEM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K 60fps] Mariah Carey - Emotions (Live in Sydney, Butterfly Tour - 1998) Pro Shot](/img/tr.png)
The way that she say “SO!” is so powerful 😭
I LOVE that “And In the MIDDLEEE of the ni-i-i-ight!” 1:24 the belting in this performance is some of her best from the 2010s!
2:35 is just so damn great
2023 here! Iconic vocals.
One of my fav "Emotions" performance from this tour!! 3:02 than run is so effortless!! :)
You could tell she tried hard to hit those noted
@@butterflyera Then we are not watching the same video. She hit the F5 like nothing here. Also in the MSG 2009 she even attempted the last belt part hitting another F5 that she only used to hit in the emotions era, not even in daydream…
WTF THAT WAS PERFECT... 2010RIAH IS PRIMERIAH WTH
This is the mariah we need now..oozing with confidence!!!!!slayyyyyyyyyy
that was amazing, she can still sing like she did in the 90's this proves her voice never went anywhere!!!!
people say her voice changed i think her style changed not her voice in her new projects she sounds different cuz its not the same style of music she used in the 90s but if she still can be amazing singing her old songs n sounds great as she sounded before then her voice is still amazing like always has been
that live increasing whistle bridge part is the one im looking for my entire life. slay Mariah!
This whole performance is live everytime mariah hit notes she always look at her backgroup singers for reactions.....
she sounded better singing Emotions here than 1998-2000
3:49 that hand 😂😂😂😂
I think i heard an F5 at 3:05 ! Yay! She got her voice back!
YES!!!! i don't care what anyone says that was GREAT! she even sang 2:37 like the cd version, she wasn't even singing that part like the cd back in 1992 so i'm really proud of her, AND WISHING HER A HAPPY BIRTHDAY or as she says ANNIVERSARY!!!!!!!!
I'ts a playback. Just pitched down whistle for original track.
@@KrisSongwriter23 Even tho the whistle parts were lipped, those belts were soooo strong and on point😍😍😍
2010 was the last year of clean voice
2014 beacon theatre would like to have a press con 🤨
I'd say 2010, 2013, and 2014 Beacon
2018 Asia also comes a bit close
2016 ssft beg you differ
her belts and transitions sound really light and fit the song here.. the tone 🥰
the ascending whistle was real good and nice and clear as well. The same goes for the ending whistles. They were really good. some of the best i have heard from her actually.
In 2010 she sounded much better than today sounded.
+Celine Dion Fan I don't think so, she was super stiff and robotic here.
She Is as good now
Celine Dion Fan and she lipped more then than she does now
@@connorcoleman0379 its the same, she only lips 1 or 2 whistles
@@Guest-wb8gx well different tracks now and most songs like hero she sings more parts live now than then and sure since I made that comment Mariahs voice has become even better healthier sounding
20 years and she stay amazing
Im in love wit Mariah!! She hasn't lost her voice!
when people say Mariah lost her voice i laugh because i know it must be a joke
She sounded incredible here. Very Rainbowish to me!!
3:48 Gurl 😭 her hand
She hit that whistle riff originally
Oh my god, mariah the best ♥
Olha o poder desse ser maravilhoso e único que é Mariah carey, olha essas notas depois de anos, mostrando pq ela é uma das maiores Cantoras e vozes de todos os tempos. Respeito e admiração por ela . ❤
Thanks for sharing this!! I recorded audio of the entire show but unfortunately the obnoxious idiot behind me decided to scream "WOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!" the entire time and essentially ruined the recording. I swear, Mariah could have went on stage and said her mom died and he would have responded with a "WWOOOOOOO!!!!!" lol... anyway, nice to hear this performance without the distraction. :)
😂😂😂😂😂
Hunter Sullivan I don’t remember making this comment but I definitely remember it happening. 😂😬
jonny823 it made my day. I’ve had tickets to see Mariah 4 times. She’s cancelled everytime. I get it
@@jonny823 LOL still a lamb i see
@@huntersullivan7861 omg lol where do you live
2:36 EPIC MOMENT, 🤩🤩🤩.
Oh her tone!!!!!!!!!!!
Best performance of this song!! Waay better than the NYE one too woo good job
shes gorgious.
gogo go!!!! amazing!
2:35
Playback
mariahcarey4ever
Wowwwwwww!!!! 🤩🤩🤩🤩❤️❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Wow this is awesome for 2010!
STOPPING THE WHISTLE LE 100 LIIVE!
2:34 that always satisfies me
113rd Commented 💙 : We're back again to this video after 13 years.
THAT WAS AMAZING!!!! GAVE ME GOOSEBUMPS ALL OVER!!!!!:).......However, i don't think the should have went on tour.. She needs to save that precious voice as much as she can because i want her to be around so my grandchildren can see her one day..and im only 15!!!:) I love her sooo much!!!!!!
♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
mariah carey is the best...
The best part is 2:33 when she that whistle she never done that with her other concerts
This is better than the one in Atlantic City
It seems like she has better belting when she has happy life
@banantwon
I hope she never ever stops either, I want my grandkids to love her too, I've loved her since I was 2 and I'm 23 years old now, it never ends the love for her
wow your 32 now
@@zaygibson1467 omg
2:34 - 2:41 ! omg, where did this mariah go?
Colorful Pineapple lol. That's not even live.
Thats lipped. Its clearly the studio version with lowered key
Back to the 90’s lol
Playback she never did that at a concert
You make me feel so--- is live
@stevendjie 90s was her peak
the person who pointed his finger up twice is definitely miming during the high notes. lol
I wish she still kept the song in this key
maybe in 2023 or 2024 she'll sing in that key again, I wouldn't doubt it, as she currently hits F5s and even F#5! I think it wouldn't be that difficult, since most of the music the notes are up to Eb5s
@tertra114 yeah AND 3:01
the best in 3 worlds !!! hahaha
@ j cast if i wer you you should go and look for a magic water to make your vocal chords not aging... ofcourse !!!! mariah is not that young!!! everybody changes! but still she killed every single song of her!
2:36 is crazy
I think in 3:21 whistle live but unsupport and in climax is prerecord/lipped
A whistle will never be supported since it's a disconnected register😂
I like how she bent into that last whistle. She put a period on it.. LoL
Where does she explain this, I wanna see it
2:36 was that live
I think only the top note is live. Her tone changes quite noticeably.
no
No
@@daydreamera1996 what
No
the whistle wasn't lipped ik when Mimi lipsynch a and thus wasn't it I wasn't as perfect as the studio version and it was taken down an octave.
They where lipped you need to learn your Mariah facts
2 Semitones*
Clearly you don’t if u think this is live
On people the whistle isn't live ok I love Mariah that's why I am telling the truth
Dont be delusional that's 1000% live..its so fucking abvious!!!
Live
the climax whistle is live but taken down a note
Nope its the studio version with lowered key
Its lipped
Studio Version -2 key
I know y'all hear that whistle in 3:00 like I know I'm not crazy
@iiAmitx3 Haha! Well I'm 17 now, but i still fill the same way bout that comment :)
Those whistle notes sound exactly like the music video's whistle this proves mariah's voice hasn't changed since the 90s
@iiAmitx3 Haha!! I know rite! lol
I realized the whistles were lipped and just lowered whistles from original song
OMG at 3:20 she starts (too low) whistle again or i'm crazy?
She's lowered the key, it's ridiculously high for a 40 year old with 20 years of vocal damage behind her.
It's a Bb4
I miss the old mariah, what's up with her voice???, is not the same that 10 years ago.......
Vocal nodules
Right now 13 years later, we would kill to have this Mariah back, who would still go for the notes even if they didn't sound perfect, still very resonant and powerful and with so much confidence, she hesitates to go for a Eb5 now , and in no fucking way will she go for a E5 like here or a f5 for the matter, D5s are nothing for her here , and now it's a struggle , it would have been awesome for people to have appreciated her in this time, 40 year old Mariah had no problems, people were making them up , thanks to that , now 53 year old Mariah does have confidence and more sever vocal issues , can't we just appreciate that she's still here ??
sadly, it is mostly out of tune in her belt voice range. however, the whistle always gives me goosebumps...
You are dillusional