Save the Taj or muzzle Agra’s economy, UP government’s Catch-22 situation. Bisbo
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 10. 2021
- It is no secret that the Taj has been losing its pearly white luster over the years. Now, after being headed for its 6th “facelift” there’s a need to find a permanent fix. The solution is simple, more stricter emission norms. But should it come at the cost of muzzling Agra’s economy? Watch how the UP government has found itself in this Catch-22 situation.
#tajmahal #agratajmahal #restoration
Join us on
Discord: / discord
Instagram: @gobisbo
Facebook: Bisbo
Twitter: @Bisboworld
Sources
www.statista.com/chart/18716/...
images.hindustantimes.com/sta....
The Guardian
The restoration of St Paul's Cathedral; July 05, 2007
BBC News
St Paul's Cathedral pollution damage 'lowest ever'; October 10, 2012
Firstpost
Facelift for Taj Mahal: The monument gets a much needed beauty treatment; October 04, 2015
Hindustan Times
Taj Mahal gets a facelift with the age-old mud-based pack; March 15, 2016
Economic Times
Govt to reclassify ancient monuments review policy regulating construction around ASI protected sites; Mar 11, 2020
Quartz India
Can lessons from London save the Taj Mahal?; Carolyn Roberts; Aug 29, 2018
The Hindu
State forts to get a ₹600-cr. revamp; Renni Abraham; February 10, 2019
India Times
Here's A Look At The Renovation Of Historic Monuments Across India And Why It Needs To Be Done Well; Susmita Mukherjee; Sep 05, 2016
Taj Mahal's Foundation Is Under Threat Due To Decrease In Yamuna Water Levels; Shweta Sengar; Feb 12, 2021
Architectural Digest
Two Years Later, Here’s the Latest With Notre-Dame’s Restoration; Nadja Sayej; April 13, 2021
The Tribune
Neglected monuments in Mahendragarh to get facelift; Ravinder Saini; Jun 22, 2021
Times of India
'Either restore beauty of Taj Mahal or demolish it': SC slams government, authorities for apathy ; July 11, 2018
Restoration work of Ghodbunder fort to start soon; Aug 30, 2020
For 1st time, Taj Mahal’s main dome to get mud pack for 6 months; Anuja Jaiswal; Aug 06, 2021
Nearby Varanasi!! The one who has written it must be high af 😂
Map dekh
@@rowshanarasahar56 Kaisa map?
Varanasi agra se 600+ km door hai. Script likhne wla ganja fooka hai inka aur lagta hai apne bhi fook rkha hai
IKR..when I heard it I was like what..!! Varanasi too far from Agra for fumes of funeral pyres to reach, even winds hardly flow westerly across
I went to Taj mahal in 2019 . It was so huge and beautiful I never felt anything mentioned in video . Just imagine how it would have looked when made
Yahh we never feel it because you never saw the Taj Mahal 20 years ago the vividly bright white bought a undoubtedly shine and polish to world's 7th wonder.
Decreasing of Yamuna or increasing in water level caused small breakage of interior part of tomb . Well it was restored then too. Now Taj Mahal is in verge of collapse . Experts /archeologists say it can collapse any time now.
You may not find it ,but the pillars of Taj are slightly tilted inwards.
And yes forest fires , are one main reason for quite yellowing of the historic monument.
@@PrithviRajPatil1 Acc to mythology yamuna river is supposed to disappear in this yuga
@@vijayeville8704 what's the lore behind it?
Same here i went there on 2019 it is mesmerizing piece of art but was horrified after seeing the condition of Yamuna river
I have seen it when it wasn’t yellow, It just feels like blood of several workers..
I think stricter measures like installation of calcium scrubbers may be needed to reduce pollution without harming the economy
Yes exactly! Only innovation would work in this case.
1:13 lmao i never expected people to spit gutka on taj mahal even tho they have so many options to spit it on 🤦♂️
ha, you have never seen railway station, these people usually come from labour and lower middle class.
North indians
@@bitik9847 classic ricebag trying to stereotype north Indians in order to create divide.
@@rohan14040 Even those so called high class people do it.
what an explanation.With utmost perfection. It is explained as if it is his own house.loved it bro.
I would like to suggest BISBO, please make a video on temples in india. we would love it.
We'll surely look into the topic, Srikar.
South india ...Temples...Have always been ignored...Kindly give some coverage
@@vinodhajjan6412 They are not ignored. They are in South. We never hear much from South, not even in our media.
@@samyeharshel south is always neglected in everyway
@@nmurthyk3295 but south Indian temples are great pieces of architecture. What a great art. I have affinity to explore the temples in South India, especially the Thanjavur temple in Tamil Nadu, marvellous!
Don't know why govt is responsible for the restoration or maintainace of Tajmahal?? It is not own by govt it is owned by waqf board.
Spending tax payers money on non public property is not fair.
Because the government makes
Money from the taj. You know millions of tourists .. 7th wonder if the world ...
@@Kobebryant5947 The industry around Tak mahal earn more sud govt not focus on them?? Issue is why Taj Mahal is private??
LOL.Half knowledge is dangerous. Plz do some research .
@@ShahPatel if you had full knowledge thn u wd know that court case is going on this matter.
wrong question I will tell you who owns taj mahal.government owns the waqf board under Ministry of minority affairs. Govt of India.
Invest in IT sector development in Agra, no issues having development and beauty of Taj preservence at all.
When I visited taj on a normal day , I enter their by 9 o clock, when I gone back by 11.30 , I saw like some flooded river like scene in the corridor, nearly 1 lakhs people arrived their daily, Europe’s main revenue is tourism, every tourist spend money without any limit on their holidays , our government still not thinks of any thing like that
In country where ghukta in endorsed by actors spitting stains are common
It's a filthy culture
The picturization, animation and graphics. maker is as great as the TAJMAHAL is.
GBU
Those are some very kind words, Manoj! We'll convey your thanks to our artist.
Artists*
I just want to see the Taj Mahal once with my wife before anything happens! I hope it is well protected 🙏
5:48 ASI= Archaeological Survey of India, not Archaeological Society of India... Great video altogether :-P
Ah! Sorry! That was a good spot, Raj. Thank you bringing it to us.
The best way is to actually provide tax relaxation for Agra's industries for 10-20 years, only if they shift outside the city, at a specified distance.
Yes Partham, seems like a very logical solution.
@Kaushal Batavia Taj Mahal has a tourism potential even if it is a burial ground.
It is one of the 7 Wonders of the World.
Besides a signficant portion of Agra's economy is also tourist run, we cannot deny that as well.
Besides relaxation of taxes is actually a driver for growth.
@Kaushal Batavia We have, the Konark Sun Temple is one of them. But the mausoleum cannot be ignored as well. Obviously, over-dependence on a single monument is not good. Backups should be there.
@Kaushal Batavia Socialist, eh??
@Kaushal Batavia Quite contrary to the ideals of capitalism. Anyways, Agra does not have an industrial sector anyways. There are 12 units.
UP's cash cow is anyways Noida and Lucknow.
The factories should be shifted to elsewhere in U.P, the surrounding place near Taj mahal, should be allowed for only residential areas, abt crop burning from neighboring states like Haryana, Etc should be dealt with regulations and introducing of new technology to get rid of it by the respective state govts.
Which bring forths the Catch-22 situation we mentioned in the video.
Shifting would slow down economic growth
@@PUSHPENDRAsingh-rq6tp yes slowly, even it does it would be temporary, and I don't think there would be so many factories near the Taj mahal to do a very big loss for the nation.
@@nikhilraj418 but it will be great loss for up economy
I suggest that a fee of at least 2000 rupees be set as an entry ticket for these places.
This will keep the filthy pan spitting crowd out of such properties
There should be pan/tobacco checking before entering in Taj Mahal. And someone caught eating pan should be imprisoned.
So you think its the poor people who spit in Taj. Just check out in your Society and you will know the Truth.
@@andy8357 I don't think imprisoned, it is much cruel, there should be a 5000 rupees fine atleast at maximum
Our main concern is not taj mahal, we should have to work against pollution to save life of local people. Daily hundreds of people dying due to lungs disease which is related to pollution. We have to save them first.
Hundreds of people are also dying due to govt policies, unemployment, hunger (we are below pak and bangladesh in Hunger Index), lynchings and hit and run + murder by politician putras (lakhimpur Thar). Bisbo should make a video on all of these.
@@hanifhearts also don't forget bombings by extremists and loss of income by Andolans
@@GoFlyFeetOnGround Yes, excellent idea. Malegaon bombings by Bhagwa sadhvi should also be investigated and the whole chargesheet of Mumbai police must be featured in the video.
As far as andolans are concerned, nothing has been lost due to it, except Chodi's image. Nevertheless, the video will feature that also.
@@hanifhearts now you're giving religious twist LoL
@@GoFlyFeetOnGround lol do you think these guys truly care if bjp would have promised hajj subsidies and also went on the path of extreme appeasement they can easily win 10% out of 14%
Bisbo rocks always. May it grow more and more ❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏
We're trying our best with your support!
Yogi Adityanath doesnt take PN Oaks book seriously. Even though BJP clarified this and makes extra efforts, these kind of comments never stop. I wonder why BJP even tries to clarify
People who are doubting will never stop.
As per one meme, Amit shah can cancel someone's name from the Raid list if that someone wishes him happy birthday. I don't even care to remember people's birthdays outside my family nor care too much if someone forgets to wish me. LOL
Bisbo is something all news channels to aspire to be !!
Thank you for your support, Sameer.
@@BisboWorld you're best
Make a biography of someone’s life, who went from touching the cloud to the down fall of their empire plz
If you are talking about Anil Ambani, then they have already made a video on him.
@@bhanuprataprahi1693 there are many others who received the same faith, so yea
He made those, one on Anil Ambani and other on BR Shetty
We've covered many of them on our channel.
@@BisboWorld I mean to say, we want more
Great explanation that why there is no international airport in Agra
Building a dam is a good idea i guess 😄
Bruh the iron pillar is still without any rust and this is going yellow 🤣
Whats so funny about that? Its marble and it gets damaged by pollutants whereas the pillar in Delhi is Steel.
But why are you laughing it's one of seven wonders
it's not iron...
@@aryaaswale7316 nah bro I'm trying to show that we have much superior pieces of art and engineering than the Taj Mahal in india
@@sunnyarora3557 there are structures in india that deserve it more than the Taj Mahal
I love how questioning Taj Mahal's past is labelled ijlamophobic
I went to Taj Mahal in my school trip 2010 I hope we maintain it for future generations to also see
Create a huge glass dome covering entire TAJ
Stephen King would be proud!
i had the same idea
As usual maintaining the quality of the content and also presenting it in an elegant way. Super bisbo
Thank you so much 😀
Love your videos
Great job! Loved it.
Btw, please also make a video on the exposes by Julian Assange and Edward Snowden. I've read a bit about them; that'll be extraordinarily engaging with your style of storytelling and animation!
I find these sites useless they are just sitting there. Of course they attract tourists but that's about it instead we should focus on spending money on our Environment but again it's my opinion
@Geek then what about IT parks which are causing massive destruction for environment
@lakshya varshney It's my personal opinion like you have
@@anoopm2022 Not everywhere we can save our Environment
@lakshya varshney right 🙏
Flash ki speed se click kiya hai...bisbo rocks
Always interesting and mesmerizing work ✨
Thank you!
These monuments are National Treasures so the Federal Government should be paying for restoration rather than the local government
Loved the video 😊🙏😊
Thank you, Manas.
Taj Mahal area has great opportunity to develop as a great tourist attraction from world,our Central and State govt has failed to utilized it to its best level.
Yet again another masterpiece video. How do you make such videos. Do I need to go through a course or something. Any suggestions are highly appreciated.
We just follow everyday news but more thoroughly!
Bisbo sure. You have great analytical prowess. Please tell me how do u make animation videos like this. Do u went through some sort of training, the apps or software you used. I want to make in my regional language.
@@atomlanchenba2932 question which bisbo never answers
Himanshu Ruwali thanks for the info. I will ask another again another till I know the answer. So no worries..
Bisbo sure. You have great analytical prowess. Please tell me how do u make animation videos like this. Do u went through some sort of training, the apps or software you used. I want to make in my regional language.
If you guys are interested we can think about making a video on it.
Bisbo yes please . Expecting soon too. Regards from Manipur….
amazing video bisbo
It is impossible for such a heavy structure like the Taj Mahal to be built on a foundation of wooden pillars. The wood would rot in the water and the structure would slump in no time. The foundation is mostly built on Black granite. Water should be kept away from wooden furniture. How can wooden pillars submerged in water withstand the weight of such a heavy structure?
No, taj mahal's base foundation is made of ebony woods which is a special type of wood that gains it's strength from moisture. So actually, a perennial yamuna is good for Taj Mahal. If yamuna dries up, then the wooden base will lose its moisture which will result into developing cracks in the base.
India needs to build modern day tourist attractions like one in Gujarat statue of unity to over come this just like what UAE is doing right now and economic restrictions is going just create new problems only .
@lakshya varshney preservation of heritage shouldn't be on the expense of the future it needs to be balanced.
good job bisbo.. my knowledge bank
Correction : Ellora does not have Paintings, Ajanta Does. What non residents of Aurangabad don't realise is, though spoken of together, Ajanta is more than 100km away from Ellora.
Noted Sayantan
Way of storytelling is lovely
Bhuvan Bam is releasing a episode of his series every Thursdsy and yet I am more excited every week for your video❤
That's a high praise! Thank you!
This channel is very good. Creator present the news in very interesting manner
High praises from the Pope himself!
@@BisboWorld 😅😅😂
Superr explanation bisboo!
0:57 which is that music in background
Wonderful bisbo ❤️
Thanks, Ravi.
Amazing coverage👍
Bisbo do a video on India's Sugar Cartel and Sand Mafia please🙏
Yes they seem like interesting stories.
Replace the Taj Mahal with a Hindu temple. You don't see Israel preserving Nazi monuments. Why is India preserving Mughal monuments?
But it is made in india 🇮🇳
Bro are you dumb . It is a UNESCO protected site and consider 7 wonder of the world . It is only preserved by india . it can't be demolish by india .
Why not? The Mughals have served the Indians as their own people and the Taj is even generating money for the government through tourism . So we should be thankful for it .
stfu bro , we are not that stupid .
Bruuh keeping british flag and talking about india's
Varanasi in 600+ km away from Agra not nearby😅
*TAJ IS OWNED BY WAQF BOARD, LARGE AMOUNT OF TAXES GOES TO WAQF BOARD. IT'S THEIR RESPONSIBILITY TO CONSTRUCT*
All the Waqf board does, is radicalize the local Muslims
Taj is under Archaeological Survey of India, not waqf! ASI comes under Central Govt.
Abe yaar nafrat pehlanai Sai kabhi to Bazzz a jao
@@farazahmad2974 Kabhi Sachai ka saamna bhi kar Liya karo...Kab tak muh ferte rahoge sachai se...aur ye nafrat ka dhong karna band Karo...Kashmir me tumhaara pyaar dekh chuke hain Kashmiri pandits
@@samarpitjena4281
Mai kashmiri nahi hoo Mera poorai khandan Mai koi kabhi kashmir nahi gaya sewai mere papa kai jo wahi par posted hai as an cisf inspector
Video is very well documented 👌🏻👍🏻…..but how come Varanasi is near by to Agra ?? (2:15) ….Distance between them is more than 600km
emd the limeric with Smoking is injurious to health... I have been born and brought up in Agra visited the Taj Last month to be honest Covid has been kind on the monument not having to deal with hoards of people in the past year the marble looks white
There's no agra without the Taj... Protect the Taj it's a symbol of Indian history... Agra can spread around into suburbs... People can move monuments cannot... It's a curse and a blessing for the city but it's not much of a choice...
Good to see this opinion coming forth!
Agree bro Taj is the last symbol of India's Rich History
Exactly. Many of us may consider Agra as a representation of the chaos of the Mughal rule, but to the uninitiated one with Indian history, it is a big white, magnificent building, wonder of the world. The Taj Mahal, at this point, has become synonymous with Agra, and to some extent, India. The architecture of the Mughal period is (unfortunately) one of the last remnants of the India that was, along with a few ancient monuments, and the British, Rajput, and South Indian monuments, almost all heavily influenced by the Mughals. China wouldn't tear down the Great Wall if it was built by the Mongols, would it? Would Egypt destroy the pyramids if they were built by slaves? Why should we allow our Wonder of the World to decay, just because it was built by foreign invaders?
Wonderful Animation brother🙏
Thanks, Harsha.
India should invest more into protecting it's historical buildings.
Yes we should
and live in poverty?
Bro amazingly covered
Thank you, Martian.
Hey Bisbo, just a small request, please make a video on the recent turn of political situation in Punjab
You are doing good job .sir
Thank you, Raj.
The only solution is to have unified national pollution control guidelines. Currently the industries are pitting the state governments against each other to lower restrictions to keep them in the state. As soon as a state strengthens and cracks down on pollution, they'll move to another state with less regulations causing the other state to lose a lot of employment opportunities
The dam construction should be handed over to a more competent organization i.e L.A.W.D.A
Full form? 😅
@@khalidibnalwalid2032 Lake And Waterways Development Authority (LAWDA).
@@deadpoolreborn5322 oh thanks
@@deadpoolreborn5322 🤣
@@khalidibnalwalid2032 😂
4:06 that laugh was little ingnorent don't always believe something that you hear while seating in a room should look at the architecture type which has lotus ,swan etc its may be not shiv temple but you cant trust mugals when you have examples like ram mandir , and kashi were temples were Buried as foundations. For you druve stamb is kutub minar before you visit there and see the demolished ideols of ganesh behind the place in a cage .
Yes
czcams.com/video/Lens-aiSXqg/video.html
Here is the link to a video which clear explain why it is not islamic architecture with proofs i hope bisbo atleast believe in proofs.
Maybe we can too close the industries surrounding Taj mahal and replace it with residential projects
Hmmm, you are going to feed thousands workers and their families?
Govt. Be like , what an idea . Why didn't we think of it?
Restoring Economy on the cost of people life, yes, this is what we want!
Human must understand they are not above nature and no sense in preserving things made in swamp area which does not stand up to time how beautiful it is.
I don't think that there is any other channel in this segment
Do we seriously need a taj in India.
near by varanasi? its 600km
Wah super poem at last
Thank you, Reuben Jj
Help me out here , Can the foundation be replaced with todays modern methods ?
Maybe it'll be too risky and costly of a manoeuvre
it might reveal a secret which will result in its demolition. i cant say its true but there is a chance.
There will be riots even if it's possible. Oppositions will leverage on radical muslims and will call it a Babri 2.0 😂😂
@@flyiing_fish Owaisi Vs. Yogi
Bisbo please make video on public schools in india and the school vouchers that are in much talk nowadays
Varanasi nearby kabse hua?!? East UP mai hai Kashi !
Give the wooden pillars some creatine monohydrate...would make them stronger n help in water retention
Give them some whey protein too
@@siddharthgoyal3023 absolutely
Bisbo make video about reliance vs Amazon feud continuation and how these 2 will change india
2:26 no it's not agra's refinery it is mathura refinery
Why do I feel like I have watched this video 5 years ago
It is an old video which we've now updated with new information. Good catch!
well done
Thank you, Advait.
Monuments are being restored roads being made to reach the monument but no one is paying attention to thousands of temple which are architectural marvel but now they are in ruins .
Good video.... but I have no faith in UP Government that it even thinks of protecting the historical building.
Well, the UP govt. has other priorities. It is providing face lift to the hindu sites though.
@@tron8421 which no one really knows about , unlike Taj which is in the 7 wonders and bring almost 25 crores per year in just revenue.
@@cocomoose4730 true not denying that. But it is good to promote other sites too.
@@tron8421 not at the cost of others.
@@cocomoose4730 I mean, earlier Taj got fame at the cost of others. So, what's wrong when karma strikes back?
One of the most corrupted department: ASI
Agar vo kal ko tut jaye to Mai Asha karta hun ki har chiz me University ki demand karne wale yahan bhi wahi kahenge
We don't need more regulations. We need better enforcement and more importantly, better execution of current incentives supplemented by infrastructure. STPs aren't getting clearances or are stuck in courts. Pollution control devices and sewage connection for tanneries aren't getting distributed dispite the Central govt Swacch Bharat program.
Instead what we have is constant harassment and unbalanced enforcement. DCs will not issue PCB. certificates or make tanneries eligible either because of corruption or outright refusal over religious prejudices. STPs are stuck because some mid level Babu in the forest dept thinks the project needs to go back to Environment Ministry for approval because they found one more tree in the plot. (Babu is looking for a deal to fill his coffers).
Our environmental laws are good and very broad. The standards in them are pretty good and comparable to environmental regulations in Canada but this is all on paper. We don't need more regulations, we need better processes that rewards execution of projects.
A bureaucratic rut!
Once india become EV vehicle then india and whole world will be pollution free and people will live more remain healthy and fit and people who suffers from respiratory asthama it will make free from it.
EV implementation might take a few decades to become mainstream.
@@BisboWorld i disagree, we're innovating in battery, ola is doing good. We've already seen e-rickshaw in tourist cities & ebike-eCar market growing.
Also Tesla is coming
Us Indian really do have civic sense problem
After visiting south temples, Taj Mahal is very overrated
UP will never change ! Ppl need to be more aware
forget about taj mahal exiting top 7 wonders..taj may be closee or destroyed completely.. either due to indains unhiguene practise or govt lack of any force to change things
WTF r u talking ?
Please make a video on Aryan khan Drug case
The refinary is not in agra but in mathura
paint it black like Kaaba you don't need maintenance issue
Kaaba is not painted it is covered with black cloth
The adoption of greener technologies and technologies that can ne used to limit the damage already done like cleaning of Yamuna meed to taken up asap. This will able to save the Taj while also, helping in allowing the Agra economy survive. The solution is co-existence not this or that.
U r talking as if rest of UP is developed. Focus on other districts. UP CM's district itself is one of the poorest in the country. Focus on that....whole area of Bundelkhand comprising of several districts lies in extremely Backward district category. Some r even poorer than African countries. UP needs work anywhere u look. U don't have to focus on Agra. Forget about development, the level of crime in Bundelkhand is on another level
You are right, Congress exploited the whole country in it’s time now UP is developing, this year UP became the 3rd biggest economy in India. Also the population bill will add to it, crime rates are also getting down, infrastructure is developing but still UP needs to develop a lot more
2 nd
Varanasi is not near Agra. It's around 600 kilometres away
Bisbo hates UP govt.
@@venkateshe7506 then the grief will continue for many more time.
When the wrong is corrected of the taj to tejo mahal temple
1:06 Replica graves?
The original don't exist there?
by the way it's going they would probably rename it to hanumamahal or something.
Please do a video on mulleperiyar dam contraversy🙏🙏🙏
Hasn't anyone considered a ceramic coating yet🤷
Bisbo please make a video on Aryan Khan ,Sameer Wankhede ,Nawab malik chaos
We Indians see the Taj Mahal as a Mughal Building. But, on International Level, Taj Mahal is one of the symbolic representations of India. International Tourists are not interested in seeing high rise building, they have it in their countries, Taj Mahal and Agra remain a priority on their list.
That's bcoz some people portray it was done by great Mughals and potray them as great rulers...
Obviously most people don't like Mughals
You not we indians , to me Mughals came and stayed , unlike Brits who looted everything and took away what was ours for centuries, they were the real exploiters
@Liama_1995 yeah mughals stayed and destroyed all hindu temples which the Hindus pretty much deserved while on the other hand Britishers dared preserve these temples which is totally unacceptable, I mean how could they do that
@@ashutoshsingh2495 all Hindu temples? Are you sure ? And Britishers took away everything from india, be it from a Muslim or a Hindu. Atleast what Mughals took invested it back into India.everyone benefitted, because during Mughals india was at peak position in the world
@@cocomoose4730 in the north yes all were destroyed places like kharaho and sanchi were never touched because they were lost in the forest while in the south kings like Hader ali and tipu sultan used to patronize the temples(they basically used them as cash cows by applying laws like jajiya and all that and because of this marathas actually attacked them and destroyed the temples and took the statues of deities with them) on the other hand britishers who found the sanchi stupa actually rebuild and maintained it and unlike the mughals the British even allowed decent